Regular Governing Body Meeting - Last Wednesday Wed, Oct 28, 2026 · Governing Body https://santafeminutes.space/meeting/936-governing-body-oct-28-2026 == Executive Summary == The Governing Body of Santa Fe convened on October 28, 2026, addressing disaster response, city operations, and community concerns. The meeting began with the approval of the agenda and consent agenda, followed by the denial of an appeal related to a conditional use permit due to a missed deadline. A significant portion of the meeting focused on the city's response to a recent tornado, with the Mayor noting the need to extend the disaster declaration, which was subsequently approved in an emergency meeting held immediately after the regular session, extending the proclamation until 11/05/2026. Key discussions included an update on the Behavioral Engagement Support Office (BASO) and Crisis Assistance Response and Engagement (CARE) units, highlighting their new structure and dispatch protocols, with councilors emphasizing the need for comprehensive success metrics beyond call volume. The Governing Body also approved a budget adjustment of $175,000 for Sireos Road repairs under the Complete Streets program and appointed Chandler Moore to the Public Safety Committee. Public comments largely centered on opposition to nuclear weapons, concerns about gentrification, and calls for improved tenant support and eviction prevention. Additionally, the Governing Body approved the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) Annual Performance Report for Program Year 2025 despite public criticism regarding unmet goals and limited public input, and unanimously approved the rezoning of approximately 5.96 acres on Boylan Circle and Boylan Lane from R1 to MU. == Key Decisions == - Approved the agenda, removing item 8A (recognitions). - Approved the consent agenda. - Denied an appeal of the Planning Commission's conditional use permit approval for 1802 Surios Road due to being filed past the 15-day deadline. - Approved a $175,000 budget adjustment from gross receipts tax for Sireos Road repairs under the Complete Streets FY27 WIP construction. - Appointed Chandler Moore to the Public Safety Committee for a term ending June 2028. - Approved the extension of the emergency proclamation for severe weather until 11/05/2026. - Approved the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) Annual Performance Report (CAPER) for Program Year 2025. - Approved the rezoning of approximately 5.96 acres at 2745 Boylan Circle, 2743 Boylan Circle, and 1372 Boylan Lane from R1 (one dwelling unit per acre) to MU (Mixed Use). == Motions & Votes == - Motion to approve the agenda, removing item 8A (recognitions) — Passed 7-0. - Motion to approve the consent agenda — Passed 7-0. - Motion to deny the appeal of the Planning Commission's conditional use permit approval for 1802 Surios Road — Passed 7-0. - Motion to approve a $175,000 budget adjustment from gross receipts tax for Sireos Road repairs under the Complete Streets FY27 WIP construction — Passed 7-0. - Motion to appoint Chandler Moore to the Public Safety Committee for a term ending June 2028 — Passed unanimously. - Motion to approve the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) Annual Performance Report (CAPER) for Program Year 2025 — Passed 6-0 (Councilors Fagalli, Barrett, Bustamante, Cassutt, Chavez, and Faulkner voted "Yes"). - Motion to approve the rezoning of approximately 5.96 acres at 2745 Boylan Circle, 2743 Boylan Circle, and 1372 Boylan Lane from R1 to MU (Bill Number 2026-17) — Passed 7-0. - Motion to approve the extension of the emergency proclamation for severe weather until 11/05/2026 — Passed 5-0. == Public Comment == Public comments covered several key themes: opposition to nuclear pit production in New Mexico, with speakers urging the city to sue Pfizer and resist nuclear arsenal expansion due to moral, environmental, and economic concerns; criticism of gentrification and its link to the nuclear industry, arguing it does not foster broad-based economic development; and calls for improved tenant support and eviction prevention, with a Chainbreaker member highlighting bureaucratic delays and insufficient aid from the City's Eviction Prevention Fund for fire-displaced residents. Other speakers raised concerns about the housing crisis and the city's mental health crisis response, urged the City Council to waive a $1,000,000 insurance requirement for peaceful assembly permits, and provided suggestions for improving the appeals ordinance. Concerns were also raised about potential water fee increases and the accuracy of project cost estimates for water utility system upgrades. Regarding the CDBG CAPER, public commenters criticized low achievement rates, the short 15-day public comment period, and limited opportunity for public input. == Topics == - Severe Weather/Tornado Response - City Employee Retirements - Zoning Change (Boylan Circle) - Mixed-Use Zoning Effectiveness - Emergency Proclamation Extension - Dolores Huerta Remembrance == Full Transcript == MICHAEL J. GARCIA: I'd like to call our October 28 regular meeting of the governing body to order. We will start off with a pledge of allegiance led by Councilor Chavez, a salute to the New Mexico flag led by Councilor Castro, and invocation remembrances led by Councilor Bustamante. Lease stand as you're able AMANDA CHAVEZ: e. Alright. Well, what a week. I just want to first take a moment to think about all those who were affected by the tornado and severe weather that we had this weekend. A lot of people lost their homes or got severe damage to them or their vehicles or trees ripped up out of the yards. We were fortunate in the city not to have any serious injuries or deaths, but unfortunately, we did lose somebody in the county. I also think, though, that during these times, it's important to recognize what's going right. So, first, I'd like to thank the mayor and the city manager and all of our department heads and division heads and our chiefs and everybody who just went out there and got straight to work. Walking through some of the affected areas yesterday was a heck of a lot different than walking through it Sunday. It's just amazing what was accomplished. And I think, even more amazing was the way community came out for each other. I've talked to many people and heard within minutes, neighbors were checking on neighbors. And within a span of just a few hours, there were people out there who had worn ice teams with chainsaws and trucks and food and anything that their neighbors needed. I'm going to quote Mrs. Delgado, one of the people that got affected. She said, "The Hinta showed up," and she was not wrong. And to me, that's what Santa F MICHAEL J. GARCIA: Fe is about. Thank you. Sir, are there any other remembrances? Yes. ALMA CASTRO: Councilor Castro? So just briefly, thank you so much for that, Councilor Bustamante. Also, some sympathies. We did lose a leader in our community today, Dolores Huerta, and I just wanted to acknowledge all the work that she did in repres MICHAEL J. GARCIA: senting New Mexico. The other remembrances. I'll follow up both Councilor Bustamante and Councilor Castro's comments. When tragedy hits, I think it shows the true spirit of community, and our community showed up on Saturday night all the way through today. People are still working their butts off to clear debris, make sure folks are safe, and ultimately, making sure we're leading that recovery effort with compassion, with strategy, and most importantly, making sure we continue to be one community. As Councilor Castro mentioned, we did lose a strong champion with Ms. Huerta. She is from our community, from New Mexico, but most importantly, she was a national icon, a national leader in civil rights, somebody who truly showed that when you organize, you do see change. And so with that, let's take a moment to recognize anybody else in our community that needs any compassion or support. Thank you, everybody. Okay. Mr. Assistant City Clerk, can we get a roll call, Lease? Yes, Mayor. Councilor Bar ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: rrett? Here. Councilor Bustamante? Here. Councilor Cassutt? Here. Councilor C ELIZABETH BARRETT: Castro ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: o? Something. Councilor Chav AMANDA CHAVEZ: vez? Here. Counci PATRICIA FEGHALI: ilor F ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: Faulkner? Here. Councilor Feghali? Here. Councilor Garcia? He is MICHAEL J. GARCIA: excused. Mayor ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: r Garcia? Present. You have a quorum, Mayor. O MICHAEL J. GARCIA: Okay. Next up is approval of the agenda. Any changes from staff? ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: ? Mayor, item 8A, recognitions, is being removed. Oka JAMIE CASSUTT: ay. We'll get to approve as amend MICHAEL J. GARCIA: ded. I second. Okay. Got a motion and a second. Any discussion? Hearing none, Mr. City Assistant City Clerk, can we get a roll call vote, L ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: Lease? Yes, Mayor. Councilor Barrett? Yes. Councilor Bustamante? Yes. Councilor Cassutt? Yes. Councilor Castro? Yes. Councilor Chavez? Yes. Councilor Faulkner? Yes. Councilor Feghali? Yes. The motion to approve the ag MICHAEL J. GARCIA: genda as amended has passed. Thank you. Next up, approval of the consent agenda. Any items, Mr. Assistant City Clerk, been pulled? Mayor, no items were removed. Move to approve. Second. We've got a motion and a second. Any discussion? Hearing none, ca ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: an we get a roll call vote, Lease? AMANDA CHAVEZ: ? Yes ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: s, Mayor. Councilor Bustamante? Yes. Councilor Cassutt? Yes. C PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: Counci ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: ilor Castro? Yes. Councilor Chavez? Yes. PATRICIA FEGHALI: Coun ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: ncilor Faulkner? Yes. Councilor Feghali? Yes. Councilor Barrett? Yes. And MICHAEL J. GARCIA: the motion to approve the consent agenda has passed. Thank you. That takes us to presentations. Will you Le ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: ease read into the record tonight's first presentation? Yes, Mayor. Tonight's first presentation is item 8B, recognizing City of Santa Fe November retirees, presented by City Manager Brian Moya. I believe the Deputy City Manager will be MICHAEL J. GARCIA: taking over. And our HR CITY STAFF: Director, Monica Acevedo. Yep. The floor is yours. If we can make sure that mic is on. And to our distinguished guests. Can you hear me? Sorry about that. Yes. Tonight, we have the honor of recognizing two dedicated City of Santa Fe employees as they embark on their well-deserved retirement. Throughout their years of service, these individuals have demonstrated commitment, professionalism, and dedication to our community. Their contributions have helped shape our city and have left a lasting impact on those they have served and worked with. On behalf of the City of Santa Fe, we extend our sincere gratitude for the years of service and wish them continued happiness, good health, and fulfillment as they embark on their new chapter in lives. It's my privilege to present these retirement plaques as a small token of our appreciation of their ou MICHAEL J. GARCIA: utstanding service. We have Jesse Benavides for twenty years of service. And don't go nowhere yet, Jesse. We all got kind words for you. So I'm just going to go from my right to my left if an PATRICIA FEGHALI: ny councilors have any remarks. If not, happy to also turn the mic over to you. Twenty years. That's amazing. Congratul ELISA MONTOYA: lations. And I'm sure we will miss you, but I hope you don't mis JAMIE CASSUTT: ss us too much. Just want to say congrats, and thank you so much for your service. Congrats, and thank you for the impact you've had on Santa Fe. I know, I feel like every city employee has so much heart invested in Santa Fe, and so thank you f PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: for giving twenty years of your heart. That's amazing. Enjoy some relaxation. Okay? Councilor Faulkner. Yeah. Thank you for everything you've done for the city. I know that working for the city can sometimes be taxing because our problems are sizable, and sometimes we can't resolve them immediat ALMA CASTRO: tely. But all the things you've done for the City of Santa Fe, I genuinely appreciate you. You, Jesse, we can't appreciate you enough. And although our words are really important and the recognition you're getting here, I think the fact that your colleagues are here to support you speaks volumes. You have made a differen AMANDA CHAVEZ: nce not only in your department but in ELIZABETH BARRETT: n this city. So thank you so much for the last twenty years. We're waiting for a councilor to cancel. Thank you. Jesse, thank you so, thank you so much. I just have such warm memories of every interaction I've ever had with you, but specifically remembering a project with cleaning up Hurt Martinez Park. And just your dedication, your passion, your positivity, you really always brought that spark. But I truly appreciate everything you've done for our community, and I will very much miss getting to see you. And hopefully, we'll get to see you around town, though. And thank you again so much, and congratulation AMANDA CHAVEZ: ns. Hopefully, you're going to get some rest and have some fun. Thank you, Jamie Cassie. Councilor. Thank you. Just want to say, just want to say thank you so much MICHAEL J. GARCIA: h for your service. And, you know, I hope your retirement is as fulfilling as your career. T MARCY MATASIK: Thank you so much. Cong MICHAEL J. GARCIA: gratulations, Jesse. Thank you, Mayor. Yeah. One of the best darn salsa makers I know. So, make it with love. That, it definitely shows. It is, it is amazing. So, just thank you for everything you've done. I think your service is a true testament to why our parks are improving today. It's the passion that you have instilled that, I think that other colleagues in the Parks Department are now taking on, and you led the way. So thank you. Thank you. Thank you so MARCY MATASIK: much. I just want to say, you know, I love my city, my parks. I think I made my footprint with the signs and how much I just enjoyed, you know, with the work in the community and my volunteers. So I'm going to become a volunteer, and I'd really like to see the Swan Park. One of the projects I didn't accomplish was to bring that park above. I think I emailed the beautiful, and to bring th STEPHANIE BENONATO: hat here over to ou CITY STAFF: ur South Side kids. So, call me anytime. I'm here, I'm available. Thank you all. Thank you, Jesse. Friend. Love you. Tha MICHAEL J. GARCIA: ank you for that. And we have one more, Mr. Roberta Castillo with fourteen yea AMANDA CHAVEZ: ars of service with the libraries. Okay. This time, I'm going to go from my left to my right, Councilor Bustamante. Congratulations, Mr. Castillo. I appreciate your service to our community ELIZABETH BARRETT: y, and I hope you have a big stack of books of your own to read now that you're going to finally have time to read them. Thank you so much for all of your work and everything that the libraries do. I don't think people appreciate how varied your jobs are and the impact that you make on the community. I think this council does, but Justin general, I know that it is such an impactful position and institution and the amount of people that really rely on the libraries, and we cannot do it without your incredible work. So thank you so much. I agree with Councilor Bustamant ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: te hope you ALMA CASTRO: get some time to relax and enjoy, and we will really miss you and appreciate everything you've given us. Thank you. Thank you so much, Mr. Castillo. I think that as my colleagues have said, the libraries in these third spaces are super important for our community, especially in these difficult times. You guys take on so much of the work of providing services, and we hope to see you PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: using those services as well. We want to see you again, but thank you for the last 14, and we're here if you need anything. So I always look at libraries as a last, as like the first bastion of democracy. It's a space where all people from all different socioeconomic strata have access to information, and it's free for the most part. And so libraries are really important, and serving in the capacity where you have helped people from all different wal ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: lks of MICHAEL J. GARCIA: f life access information that they may no JAMIE CASSUTT: ot have been able to access otherwise is super important. So thank you so, so much. You. Yeah. Yeah. So Chavez. Thank you, Mayor. I want to just highlight how important or like the gains of the library and the fact that