Regular Finance Committee Meeting - Second Monday Tue, Oct 13, 2026 · Finance Committee https://santafeminutes.space/meeting/945-finance-oct-13-2026 == Executive Summary == The Finance Committee meeting on 10/13/2026 focused heavily on reforming the city's numerous committees, boards, and commissions, as well as streamlining the legislative process. A key goal is to eliminate inactive committees, standardize terminology, and implement term limits to improve efficiency and public participation. The committee also discussed a new process for vetting legislation publicly to increase transparency and allow councilors to discuss items more openly. Significant discussion revolved around identifying and removing "red" or non-functioning committees from the city's books, with staff tasked to provide a list for review. The committee also explored a pilot program for the Finance Committee to vet legislation, aiming to expedite the passage of certain items and potentially lead to the formation of a dedicated legislative committee. Future topics include legislation to streamline the City Manager's contract signing authority and further discussion on term limits for both committee members and elected officials. While no major legislative decisions were made, the committee approved its agenda and consent agenda. Action items include staff preparing a list of inactive committees, legislative staff preparing a version of "orphan" legislation, and the committee providing feedback on proposed committee reform legislation to its sponsors. == Key Decisions == - Approved the agenda by unanimous voice vote. - Approved the consent agenda by unanimous voice vote. == Motions & Votes == - Approval of Agenda — Passed by unanimous voice vote - Approval of Consent Agenda — Passed by unanimous voice vote == Public Comment == A constituent expressed a desire to reactivate the Parks and Recreation Advisory Committee due to concerns about Fort Marcy Park trees. Councilor Castro announced an upcoming "La Posada" event in District 3, seeking volunteers and thanking various city departments and the Northern New Mexico Toy Drive for their support. == Topics == - Committee Structure Reform - Term Limits for Committees - Public Participation & Feedback - Committee Effectiveness & Purpose - Staff Burden & Resources - Legislative Vetting Process - Committee Membership Qualifications - Airport Advisory Board - City Manager Contract Authority - District 3 Event == Full Transcript == CITY STAFF: Can we get roll call, Lease? Counci ilor Cassett? Here. Councilor Castro? Councilor Garcia? Here. Councilor Bustamante? Here. Sheriff Faulkner r? Here. We have a quorum. Are we getting approval of the agenda? Anything removed by staff? No, no changes. Move to approve. Second. Can we get a roll call, Lease? Actually, let's... All in favor, say aye. Aye. Okay. Approval of Consent Agenda. Move to a approve. Second. All in favor. Aye. Presentations? None. Presentations? Nope. Okay. So then we're on to the next item on the agenda, which is Legi islative Topics Legi islative Process. This is the committees. Okay. Okay, everyone. So this is the process that we've been talking about. I hope everyone read the memo. We're trying a new process on the standing committees to vet legislation so that some of the sausage making is public facing, and then also so that counselors can have a dialogue about legislation without violating the Open Meetings Act. And so the topic tonight is the committee process and how we want to maybe get rid of some committees that aren't functional. What do term limits look like? So the hope is we can take some of these bigger initiatives and some critical pieces of legislation, and we can vet them in one of the standing committees and get the amendments worked out and all the stuff that happens behind the scenes that really taxes State Legislative staff, that we can kind of handle those out in a public facing way where we can talk to each other as a collective. And to be clear to the public, any city councilor and the mayor can attend these meetings and participate in the dialogue. There will be no official action such as introducing legislation or passing legislation in this space. But one action that could happen is that the committee could say, "Let's draft this legislation. I think we're ready to pull the trigger on it." And, hopefully, that moves legislation a little bit faster for the community and for the council and for the administration. And it's really just a way of trying to pull us all together in a public facing manner so that we can just move initiatives through the city. So with that, is there anything... I know we have items on here about what we want to talk about. What do you... I'm kind of... Because this is a new process, I'm kind of open to feedback from staff or the committee about how we want to proceed. I know we have some items on here. Let me find them. Oh, we don't have as many items as I'd... So do we want to start with talking about ter rm limits? Should we start with maybe a discussion? Sorry. About the... What the proposed legislation is first. And okay. Perfect. Yeah. Okay. Let's go. Okay. I guess... Yeah. I think you'r re... Yeah. You're taking the lead on this. I am. Yes s. So, part of what we're hoping to achieve with this, there's a few things, but we're looking overall at the committee structure. There are something... And I always forget the exact number, but there's over 45 committees on the books right now. A lot of these have not met in a long time, so they're just kind of hanging around. Some of our committees are required by, you know, ordinance or statute, so we need to determine which ones those are. So we're hoping to basically get some of those older committees that are not meeting off the books, so to speak. We are hoping to standardize the language surrounding committees. Right now, there's things such as committees, special ad hoc committee, commission, board. So we're hoping to kind of standardize the language built around those. One of the topics that has come up is term... our term limits. So, yeah, maybe that's a lead-in to what topic we can discuss. Ye eah. And I'd like to run these kind of like a study session in the sense of, like, you may be a little more informal than we normally would be on a standing committee because I want free flow of thought to happen in these discussions. So do we want to take up term limits first as a discussion? Just a clarification, be ecause we have two types of committee. We have our standing city council committee, which we are in right now, and our resident advisory committees. We are specifically talking about resident advisory committees, not city council committees. Just not standing committees. Yeah. Not council standing committees. Yeah. And I actually... Just because I'm a little bit new, though I've been getting some briefings. Thank you all for being collaborative. I don't know this legislation or the ideology so in-depth. I would like to start a little bit more from a higher thousand foot. Yes. If you could. Because from my perspective, I will just talk about some of the difficulties I've had in one of our advisory boards, CDC currently, and some of my ideas and ideologies around what that committee looks like and what it does. So we don't currently have a very robust participatory anything at the city of Santa Fe. And we, I think, collectively sort of agree that our public input process is broken. So though it's not a great execution of this, it is the only mechanism we have right now to hear from the community in terms of, like, a participatory budgeting, sort of what we tried to do at the beginning of the year, but this is an actual recommendation process. So I would like to keep that intent of hearing from the public and giving community access to decision making in a recommend... How would I say that properly? Recommendary role, if th hat makes any sense, Chuck. I can provide some history because I've... Believe my first foray into this was actually before Marcy was here. So, where this came from... Gosh. I actually remember sitting with Kira Ochoa and Julie Sanchez before COVID talking about this. So where this came from is a few things. One, all of these committees are... They take a lot of time and energy out of staff. And at that time, it was community Services Fund we were talking about, you know, the amount of time and energy that staff was dedicating to these. But