Regular Finance Committee Meeting - Last Monday Mon, Oct 26, 2026 · Finance Committee https://santafeminutes.space/meeting/957-finance-oct-26-2026 == Executive Summary == The Finance Committee met on 10/26/2026, primarily discussing proposed changes to the City Manager's administrative authority regarding budget adjustments and contract approvals. The main proposal was to increase the City Manager's Budget Adjustment Request (BAR) approval limit from $60,000 to $200,000, aligning it with contract approval authority. This change aims to improve efficiency and expedite processes, particularly for grant applications. Councilor Cassett expressed significant concerns about the potential erosion of the governing body's budgeting power, lack of transparency, and the cumulative effect of multiple BARs. Other councilors acknowledged the need for efficiency due to inflation but also emphasized the importance of council oversight. The committee requested staff to develop more detailed guidelines, reporting mechanisms, and 'guardrails' for these administrative actions, including options for more frequent reporting and a process for council objections. They also approved allowing the City Manager to apply for grants of any amount and enter into grant agreements up to $1,000,000, provided the local match is within their contract approval authority. The committee also clarified that any purchase exceeding $100,000 for prepayment is exempt from competitive procurement. Further discussion is needed on delegating signature authority to department directors and policies for contract amendments. The committee agreed to limit discussions on a given issue to a maximum of two meetings to streamline the legislative process and requested staff to draft legislation after these conceptual discussions. Public comments included a resident discussing a lawsuit against Pfizer for vaccine injuries and encouraging dialogue with city officials. == Key Decisions == - Approved the agenda as amended, postponing the minutes for item 7a to the 11/09/2026 meeting. - Approved the consent calendar. - Approved removing the term 'initial' from Chapter 11, Section 13, clarifying that any purchase exceeding $100,000 for prepayment (e.g., subscriptions, memberships, conference fees) is exempt from competitive procurement. - Approved allowing the City Manager to apply for grants of any amount, unless the grantor requires governing body action. - Approved allowing the City Manager to enter into grant agreements up to $1,000,000, provided the local match is within the City Manager's $200,000 contract approval authority. - Approved designating the City Manager as the signer for all grant applications, notices of intent, and calls for applications, with the understanding that some grantors may still require governing body resolution or mayoral signature. - Agreed to limit discussions on a given issue to a maximum of two meetings to streamline the legislative concept review process. == Motions & Votes == - Motion to approve the agenda as amended — Passed (Councilor Castro, Cassett, Bustamante, Faulkner voted yes) - Motion to approve the consent calendar — Passed (Councilor Castro, Cassett, Bustamante, Faulkner voted yes) == Public Comment == Steven Fox accused Ursula von der Leyen of corruption and suggested the Spanish Princess replace her. He also announced that Mayor Garcia and City Attorney Ryan Moyer are moving forward with a lawsuit against Pfizer for vaccine injuries in New Mexico, separate from the State Attorney General, and encouraged further dialogue between Councilors, the Mayor, and the City Manager to discuss logistics for victims to present their cases. Councilors also encouraged residents impacted by a recent tornado to reach out for support. == Topics == - City Manager Signatory Powers - Budget Adjustment Request (BAR) Authority - Budgeting Process Transparency - Legislative Process Efficiency - Tornado Disaster Response - Grants Management Policies - City of Santa Fe vs. Pfizer Lawsuit - European Commission Corruption - Community Engagement Events == Full Transcript == PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: Are we live? Hello? We ar JAMIE CASSUTT: re live. Okay PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: y. Let's call this meeting to order. Can you get a roll call, please? Co CITY STAFF: ouncilor Cassett? Yeah. Councilor Castro? PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: Yes. CITY STAFF: Councilor Garcia? He's excused. Councilor Bustamante? Here. Chair Pilar Fauchner? Here. Thank you. We have a quorum. Th PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: hank you. And now, can we get the agenda? Any changes from staff? CITY STAFF: ? There is one change. Yes. We are requesting the minutes be presented on item 7a, be postponed to the next meeting, which is 11/09/2026 PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: 6. Can I get an explanation as to w CITY STAFF: why? Because they were not finished. We weren't quite sure how to notate the minutes, so they're still being worked on. Okay. No p PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: problem. We've had a busy several days at the city. So, can I get a motion to approve the agenda? Vote to approve as amended. I can. Can I get a roll call, please? Coun ALMA CASTRO: ncilor CITY STAFF: r Castro? Yes. Councilor Cassett? Yes. Councilor Garcia? Oh, sorry. He's excused. Councilor Bustamante? Yes. Council PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: lor Faulkner? Yes. Passes. Onto the consent calendar, any CITY STAFF: y changes fr PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: rom staff? No changes. Any changes from... Move to approve. Second. Can we get a roll call, please? CITY STAFF: Councilor Castro? Yes. Councilor Cassett? Yes. Councilor Bustamante? Yes. PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: . Councilor Faulkner? Yes. Okay. Anybody in the chambers? Doesn't look like it. Who wants to make public comment? Anyone online? Nope. No. We have no presentations. That brings us to the next business of order, which is the legislative discussion on the signatory powers of the city manager. Andre, you just want to give us a little brief overview, and then we can get into the discussion on this. Oh, but I do want to say something really quickly. Andre and Monica, you guys did a great job on presenting this to us in a way that's palatable and easy to understand. And I know you guys have done a lot of work on this, and so I just apprecia CITY STAFF: ate both of you for the work you put in. Thank you, Councilor Faul lkner and members of the Finance Committee. Yeah. So we wanted to put this in front of you this evening. Sorry. One second. There's a feedback going on. Do we e know why? Thank you. Yeah. So in your packet is a memo with this item and a table that shows some proposed changes that we have been discussing internally and with some councilors. Let me maybe just back up a little bit. The goal with this is to discuss some proposed changes with you all and see if there is an appetite to move forward with some of these changes. These would result in potentially a bill being drafted that would amend sections of our municipal code. It could include changes to Chapter 2, which is, there's a section in there about the city manager's authority, and then Chapter 11, which is finance and budget. There may be some language that would change there as well, and there are some sections or excerpts from the municipal code attached in the packet if you want to refer to that. We also, depending on what changes come forward, may need to make some Amendment No our procurement manual and our grants policies and procedures. We are actually developing a grants management P&P right now. So we've got that probably 90% drafted, but depending on what we do with some of these authority levels, we may need to make some changes to that document as well. And then finally, we may end up bringing forward some budget management policies and procedures. It's probably an area, frankly, where we need to have some more robust documentation about what we're doing and how. So I think maybe there could be kind of a flow through to different documents depending on where we go with these changes. So, with that, I will go ahead and try to pull up this table here. Oh, sorry. Michael, are you able to show what's on my scre PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: een? Oh, th CITY STAFF: here it is s. And I think I can do a full screen. You see that? We see that, and it's in your packet as well. So maybe just a reason why we're bringing this forward is a few things. One, I think that there could be maybe a little bit more of a delegation of authority, frankly, to the city manager. This would allow for maybe a little bit more efficiency in our process. By delegating to administration, they can, you know, do some contract and Budget Adjustment without having to go to governing body every time. So this would seek to increase the budget adjustment level. And then the other kind of part of this is making some changes to our grants process so that we can hopefully apply for and receive funds and enter into agreements in a quicker manner. So that's really kind of the goal with this is to try to streamline, be a little bit more efficient, try to get things through a little quicker, while still