you played a role. Right? Because we're living in this tech world. We're losing kids to technology. However, in Santa Fe, I would say especially, we have found the power of let's bring our community together in these hubs and remember what libraries can serve, which is a, it's a gathering place. And so you contributed to making Santa Fe Library stand out to so many libraries around the nation as it's not so much about combating a tech world, but it's about bringing community members together to connect and to find resources and to engage in activities and to engage just into hands-on opportunities that remind us like what makes life special. And so I feel our libraries in Santa Fe are really amazing because of that. And the fact that you played a hand, I hope you carry that with you because that is such an important thing. And I feel like it has made Santa Fe Libraries stand out compared to so many others who have lost people in just this transition to the tech ELISA MONTOYA: world. So thank you for being part of that. Thank you for your work in that. It's, it's an amazing impact. So I hope you know that and carry that. You. Just want to thank you for all of your work and say PATRICIA FEGHALI: y my family and I were frequent flyers at the Santa Fe libraries and found a lot of enjoyment and peace there. So than MICHAEL J. GARCIA: nk you so much, and enjoy you WAYNE DALTON: ur retirement. I'll just echo what all MICHAEL J. GARCIA: my colleagues have said. Thank you for all your work, and enjoy your retirement. Thanks. Thank you, Mr. Castillo. All of you. Thanks all of you as well. Enjoy. Southside Library is definitely going to miss you. So thank you. Going to miss it as well. Well, come back. We'll always take you on as a volunteer. So thank you. Enjoy. Enjoy. Enjoy. Thank you. Okay. Thank you so much, Miss Director. Yes. How about th ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: he retirees come down, and we can take a picture with you all? Mr. Assistant City Clerk. Next presentation, Lease. Your next presenta SCOTT OUDERKIRK: ation will be on CARE. Here to present on this item is Scott Ouderkirk, Interim Fire Chief. Excuse me. Good evening, Mr. Mayor, members of our council. I'm glad to be here tonight to present some of this information for you all. Tonight, we're going to be talking about the BASO and CARE Unit. This has been a work in progress over the last several months. Originally, this program started out as a pilot program. As it got going and it got established, we were able to make positions that were at one point grant-funded, full-time positions. Then we could see value in this program, and they all became fully funded, and it became part of our identity here in the city. As we go to improve on this program and to help it move into the future for our city and what it can accomplish, we began to put together these two distinct parts of it, which is BASO, our Behavioral Engagement Support Office, and our CARE Unit, our Crisis Assistance Response and Engagement Unit. Now, our BASO is the overlying office that oversees our CARE Unit and our case management. So it is our office that oversees all those different things. Our CARE Unit is our boots on the ground. It is our unit that responds to not only 911 calls, non-emergency, but does community engagement and proactive engagement in our community. So that is our boots on the ground unit. As we began to formulate all these things, we put together a working group. As we can see, these are all the different partners that we had in this group from members of our fire department, our community services, our police department, our RECC dispatch center, city council members, emergency management, our PIO, and many others, including a consultant that offered her time to be with us as well, that has performed and helped programs like this around the country get established and provided a lot of good information for us. As this unit has evolved over time, it's still operating about the same that it always has at this point. We'd like to see that increase in the future, and they're running just about a thousand calls to date, which is still about 5% of our call volume. They are still providing a lot of the services in the city that they always have, with currently a few less members than it did in the past as we're waiting on getting those job postings announced and out for application acceptance. Some of the good work that this unit and this office has done is they've received the Behavioral Health Star Award, and they were awarded that this year. They've done a lot of good work in the community, and we can see the value in it. That's why we're putting so much time and effort into getting a program that can be long-lasting. One of the major things that came out of our working group is the idea of having dispatch protocols. It's difficult for our team to look at all the different calls throughout the entire city that's between our fire department and our police department, and to look through and sift through all those, which takes a lot of time, and to decide what's the most appropriate thing for them to do. What we're able to do with these protocols that we're putting in place is they'll be automatically dispatched to the calls that are appropriate for that unit, and they will be able to go directly to those people and to help them. Now, this unit is not... It can be a standalone dispatch, but it also can be a co-response dispatch as well. These protocols took some time to develop between all the different agencies that are involved to make sure that we're making sure our people are safe as they're being dispatched to different kinds of emergencies. Some of the things that we will be dispatching them to is our behavioral health and people that are in behavioral health crisis, and those that are needing assistance or connecting to resources, and those that might be our most vulnerable parts of our community, those that are experiencing homelessness or other such things that might need assistance. They'll be directly dispatched to those. In cases where there might be a violent individual or something that needs more people, we'll have a co-response between our police department and our fire department EMS to make sure that the most appropriate units are there for them. At that point, once everyone's on scene, they'll be able to decide who needs to stay and stay a little bit longer or what's the most appropriate action for that individual. Then we'll also have our case management to go along with that. These people might be able to be connected to the resources after the crisis has been kind of resolved. As they're moving forward, our case managers will be able to help them connect with the proper resources to have warm handoffs to the most appropriate person to help them in their needs. The office is going to be organized very similar to how it is currently, with our behavior health manager overseeing the office and then our two supervisors overseeing our case managers and the CARE Unit and the work that they do. We've created new positions within our BASO office. We have a Crisis Responder One and a Crisis Responder Two. This provides ways for our case managers to be able to have a ladder to climb, promotional opportunities, as they gain more experiences to have opportunities for promotions and pay raises. Along with that, with our Crisis Responder Twos, they will be EMT-licensed individuals that will be able to provide assessments on scene to be able to decide what's the best course of action if there is a medical need and to be able to request advanced life support if needed. If not, they would be able to handle any basic life support needs and transport to the most appropriate facility. As we continue to look at the evolving program that we're developing, it provides our case managers and our crisis responders an opportunity to focus on what they do best. Currently or in the past, they were spread out. We had one case manager position, and they had to do a lot of different things. Their hat was really full. With these new positions, we say you can focus on this part of the office. You can focus on this part of the job. They'll be able to kind of narrow down and become more of an expert instead of a jack of all trades. The other thing that really came from our working group is the importance of collaboration with all our community partners. We have been able to establish client coordination meetings, and as those meetings go forward, they're able to discuss the different clients that we're seeing, that they're working with. So we're not duplicating efforts as much. We'll be able to make sure that person is getting the necessary help and that no one falls through the cracks. Sometimes someone's getting a lot of help, and we're duplicating a lot of efforts, and other times people fall through the cracks. That's what we don't want to see. With our client coordination meetings with all our community partners, I think we're upwards of just over 20 within these coordination meetings that they're having on a regular basis. They're prepared. I think the next one is coming up this next month, and they'll be able to make sure that the individuals needing help are getting the proper help. So as this program has evolved, we're making sure that the members in our community are receiving the proper help, that they are getting the things that they need when they need it, and that this program is evolving, and it's here to stay, and we're expanding it, and it's becoming something that our community needs. As our community changes, we change with it, and we try to provide the best necessary resources that they need. As we continue to evolve this program, we're going to be measuring all our successes and any shortfalls that we may have. We put together many different key point indicators to make sure that we're reaching our goals that we have set. We want to make sure that the people are getting the help they need. So we'll continue to gather many points of data and make sure that our decisions are data-driven, that we're providing that resource that we want to provide to the right people. As we gather this data and we look at what's coming from it over the next several months as all these different parts of this program are implemented, we'll be able to have better decision-making capabilities for where we need to move in the future, as we need more personnel, we need more case managers or crisis responders, different units, different kinds of types of equipment that they may need to use, and we'll be able to provide that to them as we gather that information over the next several months and moving into the future. Everything that we've been doing is underway. We're not waiting for anything. We're trying to implement all this as quick as we can to provide all these different changes into our community. We have some of our case managers that have entered our EMT class that we can get them the more training that they need. That class is quickly coming to an end right now. They're in their last instructional week, and they'll be starting their ride-along clinicals with the ambulances and hospitals and stuff like that this next week. So that's really exciting that they're getting really close to finish their EMT course. Our dispatch protocols are going to be put in place too. We've developed sit-alongs with our regional dispatch center that will be able to have our supervisors sit in there as this is being implemented to make sure our dispatchers and our person in the field are getting properly trained as we're implementing all these different parts of it. So it's really exciting as all this is really happening very quickly at this time. With BASO and CARE, we're trying to establish very unified and clear direction for the future. We're wanting everyone to know what it is and know what its capabilities are. We want our people in our office to also understand what their job functions are. That's been some of our challenges in the past where our case managers that we have hired or those that have gone through interviews are like, "I have to do that also and that also." So this is very defining, and it provides more clear direction not only to our employees that are working there but also to those that are receiving the services. They'll understand exactly what they're getting. They've developed, our team has developed a new logo, as you can see here, our CARE logo. They'll be in their own uniforms, and they'll be able to see what resources are arriving. They'll be able to distinguish that this is the person I need or I want, and I don't need this guy over here or this person over here. It will hopefully be able to help people connect with the resources that they need. That's all I have for you tonight. I'll stand for any questions MICHAEL J. GARCIA: s. Thank you, chief. Any questions from governing body members? Councilor Chavez. Thank you, mayo JAMIE CASSUTT: or. I'm sorry I couldn't be there for the media release, so I do have some questions. The first question I have is, will case managers or care providers, vessel providers, still be able to view RECC calls as a whole rather than just RECC deploying them based on the calls they SCOTT OUDERKIRK: y receive? Absolutely, councilor Chavez. They're going to have access to the CAD system in their computers like they do now. They'll be able to see all the calls that are happening throughout the city. And as they're dispatched to the call they need, they won't have to sift through all those. They'll have the one pop up on their screen, but they'll be able to see all the PD calls, all the fire EMS calls that are continuing going through the city at the city. And do they have permission from lea JAMIE CASSUTT: adership to respond to calls that seem appropriate for them despite RECC dictating which calls may be more appropriate th SCOTT OUDERKIRK: han others? Absolutely. Yes. These calls, they'll be dispatched to certain calls, but in any times of downtime or there is no particular call that's coming in through 911 at the time for that unit, they're able to go through those calls and say, hey. This is not something we were dispatched to, but we can definitely provide help at that same call. There might be something that's considered only EMS or only PD. But they might be able to look through that call and say, hey. This is somewhere where they can use a crisis responder, and we can connect them with other resources. And so they'll be able to also continue to self-dispatch to those calls and say, this is appropriate for me. And they'll call our dispatch center and put them on that call. And I only say, and I bring this up, I only bring this up be JAMIE CASSUTT: ecause for those in the community that don't realize, ARU has been a huge, just like a care, like a sense of security for a lot of community members out there that have struggled with behavioral health. Meaning, there are repetitive individuals that require support, and ARU has shown up through the years and have developed a relationship. And those calls can go from very low priority to high priority based on the person's need. And I feel like ARU has relationships with those individuals and knows how to respond appropriately. So it's very important to me that they can see names. They can see all of the details of calls to know whether it's one of theirs. Right? Because they've already established a caseload of theirs with the care that they provided to Santa Fe. And so I think that is essential. So I really want to make sure that this isn't like a restart of caseloads, but care still has this ability to look for names and look for types of behaviors and looks for things that they're experts in and they have expertise in to respond appropriately too because they'd be the best people to respond SCOTT OUDERKIRK: d. Counselor Chavez, absolutely. They're going to be able to see that, and they'll be able to see those names. And when they see those Springfield fires or one of their clients pop up on the screen, absolutely. And I've seen them do it even recently. And they're like, this is so and so. We need, let's go over there and let's help PD or fire or whoever's there, and let's go see what's going on. They absolutely will still have that ability. JAMIE CASSUTT: . Awesome. I have three questions. So we're on number two now. The second question is, I know, again, I don't think people understand the magnitude of the impact ARU has had. They literally have such solid relationships with individuals in our community that only respond to them. Like, we have community members that expect ARU to show up, and they only trust ARU. And ARU has been really amazing in checking in on individuals, just being a consistent, trusting Contacto. And I want to make sure that the community knows and everyone involved knows that won't change. ARU will still have the flexibility and the room to, you know, kind of roam through Santa Fe, connect with individuals throughout the city that they have relationships with, check in with