as it's gone on, it's really been this concept, you know, to your point, all my counselor, about that this is supposed to be the mechanism by which we get community feedback. It doesn't really do that. See, there's a few that are a bit unique in the sense that they have assigned activities, CDC being one of, children and youth commission. Obviously, the land use boards are their own beast. But there's no way that we actually find out what's happening in those committees unless sometimes if there's a council chair, which seems to be a bit random, whether or not there is one, and I think may just have occurred based on special interests of counselors at the time that said committee was established. We don't really get any feedback. If they vote on something, we don't know what that in getting legislat tion in front of the g governing body. Alright. So, Garcia. Thank you for that input. And I kind of like to break things down sometimes to, like, my understanding. So we have boards. We have committees. We have commissions, task forces, and special committees. And so my... I guess, what my take is on this is how effective are each of these? How... What is the responsibilities that they have? And back to your points, how do we utilize that information to make good decisions? I'll just give you my example as being on the airport advisory board now, committee. And for the last few years, it's just been meeting and meeting and meeting. And some of the feedback I got when I became the chair of that advisory board is, like, "Well, we come to get a report from the staff, but you asked really nothing of our opinions on this." Because on that board, there's... There are a very, very large amount of individuals who have a lot to say, have a lot of experience, and have a lot of good direction. Now with a new director, they want to start... Matter of fact, we're talking about having a mission. We're having... We're looking at our bylaws. We're looking at why we exist. And if we don't know those things, then we have no purpose. And if we have no purpose, then why are we even meeting? It's just not just an extra time. Going back to input from the community, I can tell you how many boards that I've chaired over the last four and a half years. And when you ask for public input, there's never anybody from the public that have anything to say. And this is even going to the Blue Bus Board. I've been a chair for the Blue Bus Board, which is a big board and has a big impact on all the northern part of the state for public transit, and you don't really hardly see that many people come. And so, again, how do you get that participation of the public? And if that's the whole purpose of it, then... I don't know. I guess you have it. But, going back to what is by law, by our charter and our code required, or is it just another, "Oh, this committee would sound great. Let's put it together." What is their purpose, and how do they affect our decision making processes as a recommendation? And I think k... I don't know how we come up with some sort of metrics to qualify those things, and I think that's where we got to start. So can I Lease? Go ahead, Councilor Buscay. I just want to say staff put together a really good spreadsheet. That's what I was going to say. Talking about what the establishing legislation was for these committees as well as the reason why we may have them. Now what you bring up is a very valid point that came up in our discussion is some of these committees have floundered because they didn't know what they were there for. You know, we can look at some of them where, you know, looking at the meeting minutes for the meetings they had. That was their entire discussion is, "Well, what can we do? What are we here for?" And then they... Some of the em just kind of drifted off and fell apart, but they're still on the books. Right. And I think to the point of having a counsel... I mean, there's a reason why counselors are on these committees. And going back to how many times do we bring back that information from those committees that we're on to bring back to the governing body in a format that is useful? Or another just report. Okay. Thank you. We've got a long agenda. Pass it on and appreciate it. You're doing a great job. But, you know, there are some things in... Going back to this airport advisory committee is... There's a lot of things that needs attention at our airport, and it's going to really push the direction of where we go, how fast we go, and how much they're going to utilize me as a counselor to bring forth either resolutions or requests to get their agenda passed and what they need, what we need to go. It may not be wh hat the governing body wants, but at least it's there for us to make a decision on. So, staff of Marcy, who we all love to death, can you... Can you come up and just go through the list of... I know we did... The core working group did, like, red, yellow, green, and then we identified some committees that actually aren't even on the books at all, but they're showing up administratively. Do you have that list? And can we just run through it just so that's a good starting point to kind of, like, have the dialogue about, like, let's direct staff. Like, if they're not on the books and they're not functioning, get them out administratively. If... You know what I mean? Like, we can start by looking at the committees s and, like, what... Which ones are functioning and which aren't and why not. Chair Faulkner, counselors, if you give me two seconds, I think this is in an email. I have that pulled up. Yeah. I have it pulled up. If you want me to read them off, I can. Yeah. Read those off. This was such a good project. Yeah. So here are the committees, boards, commissions, etcetera, that we identified as red, i.e., not functioning, never met in some cases. Nobody was ever appointed, or they just haven't met in a number of years. And so these are the ones that we identified: the Civil Defense Council, the Flow Task Force, the Homelessness Task Force established in 2018, the... Oh, no. Wait. Oh, yeah. Long Range Planning Subcommittee, the Municipal Drug Strategy Task Force, Parks and Recreation Advisory Committee, Public Utilities Committee. So that was actually absorbed into Public Works, but still on the books. Summary Committee, Sustai inable Santa Fe Commission, and the College of Santa Fe Local Advisory Group. College of Santa Fe. There's no law. Yes. I'm sure if I could. I just want to... It's interesting how government has evolved, right? Because as one was absorbed, I was saying we have things that function as this. We just assigned a joint city-county long-term planning committee, for example, which seems to me to do the job of that long-term planning subcommittee that we intended. So i it just seems that maybe folks didn't know that these existed and recreated things. Well, I think the long-term planning committee was actually part of land use, part of the Planning Commission. And then under different directorates, I know because I think Lee and I served on the commission together when this was happening. They just weren't doing any... Like, it wasn't happening because we lost our long-range planning staff. So then there was no one to staff it, so then it was replaced with the policy subcommittee, which kind of does the same thing. But... So, like, a question for the committee is, do we feel like these red things we can say to legislative staff? Let's consider just putting those in a space where at least in a draft piece of legislation, we can easily get those off the books because they're not functioning. They're... . And that's the question. I'm just... I'm not saying we should or should not. I'm posing the question to the committee. I think that's probably smart to do. We need to take an inventory back to this point. You mentioned the Summary Committee. I was the chair of the Summary Committee when it got abolished and put the responsibilities onto the land use director. Wh hy didn't it come e off the books with the A Resolution that was created? And is it in our... Is it in our code or is it in our charter to have that? And what is it? The Summary Committee? The... Yeah. It just dealt with lot splits and minimal land use cases. Would this say, surveys, plot surveys, and things for... Like low-hanging fruit on the land. Small... Let's just say you had a two-and-a-half-acre lot and you wanted to split it. Well, you would... Now