maintaining our internal controls and tracking and reporting. And I'll kind of get into that here in a little bit. I did do a little research to see what other cities in the county have in terms of authority level, and what we're proposing is very much in line with what other communities in New Mexico are doing. So first of all, we would like to suggest that we align the budget adjustment request or BAR authority to be synonymous with the contract approval authority level. So right now, the city manager can approve a BAR up to $60,000. Otherwise, it needs to go to the governing body for approval, and you've seen those before. What we're suggesting is to bring that up to the current contracting authority level, which is at $200,000. So I just wanted to kind of pause there and PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: let you guys ask questions or gi CITY STAFF: ive feedback on what you think that might look like for us here at this. Questions or comments? I'm sure. Thank you so much. Yeah. Thank you. I, this is the one that I actually struggle with. So I'm glad that we got here first. My bigger concern with the BAR has to do with... I feel like the governing body already feels pretty when it comes to our ability to budget. And so if we give up this piece, I mean, it just feels like another, I mean, another component that is gone. So where is the kind of check Fund Balance? And I see that they're supposed to be... You know, they're compiled and brought to finance and governing body for approval. What happens if we don't approve them? Because it sounds like that's something that's like already happened. What happens if we go back? We're like, we actually don't like what you just did here. Yeah. So... No. You bring up a very good point, and maybe I can just explain what our current process is. So any adjustment to the revenues or expenditures in a fund that results in a net increase or decrease beyond what was appropriate and adopted in the budget needs to be approved by the... by DFA. And what our process is right now, the city manager can approve BARs up to $60,000. Those get approved or reviewed and approved. There is a form. It gets routed throughout our internal processes. The division or department director requesting it approves it. The budget officer approves it, and the finance director and city manager approve it. And so there is a, you know, digital record of all of that. Those adjustments get made by the budget team, and they're logged within the Munis system. So there's a record in our ERP system of those changes being made. And then they're also keeping a catalog or monitoring of all of those adjustments that are made throughout the quarter. And then, of course, simultaneously, anything over $60,000 gets brought to governing body for review and approval. And all of those get collated into a quarterly budget amendment resolution that essential lly shores up what has been done administratively and through governing body approval. And then that resolution after it's approve ed gets sent to DFA. Okay. And then what would happen if we didn't approve the resolution? I mean, we... That's never happened, but I'm curious. Yeah. So I guess what do you mean? Do we undo things? Yeah. Then we would need to journal entry it back, and, you know, that would trigger then a reversal of that decision. So, yeah, this would be asking for additional authority above the $60,000 up to the contractin ng authority level, the $200,000 or whatever number feels right, but essentially allowing a higher threshold or administrative adjustments to be made. And then in terms of, you know, say we, you know, we have one of those moments of unanticipated revenue that comes in that we're always... You know, there's been a lot of conversation around how does that get allocated. In theory, say, under this scenario, if there's, let's say, a million dollars and the city manager could... Let's take a large department. Let's go for community services where there's a number of different places. In theory, they could Allocate GRT out to community services in a variety of $200,000 lumps or because it's going to one overall department, it would... I mean, so if they're... Even if they're like, this one's youth and family services. This one's recreation. This one is for libraries. So... And a million dollars could go into community services bu udget, but I think that budget is presented altogether. So would it only be $200,000 to that department despite the fact of the different divisions? Is that something that we could? Councilor Cassett, you're bringing a really great question, and it's something that, you know, if there is concurrence to move forward and even if there isn't, I do think we need more clarity and documentation around our process for this, because I do think even as it is, there's maybe a little bit of a gray area, at least for me, in terms of, you know, could you have multiple $60,000 BARs for a single department? Right? So I think kind of ironing out those parameters would be very helpful. Yeah. I think that would be something I would really want to see is, you know, what is... What would be the limit in the max per year? At what point... Yeah. And at what point do we need to be coming forward to governing body? Again, the unanticipated revenue can be really similar to just the budget process in general where the governing body does not necessarily... As I always say, I don't get to see what was left on the cutting room floor. I don't get to see what the other options were when we wound up budgeting this over this. And a lot of times, you know, that's policy decisions. You know? How much are we budgeting towards homelessness versus streets? You know? That's absolutely a policy decision in the end. So, so, so, yeah, this is the one that I have a little bit of heartburn on, and, honestly, that might be... I might have less as we move forward with working on our budgeting process, which I know that has been something that we are we are trying to make some changes with as well as, you know, we've talked about having our budget to actuals. We're actually seeing what's happening with the budget to actuals. We're actually seeing what's happening with the expenditures of the city so that when there is, you know, a BAR for some reason, it actually makes sense to the finance, at least the finance committee, if not the governing body as a whole, to say we understand why there was a Budget Adjustment this amount because we are seeing what is happening with the expenditure. So that's... I think that's my big challenge is maybe it's not necessarily this inherently, but the fact that there are these lack of transparency aspects right now, that, again, you know, when people say that, they think there's some conspiracy going on. There's not... Just we really need to work on our systems. There is a system issue, and that, you know, the city council, our ability to impact the budget is still quite limited, and, again, something that we're working on. So that... My concerns with this proposal may actually just be part of the inherent issues that we are continuing to try to address with budgeting and with finance, and, you know, these are no secrets or surprises to anybody. So I would really like to see a lot more details with this. What does it mean when there's dollars being added? Was there dollars being moved? Is it subtracting money from another place? And where might we be able to weigh in? The flip argument is, one, it goes through all these committees and usually just passes on consent. Nobody asks about it. Nobody pulls it off, and it just flies on through. And so, why are we going through this exercise, other than for us to have this sense of comfort of, oh, we saw something? So I don't know if there's a way that maybe those get posted, that we're able to review them before they actually hit. So if there is some typ pe of balance there while we're working on these other processes that help the City Council be more informed and impactful when it comes to our budget and our spending. Thank you. And I appreciate you always ask such great questions and think about all of these details. And I think some of this can be fleshed out and needs to be regardless of whether we change the limit in terms of just fleshing out those guidelines and parameters and making sure that you all are comfortable with what we're doing. So right now, the cadence for reporting would be quarterly. However, we might be able to, since there is a log that is being kept by the budget team, and it's, I mean, it's an Excel file. It's not anything very fancy, but we might be able to do like a monthly reporting of that. Some of these are what we call T-bars. So I can't remember what the T stands for. Transfer bar, transfer bar. And that would be within a fund and within a department, where it doesn't cause a net increase or decrease. So those are already being done administratively as well. So there may be a way that we could kind of catalog bars and T-bars that are taking place and put them out on some kind of reporting mechanism on like a monthly basis or something like that. I guess, ultimately, if they were not approved on the quarterly basis, they would just not, they would be adjusted back. I mean, t that might be a question for Marcos. But, ultimately, if governing body doesn't approve it and then DFA doesn't approve