individuals they have relationships with, like, continue doing that preventative care that's also essential. I realized that it has to be secondary to the primary focus, which is whatever is a priority call. However, I think that preventative is essential. And the individuals on ARU have created a foundation of preventative care because they've created relationships, and relationships are key to everything. Let me just emphasize that. I'm an educator, behavioral health, whatever you want to call it, advocate, and relationships are key. And I think that they've established all that. So do they still have room in their role to do the preventative aspects that is that checking in, that roaming of Santa Fe, that connecting to individuals that may not have asked for help but may need help, is there room in their role for that as well? Counsel SCOTT OUDERKIRK: lor Chavez, absolutely. They'll still, they're still carrying their current client load and caseload, and that's not, that's not changing. What they're, what they're doing is not changing too much. What is happening is we're defining more clear roles and responsibilities and creating more positions and, hopefully, area for gr JAMIE CASSUTT: rowth and expansion. Right. So there's room in both Beso and Care that allow for the preventative care of engaging with th SCOTT OUDERKIRK: he community off calls. Absolutely. This is the same great work, just a different name. Okay. Great. And JAMIE CASSUTT: then my last question is, there's a lot going on about bike paths, about just paths in general, the safety, all of those things. I know that we have our bicycle team on police, and I, you might not be able to answer this, but there's a lot of things occurring on bike paths because we have a lot of encampments. We have a lot of things in regards to homelessness. How can we integrate CARE and Beso into that work rather than the bicycle team for police? Because I feel like, from what I've heard is there's a lot of arrests that are occurring due to encampments around pathways or around our trails. But, really, those people probably need some behavioral health support. And I don't know what extent Beso or ARU previously, Beso and Care currently have engaged in that work. But how can we integrate that more? Because there's a high need there. I feel like arresting individuals is not helping the issue. I feel like they need behavioral health support. I also know that you all use vehicles, and that's very different. But how can the bike team for the city, the Santa Fe Police Department, work collaboratively more so with Beso and Care so that they could actually get the support of your team more so SCOTT OUDERKIRK: than ending up in the system? Absolutely, counselor. This is, so one of the things that the unit does is engagement. And they, they do proactive engagement. And this is a great opportunity for them to look down these bike paths. And I think we have a really good idea between fire and PD of where these encampments are on these bike paths and these different locations. And we can definitely send our care unit out there to do proactive engagement with the individuals that are in these locations and see what kind of resources we can provide them and see what kind of help that they, they might need. And I think that's a definitely good area f JAMIE CASSUTT: for one of our proactive engagement spots. I absolutely think that is true, and I think that is a data piece that we could look at. Right? Because right now, we, from what I'm aware of, have a higher arrest rate in regards to encampments on our, on our trails. So if we can, from now moving forward with a collaborative effort between the Santa Fe Police Department and fire department, show that we are providing resources to these individuals to avoid them entering into the system, then that would be a great celebration. So I would like to collaborate with you and interim chief Valdez to see how we could start monitoring that and tracking that so that we could see that reduction because we know that we put them in the system, they're out. We put them in the system, they're out. We put the, it's repetitive. Staking up resources. We're not solving the root cause. But with Beso and Care, collaboratively, I think we could actually solve some, really hardships for some of our community members that are essential to solve. So I will connect with you and Ben, and we will see SCOTT OUDERKIRK: what we can do. Okay? Yes, counselor. We actually have a group, a working group, around encampments, with multiple different staff personnel, including myself, chief Valdez, community services director, and a few others. And we are, we're, we're working on all that stuff. It's very new still, and we're still developing some of the definitions and policies and things like that. And as that progresses, we'll definitely be bringing that forward. Right? But that's something we're currently working on, and so we're, we're on top of that hopefully JAMIE CASSUTT: y right now. Well, great. I would love for you to invite me. I'd love to be part of that conversation if possible. So, yeah, we'll conne MICHAEL J. GARCIA: ect. I will definitely connect with you both on that. Thank you. Councilor Bust AMANDA CHAVEZ: tamante, then councilor Fokner, and we'll go to councilor Cassutt. Thank you, mayor. Well, chief, first, I want to say again, thank you so much. You and your team really took this to heart and saw that this is still a need in the community, and I think you've set up a pretty good road map here for their success. So, thank you. I do have one question, if, if you wouldn't mind explaining, because I see a lot of discourse on this, th SCOTT OUDERKIRK: he decision to keep the operating hours, eight to four, Monday through Friday. And currently, that fits our staff model for our current personnel. That's one of the reasons. The other reason it also fits with our coordinating partners and our supporting members in the community, and it fits with their operating hours as well. And so, we try to fit that in within their operating hours. So as we connect with pe AMANDA CHAVEZ: eople that the resources that they need to MICHAEL J. GARCIA: go to are also av PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: vailable at the same time. Great. Thank you, chief. Thank you, ma'am. Mister Faulkner. Yeah. I just want to thank you, chief. You and Rizzo. I, I do know that this topic became controversial, and in a lot of spaces, it became controversial without us, more out of people being afraid of something happening rather than what was actually happening. So I know this was a lot for you guys to juggle, and I really appreciate the mindfulness and the incorporation of counselors and community members to try to get this in the sweet spot. Is Theresa space where we might be SCOTT OUDERKIRK: looking towards having services in the hours that are the most high-risk hours, which is at night? Yes. As we pull our data and as we look with that, we'll be working with our, with PD, and to see what is the most appropriate course of action for our city and what would be best for our staff members and our community members. And those are conversations we definitely wan PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: nt to have and will continue to have as we continue to evolve this program into what the community needs. Alright. Thank you. And, again, I, I thank you and your staff for the, the amount of work you put in, in a space that got very contentious at times. So I think you guys have done a good job of managing the community's concerns, the council's concerns, the ad MICHAEL J. GARCIA: dministration's c ELIZABETH BARRETT: concerns, and then the, I don't know. I think you just did a good job. So thank you. Thank you. Master Cassutt. Thank you, mayor, and, and thank you, chief, for being here and, and for, for all the work that went into to this proposal or, I guess, this, this change that's moving forward. Really do appreciate it. And I know that there was a lot of conversation with a lot of different stakeholders, so really, really appreciate that collaborative approach. I'll kind of piggyback off of these questions on ours. I want to say that I'm really excited about this concept that care will be dispatched, that it's not just about watching the monitors, but that there will actually be protocols in place for when those calls should be dispatched. And on that note, looking at the hour question, will that mean that, and I know you'd have to work with RECC for this, will we be able to track essentially which calls SCOTT OUDERKIRK: RECC would have sent a care, you know, care out if they had been on the clock or not? Councilor Kassett, yes, absolutely. That's one reason why we wanted dispatch protocol so we could track the calls that they're unable to go to that they normally would go to if they were available in service. So even if they're on a call and another call comes in that they're able to be dispatched to, we'll be able to track that as well. We'll be able to track all the after-hour calls. Every call that unit shows not available or out of service for, we'll be able to track those, and we'll be able to see how many people we're missing and what we can do to capture more of those people. And so this is on ELIZABETH BARRETT: ne of those areas that our dispatch protocols are really going to help us capture better data with. Yeah, wonderful. I appreciate that. And to your point, when they're just not available because maybe they're otherwise engaged at that moment in time. And as Councilor Chavez mentioned, I am also really glad that there will still be this flexibility for them to self-dispatch because I think when you have individuals that are familiar to this team, or you know, you have specialists on this team who understand behavioral health issues and might be able to see them in a way that others may not, you know, them having that flexibility will be important. And I think it would be interesting to capture those, you know, those scenarios where maybe dispatch did not send them out, but care is looking at a call and saying we really should be there so that we can, you know, see again where that utilization or that capacity may need to be increased based on that utilization. I'm curious about how we are measuring the success of this program. And the reason I ask that is because when we're dealing with these complex issues, I know sometimes it's like, well, how many times is somebody washing and repeating into the system? And there are moments where that's actually not within our control, you know? So it might be just the fact that there's not, you know, the behavioral health services that are needed, or if they're trying to get some medical care and it's not available to them. So I would be wary to be in a scenario where we're seeing a lot of high utilizers that continue to show up and continue to be engaged with care and us thinking that's care not working. Of course, I want to, you know, assess that and see, hey, what are we doing that we could be doing better? But we know we have a deficit when it comes to behavioral health services in the community. And so I want us to be mindful of that component as well because I would imagine that there are going to be individuals they're already seeing quite a bit, but that they will continue to see quite a bit simply because there's nowhere to refer them to, or they're trying to refer them in those, you know, those organizations and agencies have waitlists that are miles long as they're, you know, we're trying to get them stabilized and they need these resources. So, can you talk a little bit more about, you know, what does success look like? If we're, you know, looking at this in about three years, as I always say, public health, you can't assess it in six months. It takes a while. So three years minimum. But if we're looking at this in three years, how will we know that we feel this is, that we are on the right track and where we may feel like we SCOTT OUDERKIRK: need to adjust? Councilor Kassett, absolutely. I think measuring success with behavioral health is, it can be very difficult. There's so many different ways to measure it, and we can measure it as one instance. We see someone, and our care unit provides the necessary needs that they have at that time, and that could be a success. And they could call back again. It could be a success of not having that person go to the emergency room and just having care sit with them for an hour or two. It could be an individual not having to go to, not getting put in jail because of a different issue. Right? Like we talked about our encampments. Success is going to be measured on so many, so many different ways that I think it's going to be very difficult. Why don't I have to look at it case-by-case basis for that? And we can't measure it just on call volume alone. And if we look at that, we say, hey, we want to see our call volume drop or we want to see our call volume go up. We can spend that both different ways. So I think, I think you're right. Success is going to have to be measured on many, many different platforms for us to decide. And as we present this, as we move forward, and the program continues to go forward, we and we come to the governing body again and say, hey, this is what our data looks like. And we can all decide as a team, this is being successful, and this is what we can do to help see more success. And I think that's how we look at measuring our success with this program. Mayor and Councilor Kassett, can I c JAMIE CASSUTT: chime in on your question? Always. She knows where my heart is. I would, I would strongly advise that we look at warm handoffs and the outcomes of warm handoffs. I feel like there is really solid data to look at with behavioral health. The reason why we have a hard time monitoring behavioral health data is because we don't have strong systems, and we don't have consistent services. But if we're doing things the right way as an agency, it's actually quite easy to monitor in my opinion. So for the city of Santa Fe, I would advise or I would recommend, it is very easy for us to document who we hand community members off to. And then if we have that information, then we know who to follow up with, what happened next. Right? And then if those individuals fall back into our system, then it's very easy to go back to our warm handoff and say, what happened after we handed them off, and why are we servicing them again? So in reality, I feel like that is where I would start with is, and you have done great work. I have to completely celebrate our leadership in fire and what you have done in bringing our service providers together and really having that collaborative conversation because they are the people we do the warm handoffs with. But I will just say, six months from now, what I'm going to ask is how many individuals did we warm handoff to, how many of those individuals did we see again, and why? Where was there an interruption in their services that we were having to service them again with Care Beso, because that is a quick response needed, and that means that somewhere along the line with the warm handoff and the services that should have been provided, there was a kink. But looking at it that way, I feel like it's really easy for us to evaluate what we can do better with. So I would ask, and I will give a heads up, that's what I'm going to consistently ask for is, like, who are we handing off individuals to? How many of those individuals that we're handing off to certain providers are we seeing again? And we need to have certain conversations with those providers as to why we're seeing those individuals again. So I just wanted to plant that seed because that's the real data. That's all you have control in because ours is a, it's a crisis response. It's in the moment. How do we get individuals to care? Well, we're getting them to care. That is a warm handoff. We are giving them to other providers, so we have to monitor the impact of those providers on those individuals. And if we're seeing them again, there was a failure. So we have to work with those providers to figure out SCOTT OUDERKIRK: what that failure is. We are currently capturing that data, and so that's going to be, that's something that we can definitely provide. And with our client coordination meetings, that's one of the purposes is to find out who's slipping through the cracks and what more can we ELIZABETH BARRETT: e do for those individuals. Yeah, and thank you, Councilor Chavez, for adding that. And I would agree that in six months, or I would love to see, you know, kind of where we are and what we know at that moment in time, and that would give us another opportunity to ask questions that would help, you know, form this evaluation process. And, you know, obviously, this council and I know Councilor Chavez and Councilor Barrett as well, they have, you know, incredible backgrounds to really inform what are some of the things that we should be looking at. The other, the other one that