Special Meeting of the Governing Body — Wed, Nov 18, 2026 · 10B. Appeal # 2026-12950-APPL of Case # 2025-11753. Forrest Thomas of Thomas Trust Holdings, LLC Appeals the Planning Commission’s June 4, 2026 Decision Approving a Development Plan by Amatren LLC for a Self-Storage Facility at 1802 Cerrillos Road, 1750 Cerrillos Road, 1361 Fourth Street, 3 RD Berry Avenue (Natalie Cauley, Assistant City Attorney, nscauley@santafenm.gov)
DX D E M P I R E / 1 8 0 2 C E R R I L LO S R OA D DEVELOPMENT PLAN APPEAL City of Santa Fe · Governing Body · November 18, 2026 Appellants: Thomas Trust Holdings, LLC · TP-SFSS, LLC · Thomas Properties-NM, LLC Presented by Forrest R. Thomas, Manager 2 PROCEDURAL RECORD Appeal timing: guidance changed FORREST THOMAS / REQUESTS CITY / RESPONSES JUN 15, 10:53 a.m. | Forrest Thomas “...let me know the deadline for the appeal and the specific appeal process.” JUN 16, 10:32 a.m. | Forrest Thomas “The deadlines are tight and unforgiving, so please provide the information as soon as possible.” JUN 16, 11:53 a.m. | A. George Terry “I am confirming the precise case-specific appeal deadline and filing path before providing a final deadline calculation.” AUG 7, 2:22 p.m. | Forrest Thomas Requested a meeting to deliver the finalized appeals and discuss the SUP deadline. AUG 7, 3:41 p.m. | Heather Lamboy “the 30-day deadline will apply to both cases.” SEP 15 | Heather Lamboy, voicemail transcript “the city attorney’s office ultimately determined that the special use was not timely.” SEP 28, 11:08 a.m. | Forrest Thomas “For clarity, I am not withdrawing the SUP appeal, and I do not agree that it was untimely.” The record shows deadline requests, conflicting guidance, and continued disagreement with the later determination. Source: Filed DP Evidence Packet pp. 25–27, 32–34, 37. Sept. 15 is an automated voicemail transcription. 02 3 PROCEDURAL RECORD Required notice: repeated requests for the recipient list FORREST THOMAS / REQUESTS CITY / RESPONSES AUG 31 | Acknowledgment recounted Sep. 28 “acknowledged by Mr. Terry on August 31” — Forrest Thomas’s Sep. 28 follow-up. SEP 28 | Forrest Thomas “I still need confirmation of what will be supplied—mailing labels, a recipient list, an editable address file, and any separate neighborhood-association list—and when.” OCT 1 | Natalie Cauley “I will respond in the email chain with Mr. Pacheco so we can address your other questions about notice, as appropriate.” OCT 6 | Forrest Thomas “At a minimum, the Casa Alegre Neighborhood Association was not included.” OCT 9 | Natalie Cauley “I will respond to your question about the neighborhood association next week.” OCT 13 | Forrest Thomas “Please confirm that the final appeal-notice list will include all required recipients, including applicable neighborhood associations…” OCT 21 | Natalie Cauley “These neighborhood associations can be found through the City’s online mapping tool.” OCT 23 | Forrest Thomas “I am not in a position to determine which neighborhood associations are sufficiently close to the property to require notice.” AUGUST 27 → OCTOBER 27 61 days between the documented request and final-list confirmation. OCT 27 | Natalie Cauley “That is correct, the two addresses sent below and Mr. Pacheco's list for neighboring properties comprises the entire official mailing list.” 03 AUG 27 | Forrest Thomas “...provide me a copy of the property-owner/address mailing list, neighborhood-association notice list, and proof/certificate of mailing...” Sources: Aug. 27 email supplied by appellant; Filed DP Evidence Packet pp. 39–41, 43–45, 47, 49; Oct. 27 Cauley email supplied by appellant. P R O C E D U R A L R E C O R D Information needed to prepare the appeal FORREST THOMAS / REQUEST CITY RESPONSE / STATUS OCT 13 Forrest Thomas OCT 21 NO DEEMED-COMPLETE DATE PROVIDED IN REPLY OCT 13 Forrest Thomas “When will the complete written Planning Commission record be available to the parties…” OCT 21 Natalie Cauley OCT 20 OCT 21 Natalie Cauley OCT 29 Forrest Thomas “Please advise when the final written decision will be issued…” (SUP ruling). 