it, ultimately, the budget did not get adjusted. Yeah. I guess my concern would be there if, like, say, this was related to a contract. And then we're like, nope, just kidding. And the money has already, contract has already started to accrue expenditures. So, yeah, definitely something I want to explore more. And I think this goes for all of us, and maybe this is just, just, you know, kind of our decision of where we're giving up power. But there's, I know even for contracts right now, there's a contract going out that I don't like. It's within City Manager authority. I have no idea what my ability is to yank it, when I can yank it to say, I want to actually take this to a vote. So, maybe understanding and looking at those protocols, I think I would feel more comfortable with this delegation of power if we do have the ability to object within a timely manner where it's not going to cause this mayhem, where it's like, hey, we've already approved th PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: his budget, and we got this contract, and we're moving forward. And then just kidding, three months later, the governing body is like, no, no money for you. Said if I may. Yeah. One of the things we discussed with, I discussed with Monica and Andrea was that if we are going to give up these powers, what is about to be given up has to be reported to the counselors or anything substantial happens. Like, if there was a major contract or a bar or some major thing, we would get reports on it before it happens so that then if we wanted to, we could pull it onto a committee or onto governing body. We haven't worked those details out yet, but that's kind of like the guardrails that we're thinking about working on. I think, Monica, can you speak a little bit to, like, we were talking the other day about a little portal where we could log in and see what was coming? I know we're not there y CITY STAFF: yet, but just so the counselors on the committee understand, like, this isn't like a give all to the City Manager without some consideration for guardrails. Yes, ma'am. Madam Chair, Councilor Cassatt, I hear you loud and clear, and I think that we are working currently. We actually started meeting with all the departments in the last two weeks just to give them a snap for where we're at. Progress, we, we're hiring two new budget folks coming on board with Andy's departure, but I totally want to be able to provide the counselors, here's a list of everything that we have going on. Here's, I'm working on it. I promise. I want to make sure to provide you guys expenditures, the budget levels, all those sorts of things. It's really important. I think that you guys need that information. I do have to say, though, in coming from the state, I'm still learning my roles here at the city, but the $60,000 threshold is very low for volume of that, the stuff that we do. And, but I think you'd have a comfort level if we're able to provide you some reports to say, look, these are all the contracts. These are out. But we did talk with Councilor Faulkner the other day of, and I asked Travis, who's online, if maybe OpenGov, now that we've used OpenGov for procurement, if they can do some reporting functions when we start to initiate those things in the process. So you can see a list of those things before they go, and then it give you a little bit more, we hope, a comfort level to trust us, but you need that information. So I hear you loud and clear, Councilor. I've definitely want, I'm working to provide that to you all. Yeah. Thank you. I appreciate it. And like I said before, , I understand that this is not a piece of, like, we don't want the counselors to know about things. And there's been all these accusations in the past that I find very frustrating because I, a lot of it is just we do not have the systems in place, and so I really appreciate you working on that. So I think part of it is making sure the system is in place. And then, as we look at moving forward with ordinance change of making sure within that ordinance that there is kind of permission given to the council to say, hey, we can object to things if needed because I could see a scenario where there might be something we're saying, we don't like this, and then we get this like, well, but, you know, th he code says that the City Manager has the authority. So I think we have to, you know, kind of figure out what all those different details look like. Yeah. And I'm just kind of thinking about how we could do that and keep, keep, I mean, because the intention of this is to keep things moving, you know, and not have, you know, multiple, you know, try to streamline this process a little bit. And so, yeah, we would need to be, whatever that level is, I think we would need to be comfortable that you are delegating that authority to the administration. Right? And so if there is this feeling that, no, we might want to look at every single thing, and we're not sure, and we might want to pull it, then that could actually end up slowing down the process. Right? And then it could also lead to confusion if we're like, oh, yeah, City Manager approved it, and now we've, you know, gone ahead and taken another administrative action to allow it. And then, you know, then we're saying, oh, just kidding. You know, there's, it's now being revisited. So I think we always need to be careful about that piece. And so I think the reporting of it is definitely important, but like t PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: the objection kind of period and what that looks like, we would want to, you know, be JAMIE CASSUTT: comfortable with that and assure that it's not creating additional, right, you know, stops in the process. Yeah. So Councilor Cassatt will come back. Yeah. Councilor Bustamante? Thank you, Chair. No, I mean, I see your points for sure, and I definitely have a bit of an issue of the, of the, what you were talking about. Like, well, here's an opportunity to, you know, deny that, but we're not always going to get that. Like, some of these might be emergency sort of things and whatever. But, I, that's beside the point. What I wanted to bring up is, you know, I have no idea how long this has been in play like this, but 60,000, you know, was really not that much. And it may have been a lot when this was written into code. So, you know, when you look at adjusted rates of inflation and cost to do PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: a business, 200 ALMA CASTRO: 0,000 honestly doesn't seem like that big of a jump or an ask. So, you know, it's kind of what I was running through my mind as we're talking about this. Thank you, sir. The house, Councilor Castro? Sure. Thank you so much, sir. I agree, and I see both points. This is a difficult one because we've had some conversations around the threshold, and even going up to 200,000 on the other one was giving some folks a little heartburn to use Councilor Cassatt's terms. I also understand that things have gone up in price, just the cost of c PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: contracts in general. This might be coming down to trust in the City Manager and the conversation around the professionalism and what requirements we want to have around that City Manager and what experience we want. I think that, I think it's fair to say that was contemplated when the Councilor Cassatt and I, who else was on that legislation? Dean Amanda. I mean, we contemplated what a City Manager's credentia CITY STAFF: als should be in order to be a City Manager in an effort to get a professional City Manager and not a political appointment. Kendra Cassatt, do you have any other things to add? No. I would just say that, like, in summary, I wouldn't say at this point I'm against it. I think that it's definitely something to consider, but I want some pretty thoughtful, you know, pieces about this. And, again, the reason I've always had a hard time with bars is it could potentially represent a change in policy. Now to the point, two to a 100,000 these days actually really isn't that much. So maybe it doesn't have enough of a chance to have a change in policy. But we, you know, I'll do a better job of paying attention maybe to some of these, you know? So, because, again, they, they, they fly through and we let them go. So, I mean, when practically speaking, it's kind of for show. So, I would be interested in seeing what some of those different requirements would be, where some of the thresholds are. Is there, you know, a maximum amount within a quarter that can, or a year that a department can receive without coming back for authority from the governing body, or a decrease that could happen in a single department, that's PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: another one, without coming back to the governing body? So I'm absolutely willing to look at some of those pieces and discuss them more. So, I see the benefit, and I'm more than happy to have this more fleshed out to have further conversation. Okay. So I think it's fair to say that on the bar discussion, I think we want some more guardrails up and preemptive reporting. I would also add that one thing that I find interesting is we say, I have heartburn about the bars as well, not so much the contracts that we're going to get into. But bars are interesting to me because money shows up when we have a more