Special Meeting of the Governing Body — Wed, Nov 18, 2026 · 10B. Appeal # 2026-12950-APPL of Case # 2025-11753. Forrest Thomas of Thomas Trust Holdings, LLC Appeals the Planning Commission’s June 4, 2026 Decision Approving a Development Plan by Amatren LLC for a Self-Storage Facility at 1802 Cerrillos Road, 1750 Cerrillos Road, 1361 Fourth Street, 3 RD Berry Avenue (Natalie Cauley, Assistant City Attorney, nscauley@santafenm.gov)
36A
APPELLANLNEORMAIQN
Thomas Trust Holdings, LLCName:
1Address: 340 East Berger Street
(
RY:
thomasprop@newmexico.comEmail Address:Phone:
Additional Appellant Names: TP-SFSS, LLC; Thomas Properties-NM, LLC
• BothCorrespondence Directed to: ApplicantAppellant
APPLICANI/AGENIINFQRMAIQN IE DIEEERENLEROM APPEL LANT)
Amatren, LLCCompany Name:
E-mail Address:Phone:
AGENT AUTHQRIZATON (IE APPLICABLE)
I am/We are the owner(s) and record title holder(s) of the property located at:
l/we authorize
Date:
SUBJECT OE APPEAL
1802 and 1750 Cerrillos Road, 1361 Fourth Street, and 3 RD Berry Avenue, Santa Fe, NMLocation of Subject Site:
Permit Number (if applicable):Case Number: 2025-11753
Other Final Determination of PLUD DirectorIssuance of Building PermitFinal Action Appealed:
• Planning Commission BCD-DRC
Board of Adjustment Historic District Review Board
eceipt Attached)
6/1020% | Staff Signature:
Pxelobwent Tlan2024 Page 3 of 4Revised 2/27/26
VERIFIED APPEAL PETITION2Aj CITY OF SANTA FE PLUD-17
Signed:
Signed:
Time Filed:
Date Filed:
Final Action of
Board or Commission:
87505
ZIP Code
87592
ZIP Code
Suite/Unit #
NM
State
Suite/Unit #
NM
State
Project Name: DXD Self-Storage / Empire Self Storage Project
Applicant or Owner Name: Amatren, LLC
Street Address
Santa Fe
City
505-983-3131
Name (First, Last): See continuation sheet for agents
Address: P.O. Box 5587
Street Address
Santa Fe
City
Two originals of this form must be filed. The Land Use Department Director or their designee will enter the date and
time of receipt and initial both original copies. See Section 14-2.1.B.5.IV for the procedure.
_LANDUSESTAEEQNLY
I Fee Paid: $ 20
to act as my/our agent to execute this application.
Date:
UUE3
BASIS QE SIANDING
Basis for Appeal: • The facts were incorrectly determined y Ordinance/laws were violated and/or misrepresented
SIGNATURE & VERIFICATION
I hereby certify that the documents submitted for review and consideration by the City of Santa Fe have been
m standards outlined in the Land Development Code, SFCC Chapter 14, as amended.prepared to meet the mini
e rejection or postponement of my application.inFailure to meet these standards ma
g/w/2o26Appellant Signature: Date:
Agent Signature: Date:
Forrest R. Thomas, Manager of each Appellant LLC , being first duly sworn, depose,l/We
/We have read the foregoing appeal petition and know the contents thereof and that the same are true toand sa
SignatureSignature
Print Name
day of Aogus± NOTARY PUBLIC
Page 4 of 4Revised 2/27/26
VERIFIED APPEAL PETITION
CITY OF SANTA FE PLUD-17
Description of the final action appealed from, and date on which final action was taken:
June 4 approval; City confirmed July 9 deemed date and 30-day deadline. See continuation.
B. EXPLAIN THE BASIS FOR APPEAL Please detail the basis for Appeal here (be specific):
See attached Statement of Grounds and PLUD-17 Continuation Sheet; both incorporated by reference.
Forrest R. Thomas
Print Name
Subscribed and shown to before me this IO
,20 2% .
MCKENZIE RYLIE ROBINSON
dea) Notary Public
-5577 State of New Mexico
Comm. # 2009132
My Comm. Exp. Apr 6, 2030
BJagmur
and say/Wehave read the f
23224
Check here if you have attached a copy of the final action that is being appealed.
A. DESCRIPTION OF HARM Describe the harm that would result to you from the action appealed (attach additional pages if
necessary):
See attached PLUD-17 Continuation Sheet for standing and description of harm.
