Historic Districts Review Board Meeting — Tue, Nov 10, 2026 · 9K. 2026-013402-HDRB. 224 E Palace Ave, Downtown and Eastside Historic District. Significant. Dimitrov Design Studio LLC, Tiho Dimitrov, agent for Drury Southwest Santa Fe Inc., owner, proposes to remove the ADA ramp, basement access exterior steps, walls, and metal railings, and replace pipe guardrails. Exceptions are requested to 14-4.6(E)(4)(II) for alterations to primary facades. (Lani McCulley)
HISTORIC DESIGN REVIEW BOARD FIELD TRIP
TUESDAY, JUNE 30, 2009-12:00 NOON
HISTORIC PRESERVATION DMSION, 2ND FLOOR CITY HALL
filSTORIC DESIGN REVIEW BOARD HEARING
TUESDAY, JUNE 30, 2009-5:30 PM
CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS
A. CALL TO ORDER
B. ROLL CALL
C. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
D. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
E. COMMUNICATIONS
F. BUSINESS FROM THE FLOOR
G. OLD BUSINESS
I. Case #H-08-095B. Southwest comer of Palace Avenue and Paseo de Peralta.
Downtown & Eastside Historic District Mark A. Hogan, agent for DSW Santa
Fe, LLC, proposes to restore historic character on a significant building, remodel
two contributing buildings by removing non-contributing additions and
constructing 39,000 sq. ft. of additions, as well as constructing approximately
62,000 sq. ft. of additional buildings and site improvements. The maximum
allowable height for streetscape structures is 16'9" and interior lot structures is
18'8". New structures are proposed at 25'9" and 44'4". Six exceptions are
requested: height {14-5.2(0)(9)); roof pitch (14-5.2(D)(9Xd)); Santa Fe Style
(14-5.2(E)); altering openings on primary elevations (14-5.2(D)(5)(a));
exceeding the 30" window rule (14-5.2(E){l){c)); and constructing an addition
on a primary elevation {l4-5.2(D){2){c)). (David Rasch)
H. NEW BUSINESS
I. MATIERS FROM THE BOARD
J. ,ADJOURNMENT.
For more infonnation regarding cases on this agenda, please call the Historic Preservation
Division at 955-6605. Persons with disabilities in need of accommodations or an interpreter for
the hearing impaired, contact the City Clerk's office at 955-6520, five (5) working days prior to
hearing date. If you wish to attend the June 30, 2009 Historic Design Review Board Field Trip,
please notify the Historic Preservation by 9:00 am on Tuesday, June 30; 2009.
SS002.pmd·11Al2
•
A.
B.
C.
D.
E.
F.
G.
CITY CLERK'S OFFICE
Agenda n,11,,f
IDSTORIC DESIGN REVIEW BOARD FIELD TRIP
TUESDAY, JUNE 30, 2009-12:00 NOON
HISTORIC PRESERVATION DIVISION, 2ND FLOOR CITY HALL
IDSTORIC DESIGN REVIEW BOARD HEARING
TUESDAY, JUNE 30, 2009-5:30 PM
CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS
CALL TO ORDER
ROLL CALL
APPROVAL OF AGENDA
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
COMMUNICATIONS
BUSINESS FROM THE FLOOR
OLD BUSINESS
Case #H-08-095B. Southwest comer of Palace Avenue and Paseo de Peralta.
.Downtown & Eastside Historic District. Mark A. Hogan, agent for DSW Santa
Fe, LLC, proposes to restore historic character on a significant building, remodel
two contributing buildings by removing non-contributing additions and
constructing 39,000 sq. ft. of additions, as well as constructing approximately
62,000 sq. ft. of additional buildings and site improvements. The maximum
allowable height for streetscape structures is 16'9" and interior lot structures is
18'8". New structures are proposed at 25'9" and 44'4". Six exceptions are
requested: height (14-5.2(0)(9)); roof pitch (14-5.2(D)(9)(d)); Santa Fe Style
(14-5.2(E)); altering openings on primary elevations (14-5.2(D)(5)(a));
exceeding the 30" window rule (14-5.2(E)(l)(c)); and constructing an addition
on a primary elevation (14-5.2(D)(2)(c)). (David Rasch)
H. NEW BUSINESS
L MATTERS FROM THE BOARD
J. , ADJOURNMENT
For more information regarding cases on this agenda, please call the Historic Preservation
Division at 955-6605. Persons with disabilities in need of accommodations or an interpreter for
the hearing impaired, contact the City Clerk's office at 955-6520, five (5) working days prior to
hearing date. If you wish to attend the June 30, 2009 Historic Design Review Board Field Trip,
please notify the Historic Preservation by 9:00 am on Tuesday, June 30, 2009.
SS002.pmd-11/02
SUMMARY INDEX
~ HISTORIC DESIGN REVIEW BOARD
June 30, 2009''-
ITEM ACTION TAKEN PAGE(S}
Approval of Agenda Approved as amended 1-2
Approval of Minutes None
Communications None 2
Business from the, Floor None 2
Old Business
1. Case #H 08-0958 Approved with condition 2-66
Palace at Paseo de Peralta
New Business None 67
Matters from the Board None 67
Adjournment Adjourned at 8:00 p.m. 67
'~
MINUTES OF THE
CITY OF SANTA FE
HISTORIC DESIGN REVIEW BOARD
June 30, 2009
A. CALL TO ORDER
A special meeting of the City of Santa Fe Historic Design Review Board was called to order by Chair
Sharon Woods on the above date at approximately 5:30 p.m. in the City Council Chambers at City Hall,
200 Lincoln, Santa Fe, New Mexico.
B. ROLLCALL
Roll Call indicated the presence of a quorum as follows:
MEMBERS PRESENT:
Ms. Sharon Woods, Chair
Ms. Cecilia Rios, Vice Chair
Mr. Dan Featheringill
Dr. John Kantner
Ms. Christine Mather
Ms. Deborah Shapiro
Ms. Karen Walker
MEMBERS ABSENT:
OTHERS PRESENT:
Mr. David Rasch, Historic Planner Supervisor
Mr. Carl Boaz, Stenographer
NOTE: All items in the Committee packet for all agenda items are incorporated herewith by
reference. The original Committee packet is on file in the Historic Planning Department.
Chair Woods announced to the public that anyone wishing to appeal a decision of the Historic Design
Review Board could do so and would need to file the appeal within seven days of this meeting.
C. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 1
'
Ms. Rios moved to approve the agenda as published. Ms. Shapiro seconded the motion and it
passed by unanimous voice vote.
D. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
None.
E. COMMUNICATIONS
None.
F. BUSINESS FROM THE FLOOR
None.
G. OLD BUSINESS
1. Case #H-08-0958. Southwest comer of Palace Avenue and Paseo de Peralta. Downtown &
Eastside Historic District Mark A. Hogan, agent for DSW Santa Fe, LLC, proposes to restore
historic character on a significant building, remodel two contributing buildings by removing •
non-contributing additions and constructing 39,000 sq. ft. of additions, as well as constructing
approximately 62,000 sq. ft. of additional buildings and site improvements. The maximum
allowable height for streetscape structures is 16'9" and interior lot structures is 1a·a•. New
structures are proposed at 25'9" and 44'4•. Six exceptions are requested: height (14-5.2(0)(9));
roof pitch {14-5.2(O){9)(d)); Santa Fe Style (14-5.2(E)); altering openings on primary elevations
(14-5.2(O)(5)(a)); exceeding the 30" window rule (14-5.2(E)(1)(c)); and constructing an addition on
a primary elevation (14-5.2(O)(2)(c)). (David Rasch)
A handout from the Drury Southwest team was distributed to the Board members.
Chair Woods asked that Mr. Rasch read the staff report. She decided that the exception criteria
responses did not need to be read but were included in this record. She explained that at this meeting they
were taking the remaining height exceptions. Mr. Rasch would read a section of the staff report for the
topic being focused upon and then have public comments and then they would go to the openings and
glazing exceptions; and then they would go to the style exceptions. They probably would not get to project
design approval. That would probably in their final meeting.
Ms. Walker asked if the exception was an additional six foot ten inches.
Chair Woods responded that they should let Mr. Rasch present his report and explained that this
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 2
handout was not an official document but was something that the Board would correct it if needed.
Mr. Rasch presented the staff report in separate sections. However, the staff report in its entirety and
the exception criteria and responses are presented herein for the record.
BACKGROUND & SUMMARY:
The structures on the property at the southwest comer of Palace Avenue and Paseo de Peralta in the
Downtown & Eastside Historic District are: Marian Hall at 224 East Palace Avenue; old St. Vincent's
Hospital at 228 East Palace Avenue; and Central Boiler Plant behind 228. Other structures include the
Maintenance Buildings behind 228 and connecting hallways between Marian Hall and the Hospital and
between the Hospital and the Boiler Plant.
The first exception we will hear is the remaining height exception and that is for the new gallery - retail
- parking garage building. That starts on page 11 in your packet.
The applicant proposes to remodel the property as follows.
Marian Hall
224 East Palace Avenue, known as St. Vincent's Sanatorium and also Marian Hall, was constructed
with brick around 1908 by Isaac Hamilton Rapp for the Sisters of Charity in the Craftsman style. The
building originally functioned as a convent and a sanatorium with sleeping porches on the second and third
floors. The porches have been removed at approximately 1954. Two hallway connections and a stairwell
were constructed on the east elevation when the new hospital was consbucted in 1952-1953. All historic
windows were removed and replicated windows were installed when the State of New Mexico moved
offices into the building in 1984. The building retains much of its original integrity and it is architecturally
and historically important. The building is listed as significant to the district and all elevations are
considered to be primary.
The building will be rehabilitated to restore important elements of original integrity. In case of building
code conflicts, the applicant proposes to restore original character if not the literal historic construction.
Non-historic material will be removed, including the stucco finish where applicable, cladding on bay
windows, and the south elevation ADA ramp and handrails. The non-original stair addition to the
southeast corner also will be removed. Using historic documentation, the multistory verandas with
replacement of non-historic windows with doors leading onto the verandas and the solarium will be
reconstructed along the south and west elevations along with restoration of the exterior brick finish. This
proposal follows the Regulation of Significant Structures (Section 14-5.2 (C)) which preserves distinctive
historic features such as brick finishes and the General Design Standards which requires documentation to
replace or duplicate missing architectural features (Section 14-5.2 (0)).
The historic canopy over the east elevation entry will be recreated from historic documentation. A
larger canopy will be consbucted in front of the east elevation entry door and over the recreated canopy
without attaching to the structures but with an overlap to achieve weather protection. The larger canopy
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 3
will have wooden beams on brick piers with cement caps and a standing seam pitched metal accent roof
that harmonizes with the existing roof pitch on the building.
Marian-Hospital Connecting Hallways
The connecting hallways from the Hospital to Marian Hall were part of the Hospital construction
campaign. They are constructed with the same materials and style of the Hospital but, they do not have
unique merit in themselves. The connections obscure the·important east elevation of Marian Hall, the
adjacent significant building. The connections were listed as non-contributing to the district in 2008.
These additions will be removed.
Old St. Vincent's Hospital
228 East Palace Avenue, known previou;ly as La Villa Rivera, and now known as the old St Vincent's
Hospital was constructed with brick in 1950 by John Gaw Meem in the Territorial Revival style. The
building originally functioned as a hospital, then as a home for the elderly, and finally as State of New
Mexico offices. The HCPI is silent regarding alterations, but there are a variety of non-historic changes
present including two stair towers on elevations 2 and 11, sealing-up of the north elevation entrance on
elevation 3, and opening dimension changes on the south elevation 7. The building is listed as
contributing to the district and this status was confirmed in 2008. The following elevations were
determined to be primary on May 28, 2009: 1. NW-N; 3. N; 4. NE-E; 5. NE-N; 6. E; 9. S; and 12. W.
These elevations embody all of the unique architectural details and establish the building massing and step
backs with upper floors.
The building will be remodeled with approximately 39,000 square feet of additions on the south side.
The entrance to the hotel will be located on the south side, changed from the original hospital entry on the
north side.
The following changes are described by elevation number.
1. A Territorial surround will be installed at a second and first story window group and the first story
window will be removed with the subsequent opening lengthened for a door entrance. This historic steel
casement window will be reused on a subgrade wall on elevation 5, see below.
A 1O' high pergola will be constructed on the roof attached to the west elevation of the solarium.
2. The non-historic stair tower will be removed.
The first and second story windows will be remodeled. The second story window openings will be
lengthened and doors installed with balcony rails. Awnings will be installed above these doors. The first
story window openings will be lengthened and doors installed.
A non-historic solid .door on the fourth floor will be replaced with a door with divided-lights in the same
opening dimension.
A portion of the historic wooden balustrade will be retained to protect a tree but the level of installation
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 4
will be altered after the stairwell is removed. Some of the balustrade is in very poor condition and parts
that are not repairable will be replaced in-kind.
3. The original portal opening that served as the main hospital entrance will be restored by removing
the wall infill. Restoration of architectural wood detail will be completed.
4. The 8' high rooftop finial will be reconstructed from historic photographs. It appears to be iron.
An existing historic window on the fourth floor will be removed and a divided-light door will be installed
in the existing opening at the same width and header height. The window will be reused in the subgrade
wall on elevation 5, see below.
5. Six new window openings will be added subgrade in a new window well. All new window openings
can be installed with historic steel casement windows which were removed from other elevations on the
building.
6. There are no changes proposed to this elevation. Restoration of architectural wood detail will be
completed.
7. The non-historic portal will be removed.
An approximately 22,000 square foot 4-story addition will be constructed at this southeast side. The
addition features Territorial details that are similar to but do not repeat the existing details. The addition
will be set off from elevation 6. Along the south elevation of the addition there will be a brick capped
parapet at the second story, a pitched standing seam roof over the portal on the third story, and a trellis on
the fourth story. A brick-surfaced tower block on the addition features a pitched roof accent that mimics
existing non-conforming features on the building.
8. The one-story room addition will be remodeled as part of the proposed addition on elevation #7 and
this existing condition is non-conforming to the 10' required setback from primary elevation #9 (Section
14-5.2 (D)(2)(d)).
An existing historic window on the fourth floor will be removed and a divided-light door will be installed
in the existing opening at the same width and header height. The window will be reused in the subgrade
wall on elevation 5, see above.
The rooftop mechanicals barrier screening will be enlarged and capped with brick.
9. The mechanical ducts will be removed.
Restoration of architectural wood detail will be completed for upper balustrades and window casings.
The lower fa~ade will be remodeled as the main entrance to the building. Three two-story openings
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 5
will have large windows and an entry portal, a second story balcony, and a canopy above. Three
exceptions are requested for this remodel.
Excpt1. The portal and canopy additions at the entry violates the primary elevation rule for additions
(Section 14-5.2 (0)(2)(c)) and an exception is requested.
The following exception criteria are presented:
I. Do not damage the character of the streetscape;
The Addition exception requested is to allow a new entry feature to be located on fa~e #9 of this
existing building. This addition will not alter the character of the streetscape because this portion of the
building is removed from the streetscape and is more internally focused. While visibility of this feature
is important to the hotel, the portion of the south F~ of this building where the hotel's new entry is
proposed is setback from the sidewalk by over 220 ft. While there is Public Visibility of these south
elevation entry additions, they are not in relation to the Paseo de Peralta Streetscape.
Staff is in agreement with this response.
ii. Prevent a hardship to the applicant or an injury to the public welfare;
The renovation of the Old st. Vincent's Hospital Building is an example of adaptive re-use of an
existing historic building to create and maintain a new and viable use of the existing structure. The
entry addition proposed is required to serve the new main entrance to this important renovation
project. Without the proposed additions the building does not present a suitable public entrance for a
quality hotel. The denial of this exception would create a harr/ship for the applicant by prohibiting the
best use of the building as well as for the surrounding merchants and the downtown historic
community which will suffer the continued blight this building presents to the Downtown.