I would also be interested in is, you know, if we have individuals that are rejecting assistance, we know that sometimes just those continued interactions as Councilor Chavez was mentioning before really builds trust. And so all of a sudden, you know, you might offer and offer and offer, and they're saying no, no, no, no, no. But as you are, you know, just checking in or providing food or, you know, whatever the case may be, that trust builds and it can create a place for somebody who has been in a very precarious situation where they're very guarded, then feels, you know, more open to taking the recommendations or the referrals that this team would provide. So, I would also be really interested in seeing how those, those relationships develop. And so, yeah, in six months, I would love to see kind of, like, here's what we're measuring. This is what we're seeing, and then us having the opportunity to ask questions and think about these things and see where else we may do some other measurement. The other thing I, so I, I'm trying to understand. You know, I hear more clear roles and responsibilities. So I understand there's now a career ladder that has been implemented. There is now the EMT training that is going in. There is also the dispatch protocols. Is there anything with this change that care would not be able to do or will not be doing that ARU was, in terms of, you know, what as we're defining those roles and responsibilities, not only is that giving permission to say, hey, these are the things we really want you to focus on, but does that mean that there are things that are no longer going to be focused on by this unit? Absolutel SCOTT OUDERKIRK: ly not. So this is an expansion. We're not taking anything away from what they were doing in the past. We're just adding to that and providing more clear direction for the individuals doing the work. And so that's where we're heading. So they'll still be able to do everything they were doing before plus a little bit more. Okay, okay. So they can still transport to the ER, bu ELIZABETH BARRETT: ut on their, on their own, or do they have to call somebody in? I know that was a conversation about whether that was a capability. Righ SCOTT OUDERKIRK: ht. Yeah, anyone can take anyone to the ER. Right? So they have the ability to go to the, to go to the hospital with anyone that needs that service. Great. And so they also have the ability to call an ambulance to come over and help them if they wish to. If they need more medically trained personnel there, all that's still available resources. We have all the fire department resources to their need if they need it, and ELIZABETH BARRETT: d vice versa. Okay. Alright. Wonderful. Thank you. I appreciate that. And, yeah, then I think the other one that I'm going to be really interested in hearing about is capacity. And I don't know what's happening with this. I know we've had conversations. There was that frozen assistant chief that then went to the community health and safety director, and now that director's not there. And so, I really want us to take a look at capacity. I don't know if that position is coming back into play somewhere. I know that's been part of this conversation along the way, and this, you know, what that structure looks like. But, I think that we're probably going to see in being able to build some of this data, that capacity of this unit. And to Counselor Chavez's point, the information that we need, and that's, it makes a lot of sense. We need to understand these things, but that is pretty time consuming when it comes to that data gathering and analysis. And so, I want us to be very mindful of what this capacity needs to look like. Again, with my public health hat on, I know the best way to make a public health program fail is to not fund it enough to be able to succeed. And so, I don't want to see that happen where like, oh, well, this isn't quite working, and it could just be that it's underfunded, not that it inherently is not something that's going to be beneficial. So, again, in about six months, I think having those conversations and looking at what could we do if we potentially had more funding, whether or not we have it at that moment in time, would be really helpful for us to look at success and how we continue to move forward with the development of this. So, look forward to seeing you in six months with all this fun information. Absolutely, Counselor. Thank you. Thank you so much. I will try to SCOTT OUDERKIRK: be brief. I don't want ELIZABETH BARRETT: t to belabor ALMA CASTRO: r this too much because the amazing work that we all did in the working group speaks for itself. I do want to address some comments that I got after the media release about things being very similar and there just being a change in name, which I strongly disagree with. I think that the work that was done around changing the job descriptions and also putting staff in the driver's seat. So, one thing I do want to make very clear is that the former ARU, now CARES and Beso's program staff were at the forefront of making many of these decisions and were clearly the ones telling us the needs that potentially this group of folks will need. To your point, Counselor Cassutt, the data is what is going to drive basically what we already know that we're going to need more capacity, we're going to need more staff, we're going to need more supplies, which Chief Oedekirk sort of alluded to earlier. But one thing, and I'm so sorry if I'm speaking over you, Chief, but I think there is a little bit of a change to Counselor Chavez's point on the warm handoff. There was a practice of potentially having really long-term case management, which now we're going to be working better with our partners to make sure that we have those warm handoffs and that folks have services in a different way. It is really taxing on our services in our city to have long-term case management and know where to take folks, and we know that we're at a deficit for providers. We know that we need more providers and we need better relationships. We have accomplished that, I think, in this new process of working with providers. There is also a really important piece of what happens when we sort of build out a pilot or some new program and we don't know what to do with it. We learn some really great lessons with this pilot moving from different departments and also realizing that, for example, we got some questions about line items on budgets. We're going to have to look deep and dive deep into some of our department budgets just like we did with affordable housing and sort of line item some of these programs and projects out so that we have a better idea of, are we getting our bang for our buck? Are we able to really measure some of the successes of these programs? That being said, it was a really inspiring and wonderful group of people to work with along with our contractor, Marcela. Marcela was just a support MICHAEL J. GARCIA: t. She, yeah SCOTT OUDERKIRK: h, so she's a consultant that provided basically free services for us. And so that was Mariela. And, yeah, she was, she was great. T ALMA CASTRO: Thank you so much, Chief. And so, I mean, the people that were at the table and were able to build out this program were just amazing. So, kudos to you and to your leadership. Thank you so much. Thank you. Any other comments? Yep. Counc MICHAEL J. GARCIA: cilor Barrett. Sorry. I know many people hav ELISA MONTOYA: ve commented on this, but I just want to thank you guys for letting us in the process. As a social worker, this is super important to me in having worked in similar programs like this in other areas, like in Albuquerque. I worked in a similar program. It was really important for me to get in there and talk to the other, the two social workers running the program and really seeing what their needs are and what was going to help the program grow in capacity and what they were able to do. So, I just want to thank you for letting the staff, letting us come in and give our opinions and ask questions because I know, I think, like, Counselor Chava said, it's the relationships that are at the heart of all these things. We know that in education and social work, if people trust you, they'll come to you. If you build the relationships, they'll call you and they'll ask for support when they need it most. And also, I know Director Emery was in on this too, calling in all the providers because the social workers told us directly when we lost those meetings, we lost a lot of the community support. So, having all the providers in one room, it was really powerful and impactful. So, great job on the team on getting all the community providers together. I think that was just super important. So, I was happy to be part of the process, and thanks for letting us elbow our way in there and give our opinions. I appreciate that. Absolutely. Thank you, Cou MICHAEL J. GARCIA: unselor. Any other comments? Thank you, Chief Hatterkirk, and all the best. Thank you. Yep. That, Mr. Assistant City Clerk, next item on the agenda, Lease. Mayor, the nex ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: xt item on the agenda is request for acceptance of the City Attorney's Office recommendation to deny appeal of Planning Commission's approval of conditional use permit for 1802 Surios Road, appeal number 2026-012949-APPL, land use case number 2025-11756. Here to present this item is Natalie Cauley, Assistant City Attorney. Welcome, Natalie. Thank you, Mayor. Good evening, everyone MICHAEL J. GARCIA: e. Right. So, just NATALIE CAULEY: want to quickly run through the procedure MICHAEL J. GARCIA: e sheet on this one. And now is the time for any governing body members to disclose any previous communications regarding the merits of the appeal and potential recusal if a member cannot be fair and impartial. This is not a public hearing. With that being said, not hearing any, then we will move to the order of business. We will first have a presentation from the Assistant City Attorney's Office. We will then move forward with the governing body for any questions, then move forward with a governing body with any potential motion or a second, then any discussion deliberation on the motion, and then a roll call vote. And with that, the floor is yours. Thank you, Mayor. The entirety of th NATALIE CAULEY: he information about this item is in the City Attorney's Office written recommendation in the agenda packet. So, I'm happy, I don't have a standalone presentation. I'm happy to just stand for questions or to provide a brief summary if that's the will of the body. Which, governing body? Yeah. It' MICHAEL J. GARCIA: 's in the packet so the pu PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: ublic has access to it. Any other comments? Okay. Any q MICHAEL J. GARCIA: questions? What's the will of the body? Mayor Garcia, I believe Coun ELIZABETH BARRETT: nselor Cassutt has her hand raised. Sorry, Counselor. I apologize. That's okay. Your consent. Thank you, Mayor. Thank you, Natalie, for being here. I just, I think that one, the important component that I want to make sure that we're clear on for the public because it is a lot of legalese in there is that the, we have a, basically, we have a certain time period for appeals, and it is fifteen days after the decision is made. Am I correct there? It depends on the type of NATALIE CAULEY: decision. In this case, yes. The work for a conditional use approval, it's fifteen days. For other types of decisions, it can be thirty days. Okay. And this, the individual that was wanting to appeal had reached out after that fifteen-day ELIZABETH BARRETT: y period had already passed. Correct? That's correct. Okay. I think that's an important piece of this. Mayor, is it time for comments? I have a comment, a general comment on this, or do I have to wait a minute? Go right ahead, Counselor. Okay. Thank you. So, this is, we've had a few of these where the appeal process does not seem clear to a member of the public, and they've attempted to appeal, and they weren't able to because they missed a date, they missed a deadline. I understand that it's in the code. And, Natalie, this is not to you because you are not responsible for the code update. But as we are doing the code update, one of the big challenges is that it is just not necessarily accessible to the general public. And I know sometimes, you know, when we'll, we'll have conversations with staff and they're like, it's very clear. And if, of course, it's very clear to those of us that are, well, and I don't do it, to those of you that are, you know, kind of inside this world every single day. As I've always said, you know, I think, you know, sticking to the code because it gives, you know, clear, fair treatment for everybody is important. But we've seen this happen multiple times, which tells me that we really need to work on how we communicate with the public, their ability, and the, you know, kind of the requirements around appeal. Because we, we have a lot of, we've had a lot of mix-up. We've had a lot of confusion. We've had times when people think that they got within the fifteen days, but we were counting it differently or which day we started counting. So, Justin general, I think that this is something that we really need to address with the code update and also with some of our public-facing materials regarding land use and land use processes because it is really challenging to understand and to find and for people to know and understand the rules. So, I very much understand why there is a recommendation to deny the appeal. It was outside the time limit that is, you know, that is stated, but I would really like us as a whole to work on the communication with the public so that they understand what this process is, and it is, it is very clearly stated. This individual, you know, may have been outside anyway. They looked, and it was too late. But, but I think it's something we should be really mindful of as this is not the first time this seems to have happened. So, that was all. Thank you, Mayor MICHAEL J. GARCIA: r. Thank you, Counselor. Any other commen PATRICIA FEGHALI: nts? Counselor Feghali. Thank you, Mayor. I'm a little confused about, there's a, there's a line in this report that says the land instructor issued a conformity review concluding that the appeal may go forward, given the thirty-day appeal window applicable to such matters. Is, can you e NATALIE CAULEY: explain? Absolutely. Thank you, Counselor Fagalli. So there are two relevant land use cases here. On June 4, the Planning Commission approved the conditional use approval for the 1802 Sireos. That's one land use case. At the same time, they approved a development plan for the site. The conditional use approval has the 15-day appeal window. The development plan had a 30-day appeal window, so the appellant was able to file his appeal in time to make the appeal window for the development plan. So that appeal is going forward. That will be heard by the body at the special hearing in No PATRICIA FEGHALI: ovember. Okay. So the filing was between 15 days and 30 days, essentially. It w NATALIE CAULEY: was on day 30. Yes. Okay. Thanks. Any MICHAEL J. GARCIA: y other questions? It's the will of the body. We move to JAMIE CASSUTT: approve the city attorney's request for acceptance to deny appeal of the Planning Commission's approval of conditional use permit for 1802 Suros Road, appeal number 202601949. Ivan, APBL land use case number 202511756. Second. Okay. W MICHAEL J. GARCIA: We've got a motion and a second. Any discussion on the motion? No ALMA CASTRO: o. I just want to make very clear for us and for the public that this is an approval of a denial of an appeal NATALIE CAULEY: l. I'm sorry, Mayor. I think the number may have been slightly misstated. It's 2026-012949. I think just the two was left out. MICHAEL J. GARCIA: Okay. Is that the intention, Counselor? Yes. Okay. PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: . Second. MICHAEL J. GARCIA: . Any other discussion on the motion made? Seeing and hearing none, Mr. Assistant City Clerk, can we get a roll call vote, Lease? ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: Yes, Mayor. Counselor Cassutt? ELIZABETH BARRETT: Yes. ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: Counselor Castro? Yes. Counselor Chavez? MARY NATALIE: ? Yes. ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: . Counselor Faulkner? Yes. Counselor Feghali? Yes. Counselor Barrett ELISA MONTOYA: t? Yes ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: s. Counselor Bustamante? Yes. The motion to deny the appeal has pass MICHAEL J. GARCIA: sed. Okay. Thank you. Next item in the agenda, ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: Lease. The next item on the agenda is request for approval of a budget adjustment request in the total amount of $175,000 to allocate half percent gross receipts tax to Complete Streets FY27 WIP construction for repairs to Sireos Road from Saint Francis Drive East Point 07 miles. Here to present this item Marcos Esquibel, Interim Complete Streets Division Director. Mr. Esq MICHAEL J. GARCIA: quibel, the floor is yours. Oh, just make sure the mic is on. Mr. Mayo MARCOS ESQUIBEL: or, members of the council, thank you for having me. I actually stand for questions. I can give you a quick summary of why we're here if you would like. In July 2026, the NMDOT offered to collaborate on a road improvement project that they were working on Saint Francis Drive, which included the intersection of Surreal's Road. They offered to collaborate with us for our portion of the roadway, which is the east side of, which is Surreal's Road, East of Saint Francis for about 7/100ths of a mile. That intersection is what they offered to help us with, and we took the help. So the collaboration project's going to be essentially a hot emplaced replacement of the asphalt. And thank yo MICHAEL J. GARCIA: ou, Mr. Escobelli. Any comments or questions? Yes. Answer for Gh ANDREA HOLLY: haly. Thank you, Mayor. Director Esc PATRICIA FEGHALI: cobelli, I get a lot of questions about the bollards, the sort of plastic bollards on Saint Francis near that intersection. This is not affecting that area. Is that correct? My coun MARCOS ESQUIBEL: ncil, Mr. Mayor, Councilor Begley, to my understanding, it does not. However, if they do work on replacing the asphalt through there, they would most likely replace those bollards, and those bollards do belong to me. Okay. T PATRICIA FEGHALI: Thank you. Motion PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: n to approve. Second. And MICHAEL J. GARCIA: we've got a motion and a second. Any discussion on the motion? Hearing, seeing none, Mr. Assistant City Clerk, can we get a roll call vote, Lease? Yes, Mayor. Councilor Castro? Yes. C ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: Councilor Chavez? Yes. Councilor Faulkner? Yes. Councilor Feghali? Yes. Councilor Barrett? Yes. Counselor, Counselor Bustamante? Yes. Counselor Cassutt ELLA KATZ: t? Yes ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: s. The motion has passed MICHAEL J. GARCIA: d. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Esquibel. Next item on the agenda, Leas ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: se. Mayor, the next item on the agenda is matters from the city man MICHAEL J. GARCIA: nager. Madam Deputy City Man CITY STAFF: nager? Mr. Mayor, Interim Chief Moya could not be here this evening, but he did want me to extend his thank you to all of the staff and city leadership who helped out, came together quickly to manage the tornado incident, severe weather incident over the weekend. We will be asking you to consider extending the emergency proclamation that the Mayor issued. We'll have an emergency meeting right after this regular governing body meeting at which you can consider extending that. We did have staff who assisted in multiple areas across the city in managing the incident and assisting in the recovery. And this included everyone from the public safety folks and emergency management, police and fire. They provided excellent and regular communication on the situation and ensuring that people were aware of all of the, as the situation was evolving. We also had staff like Sandy Emory who, through her team, helped to connect residents to resources, to help them, to assess their properties and in cleaning up. And, of course, our public works team was amazing. Environmental Services Division and our Utilities Department, and our Constituent Services Team and Communications Team as well. So, just wanted to extend a sincere thanks to everybody who helped out in managing the MICHAEL J. GARCIA: crisis. So, thank you. Next ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: item, Lease. Mayor, the next item is matters from the MICHAEL J. GARCIA: city attorney. Thank you, Mr. Mayor, members of the governing body. I don't have anything for you tonight. Okay. Okay. ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: Thank you. Next item. Mayor, the next item on the agenda is executive session action items of which there are none. So the next item after that is matters from the city clerk. I'd just like to echo the sentiments of Deputy City Manager, Andrew Phillips, to all the staff that helped out with the situation we had this weekend. I'd also like to give a shout out to our community engagement staff, our comms team, Jordan Buxton, Aaron Pulsiver, and Chris Peralta for all the work they put in this weekend to get the word out about what was going on. I'd also like to give a shout out to our Constituent Services Team, to Xavier Aguilar Morales and Michael Marchant. They did come in this weekend to start answering phone calls and putting in work orders to help with people who were affected by the storm. Yeah. It was, we would just like to thank everybody who assisted with this. It was a really great team effort, and that's all I have, M MICHAEL J. GARCIA: Mayor. Thank you. Thank you. Next item. Mayor, the next item on the agenda is communications from the governing body. Okay. I'm going to go to Councilor Cassutt just so I mak ELIZABETH BARRETT: ke sure I don't forget you. Thank you, Mayor. I would, I would echo a lot of what has been said. One of the main touch points was in the middle of District 4. And so I really cannot express my gratitude to the entire city, the city leadership, everybody who showed up to help our constituents who had been impacted. It really was a very frightening situation, and I think that it is quite the miracle that nobody who was directly impacted by the tornado was injured, or worse. And so I am extremely grateful. I know we've mentioned Sandy Emory. We've mentioned the Public Works Team and Environmental Services. Manuel from Senior Services. He was out knowing that this was a, or a neighborhood that has a lot of seniors and making sure that he was reaching out to them. We had Senator Ben Ray Luhan come out with his team to take a look at how they can assist, and I am, you know, extremely grateful to that. And then as, as Councilor Bustamante mentioned at the beginning, just seeing the community come out to really assist everyone. Councilor Bustamante and I were both there on Sunday morning, and just seeing the amount of people who were there and how quickly they were clearing trees and getting things into the dumpsters. And thank you to the city team for bringing out the dumpsters. I know that was, you know, really meaningful for the individuals that were impacted, and we're still getting requests. And that response is still coming quickly. So, an event that nobody would want to see, of course, and not that, not that we expected either as, as we, you know, we had one question. Do people know what to do? I'm like, we don't, we don't do tornadoes here. This isn't our thing. Wildfires and floods, we, you know, we know how to be prepared for those, but tornadoes, that's, that's not it. But just watching the city team and the community spring to action to take care, to address all of the challenges and really take care of each other was, was wonderful. Mayor, I've seen you out in the district numerous times throughout the last few days, and I'm really grateful for that. And I know my constituents are as well as well as City Manager Moya, who has just been ever present. So thank you to everybody. Thank you to the community, and, you know, really thinking about those constituencies that, constituents that were impacted. Lease continue to reach out to us. I know Councilor Chavez and I have had some, some email communications with a, with a couple of them. So Lease continue to reach out to us as, as, as more needs arise, because we're, we're here, and we will continue to support as long as needed. Thank you, Mayor. Thank you, Councilor. I'll j MICHAEL J. GARCIA: just go from my left to my right. Councilor Bustamante. Thank you, Mayor. I just w AMANDA CHAVEZ: want to remind everybody that this Friday, weather permitting, we're going to have the City of Santa Fe's Fall Festival and Halloween event at Regal Park from 4:00 to 8:00. So thank you. Councilor Castro. ALMA CASTRO: Thank you, Mayor. Echoing the sentiments of both of my colleagues, yes, definitely come out and do all of the Halloween activities. Thank you so much to the city teams for all of that they did. I think it's really important that we're coming together in these really difficult times. I, I also wanted to give kudos to Land Use Department for helping Councilor Feghali and I last night at the Chat with Pat. We had some really interesting conversations about the needs of the city, and as usual, we don't have enough resources. And so we're going to have some really difficult conversations as we come up on, as we heard tonight, some new streets designs, new support for affordable housing, new support for our facilities. So I hope that all of us are ready to really dig deep with our constituents like we have through these, I wouldn't say disasters. I think these are, again, difficult times that we're doing really well moving forward through. And I love, move, look forward to those conversations. Thank you. PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: Thank you, Councilor. Councilor Wagner. Yeah. I would, I would like to echo the sentiments of my colleagues. When there's disasters or trying times, it is amazing to see how fast politics don't matter, how fast just helping one another matters. The city manager and the mayor and the public works and constituent services and the police and fire. And I, I think, like, every department was touched by this, and I was really proud as a city councilor to see not only the city respond in a way that was not only appropriate, but that was also amazing to see. I heard tales of the mayor helping get a tree out of someone's backyard. And along with the city manager. That's the stuff that makes Santa Fe a good community. And then to see our community members come together is incredible, and it does remind us that at the end of the day, we are a community. And I think when things are real, we definitely come together and are there for one another. So thank you everyone for that. And as I said before from comments from the membership of committees and council, Posada Toy Drive, Posada Toy Drive, Posada Toy Drive. We're working on both those things. We have an amazing, an incredible artist donated some pieces of artwork to the toy drive. We're having a silent auction at the community gallery on December 18, and that's going to be a pretty fun event. We should hopefully raise a lot of money for the toy drive. The toy drive last year gave toys to 10,000 children all over the state, but roughly 6,000 of those children are in Santa Fe. So the majority of the kids who benefit from the toy drive are within the city of Santa Fe. And the Posada is going to be on the 17th. That's always a big fun event. I expect everyone to ALMA CASTRO: volunteer. So anyway, those are two big events on the South Side. Councilor Faulkner, I'm going to steal a little of your thunder. We always have a little bit of a difficult time with the older folks, so we're really doing a push for, if you do classes or events or experiences, if you could really reach out to us for that toy drive. PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: . Thank you. 100%. Thank you, JAMIE CASSUTT: , Councilor Castro. Councilor Chavez. Thank you. I want to start with, well, first of all, thank you to the counselors that reached out to me during the tornado. I have my three kids, and they were terrified. My daughter was terrified. Everyone was terrified, but it was amazing how many people checked in. So on a personal note, thank you for those that checked in on us. And then I want to do a personal shout-out to CHRISTUS St. Vincent. My daughter happened to get very sick after her traumatic terror with the tornado Saturday night. She got very sick. We were in the ER multiple times. And I want to shout this out because I feel like a lot of us have a lot of frustration with our medical system right now, rightfully so. But my daughter got amazing care at CHRISTUS St. Vincent's this weekend. She was severely dehydrated multiple times. It was scary for all of us, and the physicians and the care team were amazing. And it was a pattern of beautiful human beings. Just if you stop and you look around, we have beautiful human beings doing amazing things for other people. And so I was able to witness that this weekend. So I was in the hospital seeing these nurses devote so much time and caring to my daughter while looking online and seeing all of the individuals on this dais over there helping our neighbors that were impacted by the tornadoes and also seeing an overwhelming amount of community members saying, "How can we help volunteer? How can we help?" Showing up, doing the hard work to help their neighbors feel more secure and stabilize after that disaster occurred. So it was something that was very hard for our community, but it also was a reminder of what makes Santa Fe Santa Fe. And I said this multiple times, why we're Santa Fe is because we're family. If someone needs something, we show up. If a stranger needs something, we show up. We want to support one another. And I think we all witnessed that this weekend, and it was an incredible thing to witness. So I want to thank the members here that were there. Mayor, I think it spoke volumes that you were there putting in the hard work. I saw posts, but I also know that genuinely you care about your neighbors, and I just think that was a great example for our community. So I want to thank you for that. And I know that many community members saw that, Mayor, and they showed up, and they wanted to do more. And so, you know, look at the beauty we saw in such a dark place, right? Like something to celebrate through the darkness, which makes us resilient as a community. And, you know, we could take on anything as a community when we have that type of human beings coming together in a beautiful way. So I experienced that on a personal level, but then I was also able to observe it on this larger level that just, I have to say, I was incredibly proud to be born and raised in Santa Fe after this weekend. So thank you for all of those that were examples to the care that makes us who we are. Thank you for those who cared about me and my little. And yeah, I just, I can't be more grateful to be walking beside so many community members in Santa Fe that make us who we are. It's a great place to exist. So thank you all. Thank you, Councilor. Councilor Barrett. I just want to echo the sentiments of everybody too. I know it' MICHAEL J. GARCIA: 's all been said, but the community an ELISA MONTOYA: nd city response was just amazing and overwhelming. Our neighborhood got hit really, really hard. We got hit. Our house got hit. We had a tree uprooted, and it fell onto our house. And it was like, the next day, people came out with their chainsaws. People were knocking on our door. People brought coffee. It was just amazing. Neighbors that haven't lived in our neighborhood for years came back, and they were like, "Hey, I heard what happened. We're going to be there." So that was the silver lining. I know it's all been said before, so I don't need to go on, but it was very heartwarming to see that response. And also just want to pivot a little bit and shout out our Mayor's Youth Advisory Board. We've had several meetings. We're going to have names coming up again, six new names of members to be confirmed coming down the line. And we were also pre-tornado, we were volunteering at the Teen Center Halloween Carnival, which was Friday night, which had an amazing turnout, and Maya was there running all the carnival games. So I just wanted to shout them out, and we're growing and growing. So it's very exciting. Thanks. Thank you, Councilor Feghali. Thank you, Mayor. Again, echoing everything t MICHAEL J. GARCIA: that people said about the storm re PATRICIA FEGHALI: esponse and the amazing community that we have here. And then just pivoting a bit to this weekend where hopefully we'll have much better weather, but all the great activities, the city Halloween party, Dia de los Muertos on the Plaza, which is Friday and Saturday, and just a lot of a lot of fun things going around town. So I hope that people can take part in those and hopefully have a better weekend than last. Thanks. Thank you, Councilor. Not to be redundant, but just to get, as all had said, thank you MICHAEL J. GARCIA: u to everybody who stepped up during the initial response from the tornado and then all the recovery efforts that are continuing. City staff is still managing the process. It's ongoing. And as mentioned by the Deputy City Manager, we are bringing forward a proposal for continuation of the disaster declaration because we definitely see the need is still there. We want to make sure we're working to support the residents as we work to recover. Thank you, Councilor Chavez, for the words. It was one of those things where when these type of things happen, people just