it was all handled administratively. Didn't have to come to the committee, and we had... Actually, there were some rules there that if somebody notice had to go out to the neighbors, adjoining properties, adjacent properties, they'd get a letter. If they had a dispute over what was going to happen, then they could actually bring it back to the Planning Commission for a judgment if they weren't in agreement with the land use director's decision. So, obviously, there was a rule that was... I don't know what created the Summary Committee. However, when it got taken back away, the responsibilities of that... Because it was a vote, we had to actually have a roll call and everything. It was, I think Brian Gutierrez was the first... Was chair before me. Yep. And then when I was sitting chair, it got removed. I remember meeting wit th Councilor over it, and they brought forth either a RESOLUTION NO something to get rid of that and then put it back on the land use director. So what happens after that is why is that committee still on the books if that A Resolution was put forth? Right. And some of this is just housekeeping because a couple of those were brought up that it's cleanup. But some of the other ones that have been, you know, questioned where they should be ready, I'll bring up one of the big ones, Parks and Recreation Advisory Committee, which hasn't met in a very long time. And when the legislation was brought up that created that, you know, a lot of these have specific goals or visions in mind. It's the purpose, right? And that may not be something that's still relevant for today. The Civil Defense Council, for example. That's a huge one, right? Obviously, we're not going to need to defend Santa Fe from foreign invaders anymore, right? So, you know, why is that something like that on the books? And there's nothing saying that because we pull it off today that we can't reintroduce it again tomorrow with a more... Wi ith a better vision... A clear vision of what people are... What their job NO Councilor Castro, you were biting. Thank you. Yes. I just... This is a perfect example because I've had constituents specifically asking for us to appoint this board again because of the situation that happened with the trees at Fort Marcy, right? And so I think that we do really need to think about the intent. The Parks and Rec... No. No. No. Sorry. Parks and Rec boards. We... Because it's a fort, and we need to continue... No. Sorry. When there was some concern about the updates of Fort Marcy Park, there was a call by constituents around Fort Marcy Park to bring back the advisory board, also where the tree board sits and, like, what are some of these other advisory boards. So I will offer... I emailed everyone on the committee a white paper that we got last year, I believe. Is that right, Councilor Kesset? Around civic assemblies or citizens' assemblies. I think you all have heard me talk about this before. I do have a piece of legislation around civic assemblies putting that as a tool in our toolbox, and this would be sort of a one-issue advisory board that has a very specific task that we are giving really clear direction to. So if there are sort of pet projects, which is one thing... So orry. I'm still recovering. If there are projects that are very specific that have a start and end date, maybe we don't need to create new commissions and boards. Maybe we do it in a different way. So one thing I would offer is in this process as chair, if anyone wants to take up, like, a Priority List, civic assembly, we can pull that onto this process as well. And, like, it's a way of kind of fast-tracking priorities, right? So, what I was saying about the committees is do we need a Summary Committee if we have a Tree Committee if the issue was the trees, right? So we don't need to duplicate, right? So in my mind, I'm like, well, if we have a Tree Committee that has decent amount of powers, very active, cares about what they're doing, pro... Like, they're engaged, and they're doing a good job according to what everyone says. We don't need to bring about the Summary Committee because we have the Tree Committee to address the tree issue, right? And so I think, like, what we're trying to get to is what's a good first step on a possible piece of legislation from the Finance Committee that says everything in red, we've identifie ed as not functioning, not even really on... They're on the books administratively, but not legally. Can we say to legislative staff in this building piece of legislation, all the reds, you can just take them off? Just to address a point, so it's not called a civic assembly, but there is something already in the books, special ad hoc committ tee that has a start date, a stop date with a report due to this governing body. And after that report is given, the board... The committee is by ordinance, supposed to dissolve. So we already have something in there. Reid. And I think we can just state it. What I would like to see, and I think that this is a great... If we have something in code already that we can utilize, the only addition would be that we give them a little bit more teeth. So the beautiful piece of the civic assembly that I think I've sort of lobbied for is that, yeah, we commit as government to acting on any recommendations that we can legally. You know, we make some framework, but we actually do give power to c citizenry, sort of like participatory budgeting where we agree we're going to give some power to these folks. And I think that can be accomplished in the establishment. With an amendment. Yeah. I think that'd be great. Sorry. Marcy. I actually... Thank you, Chair Faulkner, Councilor Castro. I think you just said what I was getting ready. I wanted to make it really clear. It's been a minute since I've read a couple of you had things about civic assemblies. I think you may have two at one point, Cast... Councilor Cassette. That they're not quite the same as the other types of ad hoc committees because they specifically... If I'm remembering correctly, they rely on a lottery system where you strategically get community voices involved, and it's not an appointment. It's actually a lottery where interested people who are interest ted in contributing are assigned to a topic, and are often used to resolve really, really tricky community issues. And so... Right? Yeah. So I just wanted to draw that quick distinction. And we do almost have a couple examples. Our Redistricting Committee, our, the salary, the Charter Review... Charter Review not quite because Charter Review still has to come to us for approval. Redistricting, they redistrict, we don't get a vote. The salary... The Independent Salary Review Committee, they set the mayor's salary. We don't get a vote. It's just that's what happens. So we do have some that are similar, and the redistricting actually literally is they pull names out of a hat. At least that's what they've done in the past. I think the big difference between that and a civic assembly, though, is a civic assembly aims to get a representative sample of the population. So you are looking, you know, across the various demographics and geographies to actually get a... Whereas our redistricting, we just, like, yank them. But it does it does bring up the point that... So the Municipal Drug Force... Drug Strategy Task Force is on here. That was a task force that had a limited amount of time. They had a report. They gave it to us in, I think, beginning of 2020. And so it should be off the books because they've already completed their work. And I think I think that's something that we've... We probably do not utilize enough. And there's a lot of ways that we could use these, you know... So for example, the Sustainable Santa Fe Commission. When we're coming up with our sustainability plan, that's a really great time for us to, you know, have a task force that's going to help us with that, you know, five, ten-year plan. We actually probably... Interestingly enough, maybe... Well, I guess we kind of are doing that with the general plan with, like, the COG and the COG and whatever they're called at this point. So... But we may want to look at how we how we determine those memberships. And one thing that I feel like we need to look at for most of these, is some type of experience. Because if we are saying, hey. We really actually... You know, we want these advisory committees to have impact, whether it's authority or