04 “...the Chapter 14 provisions applicable to the substantive review of each application and the application-completeness dates used to make that determination.” Forrest Thomas · Corrections 39–44 “Were these corrections considered satisfied, deferred for completion at a later stage, or still outstanding when the Planning Commission approved the project?” Sources: DP Evidence Packet pp. 45–48, 52–53; Oct. 13 and Oct. 20 emails supplied by appellant. Summary: Explained permitted prehearing submissions and how to cite documents; did not directly specify when the complete Planning Commission record would be available to the parties. “None of the information you seek has any bearing on the three permitted bases for appeal. As a result, City Staff will not respond to these inquiries..” OCT 21 Natalie Cauley · Packet availability The October 21 response also stated the compiled Governing Body packet would likely be available November 13—after the November 9 evidence deadline. OCT 29 Natalie Cauley “There will not be a written decision issued by the Governing Body…” 5 PROCEDURAL RECORD Late guidance compressed preparation CITY COMMUNICATIONS EFFECT ON APPEAL PREPARATION SEP 28 · Natalie Cauley | SUP conformity “The conformity review will be provided to both parties with ample time to prepare for the October 28th hearing.” SEP 28 · EFFECT ON PREPARATION Assurance of adequate preparation time despite travel Oct. 16–20 already disclosed. OCT 21 · Natalie Cauley “the 2011 Resolution does not provide for an additional brief to be submitted by the Appellant.” “There is no procedure for you to respond in writing to the Governing Body packet in advance of the hearing...” OCT 21 · SUBMISSION INSTRUCTIONS Change in instruction, requiring rework of the submission. OCT 26 · Natalie Cauley Corrected October 21 direction: the appeal form could no longer be amended. OCT 26 · EFFECT ON PREPARATION Earlier amendment guidance was rescinded after the appeal filing deadline. Successive and late instructions curtailed the appellant’s available preparation and response time. 05 NOV 5 · Natalie Cauley "any presentation that a party plans to present must be provided to me via emailed PDF by 5pm on Thursday November 12." NOV 12 · PRESENTATION DEADLINE Sources: Filed DP Evidence Packet pp. 38, 47, 50; Nov. 5, 2026 email from Natalie Cauley supplied by appellant. Changing instructions reduced time to prepare and respond, forcing me to work during previously identified travel or miss the submission deadline. C O D E A P P L I CA B I L I T Y Which Chapter 14 governed the Development Plan? Source: Aug. 10 DP petition (Code-application ground); DP Evidence Packet pp. 6, 30, 45–48. DEC 19, 2025 Application received Documented → JAN 1, 2026 New Chapter 14 effective Transition date → FEB 9, 2026 DRT intake Documented AUG 10, 2026 Development Plan appeal filed — incorrect application of Chapter 14 was already a stated ground. OCT 13, 2026 Forrest Thomas again requested the application-completeness date, referring to prior unanswered requests. OCT 21, 2026 · NATALIE CAULEY DEEMED-COMPLETE DATE: UNANSWERED 06 C O D E A P P L I CA B I L I T Y Why the Code determination matters Source: DP Evidence Packet p. 6; August 10 verified appeal; City email at packet p. 30. 01 APPLICABLE EDITION Identify the substantive Chapter 14 legally governing the application. → 02 REQUIRED STANDARDS The governing edition determines the applicable approval standards. → 03 SUPPORTED FINDINGS Did the Commission even apply the correct version of the Code? Correct Code selection is foundational to the Development Plan approval. The applicability issue concerns substantive review—not the separate appeal procedure. 07 A P P E A L F R A M E WO R K The required Development Plan findings Source: DP Evidence Packet pp. 3–8, 10, 16–20; original DP petition and operative Commission findings. PUBLIC INTEREST COMPATIBILITY A 29′6″, predominantly windowless building has a scale and character that do not fit the surrounding neighborhood. ADAPTABILITY The building footprint, site arrangement and parking supply constrain meaningful conversion to other commercial uses. The Commission needed sufficient evidence for each finding when it approved this specific plan. Vehicle types, turning movements and pedestrian crossings create safety concerns on surrounding neighborhood streets, Cerrillos Road and with Fire Station 3. 08 T R A F F I C A N D AC C E S S Area streets: traffic circulation Source: DP Evidence Packet p. 15 (NMDOT aerial overlay); pp. 3–4. 