My commission expires:
41/6/2030
PLUD-17 CONTINUATION SHEET
Case 2025-11753 | Development Plan j Attachment page 1
Standing and Harm
Thomas Trust Holdings, LLC and TP-SFSS, LLC received mailed notice of the June 4, 2026 Planning Commission
hearing and own adjacent or affected real-property interests. Thomas Properties-NM, LLC is the sole member of TP-
SFSS, LLC and manages affiliated real-property activities. Forrest R. Thomas is Manager of all three LLCs and is
authorized to act for each.
The Development Plan affects Appellants' economic, environmental, aesthetic, access, operational, and property
interests, including traffic and circulation, pedestrian and emergency access, drainage and stormwater, lighting, corridor
character and compatibility, landscaping, and use and enjoyment of affected property.
Authorized Basis for Appeal
Current SFCC Section 14-2.1(B)(5)(IV)(b) allows an appeal only for: (1) noncompliance of a final action with Chapter 14
or Sections 3-21-1 through 3-21-14 NMSA 1978; (2) incorrect application of Chapter 14; or (3) a decision lacking
substantial evidence. This appeal is based only on those authorized grounds, as mapped in the attached Statement of
Grounds. The City Staff Report states that these applications were received in December 2025 and reviewed under the
prior Land Development Code, so the merits grounds rely primarily on the former substantive criteria actually applied by
the City.
Without waiving that position, if corresponding current provisions are determined to govern, Appellants assert the same
record-based challenges under current SFCC Section 14-2.1(F)(4)(V)(b) and other applicable current provisions. Current
SFCC Section 14-1.9(D) is preserved as additional transitional support to the extent its application-completeness
requirement is satisfied.
Final Action and Timeliness
The Planning Commission voted to approve the applications June 4, 2026. The City later advised that July 9 was the
deemed final-action date. Following consultation with the City Attorney's Office, the Planning and Land Use Director
advised Appellants in writing that the 30-day appeal deadline applies to both Case 2025-11753 and Case 2025-11756.
Under current SFCC Section 14-9.1(D), the Saturday, August 8 deadline moved to Monday, August 10. This appeal is
tendered August 10 and is timely under the City's written determination. Appellants preserve all arguments concerning
the legal effect of any later new, amended, or materially altered written decision, including any appeal rights arising from
such action.
Applicant / Owner and Agents
Amatren, LLC, P.O. Box 5587, Santa Fe, NM 87592.
Applicant agent: Lisa Martinez, B Constructiv, LLC, 3201-C Zafarano Drive, Suite 111, Santa Fe, NM 87507.
Additional agent/counsel: Joseph M. Karnes, Sommer Karnes & Associates, LLP. 125 Lincoln Avenue, Suite 221, Santa
Fe, NM 87501.
Relief Requested
Primary Relief. Reverse the Planning Commission's approval of Case 2025-11753. Reversal of the Special
Use Permit would also require corresponding disposition of the Development Plan; this Development Plan
appeal independently seeks reversal on the grounds stated in its attached Statement of Grounds.
Alternative Relief. If the Governing Body does not grant reversal, vacate the approval and remand for
proceedings and findings supported by substantial evidence and consistent with the applicable provisions of
Chapter 14.
Appellants
Representative
Contact
Mailing
Thomas Trust Holdings, LLC; TP-SFSS, LLC; Thomas Properties-NM, LLC
Forrest R. Thomas, Manager of each Appellant LLC
505-983-31311 thomasprop@newmexico.com
340 East Berger Street, Santa Fe, New Mexico 87505
DXD Self-Storage / Empire Self Storage Project - Case 2025-11753 | Development Plan Appeal
Incorporated into the accompanying Verified Appeal Petition on City Form PLUD-17.
Appellants and Contact
STATEMENT OF GROUNDS SUPPORTING VERIFIED APPEAL PETITION
Case 2025-11753 - Development Plan | DXD Self-Storage / Empire Self Storage Project
Case 2025".11753 I Development Plan I Attachment page 2
CENTRAL ISSUE. The Planning Commission could approve the Development Plan only upon the findings
and showing required by Chapter 14. The record presented did not establish those prerequisites before
approval was granted. Material questions concerning public interest, compatibility and adaptability, traffic
and access, drainage, lighting, and other compliance matters remained unresolved. The City's own
technical review confirms that material compliance required by Chapter 14 had not yet been demonstrated.
1. This appeal fits the three grounds allowed by current Chapter 14.
Current SFCC Section 14-2.1(B)(5)(IV)(b) limits this appeal to noncompliance with Chapter 14, incorrect
application of Chapter 14, and lack of substantial evidence. The Development Plan appeal invokes all three
grounds as supported by the record. It is independent of the Special Use Permit appeal, although the two
approvals concern the same Project and rely on overlapping public-interest finding and the mandatory finding
of compatibility and adaptability.