impact, I want them to really know what they're doing. So EDAC is actually a really great example, and it's taken me years to get there. But, like, the group that we have in EDAC is brilliant and perfect for this for this committee. And it took a long time to get there, and that was, you know, really intentional, for me and, both mayors who've appointed around, like... And, honestly, the, Office of Economic Development team and looking at the applicants and saying, we have a hole in this arena. We don't have anybody who's in the arts maker space. We don't have anybody in education. We don't have anybody in tech, and really trying to target those. And I think that as we're going through this, yeah, and I would say yes, strike everything that's not functioning. And then I think we need to take a look at what's there and what their pieces are. But I would really like to look at membership to have a good combination on any committee that has expertise, education, p professional experience as well. And then on the flip side, also having some of the kind of larger pieces that would come into play or larger community members that would come in by. Catch Lee first. Mr. Garcia. Yeah, it's going to take an inventory, see what's working, establish criteria as to how these groups are working on, what is their mission, what are their goals, and how do we use that information to make the decisions? Because that's what it's supposed to be. And I get it. The hard part is getting people to... I have people who say, "Hey, I'd like to be a part of a committee." And then I've gone to them and it's, "No, we're not." They kind of want to be involved. But how do we establish the criteria? How do we establish the rules that they're going to? And then how do we give them a goal and an end date? You can't just let something go on and on and on because you put people in the same room. They just want to talk to themselves, to each other. Exhibit it. They just go. There's no video. Yeah, here's what it is. Here's why we're existing, and here's the decision that we have to make. Is i it this or is it this? Okay, so give them clear direction as to what that is because I think that's the biggest deal. Yeah, NO Councilor Garcia, we have made this list. Staff has, including the city clerk. I think the meeting, how many people were there, Councilor Bustamante? Like, the whole conference room? Yeah, pretty much. Yes, so it was like the... You were there NO Councilor Cassette. It was like the whole, all the staff that deals with this stuff, and that's how we came up with the red, green, and yellow, is that staff looked into, in purple, staff looked into what's functioning, what's not functioning, what's operating, what isn't, what's off the book, what's not on the... Like, what can be... We did already do the inventory discussion. And so if you want, we can go through that again. Like, that's why I'm saying we can't. Okay, lesson learned already. We're going to be all over the map because th his is a creative space, but this will not work if we don't give direction. Right? So as a committee, are we saying... Oh, sorry, Marcy. Chair Faulkner, thank you, counselors. I just wanted to quickly say something because I wasn't sure where you all are headed with this conversation. We had the meeting that Councilor Faulkner is describing. We categorized things in the colors. And then without talking to you all, I had my staff, I had Palmer start pulling the reds that I don't already have included in a RESOLUTION NO a bill. Because I already... I don't know if you guys remember, but I was talking about orphans a long time ago where we had these pieces of legislation, and I kind of wanted to put them on an orphan board and be like, "Speak now or forever." I'm going to take them off my list because I want a shorter list. But this one got pulled to keep, and Paul has adopted the orphan. And I have one bill and OF RESOLUTION that are already dedicated to a bunch of these reds, actually, and all I have to do is add the reds that are not already there. So I had Palmer go, and he's out today. But one of the first things I was going to do with him today was take a look at his research because I think all we have to do is add them to the RESOLUTION NO I'm not sure I need you all to... Do you need to do that? Unless, I mean, there's... You all are talking about, and this kind of gets back to the memos number one about how best to utilize this kind of activity that you are doing. We have like a giant legislative list. Right? And you all have seen different versions of it because it's not a secret anymore. Right? And you can connect with us and ask us to see the most recent version. It's a fluid document. It's an Excel spreadsheet that my team and I keep. When we have a minute, we put the new JotForms into it and blah. That is a big list, and one of my big things that my office grapples with on a regular basis is to know how to prioritize that list of 73 items. So, you all could give me five things to work on, but if I only have two or three staff working at a time, and you guys know what this feels like because you all are often wanting to know what's going on with your legislation. So part of wh hat I think could be really useful is you all helping me to know how to put my staff organized in context with multiple projects. So I would... You know, I would offer, Marcy, that one of the things that is good about this new process, mm-hmm, is you have five city councilors sitting here. Mm-hmm. So if we say take the reds and get rid of them, you have the majority of the council publicly and without violating rolling quorum saying this is... You got this. This will be a slam dunk. That's a a slightly different topic than prioritizing. But I would think that if I was prioritizing, I'd be like, this will go, this will pass. Yes. And I also would offer, if I may, and then I'll be quiet, but this is a great piece of legislation to get out of my queue. Right. There's two pieces here, and it's low-hanging fruit. The legislation is basically all it... Already drafted. All I have to do is add the ones that were not here yet. And Palmer was finding that some of them don't have enabling legislation. So we... It really is just like, clean up your books. You know what I mean? So, like, I think this is a great one to kind of put... There's like different categories. Right? There's... It's a priority because it's really important because it has a huge impact on your community. It's a priority because it has an external deadline that we can't get around. It's... These are the kinds of things that'll pop it to the top of the queue. It's a p priority because it's almost done. Just get it out the door, and this is in that bucket. Well, that's like the hope of this process. We have talked with staff round and round about how this process is going to work, and I keep cautioning people this is a new process, so we're going to be learning the whole time. But I do feel like this is a space and this is an example where legislative staff goes, five counselors are saying do this, get rid of this. You have the majority of the council. Let's get it off the books. Like, let's move it. And, Chair, if I could, thank you so much for allowing us to vet this process here at Finance. It sounds to me like your recommendation could be State Legislative team kind of works with the Chair on what low-hanging fruit is and what counselors might have buy-in so that we could get some of those things through the queue more easily. For example, I know all of us would support cleaning up this bill. And now that we've spoken about it publicly, we could potentially have five sponsors going forward. Yeah, which is wonderful. That's not always going to be the case, but I think your team would know best what pieces of legislation that would work with. That's a good point. And I do... I think there is a nuance in that. I have to still talk to Marcos about, like, if we, five of us talk about it on the record, it's not formally introduced, but it is on the, but it is on the record, and it's now no longer a situation of a rolling quorum or the, or the possibility of that happening. We could have however many people want to jump on because it's on the public record. So this is a space where we can work really well with the administration. Like, we can find spaces where it's like the five of us, and then the Mayor, the Mayor is very interested in this as