step up, and that's, as others had said, that's what makes Santa Fe so special. So disaster should not have to bring that out, but it definitely brought it out this weekend. Last announcement, you got less than a week to vote. So get out there, vote if you haven't. There are plenty, plenty of places, and make your voice heard. Get out there and vote. With that, I believe we've reached our evening portion of the agenda. Oops, sorry. I always do that. Let's move forward with the next item. Mayor, the next item on the agenda is introduction of legislation. Okay. We have consideration of a resolutio ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: on sponsored by Mayor Michael J. Garcia, resolution approving budg MICHAEL J. GARCIA: get ame ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: endments and requesting that the New Mexico Department of Finance and Administration approve the City of Santa Fe's first quarter budget amendments for fiscal year 2026 through 2027. I believe it speaks for itself. Consideration of a resolution sponsored by Mayor Michael J. Garcia MICHAEL J. GARCIA: a, Councilor Paul C. Bustamante, ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: , Councilor Hilar Faulkner, and Councilor Jamie Cassutt. A resolution identifying special committees that have sunset because they have completed their assigned work and sunsetting other standing committees whose purposes have been assumed through other means, the Parks and Recreation Advisory Committee and the Sustainable Santa Fe Commission. Councilor Bustamante. Thank you, Mayor. I think it speaks for itself. Thank you. C MICHAEL J. GARCIA: Councilor Faulkner. All AMANDA CHAVEZ: l I would add is we're trying to make the processes at the cities more expedit PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: ted when appropriate. And so one of the spaces we're looking at is the committees, and there's some that aren't even active that are still on the books. And so this is an attempt to clean up the committee process. Councilor Cassutt. Thank you, Mayor. And as Councilor Faulkner mentioned, you kno MICHAEL J. GARCIA: ow, these are inactiv ELIZABETH BARRETT: ve committees. I will say this is the, sponsors are having continuing conversations around our resident advisory committees and what are the various changes that we need to make in order to make sure that they're an effective use of time and that the governing body is really actually able to take advantage of the wealth of knowledge of these individuals who volunteer to provide their expertise to the city. So we are continuing to look at these committees and these processes so that they are as effective as possible. Thank you. I think everybody said what needed to be said. So with that, next item, Lease. The next MICHAEL J. GARCIA: item on the agenda is petitions from the floor. Okay. Do we have any folks? I know ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: w that we typically go at seven. I think if it's okay wit MICHAEL J. GARCIA: th the governing body, we can hear it from folks and then maybe circle back again at 7:00 PM Justin case folks show up. Mayor, can I make a recommendation? Yes. Yes. We do also have appointments, and I know it'll take about 30 seconds, but ELIZABETH BARRETT: t I would recommend that we jump to appointments and take care of that, and then we can buy ourselves a little more time. Okay. So that was a motion? Yes, that was a motion. Okay. We got a motion, and I beli MICHAEL J. GARCIA: ieve I heard a second. Any discussion on the motion? There are none. Mr. Assistant City Clerk, can we get a roll call, Lease? Yes, Mayor. Councilor Chavez? Yes. Councilor Faulkner? Yes. Councilor Fegha ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: ali? Yes. Councilor Barrett? Yes. Councilor Bustamante? Yes. Councilor Cassutt? Yes. Councilor Castro? Yes. The motion passes. Okay. We, Mr. ELIZABETH BARRETT: Assi ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: istant City Attorney, Lease read this item MICHAEL J. GARCIA: into the record. The next item on the agenda is appointments. We have an appoin ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: ntment to the Public Safety Committee, Chandler Moore, appointment to the Bicycle and Pedestrian Advisory Committee member seat, term ending June 2028. To approve? Second. And we've got a motion and a second ANDREA HOLLY: d. Any discussion? He MICHAEL J. GARCIA: earing, seeing none, Mr. Assistant City Clerk, can we get a roll call vote, Lease? Yes, Mayor. Councilor Faulkner? Yes. Councilor Feghali? Yes. C ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: Councilor Barrett? Yes. Councilor Bustamante? Yes. Councilor Cassutt? Yes. Councilor Castro? Yes. Councilor Ch PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: havez ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: z. The motion to approve the appointment has passed. Okay. Believe that returns us back t MICHAEL J. GARCIA: to petitions from the floor. So now is the time if any member of the public would like to step up. And just a reminder, we will circle back to petitions as close to seven as possible. Councilor, Mayor, this is Steven STEVEN FOX: n Fox, founder of United Nations Santa Fe. As you well know, I've put a lot of effort, some of you know better than others, into this concept of suing the City of Santa Fe, suing Pfizer for damages and harm done to New Mexicans. No, not just to New Mexicans in general, but to Santa Fe. New Mexicans, that's when we require the Attorney General. It's too tedious. I have to know what, you know, communicate with me. You don't have to know it right now. Communicate with me in the next thing, my Monday. If you like this idea and you've seen the merits in it, you've seen the absolute necessity to stop Pfizer and Moderna continuing their genocidal onslaught, which has, by the way, replaced nuclear weapons. Nuclear weapons are obsolete compared to... A pharmaceutical company can kill you for 29¢. That's a lot more for plutonium. That's a whole another question. Rand Paul, the senator from... I'm talking about this a lot, wasting money. We Morrow money from China and Japan, United Kingdom, to build all this stuff and then drop bombs, alienate nation after nation, but nothing comes back to Santa Fe. Will you Lease let me know? You all have my email. Let me know your ideas on this because there's no point in me pursuing it. Mayor has been very responsive. Those are chief of police. I've had to give a long talk with about the logistics and the criminal aspect of this pharmaceutical corporation. And as you know, the state of Florida is suing Pfizer, make new things in The Netherlands. Make new things. Thank you very much. My time's up. I look forward to your reply. Hello. My name is Madison Figueroa. MADISON FIGUEROA: I am a student at the University of New Mexico and the president of Albuquerque Students for Nuclear Disarmament. I am extremely concerned that the idea of pit production in our own capital and by our own people is not more of a concern to this city. I am concerned that you are not fully grasping the gravity of this situation. I again plead with you to take ten minutes out of your day and look into Trump's proposed pit mission. The streets of this city are covered with signs that say resist. We now have a chance to do just that, to resist. Why is this decision so hard? Because they're promising jobs? Because they are promising us financial security? I do not see this. I do not see jobs, and I do not see financial security. Are we okay with the Trump administration's and its wants when it brings a few decent jobs to New Mexico? Don't New Mexicans deserve well-paying jobs that aren't centered on building the country's nuclear arsenal? That is not something to be proud of. I am not proud that what so many call big tech is making its home here in New Mexico. I am not proud that my state is responsible for supporting Trump and his nuclear arsenal. I am not proud that my state is a trash can for the nation's nuclear waste. I think that my neighbors and my family are worth more than that. I think that all of you in front of me are worth more than that. I want to be proud of my home state. You have the chance to resist. Tell Trump and his administration, no. We will not sacrifice our people, housing, or streets for your arsenal. We will be a city of peace, and we will be a strong capital for our state. Now is the time to do so. Thank you. W GREG MELLO: Well, my name is Greg Mello. I'm the director of the Los Alamos City Group. Thank you for your attention this evening and for your service to the city. It's a particularly propitious time to speak up about nuclear weapons because we're entering a volatile period after the election. Congress has bills in front of it that reflect very different visions of the future of nuclear weapons and of pit production in particular. There's big differences in proposed appropriations. This council can affect this on the Martin. We can be the little weight on the scale, and we can help inspire others because Congress has to decide whether they're going to make pits at one site or another site or both sites. How long and how many? How many new weapons? So all these things are going to be on the table even more than they are now. I want to then look at the question of fusion experiments. Here is an article from the Wall Street Journal recently: "America leans on fusion breakthroughs to turbocharge its nuclear weapons arsenal." And I'm going to do this. And, unfortunately, some of this is going on at Midtown. Here's a resolution, I mean, ordinance number 2022-19. It covers Midtown Link. It would only need minor modifications just to rule out doing nuclear weapons development activities at Midtown. I don't think that's what the people wanted there, but that's what's happening, as well as training for making nuclear weapons. This is a large subject, and I'll have to leave it there. Thank you very ELLA KATZ: much. Hold on. Okay. Perfect. Good evening, counselors. My name is Ella Katz. I am a student at UNM and the vice president of Albuquerque Students for Nuclear Disarmament. Hold on. I am again here to urge you to take action on the Los Alamos Study Group resolution to oppose nuclear pit production in New Mexico. I feel that my face is already becoming familiar to you, and it quickly becomes difficult to deliver any new information as we await your decision. So I am going to focus on my relationship with and observations of Santa Fe. The first time I came to Santa Fe, I was one week old. My parents have been selling at the Santa Fe Farmer's Market since before I was born. Our entire livelihood depends on the market and therefore, Santa Fe. The vast majority of my Saturdays have been spent in this city. As a little girl, I would run around the market dodging between people's legs, stealing free samples, and exploring wherever I could. I loved it, and I loved being in Santa Fe. As I've aged, I've watched the market change profoundly. We used to be a produce farm, but my parents now sell fancy herbal products targeted at the rich tourists because this is what we must do to survive. I have watched the entire economy of the market shift. Farmers need to make themselves marketable to a whole new crowd, and often that is a sadly transient crowd. I worry that if this is something visible and pervasive in my small microcosm of Santa Fe, it must be the city shifting as a whole. Is it moving away from sustainability for locals and towards the profit for a few? I hope not. It might seem strange that I am talking about the farmers market as an anti-nuclear weapons activist, but it is because I believe that this is all interconnected. The character of Santa Fe has changed in my short lifetime, and I do not feel it is for the better. Focusing on the needs of our people should be more important than the money that is injected into the state by things like the nuclear weapons industry. As we have said many times before, by signing a resolution, you aren't writing its contents into law. It is simply declaring morality. I want to see a Santa Fe that is focused on community and prosperity. Morality is vital to the health of a city. I do not want to see a Santa Fe lost in greed. Thank you. Hello. M WINSTON DELORIA: My name is Winston Deloria, District 4. I'm an organizer with the Party for Socialism and Liberation. You've heard me before, I know. And previously, I've spoken about the politics and the morality, what our organization thinks about nuclear weapons in principle. But today, I'd like to focus more narrowly on our local economics. I want to preface this by saying, we do not see this as something to pit other Santa Feans against lab workers. That's not the line we take on gentrification. We don't think that's a useful line. We don't think that's a serious line. But I do think in terms of our planning for the economic future of Santa Fe, this lab work is the general, the kind of generic defense we hear about this is it brings in jobs, it brings in economic development. And to a certain extent, that's true. But any kind of economic development brings in jobs and brings in, technically, an increase in tax revenue, but not all these things are created equal. Forms of economic development that tend to bring in a narrower strata of workers, it does not create broad-based economic development. And what are the problems we're constantly hearing about in the city? Congestion and gentrification. We should be looking at forms of economic development that bring in a broader mass of jobs that can pay decent wages for working Santa Feans, more than just what is, frankly, does bring in quite a bit of revenue, but a very limited number of jobs has a very uneven impact on our city. Thank you. Good evening. My name is Marcy Matasik. I am not here to represent any organization. I'm here as an individual, a citizen. And I want to address this resolution that has b MARCY MATASIK: been mentioned this evening in previous meetings, opposing nuclear weapons. Nuclear weapons are against my religion, and they're against your religion too because every religion that I've ever heard of says that it is a sin or it is wrong to murder someone. But these bombs are meant to murder millions of people. There are weapons of mass murder being manufactured just some 20 miles west of here. And it's very, very concerning to me. It's deeply concerning to me that they're even being made. We already have thousands of weapons of mass destruction. Each one of them is many times more powerful than the bomb that destroyed Hiroshima. We've all seen the pictures of what Hiroshima looked like. Every one of these bombs is probably on average 20 times as powerful as that. We could kill millions of people with one of them, and we have thousands of them. And yet they want to make more. There's something really, really evil, really morally wrong about that, and I believe our city needs to say no, at least to say no to the expansion of that into our city. If you pass this resolution, it's not going to shut down LANL, but it will make a statement. It will say that we don't stand for weapons of mass murder, that weapons of mass murder aren't what we're all about. So Lease consider it, and Lease make a statement. Lease wrap up your comment, Lease. Your time has expired. Hello? My name is Mary Natalie. I'm a Livingston. We tend to downpl MICHAEL J. GARCIA: lay the danger of nuclear war, telling ourselves it's very unlikely. And when we hear words like apocalyptic, w MARY NATALIE: we assume it's an exaggeration. It's not. I'd like to quote Annie Jacobson from her meticulously researched novel, "Nuclear War: A Strategy." In her section on the aftermath of the nuclear war, she makes a final comment: "It was the nuclear weapons that were the enemy of us all along." The whole world knows nukes were invented in New Mexico. Brilliant scientists came together from many countries thinking they were in a contest with Germany to be the first to achieve it when in fact Germany wasn't putting energy into it after all. None of the scientists knew the United States would immediately utilize the first bombs in Japan or that the United States would appropriate it as our own special weapon during Russia than other countries to make them to protect themselves from us and to project their own power. At a recent peace conference in Kyoto, Japan, Alexander Mercuris, a British intellectual, made a closing statement that the thing that is particularly worrying in this specific period of time is the existence of nuclear weapons. Because if things go wrong, there's, quote, "no coming back from that." This is a pivotal moment with crises in Europe and the Middle East. World leaders are worried about heightened nuclear risk. New Mexico itself is in danger as a potential nuclear target state, specifically Albuquerque, with the lab increasingly drawing attention to Los Alamos and by proximity Santa Fe. It would be helpful and not merely symbolic for us to have the courage to speak out against the folly