Historic Districts Review Board Meeting — Tue, Oct 27, 2026 · 9D. 2026-013210-HDRB. 124 Camino Santiago. Downtown & Eastside Historic District. Contributing. Kareem and Mary Jo Edwards, owners, request approval to replace doors & windows on a primary façade with exceptions to 14-4.6(E)(4)(I)(a) for altering openings on a primary façade, & to 14-4.6(E)(4)(II)(b) for changing the historic stucco color & texture. (Lauren Vagts, lavagts@santafenm.gov)
October 04, 2022
Stucco Styles, Material, and Color Guidance in the Historic Districts
Purpose and Intent:
These guidelines are offered to promote preservation of the stucco styles and colors
within the historic districts designated by the City of Santa Fe. This guidance is
consistent with the standards set forth in SFCC 14-5.2 H Districts.
In Santa Fe, stucco is noted on the revival style buildings built from the late 19th century
to the present. In some cases, the stucco exterior of buildings in Santa Fe is intended to
simulate adobe and in other cases the stucco exterior of buildings represents more
textured styles which demonstrate more practical or stylized designs of a particular time.
The use of stucco in each of the Santa Fe historic districts is noteworthy and is
important to maintaining the feel and character of Santa Fe. As such, the guidance for
stucco style is considered necessary to preserve on contributing, significant, and
landmark structures.
Stucco Style:
The historic districts in Santa Fe demonstrate a variety of stucco styles. Styles include
more simple smooth finished stuccos as well as stuccos with more pronounced surfaces
and textures. Stucco styles are a moniker of particular time periods, demonstrating
architectural style as well as materials of a particular time.
In Santa Fe the most common historic styles for stucco finishes that require
preservation include (but are not limited to): adobe finish, sand finish, pebble-dashed
surfaces, dry-dashed surfaces, fan texture, and sponge texture. The style of stucco on
contributing, significant, and landmark structures must be identified and preserved as an
architectural feature per 14-5.2(D)(5) of the H Districts code.
Fan Texture near Delgado St. Fan/Palate Texture; Gomez Rd Heavy Sponge near Don Gaspar
October 04, 2022
Pebble-dashed Texture on Santa Fe Depot Light Sand Texture on Greer Mansion Light Sand Texture near Delgado St.
Smooth Finish Mud Plaster on El Zagan Light Brushed Texture on on El Zagan Smooth Finish on El Zagan
Material:
The use of the correct type of material on the exterior of historic buildings is essential to
preventing damage and maintaining historic integrity.
Mud Plaster- Mud plaster is character defining and shall be preserved on contributing,
significant, and landmark structures as is appropriate to maintaining the historic
character of the building and the streetscape.
Cement Stucco- Cement stucco shall be used on contributing, significant, and landmark
structures as is appropriate to maintaining the historic character of the building and the
streetscape.
Synthetic Stucco- Synthetic stucco is permissible on non-contributing and new
construction.
October 04, 2022
Paint- Paint is not permissible on cement stucco on contributing, significant, or landmark
structures. Synthetic paint is permissible on non-contributing structures for the purposes
of repair and maintenance or structures where paint is inherent to the historic nature of
the building (e.g., buildings with wood siding).
Paint is generally not advisable on any building within the historic districts unless it is
over elastomeric stucco that was previously approved.
Color:
Stucco color in the historic districts is also important to maintaining the look and feel of
Santa Fe. Per SFCC 14-5.2 the color of stucco shall be predominately earth toned,
meaning of the earth or soil, with lighter colors, such as white or yeso, being permissible
underneath portals. Colors approved by the Historic Districts Review Board, which are
listed below, are allowed in the historic districts, and can be approved administratively.
These are color swatches for which to give a basis of reference. If pantone colors are
used, this guidance may help provide a range to help guide color selections. Other
stucco color requests required approval by the HDRB. If an applicant feels a proposed
color, not included in this document, is right for a project it should be evaluated by the
Board. Please review SFCC 14-5.2(E)- (I) for specific information on colors in each
district.
The approved colors apply to both cement and synthetic stucco. El Rey® stucco colors
are used to serve as a general guideline for acceptable colors. El Rey® brand is not
required to be used. Other vendors are acceptable to use. A color chart can be provided
upon request.
Exterior Stucco
Colors Allowed
THESE COLORS CAN BE
ADMINISTRATIVELY APPROVED
Colors Allowed
Under Portals
THESE COLORS CAN BE
ADMINISTRATIVELY
APPROVED
Colors Requiring
HDRB Approval
Madera Cameo Cameo
Hacienda Candlelight Candlelight
Fawn Cream Cream
Palomino Ivory Ivory
Sandalwood Soapstone Soapstone
Straw Navajo White Navajo White
Buckskin Denim
Kokanee Ash
Sand Soft Rose
Sahara Desert Rose*
Adobe Pueblo
Suede Coral
Bamboo Cottonwood*
La Luz Dove Gray*
October 04, 2022
*Desert Rose, Dove Gray and Cottonwood are not considered to be in harmony with the streetscape in the
Downtown and Eastside Historic District.
Stucco Approval:
Administrative Approval for Stucco- The City HPD provides administrative approvals
and prepares cases for the HDRB for Board approval at a public hearing. The
administrative approval is provided when maintenance and repair issues, and for color
changes to existing stuccos when a permit is required. Administrative approval is also
provided for stucco color change on existing HDRB approved cases.
HDRB Approval of Stucco- HDRB approval of stucco is required as part of an
application for remodel or new construction, or in the cases where a non-approved
stucco color is requested.
No Approval Required- No administrative or HDBR approval is required for basic
maintenance and cleaning of stucco where a permit is not required, and the color of the
stucco will not change.
El Rey Stucco Chart:
Source of color chart- https://elrey.com/color-charts-premium.shtml
Premium Stucco Finish Colors
Cameo
102 (67)
Colonial White
100 (76)
Madera
212 (24)
Candlelight
90 (75)
Hacienda
127 (52)
Cream
128 (70)
Ivory
129 (70)
La Morena
197 (19)
Soapstone
30 (66)
Fawn
117 (45)
October 04, 2022
Palomino
119 (55)
Navajo White
101 (71)
Sandalwood
121 (56)
Straw
122 (42)
Buckskin
106 (35)
Kokanee
108 (54)
Sand
103 (52)
Denim
107 (44)
Sahara
135 (35)
Adobe
116 (24)
Suede
118 (38)
Bamboo
105 (47)
Ash
110 (64)
Soft Rose
80 (60)
Cottonwood
115 (32)
Desert Rose
114 (39)
Pueblo
130 (53)
La Luz
125 (20)
Coral
124 (35)
Dove Gray
113 (50)
Stucco is the best value and the most efficient wall finish available. It is a tried and true finish with a proven
long-term and well documented history. Providing a variety of textures, beauty, durability, and fire-
resistance properties, portland cement stucco is the obvious choice for your home.
Due to individual computer screen limitations, colors shown here may not accurately reflect the Parex USA
colors.
The colors shown are intended to show the approximate color of the finish. Color will vary depending on the
type selected. Application by machine spray or texturing will increase the depth of the color. Variation in
color due to weather, job conditions, and method of application should be expected. For color verification,
request actual sample in the color and texture prior to ordering material. Apply a sample of finish to be used
on actual substrate before proceeding with the application. ParexUSA is not responsible for color correctness
of applied finish. Color must be verified and approved by owner prior to application.
October 3, 2022
Window Guidance in the Historic Districts
Purpose and Intent:
These guidelines are offered to promote preservation of the historic window and window
styles in the historic districts designated by the City of Santa Fe. This guidance is
consistent with the standards set forth in SFCC 14-5.2 H Districts.
In Santa Fe, windows are noted on the revival style buildings built from the late
nineteenth century to the mid-twentieth century. Historic windows are character-defining
features that give an indication of the time period, craftsmanship, and technology.
Windows may be double hung (slide up and down), casements (opening like doors),
transom (above a door or another window), or fixed picture windows to name a few
types.
Brief History:
Historic Windows: Wood casement were the first operable glass windows, appearing
prior to 1880. Around that time, double hung wood windows became popular. Steel
casement became popular after WWI.
Non-historic Windows: With the depletion of old growth forests, vinyl and fiberglass
were invented in the 1950s. Metal or vinyl clad wood windows were introduced post
1960.
Sustainability and Longevity:
Wood windows in historic properties have been proven to last 100 to 200+ years with
maintenance. Replacement window companies generally estimate their products to last
15-25 years before needing to be replaced. Replacing old windows starts a cycle of
waste that sends non-recyclable materials to the landfill, sometimes multiple times in a
single homeowner’s tenure.
Single pane wood windows generally have an R-value of R1. Double and triple pane
windows R-value are R-2 or R-3. Much energy loss and air infiltration occur at the gaps
and edges. Without providing proper sealing, weather stripping, and glazing putty,
adding more glazing can have minimal impact. Exterior or interior storm windows can
reduce energy loss if a non-destructive attachment is used to attach to the historic
window.
Window Repair and Replacement Approval Process:
Administrative Approval of Windows - The City HPD provides administrative approvals
and prepares cases for the HDRB for Board approval at public hearings. Administrative
approval is provided for:
1. maintenance and repair issues,
2. window replacements on non-primary facades of contributing buildings that fall
within the district standards and maintain the historic style of the building, and
October 3, 2022
3. window replacements on non-contributing buildings
HDRB Approval of Windows - HDRB approval of windows is required when:
1. as part of an application for remodel or new construction that requires Board
approval,
2. when window replacement is requested on primary facades for historic windows,
3. when replacement of historic windows is requested on significant buildings, or
4. when a change is requested for the size of opening of the window on a primary
façade (requesting a code exception required).
No Approval Required- No administrative or HDRB approval is required for basic
maintenance and cleaning of windows where a permit is not required.
Requesting Replacement Windows:
Is your building contributing or non-contributing? Consider that it may require a status
review if 50 years old or older. Once you find this out, the information below applies.
Please consider that District Standards (listed below) apply as well.
Contributing Structures:
Primary Facades: Due to requirements in SFCC 14-5.2(D)(5) for historic windows
to be repaired or restored wherever possible, a historic window must be proven
to be beyond repair. Therefore, a window assessment is required to show that
each piece of the window is at least 30% degraded beyond repair per 14-
5.2(C)(3)(b). A window assessor can be chosen from the City of Santa Fe’s
Approved List for Window Evaluators.
Once the windows are proven to be beyond repair, the window shall be
duplicated in the size, style, and material of the original.
Non-Primary Facades: District standards outlined in SFCC 14-5.2 must be
followed. The style of the building should be maintained through window
replacement. According to SFCC 14-5.2 (D)(2)(a) additions must have similar
architectural treatments and styles of that of the contributing building.
Non-Contributing Structures: District standards outlined in SFCC 14-5.2 must be
followed.
All: Thermal glass may be used for individual panels but the replacement of rolled glass
or historic rippled glass is discouraged. Exterior or interior storm windows are
encouraged to reduce energy loss if a non-destructive attachment is used to
attach to the historic window. Window screens are generally acceptable. Snap-in
muntins are discouraged and should not be used. Muntins, or the visible lites
divisions, should be seen from the exterior of the window. Non-arresting colors
and considerate of streetscape harmony per SFCC 14-5.2(A)(1)(c) may be
chosen.