Staff is in agreement with this response.
iii. Strengthen the unique heterogeneous character of the City by providing a full range of design
options to ensure that residents can continue to reside within the Historic Districts;
This application, when approved, stands to remove one of the largest and most conspicuous blights in
the downtown. This alone will greatly strengthen the character of the City as we// as restore civic pride
in the appearance of our community. The proposed Addition exception will allow for the practical re-
use of the existing building and will provide a viable space and configuration for a secondary use. The
planned hotel win serve the local community as well as their guests with Dining, Shopping, Fitness and
Spa activities and senlices. The availability of a wide variety of activities and quality environments in
the Downtown will continue to strengthen the unique character in this portion of the City and ensure
that residents can continue to reside in and enjoy the Downtown.
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 6
Staff is in agreement with this response.
iv. Are due to special conditions and circumstances which are peculiar to the land or structure involved
and which are not applicable to other lands or structures in the related streetscape;
This request is unique in that the proposed design is specific to an existing building. The Old St.
Vincent's Hospital, a historically contributing building, was originally developed with the ambulance
entry and the kitchen's back door on the South Elevation on the f~de now known as #9. Above
these back-of-house uses, on the two uppermost floors, Meem the building's architect, centered two
balconies, similar to the balconies he had built on the East Elevation. These balcony features do not
reduce the overall height of this very tall and very flat portion of the building but add detail that creates
an architectural accent and provides some relief to the f~e. This proposal retains the important
upper balconies of the original construction as well as removes the unsightly back of house functions
from the newly activated ground level. Other buildings and projects in the H-District do not have these
existing conditions to relate to architecturally.
Staff is in agreement with this response.
v. Are due to special conditions and circumstances which are not a result of the actions of the
applicant;
The applicant purchased this property with the existing Hospital, Boiler PlantA.aundry and Marian Hall
already constructed. Recognizing the importance of these existing buildings the applicant committed to
preserving these buildings through adaptive re-use of the structures. Similar to previous answers on
this subject, the conditions that exist were established as part of a former and quite different use of this
building. The applicant did not create these conditions but in this application for exception attempts to
work with these special conditions and circumstances to find new and viable uses for this area of the
building. The proposed additions to this lower portion of the f~e in question endeavor to make this
entry viable without disturbing any of the more Historical Appearing Elements on the upper floors.
Staff is in agreement with this response.
and vi. Provide the least negative impact with respect to the purpose of this section as set forth in
paragraph 14-5.2 (A)(1).
There is no negative impact to the historic structure or the overall historic integrity of the buildings on
the site due to this proposed addition. The planning of the adaptations and restorations calls for taking
the least functional and historically sensitive portion of the existing building and carefully working with
the existing structure to add and integrate the hotel's main entry. This proposal presents no conflict
with the Code for development in Historic Districts and supports the Department of the Interior's
practices for the Adaptive Re-Use of Historic Structures. The proposed design also supports the
purpose and intent of 14-5.2 in preserving harmony in outward appearance and preseTVing property to
attract visitors and residents alike. A general harmony as to style, form, color, height, proportion,
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 7
texture and material is accomplished in the re-use of this portion of the building.
Staff is in agreement with this response and the proposed addition could be reversed to return original
integrity to the fagade.
Excpt2. The opening dimensions on the primary elevation will be altered in violation of the rule that
does not allow enlarging opening dimensions (Section 14--5.2 (D){5)(a) and an exception is requested.
The following exception criteria are presented:
I. Do not damage the character of the streetscape;
The opening exception is requested to allow new openings in an existing building that wiU not alter the
character of the streetscape. The portion of the south F~de of this building where the hotel's new
entry is proposed is setback from the sidewalk by over 220 ft. There is limited Public Visibility of these
south elevation openings in relation to the Paseo de Peralta Streetscape. The proposed openings are
not out of character with the pattern of existing openings and follow the pattern for structural columns
and window openings found elsewhere on the structure. The scale of the openings has been
increased to two story openings with inset panels that cover the floor structure and have windows
above and below (see elevations).
Staff is in agreement with this response.
ii. Prevent a hardship to the applicant or an injury to the public welfare;
Drury Southwest's redevelopment of the Old st. Vincent Hospital Building is an example of adaptive
re-use of an existing historic building to create and maintain a new and viable use of the structure. The
new openings proposed are required to serve the new Main Entrance to this renovation project
designed to bring people, light and air into the Lobby of the hotel. Wdhout the proposed openings the
building does not present a suitable public entrance for a quality hotel use. The denial of this exception
would create a hardship for the applicant by prohibiting the best use of the building. The hardship is
extended to the surrounding merchants and for the downtown historic community which will suffer the
continued blight this building presents to the Downtown and the continued degradation of Historic
Properties.
Staff is in agreement with this response.
iii. Strengthen the unique heterogeneous character of the City by providing a full range of design
options to ensure that residents can continue to reside within the Historic Districts;
The proposed opening exception will allow for the practical re- use of the existing building and provide
a viable space and configuration for a secondary use. The planned hotel will serve the local community
as well as their guests with Dining, Shopping, Fitness and Spa activities and services. The availability
Historic Design Review Board June 30. 2009 Page 8
of a wide variety of activities in the Downtown will continue to strengthen the unique character in this
portion of the City and ensure that residents can continue to reside in and enjoy the Historic
Downtown.
Staff is in agreement with this response.
iv. Are due to special conditions and circumstances which are peculiar to the land or structure involved
and which are not applicable to other lands or structures in the related streetscape;
This request is unique to this project in that the applicant proposes to convert a former service entry
and back of house portion of the original hospital building into a stately feature that will serve as the
building's Main Entry. These circumstances cannot be duplicated on any other land or in another
structure.
Staff is in agreement with this response.
v. Are due to special conditions and circumstances which are not a result of the actions of the
applicant;
Similar to previous answers on this subject, the conditions that exist were established as part of a
former and quite different use of this building. The applicant did not create these conditions but in this
. application for exception attempts to work with these special conditions and circumstances to find new
and viable uses for these buildings. The proposed openings endeavor to make this re-use viable.
Staff is in agreement with this response.
and vi. Provide the least negative impact with respect to the purpose of this section as set forth in
paragraph 14-5.2 (A)(1).
There is no negative impact to the structure or the overall historic integrity of the buildings on this site.
The planning of the adaptations and restorations calls for taking the least attractive and historically
sensitive portion of the existing building and carefully working with the existing structure to
integrate the hotel's main entry. This proposal presents no conflict with the Code for development in
Historic Districts and supports the Department of the Interior's practices for the Adaptive Re-Use of
Historic Structures. The proposed design also supports the purpose and intent of 14-5.2 in preserving
harmony in outward appearance and preserving property to attract visitors and residents alike. A
general harmony as to style, form, color, height, proportion, texture and material is accomplished in the
re-use of this portion of the building.
Staff is in agreement with this response.
Excpt3. The large windows in the entry violate the 30D rule (Section 14-5.2 (E)(1)(c)) and an exception
is requested.
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 9
The following exception criteria responses are presented:
I. Do not damage the character of the streetscape;
The 30" Glazing Rule exception is requested to allow the glazing in new openings at the buildings
entry areas to exceed the limit of 30" diagonal for any single pane of glass not under a portal. Allowing
this exception will not alter the character of the streetscape because this building elevation is not part
of the streetscape and because adherence to this rule would create a dishannonious condition
between the buildings existing windows which are non-conforming and the new windows designed for
the entry areas. The contrast in scale can be compared to the diagonal measure of the smallest
existing windows of 48" and the 30" allowed by current code. The largest diagonal measure of a
proposed window at these two f~des measures 6ft. A visual comparison makes clear that the 30"
windows are out of scale with the existing architecture whereas the proposed windows are more
appropriate for the new entry elements.
The entry area may be visible from a distance on Paseo de Peralta, but compliant glazing on these
larger panes would damage the building's harmony. From the street distance the size of the glazing is not
relevant to the streetscape.
ii. Prevent a hardship to the applicant or an injury to the public welfare;
The 30" Glazing rule creates a hardship to the applicant in that it requires a design solution that is not
harmonious with the existing architecture and presents a disjointed elevation that poorly melds old and
new.
Compliant glazing would be visually disturbing in this proposed design.
iii. Strengthen the unique heterogeneous character of the City by providing a full range of design
options to ensure that residents can continue to reside within the Historic Districts;
The proposed 30" Glazing Rule exception will allow for the successful integration of new and old
architectural features that will provide harmony and architectural integrity to the finished design. These
characteristics are important features to any business as well as to any Santa Fe resident that cares
about the quality of spaces found in our unique city. Attractive buildings will draw local residents and
visitors alike and that will perpetuate the viable use of these buildings which in tum continues to serve
those that Jive and work within the Historic District.
The larger panes will effectively help to draw the attention that the entry needs for this appropriate
adaptive re-use of the building.
iv. Are due to special conditions and circumstances which are peculiar to the land or structure involved
and which are not applicable to other lands or structures in the related streetscape;
This request is unique in that the proposed design is specific to an existing building. The existing
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 10
hospital which has been determined to be a historically contributing building was originally developed
with windows that are consistently larger than the maximum size of glass panes that are currently
allowed under the 30" glazing rule. Other building and projects in the H-District do not have these
existing conditions to relate to architecturally.
The existing historic windows are non-conforming because they predate the 30" glazing rule.
v. Are due to special conditions and circumstances which are not a result of the actions of the
applicant;
The applicant purchased this property with the existing Hospital, Boiler Plant/Laundry and Marian Hall
already constructed. Recognizing the importance of these existing buildings the applicant committed to
preserving these buildings through adaptive re-use of the structures. Similar to the answer to point
above the conditions that exist were established as part of a former and quite different use. The
applicant did not create these conditions but in this application requests the understanding and
assistance in completing the renovation with integrity of design that such prominent buildings require.
The applicant purchased the non-conforming condition as part of the historic character of this building.
and vi. Provide the least negative impact with respect to the purpose of this section as set forth in
paragraph 14-5.2 (A)(1).
There is no negative impact resulting from the granting of this exception. The negative impact will
come from the exception not being approved since it will create conflicts with the existing architecture
~ and degrade the overall appearance of the project and specifically the integrity of the existing building.
This proposal presents no conflict with the intent of the Code for development in Historic Districts and
supports the purpose and intent of 14-5.2 in preserving harmony in outward appearance and
preserving property to attract visitors and residents alike. A general harmony as to style, form, color,
height, proportion, texture and material is accomplished between buildings of historic design and the
proposed changes.
This proposed design is the least negative in impact to the building.
10. The lower f~e will be remodeled where three two-story openings will have large windows and
doors. These large windows violate the 30" rule (Section 14-5.2 (E)(1)(c)) and an exception is requested,
see above on elevation 9. Also, a canopy like that proposed for elevation #9 will be constructed. This
addition conforms to the 10' setback requirement from primary elevation #9 (Section 14-5.2 (D)(2)(d)).
11. The non-historic stair tower will be increased in height to gain access to the roof with an elevator.
The stair tower will be incorporated into an approximately 17,000 square foot 4-story addition on at the
southwest side. A two-story entrance will be constructed that mimics the new two-story entrance on
elevation 1.
The addition features Territorial details that are similar to but do not repeat the existing details. Along
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 11
the south elevation of the addition there will be a brick capped parapet at the second story, a pitched
standing seam roof over the portal on the third story, and an inset portal with a brick capped parapet on the
fourth story. A brick-surfaced tower block on the addition features a pitched roof accent that mimics the
roof on the existing solarium. These features are similar to but do not repeat existing non-confonnities.
Also, the addition confonns to the 10' setback requirement from primary elevation #12 {Section 14-5.2
(D)(2)(d)).
12. There are no changes proposed to this elevation other than removal of the connecting hallways.
Restoration of architectural wood detail will be completed.
Hospital-Boiler Connecting Bridge
The connecting mechanical gangway from the Hospital to the Boiler Plant was part of the Hospital
construction campaign. • It is constructed with the same materials and style of the Hospital but, it does not
have unique merit in itself. The connection is an awkward attachment to both the north elevation of the
1950 addition to the Boiler Plant and to the south elevation of the Hospital. The connection angles
between the structures and it is not integral to either structure. The connection was listed as
non-contributing to the district in 2008. These additions will be removed.
Central Boiler Plant
The building that is located south of and behind the Hospital is known as the Central Boiler Plant. It
was constructed with concrete and brick in 1904 to serve Marian Hall. At an unknown date, the historic
stair and landing on the north elevation were removed. Also, the original arched double entry doors on
the north elevation were altered to a rectangular opening. In the 1950s, a large addition was constructed
by John Gaw Meem on the east and south elevations, and the character of the entire structure was altered
by replacing a pitched roof with a flat roof and adding Territorial detailing to match the architectural style of
the new Hospital that it now also served.
The buHding retains its historic materials, including wood double-hung windows in the 1904 portion,
and the non-original additions are now considered to be part of the historic character. A small CMU block
addition was constructed on the west elevation at an unknown, presumably non-historic date. The
building was listed as contributing to the district in 2008. The following elevations were detennined to be
primary on May 28, 2009: 1. 1910 N; 2. 1910 W; and 3. 1950 E. These elevations embody all of the
unique architectural details and establish a record of the historic changes to the building.
The following changes are described by elevation number.
1. The historic balcony opening on the north elevation will be restored with installation of transom
windows and doors. The historic landing and stair will be reestablished with a change of orientation on
the stair from north to west due to fire-lane restrictions and mimicking the historic stair that exists on the
west elevation. Detailed drawings of the rail design, materials, and colors are attached.
Non-historic alterations to wall openings on the north elevation will be remodeled. The historic
window opening at the east side will be retained in the same location. The non-historic door infill at the
center will be retained. The non-historic alteration to the window opening at the west side with a
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 12
mechanical grille will be infilled with brick wall rather than restored to the original opening dimension.
2. The non-historic CMU block addition at the northwest comer will be removed.
A new railing at the landing on the west elevation is proposed to match the new railing on the stair of
the north elevation. This railing does not reestablish an historic rail in this location, but it is required to
meet current building codes.
3. New door and window openings are proposed for the north end of the east elevation. An exception
is requested to create new openings where opening do not exist on a primary elevation (Section 14-5.2
(0)(5)(a)(ii)). The windows mimic the non-conforming style of the existing historic windows.
The following exception criteria responses are presented:
I. Do not damage the character of the streetscape;
The opening exception requested to allow two new openings in an existing building will not aHer the
character of the streetscape because this building elevation is not part of a streetscape. The east
fa~ade of this building is setbac/c from the sidewalk by over 240 ft. and is largely obscured by the
proposed parking structure that is located between the Boiler Building and Paseo de Peralta. There is
limited Public Visibility of this feature in relation to the Paseo de Peralta streetscape and the proposed
openings are not out of character with the existing window openings and will be only subtly different
from other windows on the building.
The east elevation of this building will not be fully visible from the street and therefore judgments about
damage are not relevant. The building has changed over time and those changes may confuse its
character.
ii. Prevent a hardship to the applicant or an injury to the public welfare;
The Existing Boiler Building is an example of adaptive re-use of an existing building to maintain a
viable current use of the structure. The new openings proposed will bring light and air into the comer of
the building adjacent to main entry to the hotel. Without the proposed openings the building does not
present an attractive structure for restaurant use, would prove itself difficult to lease and or market, and
would not enhance the experience of any potential restaurant clientele, and thus creates a hardship for
the re-use of this building.
The northeast comer of the building is most visible from the street and needs to draw attention to the
entry of this appropriate adaptive re-use project.
iii. Strengthen the unique heterogeneous character of the City by providing a full range of design
options to ensure that residents can continue to reside within the Historic Districts;
The proposed opening exception will allow for the practical re- use of the existing building and provide
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 13
a viable space and configuration for a secondary use, which in this case is a restaurant. The planned
restaurant will serve the local community as well as hotel guests. The availability of a wide variety of
dining establishments has always been a magnet for the Downtown and will clearly continue to
strengthen the unique character of the site and this portion of the City to ensure that residents can
continue to reside in and enjoy the Historic District.
