Special Meeting of the Governing Body — Wed, Nov 18, 2026 · 10A. Appeal # 2026-12870-APPL of Case # 2026-12571-HDRB. Anne Pfauth and Thomas Eric Sikes, the Owners of a Contributing Property at 1295 Cerro Gordo Rd. in the Downtown and Eastside Historic District, Appeal the Historic Districts Review Board’s June 23, 2026, Decision Denying a Proposal to Build a 1,390-Square-Foot Addition and to Remove Part of a Retaining Wall, and Denying Exceptions to Exceed 50 Percent of the Historic Footprint of a Contributing Structure and to Remove Historic Material. (Frank Ruybalid, Senior Assistant City Attorney; feruybalid@santafenm.gov)
CITY O_· SAN
CIT
CITY OF SANTA FE
Appeal of Denial for Alterations
at
1295 Cerro Gordo Rd.
Appeal # 2026-12870-APPL
of
Case # 2026-12571-HDRB
~-
f We tideI , I
Guadalupe _
r - . ~-,l , . ..t)
Don
Ga par
Downto,vn
And
Easi -.ide
\ r, I
.I
Histo.ric Revie,-,·Di .trict
~-
f We tideI , I
Guadalupe _
r - . ~-,l , . ..t)
Don
Ga par
Downto,vn
And
Easi -.ide
\ r, I
.I
Histo.ric Revie,-,·Di .trict
Clt
o 0 0
@ ~ @u ~ [Q)O~Uu□ ~U~
Clt
Clt
H'_
w
Z r
<(
_J I
· o
----• ~
cc
<(
UJ
2
<(
-J
0
~
~
I er
I <(
0
~ ITT) ® ~ @UO~ [Q)O~Uu□ ~u~
Clt
H'_
w
Z r
<(
_J I
· o
----• ~
cc
<(
UJ
2
<(
-J
0
~
~
I er
I <(
CERRO GORDO ROAD
~ ~~@ ~®OTF@ @@CF@@ ~@o
o ~ ~ @§ti~0 ©1@ 0 IB @[10(£ [Q)fiIBW□ (sfr
~ ~~@ ~®OTF@ @@CF@@ ~@o
@§ti~0 ©1@ 0 IB @[10(£ [Q)fiIBW□ (sfr
~ ~~@ ~®OTF@ @@CF@@ ~@o
@§ti~0 ©1@ 0 IB @[10(£ [Q)fiIBW□ (sfr
S 84'5!'29" E
---
•,
CASE 2026-012571-HDRB, 1295 CERRO GORDO ROAD
DOWNTOWN AND EASTSIDE HISTORIC DISTRICT
Existing
and
Proposed
Site Plans
I
I
I I
I
I
I
I
I h
I
I
I "I ~
I
I
I I
~
I
Case 2026-012571-HDRB, 1295 Cerro Gordo Road
Downtown and Eastside Historic District
Existing and Proposed Site
Plans
0 0 0
0 0
CASE 2026-012571-HDRB, 1295 CERRO GORDO ROAD
DOWNTOWN AND EASTSIDE HISTORIC DISTRICT
Existing and Proposed South Elevation
I- -- - -- - ~ - ---..---.-----------------.-~----------.---.-----------,--,
mrl--------'-1--j-------------'-1_________1 1 It--------....---
~ El p
p
0
_______ ~ of_f ara,
7238' - 1
-+----~~--~~~--~---------------------...---------...~.-------,-,,.---- ---~ ----------------
;;;;,...;;;;=~~- - - - · ·- - - - ,,_ -;:;::.,::a:=~~~--~ ~ - -
-- -i
Case 2026-012571-HDRB, 1295 Cerro Gordo Road
Downtown and Eastside Historic District
Existing and Proposed West
Elevation
8
Eh
Case 2026-012571-HDRB, 1295 Cerro Gordo Road
Downtown and Eastside Historic District
Existing and Proposed North
Elevation
___ -.---.---------------~-------------~-- _______ ~o:.£'a:r_·a.....,_,,,.,,........,.
1 I I l 723B' -
'~
n ,- . ~ : . ~ .. - 'I • ' • • ... .