well. Like, he's on the legislation with Paul and I. And so then it's like, well, the en you know you have six. Right? It's public. It's not a secret. So then to me, I'm like, well, then that's legislation that you know is going to go. Let's go. Move it. So I just, I think that's great for clearing the books around on some of things, but I just caution for doing that with some other things because I have other stuff in the hopper that I would say is a much higher priority than this. But this is something that s seems, seems like we could just kind of push through because of the fact that it is written already. So this is basically done. Maybe for team, then is our individual priority different than what you would be bringing in a scenario, not hypothetica al scenario, what you're bringing to committee for discussion, but then we also would have our individual Priority List. You could, like, as Chair, I would accept, if there was a piece of legislation that we kind of were like, okay, this is a, we need to talk about this. Right? Like, we need to talk about homelessness or, and that will be on these agendas. So I'm also leaving this open for, like, not just legislative concepts, but legislation that we are like, okay, this has to move. Right? And so, that's kind of like, we're learning again. It's going to be a little all over the map in the beginn ning because it's a new process, but everybody weigh in on all things. Councilor Garcia, you're always quiet, but t I alway ys know you've got something wise to offer us. I'm still listening at this point, but I, I, you know, I, I think that going forward in regards to discussion over our, our priorities or whatever it may be. You know, I think collaboration with each other, we're here in open format. Also, understanding and knowing that staff and what they have, have, I mean, there's, there's so much that they're doing. And so, I think we have to be respectful of tha at as well. I mean, it's great conversation. I'm obviously, I'm absorbing a lot of it because there's so much work that's already being done and, just leave it at that. Thank you. . Okay, so can we, for getting back to the committee's discussion, does the committee feel like the reds can be adde ed to the list that's already an established piece of legislation? I would like to see a version if it's legally feasible. It is. Yeah. I would love to see a version w with the new reds. So I think we can bring back that back to this committee at our next Finance Committee meeting. Yeah, we can. If staff, Marcy, does that work for you guys? Oh, damn it. Chair Faulkner, counselors, one thing that makes me a little bit nervous about promising to have something done in a week is, is that, or two weeks or, is that sometimes we do have things come up like amendments or, that are not predicted. You know what I mean? Or we have fires that we didn't realize were coming or, you know, that kind of thing. I I, I would want to make sure that I didn't promise things that we couldn't actually deliver. Do you know what I mean? Yes. At the same time, I'd want to try to figure out how to work with this idea. So I think Marcina has, have talked about, is the committee comfortable with, Marcy and I are going to meet, like, two, like, I think we talked about two weeks before the next Finance Committee meeting so that her staff would have knowledge about what we might be wanting to see in this arena of a policy discussion. And so I think if the committee is comfortable, we can say, like, I can meet with Marcy and be like, what can and what can you not do? And then if you can't do it, we can put it on the next one. I don't think there's a rigid "have to have it done," but I do think it'd be good for r momentum to have targets. And if we don't meet the targets, it's okay. We'll meet the next target. But at least if we can try to target things so we keep a little bit of momentum. Does that work, Marcy? I'm looking at Indira too because she's my, we're like the monkeys blasting in just a couple of other in the shed. Yeah. Mayor Faulkner, counselors. One thing I just do want to point out is that, and I know this is probably on your minds, sometimes it is actually slower to draft in a group. If you all had to come to a consensus before we settled on something in our draft, that might take longer to actually introduce that draft. And so even n though you're having great conversations that are real policy conversations, it might not always make sense to have a piece of legislation that we're all working together at these meetings. I would say that's part of why bringing the draft. So I think this discussion is more direction. Marcy and I were having this conversation about the last study session with these governing body procedural rules. My question for her was, do you have enough direction to know in general where to go? And for the most part, yeah. But I think that this could be another opportunity where right now we're saying, okay. Go ahead. Axe those rents. And I would say when the ability for this team to get it done, knowing that this is an interest to bring back, and you guys are able to get that draft in because there are a lot of moving pieces, then communicate with the chair and get something on the agenda. But then that does give us the option to take a look at this legislation at this point in time and be like, alright. Did this... You know, what shifts or changes would we want to see here? And I do think it might take a little bit longer. That's actually why I think this one's actually probably a good one to experiment with because it's not that detrimental if we don't get this done quickly. If we have some fits and stops, we'll be able to... The e city's still marching along. It's not something like code enforcement, which that gets a little bit stickier. May I? Yep. Nope. Absolutely. One thought I'm also having as a caution is that in this scenario, it feels great because we have Counselor Bustamante who... This is Counselor Bustamante's project. So you're comfortable having this conversation because it's yours. But I don't know if there's... You might want to think carefully about if we have legislation. This is why a whole group legislative committee might be less fraught for me because I wouldn't want decisions being made here about somebody's legislation that isn't sitting here with you. That puts my office in kind of a difficult position. So, an example might be we have some ideas about enforcement and working with the landlord, the tenants act. Trying to maybe set up a... I don't know how much I want to say right now because I don't know how much permission I have to talk about it. But that one has a smattering of people that are not on this group. Yeah. And it is in that category where we have lots of good interest in it. Several of you are interested in it. But that gets a little bit tricky too, and that's a thought t I just want to plant in your minds. Well, and I also think this is to your point around a primary sponsor where the benefit of a primary sponso or actually really assists. So, you know, when I get... That's what I was going to bring up is, you know, we had that discussion at our governing body study session of having a primary sponsor. And so appointing a point guard or two people that are to take the lead on it, which would be the liaison communication for the rest of the group, so to speak. And I think going to act towards including a legislative committee, and now we're going back into now discussi ing procedural stuff. But that's what I was going to say. I can only offer as chair. I'm not going to pull someone's piece of legislation onto my committee if they don't want it on the committee. That's not going to happen. But there is enough of us. Every committee is representative of every district. And so we... There's multiple sponsors of legislation on the code enforcement issue. And so those who want their legislation vetted on the finance committee, we'll pull those on the finance. If you don't, then we won't. I think it's... I don't think this is a "have to." I think this is a "want to" scenario. And in this pa articular situation, I'm hearing that you'd like us to move this just because it's ready. It would get it out of the queue. It's on its way. It's the first move among some others that you guys are. I know you've been interested in taking a look at other components of committees, and some of those things are listed here on your