October 3, 2022
District standards:
In the Downtown and Eastside Historic District, on Old Santa Fe Style buildings,
30” glazing in any dimension and divided lites are required. On Recent Santa Fe
Style buildings, non-divided lights are allowed on non-publicly visible facades.
In the Historic Transition District, a general harmony is maintained. Architecture
is wall-dominated. Santa Fe Style is to be emulated. Large undivided light is
allowed on south facing walls for solar collection.
In the Historic Review District, Santa Fe Style is to be emulated. Large undivided
light is allowed under portals and on south facing walls for solar collection.
In the Don Gaspar Historic District, a general harmony is maintained. The use of
large glazed areas on south facing walls is allowed for solar collection.
In the Westside-Guadalupe Historic District, a general harmony is maintained.
The use of large glazed areas on south facing walls is allowed for solar
collection.
PLAZA DEL MONTE
Santa Fe, New Mexico
Historic Resources Evaluation
Amendment to March 28, 2018 Report
May 7, 2018
Client: Wayne S. Lloyd, A.I.A.
Lloyd and Associates, Architects
100 N Guadalupe Street,# 201
Santa Fe, NM 87501
Consultant: John W. Murphey
Architectural Historian
2833 Plaza Verde
Santa Fe, NM 87507
lID r re~ TI ~J ~ ™1Pi
lfil MAY O8 2Ul8 w
BY: ____________ _
Introduction
This brief amendment addresses issues the Historic Districts Review Board brought up at the
April 24, 2018 hearing, as well as information requested by the City of Santa Fe Historic
Preservation Division after the hearing.
Retaining Walls: 124 and 126 A Camino Santiago
David Rasch, the case manager for the project, communicated to the applicant after the hearing
that the retaining walls of the two units granted demolition by the Board required
documentation.
On May 3, 2018, the consultant recorded the retaining walls at 124 and 126 A Camino Santiago
(the combined garage/carport structure), associated with the two units granted demolition at
the April 24, 2018 hearing.
Both units include low concrete-and-stone walls which work as retaining walls and/or
transitions between building pads.
The wall for 126 A retains the dirt between the apartment building (126) and the parking stalls.
It is constructed of non-reinforced concrete, mixed with heavy stones most likely taken from
the adjacent arroyo (Figure 1).
The wall is erected over a concrete walkway and stands approximately 32" above the sidewalk
and 14" above the contained earth. The 10"-thick structure presents an angled face similar to a
dam. It is topped with rounded concrete coping. The wall runs the length of the parking
structure before tapering to the ground on the west and rising above grade to the east as a
pathway entry.
A wall of similar composition edges the south and east exposures of the back yard of 124
Camino Santiago (Figure 2). It begins at 9½" above grade at the patio, and continues in a
northerly direction, ranging between 18" to 26" above inside grade. Near the northeast
tangent, it connects with another wall erected with the construction of 122 Camino Santiago.
Based on aerial photographs, neither the 124 nor 126 A retaining walls predate the
construction of their associated units. And while this fact is inconclusive, neither wall is visible
on the February 28, 1968 aerial photograph (Aerial 1). The retaining walls are apparent on a
February 27, 1969 photograph, indicating the completion of the units and their landscaping
(Aerial 2).
Given their low architectural value, and assumed c.1968+ construction date, neither is
recommended for Contributing Structure status to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District.
Additional Walls
As stated in the Historic Resources Evaluation, the Plaza del Monte landscape includes a
number of retaining walls. The retaining walls, constructed of formed concrete or concrete and
stone, were built over several phases, dating generally between 1950 and 1973. The walls were
constructed to retain earth or to separate building pads (Figure 3). Very few of them rise above
grade. A few lots have above-ground property line walls. These are made of stucco-clad
concrete masonry units (Figure 4). From aerial photographs, both retaining and property line
walls appear to post-date the construction of their associated units.
Given their recent date of construction and utilitarian quality, the retaining and property walls
are not recommended for individual or collective Contributing Structure status to the
Downtown and Eastside Historic District.
Aerial Imagery
To address the Board's concern over the lack of c.1968-69 aerial imagery for the west side of
Plaza del Monte, the consultant approached the NM DOT seeking additional photographs.
The head of aerial photography, Alane Wainwright, confirmed in an April 30 email to the
consultant that the February 27, 1969 aerial {1969_02_27_4072) presented in the Historic
Resources Evaluation represented the end of the flight line. The email supported her January
17, 2018 communication, which asserted that the image was all that the NM DOT could offer.
Wainwright explained in that email that the image didn't "get the entire area."1
However, given the importance of the case, on April 30 Wainwright performed an additional
due-diligence search and found three 1968-69 era photographs that are not available to the
public.2 These include two secondary images from the February 27, 1969 flight and one from
February 28, 1968. Wainwright additionally provided several images from May 1973.
Both the 1968 and 1969 aerials show the southwest quadrant of Plaza del Monte to be
populated with only two structures: 124 and 126 Camino Santiago (Aerials 1 & 2).
1 Alane Wainwright, email communication to John Murphey, January 17, 2018.
2 Ibid., April 30, 2018.
The newly revealed aerial photographs present a strong case that only a handful of units were
fully completed by February 28, 1968. The 1973 image shows most of the units finished, and
118 Camino Santiago still in the framing stage (Aerial 3).
Construction Dates
At the April 24, 2018 hearing, the Board expressed apprehension about the report's assigned
construction dates. The dates were premised on the consultant's methodology which used
various sources (primarily aerial photographs, city directory entries, and architectural
drawings), to arrive at a relative - though most often accurate - "circa" date of construction.
Sowing confusion was mention of a 1988 appraiser's estimate of dates introduced during sworn
testimony. This information was neither viewed by the Board nor officially introduced into the
record.
Given the Board's questioning, the consultant reviewed the sources again, examined the 1988
appraiser's estimates, and evaluated the additional aerial photographs recently made available.
This analysis is presented in the table below.
After this exercise, the consultant believes that the Historic Resources Evaluation's assigned
dates of construction are mainly accurate.
Table 1: Yea r of Construction
Address Year Built* Date of Drawings 1988 Appraiser's Consultant's Original Source and Justification
Estimate•• and/or Revised
Estimate***
CAMINO SANTIAGO
101 c.1967-68 Unknown 1968 c.1967-68 Aerial photographs and first city
directory
102 I C.1965 Kenneth S. Clark & 1962 Before 1966 May 2, 1966 aerial photograph and first
R-2 Philippe Register, Appraiser assigns city directory entry
assumed address to
Camino Matias
1
103 c.1965 Philippe Register 1968 Before 1966 May 2, 1966 aerial photograph and first
R-12 1962 city directory entry
105 1971 Register, Ross & Burnet 1962 1971 Does not aQQear on either May 2, 1966
R-14 1970 or February 27, 1969 aerial Qhot ographs
Drawing, aerial photographs and first
city directory entry -- -106 c.1965 Kenneth 5. Clark & 1962 Before 1966 May 2, 1966 aerial photograph and first
R-3 Philippe Register, Appraiser assigns city directory entry
assumed address to
Camino Matias
109 c.1965 Philippe Register 1963 Before 1966 M ay 2, 1966 aerial photograph and first
R-15
1c.1962/
1963 city directory entry
110 Kenneth S. Clark 110:1962 110: c.1962 Drawings, aerial photographs and first
(112) c.1968 1962, original house; 112: 1968 112: c.1968 city directory entries
R-S Register, Ross &
- Burnet, addition__
111 c.1965 Philippe Register Unknown; Before 1966 Drawings, aerial photographs and first
1963 remodeled, 1962 city directory entry
113 c.1970 Unknown 1970 c.1970 Does not aoQear on February 27, 1969
Appraiser assigns aerial Qhotograoh
address as 115 a
Drawings and first city directory entry
114 c.1972 Register, Ross & Burnet 1971 c.1972 Does not apoear on February 27, 1969
R-26 1971 aerial Qhotograoh
[--
115 c.1970 Unknown
Drawings and first~y directory~ntry
1970 c.1970 Does not aQQear on February 27, 1969
aerial ohotograoh
First city directory entry
117 1966-67 Philippe Register Unknown; 1966-67 May 2, 1966 aerial photograph and first
1965; 1966 estimated 1963- city directory entry
1968
Address Year Built* Date of Drawings 1988 Appraiser's Consultant's Original Source and Justification
Estimate .. and/or Revised
Estimate ***
118 c.1973 Register, Ross & Burnet 1972 1973 Does not a1n1ear on Februa!}'. 27, 1969
1971 aerial photograph
Register & Burnet
1972 Drawings and first city directory entry
-- -- ---
119 c.1965 Philippe Register 1963 Before 1966 May 2, 1966 aerial photograph and first
1965/1968 city directory entry
120 c.1971 Register, Ross & Burnet 1970 c. 1971 Does not appear on Februari1 27, 1969
R-25 1970 aerial photograoh
Drawings and first ci!Y directory entry
121 c.1971 Register, Ross & Burnet 1970 c.1971 Does not aooear on Februa!}'. 27, 1969
R-20 1970 aerial photograph
Drawings and first city directo_ry entry
122 c.1971 Register, Ross & Burnet Unknown; c.1971 Does not apoear on Februa!}'. 27, 1969
1967 estimated 1963- aerial photograph
1968
first city directory entry
124 c.1968 Philippe Register 1964 c.1968 Does not aooear on Mall 2, 1966 aerial
R-23 1967 photograph.
125 c.1970 Register, Ross & Burnet 1969 c.1970 Does not aooear on Februa!Y 27, 1969
R-21 1969 aerial ohotograoh
Drawings and first city directory_!!ltry
126 c.1968 Philippe Register 1967 c.1968 Drawings, aerial photographs and first
R-24 1967 city directory entry
--
126 c.1968/ Unknown No covered c.1968/ Drawings and April 9, 1975 aerial
Garage 1977 1977 photograph
CAMINO MATIAS
104 c.1965 Kenneth S. Clark & 1962 Before 1966 May 2, 1966 aerial photograph
Philippe Register,
assumed;
Philippe Register
1963, alteration
105 1950 Unknown Unknown; 1950 Carolyn Atkins, The Allison-James
R-10 remodeled 1962 Picture Book, 1866-1959, (Albuquerque:
Menaul Historical Library of the
Southwest, 1983), 25; aerial
photographs
107 1950 Unknown Unknown; 1950 Carolyn Atkins, The Allison-James
R-9 remod eled 1962 Picture Book, 1866-1959, (Albuquerque:
Menaul Historical Library of the
Southwest, 1983), 25; aerial
photographs
109 1950 Unknown Unknown; 1950 Carolyn Atkins, The Allison-James
R-8 remodeled 1962 Picture Book, 1866-1959, (Albuquerque:
Menaul Historical Library of the
- r ----- --- ---- --
Address Year Built* Date of Drawings
- -
111 Pre-1960, Unknown
R-6 ! moved to
site- ------
116/120 Pre-1957, Unknown;
I R-7 ! with c.1984 Philippe Register and
additions Associates
1984
---~~------
Key:
·----
1988 Appraiser's
Estimate**
Unknown;
remodeled 1962
110: Unknown;
renovated 1967;
remodeled 1986
120: remodeled/
Renovated 1962
-----
Consultant's Original Source and Justification
and/or Revised
Estimate***
. Pre-1960,
• moved to site
Pre-1957,
with c.1984
additions
Southwest, 1983), 25; aerial
photographs
Aerial photographs
Drawings and aerial photographs
*The year the consultant originally estimated, as presented in March 28, 2018, Plaza del Monte, Santa Fe, Historic Resources Evaluation
report.
