Historic Districts Review Board Meeting — Tue, Oct 27, 2026 · 9D. 2026-013210-HDRB. 124 Camino Santiago. Downtown & Eastside Historic District. Contributing. Kareem and Mary Jo Edwards, owners, request approval to replace doors & windows on a primary façade with exceptions to 14-4.6(E)(4)(I)(a) for altering openings on a primary façade, & to 14-4.6(E)(4)(II)(b) for changing the historic stucco color & texture. (Lauren Vagts, lavagts@santafenm.gov)
Mary Jo Edwards 124 Camino Santiago Santa Fe, NM 87501 (505) 429-9729 maryjoedwards@email.com October 01, 2025 City of Santa Fe Historic Preservation Division Planning and Land Use Department 200 Lincoln Avenue Santa Fe, NM 87504 RE: Historic Window Replacement Proposal — 124 Camino Santiago Dear Historic Preservation Division, I am submitting this proposal in support of a request for administrative or HDRB approval for window replacement at my residence located at 124 Camino Santiago, a contributing structure in the Downtown & Eastside Historic District (Lot 16, Plaza del Monte subdivision). The purpose of this proposal is to upgrade and replace several existing windows that are not original to the structure with windows that will both meet egress requirements and match the original windows of the historical neighborhood with new units that meet International Residential Code (IRC) egress requirements while preserving the architectural character and historic integrity of the home. Scope of Work The project consists of replacing a total of 6 windows and one sliding glass door with bronze-clad wood units from Pinnacle Windows. The design and configuration will match the originals as closely as possible, including simulated divided lights and proportional muntins. The proposed changes include: - Bedroom Windows (Guest and Primary): Existing three-window configurations will be replaced with larger, two-window casement units to meet required egress opening sizes (minimum 5.7 sq. ft. and sill height under 44”). - Living Room and Kitchen Windows: Minor configuration adjustments will retain original dimensions and style while improving performance. - Sunroom Patio Door: Replacing existing slider with a new 4-panel bronze-clad patio door with narrow stile rails. - West Elevation (Primary Façade): Windows facing the street will retain original opening sizes, divided light appearance, and trim details. Historic and Legal Context - The subject property is part of the Plaza del Monte subdivision and is designated a Contributing Structure per H-19-019. - The west façade is considered primary and will not have any size alterations, only replacement in-kind. - The home is within the Downtown and Eastside Historic District, subject to Land Development Code Section 14-5.2. - Supporting documentation includes the plat map, CC&Rs, and recent property survey. In addition to the proposed window replacements, we are requesting approval to proceed with exterior stucco replacement. The existing stucco has deteriorated in several locations and requires replacement to preserve the structure and aesthetics of the home. The replacement will use historically appropriate materials and match the existing color and texture, ensuring compliance with Historic District requirements. All work will be executed with attention to preserving the contributing character of the structure. Request Based on guidance from Planner Lani McCulley and window consultant Melissa Cobb, we are seeking administrative approval if the window replacements do not alter existing opening sizes. If HDRB review is required due to egress-driven adjustments, we respectfully request placement on the next available hearing schedule. I appreciate your consideration of this proposal and am happy to provide additional documentation or meet with a staff planner as needed. My goal is to ensure the safety, comfort, and historic integrity of the home are preserved with thoughtful updates. Sincerely, Mary Jo Edwards (505) 429-9729 maryjo@itconnectinc.com 124 Camino Santiago Roof Tear-Off Mod-Bit Re-Roof Legend 124 Camino Santiago 20 ft N ➤➤ N Image Landsat / CopernicusImage Landsat / Copernicus FURNACE W/H RANGE REFRIG. BEDROOM BEDROOM LIVING ROOM STORAGE BATHROOM BATHROOM KITCHEN G. DONALD DUDLEY AIA DATE:08/16/2026 REF: SKETCH#: . A101 . . 