memo for this evening. But, yeah, I think it... We might want to really think carefully about the concept of the primary sponsor as being a tool that we can use in situations where not everyone is there. But I think it might be possible that there's more that we're not thinking about right now. Like, that could... I think that might could get complex, and it might be comfortable. I'm just thinking about it right now off the top of my head. I'm thinking out loud with you all. It might be safest to, if we're going to do this kind of work, be sure that it is something that one of you are actually working on and are acting as a primary sponsor for maybe because... So that was the... Chair, I'll offer a succession. Yeah. I think that was sort of the point of not only having it at one committee, but having it at all public work committees and so that we can make sure it gets in front of everyone, that there is a sponsor that is... Like, how we introduced it and said, hey, sponsors. Give us a rundown of this legislation. That there's someone to speak to it. But, also, there is no vote that is going to be taken from any of these committees. So I will pose to Indira's earlier point that we are... It might take a little longer, but a lot of legislation, when you get the buy-in at the front end, it'll go through the process much more quickly because there'll be less amendment ts. If I may just ask a question. So if there was somebody acting as a primary sponsor and there were differing pol licy... Sorry. You're talking in the mic. Sorry. Thank you. So o if there was somebody acting as a primary sponsor, and there were differing policy positions, would that primary sponsor come e down on one side and the legislation would say that? I would say so. I mean, and that's where the amendment process gets to happen. And, you know, potentially in this process, maybe there is a meeting of the minds and there is a compromise and maybe not. I mean, that's just, you know, that's just lawmaking. And it very well may say... But I would say that if there's kind of these different ideas... But what's helpful, or at least what I think would be helpful for me if I have a piece of legislation and there are these differing opinions, is this process allows me to think about those in a more constructive manner and potentially be able to make some changes ahead of time as opposed to... You know, as I always say, once that legislation's on the track, it becomes... It's a much bigger deal to stop it. It becomes much more like this political mayhem sometimes as opposed to like, hey. Let's actually... You thought of something I didn't think about. Let's, you know, take a minute to see if we can put this forward. So... But I would say, yes. The primary sponsor would be the one who's like, okay. I want to go this way with this. And then I do think, like, we have the opportunity w with this council. I think we all work well together. I know as chair if Paul and Jamie and Alma and I were on a piece of legislation, but Alma and I started differing in one section of the legislation from Jamie and Paul, then I would encourage that we draft the amendment from the committee. Right? Which we have done this on this council. We have disagreed, and we've drafted amendments together. And so I think this provides a space. And I know we feel like we're free falling a little bit because we're not following kind of a rigid... This is kind of like a creative space in some ways. But I do think that it... You know, I don't think the expectation is you guys are going to be sitting here with a computer writing a piece of legislation while we're talking. That is not the intention. And I think we've had that discussion multiple times, but I will say that what can happen is I do think that the committee can proffer legislation that says, okay. The committee wants to proffer a piece of legislation that says get rid of all the reds. And so the whole committee... And by the way, I invited the other counselors and the mayor to this meeting tonight. This committee will not be voting on whether legislation passes or doesn't pass us. We won't be introducing legislation. So every member of the governing body can attend these hearings and participate. And I made sure everyone was invited. And so this is a space where we can say you have five, six, seven, eight, nine governing body members who are like, get rid of the reds. Right now, you have the majority of the council publicly saying get rid of the reds. That can be a piece of legislation that moves through, and the mayor can join and Liz can... Everybody can join that legislation beca ause it's a public process. Counselor Bustamante. Sorry. I have a kind of a separate question, but this would be per your step. Piece of legislation like this. So we're not just looking at getting rid of the reds. Right? It is committee reform overall. So what is your suggested path to follow, you know, if we are also looking at things such as term limits, if we are also looking at things such as standardizing what the committee makeups may look like, is that something we would then... Would you suggest on a case by case? Or, like, for this particular one, do you suggest we put those items into a separate piece of legislation since the sun setting one is already essentially done? So we e knock that out and then move on with a separate piece. Or... Good question. Counselor Bustamante. I was actually... We were pregaming a little bit today with the clerk's office on this topic. I would want to check in with the city attorney, but I think if it's... Okay. So you have the committees that were established by A Resolution. Alright. I'll say bodies because we use different words. Mission spot... Body. You know? I'll say bodies. That's good. There's some that are established by A Resolution. There's some that are established in code. If we're doing things to the ones that are in RESOLUTION NO amend the resolutions that we're dealing with, like, the body that we're dealing with. If we're amending things about bodies that exist in code, we run a bill. I think we might be able to get away with running... Like, if... Let's say you guys... You all decided to, say, you wanted to do term limits. Let's use that as an example. To standardize that across the board, then we could write one piece of legislation, I think, touching all of the bodies. So, like, if we were going to do a A Resolution that amended the groups that were established by different resolutions, we'd list the resolutions we were amending. So, amending resolutions X, Y, and Z in order to do this standardized thing. So we could do that. It gets a little more complicated if you start wanting to do specific things with specific groups. If you want to do this standardization of firms that I know some people are interested in, what's the board, what's the commission, what's the advisory committee? That gets a little bit more complicated because you really would then start having to amend different ones, I think. And then I just want to... I don't know if this is even appropriate, but this is it. I want to finish this conversation. I have one comment that's unrelated to this about the process of using committees and legislative items like we're doing tonight. And I want to kind of put that in a parking lot real quick, and I want to circle back to it. But first, I want to make sure Councilor Luis de Monterrey's question was answered and have oth her thoughts about that. . No, that answered it pretty well. Thank you. Out of the parking lot. Okay. Counselors, thank you. One thought that I am having is, as a manager of my office, is balancing everybody's loads and all this. If we... And I'm also thinking about staff time for these kinds of things. Don't mean to put you on the spot. This doesn't have anything to do with your area, with finance and where they are living here. And I don't know if you guys are hourly or how they sort of, but I do want to think about that part for my team too because if we're going to have a legislative item at every single committee, my group has to prepare for multiple ones, and that's sort of why we originally said a single committee. So, and it would be a predictable schedule. So we would be able to... This evening, we would know we've got legislation committee, so we would come in later because we'd know we'd be there later. And that's kind of how I do it with governing body. On those days, I come in