.. Taken from "As of 1988" table of appraiser's estimate of construction dates. The table was referenced in sworn testimony during the
April 24, 2018, Historic Districts Review Board hearing. The Board did not see the table nor was it introduced in the record. The consultant
took an iPhone image of the table at the hearing {Figure 3).
... The consultant's original and/or revised estimate based on best sources available, including dated aerial photographs, dated
architectural drawings and dated city directory entries, and previously publicly unavailable February 28, 1968 and February 2 7, 1969 aerial
photographs, NMDOT provided to consultant on April 30, 2018.
Figures and Aerial Photographs
Figure 1: 126 A Camino Santiago, Garage/Carport Structure, retaining wall, May 3, 2018.
Figure 2: 124 Camino Santiago, rear retaining wall, May 3, 2018.
Figure 3: c.1950 concrete retaining in front of 107 Camino Matias. January 18, 2018.
Figure 4: Stucco-on-block property wall between 114 and 118 Camino Santiago,
January 18, 2018.
-
I..>
• - 3II ...J ¥.A.-.
I.D.
ii.=r-
R- 2
R-J
R- ◄
R-54
R-Sb
I R-6
~..... - R-7a
- R-7b
R-8
R-9
R- 10
R-ll
R-U
R-14
R- Hb
R-14c
R- l4d
c.r R-1.S
R-16
R-170
R- l7b
R-18
J, f - R-J.9
.._ j R-20
• n,,fl - R-21.a
R- llb
R-2.lc
R•2ld
R-22
R-23
R-24&
R-24b·
R-2,e
R-24d
R-25
,, .- R-26
Str~t h!d..'"'ell
104 =..-.o l'.i:.i.u 1'.= o! O,,tllina
102 c=i.ro l'.ati.u S>r.g.le-P:=:.iy
Sir.CJle-Fudly
106 C=i.no l'dtias Single-l'a:lily
ua C>::IL-.o s.u,.-..;a90 Single-Fa=ily
U0 C>:::u.-.o Kstl&s Il:;>lu
ill ea..--u.no l'.iti.u Il:;>lex
w Ocl.z,o K>ws S1ngle-Fll=lily
US Oc:i.-.o Kstiu Il:;>lex
UO o,;,.i.,o Kstlu Il:;>lex
109 c:a.,,.i."l0 Mosti.as Sln9le-Fa:olly
107 Oci:>o M.stiu Sl."qle-Fa:.ily
105 Oc:i.-.o M.ltia.s Sl."ql e-Flcily
101 CJ:nirio &,,ntlago Single-r=ily
10) C=i..•.o So.-n:.i.ago Sinqle-r=ily
105& =.!.no Sr.ti.a.90 n,,,,..,,1.,,.
105b Ol::lino s.i.-,ua90
lDSc CZl:Wlo Sanwgo
rc,,,.,,1.,,.
1':,urplcx
105d Ol::dno Santla90 Fcurplax
10, c.:::ino San-..iAgo Sl."9l e-Fll::ily
ill C1:tlz,o s.i...-..iAc;o Sl.-.gle-r..:.ily
U5a Ce:::dno s.nwc;o Il:;>lex
USb ca::w,o s...nwgo Il:;>lcx
U7 Qc::ino S.V:t.iac;o sit;l e-r=ily
ll9 ca:,:i:,o S...-:--..i.a<Jo Sinqle-!'a:lily
U1 C&r.ino s.=iago Sir.<Jle-Fa:ill.y
U5a ca::d.no Santi.ago n,urplex
illb C=ino s.nw.go n,urpl cx
US<: Oc:i.".0 sui-J.ago rcu:plex
l2Sd ca::um Santiago Fi::1--"l)lcx
U2 C&:o!zlo Sa.'ttiago SL-.g l e-!'ll::lily
124 ea..-.itlo San::iago S!ngle-r=i.ly
U6a c=ir.o s.ntiAc;o 1':,urplcx
U6b Q::iz,o Ssntia90 rc,,,.-;,lcx
U6c: adzlo Sa.-:ti.oc;<> Ft:uQlex
126d c:::i:lo s.nwc;o R:u.."j>lex
uo <:=i:,o s.intiago Sir.g le-Fuily
114 Cl::izlo Santiago Sir.gle-f'll::lil y
~'l'St'.M'AAYQOOlT
u.s PtJCrn\S IU:S!Ilnt:'L\L CO'.ro.i."\D
!'LU>. ll!:./0/lE
"""" = Co:nt
(Sa.Ft.] l'It't31-i!ed..-ccr.:s•a.,._~_. l
~ 4-2-l.S
9H 4-2-l.S
94 ◄ ,4•2-l.S
l,lU s-2-2
897 s-2-1
839 4-l-l
l,Ol 6-l-2
,l,072 q7,,. ◄-2-2
1,099 4- 2•2
1,095:, • S-2-1
9ll 4-2-l
932 s-2-1
l,lSl 4•2- 1
1,064 s- 2-2
92' . 4-2-l
"' 3-2-1
"' 3-2-1
12s ◄-2 -1
1,029 1/(,. • :, 4-2-2
i,012 4-2-2
1,052 4-2-2
1,179 ◄ -2-2
1,356 6- 2- 2
1,10s· 'i't. S-2-1
1, 152 S-2-2
944 • 9. •-2- r
676 )-2-1
676 ) - 2- 1
944 4-2- 1
1,219 s- 2-2
1,15) ◄-2-2
690 l · l-1
690 l-1-1
690 l-1-1
690 3- 1- l
l,259 s-2-2
/ ·1,318 4-2- 2
>= l'!:-s.l O::,,,,,C,,-:..:;
26 - :, ...,,---
25
26
16
26
26 ~tic::1 l9U
~ P.a::cccl~--.cv.>eed 1962
=.o,,n ·Renc-,..,.tcd 1957, R<:l:a2.led l956
~ .lc:'>.orwn ~...t.cd 1962. l'.a:lcdeled l9!6
~.Jc-.orwn ;la:o:!el~"'= 1952
~ '-<m:x!c.l~to:119'2
~J<no,n ;,a:,oeel.~ad 1962
20
("10
25
26
26
26
25
25
18
18
~.lc-.o,,n ts--~ted et!e<:ti\'9 ~ 20-lS yn.
25
19
l9
1.9119 ,.., I ?..,,~
}.9
~.Ja,o..., 1:sti:atcd c!tec-.J.,.. -~ 20-2.S yn.
it1~ h
~f ...~/
21
18 • ·~
l7 J'J'
Figure 5: iPhone image of c.1988 Plaza del Monte appraiser report
referenced at April 24, 2018 hea ring.
:
~..., Aerial 1: Portion of February 28, 1968 aerial photograph. Source: NMDOT -
02_28_68_0021.
(0 Aerial 2: Portion of February 27, 1969 aerial photograph. Source: NM DOT - 1969_2_27_ 4071.
Aerial 3: Portion of May 11, 1973 aerial photograph showing 118 Camino Santiago under
construction. Source: NMDOT- 05-11-73_0053.
PLAZA DEL MONTE
Santa Fe, New Mexico
Historic Resources Evaluation
Second Amendment to March 28, 2018 Report
May 17, 2018
Client: Wayne S. Uoyd, A.I.A.
Lloyd and Associates, Architects
100 N Guadalupe Street, # 201
Santa Fe, NM 87501
Consultant: John W. Murphey
Architectural Historian
2833 Plaza Verde
Santa Fe, NM 87507
Introduction
This second amendment addresses issues the Historic Districts Review Board brought up at the
April 24, 2018 hearing, information requested by the City of Santa Fe Historic Preservation
Division after that hearing, and additional comments made by the Board at the follow-up May
17, 2018 hearing.
Retaining Walls: 124 and 126 A Camino Santiago
David Rasch, the case manager for the project, communicated to the applicant after the April
24 hearing that the retaining walls of the two units granted demolition by the Board required
documentation.
On May 3, 2018, the consultant recorded the retaining walls at 124 and 126 A Camino Santiago
(the combined garage/carport structure), associated with the two units granted demolition.
Both units include low concrete-and-stone walls which work as retaining walls and/or
transitions between building pads.
The wall for 126 A retains the dirt between the apartment building (126) and the parking stalls.
It is constructed of non-reinforced concrete, mixed with heavy stones most likely taken from
the adjacent arroyo (Figure 1).
The wall is erected over a concrete walkway and stands approximately 32" above the sidewalk
and 14" above the contained earth. The 10"-thick structure presents an angled face similar to a
dam. It is topped with rounded concrete coping. The wall runs the length of the parking
structure before tapering to the ground on the west and rising above grade to the east as a
pathway entry.
A wall of similar composition but of lesser height edges the south and east exposures of the
back yard of 124 Camino Santiago (Figure 2). It begins at 9½" above grade at the patio, and
continues in a northerly direction, ranging between 18" to 26" above inside grade. Near the
northeast tangent, it connects with another wall erected with the construction of 122 Camino
Santiago.
Based on aerial photographs, neither the 124 nor 126 A retaining walls predate the
construction of their associated units. And while this fact is inconclusive, neither wall is visible
on the February 28, 1968 aerial photograph (Aerial 2). The retaining walls are apparent on a
1
February 27, 1969 photograph, indicating the completion of the units and their landscaping
(Aerial 3).
Given their low architectural value, and assumed c.1968+ construction date, neither is
recommended for Contributing Structure status to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District.
Additional Walls
As stated in the Historic Resources Evaluation, the Plaza del Monte landscape includes a
number of retaining walls. The retaining walls, constructed of formed concrete or concrete and
stone, were built over several phases, dating generally between 1950 and 1973. The walls were
constructed to retain earth or to separate building pads (Figure 3). Very few of them rise above
grade. A few lots have above-ground property line walls. These are made of stucco-clad
concrete masonry units (Figure 4). From aerial photographs, both retaining and property line
walls appear to post-date the construction of their associated units.
Given their recent date of construction and utilitarian quality, the retaining and property walls
are not recommended for individual or collective Contributing Structure status to the
Downtown and Eastside Historic District.
Aerial Imagery
To address the Board's concern over the lack of c.1968-69 aerial imagery for the west side of
Plaza del Monte, the consultant approached the NM DOT seeking additional photographs after
the April 24 hearing.
The head of aerial photography, Alane Wainwright, confirmed in an April 30 email to the
consultant that the February 27, 1969 aerial (1969_02_27_4072) presented in the Historic
Resources Evaluation represented the end of the flight line. The email supported her January
17, 2018 communication, which asserted that the image was all that the NM DOT could offer.
Wainwright explained in that email that the image didn't "get the entire area."1
However, given the importance of the case, Wainwright performed an additional due-diligence
search and found three 1968-69 era photographs that are not available to the public. 2 These
1 Alane Wainwright, email communication to John Murphey, January 17, 2018. See chain of communication in
Appendix A.
2 Ibid., April 30, 2018.
2
include two secondary images from the February 27, 1969 flight and one from February 28,
1968. Wainwright additionally provided several photographs from May 1973.
Both the 1968 and 1969 aerials show the southwest quadrant of Plaza del Monte to be
populated with only two structures: 124 and 126 Camino Santiago (Aerials 2 & 3).