GRT than we thought we had or, and the counselors have no idea that this is what's in play. Right? And so 200,000 or 250,000, like, 200,000, it doesn't seem like a lot by itself. But if you had five 200,000s, now you have a million. If you have 10, now you have... You know what I'm saying? You could see how out of context of the bigger budget, bars at $200,000, it feels benign if you look at them just on their own. But if you start piling them up, now you could be talking about tens of millions of dollars that's just moving through the city. And I'm not opposed to it necessarily, but I do, as we discussed when we met about this, preemptive reporting so that the counselors can look at it and say, "Okay, well, we have 20 bars going through that are $200,000 a piece." That ends up being a substantial amount of m JAMIE CASSUTT: money, right? And so I think on the bars, I think that, is it fair to say that the general sense of the committee is some preemptive reporting, maybe some guardrails up about how we pull back? I think we know how Councilor Cassette feels. Councilor Bustamante? So yeah, I think in terms of guardrails, maybe there should be an additional limit set up. Councilor Cassette mentioned that earlier, whether it's by division or what, but some sort of limit so that ALMA CASTRO: t, okay, well, all of a sudden, $3,000,000 isn't being moved by X amount of bars for that division. So yeah, I would agree to looking at some sort of guardrails on that. Councilor Castro? Yeah, thank you so much, Chair. Agreed on some guardrails, but I think folding PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: g this into the process of the budget and just talking about the budget more regularly, getting updates in general, really could accomplish the goals that we're seeking just in terms of informati CITY STAFF: ion. I think across the board, I think the counselors would like to see more information on a regular basis on all things related to the budget. Are we satisfied on the discussion related to the bars? Yes, Madam Chair, I'm working on it. I promise. I want to do that for you all, and I think that if we've already approved a budget for a department through the year, I think that they should be allowed to use their budget unless it's coming from some other kind of funding source. Right? That's where you guys would really probably need some sort of... But if it's coming within their established budget, it doesn't matter how many times in my mind how they're moving it because that's what we approved at the beginning of the fiscal year. So, but again, if it's coming from another funding source, then maybe that's the guardrail that we can discover. But I do want to tell you guys, Andrea and I and the PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: team, I'm working on it. I promise. I want to make sure I'm providing that to you a CITY STAFF: all. Thank you, ma'am. No, I have all confidence as Chair that you are working on it, Monica. Do you want to... Let's go to the next one, Andrea. Yes, thank you, Councilor Faulkner. So the next section and the next few deal with just maybe some definitions and just providing some clarifying language. So Chapter 11, Section 13, talks about purchases. And so this was actually a recommendation from our procurement team to just remove the term "initial." So I think this was talking about initial purchases Cost Exceeding $100,000 for prepayment. These are items like magazine subscriptions, organizational membership fees like New Mexico Municipal League, something like that, web-based or electronic subscriptions, conference registration fees, et cetera, are exempt from competitive procurement. And so the recommendation is to just take out the term "initi ial" and just make it any purchase that falls into that category just to clarify that exemption. And Travis is on if you have any questions about that one. Travis, can you dig into this a little bit for us? Yes, sir. Thank you so much. So when we first described or discussed updating this exemption, we were going to split it up in between two. So we were going to have the initial and subgroup. But kind of sticking with what the state has, we decided to roll it all up into one exemption, or I guess roll it back up into one e PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: exemption because it didn't... It was init JAMIE CASSUTT: tially one exemption. But then that CITY STAFF: t word "initial" is kind of an artifact of the idea of splitting it. So we're requesting to ALMA CASTRO: o remove it so it can get back to what we originally intended. So I'm going to start with Councilor Bustamante. That makes sense to me. T CITY STAFF: Thank you. That's it. Councilor? Yeah, I'm fine with PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: this one. That makes sense. Okay, Councilor Castro? Same. And I just w CITY STAFF: want to make sure I'm understanding. So we have already consolidated, and we're just cleaning up the language. Correct, Tra PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: avis? Yes, that is correct, Councilor. Thank you. Thank you. That was easy. On to the next one, A CITY STAFF: Andrea. Real quick, Madam Chair, I would just l like to know, would you like the bars to be on the next agenda? Would you like to continue speaking about this? Or I think we can... The will of the committee, you want to hear some ideas from staff on the bars? Well, you are allowed to vote on these as well. Yeah, I don't know if we're ready for a vote tonight. Yeah, but I'm taking back as feedback on each of these items. We're just kind of vetting t them tonight. So, I mean, unless you wanted to take a vote, I think I'm just hearing the feedback that we need to do some more definition around the bar. I think we're ready for a vote tonight. Yeah, but I'm taking back his feedback on each of these items. I will say I will not be here on November 9th. So, given that I was one of the ones that made some of the most noise, maybe not on November 9th. So also, I'd rather just, you know, give you all time to actually work through this and take a look at it and maybe even d JAMIE CASSUTT: data around like, "Hey, guys, this is how many bars y'all are pressing on consent under this signing authority and not caring about." So I would say, I don't know, I would prefer to see it when there's actually some more information there. It's... I thought, Councilor Bustamante? Yeah, I mean, I know we're still trying to figure out this whole process of what we're doing here right now, but I don't see th PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: he benefit in seei ALMA CASTRO: ing things multiple times in the same committee. Like, I think once get things through, and then if there's action to be taken, great, and legislation CITY STAFF: n could be introduced. But I thin PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: nk revisiting it multiple times might be counterproductive. Councilor Castro. Agreed. Yeah, I think that we probably spoke about it. We might want to talk to other council members, a governing body, but we don't need to hear it here. Thank you for the clarification. I'm kind of mixed on this one. Like, if it is a finance committee relevant issue, and we've asked for more information and more policy ideas from staff, as Chair, I would like to see more... I would like one more time to see what staff brings as a solution to our concerns, and then also the data that would... What Councilor Cassette is saying, like, for approving 100 bars every time we go through a cycle, then clearly, we're not yanking them, so we're not that concerned apparently. I would like to see it like one more time, just to see what's... Because this is going to promulgate legislation, like this process. And so I'd like to see the bars one more, the bar discussion one more time with some of our concerns addressed and so that we can have a chance as the finance committee to think about it. The bar in particular is that seems to be a sticking point for the finance committee. And so I will be bringing that back one more time as Chair. But after that, I do agree with Councilor Castro and Bustamante that this can't be... This committee cannot be an endless cycle of going over and over and over concepts. Like, we're doing this to expedite process, not to extend the process. And so I'm going to have ALMA CASTRO: to fall in the middle, which is I want to hear one more time your solutions, but then I think that's going to be all I will tolerate as well because we have other piec PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: ces of legislation to bring through CITY STAFF: this committee, through this process. Okay. So.. PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: .. Oh, okay. CITY STAFF: . Okay. So Councilor Castro. Thank you, Chair. I would just request then, since Councilor Cassette is out the 9th, the only opportunity would be Decem PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: mber 7th. So if we could have it on that agenda, please. Yes, I like that idea. CITY STAFF: And Armenia. Armenia? Armenia, can you hear us? You're on mute. Thank you. Thank you, Chair and members PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: of the finance committee. I don't know CITY STAFF: if you can hear me. Can you hear can you hear us? PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: ? Can we can hear you. Can you hear me? Y CITY STAFF: Yes. I don't think you can hear me. Yeah, we can hear you. Oh, sorry. Never mind. Thank you. Thank you, Chair and members of the finance committee. I don't know if you can hear me. He's getting ready. I'm sorry. Armenia, you have an echo, Armenia. Yeah. Destiny, can you text her or Jamie? Then I can move on to the next item if you would like. So the next item is just defining further what a contract is. 1116 has a very generic definition of what a contract is, and we've had some internal confusion maybe across the city about what constitutes a contract. And so we did, in the language here, say contracts include but are not limited to expenditure contracts for goods or services, grant agreements, sponsorship opportunities, insurance and claim settlements, l PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: lease agreements, events and facility rental ALMA CASTRO: l agreements, revenue agreements, capital outlay appropriations, donation or sale agreemen PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: nts, liens, and oth CITY STAFF: her instruments binding on the city. So this is just trying to provide a more fulsome definition for what types of instruments may be considered a contract. Okay, we're going to start with Councilor Castro. I think that makes a lot of sense. I would take that recommendation. Thank you, Chair. Councilor Cassette. Thank you, Madam Chair. I guess my question is, do we need "contracts include but are not..." Because it still is pretty open-ended, and there could be some th hings not there. Have we ever run into an instance where we don't know what a contract is? Okay, I was about to... I mean, because it's like, we'll be just adding more language and then being like, "Yeah, it could be other things too." But if there have been instances where this does need to be clarified, then, yeah, sure, clarify. Yeah, and it could be too that in the drafting of the bill that, you know, maybe this language, you know, gets consolidated a little bit, and some of it could be enumerated then in a procedures manual, , like a grants or contract kind of manual. But we have had some confusion around the city about whether, like, for instance, a lease settlement or a lease agreement or, you know, an insurance settlement is a contract. And so this just kind of helps to pr PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: rovide some clarity around that. And is ther JAMIE CASSUTT: re anything that we want to specify is PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: not a contract that people have thought maybe would be? Because this is a... You know, could also be something else. But if there's something that we're saying, "Hey, this is not a contract," I can't really think of anything that would get confused with it. But okay. All right. No problem. Councilor Bustamante? No, I would accept that as is. Thanks. The only question I have is capital outlay being ALMA CASTRO: included in that. Does that then mean that the contracts with the state... I guess they are contracts, actually, so that does make sense. They're grant agreements, which are a form of a contract. I would interpret them that way. Okay, CITY STAFF: , so I think, is it fair to say that the committee is good with this? Cassette likes it. Castro likes it. I like it. Castro does not like it. No, I do. Sorry, I did have one quick question. So the lease agreement, I am assuming that's the one situation. Deputy City Manager, is there anything we should know about lease agreements since we ALMA CASTRO: e have been entering into quite a few? No. Currently, the city manager is signing those CITY STAFF: within his contract authority level. If we are utilizing city property for a lease that has not been ALMA CASTRO: leased before, we are bringing that to the governing body as a first touch. If we have never leased someth CITY STAFF: hing before, we bring them no matter what the value is. But based on your earlier comment, t that is not a contract. A lease agreement is different? Yeah. So we're just saying that we would try to make that included within the definition of a contract. Okay. So we are redefining that to make sure that it is clear that it is a contract. Yes. Perfect. Thank you. Okay. So I think we're good on that one. What's the next one, Andrea? Yeah. So also in 11/16, this is approval authority. Currently, the city manager can apply for grants up to $60,000. They can apply for grants larger than that amount if the deadline for the grant application falls before the governing body can approve it if it's over that $60,000, and then it needs to be ratified. What we're asking, and this is in consultation with our grants team, is to allow the city manager to apply for grants in any amount unless otherwise required by the grantor. Sometimes the grantor wants a resolution or some kind of action on the record, even authorizing the city manager or staff to apply for a grant. So unless that's the case, what we're asking for here is essentially approval to go seek money, not binding the city, but go seek money for any amount. And then the second part here is to enter into grant agreements up to $1,000,000, allowing the city manager to accept funds up to $1,000,000, provided that the city's local match is within the city manager's contract approval authority, PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: , which is currently $200,000. So we're CITY STAFF: e hoping that this can help streamline some of the grants. A lot of grants are over $1,000,000, which is great. The city's been successful, especially in utilities and some of those areas, in getting pretty substantial funds. But up to that amount, we're hoping that this could help kind of delegate some of that authority and help streamline that process. Start with Councilor Cassett. Yeah. I think going to get grants in any way that we can make it easier is a positive thing to go get more revenue. And again, I guess I just keep being, you know, bringing up larger issues that we need to look at. This, I know you and I have had this conversation around, like, the city needs a strategic plan. We need to talk about what activities are reprioritizing as opposed to, you know, if we go and get this $1,000,000 grant to do a thing that we weren't planning on doing, and all of a sudden we're adding it on. But I would say that should be within a purview of a city manager. You know, they know how to run a city and make sure it's efficient. And the fact that they don't have better direction from us is not their fault at this moment in time. But this is where I think if we had a st PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: trategic plan, JAMIE CASSUTT: , that would be beneficial when they are looking at grants beca PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: ause it does take ALMA CASTRO: time and energy to actually spend them and use them for whatever activity. So that's a little piece in the back of my mind of other things that we really need to be exploring in terms of making this productive. But I would say, you know, go forth and seek dollars. Just a month. Y CITY STAFF: Yeah. Seems like it needed change to me, so I would approve it. Councilor Castro. Great change. I am excited to see the $1,000,000. Right away, I thought about the $5,000,000 that we got for Fort Marcy. And it's interesting to know that this is to seek funds, not necessarily to spend them. I think we do need to be cautious, just again, chair, with communication. Thank you. So I think you have a green light on that one, Andrea. Next one. Thank you. And also just to follow up on that one, we are working on a grants management policies and procedures document. I think it's now running like 25 pages or something. But within that, we're hoping to not only address kind of authority levels, but also just process for assessing grant opportunities, who's responsible for finding them, and ensuring that we have capacity within the city system to actually do the thing. Accept the funds is one thing, but to actually do the project and monitor it appropriately is yet another. So this next one here is essentially asking for authority for the city manager to be the designated signer on all grant applications, notices of intent to apply, and call for applications. We're hoping that this will also, kind of similar to the one above, provide some assurances to granting agencies that the city manager is the designated signer. Sometimes it goes directly to the mayor, for instance, and then that kind o JAMIE CASSUTT: of triggers a whole separate set of approvals. And some granting agencies may still say, "No, we want a governing body resolution," or, "The mayor has to sign it, not the city manager." But we're hoping that we can, you know, throughout our ALMA CASTRO: r code, make that the designated signer, and then hopefully, that would reduce some of the time that it would take to move it through. Super smar PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: rt. Yeah. No comments on this. I'm kind of CITY STAFF: f just look king at the next section, which kind of amends this a little bit by being able to delegate that signing authority, but we could talk about that then. Okay. Thank you. Councilor Castro? Same. I just wonder what some of those responsibilities are if there was a change in city