The restaurant will provide for a use that does not exist on this side of the Paseo, thus strengthening
the heterogeneity of this streetscape.
iv. Are due to special conditions and circumstances which are peculiar to the land or structure involved
and which are not applicable to other lands or structures in the related streetscape;
This request is unique in that the proposed openings are on an existing building that relates to another
existing building (the old hospital). These circumstances cannot be duplicated on any other land or in
another structure. The building in question is an architectural anomaly of sorts based on its two distinct
architectural styles being blended and manifested on each separate elevation. The structure in
question barely equates to the adjacent hospital in terms of harmony and character, and has no
relationship to structures and styles found in the streetscape.
The building is a remnant of former conditions on this site which have long since changed.
v. Are due to special conditions and circumstances which are not a result of the actions of the
applicant;
Similar to the answer to point 'c' above the conditions that exist were established as part of a former
and quite different use of both buildings. The applicant did not create these conditions but in this
application for exception attempts to find new and viable uses for these buildings. The proposed
openings endeavor to make this re-use viable.
The applicant purchased the non-street facing condition of this commercial building.
and vi. Provide the least negative impact with respect to the purpose of this section as set forth in
paragraph 14-5.2 {A){1).
There is no negative impact to the structure or the overall historic integrity of the building due to the
series of changes to the building over time. There is not a coherent historic design that needs to be
preserved but an evolution of changes to the building. This proposal presents no conflict with the Code
for development in Historic Districts. The proposed design supports the purpose and intent of 14-5.2 in
preserving harmony in outward appearance and preserving property to attract visitors and residents
alike. A general harmony as to style, form, color, height, proportion, texture and material is
accomplished between buildings of historic design and the proposed changes.
Due to the building's location on the property and in the proposed development, the southeast comer
is the best location for an entrance to the building. It will also retain the integrity of the original north
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 14
elevation but not altering that location for an entrance.
~ 4. New door and window openings are proposed on the north elevation of the Meem addition. These
meet the 30" glazing rule and the 3' comer rule.
5. The south elevation will be reconfigured and it will retain the "back-of-house" loading facility.
Several window and door openings will be infilled with wall and the vehicle door will be enlarged.
The existing walls and new wall infills will be repainted. The proposed paint color is attached.
Maintenance Buildings
The additions on the west elevation of the Boiler Plant are known as the Maintenance Buildings. They
are described in the HCPI as Blocks A, B, and C. The two-story Block A portion was constructed with
poured concrete between 1935 and 1951 and it retains the historic character of a projecting flat roof and
wooden windows. One-story Blocks B and C were constructed with CMU block and brick coping on the
parapets in 1958-1960 and 1960-1965 respectively. These non-historic additions detract from the original
massing integrity in form and architectural character. The additions were confirmed as non-contributing to
the district in 2008. These additions will be removed.
New Gallery/Retail/Parking Garage Building
Two buildings are proposed at the southeast comer with a common wall between them so that there
appears to be one large footprint. However, the two buildings are being treated as separate for this
review.
A 5,518 square foot retail building is proposed along the Paseo de Peralta streetscape to a height of
16' 9" where the maximum allowable height is 16' 9" as determined by a linear calculation. There is a
request for the Board to increase the maximum allowable height due to two feet of slope change over the
footprint of the retail building to 20' 9". The maximum height of the west end of the north elevation, the
location of the tallest part of the retail building, is 20' 9".
A 13,310 square foot 2-story garage building footprint is proposed to 29' 6" where the maximum
allowable height is 18' 8" as determined by a radial calculation. There is a request for the Board to increase
the maximum allowable height due to two feet of slope change over the footprint of the garage building to
22' 8". A height exception is requested (Section 14-5.2(0)(9)) and the required criteria responses are
attached. The maximum height of the building is 33' where rooftop appurtenances, which include vertical
transportation, are not required to conform to the maximum allowable height.
The following exception criteria responses are presented:
I. Do not damage the character of the streetscape;
The height exception requested for the structures mentioned will not alter the character of the
streetscape for two reasons: (1) The proposed gallery located on that section of the street (Paseo de
Peralta) is at the historic height allowed and screens the other structures where additional height is
requested and (2) the grades of the site drop toward the interior of the site so the buildings with
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 15
additional height are sited at lower elevation so that increase in height is offset by the lower grades. No
change to the character of the streetscape will occur except by the addition of the gallery which is
within the allowable height.
The height exception is for non-street-facing structures only and the public street is at a higher
elevation than the height exception requests. Buildings that do not exceed the maximum allowable height
would be dwarfed by the surrounding existing tall buildings which are non-conforming in height because
they predate the height ordinance.
ii. Prevent a hardship to the applicant or an injury to the public welfare;
The applicant, Drury Southwest, has committed a large percentage of the developable area of site to
public pedestrian uses that serve the community. Drury has also committed to the restoration and
renovation of two substantial and historically important buildings. While serving their business interest
their investment also presents an opportunity to rehabilitate a neglected property and an important
landmark in Santa Fe. The exception will allow the efficient use of the property while maintaining the
public benefits mentioned.
The height exceptions will allow the applicant to maintain a beneficial amount of public open space
while still meeting their square footage goals.
iii. Strengthen the unique heterogeneous character of the City by providing a full range of design
options to ensure that residents can continue to reside within the Historic Districts;
The proposed height exception will allow for the efficient use of the site in providing a viable project
economically and architecturally. The rehabilitation of the three historic buildings on this property will
clearly strengthen the unique character of the site and this portion of the City. Inversely, the continued
decay and degradation of these structures will have a detrimental affect on the Historic District.
The proposed heights utilize appropriate step backs and massing details that will give the buildings
design interest and reduce uniformity.
iv. Are due to special conditions and circumstances which are peculiar to the land or structure involved
and which are not applicable to other lands or structures in the related streetscape;
The portion of the subject property where the height exception is requested has a natural existing
grade that falls some 15 feet below the existing grade at the adjacent street (Paseo de Peralta).
Therefore, the requested height exceptions will not create any new height in this sub-district of the
BCD. In addition, the portion of the subject property where the height variance is requested is
surrounded by buildings larger than those proposed in this application. The live story hospital building
with a maximum height of 76 feet, Marion Hall at 51 feet. The St. Francis Cathedral at approximately
82 feet already exists and the property directly to the south has been approved for heights up to 42
feet. Literal interpretation would deny the applicant full use of this site which is already enjoyed by
adjacent properties and ignores the existing heights and pattern of development already establish on
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 16
this site.
~ The height ordinance works better with residential streetscapes than with preexisting commercial and
institutional streetscapes. This site is surrounded by tall commercial and institutional buildings that are
non-conforming because they predate the height ordinance and they are removed from the height
averaging that leads to the maximum allowable height calculation.
v. Are due to special conditions and circumstances which are not a result of the actions of the
applicant;
In addition to the circumstances previously mentioned regarding existing grades and heights of
surrounding buildings which were clearly not a result of the actions of Drury Southwest, the condition
of the existing buildings should be understood to be poor and neglected. Drury will be taking
responsibility for addressing the deferred maintenance of the buildings and correcting the damage that
has occurred over the many years prior to Drury's acquisition of the property.
The applicant purchased a site that is surrounded by taller non-mnforming structures which are the
reference for harmonizing of new structures.
and vi. Provide the least negative impact with respect to the purpose of this section as set forth in
paragraph 14-5.2 (A)(1).
The new construction proposed has been distributed throughout the site with the objective in mind of
creating a historically respectful design that considers density as well as height. The addition of the
height requested is consistent with existing and proposed patterns of development on this site and the
surrounding area and respect the tenants of historic preservation as described in the purpose and
intent of Chapter 14-5.2.
Larger footprints with less height would be detrimental to the public open space and to the need for
harmonizing with adjacent buildings.
The subgrade parking will extend beyond the at-grade footprint of this structure extending west,
around the existing Boiler Plant building, to near the west property boundary.
The buildings are designed in the Territorial Revival style with wall-dominated stepped massing and a
brick parapet cap. Other architectural features include white-finished window and door surrounds with
cornices and pediments, balconies, portals, a second-story trellis, and decorative brick panels on the
elevator tower.
The retail building will be finished in a different earth-toned color than the garage building. This
treatment effectively mitigates the massing of this large building with color changes, stucco and trim colors
are attached. •
New Building #1
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 17
A 21,209 square foot 3-story building is proposed to 36' high where the maximum allowable height is
18' 8" as determined by a radial calculation. A height exception was granted for 36' on May 28, 2009.
The building is designed in the Territorial Revival style with wall dominated stepped massing with
precast concrete wall caps and brick coping. Other architectural features include white-finished window
and door surrounds with cornices and pediments, shutters, and balconies. Several accent features
include arches over recessed hallways and low-pitched roofs over portals.
Two bay windows on the south elevation third floor are not subject to the 3' comer rule (Section 14-5.2
(E}(2)(b)) because the window projections do not extend 4' or more beyond adjacent fa~des and so do
not constitute new fayades.
Lantern-style wall sconce light fixtures are $hown on elevations. The applicant will submit a detailed
lighting plan for later approval. (see recommendation.)
New Building #2
A 23,232 square foot 3-story building is proposed to 36' high with a tower element at 44' high where
the maximum allowable height is 18' an as determined by a radial calculation. A height exception was
granted for 36' on May 28, 2009.
The building is designed in the Territorial Revival style with wall dominated stepped massing with
precast concrete wall caps. Other architectural features include white-finished window and door
surrounds with cornices and pediments and balconies. Several accent features include a pitched roof and
circular windows in the tower.
An arcade of arches on the north elevation violate the Santa Fe style vocabulary (Section 14-5.2
(E)(1)(a)) and an exception is requested to construct multiple functional arches.
The following exception criteria responses are presented:
I. Do not damage the character of the streetscape;
The style exception requested to allow the limited use of arches as parl of an entry arcade will not aner
the character of the streetscape for these reasons. The first is that the only streetscape adjacent to
these structures is Paseo De Perana. There is no Public Visibility of this feature in relation to the
Paseo de Perana Streetscape or any other. These arches are viewed only from within the property and
provide an important visual accent architecturally defining the entry for Building Two and present a
more formal ~e treatment to define the South edge of the Public Square
The defined streetscape for this building is a 300 foot radius and the proposed use of the site as a
hotel is publicly visible. The arcade will be part of a newly created streetscape consisting of an interior
courtyard.
ii. Prevent a hardship to the applicant or an injury to the public welfare;
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 18
The portion of the subject property where the style is requested is surrounded by a mix of
architecturally diverse buildings. Literal interpretation would deny the applicant the full range of design
options needed to integrate the new construction with the existing buildings, styles and pattern of
development that already establish on this site and within the immediately surrounding area.
The arcade will function to give focus to this entrance within the new courtyard. Without this accent,
the courtyard may lack interest.
iii. Strengthen the unique heterogeneous character of the City by providing a full range of design
options to ensure that residents can continue to reside within the Historic Districts;
The proposed style exception will allow for a variety of architectural experience similar to the variety
found in the downtown area where a pedestrian experiences a variety of buildings done in different
styles by different architects. Given the size of the property, it is apparent that all the buildings cannot
be developed all in a similar style without creating a monotonous experience. The variety proposed will
strengthen the unique character of the site and this portion of the City and is consistent with what one
may find in other parts of the historic downtown.
There are historic buildings in the downtown with arcades, such as the significantly historic St. Francis
Hotel. This Spanish Colonial style was an important part of early twentieth century style in Santa Fe.
iv. Are due to special conditions and circumstances which are peculiar to the land or structure involved
and which are not applicable to other lands or structures in the related streetscape;
The portion of the subject property where the style exception is requested has a natural existing grade
that is some 15 feet below the existing grade at the adjacent street (Paseo de Peralta) and is
completely screened from public view. Therefore, the requested exception will not create any conflicts
with existing streetscapes in this Historic District.
The courtyard where this arcade faces is entirely within the property and entirely new construction.
v. Are due to special conditions and circumstances which are not a result of the actions of the
applicant;
The portion of the subject property where the style exception is requested is surrounded by the
existing five story hospital building with a maximum height of 76 feet, Marion Hall at 51 feet. The St.
Francis Cathedral at approximately 82 feet and the property directly to the south has been approved
for heights up to 42 feet. These existing conditions were not created by the applicant but require the
applicant to respond with appropriate Architectural Designs.
The arcade proposal is non-conforming because of the Santa Fe Style ordinance requirement. The
applicant wishes to bring back a former historic style to add interest.
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 19
and vi. Provide the least negative impact with respect to the purpose of this section as set forth in
paragraph 14-5.2 (A)(1).
Since there is no negative impact there is no conflict with the Code for development in Historic
Districts. The proposed design supports the purpose and intent of 14-5.2 in preserving harmony in
outward appearance and preserving property values and to attract visitors and residents alike. A
general harmony as to style, form, color, height, proportion, texture and material is accomplished
between buildings of historic design and the proposed structure.
The minimal public visibility will not harm the Downtown & Eastside Historic District and the arcade is
only a small portion of this proposed building.
Lantern-style wall sconce light fixtures are shown on elevations. The applicant will submit a detailed
lighting plan for later approval. (see recommendation.)
New Building #3
A 7,486 square foot 2-story building is proposed to 27' high where the maximum allowable height is 18'
a• as determined by a radial calculation. A height exception was granted for 27' on May 28, 2009.
The building is designed in the Territorial Revival style with wall dominated massing in a •u•-shaped
floor plan. A low-angled standing-steam metal hipped roof is proposed to reflect the simHar roof fonns of
Marian Hall. An exception is requested to construct a pitch where a pitch is not allowed (Section 14-5.2
(0)(9)(d)) and the required criteria responses are attached.
The following exception criteria responses are presented:
I. Do not damage the character of the streetscape;
The pitch exception requested will not alter the character of the streetscape for two reasons. The first
is that the only streetscape adjacent to these structures is Paseo De Peralta and the proposed gallery
on Paseo screens the interior of the site where the pitch exception is requested. Also, no Streetscape
will be affected by this exception since Building Three is not part of any existing block. In addition, the
grades of the site drop toward the interior of the site where Building Three is located, with additional
screening provided by the extra drop in grade. Therefore the exception will not change the character
of the streetscape at all.
Although the official map of roof pitches shows no pitched roofs in the 300 foot radius, the roofs on
Marian HaH and the Cathedral BasHica are pitched. Although there are not the required 50% or more
pitches, two adjacent existing roofs are pitched, so the stmetscape will not be damaged.
ii. Prevent a hardship to the applicant or an injury to the public welfare;
The portion of the subject property where the pitch exception is requested is surrounded by the
existing Territorial Style Hospital building, the pitch roof of Marion HaU and the St. Francis Cathedral.
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 20
Literal interpretation would deny the applicant the full range of design options to integrate the new
construction with the vernacular of the existing buildings and pattern of development that are already
establish on this site and within the immediately surrounding area.
The requested roof pitch will give the building distinction of design and it will harmonize with
surrounding buildings. The project may be uninteresting without the roof pitch.
iii. Strengthen the unique heterogeneous character of the City by providing a full range of design
options to ensure that residents can continue to reside within the Historic Districts;
The proposed pitch exception will clearly strengthen the unique character of the site and this portion of
the City by recognizing building features that are unique to the history of this site. While the Pitch
exception requested will have little affect on residents wishing to continue to reside within the Historic
District it will make the experience more enjoyable as the history of this sites architecture is
demonstrated in elements of the new buildings proposed. The pitch roof requested not only responds
well architecturally to the existing Marian Hall both in ifs siting and in and form but also emulates
features of the old Rectory that used to stand in the same vicinity of the one proposed. The proposed
building three make no attempt to replace the original Rectory but will hearken back to the form and
details of the original building thus strengthening the unique heterogeneous character of the site and
the City.
The pitched roof will add interest and heterogeneity to the courtyard.
iv. Are due to special conditions and circumstances which are peculiar to the land or structure involved
and which are not applicable to other lands or structures in the related streetscape;
The portion of the subject property where the style variance is requested has a natural existing grade
that is some 15 feet below the existing grade at the adjacent street to the East (Paseo de Peralta) and
is completely screened from public view. Therefore this exception applies to the special circumstances
unique to this property and not applicable to other properties within the surrounding streetscapes.