124 Camino Santiago Santa Fe, NM 87501 WINDOW & DOOR REPLACEMENT G. DONALD DUDLEY, JR. No. 3673 NE W M E X I C O F O E T A T S D E A R E T S I G E R R C H I T E C T 8/16/2026 124 CAMINO SANTIAGO I 00 00 I 00 E 0 E X EXISTING EXTERIOR BUILDING ELEVATIONS 1/4"=1'-o" 5' 10' p R 0 PROPOSED EXTERIOR BUILDING ELEVATIONS 1/4"=1'-o" 5' 10' s T N G NORTH Q p 0 s E D NORTH Q MARK TYPE UNIT SIZE (WxH) HEAD <A} EGRESS CASEMENT WINDOW 60 .. X 41 .. s·-a· ( B) HINGED DOOR 37 1/2" x so· s·-a· C) VENT AWNING WINDOW 40 .. X 41" s·-a· < D) SLIDING PATIO DOOR UNIT 165 .. X B5"' 6'-8'" E) FIXED WINDOW 68" X 14" s·-a· F) EGRESS CASEMENT WINDOW 78" X 41 .. s·-a· PROPOSED EXTERIOR � DOOR & WINDOW SCHEDULE �----------- 124 Camino Santiago — Existing Conditions Photographic Documentation | Page 1 124 CAMINO SANTIAGO Existing Conditions — Photographic Documentation City Case #2025-011347-PAR | Santa Fe, NM 87501 | Prepared for G. Donald Dudley, AIA This packet documents the exterior condition of 124 Camino Santiago prior to the 2026 window and door replacement work. All photographs below are taken from the Uniform Residential Appraisal Report prepared by Bruce Cumming, Cumming Appraisal Service (NM License 02256-R), with an effective date and photography date of December 8, 2024 — before the window/door work took place. They are reproduced here at full resolution from that report. Purpose: on 9/1/2026, Lauren Vagts (HPD case planner) advised that because the window and door replacements were completed without prior HDRB approval, that completed work will serve as the “proposed” condition, and the submittal separately needs “existing” elevations documenting what was there before, along with a statement of whether the elevations changed at all. This packet is the factual basis for that “existing” documentation — it is not itself the scaled, dimensioned elevation drawing HDRB requires (¼"=1'-0", with heights and opening dimensions). Don Dudley should use these photographs (together with the building's known, unchanged wall/roof dimensions from his 8/16/2026 stamped set) to prepare the actual existing-condition elevation drawings for submission. 1. Photographic Record (as of 12/8/2024, pre-replacement) Front (Entry) Elevation 124 Camino Santiago — Front Elevation (existing / pre-renovation, photographed 12/08/2024) Two multi-lite window units flank the entry door beneath the front portal (round vigas on wood posts). Entry door is a single dark-toned door with a narrow vertical glazed lite. A second, narrower door is visible further along the portal near the carport. Rear Elevation 124 Camino Santiago — Existing Conditions Photographic Documentation | Page 2 124 Camino Santiago — Rear Elevation (existing / pre-renovation, photographed 12/08/2024) White-painted, multi-lite French door pair (approx. 6 lites per leaf) opening onto the rear yard, plus one multi-lite window to the right with white trim. Side Elevation — Sunroom / Utility Door 124 Camino Santiago — Side Elevation, Sunroom (existing / pre-renovation, photographed 12/08/2024) 124 Camino Santiago — Existing Conditions Photographic Documentation | Page 3 Flush white utility door at left. Sunroom addition at right: full-height multi-pane glazing (approx. 4 columns × 3 rows per bay) in white-painted wood/aluminum frames, with a glazed door at the sunroom's near corner. Side Elevation — Blank Wall 124 Camino Santiago — Side Elevation, opposite side (existing / pre-renovation, photographed 12/08/2024) No door or window openings visible along this stretch of wall — stucco only, with exposed viga tails at the roof eave. Carport (Interior Wall) 124 Camino Santiago — Existing Conditions Photographic Documentation | Page 4 124 Camino Santiago — Carport Interior Wall (existing / pre-renovation, photographed 12/08/2024) One multi-lite window with white trim and one door (dark/teal tone) along the interior carport wall, adjacent to a utility meter. Front Portal (Detail) 124 Camino Santiago — Front Portal, looking toward entry (existing / pre-renovation, photographed 12/08/2024) 124 Camino Santiago — Existing Conditions Photographic Documentation | Page 5 Detail of the covered portal structure (vigas, round posts) and the window/door grouping near the entry, matching the Front Elevation photo above. Window Condition Detail 124 Camino Santiago — Window Detail, front elevation (existing / pre-renovation, photographed 12/08/2024) Close-up confirming a white-painted wood-framed window with a center vertical mullion; paint failure and sill deterioration visible. Documents frame material/condition prior to replacement. 