management, but I'm sure we will think of that. Thank you. Mr. Cassett. Good on that one, Andrea. Thank you. And then this next one is about delegation of authority within the city manager's authority level. So say it is the $200,000. What we were hoping is that the city manager could then further delegate as appropriate signature authority to department directors and other folks within the agency. So for instance, could we delegate to Randy Randall authority to, you know, sign agreements for use of the convention center up to a certain amount, for instance? So could there be some routine administrative type functions up to a certain level that we allow directors to sign off on? What we would propose is that the city manager would maintain a list of all of those authorized sign PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: natories an ALMA CASTRO: nd what types of instruments they are permitted to sign, and then we would maintain that in conjunction with the finance department. And so that was the idea there. So that it's, you know, all directors report to the city manager, but he can delegate some of that authority up to whatever amount, you know, feels appropriate. So it could be like up to $20,000 or something like that. Okay. Councilor Castro. I feel okay about this. Deputy City Manager Phillips broug PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: ght up the one that CITY STAFF: t has been on my mind the most, whi ich is the convention center. I think that if the authority i is only up to a certain amount, I feel okay. It is important to Councilor Cassett's point that if we have been intended to use, for example, it's a community convention center, that we continue to use it for that intended purpose. I don't know how we make that will known other than just letting folks know. Councilor Cassett? Yeah. Thank you, Madam Chair. I, that's what I, I'd want to see a lot more detail on that. And I barely showed up for the tail end of the McHarg report, but there were some challenges with other people having financial authority, if I recall. And again, I, I would need to, this was wrapping up right as I was coming in. I would want to revisit that because there were some concerns. I don't know if it was specifically in this arena, but there, there were some concerns there and making sure those checks and balances were in. I believe that a lot of the systems we've put in place take care of a lot of, a lot of that. So I would need to see a lot of, you know, what types, you know, the much, a lot more detail there as to what that would look like. And this is specific. So for contracts, grants, again, I'm, I'm, you know, that one, I feel a bit more, well, I'm, I think it would depend on how much the city's committed to in matching funds. Exactly. And also our capacity to get those dollars out. And if we're working on getting those dollars out, does that mean that there's something else that's put on the back burner? You know, the governing body does have ability to direct the city manager. We do not have ability to direct directors. And so this is where, you know, kind of that, like, one step remove gets a little bit murky for me. So I am not as sure on this one. Again, I, I think the balancing, you know, we, we want efficiency. The city manager is, has too big of a job. We know this, and not enough support. We need to work on that. Maybe it's kind PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: d of like city manager JAMIE CASSUTT: r finance director. I'm not entirely sure. Or maybe the Deputy City Manager is that, you know, how, how do we balance out some of that workload? So I'd want a lot more detail on what this would really look like before I could say either way. Although I do, I have much more hesitancy here. We can fire a city manager. We can't fire a PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: director. So, you know, that makes me feel a little bit better that they're going to make sure they keep us happy. Councilor Bustamante. Yeah. I mostly agree with Councilor Cassett on this one. I think my heartache with part of this is also, and other subordinates as needed. Like, I, I think if, well, one, I would want to see a lot more information on this, but I think if we're going to allow anything like this, we need to have very strict rules set up for delegation authority. Yeah. I would have to agree with my colleagues. I do think that there's probably a lot of sp CITY STAFF: paces where we could expedite things. But again, the devil's in the details where it's, it's like, it, it's, it's a good idea at 30,000 feet, but when we get down into the weeds, what are the details of this in particular, much like the bar conversation? There, we need more details about, like, what that would look like. And also, Destiny, can you add that? Redo the bar discussion, add this to that as well. Okay. So, Andrea, are we good that we need more details about what that would look like? Okay. Awesome. Gary, this is great feedback, and that's why I wanted to have this conversation with you all before we, you know, actually started drafting language and, you know, burdening Marcy's team. I wanted to make sure we had, you know, some good understanding of what this would look like and if there was interest in pursuing these. And I do think some of these are, you know, frankly, policies and procedures that will, that will partner with what is in the code. So we want, like, the authority levels and some of the basic things within the code, but we may have more procedures within, like, our procurement manual, our grants management manual, things like that. And then this last one is just dealing with authority for contract amendments and adjustments. So right now, the, the city manager can contract, you know, up to $200,000 and make adjustments to a contract that ar PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: re non-fiduciary in nature. So they can, you k JAMIE CASSUTT: know, assign or sign on to an assignment if they're sending it to another vendor, extend it, things like that. But we don't have any clarity around a potential contract increase. So we wanted to propose, and this may not be the right threshold, but we wanted to propose so PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: ome level of autho ALMA CASTRO: ority for contract amendments that may increase or decrease the amount of the contract. And what we're proposing is 25% of the original contract amount or city manager's contract authority, whichever is less. Okay. So I think. Is it your turn first? PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: Thank you. CITY STAFF: Again, I think I would want to see a lot more detail on this. Also, just the way the language reads now, it only talks about contract increases, and I think I would want to see information on that for any sort of Amendment No it, whether it's an extension or decrease. Counselor Castro. Yeah, I would second that. I like concrete examples. I'm happy that we get to see the alchemy contracts, seeing these extensions. I'm happy that we're able to discuss the values of where we want to put our dollars, so this one is a little tough for me. Third cap. Thank you, Madam Chair. I think, again, maybe saying what the... Again, if there's multiple 25% increases, that could potentially become a problem. A lot of this, I think, keeps sticking down for me is we really want efficiency within the city. I guess maybe now I'm stuck on a strategic plan direction upfront for where we want to go. I think that this is a challenge that is had with grants and with contracts. If we are giving very clear direction of these are the goals that we want to achieve, then it becomes a lot easier to relinquish some of this administrative power because right now, we don't really have that. Things could shift in a moment's notice, and if we're not paying attention, then we're not aware that it occurred. So I think in theory, I would want to see this happen because we want things to be able to move more quickly, especially once we've gotten started on something. Then all of a sudden, we have this Amendment No a contract, and it slows down. It has to go through all these committees, and there are fits and stops with work. We sometimes lose contractors because then they start a job, and then we're delayed so much that then they go on to another project. So then we have these half-done projects. I mean, we've seen all of these scenarios. So I think how we can make this more seamless is really important. A lot of it, I think, just keeps coming back to if we haven't put in the groundwork as a governing body to give direction of here are the five things we want you to achieve in the next two years. These are the things that are super important to us. Everyday business is going to keep going. We're still going to need permits going through land. We're still going to need trash picked up and all the good stuff. But I would like to see a way to make this work. Obviously, I want to see some bounds, but I've seen too often contract amendments literally pausing projects, and then we don't get them done. Then the community is waiting longer for something that they've been promised, and they start to see movement on, and then it stops. Or we wind up spending more money because we stop, and then we have to start over. So I think understanding again the bounds, what