late so that I can stay late. Well, so I would want my staff doing things, and so I'd want to be a little organized. That's all. That's just a comment I w wanted to make about that. Yeah, so I think this is an opportunity to do a pilot program to see how this would look. And I know Marcy and I have talked several times about how, again, we're going to meet in advance to give her staff advance notice. I do think a legislative committee would be a good idea. I'm not sure we're in a position as a governing body where that's receptive to all members of the governing body, so that's why we're doing it on the finance committee. We don't necessarily have to do it on all committees, but I do think the path forward is that I, as chair, will work with your staff, much like we had planned, to give big notice, two weeks notice about what's coming up next on the finance committee. And again, I think some of the fears around, are we going to be doing stuff that other counselors don't want their legislation vetted? No, we will not. So we can take that off the table. Will we be doing stuff that you're drafting legislation on the fly? No, we will not. So that's off the table. Will you get advanced notice, and we'll work together to make sure that your team has what it needs? And if you can't get it done in two weeks, we push it off to the next meeting. That's off the table too. So I think as chair, I'm willing to work with your staff to get this in the sweet spot so that we can be productive in this process. And again, be mindful. We're learning. We're going to hit some roadblocks, and we're going to hit some challenges, but we're also going to hit a lot of opportunity. So I don't want anyone to feel like because we're doing this process, we are locking anyone into a thing that will be detrimental for their department, for their staff, for the counselors, for the governing body, for anybody. Right? And so we just... I think these are very valid points, and I think we've kind of vetted them in the sense that I've made an agreement with staff as chair that we will work together with plenty of advance notice. And again, I'll repeat this. We will not be putting legislation on this committee that the sponsor doesn't want on the committee. Right? And so, and anyone can attend this committee. Anyone is welcome. The decision to move legislation forward will be guided by... because it's not a formal vote. It will be guided by the members present. So there's no space where there's power grabs or we're expecting something from staff that is unreasonable. And I think it's important that staff knows because Marcy is our Yoda when it comes to legislation that there is no intent to be like, Marcy, tomorrow we're meeting committee. I need you to do this. We've already made a commitment to each other that we will work on this in advanced notice spaces. Okay. I guess the only thing I would just say is tell us when it doesn't work. Yeah. It would just be like, this is too much. No. I mean, tell... It's like, tell us no. You know? Like, I know that's a hard thing to tell counselors, but Lease, when you're... It's like, no, we can't. Like, this is not going to be... I mean, you never say no in that sense, but you'll be like, well, I think that this might be a challenge. Yeah. I I feel like I did a good Marcy impression. I appreciate that, and I just want to say one thing. It's like, I just I do really want to, once again, say how much I appreciate the energy that you all have about working together, and that is so wonderful. And I am the kind of person who will speak up. I think Councilor Faulconer and I said as long as you allow me to cry uncle. Yes. And actually speak up. And I... But I do really appreciate that, Councilor Cassette, because it is hard. You are our elected officials. We... You know, you all really do think of yourselves as human beings just like I am, but you're not. You really are in a special category, and it is hard sometimes to say no. So I appreciate that. But I think we can continue to think about it. My first inclination really is that a single committee with a purpose like what you guys are discussing would be a little easier for my office. The advance notice is nice, but it is also the bulk meetings that get difficult. And I think that might be why you don't have everyone here too because they know they have other meetings coming this week, so they're reserving their time. Do you know what I mean? So I just wonder about that. It's the question. Yeah, and I do think the hope is t that we will form a legislative committee. And I think there wasn't agreement on what that looks like until we knew what it might feel like. And so that's why we offered the finance committee as a test run so people could see what it feels like to... Because this is... I keep saying this. This is completely different than anything we've ever done. And so I feel like offering a space where staff can see what it would look like to look at legislation on a committee and then also for counselors to look at what it's like to kind of do policy decision making in the vetting phase in a public way. Right? So I'm hoping that this is just a pilot project and that we will eventually move into State Legislative committee format because that would be the most productive and smartest way to do it. But I do have to say one thing because I think... I don't want these meetings to go till 9:00 at night. So, I do have to say something about Marcy and Indira and Andrea Phillips and a litany of people at the city clerk's office. So many people have been involved in trying to make this work. And I can say, honestly, Marcy and her team have been incredible, and I tend to get excited about things. And this is where Councilor Garcia is also one of my best partners, is that I'm like, let's do this. And then you're like, but did you think about this, this, this, this, and this? And I'm like, oh, I did not. I was just very excited. So, I do have to say, like, Marcy, your team has been incredible. We've had some hard conversations. We've had, like... But I do want to thank you for believing and trying to fulfill this process and then being willing to say no to me. Right? Like, I hope you know you can always say no to me for sure. But I do want to thank you and your staff for all the thought you put into this, the hours you put into trying to figure out how this process might work. And so I just I just want to say I appreciate you guys so much, and I thank you for all the feedback and the willingness to try this out. And I thank the committee as well for the willingness to do this. Okay. Are we good, committee, on this discussion? Yeah. I have thoughts on some of f the questions. Jump into th hose. Sure. Okay. So for term limits for advisory committees, I think so. I think it is always good to get rotation. I think people get comfortable. When I think about it, most of them have terms of, I believe, two years. And so I would say somewhere between a total of six to eight years as a limit. The land use boards, I'm actually inclined to allowing a little bit longer simply because it takes a while to actually learn and get your feet on the ground. And especially if we want to be looking at expertise, I think that the land use boards will be pretty challenging to get those. I would say that we should give ourselves a fail-safe so that if we are unable to find somebody to replace, that individual can continue to serve until... And not, like, be in... You know, we do this now. Like, you'll continue to serve until that position is replaced. So, like, if it's taking us a while and they wind up serving for an additional nine months, let them serve for an additional nine months. There's no reason to screw back worms. And then, yes, I do think that term limit... Or, I'm sorry, staggered terms are a good idea so that you don't have the whole committee turning over at once, and I think that works really well. So that's my thought on there. I already said committee membership qualifications. I think that at least half, if it's an odd number, then pop that odd to expertise. We should probably not get too prescriptive about it, but this is where the council will have a check. You know? So this is... I mean, we just did this with planning commission where we're like, is there anybody who actually has a land use background on the commission at this moment in time? And that, you know, becomes an important conversation. And so