The newly revealed aerial photographs present a strong case that only a handful of units were
fully completed by February 28, 1968. The 1973 image shows most of the units finished, and
118 Camino Santiago still in the framing stage (Aerial 4).
At the follow-up May 15, 2018 hearing, member Powell expressed suspicion over the fact that
additional aerial photographs had surfaced after the initial hearing. The consultant includes
with this amendment the entire email communication with NMDOT's Alane Wainwright. The
communications on January 16, January 17, April 26, April 30 and May 1 are specific to this
subject (Appendix A).
Construction Dates
At the April 24, 2018 hearing, a few members of the Board expressed apprehension about the
report's assigned construction dates. The dates were premised on the consultant's
methodology which used various sources (primarily aerial photographs, city directory entries,
and architectural drawings), to arrive at a relative - though most often accurate - "circa" date
of construction.
Sowing confusion was mention of a 1988 appraiser's estimate of dates introduced during sworn
testimony. This information was neither viewed by the Board nor officially introduced into the
record.
Given the Board's questioning, the consultant reviewed the sources again, examined the 1988
appraiser's estimates, and evaluated the additional aerial photographs recently made available.
This analysis is presented in Table 1.
At the follow-up hearing, member Powell continued to question the dates of construction
provided by the consultant, pointing to differing years he found on the Santa Fe County
Assessor's parcel map website, from his cellphone during the hearing. The consultant had
already discarded the county's dates as being mostly inaccurate, as noted in the Table of
Surveyed Resources in the March 28 report. But given Powell's insistence, the consultant
reviewed the assessor's dates again on May 17, and identifies the errors in the county's
3
Address
estimates in Table 2. In general, the county's dates do not comport with evidence found on
aerial photographs.
At conclusion of both exercises, the consultant believes that the Historic Resources Evaluation's
assigned dates of construction are mainly accurate. The consultant, however, because of timing
issues, did not get to review additional material that may have surfaced at the Santa Fe
Presbyterian church library or the Menaul facility.
Table 1: Year of Construction
Year Built* Date of Drawings 1988 Appraiser's Consultant's Original Source and Justification
Estimate** and/or Revised
Estimate ***
CAMINO SANTIAGO
101 c.1967-68 Unknown 1968 c.1967-68 Aerial photographs and first city
directory
102 c.1965 Kenneth S. Clark & 1962 Before 1966 May 2, 1966 aerial photograph and first
R-2 Philippe Register, Appraiser assigns city directory entry
assumed address to
Camino Matias
103 c.1965 Philippe Register 1968 Before 1966 May 2, 1966 aerial photograph and first
R-12 1962 city directory entry
105 1971 Register, Ross & Burnet 1962 1971 Does not ai;rnear on either Ma'i 2, 1966
R-14 1970 or February 27, 1969 aerial photographs
Drawing, aerial photographs and first
city directory entry
106 c.1965 Kenneth S. Clark & 1962 Before 1966 May 2, 1966 aerial photograph and first
R-3 Philippe Register, Appraiser assigns city directory entry
assumed address to
Camino Matias
109 c.1965 Philippe Register 1963 Before 1966 May 2, 1966 aerial photograph and first
R-15 1963 city directory entry
110 c.1962/ Kenneth S. Clark 110: 1962 110: c.1962 Drawings, aerial photographs and first
(112) c.1968 1962, original house; 112:1968 112: c.1968 city directory entries
R-5 Register, Ross &
Burnet, addition
111 c.1965 Philippe Register Unknown; Before 1966 Drawings, aerial photographs and first
1963 remodeled, 1962 city directory entry
113 c.1970 Unknown 1970 c.1970 Does not appear on February 27, 1969
Appraiser assigns aerial photograph
address as 115 a
Drawings and first city directory entry
4
Address Year Built* Date of Drawings 1988 Appraiser's Consultant's Original Source and Justification
Estimate** and/or Revised
Estimate ***
114 c.1972 Register, Ross & Burnet 1971 c.1972 Does not appear on Februar:y 27, 1969
R-26 1971 aerial photograph
Drawings and first city direct_9ry entry
115 c.1970 Unknown 1970 c.1970 Does not appear on Februar:y 27, 1969
aerial photograph
First city directory entry
117 1966-67 Philippe Register Unknown; 1966-67 May 2, 1966 aerial photograph and first
1965;1966 estimated 1963- city directory entry
1968
118 c.1973 Register, Ross & Burnet 1972 1973 Does not appear on Februar:y 27, 1969
1971 aerial photograph
Register & Burnet
1972 Drawings and first city directory entry
119 c.1965 Philippe Register 1963 Before 1966 May 2, 1966 aerial photograph and first
1965/1968 city directory entry
120 C. 1971 Register, Ross & Burnet 1970 c.1971 Does not appear on Februar:y 27, 1969
R-25 1970 aerial photograph
Drawings and first city directory entry
121 c.1971 Register, Ross & Burnet 1970 c.1971 Does not appear on Februar:y 27, 1969
R-20 1970 aerial photograph
Drawings and first city directory entry
122 c.1971 Register, Ross & Burnet Unknown; c.1971 Does not appear on Februar:y 27, 1969
1967 estimated 1963- aerial photograph
1968
First city directory entry
124 c.1968 Philippe Register 1964 c.1967 Does not appear on May 2, 1966 aerial
R-23 1967 photograph .
125 c.1970 Register, Ross & Burnet 1969 c.1970 Does not appear on February 27, 1969
R-21 1969 aerial ph otograph
Drawings and first city directory entry
126 c.1968 Philippe Register 1967 c.1967 Drawings, aerial photographs and first
R-24 1967 city directory entry
126 c.1968/ Unknown No covered c.1968/ Drawings and April 9, 1975 aerial
Garage 1977 1977 photograph
CAMINO MATIAS
104 c.1965 Kenneth S. Clark & 1962 Before 1966 May 2, 1966 aerial photograph
Philippe Register,
assumed;
Philippe Register
1963, alteration
5
Address -i veO, BUiit•r Date olDrawlngs
I --- I
105 ! 1950 ! Unknown
R-10 --'~-- - - -~!---- ---
107 1950 Unknown
• R-9
109
R-8
111
R-6
I iiG/120-
R-7
Key:
__ I__ ··-·-· - - .
1950
Pre-1960,
moved to
site
Pre-1957,
with c.1984
additions
I Unknown
Unknown
---
Unknown;
Philippe Register and
Associates
1984
1988 Appraiser's
Estimate**
Unknown;
remodeled 1962
Unknown;
remodeled 1962
Unknown;
remodeled 1962
Unknown;
remodeled 1962
- ----
110: Unknown;
renovated 1967;
remodeled 1986
120: remodeled/
Renovated 1962
Consultant's Original
and/or Revised
Estimate ***
1950
1950
l 1950
I
;
Pre-1960,
moved to site
Pre-1957,
with c.1984
additions
---~·----------- ----
Source and Justification
-
Carolyn Atkins, The Allison-James
Picture Book, 1866-1959, (Albuquerque:
Menaul Historical Library of the
Southwest, 1983), 25; aerial
photographs
Carolyn Atkins, The Allison-James
Picture Book, 1866-1959, (Albuquerque:
Menaul Historical Library of the
Southwest, 1983), 25; aerial
photographs -- ---·-------
Carolyn Atkins, The Allison-James
Picture Book, 1866-1959, (Albuquerque:
Menaul Historical Library of the
Southwest, 1983), 25; aerial
photographs
Aerial photographs
--
Drawings and aerial photographs
*The year the consultant originally estimated, as presented in March 28, 2018, Plaza del Monte, Santa Fe, Historic Resources Evaluation
report.
** Taken from "As of 1988" table of appraiser's estimate of construction dates. The table was referenced in sworn testimony during the
April 24, 2018, Historic Districts Review Board hearing. The Board did not see the table nor was it introduced in the record. The consultant
took an iPhone image of the table at the hearing (Figure 5).
*** The consultant's original and/or revised estimate based on best sources available, including dated aerial photographs, dated
architectural drawings and dated city directory entries, and previously unavailable February 28, 1968 and February 27, 1969 aerial
photographs, NMDOT provided to consultant on April 30, 2018.
6
Table 2: Santa Fe County Assessor Dates
Address Consultant's Original Santa Fe County
and/or Revised Assessor Estimate* *
Estimate*
CAMINO SANTIAGO
101
102
R-2
103
R-12
105
R-14
f 106
R-3
109
R-15
110
(112)
R-5
111
113
114
R-26
115
117
118
119
120
R-25
c.1967-68
Before 1966
Before 1966
1971
Before 1966
Before 1966
110: c.1962
112: c.1968
Before 1966
c.1970
c.1972
c.1970
1966-67
1973
Before 1966
C. 1971
1964
1964
1964
1964
1964
1964
1969
No Date Provided
1964
No Date Provided
1964
1964
1969
1968
Errors with County Estimated Dates
Does not appear on May 2, 1966 aerial photograph
Only May 2, 1966 aerial photograph available for the period
Does not appear on May 2, 1966 aeria l photograph
Does not appear on either May 2, 1966 or February 27, 1969 aerial
photographs
Only May 2, 1966 aerial photograph available fo r the period
Only May 2, 1966 ae rial photograph available for the period
Appears on May 2, 1966 aerial photograph
Does not appear on either May 2, 1966 or February 27, 1969 aerial
photographs
Does not appear on either May 2, 1966 or February 27, 1969 aerial
photographs
Only May 2, 1966 aerial photograph available for the period
Does not appear on February 27, 1969 aeria l photograph ; still under
construction on May 3, 1973 aerial photograph
Appears on May 2, 1966 aeria l photograph
Does not appear on February 27, 1969 aeria l photograph
7
Address
121
R-20
122
124
R-23
125
R-21
126
R-24
126
Garage
Consultant's Original
and/or Revised
Estimate*
c.1971
c.1971
c.1967
c.1970
c.1967
c.1968/
1977
CAMINO MATIAS
104
105
R-10
107
R-9
109
R-8
111
Before 1966
1950
1950
1950
Pre-1960,
R-6 moved to site
116/120 Pre-1957,
R-7 with c.1984 additions
Key:
Santa Fe County
Assessor Estimate* *
1969
1968
1968
No Date Provided
No Date Provided
No Date Provided
1968
1964
1964
1964
1969
No Date Provided
Errors with County Estimated Dates
Does not ai;rnear on Februari'. 27, 1969 aerial photograph
Does not appear on February 27, 1969 aerial photograph
Appears on Mai'. 2, 1966 aerial photograph
Documented as constructed in 1950 in Caroli'.n Atkins, The Allison-James
Picture Book, 1866-1959, (Albuquerque: Menaul Historical Li brari'. of the
Southwest, 1983), 25, and appears on 1951 aeria l photograph
Documented as constructed in 1950 in Caroli'.n Atkins, The Allison-James
Picture Book, 1866-1959, (Albuquerque: Menaul Historical Library of t he
Southwest, 1983), 25, and appears on 1951 aerial photograph
Documented as constructed in 1950 in Caroli'.n Atkins, The Allison-James
Picture Book, 1866-1959, (Albuquerque : Menaul Historical Library of the
Southwest. 1983}, 25, and appears on 1951 aerial photograph
Appears on Mai'. 2, 1966 aerial ph otograph
* The consultant's original and/or revised estimate based on best sources available, including dated aerial photographs, dated architectural
drawings and dated city directory entries, and previously unavailable February 28, 1968 and February 27, 1969 aerial photographs, NMDOT
provided to consultant on April 30, 2018, and additional review of images after May 15 hearing.