does this look like if we're getting multiple requests within a single year? At some point, it needs to come to us. There's a problem there. But how can we make this go forward? Or maybe when we are looking at some of these contracts or these budgets, do we give them approval at that point to say, "Hey, we're going to say if this needs to go up another million dollars, go for it. Go build a new wastewater treatment plant, and it's going to take you..." Midtown's another great example. Started at $30,000,000 of infrastructure, went out to 77. So I don't know if that's something to think about and how this is designed, but that's kind of my thought there. I'd like to PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: see this actually be able to move because once a contract is approved, once a grant is coming in, we want that work to keep rolling. We've already put in some dollars, but where are the guardrails and where are the limits? Thank you. Thank you, everyone. I find this interesting to contemplate because you can say, "Midtown, greenlight it," but then that could take several administrations, and so then we don't want to not know what's happening on a project, right? So I think this is where I'm going to be a stickler for again, preemptive reporting. So I think as long as we're getting information before decisions are made, then we don't have to go through this cumbersome process, right? Then that gives the council the opportunity that if they see something, they're like, "I don't know what this is. This doesn't feel right to me." We can pull it onto a committee or into governing body and have a discussion about it. I think I'm in agreement with my colleagues on this for sure. This will all work if there's a lot of transparency and communication between the council and the administration. The other question I had, Andrea, was we had talked about we have some contracts that are like $2,000,000, but they're over five years or four years. Is there some space where we can put something in here where, like, if we approve a years-long contract, does it have to come back to the governing body every year? I mean, unless something changes by some percentage that would have a significant impact on, like, would we... If they change, it's going to cost 25% more. Well, yes, the council should see that if in the next contract, it changes by 25% more. But if it doesn't change, why are we rinse and repeating over and over for a contract we already approved initially? I like that added to the conversation too if we can do that because I do think a lot of these contracts are multiple years. So if we can try to find the Goldilocks moment with that, which is like, we've already approved it. We don't need to see it every year unless something changes. I don't know what the will of the council or governing body would be on what the threshold is, but if we could aim at a threshold and see how it CITY STAFF: t kind of pans out in the discussions, then I would think that would be beneficial too. Oh, go ahead. Who's the hand? Travis. Travis. So, Chair and Counselors, that is the initial intent. Or, I guess, when we're working on contracts, we always have the intent to set the contract for everything that we can foresee for the life of the contract. So if it's a five-year contract, we think it's going PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: g to cost X number of dollars. So, essentially, contracts should not change unless there is something that really requires the change. Just wanted to put that out there. Yeah. So I'm assuming there's inflation, tariffs, some other things we're all dealing with right now that may change along a contract that's over several years. I could see us wanting to see that under a certain, above a certain threshold. I don't understand why we're seeing contracts that get tied up in a 90 to 120-day governing body process when it's the same as it was when we agreed to it initially. So if we can roll that in, I would appreciate that. That'd be another good thing to add that I think might streamline some things. Okay, so that's the last one? Alright. So because we' CITY STAFF: 're in a pilot project, I want feedback from staff. Has this been helpful, Monica and Andrea and Destiny and Erenia and Travis? Counselor Faulkner, I really appreciated being able to bring just the concepts of a plan to you before we draft the bill because I think I'd want to be cognizant of all of the demands on Marcy and her small team. So I think it's just good to bring these as concepts, especially as we're getting your feedback and hashing out what it co PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: ould look like. So for m CITY STAFF: me, this has been helpful to have a policy kind of discussion before it becomes a bill. K. Monica and Destiny? Madam Chair, members of the council, again, I'm coming in new, so I think this is super exciting. I know in fiscal year 25 and 26, the legislature, the state legislature, is trying to increase thresholds because $60,000 is way too low. But I think that it hasn't passed because it needs some fleshing out to do. But again, my commitment to you is to make sure that I'm trying to provide those reporting tools for you and getting you more information and providing that. So this is exciting stuff. Th hank you for your discussion today. I really appreciate it. Destiny? I am excited about the changes, and I hope that everything goes well because it does take a long time for some things, and people don't like that. They don't like to wait. So as long as you can PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: streamline, I'm in agreement with Monica, and I like the way this is going. K. Armenia, you don't have to speak if you don't want to. I can guess, knowing you, that you lik CITY STAFF: ke it, hopefully. Counselors, same feedback. Oh, Travis. Sorry. Chair, everybody. Sorry. Chair, real quick. I like this. I like being able to brainstorm and get feedback before things go through the people that will eventually approve. So it's been nice. I've been with the city for about almost four years. Would it be nice to have a cabinet secretary that could approve everything? I mean, I guess for speed-wise, yes. Things don't go through the legislature for a reason. I mean, they only meet a couple times a year, so it makes sense that contracts don't. But we just live in a diffe PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: erent environment, and being that's the case, I like this. Thank you for working with us. Oh, I will say to staff that I think all of us view us as a team. And so this, I'm hoping this is an opportunity, especially on issues around finance, that we can be a team and do a lift tog JAMIE CASSUTT: gether, the administration and the counselors. Counselors, same question. Councilor Bustamante. So I know again, we're, I know we're still working on this. I do see benefit to the way that we're doing these. I'm just not sure about the frequency. I'm always trying to be cognizant of time and what we're imposing on others, especially staff. I don't want to use this as an exercise to create more work for them ultimately in terms of how often we're going to need them here and how late we're going to keep them and those sort of items. So still t PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: trying to CITY STAFF: figure that out. Thank you. Pass it. I have some words from Armenia, where she said, "I agree, and this would be a huge improvement to our processes. This would only improve the impact that we make to our projects, initiatives, and improvements around the city of Santa Fe." So really looking at this efficiency. Let's scroll back. I'm going to for a little bit of like subject, more detailed subject matter piece. Another component that we've been discussing, and this might help with some of the balance that we're concerned about, is this idea that contracts can show up and be approved on a governing body agenda on the same night. Maybe some of the places that we are concerned around balance, there could be a bit of a compromise there. If there's something that we're not quite feeling comfortable enough to say, "You know what? Go ahead." If we can say, "Hey, this just has to show up at governing body, and if we approve it, go for it." So that might be a good intermediary step, and it also could be a really, I mean, I think we should be doing that for any contract that we're seeing at this point. We have the opportunity to yank them off, throw them to committee if we have a problem with them. But I do wonder how that discussion can interplay with this one, especially in some of these areas where we're like, "Oh, I don't know about this." It might be a great way to experiment with it where we still have a check, but we're not throwing it through all these committees. We're speeding up that process. We're not making our committee liaisons have to do quite as much because they're not having to deal with these contracts on that committee level. So, something else to think about as we're doing this. In terms of the process, I would agree, where is the balance? I think what I really like here is kind of these conversations around some of these base ideas, and it gives this, where maybe some of the concerns that people have, it starts to socialize the idea a little bit more. Normally, the public