Regular Governing Body Meeting - Second Wednesday — Tue, Nov 10, 2026 · 8A. Salvador Perez Recreation Center Update (Sandy Emory, Community Services Department Director; sxemory@santafenm.gov)
CITY OF SANTA FE | FEASIBILITY & TECHNICAL EVALUATION Salvador Perez Swimming Pool Complete Remodel vs. Full Replacement Physical conditions • regulatory requirements • investment options • long-term facility considerations Feasibility study completed by: Farnsworth Group • Counsilman-Hunsaker • Davenport Construction DATE OF AUDIT October 2026 01 | EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Decision at-a-glance Consultant evaluation: full replacement is recommended over a complete remodel. CITY OF SANTA FE | SALVADOR PEREZ SWIMMING POOL 2 FACILITY STATUS Closed since March 2026; existing vessel is non-compliant with health requirements. COST DIFFERENTIAL Estimated remodel and replacement ranges differ by approximately 5%. RECOMMENDED ACTION Advance full replacement as the preferred long-term investment. Why replacement is favored If a remodel is pursued, the only component from the existing mechanical system that can be saved and reinstalled is the pool heater. All other equipment and systems must be replaced. Only about two-thirds of the existing concrete shell would be retained in a remodel. Remodeling costs will exceed 50% of the total replacement cost. This removes the pool's current grand-fathered exemptions and requires the entire facility to be brought up to current aquatic codes. Estimated total investment $4.50M–$5.07M Complete remodel $4.75M–$5.32M Full replacement ■ ■ ■ 02 | EXISTING POOL Facility baseline The pool serves as a year-round aquatic resource. CITY OF SANTA FE | SALVADOR PEREZ SWIMMING POOL 3 Location 601 Alta Vista Street, Santa Fe, NM Original construction 70+ years ago Dimensions 50 ft × 75 ft; 7 lanes; 25-yard lap pool Water depth 3 ft shallow end to 10 ft deep end Water volume 180,000 gallons Surface area 3,935 sq ft, including ramp alcove Ramp alcove 7 ft 6 in wide × 34 ft long Recorded repairs 2000 drainpipe; 2016 liner removed; 2019 plaster, 2020 mold remediation, various large and small capital projects. Current state of operations: water is recirculated unheated to maintain plaster integrity. SE1 I I_ I I I I I I □ Slide 3 SE1 Fix this EMORY, SANDRA X., 2026-11-06T14:51:04.543 03 | EXISTING CONDITIONS Physical infrastructure audit Key deficiencies identified in the feasibility assessment. CITY OF SANTA FE | SALVADOR PEREZ SWIMMING POOL 4 SeverityObserved condition / deficiencySystem area High Metal staining; unmaintained mid-pool cold joint with probable water loss into subgrade soils Pool vessel & plaster CriticalCorroded stainless-steel gutter; broken grating supports; no gutter at ramp alcovePerimeter overflow High Smooth concrete; failed expansion joints; saturated areas; abandoned corroded anchors Pool deck & drainage CriticalUndersized 6-in main drain; no floor inlets; drain-cover certification unverifiedPlumbing & inlets Critical400 GPM pump; 7.5-hour turnover; leaking pump volute; unsupported strainerMechanical & pumps High20+ year-old sand filter with broken lateral; no backwash air gap; corroded acid roomFiltration & water care CriticalRamp width reported as 40 in; corroded embedded handrails; loose starting blocksADA & safety Severity labels are reproduced from the source assessment. 04 | REQUIRED IMPROVEMENTS Mandatory remediation and optional enhancements Separate code- and safety-related scope from recommended upgrades. CITY OF SANTA FE | SALVADOR PEREZ SWIMMING POOL 5 Required scope Recommended Improvements Replace steel gutter with concrete perimeter gutter and a 3,935- gallon surge tank. Install new 8-inch main drain piping and centerline floor-inlet distribution. Remove and rebuild deck for surge tank, gravity lines, lighting conduit and non-slip concrete. Rebuild ADA ramp with 33–38-inch clear width and socketed rails. Replace mechanical systems: 575 GPM pump, stacked sand filters, chemical feed and acid-room HVAC. LED underwater lighting, including wall niches. Secondary deck-mounted ADA lift. Premium cementitious deck topping for improved traction. Variable-frequency drive pump controls tied to magnetic flow meters. Less-corrosive chemical blends to help preserve equipment rooms. ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ Ramp and alcov& ov&Niew Sp:Jfled p:Jtch at r.111 post 05 | REGULATORY COMPLIANCE Requirements affecting reopening and renovation The source assessment identifies several governing requirements. CITY OF SANTA FE | SALVADOR PEREZ SWIMMING POOL 6 NMED REOPENING INSPECTION 7.18.1.14 NMAC: because the pool has been out of public service for more than 30 days, a formal NMED reopening inspection is required before public use. SUBSTANTIAL ALTERATION 7.18.1.11 NMAC: renovation exceeding 50% of replacement cost triggers full modern-code compliance, including the Model Aquatic Health Code (MAHC). WATER TURNOVER MAHC Table 4.7.1.10: maximum 6-hour turnover (500 GPM minimum). Existing pump: 400 GPM / 7.5 hours. Recommended design target: 575 GPM / 5.2 hours. ACCESSIBILITY & DRAIN SAFETY The assessment cites 2010 ADA Standards for ramp dimensions or lifts, and the Virginia Graeme Baker (VGB) Act for certified ANSI/APSP-16 drain covers. Note: Regulatory references and interpretations are presented as stated in the October 2026 feasibility assessment; confirm applicable requirements with the relevant authorities during design. 