11
Exis 2:!~ Fklor -
722{1''·- 0"
- - ------------------------------------ exiisfo g un d81i:icm
7226"·- 8" -
---=---------------.....L....b-------......11...!..------ -
:::::I
r=
-- I
--- ----------- -----JVI
_____ , _ I _Ill I II I Ill 1- II _
..Toi
Case 2026-012571-HDRB, 1295 Cerro Gordo Road
Downtown and Eastside Historic District
Existing and Proposed East
Elevation
I
----1...11 11
~
~I
I
III
I
II
I
I
Case 2026-012571-HDRB, 1295 Cerro Gordo Road
Downtown and Eastside Historic District
CASE 2026-012571-HDRB, 1295 CERRO GORDO ROAD
DOWNTOWN AND EASTSIDE HISTORIC DISTRICT
Site Plan
Renderin
g
Note: the
rear
structure
is
withdraw
n from
this
applicati
on
North Elevation
West Elevation
South Elevations
Case 2026-012571-HDRB, 1295 Cerro Gordo Road
Downtown and Eastside Historic District
Rendering in relation to neighbors
0
0
S B'I• 00' E
~r-==,.;,.,,~ih-j;'j~~-...s.~.5;~7~•
o; WALL 8 FENCE
f:j SHED
...
D
New 30" Min. Opening
I''Bedroom
D j.- - 4'1--
Dining Room \ New 30" Min. Opening
New 36'' Door
Keplaces VV1ndow Living Room
~ Remove Door and Fm Opening
------,--. ,.,--UIUOT"' J'\"'Ol'l lOJU"O
D
New 30" Min. Opening
I ,Bedroom
D j.- - 4'1--
Dining Room \ New 30" Min. Opening
New 36'' Door
Keplaces VV1ndow Living Room
~ Remove Door and Fm Opening
r--
NEW ADDITION
[QJgb D
New 30" Min. Opening
I ,Bedroom
D j.- - 4'1--
Dining Room \ New 30" Min. Opening
New 36'' Door
Keplaces VV1ndow Living Room
~ Remove Door and Fm Opening
Historic Districts Code
SFCC § 14-4.6
(2)(II) Building Additions - Size and Location
a. Building additions are not permitted to primary façades.
b. All building additions shall be set back a minimum of 10 feet
from the primary façade.
c. Building additions shall not exceed 50 percent of the square
footage of the building’s historic footprint and shall not exceed
50 percent of the historic length in linear feet of the primary
façade.
A property owner can apply for exceptions to these rules.
Historic Districts Code
SFCC § 14-4.6
(2)(II) Design Standards – Approval Criteria:
Applicant must conclusively demonstrate the requested exception:
a. Does not damage the character of the district;
b. Is required to prevent a hardship to the applicant or an injury
to the public welfare; and
c. Strengthens the unique heterogeneous character of the City
by providing a full range of design options to ensure that
residents can continue to reside within the Historic Districts.
__.
Decision
Tree
LJ D • D
r - ~
¢ ¢ : D
¢
Appeal # 2026-12870-APPL of Case # 2026-12571-HDRB, 1295 Cerro Gordo Rd.
Appeal by Anne Pfauth & Thomas Eric Sikes of HDRB Denial
(1) Does not damage the character of the district NO
YES
(2) Is required to prevent a hardship to the
applicant or an injury to the public welfare NO
YES
(3) Strengthens the City’s unique heterogeneous
character by providing a full range of design
options to ensure that residents can continue to
reside in the Historic Districts
NO
DENY
the
appeal
DENY
the
appeal
DENY
the
appeal
Have the project Applicants conclusively demonstrated ALL THREE CRITERIA
for EXCEPTIONS to Historic District standards:
• Prohibiting an addition exceeding 50 percent of the building’s historic footprint?
• Prohibiting the removal of historic materials?
The deviation:
YES
GRANT the appeal
Thank
You