The adjacent existing roof pitches are non-conforming because they predate the 50% rule and the new
building could hannonize better with the adjacent buildings if there were a pitched roof.
v. Are due to special conditions and circumstances which are not a result of the actions of the
applicant; •
The portion of the subject property where the style exception is requested is surrounded by unique
structures with divetse architectural styles. These existing conditions were not created by the
applicant but require the applicant to respond with appropriate Architectural Designs. The pitch roof
structure of Building Three responds to the existing architectural context created by the proximity of the
Cathedral, Marion hall and the historical context established on the site as early as the Old Seminary
(original rectory building) constructed in 1853. Other historical buildings with pitched roofs constructed
after the Old Seminary include Seton Hall and the Old Orphanage (both demoHshed along with the
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 21
seminary in the early 1950's).
The pitched roof proposal is non-conforming because of the 50% rule requirement. The applicant
wishes to harmonize with adjacent buildings which have older styles.
and vi. Provide the least negative impact with respect to the purpose of this section as set forth in
paragraph 14-5.2 (A)(1).
Since there is no negative impact of a pitch roof at this location there is no conflict with this exception
request and the Code for development in Historic Districts. The proposed design supports the purpose
and intent of 14-5.2 in preserving harmony in outwatrl appearance and preserving the integrity of
historic properties, values and will attract visitors and residents alike. A general harmony as to style,
form, color, height, proportion, texture and material is accomplished between buildings of historic
design and the proposed structure.
A flat roof would be disharmonious.
other architectural features include window and door surrounds with cornices and pediments, wooden
balustrade portals on the north and east elevations, similar balustrades on balconies on the south and
west elevations, and a stuccoed yardwall to a maximum height of 3' at the northwest comer with a 3' high
iron fence installed on the top.
Other Site Improvements
Multiple yardwalls, curbs, and ramps will be removed, including the retaining wall along Palace Avenue
on the northeast comer of the lot.
A curb cut on Palace Avenue that reestablishes an historic curb cut will allow access to the entrance to
Marian Hall off from the street.
Stuccoed retaining walls and yard walls. will be constructed along the streetscape comer of Paseo de
Peralta and Palace Avenue to a maximum height of 3'. An iron fence at 3' high wiH sunnount the interior
yardwalls. Arched iron gates will be installed at the comer with flanking 6' high pilasters surmounted with
spherical ornaments. A similar stuccoed yardwall and iron fence will be constructed closer to the Hospital
building at elevation 1. A stuccoed yardwall at 2' high wiH be constructed in front of the new southwest
addition on the Hospital building. It will be sunnounted with a 3' high iron fence. Iron pedestrian gates
will access multiple courtyards.
The landscape Plan on page 30 and the Landscape Lighting Plan on page 31 of the submittal
itemizes multiple changes to the site. The applicant will submit a detailed lighting plan for tater approval.
(see recommendation.)
Conclusion
In many ways this application has served as a model project in deaHng with such a large and complex
proposal involving historically-sensitive buildings. The project has been through three previous reviews with·
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 22
the HDRB to allow the Board and the applicant to discuss the various elements of the plan and design.
This submittal addresses entitlement issues with regard to placement and intensity of use. In addition,
the Board is presented with all the architectural infonnation and detail for a typical historic design review. In
order to advance the approval process, staff encourages the Board to first review and comment on the
project as a whole to establish the framework for the review of the specific issues relevant to each building
and the proposed exceptions.
In the past, the Board has given a conceptual approval to a project overall and then refined the details
of an application. This serves the Board and applicant in realizing the full-scope of the project so that the
further study of detail occurs in an established context similar to a typical building review.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Staff recommends approval of the exception requests to exceed the maximum allowable height for the
non-street-frontage building, construct a pitched roof where pitches are not allowed, construct the
non-confonning style of a round-arched arcade, construct windows that exceed the 30" rule, to alter
opening dimensions on a primary elevation, and construct an addition on a primary elevation as described
in the background and summary. Staff further recommends that exterior light fixtures be submitted to staff
for approval at a later date. Otherwise, this application complies with Section 14-5.2 (C) Regulation of
Significant and Contributing Structures, (D) General Design Standards, and (E) Downtown & Eastside
Historic District.
At the request of the applicant, the minutes for Case #H 08-0958 are transcribed verbatim as follows:
Mr. Rasch: The structures on the property at the southwest comer of Palace Avenue and Paseo
de Peralta in the Downtown & Eastside Historic District are: Marian Hall at 224 East
Palace Avenue; old St. Vincent's Hospital at 228 East Palace Avenue; and Central
Boiler Plant behind 228. Other structures include the Maintenance Buildings behind
228 and connecting hallways between Marian Hall and the Hospital and between the
Hospital and the Boiler Plant.
The first exception we will hear is the remaining height exception and that is for the
new gallery - retail - parking garage building. That starts on page 11 of your packet.
Two buildings are proposed at the southeast comer with a common wall between
them so that there appears to be one large footprint. However, the two buildings
are being treated as separate for this review.
A.5,518 square foot retail building is proposed along the Paseo de Peralta
streetscape to a height of 16' 9" where the maximum allowable height is 16' 9" as
detennined by a linear calculation. There is a request for the Board to increase the
maximum allowable height due to two feet of slope change over the footprint of the
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 23
Mr. Boaz:
Mr. Rasch:
Mr. Boaz:
Mr. Rasch:
Mr. Boaz:
Mr. Rasch:
Chair Woods:
retail building to 20' 9". The maximum height of the west end of the north elevation,
the location of the tallest part of the retail building, is 20' 9°.
So you'll need to grant that.
Where are you in the staff report?
Page 11.
My page numbers are different.
Oh, oh. That's not good.
What is the section title?
It is called New Gallery Retail Parking Garage Building. It comes after Maintenance
Buildings. I guess I should .... no, not yet. I'll mention those later.
So the Board does need to grant that two feet due to slope for the maximum
allowable height to go to 20' 9" and that is what they are requesting. And that is
without an exception. That's just slope issue.
A 13,310 square foot 2-story garage building footprint is proposed to 29' 6" where
the maximum allowable height is 18' 8. as determined by a radial calculation. There
is a request for the Board to increase the maximum allowable height due to two feet
of slope change over the footprint of the garage building to 22' 8". A height
exception is requested and the required criteria responses are attached. The
maximum height of the building is 33' where rooftop appurtenances, which include
vertical transportation; these are not required to conform to the maximum allowable
height.
So it is 22' 8" is the.... footprint area that the maximum is.
Then there is the height exception criteria and my responses to them. And then
there is stuff about the design of the building but I believe we are getting into that
later. Is that correct,· Madam Chair? Okay.
Then I just wanted to show you ... The fact is, when we look at the retail building, the
footprint runs [inaudible). There is actuaHy a wall separating here. The streetscape
building fronts on Paseo and then a [inaudible]
Are there any questions for staff? Okay, could the applicant... Anybody who is
going to speak on or with this application, let's you get sworn in at once. Okay?
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 24
Mr. Boaz:
Team members:
Mr. Boaz:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Flance:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Flance:
[All the members of the applicant team stood.]
Please raise your right hands. Under penalty of perjury do you swear or affirm that
the testimony you are about to give is the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the
truth?
ldo.
Please state your name and address when you speak.
Go ahead, Steve.
My name is Steve Flance. I am with the Flance Company, 521 Webber Street. My
firm is part of the design team that is representing Drury Southwest which _is the
applicant here tonight. Our firm is doing planning consulting and some of the
development consulting on the project. Between ... There are other members of the
team that are here this evening that will be speaking to you.
Steve, before you go ahead, if anyone from the public wants to watch this
presentation, you want to come up behind Carl to see these posters, that's good.
Because I've heard that it is really hard on the public because they cannot see what
is going on. So you can come over behind Carl to get a better view. I know we don't
have... Or maybe you guys can tilt it a little bit more so these people can see.
Because it has been an ongoing problem when they cannot see what is going on.
Is that good still for everybody on the Board?
Okay, is that better for you guys? Okay, Steve. Go ahead.
[Ms. Brennan joined the meeting at this time.)
Okay. Good. Madam Chair, members of the Board, we are pleased to be here
tonight. Thank you. This is something like our fifth meeting. I feel we are getting
pretty close. Hopefully it is to some conclusion ofthis and I feel we are getting very
close as friends. So let's hope we can get through it quickly this evening.
What you have in front of you is a sheet which we prepared, Ms. Walker.. If there is
something you think needs to be changed on this, we can change it. But basically,
we were simply trying to outline an agenda for the review of the exceptions that we
will be discussing this evening. It is not meant to be terribly specific. Having said
that, we are talking now about, under Item 1, an exception for the height of the
garage. You heard the staff report and recommendation.
I'd like to move to the boards, if I may, Madam Chair.
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 25
Chair Woods:
Mr. Boaz:
Mr. Flance:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Flance:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Flance:
Carl has to hear? Can you hear Carl? You are okay?
Yes.
I think he will be able to hear. I've tried to use these hand-held microphones before.
[inaudible - feedback].
Please don't start singing, Steve.
Yeah. The first song ....
I'd like you to focus on this building right here. (abandoned the hand held mike].
I'm going to speak loudly. I think it will be better.
Is this your introduction? We need to tum all the cell phones off, please.
This is the retail space that is facing Paseo de Peralta .. You had an opportunity to
see this at the previous meeting. There are really two buildings with a common wall;
a fire wall. Think of this as two buildings at five feet high in a condo development
with a common wall and basically three entirely separate uses. This area here is the
part of the parking lot, the part that can be seen at the surface.. The rest of the
parking lot really spreads through [inaudible] of the development. The majority of the
parking will be underground.
In response to comments we received from the Chair and members of the Board, we
have done a couple of things with this level of parking. The first thing we did was pull
this parapet back because of the view someplace. We pulled this parapet back so
we could pull the parking at this level back from Paseo de Peralta and raised the
height of the parapet to five feet so you would be behind the parapet. I'm 5' 6° so
five feet is about here.
So the idea is to be able to have some of the parking events here that would be
screened and the parapet coming around screening the view from Paseo de Peralta.
The height exceptions we were asking for.... Pardon me. The Retail Building meets
the City's historic design height exception. I mean the historic design height
requirements. So this building presents itself to the street and the streetscape at the
height that it meets and is fully compliant with the height ordinance of the historic
district. .
This building which is attached behind does need an exception so that we are able
to accommodate the number of cars we need on the entire site.
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 26
Ms. Rios:
Mr. Flance:
Chair Woods:
[Mr. Flance went to the elevations.)
pnaudibleJ A big drawing to look at on these two elevations.... This is an elevation
from the north looking south. You can see in this area is the gallery and this area
right here does meet the height requirements of the City's ordinance.
Which is what, Steve?
Sixteen feet, nine inches. Then what happens. This is the street level and what
happens is that the natural grade is here and the finished grade will fall to a level
that is approximately ten feet below the natural grade of Paseo de Peralta here.
It is this area, along in here coming down to this torreon element that we will talk
about in a minute - that are requiring the exceptions that David outlined for you. The
design will read as one of the regular structures in the concourse. But we do need a
height except so we can still build this parapet up here, park in this area here and
continue to have our parking in here.
This [pointing to the torreonJ houses the elevator and stairway and doesn't require
an exception, as I understand it, because it is a functional element of the building
that provides access. Then if you follow east or west on the building, we will have a
portal on this torreon element.
Now we are looking from the south to the north. If you were driving , you would drive
this way to go to Palace Ave. This is Paseo de Peralta. You can see how we raised
the parapet again to block screen any possibility of public visibility on the over
[inaudible). The building itself wilt be designed in the same Territorial style as the rest
of the buildings on the .property. It wilt have a ramada in this location.
The inset window here... and actually this is the exit of the parking garage. Then we
come back down to this PnaudibleJ because the stairway and the elevator do not
pnaudible) with the portal. So that is the explanation for the height variance that we
are looking for on this building.
To summarize it will read as being complete and consistent with the calculated
streetscape that came from staff. On all of the site, the issues that we have are that
surrounding this property we have buildings much higher that we could not count in
the height calculation because they were institutional or they were a church and the
old hospital itself far exceeds the height. So that is my pitch to you this evening and
we would be open for questions.
Well I think we should defer the questions. What I would like to do is if we could
break for 5 minutes so people can .... because it is hard for us to those and we didn't
get in our packet a detail of what you have there. So we can break to see that and
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 27
Ms. Walker:
Chair Woods:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Flance:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Flance:
Mr. Hogan:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Hogan:
Chair Woods:
the model and then we will take public input and then the Board can ask you
questions.
Madam Chair, may I just. .. You notice, everybody on the Board, that when they want
to make the views feel cheaper, they put yellow cars in them?
Thank you, Karen. Okay, we'H break for five minutes.
The Board recessed from 5:46 p.m. to 5:52 p.m.
Can we come back to order please?
Okay, Steve, before we go to the public speaking, I think because the drawings
represent those windows as glass, and if they are not, I think you need to explain it;
what is happening so that the public can be made aware of before they speak.
The windows will be open and will not be glass.
Can you show which windows you are talking about?
Mark, why don't you do that? Mark can explain which ones and what they are doing
with the muntins. [He made further comments but they were inaudible.]·
Mark Hogan, 994 Old Pecos TraH.
We want it to read like a building with windows so we seated them with dividing that
looks like muntins but there is not glazing - through the garage - we do have them in
the lobby and in the elevator. {His other comments were inaudible.]
Mark, you still don't have a good idea because your openings are going to be bigger
than Code allows and a kid could fall through. The code is going to teU you four
inches. So Idon't think the muntins are really representing what the building
inspector's going to make you do
The height of the sills is also relevant so that is where that fits in. There is an open
rail. pnaudible]
I know. What I want to make sure is what you are representing so we don't have to
come back. My concern is your fiability and openings that big in places where people
are is significant And what I don't want to see is what happened on the State
p~rking garage with the wire mesh. That's really going to look bad. And so I'm not
convinced that what you're saying is actually what can happen, either by the building
inspector or the liability you guys might have if the openings are that big in a place
where people are going to be walking around and you are that high up off the
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 28
Mr. Flance
Chair Woods:
Mr. Hogan:
Mr. Featheringill:
Chair Woods:
Public Comment -
Mr. Boaz:
Mr.Acton:
Mr. Boaz:
Mr.Acton:
ground. So I am concerned about that.
May I make a suggestion, Madam Chair? That is a design issue that we can
certainly address before we have our last meeting with you on overall design and
come back with what the building inspector would or would not accept and, if it is an
issue, we will find a solution to it and present it to you at that time. And it won't affect
the height of the building one way or the other.
I know and I appreciate that, Steve. I just thought it was important with all we are
going through, that what we are looking at is actually what's going to happen. And I
think I am very sensitive to this because of what happened on the state parking
garage We did end up with this mesh that's going to.... I think when it is all said and
done that people are going to be appalled. Obviously you guys aren't going to do
that but I think that is where my concern is coming from.
There is also on the inside a rail set back from the wall. I agree with you that it would
be pnaudible) ....
On most of that wire mesh was security to prevent people from the outside getting in
as opposed to people falling out; just to let you know.
Okay. Let's hear from the public. Thank you. Anyone from the public who wishes to
speak concerning these height exceptions - this particular issue, please come
forward and speak.
Please state your name and address.
Rad Acton. 1206 Upper Canyon Road.
Under penalty of perjury to you swear or affirm that the testimony you are about to
give is the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?
I do.
Okay, I'm just going to digress about the legacy of those windows just for a second.
Now, Mark, I just... The detail that we were unable to prevail with the State was a
complete metal... white painted metal sash inside of the window opening with a
mullion pattern reminiscent of a Territorial set of proportions. So the security grid
notwithstanding, that mullion pattern should not just be like a tic, tac, toe board
inside the opening but should have a perimeter wrap around it so that it looks like a
sash.
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 29
Mr. Hogan:
Mr. Acton:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Acton:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Flance:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Rios:
Mr. Flance:
Ms. Rios:
Mr. Flance:
Ms. Rios:
Mr. Rasch:
Ms. Rios:
Mr. Rasch:
Ms. Rios:
[inaudible].
Okay. With mullions and, you know, some dimension. Okay.
Okay, let's just let the public speak and then you can respond.