I think that we can we can do a check right there, and that will be the responsibility of the council. But I would say, you know, half. And then Pilar and I had some good conversations around what we might do for planning commission specifically where it's a... where there's two per district and it's maybe, like, one per district is going to be somewhere in that professional realm, and then the other person can be more of a member at large. Financial and informational resource management for committees, I think that this is where we're actually going to have to be kind of brutal with our committee list because if we are unable to actually have the ability for these committees to... Because this goes back for the closing of the feedback loop. I think they probably need to present to the council at least once a year, once every other year with an action plan. And then... So maybe every two years, they're giving us a Presentations for those that are continually going. It's an action plan for the next two years. What do they want to achieve? And then at that, you know, at the end of the next meeting, hey, what did you achieve, and what's your action plan for the next two years? But that also means that we're gonna have to slash some of these committees so that staff has the time and energy. Maybe we more strategically utilize our counselors that way. And then we aren't having to have five committees present at every single governing body session because that is not a good use of our time either. So those are my thoughts on all the questions. And I'll just follow up quickly, counselor, since we're already there. I think that the feedback loop on that last question to you ur point, if we have staff and we have council reporting back, that should help. But if we don't have the capacity to do that, then we won't get it. I was trying to talk to Paul a little bit about that whole planning commission situation because to your point, Councilor Cassette, sorry, we're using first names, Jamie, we had in District 1 for that planning commission appointment, both District 1 counselors vote against the appointment of their own district. And that to me seems awkward. How can you be saying that this person is representing that district when they're not in relationship with those counselors? So if we are gonna continue to do things that are district focused, then we somehow need to have a mechanism for that. Counci ilor Bustamante: Yeah, just some of what we have looked at as well is maybe not necessarily getting rid of committees, but moving them under a parent committee. So, for example, the Veterans Advisory Board just moved under Human Services Fund one of the main reasons is it's less time on staff, essentially. They don't have to be at a, yeah, less burdensome on staff. And so, you know, I think there are cases where we can look at, where we can start moving some of those committees into a bigger parent sort of committee and still get the work done. Sorry, on ne more thing I forgot on closing the feedback loop. If a committee votes on legislation, and obviously it's not binding, but I've had a situation where the entire committee, with the exception of me, voted to deny something. And then they were like, well, what happens? And I was like, nothing. It continues to go into governing body, but I'll be sure to let everybody know that you all disagree. There should be some kind of, there should be like a back loop where the vote of the committee that's a recommend ding committee is reported in the packet. Mhm. That doesn't take, you know what I mean? Like the chair, we could require chairs to write up a memo and say, like, the committee voted d this way. Committee voted six three to pass. This was the reasoning. This was the reason. Enjoy. That's it. Okay. Councilor Garcia, anything? I will just spea ak to the term limits. I think tha at's a good idea. I can even think that it needs to be something looked at for council members and the mayor. I also think that in regards to the committee processes, there should be some feedback and something that we can actually see of what their intention was. And is it the thing? I think that's it. Expertise, binding committees. Oh, good. Thanks. Mr. Ca astro, NO Councilor Bustamante? ? I'll happily work k with you on that legislation if you want to for term limits on a, for electives if that's something you wanna look at. Yeah, always. Yeah, it is. Well, never mind. Oh, yeah. Okay. So one of the questions I have on this, okay, are we good with the term limits discussion? I think, like, in broad strokes, we think that there should be term limits. We need to put some guardrails up in case we can't get people on these groups. I think we're coming to sort of an understanding of where we'd like to see expertise and not expertise, more, and more collaboration with the council at least by way of reporting. It does not have to be cumbersome, but we'll work through that maybe in some of our future meetings. As chair, I'd like to, like, take on term limits at one meeting. And if we have time, maybe take on another component of, like, expertise and give direction. The question I have is do we want to run legislation as a committee where we say these are our recommendations? Do those recommendations then go on an existing request, or does the committee have a piece of legislation? I don't know if we have an answer to that. Councilor: Well, no, but this is where I see Indira's point. Right? And so we don't wanna drag these things out forever in a committee to discuss each aspect of it. Right? I don't think we need to, for then, from here, look at term limits or something else in different committees or we're never gonna get this, right, stuff done. Right? So I think it should just be, if we do something like this, it's one and done. And sponsor runs with it. Okay. Ye eah, we have, I mean, in this meeting, we have a primary sponsor. I believe I'm on this legislation. You're on this legislation. The mayor's on this legislation. So we have four ticked off on this legislation already. I think that this is, like, this gives that team some really good feedback. And then now we have to go back, draft, and come on back to the table. Agreed. And I do like bringing a draft before it's introed, though. Yep. I think that'd be, I think that's gonna be an idea. Very productive. Okay. So anything else? Okay. S So moving forward, the next planning commission board, the next finance committee major topic, we can still keep this topic on the table. The next major topic is a piece of legislation that I'm sponsoring with staff around streamlining the city manager's ability to sign off on contracts and what that looks like. So we actually have kind of a draft piece of legislation. I'm working with Monica and Andrea and Destiny and Armenia, all the badasses. Oops, sorry everybody. All the amazing people who are working on this, we are gonna look at this. There's gonna be a draft, so we will actually get to piece of, see a piece of draft legislation, and then we can work through that as a committee. Because I do think this is one space where we can alleviate a lot of time and energy for staff and the council and the governing body by just kinda getting more modern in what we allow our city manager to do. And so, and there's gonna be some other things as part of that, but that is gonna be at our next legislative discussion is that piece of legislation. Right? Anything else for anybody on this topic? Okay. Thank you. I think this was a good first meeting. We're gonna stumble a little bit, but I'm excited. Anything from staff? Nothing fro om staff. Thank you, , staff, for sitting through Matters from the Committee. Councilor Castro? I just do wan nna give support and love to the other 12 folks that were moved from our city today. A hundred percent. T Thank NO Councilor Castro, for that. Matters from the chair, it's time for District 3 to have another event. So La Posada is coming. You will be hearing about it at every single meeting. I wanna thank the city clerk's office. They have stepped up, and they're helping. Of course, the fire department always helps us, and it should be a really fun event as usual. We're looking for volunteers. The Northern New Mexico Toy Drive is helping. It's gonna be another South Side event, and we're really excited about it. And with that, we're adjourned. And the next meeting is, when is the next meeting? The 21st. October 26.