The Staff Report states that the applications were received in December 2025 and were reviewed under the
prior Land Development Code. Former SFCC Section 14-3.8(D)(1) required the Planning Commission to find,
among other things, that approving the Development Plan would not adversely affect the public interest and
that the use and associated buildings were compatible with and adaptable to nearby properties. Those
findings were prerequisites to approval and had to be supported by the record presented to the Commission.
(Staff Report, pp. 10-11.)
Appellants rely primarily on the former substantive criteria actually applied by the City. Without waiving that
position, if corresponding current provisions are determined to govern, the same challenges are asserted
under current SFCC Section 14-2.1(F)(4)(V)(b), which contains materially parallel public-interest finding and
the mandatory finding of compatibility and adaptability, and other applicable current provisions. Current
SFCC Section 14-1.9(D) is preserved as additional transitional support to the extent its application
completeness requirement is satisfied.
2. The required public-interest finding was not established by the traffic and access record.
[Authorized Grounds 2 and 3]
Former SFCC Section 14-3.8(D)(1) required the Commission to find that approving the Development Plan
would not adversely affect the public interest. The applicant relied in part on the characterization of self
storage as low intensity with relatively little traffic. Yet the traffic assessment describes Cerrillos Road as a
principal arterial with higher traffic and speed, bike lanes, and a local bus route; the Staff Report identifies
four vehicular entry points and a pedestrian connection between the project sites; and the development-plan
materials include turning templates for an SU-40 single-unit truck. (Staff Report, pp. 7-11; Impact of Traffic
Assessment, pp. 1-3; Development Plan/Paving materials.)
Staff further told the Commission that access, frontage coordination, and fire-station operations were distinct
issues and that the traffic assessment was not being presented as fire-operations clearance. Public and
hearing comments raised pedestrian, traffic, fire-station, emergency-operation, and larger-vehicle concerns.
Because the traffic evidence focused on trip quantity, the record needed evidence addressing the character
of the Project's larger-vehicle traffic and the associated site-specific safety concerns - not merely a low
aggregate trip count - to support the required public-interest finding for the physical access and circulation
plan. (Staff Report, p. 14; June 4 hearing, approximately 23:46-24:34 and 1:25:52-1:26:17.)
3. The mandatory finding of compatibility and adaptability was not established on the record
presented. [Authorized Grounds 2 and 3]
The applicant and Staff relied on zoning compliance, reduced height and lot coverage, increased open
space, architectural treatment, and redevelopment of the vacant site. Those facts were relevant, but the
required finding concerned whether this use and its associated buildings were compatible with and adaptable
Case 2025-11753 | Development Plan I Attachment page 3
to buildings, structures, and uses of abutting and nearby properties. The record included material concerns
about corridor character, landscaping, screening, pedestrian conditions, traffic safety, and the design’s
relationship to the surrounding area. One commissioner described the building as "extremely out of
character" for the neighborhood and later agreed that landscaping and screening concerns raised in public
comment were well taken. (Staff Report, pp. 10-11,14; June 4 hearing, approximately 1:39:30-1:40:03 and
1:51:45-1:52:25.)
The adaptability component was not separately established. In its Applicant Response, the applicant stated:
"The self-storage building design lends itself to being adaptable to other uses. The self-storage units within
the building shell can be modified to adapt to different uses." Staff's response focused on compatibility and
did not identify evidence showing that a substantial alternative use could actually be accommodated by the
approved building and site. The Development Plan calculates 69 required parking spaces and provides 73 for
the entire Project. Former Table 14-8.6-1 required only one space per 10 mini-warehouse storage areas,
while materially greater ratios applied to representative alternative uses, including one per 350 square feet of
net leasable area for non-medical office, one per 400 square feet for neighborhood grocery/laundromat, and
one per 500 square feet for warehouse/distribution. The record contains no analysis showing whether a
substantial conversion could meet those parking requirements or other site and building requirements
applicable to the alternative use. (Staff Report, pp. 10-11; Development Plan, Sheet A.101; former Table 14-
8.6-1.)
Taken together, the site-specific compatibility concerns and the absence of a demonstrated adaptability
analysis leave the mandatory combined finding without substantial evidentiary support. The applicant's
general assertion that the self-storage units within the building shell can be modified to adapt to different uses
does not establish that the proposed use and associated buildings are compatible with and adaptable to the
surrounding buildings, structures, and uses as required by former SFCC Section 14-3.8(D)(1).