** Dates as taken from Santa Fe County Assessor parcel map (http://assessor.santafecountynm.gov/map.php) on May 17, 2018. Webpage
states the information was accurate as of April 3, 2018.
8
Figures and Aerial Photographs
Figure 1: 126 A Camino Santiago, Garage/Carport Structure, retaining wall, May 3, 2018.
9
Figure 2: 124 Camino Santiago, rear retaining wall, May 3, 2018.
10
Figure 3: c.1950 concrete retaining in front of 107 Camino Matias. January 18, 2018.
11
Figure 4: Stucco-on-block property wall between 114 and 118 Camino Santiago,
January 18, 2018.
12
....w
rt
!:!!:.ll-l
R-2
R-3
R-4
R-Sa
R-Sb
_g-6
G.~ -R-7a
- R-7b
R-8
R-9
R-10
R-ll
a-u
R-l4a
Jl-l4b
R-14c
R-l4d
Q..P a-is
R-16
R-17a
R-17b
R-18
1) fi -R-19
tii ~·~ a:..20
"'fl,.~- R-2la
R-21b
R-2lc
R-2ld
R-22
R-23
R-24a
R-24b"
R-24c
R-24d
R-25
>'Ill,- -R-26
i .?...
St.reetlddress
104 CDmino Matias
102 Camino Matias
106 Camino Matias
118 Camino Santiago
110 Clllnizlo Matias
112 Cimino Matias
lll CDmino Matias
.11, 0maiJlo Matias
120 Cimino Matias
109 Cimino Mlltias
107 0llldno Mlltias
10S OmliJlo Hlltias
101 0llldno Sam:iago
103 0lrnirlo Send.ago
105a Camillo Santiago
l0Sb Candn:I Santiago
105c 0lmim Santiago
1054 0mino Santi&9)
109 0llldno Santiago
1ll 0lrnirlo Santiago
ll5a 0llll1no Sllnt:iago
ilSb 0llllina Send.ago
117 01mim Santiago
·119 Clmlino Santiago
121 01mim Sllntiago
l.25a 0slllil1o Santiago
125b 0llll1no Santiago
125c Clllllino Santiago
125d emwx, Santiago
m 0llldm Santiago
124 01mim sand.ago
126a 0slllil1o Santiago
126b c:amillO Santiago
126c OUni.no Sllntiago
126d Caminl) Slnt:iago
120c-in0Sant:i490
.114 'caminO Sandago
,weof l)lellln<:r
S!agl.e-&iily
Siagl.e-!lunily
Singl.e-hmly
Sia<Jle-hmily
Duplex
Duplex
Single-Pamily
Duplex
Dlplex
S.in9le-PamilY
S!ng-le-Fuiily
SJng~~:t.
SJngle-Pamily
Single-Family
~~
Fcuzplex
Single-Palaily
Single-Family
Duplex
Diplex
Sia<Jle-Falaily
Single-Flmily
SiJl9le-Family
Fcurplex
ftlu:plelC
Fcurplex
ftlu:plex
Sia<J:le-Falllily
Single-hmily
Fcurplex
FcurplelC
FcurplelC
FcNXplelC
SiJl9le-Family
Si119le-Fllmily
......... -.
'lMP1!0VEl£WJ' S1ttNY awrr
US PIACrnlS IIESDlElll'IAL CXHC10ND
~ DE[.KJN'l'E
Area
(Ser.Ft.)
944
944
RoanCcmlt
(Total•Bedroc:ms•Baths l
944
1,141
897
839
1,433
,1,on q~,4
1t_o9.. 9C . J.,!!ff.:)
932
1,ffl
1,0&4
926
699
699
,26
1,029_ II(,, . (,
'1;082
1,052
1,179
1,356
1,105~· 'i''-
!,lSl
"944•9;;:
676
676
944
1,218
1,153
690
690
690
690
1,2S9
1,318 /• ••• '• '
4-2·1,5
4-2-1.5
,4-2-1.5
s-2-2
s-2-1
4-1-1
6-3-2
4-2-2
4-2-2
• s-2-1
4-2-1·
s-2-1
4-2-l
s-2-2
, 4-2-1
3-2-1
3-2-1
4-2-1
4-2-2
4-2-2
4-2-2
4-2•2
6-2-2
s-2-1
s-2-2
-.-=2-r
3-2-l •
3"t'l
4-2-l
s-2-2
4-2-2
3-1-1
3-1-1
3-l-l
3-l-l
s-2-2
4•2-2
llae lYrs.l C'aments
2&-1Q:;:;--fi , <,-'
26
16
26
26
lllllmcwn
lrlkl10III
llnlaic,wn
llnlaic,wn
llnlcllcwll
Qila,awn
20
'21t
26
26
26
26
2S
2S
18
18
Ol1lalcwn
2S
18
Addition 1968
~tel! 1962
•llanc:,vated 1967, l!ma!eled 1986
llemuated 1962, Rm0deled 1986
~i:ed 1962
Rmr:delec!/11emMat:ed 1962
~tee! 1962
(:· -
Estilllated effective &138 20-25 yrs.
t!J19 ..... 'f~9
}.9
llnlcno«I Estiin&ted effective 1199 20-2S yrs.
21~
21\., ""t., t,._,.
~I •.:-
~ I
Figure 5: iPhone image of c.1988 Plaza del Monte appraiser report
referenced at April 24, 2018 hearing.
13
:
Aerial 1: Portion of May 2, 1966 aerial photograph. Source: NMDOT - 05-02-66_0015.
14
ft,-., Aerial 2: Portion of February 28, 1968 aerial photograph. Source: NMDOT -
02_28_68_0021.
15
(C Aerial 3: Portion of February 27, 1969 aerial photograph. Source: NM DOT - 1969_2_27_4071.
16
Aerial 4: Portion of May 11, 1973 aerial photograph showing 118 Camino Santiago under
construction. Source: NMDOT- 05-11-73_0053.
17
Santa Fe, New Mexico 87504
• REFERENCE: Appraisal Report
Plaza del Monte Retirement Ccmnunity
417 Paseo de Peralta
Santa Fe, New .Mexico _
Dear Mr. and Mrs. Friesenborg:
Attached is our report containing our conclusions of market value fran the
inspection of the above referenced property. OUr analysis indicated the
values of the property under the valuation criteria outlined in the report
are as follc:::Ms:
EFFEx:TIVE DATE:
1. Casa Grande Tract, at its
market supported Highest
and Best Use (Land Value)
,.. 2. Casa Grande Tract, as a
\~,l,.;..~ P congrega~e. care retire-
.•:·.::· ''<l"¼ment facility
, . . ',.;·.. Non-Profit
•4\. For-Profit
. ·..:~:·-~
1[t t , 3. las Placitas Tract, at its
}}_i;\\': ,/),J market supported Highest
X\ , '-r t)'j and Best Use (Land Value)), ,. .. · • Pv
'.:;lit;;
February 11, 1988
Present Value, Future Sale,
Market Value 'Iwo Y:ears Four Y:ears
$1,350,000
$ 400,000 .
$ 350,000
$1 , 275,000
$1,100,000
$ 325,000
$ 275,000
$1,000,000
$ 850,000
$ 250,000
$ 225,000
$ 800,000
i
!,;
'
:t
1~]: :~
:~
ill'. ;~
1,i,pi..--------------------------:---1 !~REAL ESTATE APPRAISERS AND CONSULTANTS 209 E. MARCY. SANTA FE, NEW MEXICO 87501 (505) 982-1262 '"
1:
.
' "..... ..)
'•...
·'.Jl
Property:
Location:
Client:
Land Area:
Net Usable land Area:
Casa Grande Tract
Ias Placitas Tract
Present Use:
Highest and Best Use:
Casa Grande Tract
Ias Placitas Tract
Date of Valuation:
Value Conclusions:
casa Grande Tract
Ias.Placitas Tract
SUMMARY OF SALIENI' FACI'S
Plaza del Mlnte Retirement camnmity
417 Paseo de Peralta
Board of Pensions
Presbyterian Church (USA)
9.146 acres
2.826 acres
5.802 acres
Retirement Carmunity
Speculative holding for ccmnercial
developnent .
Residential developnent, interim use
as residential rental canpound
February 11, 1988
Total Property (Plaza del Monte)
$1,350,000
$1,275,000
$2,625,000
DOI\NELL
DON\JELLAND ftSSOCIATES
·.,·.x.· r-li ~-
. -~-. •'
,,: _·; ·!
·•1
.......
'1}
•<:·
',i.
•?~~
.:,.
c:~•·
'jj
: l~ ••
. .'·;· ••
)
-
Neighborhocxl Developnent
Neighborhocxl developnent is mixed. 'Iwo fraternal organizations, the
Scottish Rite Temple and Ma.sonic Iooge, front on Paseo de Peralta. A
large local law office occupies a converted school dormitory on the north
side of the Masonic Iooge. The Plaza del Monte retirement ccmnunity, a
mix of a cxmgregate living facility, freestanding dwellings, and
aparbnents, borders Fort Marcy Park on the north and fronts on Paseo de
Peralta and Old Taos Highway on the southwest. There are several single
family residences fronting on Bishop's Iooge Road between the Scottish
Rite Temple and Plaza del Monte.
Developnent :imnediately south of Paseo de Peralta is a Federal Office
c~lex including the Federal Courthouse, Post Office and other federal
go\rernment offices. Developnent in the northwest quadrant of Paseo de
Per~lta and.Old Taos Highway consists of small professional offices in the
BCD. zoning district. Fort Marcy Park, a-large City operated recreational
canplex approximately 27 acres in size, includes playing fields, a
swinming pool/gymnasium canplex, a small ampitheater, tennis oourts,
jogging .trails and operi space, and a City fire station. North of Fort
Marcy Park, east of Bishop's lodge Road, and northwest of the neighborhood
is a mix of single and multiple family residential developnent.
Zoning
Zoning in the neighborhood is RM-2, Multiple Family Residential District,
and C-1, Office and Related Camtercial District. The zoning of the 2.697+
acre parcel currently occupied by the Masonic Lodge and the White, Koch, -
Kelly and McCarthy law offices was changed in 1984 £ran RM-2 to C-1.
lks \~
Zoning south of Faseo de Peralta and west of Old Taos Highway is BCD,
Business Capitol District, Marcy Subdistrict. Zoning west of Bishop's
Io:lge Road is :RM-1, Multiple Family Residential District. Zoning north
and northwest of the neighborhood is Single and Multiple Family
Residential {R-3, R-4, R-5 and RM-1).
Caranunity Services .
All carmunity services are available and adequate. Utility suppliers are
discussed in the Santa Fe Profile. Police and fire protection are typical
for Santa Fe.
Conclusions
The subject neighborhood is a mixed-use area on the northern fringe of the
Santa Fe Central Business District. The area is well located and
accessible and no detrimental influences have been observed. Please refer
to the Santa Fe and Central Business District profiles in the addenda to
the report for additional information.