2. Existing Window & Door Inventory (as photographed) Summarized from visual review of the photographs above. This is a starting inventory for Don Dudley to confirm, adjust, and formalize — it is not a substitute for field verification or the 2018 HDRB approval package (case H-19-019), if that record can also be located. Location Opening Type Frame / Material Count Notes Front, left of entry Multi-lite window unit Light-colored frame (metal or clad wood) 1 Paired look — appears to be two window units side by side Front, right of entry Multi-lite window unit Light-colored frame (metal or clad wood) 1 Matches left-side unit Front, entry Single door, narrow vertical glazed lite Dark-toned door 1 Main entry door under portal Front, portal (far end) Door (partially visible) Dark tone 1 Near carport bay; not fully visible in photo Rear French door pair, ~6 lites/leaf White-painted wood 1 pair Opens to rear yard Rear Multi-lite window White trim 1 To the right of the French doors Side (sunroom side) Flush utility door White, flush panel 1 No visible lites 124 Camino Santiago — Existing Conditions Photographic Documentation | Page 6 Side (sunroom) Full-height multi-pane glazing, ~4x3 grid per bay White-painted wood/aluminum Multiple panes, 1 assembly Sunroom addition; also a glazed door at near corner Side (opposite) None — 0 No openings on this elevation Carport interior wall Multi-lite window White trim 1 Adjacent to utility meter Carport interior wall Door Dark / teal tone 1 Likely storage or utility access 3. Existing Floor Plan Basis — Appraiser's Building Sketch The building footprint and room layout below are from the same Cumming Appraisal Service report (12/08/2024). Since the 2026 work did not change the footprint (confirmed by Mary Jo Edwards, 8/27 and 9/1/2026), these dimensions should match the current as-built condition and can serve as the basis for the existing floor plan, subject to Don Dudley's verification and conversion to the required ¼"=1'-0" dimensioned format. 124 Camino Santiago — Building Sketch (Cumming Appraisal Service, 12/08/2024) Total living area 1,265 sq ft (rounded); non-living area includes 134.4 sf open front porch and 405.02 sf one-car attached carport. 4. Recommended Next Step ● Don Dudley (or the preparer of the existing elevations) reviews this packet against the wall/roof dimensions already established in his 8/16/2026 stamped proposed set, since the massing and footprint have not changed. ● Where possible, cross-check against the 2018 HDRB approval package (case H-19-019), if it can be located and opened, for any additional historic elevation detail. 124 Camino Santiago — Existing Conditions Photographic Documentation | Page 7 ● Produce the required existing and proposed elevation drawings at ¼"=1'-0", with heights, accurate opening locations/dimensions, and a note confirming which parts of the elevation (if any) changed — per Lauren Vagts's 9/1/2026 guidance. ● These photographs, captioned as shown above, can also be submitted directly to satisfy HDRB's separate “Photographs” requirement (existing conditions). Window and Door Schedule — As-Built 124 Camino Santiago, Santa Fe, NM 87507 · City Case #2025-011347-PAR Prepared for resubmission to the Historic Preservation Division Note: The windows and door listed below were replaced prior to this schedule being compiled. Dimensions and specifications are drawn from the signed purchase agreement and product quotes from Architectural Windows & Doors (Quote #3016275 and Quote #SQDFI000005-1). Compatibility notes reflect the vendor's own comments at time of quoting. Corresponding elevation drawings (existing and as-built) are being prepared separately and will reference these unit IDs (A–F). ID Location / Room Unit Type Rough Opening Overall Frame Product / Spec Reference Compatibility Note (as supplied) A Guest Bedroom (Egress opening) Paired casement, 2 units (LH + RH), bronze-clad wood, Dual Low-E, egress hardware 60 3/4" x 41 3/4" 60" x 41" Windsor Pinnacle, Quote #3016275, Line 100 + 200 (egress hinge) Vendor notes unit does not match existing configuration B Primary/Master Bedroom (Egress opening) Paired casement, 2 units (LH + RH), bronze-clad wood, Dual Low-E, egress hardware 78 3/4" x 41 3/4" 78" x 41" Windsor Pinnacle, Quote #3016275, Line 300 Vendor notes: “Not built to match existing configuration — built for egress” C Kitchen Paired awning, 2 units, bronze-clad wood, Dual Low-E 40 3/4" x 41 3/4" 40" x 41" Windsor Pinnacle, Quote #3016275, Line 400 Vendor notes: “Will look similar to existing windows” D Living Room Fixed direct-glaze unit, bronze-clad wood, Dual Low-E 68 3/4" x 14 3/4" 68" x 14" Windsor Pinnacle, Quote #3016275, Line 500 Vendor notes unit is shorter than existing opening (reduced to close in) E Sunroom 4-panel sliding glass door (OOXO), bronze- clad wood, Dual Low-E, tempered glass 165 3/4" x 86 3/4" 165" x 86" Windsor Pinnacle, Quote #3016275, Line 600 No vendor note on file re: match to existing — confirm with contractor F Entry (front door) Single entry door, primed steel w/ primed composite jamb, 