But that's just where ... Dan and I were unable to procure from the state. I sure wish
we were able to.
But I want to say that I have no opposition to this massing. I think ifs a fairly creative
way to deal with some conflicting functions that are totally juxtaposed a 3 story
parking garage behind an art gallery on a busy street I think it is fairly sensitively
crafted from my point of view. I don't have personal opposition to this layout
Thank you very much. Is there anyone else who wishes to speak? Okay.
[There was no one eJse from the public who wished to speak on this segment.]
We actually bought her a suite at the Brown Derby Hotel.
All right. There is no one else who wishes to speak. So rm going to open it up for the
Board for questions.
Yes, Cee.
Steve, the retail space gallery area you indicated is 681 s•?
Yes, Ma'am.
And I'm reading from staffs report - there is a request for the Board to increase the
allowable height due to two feet for slope change over the footprint of the retail
building to 201 9".
That's correct.
So, can you show us where 161 g• is and 20' 9•1
Where the retail building touches the garage is the highest point and it is on the
north elevation, not on the street elevation.
Okay so the street elevation is the 16....
It is 16' s·.
So can you tell us the height of the torreon?
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 30
Mr. Flance:
Ms. Rios:
Mr. Flance:
Mr. Hogan:
Ms. Rios:
Mr. Hogan:
Ms. Rios:
Mr. Hogan:
Ms. Rios:
Mr. Hogan:
Mr. Flance:
Ms. Rios:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Shapiro:
Mr. Flance:
Ms. Shapiro:
Mr. Flance:
Ms. Shapiro:
I believe it is 33'
And do you know the dimensions of the torreon as well?
No.
It is probably (inaudible]- about 15 by 15'.
And there is a little block on top of the .... Right. What is that? Would you explain to
us what that is?
It is the- override for the elevator to the garage.
And at what height is that?
It is 30' on the back side but I'm not sure on the ... It is essentially the same height as
the front building.
And are we going to be able to see any of the cars at all or are they totally
screened?
We believe they are totally screened. We believe there is no visibility of cars.
[inaudible] all the way back pnaudible] ...the plans here. We believe you won't see
any cars in here.
May I point out, Madam Chair... We are viewing these elevations [inaudible] from
about this height from this point. From the ground you would look up so the parapet
will screen them.
Okay. Thank you. That's all I have for right now.
Yes, Deborah?
I'm confused about the fire wall and the screening wall. You said one of them was 5
feet and its...
The parapet
Okay, along the outside of the garage is five feet. Then how tall is the screening
wall?
That is the screening wall.
It looks to me like there are two walls there.
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 31
Mr. Flance:
Mr. Hogan:
Ms. Shapiro:
Mr. Hogan:
Mr. Flance:
Mr. Hogan:
Ms. Shapiro:
Mr. Flance:
Mr. Hogan:
Ms. Shapiro:
Mr. Hogan:
Ms. Shapiro:
Mr. Hogan:
Ms. Shapiro:
Woman:
Mr. Flance:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Shapiro:
Mr. Flance:
Ms. Shapiro:
That is not shown. There are two sets of parapets actually on the building.
[He showed the screening wall and the parapet and made comments that were
inaudible.].
How tall is the parapet then?
[inaudible] to the top of the parapet is ...
it is five feet.
Well it's...
Okay, from the gallery roof...
Oh, I see.
That is probably about 3' 6" and then steps up to five feet.
Okay, so the total distance is five feet.
[at the model] This parapet is five feet all the way around. So the walls that you
are looking at now, these are set back [inaudible]
Okay. So it is actually the screening wall is higher from the roof of the gallery?
Yes.
Okay. Do you know how tall it is from the gallery?
If you look on page 26, it looks like...
We have our statistical expert person sitting behind us.
Okay. Go ahead Debbie, what is your question?
Well my question is on this.. J'm wondering about the proportion of the two walls in
relationship to the height of the gallery and, if you are coming from the north,
heading south on Paseo, what are we going to see in terms of the parapets?.
From Paseo... the parapet is approximately 6' 8" above this...
Okay. So the first one is five feet; the fire wall is five feet and the screening wall is
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 32
Mr. Hogan:
Ms. Shapiro:
Mr. Hogan:
Ms. Shapiro:
Mr. Flance:
Ms. Shapiro:
Mr. Flance:
Mr. Hogan:
Ms. Shapiro:
Mr. Hogan:
Ms. Shapiro:
Mr: Hogan:
Ms. Shapiro:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Mather:
Mr. Hogan:
Ms. Mather:
Mr. Hogan:
six feet.
The [inaudible} is from the inside...
Oh, okay.
And you are looking from the outside.
Oh. Interesting.
What you have is six so you've got about 3' from this parapet to that parapet and
about five feet from the inside of the ...
garage. We don't really know how much it's going to stick above the original ... yeah.
Five feet.
From here to here it is approximately 6' 8" and divided into four steps.
Okay. It looks like the coping around the first one is thicker than the coping around
the second one. Is that true?
Yes. We were trying to put the emphasis on the first one because that's where
you're going to first perceive the height. Since the other parapet is set back further,
we put less emphasis on that and just did two courses of brick, versus the heavier
coping on the closer.
Okay. And how much is the space between the two?
About three feet. Again, it's shown here.
Yeah. Okay.
Any other questions?
I have a question about the pergola that is on the side of the building. Does it... Can
you reach that? Is it functional in any way?
Here?
Yes.
It is functional in that we hope to grow plants and vines and such, so we want it to
help soften the garage and provide more of an pnaudible].
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 33
Ms. Mather:
Mr. Hogan:
Ms. Mather:
Mr. Hogan:
Ms. Mather:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Hogan:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Hogan:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Flance:
I see. Okay. How many parking spaces do you hope to provide?
Over all the site is 324. That is only partially contained here as Dave mentioned.
Underneath all of this is additional parking, and most of it is accessed through this
door.
And that's going to be public parking for those visiting the galleries?
Yes. It's for hotel guests and for uses on the site. We have about twenty spaces
surplus that give us a little sway on that for bigger events.
Okay.
Any other questions? I've got a couple. On the higher parapet to screen the cars,
that's not roofed?
Correct.
And there's no openings up there cause that would tend to look like a western
storefront. Okay, so we don't have openings up there. In the places we have the
stepped parapets, are you gonna tum them so they will read as thick walls, as
opposed to having a skinny end of a parapet. Because the way it's shown, it doesn't
return.
There are two places here where they would need to be turned back some distance,
and it is not shown that way, that's correct.
Okay. Can you guys note that? That's really important. Otherwise you're gonna get
this skinny end, and you're gonna defeat everything you just tried to do.
So I'm really concerned about these-I know, Steve, you want to move on and not
get into the windows, but I want to get into a little more detail with that 1cause I am
concerned. And one thing I'm concerned about is if it's a big opening ...are you...and
you've done this great job of having it look like windows, but because they're
substantial, are we just gonna look in there and see cars? And what does that look .
like? I think La Fonda did an exceHent job of screening the cars, 'cause they have a
similar situation of it being open, whereas I don't think they did at the state building.
So, that's critical, because you're going to all this...these Territorial windows and
trim, and you're just gonna look into an open space that's not glass, and see
automobiles.
Well what La Fonda did, if I may. They didn't use the muntins. They basically used
poles to provide a visual screen as well as deal with the issue of safety and access.
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 34
Chair Woods:
Mr. Flance:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Walker:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Flance:
Mr. Hogan:
So they have enough open space in the windows that basically they're not using the
muntin pattern of construction. I suppose we could look at that.
I'm just bringing up concerns.
I'm trying to respond to your observation that you wonder if you're gonna look in and
see cars. And, I think my answer would be that, under this configuration, in some
cases you will see cars, and in some cases, where you don't have cars parked right
up against the exterior wall, you won't.
Well, I think it has to do with a lot of things. It has to do with the thickness of the
walls, the proportion of the windows, how the mullions are going in. One other
possibility you might want to think about, and I'm not trying to redesign your project,
Mark, but, just as an idea, you know. All these balconies that we wanted to save,
and that you have saved on the hospital - does it make sense to pull some of these
openings together, and have a balustrade coming out in front that's reminiscent of
the hospital? It doesn't have to match it exactly, which will help visually block those
cars. And I'm not exactly sure how you'd divide up the windows behind it, but I think
it might break up what's happening.
Again, I really appreciate what you are trying to do, but I think there are some
drawbacks. Especially 'cause you haven't worked out what's happening with the
muntins. So, I would ask the Board that, if we are passing the exception, that we just
make sure that there's a condition that this get re-looked aL so we know exactly
what's gonna be built.
I'm leaving it off for safety's sake. Would that all come under this later subject -
Project Design?
I mean it just doesn't make any difference how we do it in the motion, just so that
you guys are aware that this is of concern and do we want to look at...
I think you're raising a very good point, and I know that Mark and the team, all of us
are happy to spend the time to see if there's a better way to buHd this mousetrap.
But I think...you want to comment on it?
Well, when you were pointing out the balustrades - we did attempt to use that in a
couple of specific places. Again, just to add interest and not do the same thing too
much. So it's kind of lost in that. So, what we did is similar places on the hotel,
where we just did a very shallow balcony - that the balustrade just sticks out twelve
inches or so, with a screen across those windows to help mitigate that. I think, as it
is, there are places you will see cars, through the window, and it is part of the garage
(inaudible]. Butwe want to do whatever we can to mitigate that But we also wanted
it to read more like a building with openings, as opposed to big long open gates that
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 35
Chair Woods:
Mr. Featheringill:
Mr. Hogan:
Mr. Featheringill:
Mr. Hogan:
Mr. Featheringill:
Mr. Hogan:
Mr. Featheringill:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Rasch:
Chair Woods:
would make it signal parking garage.
And the deeper your windows, the more shadow you get, the more you're going to
mitigate it. Dan did you have something?
If they're windows, what is the sill height from the floor inside?
It varies and I'm not sure we have that. I said earlier that the railing is at 42• and the
sill height is down below that. We will need to put something on the inside that will
provide protection from the four inch rule extension.
Right, but if the sill heights are all basically 42 inches, you know, the hood of a car is
only 32 inches high, for the most part, that's gonna block the view of the cars. The
only other issue is at night, and up higher on Paseo you might be able to see in the
upper windows, and see cars. Now, the lower windows in that, are there cars inside
there?
Yes.
So those need some landscaping or something.
And I think we have the same thing along this portal on the west side, that is also set
back by the portal, in deeper shadows, so there's less direct light on the cars
pnaudible).
But that one will not show from the street, that's an interior view.
I would also ask, that when you guys come back with this, I mean, the trees and the
rendering and the people and the yellow cars are all very nice. Take them out. And
let's just see the elevation, and where your floor levels are, and sill heights. So we
know that .. and again .... I'm sensitive because we've got this beautiful rendering on
the State building, and it was very different than what got built, and I think we're all
sensitive to that. So lefs just see a straight elevation, so we know exacHy what we're
looking at.
Anyways, back to the height and the exception, because that's what we're talking
about, does anybody else have any questions? If you do choose to pass this, please
cite the exceptions, which are on page...Oavid?
They start on page 11 and go through page 12, and my response on 13 is the first
sentence.
And you don't have to read them. Mr. Heldman, are we okay? We're not reading
them out loud? Okay. Unless somebody from the Boald wishes to do that. I would
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 36
Mr. Rasch:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Rios:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Rios:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Walker:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Featheringill:
Ms. Rios:
Mr. Rasch:
Ms. Rios:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Rios:
also ask, too, in your motion, that you do request a return on those parapets, just at
the ends, since it was not represented that way.
Yes, Madam Chair. We kind of morphed out of the height exception into the design,
and I didn't even read that part of my staff report, but you can choose to just work on
the height, not even the design. That's coming back anyway.
Well, we're doing the height, but I think the parapets relate to that. So, that would be
the only reason. We're not getting into windows and stuff. Cee?
Madam Chair, what I would suggest, and I agree with Ms. Walker, is that we address
that part of it under number four, even though we're not going into deep detail about
the design, but that is a design element, so I would suggest that we ...
However you want to do the motion. Can we have a motion?
Yes, I will be happy to do a motion. In reference to the retail space gallery
garage, I move for approval for the heights as proposed in the garage area,
from 22' 8" to 33', and the retail area from 16' 9" to 20' 9". And I believe the
applicant has met the criteria for the exceptions as stated on pages 11 through
13 of the packet
Is there a second?
Second.
Is there any discussion?
The 33 feet is only the rooftop appurtenances. Js that what we want to say as the
height? Is that what is supposed to be said? Okay, because...
Well, I just want to indicate that even thought the torreon is not under our jurisdiction
in terms of the height exception.
Yes. That is the maximum of the building, but the height exception will be to 29' 6".
So, should I indicate that instead?
You might want to indicate that the height of the building does not exceed as
presented, and that the torreon does not exceed as presented ..
Okay. The height that the garage area will be 22' 8", not to exceed 29' 6" and
the torreon being 33'.
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 37
Chair Woods:
All:
Chair Woods:
Chair Woods
Mr. Flance
Mr. Rasch:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Rios:
Mr. Rasch:
Is that okay? Any other discussion? All in favor?
Aye.
All opposed? [None.] Okay. Thank you.
Okay, moving forward, let's go to the next one. And if you take them one at a time,
and you go through your presentation, we'll take another quick break again to refer
to the model, and then we'll take public comment.
Okay, can we have 30 seconds to get our boards up, here?
Madam Chair, do you want me to read?
Yes, David. Thank you.
And, could you indicate the page you're reading?
Yes. Madam Chair, Board members, Carl, I'm starting with the third heading of the
background and summary, it's on your page two, Old St. Vincent Hospital. We know
that it's La Villa Rivera, built by Meem in 1950. And I wanted to reiterate the building
is listed as contributing to the District, and the status was confirmed last year, and
the following elevations were determined to be primary on May 28th of 2009: 1, 3, 4,
5, 6, 9 and 12. Now I'm gonna skip down, everybody, to page four, because we're
discussing exceptions for elevation 9, one of the primary elevations.
The mechanical ducts will be removed, those are the existing ones that go up the
fa~ade. Restoration of architectural wood detail will be completed for upper
balustrades and wood casings. The lower fa~e will be remodeled as the main
entrance to the building. Three, two-story openings will have large windows and an
entry portal, a second story balcony, and a canopy above.
Three exceptions are requested for this remodel. Exception one is the portal and
canopy additions at the entry, which violates the primary elevation rule for additions.
That occurs just on elevation 9. Then, those are their answers and my responses to
them.
On page five, exception two. The opening dimensions on the primary elevation will
be altered in violation of the rule that does not allow enlarging opening dimensions.
And then their responses and my critique of those.
And then exception three, and that's on page seven, the large windows and the
entry violate the 30' rule, and an exception is requested. So, because elevation 9 is
now primary, we have three exceptions on this elevation, an addition to a primary
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 38
Ms. Walker:
Chair Wood:
Ms. Walker:
Mr. Rasch:
Ms. Walker:
Mr. Rasch:
Ms. Walker:
Mr. Rasch:
Ms. Walker:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Flance:
elevation, changing opening dimensions on a primary elevation, and exceeding the
30' glazing rule on a primary elevation.
Can I ask staff?
Yes, please.
David, on page 5, near the bottom, you say staff is in agreement with this response,
and the proposed addition could be reversed to return original integrity to the facade.
Yes.
What does that mean?
Yes, this is the exception for the addition of the portal and the canopy on the
primary. And because I felt that the portal and the canopy is a factor that could be
removed, the original facade could be restored. And that's kind of an interior
[inaudible]
.So you mean removed, not reversed.
ExacHy.
I see. Okay. Thank you.
Any other questions for David? Okay, Steve, you're on.
Well, let's pass a few of these around. Okay, but you don't have that [inaudible]
Alright. It's just hard to see this one down here, but we'll work with it. Thank you
Madam Chair. First of all, I think it's important for the Board to recognize that the
building was built before the adoption of the historic design review ordinance. And
that most if not all of the openings and windows on the existing building as designed
John Gaw Meem do not meet the 30" rule. So, we're dealing with a non-conforming
structure to begin with.