doesn't watch our committee meetings, but if they did, they may have some thoughts, which I would definitely welcome some emails if anybody is watching this and is like, "Hey, you know what? It'd be a great idea." I think that we do need to figure out the next step from this conversation to drafting. So that's, I don't want to make it so there's so many presentations that staff is having to prepare, but almost like maybe one conversation, maybe two. But then at some point, I think that whoever's sponsoring needs to just take and draft. And then we can come back as well with already drafted legislation. And so that way, we're able to have those conversations so we're not throwing out amendments. But I think that we should experiment with bringing something that is more fully baked to the committee to say, "Hey, here's something that we are basically ready to introduce. We want to get feedback so we can make any changes prior to introduction." And once it's on that introductory train, it just keeps going. So, I think it'd be interesting to look at that, and I think maybe that might be maybe less work for staff, maybe not, but something to try out. Thank you. Councilor Castro: Thank you, Chair, and thank you to the committee. I agree with sort of both, that I, with staff, that this is a gre ALMA CASTRO: eat process. I am a little bit cautious, as Councilor Bustamante mentioned, on overloading folks. I think we all are trying to be cautious with people's time. However, Deputy City Manager Phillips, I think going back to your point, having things ready baked and having things a little bit more fleshed out before we get it to Marsha's team is super important. It's something that I think we're all trying to really focus on. And so if there's anything we can do to get these huge pieces of legislation a little bit more ready, I think that we should continue to do it. Thank you. Okay, that is awesome feedback. I agree with many points that were made. I think it's help PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: pful to staff, but I also agree we can't hold legislative concepts up in like five, six, seven, eight, nine, ten meetings about the same topic. I think my colleagues are correct in that, I think once, twice, boom, draft the legislation and bring it back to the committee as a legislative draft. Because this process could become cumbersome instead of expediting. And so I do like the feedback of my colleagues. I think that is a really good idea. I take this concept that we just went through tonight. We agreed with 80%, I would say. So then staff can run with that. There's two points: it's delegation of power, and then it's also the bars. I'm willing to have, if staff is willing to have one more meeting about those two things, but then we got to draft. And we got to get the draft done and get it back to the committee for review. And so I agree that, as Chair, I won't, I probably won't tolerate more than two meetings on a given issue, unless there's, the committee's will is like, "We need one more meeting about this." But I don't want this to become a cumbersome process where we're just endlessly taxing staff, and it's a way to stall things and do some filibustering and some other awesome political things. So awesome. Thank you guys all for your feedback. This is anything we can think of to make this process better. We need to be leaning into that. So thank you everybody for participating. This is a work in progress, and we need to be fully transparent in how we think it's going because we're learning as we're going. Okay, so thank you, Andrea and Monica and Destiny and Travis and Armenia. You guys are awesome. Next, we have matters from staff. Just a quick reminder, there are only two meetings left for the CITY STAFF: e year of 2026. One meeting is November 9, and the last meeting of the year is December 7th. Anything from the members? Chair, just want to publicly acknowledge again a PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: all the department, well, a JAMIE CASSUTT: all the city personnel that have responded to the recent crisis. It was such a quick response, and just want to thank them again. Thank you. Thank you, Councilor Cassett. Yeah, I would reiterate that comment. Obviously, Councilor Bustamante and mine and Counci CITY STAFF: ilor Barrett's and Councilor Travis' districts were the ones hit. And the amount of support that I've seen from the community, the city responding to a disaster that we did not play, I mean, this is, we don't do tornadoes. That's, we do wildfires, we do floods. Like, this is not, this is not in our wheelhouse. And so really just seeing the amount of coordination that's happening, for the public, we, there's coordination meetings happening twice a day with making sure that everybody's checking in and knowing what's happening and really preparing for not just the immediate response, but the response that will need to be ongoing. So, just, if you are somebody that has been impacted or know that somebody, you know, know somebody who's been impacted that still needs support, please, please reach out to us, and we'll connect you to the appropriate staff who are doing incredible work as well as some of our partners with 211 and Red Cross and a lot of the community partners who are stepping up. So really, really grateful to everybody who has been part of this response. Thank you. Thank you. Councilor Castro. Yeah, just echoing the same. Thank you everyone for all the hard work. It's amazing that we are living th ALMA CASTRO: hrough something that I had never seen, a tornado in Santa Fe, and, you know, we really stepped up. And then just really quickly, going to remind folks that tomorrow, 4:30 at the main library, Chat with Pat or Habla Con Alma, if that's how you prefer. We'll be there talking about land use and the future of Santa Fe. Thanks. Right. From the Chair, I also want to echo my colleagues. I think all of us have gone PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: and seen the area that was impacted by the tornado. We, I know that in the county, we lost a life. The weather this weekend was pretty serious by comparison to what we're used to dealing with. I want to thank the City Manager of Public Works. I, I don't know, there's so many staff that are helping and our community partners, and then our community members. Like, I think you really see the soul of Santa Fe in that, as soon as humanly possible, not only did the city respond, but community members responded to this incident. And I think that says a lot about who we are as a community. And I'm saddened by the things that's happened, but I'm also really proud of Santa Fe for leaning into one another and standing up and being good community members. And so, I just want to thank everyone for all the hard work that is going into the recovery of this weather situation. That being said, our next meeting is November 9. And with that, we're, Madam Chair. Yes? Sorry for, we, I know it's already passed, but we do have somebody here for public comment. CITY STAFF: Would you allow that? Sure. Two minutes. Thank you. Thank you very much. My name is Steven Fox, found PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: der of United Nations. I have PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEVEN FOX): two separate one-minute statements. The European Commission was headed by a woman named Ursula von der Leyen. She's a crook. She's a genocidal crook, and then a deal with the CEO of Pfizer for over €1,000,000,000, all secret, and she survives four or five replacement attempts. So this morning, I suggested to the King and Queen of Spain, wouldn't it be great training for your daughter, the next Queen of Spain, to take her place for a year or two or to buy from that office? But also, the good news, I mean, that's good news. Nothing, only good news is this is the second person in the European Commission who is from Spain. So why not move that forward? And the second next time is, this is going to startle some of you. Some of you, maybe you heard this the other day. City of Santa Fe versus Pfizer. I finally convinced Mayor Garcia to move forward with the case. Still to him and the temporary damage case against Pfizer for vaccine injuries in New Mexico. It's out of me, not, not the State Attorney General. That would take too long, too cumbersome. However, the City Attorney, Ryan Moyer, also has been very enthusiastic about this. Not, not last week was very important to me because I know thousands of people know in the international world, and we were going to move forward with this. Florida is suing the 500 for $10,000 for making them 15,000, and they're over 65. You know, in an emergency room, Chief, Chief Police, and they told me, said in an emergency room, it looks like it's cost $100,000. So what Florida is asking for is some change. I want to encourage some further dialogue between you, Councilors, and the Mayor, and the City Manager to discuss the logistics of how Santa Fe Pfizer victims can present their case and come forward. They're going to need more than two minutes. It wouldn't be in this room. It wouldn't be too many of them. It's a medicine center. So do you have any question? If you think of some questions after this, you can email me. You can also, please, avail your thoughts of, on this vital subject. How are we going to bring justice to the