5-lite offset reeded glass — 37 1/2" x 80" Woodgrain/Loewen, Quote #SQDFI000005-1 No vendor note on file re: match to existing — confirm with contractor Legend Shaded rows (A, B, D) indicate units the vendor noted as not matching, or only partially matching, the original historic configuration — flagged here for HPD's awareness ahead of review. Plaza Del Monte Association Project Submission Form Date: 10-10-2025 Owner’s Name: Mary Jo Edwards Owner’s Address: 124 Camino Santiago, Santa Fe, NM 87501 Property Address at Plaza Del Monte: 124 Camino Santiago, Santa Fe, NM 87501 Owner’s Phone Number: 505-429-9729 Owner’s Email Address: maryjo@itconnectinc.com Type of Request: n Architectural Modification n Landscaping Change/Addition n Wall n Fence n Gate(s) n Screening n Other: Project/Request Details: Replace non-compliant windows and bring sleeping room windows into egress compliance per Historic guidelines. Attachments Included: n Project Plans n Photos or Renderings n Material Samples n Other Status of Review: Under review with Historic Preservation and City of Santa Fe Contractor Information: Company/Contractor’s Name: Johnny Roybal, Design Solutions Contractor’s Contact Name: Johnny Roybal Contractor/Company Phone Number: TBA Contractor/Contact Email: TBA Contractor’s License Number: TBA Acknowledgment: I understand that my request is subject to review and approval by the Plaza Del Monte Association. I agree not to commence work until written approval is received. Signature: Mary Jo Edwards Date: 10-10-2025 For HOA Use Only Date Received: October 29, 2025 Reviewed By: John A. Padilla, AIA Approval Status: n Approved ✣ Approved with Conditions 11/11/2025 n Denied Notes/Conditions: Review is conditional pending final review and approval required from historic preservation and Historic Districts Review Board. HDRB approval of the alterations to existing openings, introduction of new openings, elimination of existing openings shall be presented to Plaza Del Monte for inclusion with the proposed renovations. 124 CAMINO SANTIAGO Proposed Exterior Finish — Stucco Color Change City Case #2025-011347-PAR | Santa Fe, NM 87501 | HDRB Exterior Finish Swatch This sheet documents a proposed stucco color change for 124 Camino Santiago, submitted as part of the HDRB application per the "Exterior Finishes" requirement (color swatches with manufacturer name and color label; "to match existing" is not an acceptable description). Existing Condition Approximate existing stucco color (sampled from photograph) Reference only — color sampled from a sunlit exterior photograph (Cumming Appraisal Service, 12/8/2024) using image color-picking. This is NOT a manufacturer-matched color code. No manufacturer name or color label is on file for the existing stucco. If HPD requires a certified match, a paint/stucco supplier can field- match a physical sample from the house. Proposed Color Dunn-Edwards “Swiss Coffee” — DEW341 Manufacturer: Dunn-Edwards Paints Color Name / Code: Swiss Coffee / DEW341 Hex: #F8F5E9 | RGB: 248, 245, 233 Submission Deadlines To be included in the same HDRB application as the window/door and site plan items, this stucco color change needs to be finalized in time for the following submittal deadline: Submittal Deadline Hearing Date August 10, 2026 September 3, 2026 (passed) September 14, 2026 ← next realistic target October 8, 2026 October 9, 2026 November 5, 2026 November 9, 2026 December 3, 2026 Source: 2026 HDRB Hearing Schedule (santafenm.gov). If the stucco color decision or swatch can't be finalized in time for September 14, it can instead be added at the October 9 deadline for the November 5 hearing — but bundling it with the window/door and site plan items now avoids a second HDRB hearing cycle for the same property. Note ● This represents a substantial visual change from the existing warm terracotta/tan stucco to an off-white finish, and should be expected to draw HDRB Board attention as a material change to a Contributing Structure's primary façade appearance. ● Per the HDRB Required Materials checklist, this color and manufacturer/code should be itemized in the Proposal Letter (which was originally sent 8/14/2026, before this item was added) — an addendum or updated proposal letter should reference this specific change. ● Recommend flagging this addition to Lauren Vagts (HPD case planner) in advance of finalizing the submittal, since it is new scope beyond the window/door and site plan items already discussed with her. ● Don Dudley should note the proposed stucco color on the proposed elevations, consistent with the checklist's requirement to itemize materials, colors, and finishes.