4. The City's own technical review confirms that material compliance remained unresolved
when the Development Plan was approved. [Authorized Grounds 1, 2 and 3]
The City's Conditions of Approval and Technical Corrections ("Attachment A" in the administrative record)
confirm the broader problem. Technical Correction 39 states: "Current analysis shows a violation: an increase
in peak stormwater flows is not allowed per city code 14-8.2(D)(4)(b)(i)." The same review required additional
drainage analyses, verification of runoff-volume calculations because the Rational Method is not acceptable
for that purpose, and an acceptable runoff-volume analysis for the stormwater-quality event. Technical
Correction 37 separately states that the photometries "do not meet Code requirements." These matters were
assigned for correction prior to recordation rather than resolved before the June 4 approval. (Attachment A,
Conditions 32-34; Technical Corrections 37, 39-44.)
The significance of these identified deficiencies extends beyond the underlying stormwater and lighting
corrections. They constitute the City's own contemporaneous evidence that material Chapter 14 compliance
had not yet been demonstrated when the Commission made the required findings and approved the
Development Plan. They therefore reinforce the authorized appeal grounds of noncompliance with Chapter
14, incorrect application of Chapter 14, and lack of substantial evidence.
5. Relationship to the Special Use Permit
The Development Plan and Special Use Permit authorize the same Project. The Special Use Permit is the
discretionary authorization for the self-storage use in the C-2 district. Reversal of that authorization would
eliminate the land-use approval necessary for the Project to proceed as approved and would require
corresponding disposition of the Development Plan. Independently, the Development Plan should be
reversed on the record-based grounds stated above.
6. Taken together, the record did not establish the prerequisites for Development Plan
approval. [Authorized Grounds 1, 2 and 3]
The Commission was required to make affirmative public-interest finding and the mandatory finding of
compatibility and adaptability and to apply Chapter 14 to a Development Plan supported by the record. The
unresolved traffic and access questions, site-specific compatibility and adaptability concerns, and City-
identified compliance problems show that the necessary evidentiary and compliance showing had not been
Case 2025-11753 [ Development Plan | Attachment page 4
made when approval was granted. Deferring material corrections until prior to recordation did not itself supply
the evidence needed to support the findings at the time of approval.
The stormwater and lighting deficiencies are significant because they are concrete examples from the City's
own review demonstrating that the broader requirements for approval had not yet been established. Taken
together with the unresolved traffic, access, compatibility, and adaptability issues, they place the
Development Plan approval within the Code's authorized appeal grounds of noncompliance, incorrect
application of Chapter 14, and lack of substantial evidence.
7. Relief
Primary Relief. The Governing Body should reverse the Planning Commission's approval of Case 2025-
11753. The record presented did not establish the mandatory public-interest finding and the mandatory
finding of compatibility and adaptability or demonstrate the material Chapter 14 compliance necessary to
support approval.
Alternative Relief. If the Governing Body does not grant reversal, Appellants request vacatur and remand for
a determination based on a record demonstrating Chapter 14 compliance and substantial evidence for the
required findings. Appellants also request any other relief authorized by law.
INVOICE (INV-00118795)
VOICE DESCRIPTIONINVOICE NUMBER INVOICE DATE
ONE08/10/2026INV-00118795
TOTALREFERENCE NUMBER FEE NAME
$200.002026-012950-APPL Appeal Fee - F 08/10/2026 03:01PM Michael R
003293-0005 $200.001802 Cerrillos Rd Santa Fe, NM 87505 I TOTAL
$200.00TOTALREMITTANCE INFORMATION
$200.00
$200.00
$400.00
$400.00
$0.00Change due
Paid by: LLC, THOMAS TRUST HOLDINGS
Signature;
Thank you for your payment
August 10, 2026
Ver. 05
CUSTOMER COPY
DUPLICATE RECEIPT
$400.00
$400.00
Subtotal
Total
CD
co
Page 1 of 1
6/24/2019
Tenders
CREDIT CARD
MasterCard
BILLING CONTACT
THOMAS TRUST HOLDINGS LLC
340 E BERGER ST
Santa Fe, NM 87505
City of Santa Fe
PO Box 909
Santa Fe, NM 87504
LLC, THOMAS TRUST HOLDINGS
2026-012950-APPL
2026 INV-00118795
Appeal Fee - Plan - AH
Appeals
EG INVOICE
LLC, THOMAS TRUST HOLDINGS
2026-012949—APPL
2026 INV-00118794
Appeal Fee - Plan - All
Appeals
City of Santa Fe, NM
DEPARTMENT
200 Lincoln
Sante Fe, NM 87507-4808
e"alees,
a oSA
8
-9/
City of Santa Fe
200 Lincoln Ave.
Santa Fe, New Mexico 87504-0909