The general reason why we design with the size of the openings that you see is
b~cause we were trying to deal with scale, we were trying to deal with light, and we
were trying to deal with a pedestrian orientation that invites people from the outside
into the building. So, starting with a non-conforming building, that doesn't meet the
30" rule, I would like to take first facade number 9.
This is a photograph of the building. I don't know the date of this, probably about
1955 or something like that, and facade number 9 is this facade that you're looking
at right here. You can see that ifs really part of the back of the building, with two
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 39
Ms. Walker:
Mr. Flance:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Flance:
balustrades and then we have a series of windows of different size and pattern that
don'Uollow any particular design criteria. And then we have an open area in here.
So this has been defined now as a primary f~de, and we have tried to deal with it
accordingly.
Based on the meeting we had ...this is another picture of the same f~.. .it will give
you an idea. It's a little bit bigger picture, of what it looks like right now. Except that
there's a few more transformers and garbage dumpsters in this area.
They can't see, Steve.
Hi. Can you guys see that? This is what it looks like now. Does that help? I'm gonna
use this drawing here. Ifs a little hard to see. If you can't see it I'll bring it up closer.
But this is f~ number nine right here. This little punch out over here is also part
of f~de 9. That is this little piece of building right here. Can you see that? Well,
that's what we are talking about.
Let me start with the entrance to the hotel and I guess I would ask that we try to stay
with the issue of the exception, and we can deal with the design issues separately. If •
you want to talk about them tonight, that's fine, but let's just...
Why are you talking to me, Steve? (laughter)
Darts. Sometimes I feel like the guy, you know, where they're throwing the knives
paughter) with the apple on the head.
These are places where we need the exceptions: this window here, which is really
two windows separated by some kind of a masonry panel. These windows here,
which again are two windows up and down, separated by a masonry panel. This
door here which is shown primarily in glass, and is on that piece, that little punch out
right here on the building. And the rest of the windows do not require, in this area, an
exception, because they are under a portal.
So, lefs start with the sidelights, if you will, over here. The interior of this hotel will
have sort of a mezzanine running around the major, centrcll lobby. And so, these
windows are designed to both pick up the pattern of what [inaudible] under the
portal, but also provide light and a pedestrian orientation to people who are coming
up into the hotel, and inviting them into the building. They are really designed to
provide two levels of light and two levels of pretty openness, so we have an open
and very light entry into the main lobby, and so that people approaching the hotel
have a feeling of pedestrian friendliness and welcome-ness, if you wiH, into the
building.
This opening into this tittle punch out here is part of this ~e because it does not
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 40
Mr. Flance:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Flance:
Chair Woods:
• Mr. Flance:
Mr. Rasch:
have a set back of four feet, and so it becomes part of the f~ade. This is where we'll
have a bell stand under here, and this would be a place where people can store
luggage. And we have the bellman activity occurring right in here. So we wanted to
have some glass doors that are large enough to accommodate a little bit of luggage
and [inaudible]. Those are the exceptions we are asking for on f~de number 9.
Associated with that is the west side of this particular building, which is right here.
You can't see it because it's in shadow, but there is an overhang portal with a
balustrade here and again that occurs in the area right in here. This is the front of
the building right here. That occurs right in here. And it is designed, again... This is a
courtyard we're trying to establish and create a pedestrian-friendly entry into the
lobby area from that courtyard. So, this is essentially a glass entry into the lobby. So
that you'd have an entry at the front of the building, and you'll have an entry at the
side of the building from the...what reaHy is part of our promenade and courtyard
area.
It might help if I use the model. This is the front of the building. These are the two
side light windows I have been talking about. Oh, here, you can't see, can you?
Trust me, they're there. Two side light windows here, and then we have this
promenade that is picked up at Cathedral Park and is carried all the way through.
And one of the focal points of the promenade is going to be between Boiler Building
and the hotel...and this southwest wing of the hotel where we hope to have a lot of
activity going on. And ifs outdoor patio seating, that kind of thing. And that provides
access to the pnaudible} from this point here. The little bump out I keep talking about
is right here, and that is for the bellman and baggage storage room.
I would be happy to answer any questions. It's a pretty straightforward request.
So, this is everything you're asking for in #2, but how about the Boiler Building East?
I was gonna hold that until we dealt with just this one area. If you want me to do...
The only reason I want you to go on is because we're going to break for people to
look, and I'd rather they know what they were looking at. So that we can not have to
break two more times.
Okay. Let's do that.
So, let's see what I have for that. Central Boiler Plant. This is the heading "Central
Boiler Planr it starts on page 8. The building that is located south of and behind the
hospital, known as Central Boiler Plant. Remember, it has that 1904 Historic section,
and then the Meem addition. And the Meem addition is on the east and south. The
Board determined that there are three primary elevations, on the north, number one,
on the west, number two, those are both the original 1910, and then the east
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 41
Chair Woods:
Ms. Walker:
Mr. Rasch:
Ms. Walker:
Mr. Rasch:
Ms. Walker:
Mr. Rasch:
Ms. Walker:
elevation facing Paseo, the 1950 addition, is elevation number three. So there are
three primary elevations.
On elevation number three, new door and window openings are proposed for the
north end of the east elevation. An exception is requested to create new openings
where openings do not exist on a primary elevation. These windows mimic the
non-confonning style of the existing historic windows. Now, you recall, elevation
number three is the historic Meem addition which has those steel casement
windows. And what they're proposing are similar openings on that primary elevation.
Any questions for David? Yes.
David, page 8, at the bottom, your response to "do not damage the character of the
streetscape•... judgments about damage are not relevant, building has changed over
time and those changes may confuse its character. What did you mean on that last
sentence? The building is changed over time, and those changes may confuse its
character?
Yes. I know that this building is somewhat of a chimera because we have this 1910
Victorian building, and then this 1950s Meem addition that mimics the Hospital, with
very different archi.tectural features. And at the same time Meem did that addition
that doesn't mimic that 1910 Victorian building, he also, for lack of a better word,
pueblo-ized or Meem-ified the original building. So, the building does have a lot of
character difficulty.
And that was why it was so hard for you to detennine which were the primary
elevations, and you did do the right thing by taking all the historic character, not just
the original historic character. So, what t meant was, those changes that happened
over time, white they were historic, kind of make it a difficult building to read
historically.
So how does that relate to do not damage the character of the streetscape?
Because I think that the openings that they're proposing mimic part of that historic
character. They mimic that east elevation that Meem created, and it does not match
the character of the north and west elevations of the1910 building. So, I think it
doesn't damage it because they mimic it.
Which changes ... in this sentence, one more try... in this sentence, which changes
are you referring to? The historic changes? Or something...
That Meem did, yeah. That Meem did to the original building.
It didn't "may confuse its character." It did confuse it's character.
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 42
Mr. Rasch:
Ms. Rios:
Mr. Flance:
Chair Woods:
Chair Woods:
Thank you.
Any other questions for staff? Steve?
First of all, the ...just a segue... Ms. Walker's comments. This building didn't look
anything like this before it was converted by John Gaw Meem. This was a very
simple rectangular, we call it Victorian, building with a hipped roof. It was pretty
nondescript, and probably meant to be nondescript because essentially it was a
boiler.
What we're trying to do here... and I'll approach the group so you can really see this.
The east elevation, and [inaudible) see this, the east elevation of this building exists
right here. And the east elevation has these large windows and if you look into the
windows, you're looking into the boiler plant itself. It almost has an atrium kind of
feel. Like you're bringing light into a dark space, and, again, creating kind of an
atrium feel.
So when David says we are trying to mimic the same thing, that's really what we're
trying to do. This building, this would be adding these two windows right here that
are at the end of the building here. pnaudible) There are no windows here. We are
adding them right in here to mimic the kind of openings you already have on that
east elevation to create an atrium feel into what will be a restaurant. And again,
we're trying to bring Jight into it, make it pedestrian friendly, not have a blank fayade
that you have right now in this area here. But basically invite people into what is
happening inside this restaurant and bring a lot of light into that part of the building.
Any other questions? No? Well, let's break for five minutes so that everybody and
the public can get a look at these exceptions.
[A short break was taken from 6:37 p.m. to 6:44 p.m. during which the recorder was
turned off. J
Let's resume the meeting please, and open it up to the public. Okay, anyone form
the public who wishes to speak regarding the exceptions on fayade 9, and the
glazing and the boiler room, please come forward. Anyone wish to speak?
[There were no speakers from the public regarding this section.]
Okay. So then let's open it up to the Board. I just want to voice one concern. On that
side elevation that you talked about coming from the promenade, that elevation is
west facing ...that's different than your color rendering, that one is very hard to read.
I would suggest to the Board that if we grant the exception that something can
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 43
Mr. Rasch:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Hogan:
Mr. Flance:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Walker:
Mr. Hogan:
Mr. Flance:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Flance:
happen on that f~de, but we just need a much better idea of what you are doing.
That's way too hard to read for us for what's going on. 'Cause you've got one thing
going on in one and another in another, so you told me not to get into design. That's
fine, but just...l want to make sure that the Board is seeing what is actually
happening. And what's on the big colored f~de is different than what's on that
fac;ade. Just so we know that it comes back to us, but we can still grant the
exception.
And, Madam Chair, elevation ten does not need an exception.
Okay, so then we don't even need to deal with it. Then why are we dealing with it if
it's not an exception?
Its' the glazing.
For glazing it does.
The glazing issue. (inaudible, multiple speakers] Got it. Okay. Great. [inaudible,
multiple speakers] Right. Same thing on the front entry. If the Board is okay putting
the front entry on that, what is now primary fa~de, great. We're not gonna get into
the design tonight. I don't think the design is there yet. So, what are questions for
Steve? Yes, Karen.
Let's see. Hotel entry west, would be the west elevation that was in our packet on
this page Steve? Okay, it is. However, keyed notes 16, 17, 18, and 19 are missing.
They show on the building but not on the keys. You could just...Mark didn't know
they were missing, l told him already
The reason those are not on that pnaudible, multiple speakers, papers rustling)
I hear you on the west side. What we would like is the exception on the glazing, and
we'll come back with the design...
Would you be willing though, Steve, as you look at it...because as you're looking
straight on at what you're asking for, you broke up two of these big windows with the
balustrade. But then you've got this long skinny one to the right that's really not
broken up. It's a very tall skinny window, to the right of those balustrades on the
west elevation. Could we blow off those windows on the right that are very tall and
skinny? Then you've got a lot of meat on each side of your balustrades, and it would
really set them off. At this point, that windows seems really out of proportion to me
tor everything else you're doing.
We'll come back to that...
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 44
Chair Woods:
Mr. Flance:
Mr. Flance:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Hogan:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Walker:
Mr. Hogan:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Rios:
Mr. Hogan:
That was not the right answer, Steve. My concern is if we're giving the exception on
all of this glazing, and we're giving it on that, and that window's not working, I'm
concerned.
Give me 30 seconds. [He and Mark went to the rendering to discuss it.]
The right or wrong answer is that Mark thinks there's already an acoustic window
partially shown here, but we will k>ok at it more closely.
You're on the wrong window. It's the window to the far right. The long, tall, skinny
one.
I know you want this one. What I was hearing was that you felt this needed to be
pnaudible]
No, I'm just concerned, Steve, that this window, the way it's reading, you're asking
for this exception on your glazing. This is reading as a very tall and skinny and is not
in proportion to anything else on that building. And I'm saying I am nervous about us
granting the exception on this window because it is so out of proportion. Can we
blow off that window, or can it get smaller and have stucco in between, or
something? 'Cause ifs reading, even with the panel in the middle, it's reading as a
very tall, skinny element on th_at facade.
You can see it better right there.
Well, to answer that, we're working with the existing conditions, so we've got an
existing window here that's pnaudible] width as weH as the head height In terms of
breaking that into pnaudible] width, making that a two story opening and letting the
brick continue through, we were trying to create consistency with the way those
three windows worked. As you saw them from the end of the promenade. But if we
needed to do something tike a transom panel in there or do something to break that
up, we can do that. pnaudible] What we can't do without violating the set back for the
primary facade, is extend that balustrade all the way...
No, no, I'm not asking for that I'm saying either, because that's reading as this very
tall skinny element, different than anything else, either omit the entire window, or
have stucco in between the two windows, because a panel is going to make it still
read as a window, and stucco in between the windows, and then you'll be more in
keeping with the proportion of the other windows.
~ark, question. The top window, you say that is existing?
The head of all three of these windows are the heads of existing windows.
pnaudible} We just took those and ...
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 45
Ms. Rios:
Mr. Hogan:
Ms. Rios:
Mr. Hogan:
Chair Woods:
Dr. Kantner:
Chair Woods:
Dr. Kantner:
Mr. Hogan:
Dr. Kantner:
Mr. Hogan:
Dr. Kantner:
Chair Woods:
Dr. Kantner:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Hogan:
Ms. Walker:
Chair Woods:
And elongated them.
And elongated it down to the ground to really create a more of a higher sense of
scale there in proportion to [inaudible].
So, just that little portion on the long, long windows, that little portion is...
We can do that as stucco, so that it doesn't read as [inaudible] windows.
Let John have a chance, 'cause he wanted to ...
I had a question about the primary entry way.
You guys? Please stay with us.
The primary entryway, looking at some of these drawings, it looks like it's actually
recessed back into the building. Is that correct?
It is. It's both. This portion shows the columns where it projects out. This is the
fa~de of the building and recessed into the building as well to help create more
covered area for the outside.
And what is the depth into the building? A guesstimate is fine.
Between ten and twelve feet.
Okay, thank you.
And, John, I think, actually, we suggested that, so that the front portal didn't protrude
so much that we take a little bit and recess it in.
Alright. And that's my concern, is how far out the front portal is...
So, your front portal extends how far?
Nine feet, which is three feet less than it was at our last meeting.
But that doesn't make it...it's still a very narrow passageway in there, Mark. But
maybe after you see Sharon's ideas, you'll be able to...
I can't. ..it's not that narrow because they're recessing it into the building. What
they're adding on is the nine feet, but they're also taking, and carving into the
building, which gives it the depth that they need.
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 46
Ms. Walker:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Walker:
Chair Woods:
Ms.·Mather:
Mr. Hogan:
Mr. Flance:
Mr. Hogan:
Ms. Walker:
Mr. Hogan:
Mr. Flance:
Chair Woods:
Right, but they don't need to buttress out into the open space there. That's what I'm
saying.
They probably do, or I think it would probably get too narrow again, from what
you're saying.
It's too narrow now.. .it was too narrow at 12 feet. The walking space. Because it
comes to a very narrow...it's not grand at all as a walking space. And I think when
we get to the design phase, we could help a little bit...figure out something very
attractive, very noteworthy, and still create more space. You'd have to walk sideways
and be an 89 pound weakling to fit through there, you know.
Go ahead.
I have some questions. Again, returning to the west f~e where you are adding
the windows. Looking at the original west elevation, it fooks like your big windows
there on the first and second floor are taking up what was sort of a mechanical type
windows before...or maybe vents. I can't quite tell what they are. And then, but
you've added this third set, the tall skinny things that are in question. But on your
original .plan there is just one small vent there at the top. And then on the ground
level there is a blank wall. And perhaps you might consider returning to that same
pattern that was on the original building, where you're just adding windows where
there were vents. As opposed to creating a whole window that goes all the way to
the ground.
[inaudible)
You need to speak up.
We did consider that, and we can go back, depending on how strong the objection
is. Now, what we're again trying to do is create light in this area, so we've got a
window here, and one coming in...this is the tall skinny one. We're just trying to get
as much natural light into that lobby space as possible.
Or perhaps another small window.
As much as anything we're also worried about just blank f~es on an area this
active in terms of trying to create a sense of history. So those are the issues we are
wrestling with, whether or not they're fuUy resolved yet
Does that. ...
No, she's got another question, and then you can respond, Steve.
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 47
Mr. Flance:
Ms. Mather:
Mr. Flance:
Ms. Mather:
Mr. Rasch:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Rasch:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Mather:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Walker:
Mr. Rasch:
Ms. Walker:
Mr. Hogan:
Ms. Walker:
No, I just want to ask if that answered her question.