6 DOI\NELL
DON\JELLAND~OCIATES
... ,
I
Detrimental Influences
The primary detriment to developnent is the drainage easement for Arroyo
Mascaras in the northwest comer of the site. The arroyo is four or more
feet below street grade of Old Taos Highway and the drainage is supported
by a stone retaining wall. Although we have not been able to document the
drainage easement, according to Onnand Farp, City Engineer, the easement
was acquired :in the original 1901 U.S.ipatent to the City of Santa Fe
and/or by a proscriptive easement as a natural drainageway. The drainage
is maintained by the City and we assume the easement to be legally
supported. The calculated area of the easement is .519 acres, or 22,608±
sq.ft., leaving a net usable area of 8.627+ acres. All of the encumbered
area is in the Ias Placitas tract. Net usable area of Ias Placitas tractI
is 5.. 802 acres (6.321 - .519), or 252,735+ sq.ft.
Witli' the exception of the drainage channel, there are no Jmown detrimental
influences on the property. There have been no problems with soil or
subsoil conditions on the subject or adjacent properties and the site is
assumed to have adequate load bearing capability for the existing or any
proposed developnent. Drainage is adequate. There are no other knCMn
restrictive or atypical easements. The property is in an architecturally
controlled historic disμict.
Zoning
The property is zon~ltiple Family Residential District. The
intent of the zoning~rovide for single-family, two-family and
multiple-family residences and related developnents. The existing
improvements are in confonnance with the zoning. Zoning and potential
zoning changes are discussed more fully in the Highest and Best Use
section of the report.
Utilities
All public utilities are available and in place on the site.
Conclusions
The subject site is a well located property on the northern fringe of the
downtatm Central Business District of Santa Fe. The site has access and
visibility £ran three arterial streets. With the exception of the
previously discussed drainage easeneit, the site is not affected by any
knCMn nuisances or hazards.
I
8 DOf\NELL
DQN\JELLAND ftSSOCIATES
cwza
1t'
'·.;
·\
i,
,..
h
i
I
··;-•·.
IMPROVEMENT DESCRIPI'ION
At the time of inspection, the subject property was .improved with the
Plaza del Monte retirement cannunity. The canplex consists of Casa
Grande, a congregate living facility in the southwest portion of the site,
and Las Placitas, a residential canpound of 41 dwelling units in the
northern portion of the site. Please refer to the.reduced copies of
construction plans and photographs in the addenda to the report for visual
representation of the improvements. Improvement features are briefly
outlined as follc:Ms:
Casa Grande
Architecture:
Building Area:
Floor Plan:
Foundation:
Floors:
Walls:
Roof:
Pueblo style, stuccoed masonry
construction.
Gross heated building area has been
calculated at 28,428 sq.ft. £ran the
building plans.
The floor plan consists of one main
ccmnon use facility and four residential
wings. Cannon use facilities include a
lobby/reception area, lounge, shop,
kitchen and dining roan, employee lounge
and sleeping quarters, public restroans,
and manager's office. There are three
dormitory-style dwelling wings with one
and two bedroan m1i ts. One wing has been
converted to four two-bedroan apartments.
Reinforced concrete.
Concrete slab on steel joists. There is
a crawl space under the majority of the
building. •
All interior and exterior load-bearing
walls are concrete block. Interior
portions are steel frame and drywall.
Three-inch concrete on steel joists.
Roofing is built-up and graveled asphalt
over one-half inch rigid insulation.
9 f"'\r\l\. ~ICI I
.,
'·.'
'·
I
h
i
I
IMPROVEMENT DESCRIPl'ION
At the time of inspection, the subject property was improved with the
Plaza del ~nte retirement ccmnunity. The canplex consists of Casa
Grande, a congregate living facility in the southwest portion of the site,
and Las Placitas, a residential canpound of 41 dwelling units in the
northern portion of the site. Please refer to the.reduced copies of
construction plans and photographs in the addenda to the report for visual
representation of the improvements. Improvement features are briefly
outlined as follows:
casa Grande
Architecture:
Building Area:
Floor Plan:
Foundation:
Floors:
Walls:
Roof:
Pueblo style, stuccoed masonry
construction.
Gross heated building area has been
calculated at 28,428 sq.ft. fran the
building plans.
The floor plan consists of one main
a::mnon use facility and four residential
wings. Ccnmon use facilities include a
lobby/reception area, lounge, shop,
kitchen and dining roan, employee lounge
and sleeping quarters, public restroans,
and manager's office. There are three
donnitory-style dwelling wings with one
and two bedroan writs. One wing has been
converted to four two-bedroan aparbnents.
Reinforced concrete.
Concrete slab on steel joists. There is
a crawl space under the majority of the
building.
All interior and exterior load-bearing
walls are concrete block. Interior
portions are steel frame and drywall.
Three-inch concrete on steel joists.
Roofing is built-up and graveled asphalt
over one-half inch rigid insulation.
9
• : ,i ~
.·;
...· .;,
Interior Finish:
Electrical:
Pltnnbing:
Mechanical systems:
Site Improvanents:
,,
Floor covering is a mix of carpeting and
vinyl asbestos tile. Walls are painted
and stuccoed. Ceilings are painted
drywall and acoustic tile. There are
ceramic tile floors and wall covering in
the kitchen and wainscotting in the baths
is ceramic tile. 'Ihe ceilings in the
dining roan and lounge are exposed beams.
Assmned to be adequate and to code.
Fluorescent and incandescent lighting
fixtures.
The donnitory style dwelling wings have
one toilet and lavatory per roan. Seven
units have been rerodeled to add bath or
shower facilities. The donnitory style
wings also have ocmoon bath, shower and
laundry facilities. The remodeled apart-
ment wing has one full bath, two half
baths and kitchen facilities per apart-
ment. The cannon use facility has men's
and wanen' s public restroans, men's and
wanen's employee baths, and the kitchen
is plumbed for ocmnercial food prepar-
ation. The employee lounge and sleeping
roans have full baths.
Heat is fran a gas-fired hot water
baseboard system. The heating systen was
separated fran the danestic hot water
system in 1987. Danestic hot water is
nCM heated by six 100-gallon gas water
heaters. There is no air conditioning
system. A new kitchen ventilating system
was installed in 1987. •
..
Site improvements associated with casa
Grande include extensive landscaping,
concrete walks, paved parking and drives,
a 378+ sq.ft. greenhouse adjacent to the
north- residential wing, and covered
parking fran a six-car carport, one
two-car garage and one one-car garage.
10 DOI\NELL
DON\JELLAND ASSOCIATES
...
Carments:
The original Casa Grande structure was built in 1962. The north
residential wing was built in 1973 and was converted to two-bedroan
apartments in 1977. The improvements are well maintained and in good
condition. No deferred maintenance was observed.
Changes not shown on the attached plans include:
* Two of the donnito.ry style apartments in the north-central wing have
been convert~ to an activity roan.
* Showers have been added to four dormitory style roans and baths have
been added to an additional three roans.
* Interior doors have been added to convert four sets of adjacent one
bedroan units to two-roan units.
* The greenhouse, six-car carport and two-car garage have been added.
* A walk-in cooler was added to the kitchen in March, 1988.
An eμiergy conservcltion study was prepared for the building in 1986.
Improvements made pursuant to the study have been:
* The heating and danestic hot water systems are nCM independent. A new
heating system boiler and six 100-gallon danestic hot water heaters were
installed in 1986.
* Stonn windCMs were installed in 1986.
* A new.kitchen ventilation system was installed in 1987.
The study also called for a tempered fresh air system for the aparbnents.
The system was scheduled .for 1989.
The main ccmoon use building is functional in design and of average
appeal. The kitchen is a well designed and equipped cx:mnercial quality
facility. The dining roan and lowige area are of superior quality finish
to the remainder of the structure.
The apartments in the remcx:leled north wing are average quality r~tal
wiits and typical of the local rental market. The donnitory style
dwelling units are sanewhat institutional in design and of limited appeal
by current market standards. The two bedroan apartments in the north wing
contain approximately 1·,070 sq.ft. apiece. The one-roan donnitory style
apartments oontain 249+ sq.ft. and the two-rcx:m apartments contain 498+·
sq.ft.
DOf\NELL
DON\IELLAND ASSOCIATES
• !J :
.·_..-;_ :.
. .:; \
.•. ~
.! I
,• I
·, i
•. t
.
'•:' ~
;. ~-
.• s
. !·
. ~
\: ~:-. ;.
•. '•.•:1. )
0
•. \
\
.i.
I
• \
... !
·)· i
{i l
: )'
·: '·r ··t
._: !
'
The Casa Grande facility is of good to average quality construction. The
structure has been weli maintained and is in good condition. Although
there have been llltprovernents and upgrading, the design of the structure,
particularly the donnitory maparbnents, is sanewhat dated. Actual
age of the base structure i 26 ears, and the addition was built 13 years
ago and rarodeled four years ter. We estimate.effective age of the
inprovanents to be approximately 25 years.
las Placitas
The las Placitas canpound consists of 37 dwelling units in 25 structures.
The unit mix is 19 single-family dwellings, three duplexes, and three ..
fourplexes.· Five of the residences were existing at the time the project
was dedicated. 'llle remainder ,ot,,the dwellings were built over the
• approximate time frame ofr.;_1962 to ·1912., The existing dwellings have all
been renovated !and/or rernodrr. Following is a chart briefly outlining
th~ major design features. (IDTE: '11he I.D. number refers to the
numbering system used.on th -~it~ plan in the addenda).. . -\
I .
II t,, ,.
DOf\NELL
DON\IELLAND ASSOCIATES
so. as"··· ..
I.D. Street .Address
R-1 104 camino Matias
R-2 102 camino Matias
R-3 106 camino Matias
R-4 118 cam.ino Santiago
R-Sa 110 Cami.no Matias
R-Sb 112 cami.no Matias
ij-6 ill camino Matias,1 I -R-7a ,116 cami.no Matiasl.'11.c;
R-7b 120 cami.ru:, Matias
R-8 109 cami.no Matias
R-9 107 camino Matias
R-10 105 camino Matias
R-ll 101 Cami.no Santiago
R-12 103 Cami.no Santiago
R-l4a lOSa Camino 5antiago
R-14b lOSb Camino 5antiago
R-14c lOSc Camino 5antiago
.... e,() R-14d lOSd Camino Santiago
w R-15 109 camino Santiago
R-16 lll Cami.no Santiago
R-17a )..l.Sa Camino Santi.ago
R-17b 115b Camino Santiago
R-18 117 Cami.no Santi.ago
I)Fi -R-19 '119 Cami.no San_tiago
// s..., ""· ~ a.:.20 121 Cami.no Santiago .
.. Th..\)- R-2la 12Sa C".amino Santiago
R-2lb 125b Camino Santiago
R-2lc 125c camino Santiago
R-2ld 125d camino Santiago
R-22 122 camino Santi.ago
R-23 124 Camino Santiago
R-24a 126a Camino Santiago
R-24b· 126b c:amino Santiago
R-24c 126c cami.no Santiago
R-24d 126d Camino Santiago
R-25 120 camino Santiago
m, . R-26
- •
114 0Ulti.no Santiago
C 0. .. "'\, .. .. ----~ .... •
Type of Dwellincr
Single-Family
Single-Family
Single-Family
Single-Family
DuDlex
Duplex
Single-Family
Duplex
..• ·.-:
.A··-'·•·•.··
IMPROVEMml'SIMWlYamR'l'
US Pl'.N:ITAS RESIDENI'IAL ca-fPOOND
PLAZA DEL K)Nl'E
Area Roa1l Count
csa.Ft. l (Total-Bedrocms-Batbs)
944 4-2-1.5
944 4-2-1.5
944 ,4-2-1.S
1,141 s-2-2
897 s-2-1
839 4-1-1
1,433 6-3-2
_.l,072 q7t4 4-2-2
1,099 4-2-2Duplex
Single-Family \~ .'t;_Q'"ID • s-2-1
Single-Family 932 4-2-1·
Single-Family 932 s-2-1
Single-Family 1,163 4-2-1
Single-Family 1,064 s-2-2
Fou:r:plex 926 I 4-2-1
Fourplex 699 3-2-1
Fourplex 699 3-2-1
Fow:plex ~26 4-2-1
Single-~ly 1,029 / 1, . ~ 4-2-2
Single-Family i.;mra· ·4-2-2
Duplex 1,052 4-2-2
Duplex 1,179 \' 4-2-2
Single-Family 1,356 6-2-2
Single-Family 1,.105•·· ?i s-2-1
Single-Family .i:,~1, S-2-2
Fourplex ···944 ... ·9 ~-- --1.:2~r .