06 | REMODEL ENGINEERING A remodel requires extensive demolition The assessment estimates that approximately 66% or more of the existing concrete vessel would be demolished. CITY OF SANTA FE | SALVADOR PEREZ SWIMMING POOL 7 1 Gutter perimeter Remove the top 24–32 inches of pool wall around the perimeter. 2 Center floor trench Cut a 36-inch-wide trench from shallow to deep end for the new 8- inch drain line. 3 Floor inlet trenches Cut six 24-inch-wide trenches across 75% of the pool width. 4 Lighting penetrations Remove ten 3 ft × 3 ft concrete sections for underwater light niches. 5 ADA ramp and deck Remove the existing ramp alcove and surrounding deck. Note: extensive cutting, drilling and epoxy pinning into 70-year-old reinforcing steel may compromise structural integrity and contribute to reflective cracking or cold-joint leaks. Motor nameplate 07 | FINANCIAL ASSESSMENT Opinion of probable construction costs Estimates prepared by Davenport Construction Management and Lee-Sure Pools Inc. All costs subject to 10 -15% increase based on procurement. CITY OF SANTA FE | SALVADOR PEREZ SWIMMING POOL 9 Full replacementComplete remodelCost category $261,870$261,870Architectural, engineering & design $700,000–$1,000,000$675,000–$975,000General conditions & demolition $2,250,000–$2,450,000$2,050,000–$2,250,000Pool shell, gutters, tile, plaster & surge tank $750,000$750,000Pool mechanical equipment & controls $791,800–$864,800$766,800–$834,800Non-pool facility works (HVAC, electrical, plumbing) $4,749,800–$5,322,800$4,499,800–$5,067,800TOTAL ESTIMATED INVESTMENT Funding Gap: D2 Councilors have prioritized a $2m ICIP ask for SFY28 Estimate notes: includes HVAC replacement ($300,000), electrical ($142,000) and equipment-room demolition ($175,000).I 08 | OPERATIONAL FEASIBILITY Potential long-term operating benefits The assessment describes expected efficiencies from modern systems. CITY OF SANTA FE | SALVADOR PEREZ SWIMMING POOL 10 ENERGY & UTILITIES • New VFD pumps and automated HVAC / dehumidification • Estimated 25–35% reduction in annual electrical consumption • Surge tank design intended to minimize heat loss WATER & CHEMICALS • Sealed vessel may eliminate water loss (up to 180+ gallons/day) • Stacked glass-media filters may reduce backwash water loss by 50% STAFFING & MAINTENANCE • Automated chemical controllers • Less-corrosive chemical storage • Reduced manual handling risk, downtime and emergency callouts *These are projected benefits described in the feasibility assessment; actual operations may vary. 9 | ALTERNATIVES ANALYSIS Three development scenarios The report favors full replacement based on cost, service life and structural risk. CITY OF SANTA FE | SALVADOR PEREZ SWIMMING POOL 11 Assessment outcomeCode statusEstimated lifeEstimated costScenario Would not resolve turnover violation; pool cannot legally reopen. Non-compliant1–3 years$500K–$800K1. Minimal repairs Retains 70+ year-old vessel base and risk of reflective cracking / cold-joint leaks. Compliant upon build 15–20 years$4.50M–$5.07M2. Pool remodel Recommended; new monolithic structure and optimized plumbing layout. Fully compliant40-50 years$4.75M–$5.32M3. New pool vessel Key comparison: the remodel offers limited estimated savings relative to replacement while retaining the existing vessel structure. 10 | PROJECT TIMELINE Implementation: authorization to reopening Indicative 16-month sequence presented in the feasibility assessment. CITY OF SANTA FE | SALVADOR PEREZ SWIMMING POOL 12 01 Design & permitting Months 1-6 Complete design / engineering plans ($258K); submit NMED permit materials; obtain City Council authorization. › 02 Procurement & bidding Months 7-8 Evaluate contractors; onboard specialized pool contractor; order long-lead equipment. › 03 Demolition & construction Months 8–18 Remove existing shell; excavate; construct new pool vessel; install mechanical systems and deck. › 04 Commissioning & reopening Month 18 Balance water; complete safety inspection; train staff; prepare for public reopening. Schedule is a planning sequence; actual duration will depend on approvals, procurement, construction conditions and commissioning. 11 | COSF AQUATICS PROGRAMMING Operational considerations Something CITY OF SANTA FE | SALVADOR PEREZ SWIMMING POOL 13 Lifeguards Addressing the Ongoing Lifeguard Staffing Shortage Immediate next steps 1 Hiring – Current staffing levels – 2 FT Lifeguards, 2 FT Instructors, 9 PT Lifeguards, 8 Temp Lifeguards , 6 Trainees, 7 FT Supervisors, 2 PT Supervisors , 1 Tech and 1 Manager. Vacancies: 22 positions. 2 Recruitment strategies – Created a 2nd Aquatics Technician position, increased collaboration with SFPS, Free Lifeguarding course to be offered over Christmas and Spring breaks 3 Current retention efforts - Continuous advertisement and recruiting, consistent course offerings and communications, ongoing class and compensations studies for fair pay. Hiring and retention incentives. Questions & discussion 12 | CONCLUSION Next Steps CITY OF SANTA FE | SALVADOR PEREZ SWIMMING POOL 13 RECOMMENDED STRATEGIC DECISION Authorize planning for a new pool vessel within an estimated $4.75M–$5.32M investment range. 1 Approve design-phase funding of $261,870. 2 Finalize the engineering scope for design-document development. 3 Initiate NMED preliminary construction review submission. Questions & discussion