Yeah, I mean, I'm not happy with that long narrow proportion. Even if it's broken up
with a little bit of stucco in between. t think ifs the long narrowness of it that really is
in conflict with that.
Thank you. That's all I was trying to get to.
Then on your page ...ifs both page 20 and page 25. On, again, this is the west
elevation, looking at the little canopy area, it appears, on the copy I have now, that
the pillars do not connect up through to the other balcony. Or is that...
That's in an earlier rendition. You'll notice on page 25 the canopy on the second
story has a cable. That would have been another exception, and they didn't go that
way. There is a portal post at the comer of that upper canopy, connecting to the
lower portal. That's how we show it on the main drawing on page 26. So 26 is
correct, and shows those narrow posts making it not an exception. On page 25,
you're correct, there were cables holding that canopy, and Isaid, in this district,
we've got a cantilever exception, and they said we don't' want to go there. So these
drawings were earlier.
Okay, so David there's not an awning then, ifs a regular portal as shown on 26.
Correct.
Okay, good.
Thank you.
Is there any other question?
Please. Going back to the west elevation, which you say is an older drawing, is that
correct?
The west elevation, yes. That's elevation ten.
Well, could somebody just go through the missing key, 16, 17, 18 and 19 and
explain them to us, or is it irrelevant if this is all changed?
16 was making reference to the awnings on these windows, and on our copy we're
not seeing 17 and 18...
I'll show you where they are. Here's 17, here's 18, here's 19.
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 48
Mr. Rasch:
Mr. Hogan:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Rasch:
• Chair Woods:
Mr. Hogan:
Ms. Walker:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Walker:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Walker:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Flance:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Mather:
Chair Woods:
Those are all on elevation 2 pnaudible, multiple speakers away from microphone]
Those are all on elevation 2, which is non-primary. There is no exception on that
elevation.
If I could, I'll just tell you on her notes, [inaudible] 16 has to do with the awnings.
Which are no longer there.
No, that's elevation two. We're not talking about elevation two.
Okay.
It's these awnings. And then 17, that is a piece of balustrade that turns the comer at
that location, [inaudible] locating the existing one.
So, it looks smaller than the prior one, is that correct.
But, I don't think we're voting on this stuff tonight. We're only voting on exceptions.
This is design stuff.
Well, I just don't like being given something that isn't complete.
Right, but we could ask that they have it complete for the next one with the design.
That's a good idea, Madam Chair.
So that we can just focus on exceptions tonight. I'm afraid we will get lost in all this
design stuff, and then we can just do design stuff in the next meeting, how's that?
And I'll try and control myself, Steve, and not redesign your project, how's that?
There have been numerous iterations of this design, and so there may be some
mistakes and lack of coordination between the notes that you're looking at, and the
most current version of the drawings. And I think that's what's going on here.
Okay. Any other questions regarding the exceptions? Yes, Christine.
Madam Chair, I have a question for you. So, if we're just voting on the exceptions,
right now, the a, b, and c of number two, and we are not going to discuss the design
elements of those exceptions, is that it?
Well, I think what you could do, because we're a little bit at a crossover, here,
because they're asking for exceptions on this glazing, is if you specifically want to
recede when the design is presented to us, say the one window on the west f~ade,
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 49
Mr. Rasch:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Rasch:
Mr. Rasch:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Flance:
Chair Woods:
the entry, the [inaudible) plaza entry. That. Yes we are approving that they can
violate the 30" rule, that they can recess into the building as well as add the portal.
But we are not accepting the design yet of that particular window, and the way the
entry is being presented. And that way I think they get the message that - yes,
they're getting their exception, but no, we're not getting the design yet. How's that?
David?
And if I may, I want to clarify what's on the table right now. I see 5 exceptions that
are currently on the table. And I'll outline them for you.
The first exception I see is the addition, on elevation 9, the exception criteria
responses are on page 4 and 5.
Wait. Addition on ...
Elevation nine, it's the portal and the canopy. That's the first exception I see and
that's on page 4 and 5. The second exception I see on the table is also on elevation
nine, and that's the 30• glazing rule for the glass they're putting in not under a portal
or a canopy, and that's on page 7 and 8. The third exception on the table is also on
elevation nine, and that is the glazing openings. They're changing openings on a
primary elevation. That's on pages 5 through 7. So there are three exceptions on
the table for elevation nine.
There are two more exceptions on the table. Elevation ten, they're asking for a 309
glazing rule. That is not a primary elevation, so you are talking about changing
opening dimensions, but that's allowed on elevation ten. What is not allowed on
elevation ten is the 30• glazing rule for those large windows. That's again on page 7
and 8.
And then the last exception that's on the table is the east elevation of the boiler
plant, and that is the openings on a primary elevation. And that's on page nine and
ten. So there are five exceptions discussed on the table right now.
Okay, thanks, David, that really helped clarify it. I really appreciate it. Is there any
other questions or are we ready for a motion?
May I make one comment, Madam Chair? We are hearing loud and clear that you
are not approving a design. What we are dealing with are the exceptions on the
glazing. And we will come back to you, hopefully, with design of both that main entry
on the west elevation, that addresses some of the things you brought up this
evening. We'll do our best, and we'll have a chance to discuss it at the design
review.
Thank you, Steve.
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 50
Mr. Flance:
Ms. Rios:
Ms. Walker:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Rios:
Chair Woods:
All:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Rasch:
Thank you.
In reference to the exceptions being asked for under openings and glazing,
and as follows specifically, I would move for approval as follows: In reference
to the addition on elevation number nine, regarding the portal and canopy, I
would move for approval of that, the exceptions being met on pages four and
five. Regarding elevation number nine, the 30" glazing that is being asked for
as an exception, in reference to criteria stated on pages seven and eight, that
has been met as well. As has on elevation number nine, the glazing openings
that are changing... and David, stop me when it comes to the narrow window
because I don't want to include that..the criteria on that is on pages five and
seven. That has been met. Elevation number ten, the 30" rule exception, pages
seven and eight, criteria have·been met, and the East elevation, the boiler
openings, pages criteria nine and ten, have been met. And I would indicate that
on the west elevation, the elongated windows, that those be revisited, and are
not part of this exception process, that those be redrawn ...that they be
redesigned.
Second.
The only thing that I think makes sense to clarify is that, when they do
redesign, it is okay to violate the 30" rule as they have in all of the other
windows. Because they all work together.
I agree with that
Anything else? All in favor?
Aye.
All opposed?
This is like giving birth. paughter] Next?
Next, Madam Chair, we're gonna go to the heading called New Building #2, and it's
on your packet number 13.
A 23,232 square foot 3-story building is proposed to 36' high with a tower element at
44' high where the maximum allowable height is 18' 0• as determined by a radial
calculation. A height exception was granted for 36' on May 28, 2009.
The building is designed in the Territorial Revival style with wall dominated stepped
massing with precast concrete wall caps. Other architectural features include
white-finished window and door surrounds with cornices and pediments and
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 51
Chair Woods:
Mr. Rasch:
Ms. Mather:
Mr. Rasch:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Rasch:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Flance:
Mr. Flance:
balconies. Several accent features include a pitched roof and circular windows in
the tower.
And here comes the exception. An arcade of arches on the north elevation violate
the Santa Fe style vocabulary (Section 14-5.2 (E)(1)(a)} and an exception is
requested to construct multiple functional arches. That's it. •
So, David, I don't see where that is in our packet.
That was previously handed out. I only gave in this packet elevation nine, but I have
them here.
. Can you tell us what page it is on the old one?
So, here on building two, you can see on the north elevation, the proposed arcade of
arches.
So, David, the only exception on this is the arcade of arches.
Correct. We've already approved the height, and there are only two exceptions on
this building.
Okay, so for those of you that brought in the big book they gave us, it's on page 28,
up at the proposed north elevation. Okay, is there any questions for David? Okay,
Steve.
Okay. Thank you. This is really a design issue, but I thought it might help for the
Board to see a photograph of what such an arcade might look like. pnaudible,
multiple speakers, laughter] Whafs being referred to as the arcade of arches is not
dissimilar to what you're seeing in that photograph. We thought we might just remind
everybody that they do exist in downtown Santa Fe in the Historic District
It requires an exception because it is not allowed in this particular district. There are
two places where we are using arches. One is we have a series of zaguans that
provide access to the interior courtyards of a couple of the buildings. Thank you.
There's one pnaudible away from microphone] we have an arch here, and this is the
archaic arches we talked about. There's another arch here. We're just trying to
introduce a different architectural element into the building that provides a sense of
massing because these are deep arches.
The arches that are shown where the arcade of arches is, the center arch is in a
direct line with the arch that is the entrance from the zaguan into that particular
courtyard. I think that's about it. We are trying to give some interest to the building,
create different elements of depth. This is not something we're going to fall on our
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 52
Chair Woods:
Ms. Walker:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Mather:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Mather:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Mather:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Rios:
Mr. Hogan:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Rios:
Mr. Hogan:
sword over, but we thought it was an interesting element that Mark came up with to
provide some more diversity and give a sense of depth and weight to those entries.
So, is it necessary for us to break again to see the model or are we okay? We can
move on? Okay. So why don't we... before the Board comments. Is there any public
comment on this? Okay. So, we have questions. Karen?
Would you call this a touch of Tilacapaque? I think Mark must have spent a lot of
time there, because didn't you put these in the Lensic building, too. I happen to like
it. That is my only comment.
Any other... yes, Christine.
I have a question for you, Madam Chair. We're just ruling on the exception of the
arches, and no other element on this building?
Right. Because they will come back with the design. So we're only approving that we
would allow arches.
I just want to make a comment that I have no objection to the arches, but I do have
an objection to them being in conjunction with this tower. It starts looking like a
pastiche to me of a lot of different architectural things.
Well, we've already approved the tower, then, so you might not...
We approved the height of the tower.
Okay, the height of the tower not the style. Okay thank you. Anyone else? Yes, Cee.
Okay, so you are proposing, on the north elevation, 5 arches. Can you let us know
the depth of those, and the height.
The depth is established by the width of the columns, which are approximately 2 by
2, so they are substantial, and the arch follows that. So that the depth of the arches
is two feet from the columns all the way through. The depth of the arcade here is
about six feet and the height I believe is... the height of our doors are about nine
feet, so the height of the arches is about ten feet .
Any other questions?
These are gonna be publicly, correct?
They're really not publicly visible. This is one place where looking at the model is
very helpful. Ifs actually in this back pocket which you only see from this interior
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 53
Chair Woods:
Mr. Hogan:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Rios:
Chair Woods:
space. And that also kind of explains why they're in that spot, as is the tower. There
is a public square back there and we're trying to use those two devices to give
prominence to that space.
Any other questions?
So, I have a concern Steve. I'm not really concerned with the arches, but I am
concemed ...when you look... when we're looking straight on at these arches. Do you
have them, David? Well, it's really hard to see. Yeah, when you look on our
elevation, which is on page 28 of your packet, do you have just a straight elevation,
not the perspective?
[inaudible, speaker away from microphone]
Yeah, but the perspective isn't working. So, do you have page 28 in front of you so
you can know what I'm talking about? If you look at page 28, you're holding up a
second story with these arches. So, if you look at either end of the arches, you've
only got these two-foot columns. And I think it looks like it's not really reading where
it's holding up the second story.
I think those end columns need to read as a thicker building mass and not as
columns. And at the other end. Especially at the other end. So it's almost like it's
being held up on tip toes and the second story is teetering. I don't mind you using
them, but I think there's a couple things you can do to thicken that up. Even if you
set the second story back a foot, or pushed the front story and thickened those
ends. Now, it does throw off all your centering, if you thicken those ends, but it's not
reading right now that it can hold up the second story. And everything else has mass
in it, and that doesn't.
Does everybody get what I'm talking about?.So again, the arches I don't have a
problem with, but I do have a problem with them holding up that second story at the
ends.
We can thicken up those end (inaudible] space. It still stays with our center spacing if
we apply the five arches [inaudible).
Well, what you need is you need the thickness and then the post on each end. So
that's throwing everything off quite a bit. But that will make it read from the second
story down as a mass. Okay?
So does that mean that they're still gonna have five arches?
Well, you might not. Or if you have thinner arches you're going to have to make
them lower to keep them in proportion. But, I think again, we can tell you, hey, go
with the arches, but the way they're drawn is not reading, so you gotta look at that
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 54
Mr. Flance:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Flance:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Walker:
Chair Woods:
Dr. Kantner:
Chair Woods:
All:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Rasch:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Rasch:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Rasch:
again. Okay?
Form and function.
Absolutely.
I understand.
And yes, now we have steel, so we can hold it up, adobe wouldn't have held up that
second story the way you're doing it. I would also .. J know you've got those little
balconies, but even if it's thrown forward a little bit if there's a bit of a set back in the
first story and the second story, that will also help it read as a possibility. Not
necessarily, but as a possibility. Okay?
So any other questions or comments? Is there a motion?
I'll make a motion. Concerning new building number two, and the subject of
arches, as part of the Santa Fe Style vocabulary, I move to approve, in this
case, the use of arches, the design to be determined later, and the criteria
response, begiMing on page 13, seem to me totally appropriate.
Is there a second?
Second.
Any discussion? All in favor?
Aye.
Opposed?
Okay. So, it is a little early.
One more.
Oh, we have another one? What is the next one? Oh, got it.
So, this is heading New Building #3, and it starts on page 15; Ifs new building
number three.
And what page is it on in this thing if we didn't get our... 29?
You got it? Okay. A 7,486 square foot, two story building is proposed to 27' high,
where the maximum allowable 18' a• as determined by a radial calculation. A height
exception was granted for 27' on May 28fh of this year. The building is designed in
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 55
Chair Woods:
Mr. Flance:
the Territorial Revival style with wall dominated massing, and a U-shaped floor plan,
a low-angled, standing seam, metal-hipped roof is proposed, to reflect the similar
roof forms of Marian Hall.
An exception is requested to construct a pitch where a pitch is not allowed. And the
following responses are attached on pages 13 through 16. So, it's a pitch on the
entire building, and a U-shaped footprint.
Is there any questions for staff? Mr. Flance.
I'm trying to take a step here to try to architecturally provide integration of this project
in transition from existing architectural character that you find on Marian Hall, and to
some degree on the Archdiocese properties, where there are pitched roof elements,
and transition that into the Drury [inaudible].
To get you oriented, this is Marian Hall, which carries a pitched roof right now. And
this is St. Francis Basilica, which also carries .. .! don't know if you'd call it a pitched
roof, but it's a dormer, pitched, hipped, you know.. .it's not a flat roof. And this is
Cathedral Park.
So, the idea was to take this building right here, and create a roof and balcony
structure that emulates and imitates Marian Hall. This is a perspective. Right now
you're sort of about at the second floor level, looking at this building. And the idea is
to take this same kind of design, and as you create the entry from Cathedral Park,
into our promenade, that works its way up into the property. Have this one structure
that had a pitched roof element that emulates what you have in Marian Hall. With the
rest of the structures as you then move into the property being more typical
Territorial style with brick coping and a flat roof.
There's a historical reason for this, and Dedie Snow will probably address this during
the public comment period, but this is a photograph of Marian Hall and the rectory
that was built next to it. Somebody tell me pnaudible] about a hundred feet? Fifty
feet? About a hundred feet, but in the same L-configuration you see here.
So, this was the traditional streetscape or design, if you will, of this area of the site,
and you can see we are trying to create something similar with these two buildings.
This being Marian Hall, this being one of the cathedral's.
So, that's the argument, frankly, for going with the pitched roof on this one building
and then moving into, as you can see from this perspective you've seen elsewhere,
more traditional territorial styles. Then we've also incorporated balcony elements, as
you see in Marian Hall, that are similar in the rectory that was removed back in the
'40s? [inaudible, multiple speakers away from microphone} So, we'd be happy to
answer any questions.
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 56
Chair Woods:
Mr. Hogan:
Chair Woods:
Chair Woods:
Public Comment-
Ms. Snow:
Chair Rios:
Ms.Snow:
Chair Rios:
Ms. Maestas:
Mr. Boaz:
Ms. Maestas:
Mr. Boaz:
Ms. Maestas:
Do we need to break for the model? Or we're okay?