Fow:plex 676 3-2-1.
Fcurplex 676 3-2-1
Fourplex 944 4-Z:.1
Single-Family l,218 s-2-2
Single-Family 1,153 4-2-2
Fourplex 690 3-1-1
Fou.rplex 690 3-1-1
Fow:plex 690 I 3-1-1
Fourplex 690 3-1-1
Single-Family 1,259 s-2-2
Single-Family l,318 l~ ,:: ,·;.·." 4-2-2
hie (Yrs.) Cannents
26
26
26
16
26
26 Addition 1968
Unlcncwn Rsrodeled/Renovated 1962
Onkncwn ·Renovated 1967, Rem::deled 1986
Unknown Renovated 1962, Rarodeled 1986
Unknown Remodeled/Renovated 1962
Unknown Rem:deled/Jlenovated 1962
Unknown Ranodeled,IRenovated 1962
20
20
26
26
26
26
25
25
18
18
Olknown Estimated effective age 20-25 yrs.
25
18
f;J·-. ,..., / ij'(c 919
J.9
Unlcncwn Estimated effective age 20-25 yrs.
21
21
21
21
21
18
17
\
•·!,
.·A
', .. .=: ~ •
t: ..
:,; ::
.~: .
·,
\ii ·.•,..../,
...!
··. .
• I
·.:
......
:\~
..
-~-;
,:r
,\.i
•·:~
.. I
: ...
' :i.
:
•·(,
. ~ .t •
"-) ?-
:&
• \ ·, .
.;I':
•,,•
•• ._I° :, ;
•· ....
•~: :~_~:
\ . \
...
. ·•=:· 1·
·1
Site Improvements:
cannents:
Site improvements to Ias Placitas
include landscaped cxmnon area,
landscaped yards for the individual
residences, walks and drives, and two
privately owned single-lane paved
streets, Camino Matias and Camino
Santiago, approximately 20 to 25 feet in
width.
All·of the dwellings are of average quality concrete block or frame stucco
ronstruction. The dwellings have been well maintained and are in good
rondition. No deferred maintenance was observed. In general, the quality
and type of construction of the dwellings is more·twical of tract housing
than northside Santa Fe developnent cxmparable in age and location. 'Ihe
landscaping of the qanpotmd is well cared for and has strong visible
appeal.
IDT.E: Area calculations, actual age and roan counts are fran drawings
provided by our client and the project architect, Phillipe Register. We
assume these drawings to be accurate. Also, we ~ve not inspected the
interiors of all of the units. We assume that the units inspected are •
representative of the quality and condition of the canpoW'ld.
14 DCT\NEU
DON\IEUAND ASSOCIATE~
,;
it
* Interviews with the City Planner's Office as well as the property amer
and lessee of the adjacent property to the east.
* The recent zoning change on the adjacent property to the east.
The most desirable zoning for the property in terms of developnent options
would be Business Capital District, or BCD. Zoning west of Old Taos •
Highway and south of Paseo de Peralta is presently BCD, Marcy
Subdistrict. C-1, or Office and Related Catmercial District, would allow
for develop:nent with professional offices or canpatible uses. The zoning
of the adjacent property to the east was recently changed fran RM-2 to C-1.
Although in our opinion a zone change for the Ia casa Grande tract is a
reasonable expectation, it should be emphasized that there is risk
involved in any zone change application. Zoning change applications, even
with support of city staff, have been denied due to public opposition and
other political factors.
It is also our opinion that there is substantially higher risk involved in
a zone tj1ange for the las Placitas tract (estimated 6.321 acres). This
tract does not have access or visibility £ran Paseo de Peralta and
developnent to the east and west is residential. Developnent to the north
is a city park ~9ned residentially and north of the park is residential
developnent .. Op}.X)sition to a zone change for the Ias Placitas tract could
also be expected fran city staff.
At present, there is an oversupply of office and retail space, as well as
multi-family and high end ($300,000+) residential property in Santa Fe in
general and the downtown area in particular. Vacancy rates are
substantial and the market is highly canpetitive.
Developnent of an office, retail, or mixed use project on the casa Grande
tract could be ecxmanic with a strong anchor tenant and significant
pre-construction lease cxmnibnents. otherwise, an investor can expect
excessive vacancy rates and/or rent ooncessions with an office or retail
developnent. Another developnent option for this location, depending on
the scope of a potential zone change, is sane sort of lodging and/or
tourism industry project (hotel/motel, restaurant, gallery, shops, et~.).
Even with the risks associated with a zoning change and the canpetitive
cxmnercial real estate market, however, the casa· Grande tract will support
·a higher land value than a strictly residential parcel. We therefore
cx:>nclude highest and best use of the Casa Grande tract, if vacant, to be a
speculatiye holding.
16 DOI\NEL
DON\JELIAND A5SOCIATE
l.: •i:
:'\
~•-i-l
"t .,.
.~
:,
..
The dwellings on the Las Placitas tract are physically and legally
adaptable as rental housing and there is a demand for rental housing
particularly in this area of Santa Fe. We have investigated the
possibility of subdividing las Placitas and marketing the individual
units. According to the City Subdivision Engineer, it is unlikely the
tract could be legally subdivided due to the lot size, setback, and street
width and right of way requirements. The individual units could be
marketed, ho.vever as a condaninium or planned unit developnent (POD)
project with the streets and cxmnon areas the responsibility of a
haneowner's association. The incane producing capacity of Ias Placitas as
a rental ccmpound or PUD housing developnent will support value close to
or slightly above the value of the underlying land.
Although the :inprovements to the las Placitas tract have a limited
oontributocy value, we have concluded that the highest return to this
portion of the property would be fran more intensive developnent. In our
opinion, highest and best use of the las Placitas tract is future high
density residential developnent with an interim use as a residential
rental catp:>und.
18 DOf\NEU
DON\IEUAND ASSOCIATE:
Ml-\RKEI' RENT PRC>JECTION
LAS PLACITJ.\S RFSIDENTIAL COMPOUND
ID 1\ddress
R-1 104 Camino Matias
R-2 102 Cami.no Matias
R-3 106 Camino Matias
R-4 118 Cami.no Santiago
R-Sa 110 Cami.no Matias
R-5b 112 Cami.no Matias
R-6 111 Camino Matias
R-7a 116 Camino Matias
R-7b 120 Camino Matias
R-8 109 Cami.no Matias
R-9 107 Cami.no Matias
R-10 105 Cami.no Matias
R-11 101 Cami.no Santiago
R-12 103 Cami.no Santiago
R-14a 105a Cami.no Santiago
R-14b 105b Cami.no Santiago
R-14c 105c Camino Santiago
R-14d 105d Camino Santiago
R-15 109 Camino Santiago
R-16 • 111 Cami.no Santiago
R-17a 115a Camino Santiago
R-17b 115b Camino Santiago
R-18 117 Camino Santiago
R-19 119 Camino Santiago
R-20 121 Camino Santiago
R-2la 125a Camino Santiago
R-2lb 125b Camino Santiago
R-2lc 125c Camino Santiago
R-2ld 125d Camino Santiago
R-22 122 Camino Santiago
R-23 124 Camino Santiago
R-24a 126a Camino Santiago
R-24b 126b Camino Santiago
R-24c 126c Camino Santiago
R-24d 126d camino Santiago
R-25 120 Camino Santiago
R-26 114 Camino Santiago
'Ibtal Monthly Rent
'lbtal Annual Rent (RiI)
62
Monthly Rent
$600
$600
$600
$650
$550
$525
$700
$625"
$625
$600
$550
$550
$600
$625
$550
$450
$450
$550
$625
$625
$600
$600
$650
$600
$625
$550
$450
$450
$550
$650
$600
$450
$450
$450
$450
$650
$650
$21,075
$252,900
DOI\NEL
DON\JELAND ASSOCIATl
--?~·:,_,,
- .·
.,.__
•. .-1•
·a::i
•,·
;\•
. ....
,.:
·,.
..
I.
PRESENI' VALUE S'IUDY
Under a phased marketing strategy, sale proceeds may not be received until
a future date. A prudent investor would therefore 1rost likely discount
future incane (sale proceeds) to reflect lost incane generating capacity
until the incx:me is received (the time value of money) . A payment can be
discounted to present value by calculating the moount that should be
invested now to grow with cx:rcq;xnmd interest at a satisfactory rate to
equal the future payment.
Fran review of real estate industry publications, interviews with real
estate investors and other real estate professionals, and canparison with
alternative investments oonsidered cx:mparable in tenns of risk, liquidity
and other invesbnent criteria, in our opinion the most reasonable discollllt
rate for future sale of the property is in the 12% to 13% range. Future
sales will therefore be disoounted to present value at a 12% interest
rate. No appreciation or depreciation is projected over the proposed tima
frame. OUr discounting analysis is sU11111arized on the following chart .
82 DOI\NELL
DON\IELLAND ASSOCIATES
Also:
* 'lhe property has been inspected by the undersigned.
* Facts cited or used are deemed accurate.
* We have no present or anticipated interest, neither do we have any other
personal bias.
* Our catpensation in no way depends on the reported oonclusions.
* All limiting oonditions are presented within.
* We have prepared this report in cxmfonnitywith the professional
standards of the organizations to which we subscribe.
* 'Ihe use of this report is subject to the requirements of the American
Institute of Real Fstate Appraisers relating to review by its duly
authorized representatives.
* It> one provided significant professional assistance to the person
signing this report.
* The analyses, oonclusions, and opinions are ours.
Respectfully,
OONNELL, OONNELL & ASSOCIATES
Jt~~
'!he l\merican Institute of Real Estate Appraisers conducts a voluntary
program of continuing education for its designated members. MAI's and
RM's who meet the minimum standards of this program are awarded periodic
education certification. Jolm T. Donnell is certified under this program.
85 DOI\NELL
DON\JELLlll'\.I'°' ACCrv'II\TCC'
:!