09 T R A F F I C A N D AC C E S S Vehicle types and overall lengths Source: design-vehicle standards and representative manufacturer dimensions; photorealistic illustrative vehicles. FOUR VEHICLE PROFILES · COMMON HORIZONTAL SCALE 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 FEET 39.5 ft Crew cab + 16-ft trailer 40–41 ft≈ 22-ft moving box truck WB-67 tractor-semitrailer 73.5 ft Overall length and articulation—not trip counts alone—govern real access and turning conflicts. ≈30 ft 10 SU-40 / single-unit truck T R A F F I C A N D AC C E S S Two sites, four entrances, a Fourth Street crossing Source: filed DP Evidence Packet p. 10, Exhibit 1 — original DP-103 drawing (exact embedded source image). 11 T R A F F I C A N D AC C E S S Source: DP Evidence Packet pp. 4, 14–15; SFCC §24-2.6 truck restrictions cited in packet. 12 Fifth Street: Turn Pocket Capacity Concern T R A F F I C A N D AC C E S S Fourth and Fifth: access consequences Source: DP Evidence Packet pp. 3, 13, 15; NMDOT proposed linework. 13 T R A F F I C A N D AC C E S S Source: DP Evidence Packet pp. 3, 11, 15; NMDOT proposed linework. Third Street: where can outbound traffic go? 14 T R A F F I C A N D AC C E S S Second Street: signalized crossing and Berry Avenue Source: DP Evidence Packet pp. 3–4, 12, 15; NMDOT proposed linework. 15 C O M PAT I B I L I T Y Neighborhood compatibility: views from Fourth Street Source: DP Evidence Packet p. 16; June 4 applicant meeting renderings. Fourth & Berry Fourth & Cerrillos Substantial height differential, largely windowless façades, and an incongruous design incompatible with the surrounding neighborhood. 16 C O M PAT I B I L I T Y Neighborhood compatibility: views from Fifth Street Source: DP Evidence Packet pp. 17, 21–24; applicant meeting renderings and owner statements. Fifth & Berry Fifth & Cerrillos Murals and a few architectural elements do not resolve the mass and design, which remains incompatible with the surrounding neighborhood. 17 T E C H N I CA L R E V I E W Code compliance issues at the time of approval Source: DP Evidence Packet pp. 5, 8, 19–20; City June 4 packet pp. 93–94, 259–260. TC 39–44 DRAINAGE TC39–44 identified outstanding drainage analysis and required revisions. Material site-design impacts remained to be resolved. TC 37 LIGHTING TC37 identified 74 photometric points exceeding the permitted maximum. Lighting compliance was not established. TC 24 / 27–28 LANDSCAPING TC24 / 27–28 required parking-island area, landscaping and screening corrections affecting the site design. APPROVAL STANDARD Violations which may change the project footprint, parking or landscaping should have been resolved before approval. 18 P U B L I C I N T E R E S T Community amenities: limited access and operational concerns Source: DP Evidence Packet pp. 4–7; original City Planning Commission packet pp. 75–80, 245. DOG PARK Access hours COMMUNITY ROOM Access hours Community-room availability likewise appears tied to staffing or operating hours, limiting the public benefit represented in the application. The represented public amenities are constrained by access and practical operating arrangements. Applicant testimony indicated the dog-park access would have to be limited to staffing hours if the gate is to be secured overnight. No dedicated dog-park water source was identified; sanitation and waste disposal remain concerns. 19 C O M PAT I B I L I T Y Height, scale and Cerrillos frontage Source: DP Evidence Packet pp. 8, 18; original DP-103; applicant height illustration. 29′ 6″ Height shown on Development Plan DP-103 SITE AND STREET RELATIONSHIP The building’s scale and largely blank frontage heighten its impact on the Cerrillos streetscape. 20 21 ADAPTABILITY Adaptability: current parking versus possible reuse BUILDING 1 — APPROVED DEVELOPMENT PLAN 89,648 sq. ft. gross floor area Illustrative floor area supported by all 73 existing parking spaces POTENTIAL FUTURE USE AREA AT FORMER CODE PARKING RATIO 14,600 sq. ft. net leasable Nonmedical offices 25,550 sq. ft. net leasable Neighborhood grocery / laundromat 29,200 sq. ft. net leasable Flea market 36,500 sq. ft. vendor area Current proposal: 73 parking spaces provided / 69 spaces required Source: DP Evidence Packet pp. 4–5, 8, 10; former SFCC parking ratios. Alternative-use comparisons are illustrative. 21 Certain retail sales/service uses R E Q U E ST E D D E C I S I O N Reverse the Development Plan approval Alternatively: vacate and remand for review under the correct Code, with findings supported by the record. 01 Correct Chapter 14 edition 02 Traffic and safety undermine public interest 03 Incompatible and not adaptable Redevelopment is welcome. This project is not compatible with the neighborhood or adaptable to alternative uses. Traffic and safety concerns do not support the required public-interest finding.