Well, Mark thinks it would help if people looked at the model.
Okay. Let's break for five minutes to look at the model.
[A short break was taken from 7:24 p.m. to 7:30 p.m. during which the recorder was
turned off.]
Do we have anyone from the public who wishes to speak concerning the pitch
exception? Come forward, ptease.
Dedie Snow, 425 East Coronado road. The old seminary, which is the name of the
pitched roof structure over here on the end, was constructed in 1853 by Carlos
Brunn for then Bishop Lame. It was the first rectory that Lame occupied. It was also
a school for boys. It was a one story adobe structure, and described later by Lame
as having no architectural character. Seriously. [laughter] In 1865, the Sisters of
Charity were given the structure by Lame. They added a second story, the pitched
roof, and two story sleeping porches on all sides of the building. There were other
improvements. Most of those were on the interior of the structure. The structure was
used as an orphanage, a dormitory, a hospital, and remained standing until 1954,
when it was demolished because it was a fire trap. I think it is one of the more
charming buildings that once existed on that property. Any questions?
Well, did you want to comment on what they're proposing, or...
I think it's wonderful because they're restoring the pitch to the streetscape that was
there for almost a hundred years.
Okay. Thank you, Dedie. Next, please?
My name is Maureen Maestas, 1000 Paseo De Peralta, Santa Fe.
Were you sworn in before?
I was not.
Under penalty of perjury to you swear or affirm that the testimony you are about to
give is the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?
Yes, ldo.
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 57
Chair Woods:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Flance:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Rios:
Mr. Flance:
Ms. Rios:
Mr. Flance:
Ms. Rios:
Mr. Flance:
I think the thing that catches my eye the most is this is an effort on the part of
developer and the architect to create a motif that doesn't otherwise exist. You have
that pitch elevation Marian Hall, and that doesn't exist anywhere else.
It's a nice segue onto the property as one moves through it. I think it's appropriate.
There was a good discussion of the historical aspect of that building that I won't go
into, and I don't know how qualified Archbishop lame was in speaking to style and
aesthetic. He left us with a grand Cathedral and no spires.
So, I think the most important thing here is that we by to preserve what is on the
campus already, and enhance it. And this does a good job of that.
Thank you very much. Anyone else who wants to speak?
[There were no other speakers from the public regarding this section.]
Okay. So, Steve, are you ready to take questions?
Yes Ma'am.
Yes, Gee.
Steve, what is the material of the roof on Marian Hall?
lt's...standing seam.
It's standing seam? tt's not...
[other speaker, away from microphone]
Shingle.
It's shingles. Okay. 'Cause, my second question, on the new building that you are
proposing, are you hying to complement Marian Hall, or are you hying to replicate?
Because we're dealing with a significant building, as you know.
Well, I think we're hying to ...we're not trying to replicate. I think we're hying to
complement it. What's the roof material we're going to use, Mark?
[inaudible, second speaker away from microphone)
Standing seam roof. Picking up the elements that are characteristic of Marian Hall,
but certainly not trying to recreate it.
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 58
Ms. Rios:
Ms. Rios:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Hogan:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Walker:
Mr. Flance:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Walker:
Dr. Kantner:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Shapiro:
Chair Woods:
All:
Chair Woods:
Chair Woods:
And what is the color of the standing seam, have you decided that?
[Inaudible, speaker away from microphone]
Thank you.
But it's not a baked on, enamel finish.
No.
Promise? Okay, good. Karen?
Oh, I wanted to address the lady from 1000 Paseo De Peralta. He never met any
style he liked unless it was French ...Gothic or something. But the reason the spires
aren't there is that at that time, he faced the possibility of taxation on the building if
he completed it. So he didn't complete the building so he wouldn't be fa}(ed. Little bit
of trivia.
That's good. I like that.
Anyone else have a question? Okay. What are the wishes of the Board?
I think it's John's tum, or Dan's. [laughter]
I can give it a shot here. So, in regards to the new building #3, constructing a
pitch where pitch is not allowed, I move that we allow the pitch with the
exception criteria given on page 15 and 16.
Is there a second?
Second.
Comments? All in favor?
Aye.
Opposed?
Okay, well I think we're gonna wrap it up tonight by...Steve has asked that we go
through the design elements that we're concerned about, so that they can be
responsive. And I think that in doing that...
I want to take this opportunity to thank this group for being so responsive to us and
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 59
Mr. Flance:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Walker:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Walker:
Mr. Flance:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Flance:
Chair Woods:
Dr. Kantner:
that we have become a big part of working with them, and they've been really
responsive to our concerns and I really appreciate that, and thank you for it. And I
think that the result is something that we will all appreciate, because of what you're
going through. So thank you.
We appreciate your candor, and the input we've gotten.
Most people don't compliment me on my candor, Steve, but thank you. And also I
want to thank David because he has really stayed on top of all these details and
elements and really helped us and the developers move along on it. And it has
helped me a lot as he walked us through it, so, David, thank you. So, Steve did you
want to ...
Madam Chair, can I ask you ...you're saying tonight we could make some
suggestions for them to come back with, but if there's something missed on this list,
that doesn't preclude us from bringing it up...
No, we're not voting on anything, you know, he's just asked that...you know, we've
brought up several design issues that we're concerned about, and he wanted to go
through the list...was there anything else, was he missing anything. We're not voting
on it, we've just saying great, you know, come back to us with that.
Right. Do you want me to start with some ideas?
Madam Chair, the easiest thing for us would be to review... and your question is well
taken, Commissioner Walker, we're not trying to make this exclusive, but we want to
make sure we cover as many of your concerns as we can when we come back for
the design review, and hopefully we can all reach agreement then on the overall
design of the project, and move on.
So, you brought up several issues, the Chair brought up several issues, I think Ms.
Mather brought up several issues. I'd like to simply go back through and make sure
we've got everything that you have felt was important that you saw tonight. That
doesn't mean we're not going to be open to further discussion of other issues at the
next meeting.
Well, how about if we do it as a polling of the Board and we go through each
member. Does that work?
Sure.
Okay, John, do you want to start?
Okay, so just the issues? So, obviously there's a concern with facade 9 on the old
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 60
hospital building. And I think the new design that was brought back as far as I'm
concerned it got much more ornate, and I'm not sure that's what I was looking for.
I think my main concern is that it sticks way out into the walk way. I think that
compromises its effectiveness as a good entryway because it's pushing up against
the boiler building. So, I would like to see that moved back. I think you reduced it to
nine feet, I wouldn't mind seeing it reduced more.
I suppose there's other things I could talk about, but I agree with Christine, I'm not
excited about the lighthouse, or whatever that is, it's on ... building #2. And I know
that we approved the height exception, I'm not sure if that meant that we also
approved that specific design.
Mr. Flance: No.
Chair Rios: Thank you. Mr. Featheringill?
Mr. Featheringill: I, too have concerns about the entry, and it sticks out too close to the boiler building
to be visually effective, I believe. I don't have too much of a problem with the light
house, or whatever the term is, on Building # 2. It kind of works a little bit in the fact
that it obscures a little bit of the...at least in some of the drawings it seems to pop
other ones it doesn't, so I'm not sure which way it really works, but it does create a
little bit more of a courtyard effect in there. I don't have a whole lot of concerns at the
moment.
Chair Woods: Karen?
Ms. Walker: I think that Chair Woods mentioned return on the parapets, and I think that was on
the garage, is that right, Mark? And the entrance, I think we can make it, or help
make it simplified, and you still would have a stunning entrance, and we can all work
together on that. Throughout the packet tonight it mentions colors are attached.
Nothing was attached... Colors are forthcoming, paint, stucco, nothing was
forthcoming. We want to make sure we have the colors at the design phase. And
then possibly Christine or Debbie will have something to say about the combo of the
arches and the "light house• as it's now commonly becoming known, but I won't
address that. Thank you, I'm through.
Chair Woods: I would also like to mention the long narrow window on the west faQade. You know,
we talked about somehow breaking up that proportion. What I'd like to ask you to
look at...l don't even know what page this is...in the packet you gave us with photos
of the existing hospital, and you look at the original, beautiful entry, and this territorial
surround.
And somehow, I think, on the new entry, if we could work off that design. And I'm
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 61
Mr. Rasch:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Rios:
Ms. Shapiro:
Ms. Rios:
not saying to copy it, but my concern is it now almost looks like New Orleans. It's just
too much .. .I think it could be so much more. That would be my biggest concern.
I think Karen's point is really well taken of when you come back, give us a complete
color board. Because there is a lot going on when you look at the different roofs, and
stuccos, and painted brick, so we have an idea of the entire thing.
I would also request that, and although we haven't talked about this, on the front of
the old hospital, please don't give us awnings. I think Cecilia remembers, the last
time we were on the Board, long awnings, and those kind of arched awnings, just,
there's nothing like that in Santa Fe. I would just ask that it be taken off. Let's not
even discuss it.
Those are on elevation 2.
Right. Okay. So, those would be my concerns. Cee?
I just echo what everybody else has said. And I put emphasis on the entryway. Just
simplify it, please. I do want to say I am very appreciative of your thoroughness, your
preparedness, and your cooperation on this project. And I also want to thank David
because I know this has been tough. I like the way we are breaking up things and
addressing everything. But my emphasis would be on that entry. You want to do a
good job on that.
I'd go along with what everyone has said, but no one has again mentioned the
windows in the garage, or the lack of windows in the garage, muntins. I think we
really want them to look like windows, but we don't want to see the cars inside.
Maybe there was another solution, maybe more muntins, and just a cross in the
center, something like that.
Also, we haven't talked about walls at all. I'm not exactly sure.. .l mean, I haven't
gone over them in my mind, but I was thinking about designs of them, and the return
on parapets, that we might have returns on the walls, too. That they have a
substantial thickness to them, instead of.. .. I don't know what you're thinking of,
poured concrete? Or something like that.
The lighting at front door, and under the arcade, some of it seems very ornate, if I'm
reading it corr~Uy. I think it needs to be simplified, more in keeping with the style.
Oh, and the long thin window on the west, elevation #9.
Madam Chair, we also forgot to include the thickness on the sides of the arches,
whether you're going to lessen the number of arches or however you're going to
accomplish that.
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 62
Chair Woods:
Ms. Mather:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Rasch:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Flance:
Christine?
Famous building #2, with the "light house." I mean, I don't have a solution for that, I
just don't like the element of having the arches, then the tower, and then there is a
little bump out on the fa~ade, at the top of the parapet so it looks like it's somewhat
imitating a church. I think you really want to avoid that look and simplify it, and
maybe make the tower not have such a dramatic pitch top. That's my comment on
that
And then the old St. Vincent's, the south elevation, # 9, I agree with everybody we
want a simplified design on the front, and maybe copying the balustrade design that
already exists on that elevation might be a solution.
I'm a little concerned, also on that south elevation. Meem used the pediment type
design over major windows, but on the south elevation, a lot of small windows have
these little pediment elements, and I think it kind of detracts. And it kind of draws
attention to these small windows whereas he was trying to do it for major openings.
That might be revisited.
And I'm always kind of concerned about the pergola effect, too. That those serve a
function and seem substantial, instead of something that's just kind of perched on
the building. But again, thank you for these beautiful renderings, too. I think it's
made it easy for me to see what's going on.
David, did you have anything you wished to add?
No.
Steve, did you have any further comments, or questions?
No questions. I'd like to make a comment, and I mean this sincerely from all of us.
When we started this project, the idea of coming in and redeveloping the old St.
Vincent's property, frankly for all of us seemed very daunting.
In our first meeting that we had with you, I explained that it was our intent to stay
right here at the HDRB and work out the design issues, the exceptions that we
needed, the give and take, if you will, the candor that I get from the Chair, all of
these things are really appreciated.
This is the way, in my opinion, having served on this board for six years, this is the
way I think projects should be dealt with. Where we benefit from your knowledge,
and you listen to our needs, and try to meet someplace where we're combining the
value of the function that we're trying to create with what, sort of, the collective
thoughts are, on your part, on good design.
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 63
Chair Woods:
Mr. Rasch:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Rasch:
Mr. Boaz:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Walker:
Chair Woods:
Ms. Walker:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Boaz:
Chair Woods:
You know, we have another meeting to go to, I don't know how everything is going
to tum out, but up to this point I want to compliment the Chair, Sharon, and your
Board. You guys have been terrific. These meetings have been substantive, they've
not been political, they've not been anything but focused on what makes this project
work from both a design and functional aspect. So, I appreciate it, and I know that
the folks from Drury and the rest of our team appreciate it. And I wanted to thank
you.
Thank you. I want to remind everybody, and I haven't done it yet, there were
verbatim minutes, not taken by Carl, and they were not of Carl's standards. And I'm
actually daunted by how to correct them. I think, Frank, you had things with them.
And I'm wondering, would it be easier, Carl, because I haven't responded to them, I
don't know about anyone else. Can we get them in email form so we could correct it
that way? Because, by mentioning every line, it's gonna take forever. They are such
a mess.
Madam Chair, Carl has sat down with the recorder, and they spent eight hours
revising it. Because he knows more of the lingo than she did, and we're gonna hand
out that corrected verbatim minutes to you, and they'll probably get on the July 14th
agenda. So, we'll hand those out in advance, and if you have corrections of those,
which I think have less problems, then we'll go from there.
And please send them to Mr. Herdman, too, so he can look at them.
Yes.
I do believe that what we have corrected, you will find, is acceptable, however, I
could send you a read-only word file, also, if you wish. If that's okay.
Do you guys want that? So you can see it ahead of time?
Well, it would be in our packet, wouldn't it?
No, he's saying sending it by email so if we had corrections, it's so much easier to
correct by email.
But it's going to be read-only.
Oh, it's read-only. Okay.
I think thafs all the Clerk will allow.
Oh. Okay. That would be great.
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 64
Mr. Flance:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Flance:
Chair Woods:
Mr. Flance:
Ms. Rios:
Mr. Flailce:
Mr. Whitfield:
Ms. Rios:,
Client:
Ms. Walker.
Chair Woods:
Mr. Flance:
Ms. Walker.
Pardon me. Madam Chair, do you have a date in mind for our next meeting, and will
it be pretty much the same format that we've been following up to this point?
I think that's a really good question as far as design. I think we'd almost have to take
it, as we have been, building by building. If we look at Marian Hall... I think it's the
most effective way we've come up with so far, getting through this.
I think it's working.
Okay. So, is everybody okay with that? And then I think you should propose some
dates David and Tracy will email them out to us and we can respond.
Okay.
I have a quick question to ask Steve. This is just a question out of my own curiosity.
Is this hotel considered a luxury hotel?
You know, I actually have stayed in many Drury hotels. They consistently receive the
highest awards from J.D. Power and Associates for mid-range hotels. Let me ask
our Client to address that.
Ms. Rios, basically, this is our high pride. This is a full service hotel. Luxury almost
denotes five stars. This is something three and a.half to four. So, ifs still in an
affordable range, but it does have amenities. Like in this case, we want the spas and
the restaurants and the bars, and you know, the indoor lap pool and the outdoor
pool, a lot of the items you would expect to see in a full service hotel. pnaudible] it's
something we want to do, almost by necessity, pnaudible]. ls that...
Yeah. Just curious.. ............. , - ..
[Inaudible]
May I make a suggestion? One of the things that endeared La Posada, not the
current way it is, but. before, was that they offered memberships to the city to use the
pool. Just thought I'd mention it.
I'd also like to mention that Woods did some work on that, and that pool had no
electrical grounding. paughter]
And I'd also like to mention that several of the applicants before this Board ended up
in that pool with no electrical grounding. paughter]
Did you know it was hand-dug by Bob Lockwood"s company in 1948.
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 65
H. NEW BUSINESS
None.
I. MATTERS FROM THE BOARD
None.
J. ADJOURNMENT
Having completed the agenda and with no further business to come before the Board, the meeting was
adjourned at approximately 8:00 p.m.
Sharon Woods, Chair
Submitted by:
Historic Design Review Board June 30, 2009 Page 66