(.l;
~ ,•• ·::-:
... ,
. ~·
I
CERTIFICATION
'!his certifies that effective February 11, 1988, the estimated values ot
the subject of this report are:
1. Casa Grande Tract, at its
market supported Highest
and Best Use (Iahd Value)
2. Casa Grande Tract, as a
congregate care retire-
ment facility
Non-Profit
For-Profit
3. Las Placitas Tract, at its
market supported Highest
and Best Use (Land Value)
4. las Placitas Tract, as a
residential rental canpound
5. Entire Property (Plaza del
Monte), at its market sup-
portable Highest and Best
Use (land Value)
6. Plaza del Monte as a
retirement cx:mnunity
Non-Profit
For-Profit
Present Value, E\lture sale,
Market Value Two Years Four Years
$1,350,000
$ 400,000
$ 350,000
$1,275,000
$1,200,000
$2,625,000
$1,500,000
$1,300,000
84
$1,100,000
$ 325,000
$ 275,000
$1,000,000
$ 950,000
$2,100,000
$1,200,000
$1,050,000
$ 850,000
$ 250,000
$ 225,000
$ 800,000
$ 775,000
$1,675,000
$ 950,000
$ 825,000
DOI\NELL
DON\IELLAND ftSSOCIATES
.,
r'TY CLERK'S OFFICE
AgendP 1lsl1'6' 1 w/�:.;.__3�-11_
... ,, dY
�:) p I
HISTORIC DISTRICTS REVIEW BOARD FIELD TRIP
TUESDAY,April 24,2018 at 12:00 NOON
HISTORIC PRESERVATION DIVISION,1'1 FLOOR CITY HALL
HISTORIC DISTRICTS REVIEW BOARD HEARfNG
TUESDAY,April 24,2018 at 5:30 P.M.
CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS
A. CALL TO ORDER
B. ROLL CALL
C. APPROVAL OF AGENDA
D. APPROVAL OF MINUTES: April 10,2018
E. FINDINGS OF FACT & CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Case #H-17-106. 345 Delgado Street.
Case #H-11-035. SOS Cerrillos Road.
Case #H-18-017. 118 Martinez Street.
Case #H-18-029. 723,725,725 ½ Canyon Road.
Case #H-18-032. 1341 Canyon Road.
Case #H-18-036. 1662 ½ Cerro Gordo Road.
F. BUSINESS FROM THE FLOOR
G. COMMUNICATIONS
1-J. ACTION ITEMS
Case #H-18-031. 644 Camino del Monte Sol.
Case #H-17-099. 235 Delgado Street.
Case #H-18-034. 125 E Water Street.
Case #H-18-030. 401 Old Taos Highway.
Case #H-18-035. 1233 Cerro Gordo Road.
1. Case #H-17-098A. 101 - 126 Camino Santiago and 102 - 120 Camino Matias. Downtown & Eastside Historic District.
Lloyd and Associates, agent for Plaza del Monte LLC, owners, requests historic status reviews with primary
elevation(s) designation,if applicable,for 27 contributing,non-contributing,and non-statused residential structures.
(David Rasch)
2.Case #H-J 7-098B. 122, 124, 125, and 126 Camino Santiago. Downtown & Eastside Historic District. Lloyd and
Associates, agent for Plaza del Monte LLC, owners, requests demolition of the structures with yardwalls. (David
Rasch)
3. Case #H-18-010B. 125 East Santa Fe Avenue. Don Gaspar Area Historic District. Satto Rugg,agent for Rachel Dixon
and Ned Conwell,owners,proposes to construct a 228 sq. ft. two-story addition and gabled dormers on the west and
east,replace a door and windows,refinish and repair windows and siding,and construct a 6' high fence with security
gate on a contributing residential structure. (Nicole Ramirez Thomas)
4. Case #H-17-102. SOI,503,507 Webber Street. Don Gaspar Area Historic District. Ju M. Tan,agent for Ross Hall,
owner, J>roposes to re1>lace windows and doors and re-build stoops. An exception is requested to widen a door
opening on a primary elevation (Section 14-S.2(D)(S)(a)(i)). (Nicole Ramirez Thomas)
5. Case #H-18-033. 106 N. Guadalupe Street. Downtown & Eastsicle Historic District. JNS Services,agent for Andy and
Crystal Barnes,owners,proposes to install a door on the cast elevation of a non-contributing residential structure.
(Nicole Ramirez Thomas)
6. Case #H-18-039A. 367 and 367 ½ Hillside Avenue. Downtown & Eastside Historic District. Liaison Planning
Services,agent for 2017 Hillside Partners,LLC, requests a status review of primary elevations, if applicable, for a
non-contributing residential structure. (Nicole Ramirez Thomas)
SS002.pmd· 11/02
8. Case #H-18-042. 945 Canyon Road. Downtown & Eastside Historic District. Liaison Planning Services, agent for
Matthew Boland and Chris Grulich, owners, proposes to construct a free-standing garage, install skylights, add a
driveway gate, and replace coyote fences at a non-contributing residential property. (Nicole Ramirez Thomas)
9. Case #H-17-098A. 101 - 126 Camino Santiago and 104-120 Camino Matias. Downtown & Eastside Historic District.
Lloyd and Associates, agent for Plaza del Monte LLC, owners, requests historic status reviews with primary
elevation(s) designation, if applicable, for 27 contributing, non-contributing, and non-statused residential structures.
(David Rasch)
10. Case #H-17-098B. 122, 124, 125, and 126 Camino Santiago. Downtown & Eastside Historic District. Lloyd and
Associates, agent for Plaza del Monte LLC, owners, requests demolition of the structures with yardwalls. (David
Rasch)
I. MA'ITERS FROM THE BOARD
Heritage Preservation Awards ballot voting
J. ADJOURNMENT
Cases on this agenda may be postponed to a later date by the Historic Districts Review Board at the noticed meeting. Please contact the Historic
Preservation Division at 955-6605 or check http://www.santafenm.gov/historic districts review board hearing packets for more information regarding
cases on this agenda. Persons with disabilities in need of accommodations, contact the Historic Preservation Division office at (505) 955-6605 five (5) working
days prior to the meeting date.
2
Mr. John Eddy, 227 East Palace Avenue Suite E, was sworn. He was glad to have the perspective. "I'm
totally confident these donners will enhance the house and make it more holistic and true to the original
design."
Chair Rios said the donner, as shown on the bottom, doesn't go with the home right now. It is squared,
and you can see it needs to be removed.
There were no other speakers from the public regarding this case and the public hearing portion was
closed.
Action of the Board
MOTION: Member Boniface moved In Case#H•18-G10B at 125 East Santa Fe Avenue, to follow
staff recommendations and approve it with the condition that the fence, which has not been drawn,
be constructed as the Applicant described verbally as six feet high with 1x6 no dog-eared cedar
fence.
Member Roybal seconded the motion with a friendly amendment that the drawings be brought
to Staff for review and approval.
Member Biedscheld requested an amendment that front door style be consistent the style on
the cut sheet shown by the Applicant at this hearing. Member Boniface accepted those.
VOTE: The motion passed by unanimous voice vote with Members Bayer, Biedscheld, Boniface,
Katz, Powell and Roybal voting in favor and none voting against
2. Case#H-18-G31. 644 Camino del Monte Sol. Downtown & Eastside Historic District. Lorn Tryk,
agent for Karen and Scott Malouf, owners, proposes to add 1na sq. ft. to the main house. (Nicole
Ramirez Thomas)
Ms. Ramirez Thomas presented the staff report as follows:
BACKGROUND & SUMMARY:
644 Camino del Monte Sol is a non-contributing single-family residence constructed in the Spanish-Pueblo
Revival style. A 2,868 square foot main house and a 980 square foot guest house are the existing buildings
on the property. They were both constructed after the year 2000.
The applicant proposes the folfowing modifications and additions to the property.
1) Addition of 1,na square feet to the main house. The height of the addition will not exceed 13'-<r, which
is lower than the existing parapet.
Historic Districts Review Board April 24, 2018 Pages
Santiago to Contributing.
VOTE: The motion falled by voice vote with Members Biedscheld and Powell voting In favor and
Members Bayer, Boniface, Katz and Roybal voting against
MOTION: Member Powell moved, seconded by Member Biedscheid, In Case #H-17-098A. 101 - 126
Camino Santiago and 104-120 Camino Matias to upgrade 125 Camino Santiago to Contributing
status.
VOTE: The motion passed by majority 4-2 voice vote with Members Bayer, Bledscheld, Katz and
Powell voting In favor and Members Boniface and Roybal voting against.
MOTION: Member Powell moved, seconded by Member Biedscheld, In Case #H-17-G98A at 101 • 128
Camino Santiago and 104-120 Camino Matias to upgrade 126 Camino Santiago to Contributing status.
VOTE: The motion to upgrade to Contributing status resulted in a 3-3 tie vote with Members Bayer,
Bledscheld and Powell voting In favor and Members Boniface, Katz and Roybal voting against.
Chair Rios voted In favor of Contributing status and the motion passed.
MOTION: Member Powell moved, seconded by Member Biedscheld, In Case #H-17-G98A at 101 • 126
Camino Santiago and 104-120 Camino Matias to keep the status of the garages at 128 Camino
Santiago non-contributing.
VOTE: The motion passed by unanimous voice vote with Members Bayer, Bledscheid, Boniface,
Katz, Powell and Roybal voting In favor and none voting against.
10. Case IH•17-G98B. 122, 124, 125, and 128 Cimino Santiago. Downtown & Eastside Historic
District Uoyd and Associates, agent for Plaza del Monte LLC, owners, requests demolition of the
structures with yardwalls. (David Rasch)
Mr. Rasch presented the staff report as follows;
BACKGROUND & SUMMARY:
The historic status of 122, 124, 125, and 126 with the associated garage/carport and yardwalls was
assigned in the previous hearing. Plaza del Monte is accessed through vehicle gates at both enb'ies to the
properties. Therefore, these structures are not located on a public way and their applicable streetscapes
are defined as a 300-foot radius from the midpoint on the fayades containing the primary entries.
On November 28, 2017, the HDRB postponed action on the demolition request pending historic status
review of all structures at Plaza del Monte.
Historic Districts Review Board Apri124,2018 Page48
Now. the applicant proposes to demolish all structures in this southern area of Plaza def Monte. No
plans have been submitted for any proposed structures.
14-3.14(G)(1)(a): The structures are either marginally historic in date of construction or from just
outside of the historic period and do not represent important examples of Santa Fe Style.
14-3.14(G)(1)(b): The structures are not essential parts of a unique street section. Similar structures
built by 1962 are located at the east side of Plaza del Monte. some may be listed as contributing structures
in the Downtown & Eastsfde Historic District.
14-3.14(G)(1)(c): The structures are •sound" and do not meet all current codes.
RELEVANT CODE CITATIONS
14-3.14 DEMOLITION OF HISTORIC OR LANDMARK STRUCTURE
(G) Standards
(1) In detenninlng whether a request for demolition in a historic district should be approved or denied,
the HDRB shall consider the following:
(a) Whether the structure is of historical importance;
(b) Whether the structure for which demolition is requested is an essential part of a unique
street section or block front and whether this street section or block front will be reestablished
by a proposed structure; and
(c) The state of repair and structural stability of the structure under consideration.
PUBLICLY VISIBLE
The portion of a structure visible from a public street. way or other area to which the public has legal
access; and provided that to be publicly visible. a structure need not be adjacent to a public street or way or
area to which the publfc has legal access.
STREETSCAPE
The visual character of a street or section of a street as defined by topography; the pattern of structures
and open space; building and wall setbacks; street design; architectural design; and heights. widths and
proportions of structures. fixtures and graphics.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION:
Staff finds that the demolition standards have been met.
Mr. Rasch clarifled that with the status votes from the previous case, only 124 Camino Santiago and
the garages at 126 Camino Santiago are eligible for demolition without an exception.
Questions to the Staff
There were no questions to the Staff.
Historic Districts Review Board April24,2018 Page49