and extreme risk posed by nuclear weapons, and now is the time. Our voices are not as important as others. They are far more important. For the sake of world peace, Lease sign a resolution opposing pit production at. Thank you. Miss Garcia, if you can Lease wrap up the comments. Hi, mayor and council members. My name is Italia Reyna Aguilar. I will be translati MICHAEL J. GARCIA: ing for member Lucero. Hello, my name is Lucero Garci ITALIA REYNA AGUILAR: ia, and I live at the Casitas Trailer Park at 4650 Airport Road. I am a Chainbreaker member, and my family applied for and received assistance from the City of Santa Fe's Eviction Prevention Fund. Chainbreaker is a member-led organization dedicated to economic, environmental, and racial justice. It has over 800 dues-paying members in Santa Fe, New Mexico, most of whom reside in neighborhoods that suffer from a lack of investment and are vulnerable to gentrification and eviction. Chainbreaker organizes community members on the front lines, those directly affected by issues concerning housing, transportation, and civil rights, to help make Santa Fe a more equitable city. I am one of the eight households that were forced to leave the Sangre de Cristo complex in June 2026 due to a fire in Building C. Chainbreaker has been working with me and the other affected residents of Sangre de Cristo to help us access resources, obtain reports on the cause of the fire, and secure compensation for damages from property management and government agencies. Thanks to our collective efforts, the Santa Fe City Council expedited the approval for an emergency fund for tenants. After months of bureaucratic delays, the funds finally became available in October. The need within the community was so great that the entire fund was distributed among 227 households in less than a week. Despite the success of this round, we know that the aid is not enough, and the tenants need more support. For instance, because my husband is the sole income earner in our household, I did not meet the eligibility requirements, and my application was denied. We must address oversights like this. Ultimately, my husband was able to apply and then receive the funds. All I want is to be able to reapply for this fund as the expenses resulting from the fire exceed the money we received. My family and I, along with all of the residents of Sangre de Cristo who support me and tenants across Santa Fe who have been displaced from their homes or are barely scraping by, know exactly what is at stake, and we face it head-on day after day. Policies like the Eviction Prevention Fund have been included in the Hopeful Man Neighborhood Stabilization Plan because tenants like this, we broke them. We already know how to get out of the housing crisis. Now we just have to do it together. Thank you. Thank you, Mayor Garcia. Counselors, good evening. Andrew Holly, District Two. I want to thank them ANDREA HOLLY: for sharing their story because I'm actually here in the capacity of activist, investor, I know some of you, in housing. And I'm here, which the report will probably be presented shortly regarding the CAPER report, which is the report on the Community Development Block Grant that the city receives from the federal government. And I happened to watch the meeting of the Quality of Life Committee, and I'm looking. Miss Holly, I just want to stop because there is a public hearing for that item MICHAEL J. GARCIA: m, and that's the appropriate time to provide the public comment. Okay. My comment is I would love for the counselors who were there to share their sentiments ANDREA HOLLY: s because it was quite an interesting meeting. I'll be back. Okay. It's connected to something you and I talked about too. Good evening, Council and staff. The planned expansion of nuclear weapons work is cont PUBLIC COMMENTER: tinuing a massive misallocation of resources based on the misguidance of the U.S. foreign policy elite. This elite has been wrong since the end of World War Two and asked us to continue the same policy. This elite determined that the Soviet Union after World War Two was getting ready to attack the United States. They were wrong. The Soviets were not contemplating attacking us and seeing our buildup, were worried we were going to attack them and thus starting the Cold War. We went to war with Vietnam concerned that world communism was spreading. Later, Roberta McNamara, who was Secretary of Defense leading the war effort, wrote that it was a mistake. A mistake cost the lives of 58,282 American soldiers. That's 303,704 more Americans to see. It killed three and a half million people and destroyed three countries. There was no reconciliation commission after the war to determine what went wrong. The war in Iraq cost the lives of 4,492 Americans and wounded another 32,292. Brown University's Cost of War project estimates that well over a quarter of a million deaths is a result of that war. The U.S. has 250th anniversary. U.S. Foreign Policy Association compiled a list of the 10 best and 10 worst foreign policy decisions this country has made. The best decision on the list was the Marshall Plan. The worst was Iraq. Another mistake. Too long for me to explain here, but the United States, not Russia, is primarily responsible for the war in Ukraine. See the article "Why We Are in Ukraine" in Harper's Magazine, June 2023. With this kind of track record, are we really going to continue the same policy leadership? It's not just about prediction. It's about a gross misallocation of resources. Thank you. Mr. Pox, it's not the time for audience commentary, but thank you. I was addressing it to the gentleman behind you. Next speaker, MICHAEL J. GARCIA: Lease. Is the mic on? I just want to make sure that folks can online can hear you. The mic should have a... It's turned it up. Good evening. We're good to go. Good evening, Mayor Garcia and City Councilors. I'm Linda Flatt, and I'm representing Indivisible Santa Fe this ev LINDA FLATT: vening. We're the grassroots organization that produces the No Kings rallies. The last one had about 8,000 attendees and featured Senator Ben Ray Luján as the key speaker. We are wondering why the city hasn't fully resolved the issue of its citizens' rights to peacefully assemble as guaranteed by the First Amendment. The city's requirements that we purchase a $1,000,000 insurance policy is unduly burdensome for a grassroots organization like ours. We ask that you accept a more reasonable standard, waiving the requirements of this insurance coverage. Other cities like Albuquerque have figured this out. Surely, we can do so also. If that burden is lifted, Indivisible Santa Fe can move forward with preparing well-coordinated and planned rapid responses for the tsunami that might occur after the mid-elections. Our country is in political turmoil at this time, as you know, and no one knows how the current administration may try to further sabotage the midterm elections on November 3rd and after, before certification and other legal processes. It is imperative to protect these votes. Local decision-makers, excuse me, must pick a side and act. Mayor Garcia, you and the City Councilors, all of you, are responsible for the safety and well-being of your constituents, ensuring that all citizens are able to exercise their rights under the Constitution. Lease, I urge you, resolve this issue. We can then move forward to be prepared for what lies ahead, and time is of the essence. Thank you. Thank you, Mayor and Councilors. My name is Melinda Hall, and I'm also with Indivisible Santa Fe. I'm on the steering committee. I'm MELINDA HALL: m here to... First of all, I sent everybody an email earlier today. I hope you got a chance to read that. If not, I hope you read it soon. I'm here to ask the Mayor and City Council to work together with urgency to create a way forward to protect our constitutional rights. In the coming days, we could be called upon to protect and defend the vote. We are preparing to mobilize the masses to protect and object to any unlawful actions to compromise the votes, including protecting any lawful seizure of the ballot boxes from the County Clerks or wherever that may be happening. Most of our community, as you probably know, is made up of older activists. And for those of us of a certain age to consider placing ourselves in harm's way to protect the rule of law, to tell you all you need to know about how much we love this country and respect our democracy. Thank you all. Thank you all for working creatively to solve this impasse, which it is. It has been an impasse now for over a year around these exorbitant fees that prevent our First Amendment rights. Thank you. I got to say, wow. Wow. You're clapping yourself and patting yourselves on the back for doing your job on Satur PUBLIC COMMENTER: rday. Congratulations. You're amazing. You know what? It's not about politics. No fireman, no police person deals with politics when it comes to dealing with the call. When it comes to issues, it is about taking care of the constituents, the community. They care about the community. You guys are playing a political game. It's sad, sick, and pathetic. You don't care about them. You're out there just to get your photo in the newspaper. It's sad. Two, when it comes to mental health crisis, it doesn't have a time limit. It could happen right now. It could happen in 10 minutes. It could happen in five days. You just don't know. So to make a time limit from four to eight, jack off. That's a joke. Congratulations. There's people out there that deal with mental issues all day long. And you know what? They don't want to deal with the person. They don't want to deal with that. They don't want to deal with this because they've already went through it, and it's a joke because they don't help. They make the issue worse. You guys are sick and sick not to deal with these issues. It's disgusting. You guys don't care what I say. I know you don't, and I don't care. But I'm going to come up here every meeting, and I'm going to tell you how I feel because it's my right. And you know what? I might start protesting outside this building just to do it because it's my right, and I don't need no permit. You guys are disgusting. Figure it out. We need to stop giving out handouts and start teaching people. If we keep giving handouts out, they're just going to keep coming back. It's like a stray cat. You feed it, it's going to keep coming back for free food. We need to stop doing that. Is there any other member of the audience that would lik MICHAEL J. GARCIA: ke to provide public comment tonight? None. Mr. Assistant City Clerk, is there anybody online? Mayor, Stephanie Beninato is online. Stephanie Beninat ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: to. I thought it was rather prescien STEPHANIE BENONATO: nt that I sent you comments on the appeals ordinance given that 1802 Cerillos Road came up tonight. And I appreciate Councilor Casa bringing up some problems with people understanding the timelines. But I think the real problem is the due process and that the person who's the appellant, who's paid $200 for that appeal, does not have an opportunity to be heard in front of the Council. And maybe tonight's suggestion by the City Attorney was obvious to you all. But again, due process requires that the appellant be heard. And I have suggested a limited public hearing with only the city and the appellant as party, limited to the reasons for dismissal. I've suggested this more than once. It's an easy fix. It also brought up the problem of the 35-day rule where if the agency, organization, commission, board does not rule, it becomes a final decision, and then you have so many days in which to appeal. And the fact that you have two different appeal periods, I think, is rather confusing. Whereas the city itself can take its sweet time in coming up with findings of facts and conclusions of law. And my experience is that often they are creatively, they are creatively made to support the outcome but do not reflect what really happened in the meeting. And that happened in the case of 515 Paseo de Peralta, for example. You did not read the transcript of YouTube or listen to it, and you could have a transcript from Zoom. So again, my suggestion is that at 35 days, the board has to have a meeting to adopt the findings and facts and conclusions of law, or in the alternative, the city is limited to providing a transcript of the hearing and if applicable, the staff recommendations. And then I also wanted to point out that you have this provision that permits can only be appealed for 15 days after the issuance, but the problem is that person doesn't know when they're issued. The person who's picking up the permit does not have to pick it up on the day it's issued. And so that it's been an odd two-year time has expired. If you can Lease wrap up your comment. Yeah, sure. So that 15-day rule is useless, especially since you have to also ask for the permit through EPRA. And I did, just to finish, point out to you a problem about the minimum number of votes at the historic board meetings, and I hope that you have read the comments I put into the public record. I think it's important that these... Thank you, Ms. Beninato. Balance. Thank you. Mr. Assistant City Clerk, is MICHAEL J. GARCIA: there any other public comments online? Mayor, there are no additional ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: l public commenters online. Okay. With that being said, MICHAEL J. GARCIA: let's go ahead and move on to our next item of business. The next item on the a ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: agenda is public comments on bills. We have consideration of Bill 2026-20, adoption of an ordinance sponsored by Councilor Amanda Chavez and Councilor Pilar Falconer, a bill authorizing the execution and delivery of a water project fund loan/grant agreement by and between the New Mexico Finance Authority and the City of Santa Fe, New Mexico, in the total amount of $2,550,000, including a loan in the amount of $1,020,000, evidencing an obligation of the borrower/grantee to utilize the loan/grant amount solely for the purpose of financing the cost of designing upgrades to the chemical feed equipment incorporated in the water utility system owned and operated by the city for the purpose of improving the water utility system and solely in the manner described in the loan/grant agreement, providing for the pledge and payment of the loan amount and an administrative fee solely from the net revenues of the water utility system of the borrower/grantee, certifying the loan/grant amount together with other funds available to the borrower/grantee is sufficient to complete the project, approving the form of and other details concerning the loan/grant agreement, ratifying actions heretofore taken, repealing all actions inconsistent with this ordinance, and authorizing the taking of other actions in connection with the execution and delivery of the loan/grant agreement. This is the opportunity to provide their first public comment on MICHAEL J. GARCIA: this proposal. Is there anybody in the audience that would like to speak to this? Not seeing any. Are there any online, Mr. Assistant City Clerk? Mayor, Stephanie Beninato would like to make a comment. Okay. Ms. Beninato, the floor is yours for two minutes. Thank you. I just wonder if, I mean, it sounds like our water fees wi STEPHANIE BENONATO: ill go up again, and they are already pretty high. I also wonder if it's in a... I know it used... It says that you're supposed to be able to do this project within the amount designated, but is it really accurate? And then I wonder how much the entire project costs to get the whole thing done because this is only a part of the whole project to improve the water system. So those are some questions that I raise in considering this bill. Thank you. Thank you. Is there any other public comment? No. Ther MICHAEL J. GARCIA: re are no additional public commenters. Okay. ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: With that, thank you, Mr. Hook. And happy to h MICHAEL J. GARCIA: have you give a presentation if you like, but if not, we can move to the next item. I'm okay with moving forward to the next item. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Hook. I appreciate it. Have a good evening. Next item on the agenda, Lease. Mayor, the next item on the agenda is final ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: action on legislation, of which there is none. Okay. Next item, Lease. Mayor, the next MICHAEL J. GARCIA: item is public hearings. ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: . Item A is request for approval of the Program Year 2025 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report, or CAPER, for submittal to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development as a condition to the City of Santa Fe's Community Development Block Grant. Here to present this item is Heather Lamboy, Land Use Director, and Christina Browning. Okay. We'll start off, staf MICHAEL J. GARCIA: ff. Looks like you got a presentation, and then we'll move forward to public comment. And then we can move to... Comes from the governing body. Mayor Garcia, members o HEATHER LAMBOY: of the council. I'll be doing a presentation on the 2025 Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report, also known as the CAPER. So, what is the CAPER? The City of Santa Fe's 2023 through 2027 Consolidated Plan is carried out through annual action plans. And annual action plans provide a concise summary of the actions, activities, and resources that will be used each year to address the priority needs and specific goals identified by the Consolidated Plan. The city reports on accomplishments and progress towards Consolidated Plan goals in the Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report. Now, the CAPER is required by HUD, and it includes a report on resources and investments, goals and outcomes, progress towards providing affordable housing, demographic composition of individuals and families assisted, citizen participation efforts. So the source of the funds are CDBG. And CDBG is the Community Development Block Grant, and it provides... It's a program that provides federal funding to help communities address housing and community development needs, primarily benefiting people with low to moderate incomes. So the resources made available for this program year are $1,067,380, and the amount expended during the program year was $875,415. The city's Program Year 2025 CDBG resources include $633,475 in annual entitlement funds, $200,000 in program income, and $233,905.68 in unspent funds carried forward from prior years. Actually, let me go back one. One. So before I review the goals and the outcomes, I want to clarify this CAPER covers 07/01/2025 through 06/30/2026, and it's HUD's required annual report for that reporting period. All contracts continued through 09/30/2026. Additional accomplishments during July through September fall outside this report and will appear in the Program Year 2026 CAPER. An activity showing no completed outcomes by June 30 does not mean no work occurred. The Office of Affordable Housing can provide a supplemental update on activities completed after June 30 at a later date, but for today's purposes, this is what we can report. Okay. So for the goals and outcomes for Program Year 2025, our first goal, 1A, increase availability of supportive services. The goal was 800 persons assisted, and the outcome was 963 persons served. 1B, expand options for overnight shelter beds. The goal was 400 persons assisted, and the completion is anticipated in Program Year 2026. 2B, expand choice for affordable home buying opportunities. The goal was 20 households assisted, and the outcome was eight households assisted through mortgage assistance programs. 3A, provide owner-occupied housing rehabilitation, and the goal was 20 households assisted. 3B is to provide for energy efficiency upgrades and accessibility, and the goal was also 20 households to be assisted. The outcome for that were zero households assisted. And 4A is to increase economic opportunities for LMI, low to moderate income populations. Goal was 80 persons assisted, and the outcome was zero persons assisted. The city's decision to delay acceptance of its Program Year 2025 CDBG funding due to concerns related to federal executive orders, along with staff turnover, affected the timing of program implementation and the number of beneficiaries assisted during the year. This slide shows persons assisted by race and ethnicity, and you could see that it's separated by race, ethnicity, and the number of percentage for each category. Households assisted with affordable housing. So the city leverages CDBG with other funding sources to complete housing rehabilitation projects. There were eight households that were assisted with homeownership activities through HomeWise Mortgage Assistance Program and the Housing Trust Mortgage Assistance Program. Below is a table shows where the income level falls. So there were six low-income beneficiaries and two moderate-income beneficiaries for a total of eight. For our citizen participation, the CAPER was made available to the public for a period of 15 days, which actually started on September 15 through September 30. A legal notice was published in the Santa Fe New Mexican in English and Spanish to notify the public of the comment period in today's public hearing. The draft CAPER is available online at the city's affordable housing webpage, and a paper copy is also available for review at the Office of Affordable Housing during regular office hours, or it may be requested by calling (505) 955-6574. Today serves as a public hearing and how you can participate. Comments are accepted during the public hearing or may be submitted by email to contactoah@santafenewmexico.gov or by mail to the Office of Affordable Housing, City of Santa Fe, 200 Lincoln Avenue, Santa Fe, New Mexico 87501. The HUD submission, the CAPER will be submitted on or before 10/30/2026. And again, any questions or comments could come to the Office of Affordable Housing, in person, if you want a copy of the draft paper, our office 9, and our office email address. And that concludes my presentation. Okay. Thank you, Ms. Browning. This is a public hea MICHAEL J. GARCIA: aring, so if there are any members of the public that would like to provide comment, now is the time to do so. I again... What point of order, Mayor? Yep. I ju ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: ust conferred with the City Attorney. We do need to swear these people in if they're going to comment. Lease state your... Raise your right hand and state your name and address for the record. Andrew Holly, 1584 Louisa Street. Do ANDREA HOLLY: you solemnly declare and affirm th ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: hat the testimony you have in reference to this item shall be the truth and nothing but the truth and do this under the penalties of perjury? Yes. The commentary has been sworn in. Good. So, Andrew Holly, back again. I ANDREA HOLLY: like you. I like you. A lot of what I'm about to say probably has nothing to do with either one of you. But three main points. I happen to be watching this meeting, and I overheard pieces of the presentation. And the reactions in the room during quality of life sort of made me turn and look again. And councilors present, Barrett, Chavez, Castro, and Cassutt can speak for themselves. I also want to shout out, I believe it was Community Development Commissioner Torres was here, also from District 2, who spoke a bit. The reason I wanted to comment on it is because the main accomplishment as highlighted in these past slides and on the draft memo were that eight households were assisted with home buying. I had a meet with Mayor Mike. What's up, Mayor Mike? And you had said to me when we discussed housing, like, kind of one of your first comments was, "I want people to be able to buy houses, build wealth, you know, get property and start building generational wealth," which is a very legitimate housing goal. So when I heard, "Okay. They're buying homes," I'm like, "Okay. That's part of your goal." I then went and looked at the report after the reactions, and I realized that the money allocated to that was $522,000. Divided amongst eight is an average of $65,000 per household. I'm happy for those eight people, but that amount of money per person is quite a lot. I come from the world of health economics, Masters in Public Health, shout out. But more importantly, Mayor and others, I wanted to bring it back up because also when you and I talked, you talked about how a strategic plan is being developed from homelessness to housing. And I said to you, I have some skepticism around strategic plans for these type of reasons. We had goals, we had percentages, we all... outcomes. And a lot of the goals, I'll let the council members speak, were like zero. Or even the housing one, they accomplished eight on 20. People can do the math. So that... I admire plans. I appreciate goals, but they can go, "Yeah, yeah." And last but not least, I asked you about staffing shortages and turnover, and we didn't really get into that. But I feel like these two ladies are answering for a lot of things they didn't do. MICHAEL J. GARCIA: . So thank you. If there are any other members of the public who would like to speak to this item, now is t ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: the time to do so. Lease raise your right hand and state your name and address for the record. Elizabeth West at 8, 318 Center Street, Santa Fe. Do you solemnly declare and affirm that the testimony you have in reference to this item shall be the truth and nothing but the truth and do this under the penalties of perjury? Yes, I do PUBLIC COMMENTER: o. You have been sworn in. I confess I've been out of town for nearly a month, traveling with my son and doing great things and not thinking about Santa Fe very much. So I know nothing about this, and it seems like a drop in the bucket. And that's better than nothing, but I don't understand it. So, my reaction is a little bit of surprise, and I'm sorry I'm not better equipped. But I decided I would speak up and say that to you all. Thank you for all the work you're doing, and s MICHAEL J. GARCIA: sorry I've missed you. Okay, bye. Okay. Are there any other members of the audience that would like to speak to this item? Seeing none, are there any online, Mister Assistant City Clerk? Mayor, Stephanie Benonato would like to make a comment. Okay. Go ahead, Miss Benonato. I need to swear ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: in. Sorry about... Apologize. Thank you, Mayor. L STEPHANIE BENONATO: Lease state your name and address for the record. Step ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: phanie Benonato, PO Box 1601, Santa Fe, New Mexico. Do you solemnly declare and affirm that the testimony you have in reference to this item shall be the truth and nothing bu STEPHANIE BENONATO: ut the ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: e truth and do t STEPHANIE BENONATO: this under the penalties of perjury? Yes. You are sworn. So, I just want to say that I understand that this was discussed at Quality of Life and how it's been brought to you in a rather abbreviated way. But I find it to be a little bit concerning when on the 28th during the meeting, you're saying that you can bring comments about this plan. It doesn't give people the opportunity really to do that, and you're going to submit something two days later. Again, this is not much time and not really any real opportunity to have your comments incorporated into any draft that has already been made and will probably not be changed no matter what comments are received in the next day or two. So in terms of public participation, public knowledge, I just find it a little bit lacking in terms of people understanding what this grant, this block grant is and how it's working. And I would agree that the goals have really not been met. And I can understand that there has been turnover and there have been changes in policy. But again, it's pretty discouraging when we keep havin MICHAEL J. GARCIA: ng to talk about the same issues over and over again. Thank you. Are there any other individuals online that would like to provide comp... Mister Assistant City Clerk? Mayor, there are no additional commenters online. Okay. Let's go ahead and move to a ALMA CASTRO: any questions or comments from the governing body. Councilor Castro? Thank you, Mayor. Thank you, Governing Body. I do note that I saw in Quality of Life that our schedule was incorrect, and so we have updated that. Thank you so very much. Are there othe ELIZABETH BARRETT: er changes that we should be aware of since Quality of Life on this CAPER? Mayor, Councilor Castro, we did update some of the numbers, and C HEATHER LAMBOY: Christina is more adept at answering that question, so I'm going to defer to her. Maya Garcia, members of the council. Yes. So the... A question came up last time about the 800 people goal, and that was actually exceeded. And let me go to the actual goal. The goal of to increase availability of support services was 800, and it actually was exceeded. The outcome was 963 persons. And also with the overnight shelter beds. So the goal is 400. This will be on the program year 2026 CAPER report, but we did receive an update on that, and there were 27 beneficiaries that were served there. So we didn't meet the goal, but there were people served in that category as well. And so those would be the major updates ALMA CASTRO: s that were questionable at the Quality of Life meeting, which is totally understandable. Thank you so much. And I also want to address just a little bit of that change in directive that we've heard from a couple of the folks who gave comment tonight. Because we are looking at a very increased, and we heard actually from public comment as well, need for direct services, eviction prevention. We did hear from Commissioner Torres at Quality of Life about the desire, at least internally, for the CDC to look at maintaining and preventing eviction for folks that are already in their homes. And so I just wanted to have that be part of this conversation. When we talk about change of directives, though it is extremely important that we allow for folks to get into new homes and allow to build wealth, we're also seeing a big need in our senior community of folks who have just real needs of updating the homes that they're in or maybe downsize. And s MICHAEL J. GARCIA: so we are also trying to look at how we best use these dollars across the board. Thank you so much, ma'am. Thank you, Councilor. Any other comments? Not seeing any, and Councilor Casa, just double checking with you. I just got one quick question, Miss Browni HEATHER LAMBOY: ing. When, given that this is a strategic plan that covers many years, when is the end of t MICHAEL J. GARCIA: the strategic plan? Mayor Garcia, I believe that would be 2027. Okay. And so there'll be a new plan going forward. Okay. Just wanted to make sure that we understand HEATHER LAMBOY: that this is a MICHAEL J. GARCIA: multi-year process. Yeah. And not everything has to be completed by t PATRICIA FEGHALI: the submission date of th MICHAEL J. GARCIA: he 30th. Correct. Okay. Any other comments, questions? What's the will of the governing body? Move to approve. Second. And we got a motion and a second. Any d ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: discussion on the motion? Hearing, seeing none. Mister Assistant City Clerk, can we get a motion or a rol ELIZABETH BARRETT: ll cal ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: ll vote, Lease? Yes, Mayor. Councilor Fagalli? Yes. Councilor Barrett? Yes. Councilor MICHAEL J. GARCIA: r Bustamante? Yes. Councilor Cassutt? Yes. Counc ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: cilor Castro? Councilor Chavez? Yeah. Councilor Faulkner? Yes. The motion has passed. Okay. Thank you, sir. Next item on the agenda, Lease. Mayor, the next item on the agenda is consideration of Bill Number 2026-17. A bill rezoning an approximately 5.96 tract of contiguous land parcels located at 2745 Boylan Circle, 2743 Boylan Circle, and 1372 Boylan Lane from R1, one dwelling unit MICHAEL J. GARCIA: t per acre, to MU, mixed use. Case Number 2024-61. Here to present this item is Joel Cruz-Haber, Senior Planner. Okay. Before we get started, Joel, let's, now is the time if there are any external communications where a governing body member feels they cannot be impartial. Now is the time for them to do or to recuse themselves. Seeing none, we'll... I'll go ahead and quickly run through the process. We will first have a presentation from staff, not to exceed 15 minutes, then a presentation from the applicant, not to exceed 15 minutes, then we will move towards sworn public comment, not to exceed three minutes per person. Then we will move to any questions from the governing body members. After that is concluded, we will close the public hearing, and then the governing body will consider a motion and a second potentially, and then any discussion deliber JOEL CRUZ-HABER: rations on that motion with a potential roll call vote. So with that being said, Joel, the floor is yours. Thank you, Mayor. Let me do it. All right. I'll just jump right into it. City Clerk did a great job explain... introducing the case. The general location of this property is about one mile east of the Seiler and Agua Fria intersection, which is shown here at the yellow and purple intersection. The site is here in blue. It is adjacent to the Acequia Lofts, and we'll go into a vicinity map. Again, the blue parcels, the subject property consists of four continuous parcels adjacent to the site. To the east are Acequia Lofts. To the south, we have HomeWise, multi-family units, Escondido restaurant right across the street, Frenchies Park, again, further down east, Tumble Root FA to the west just for vicinity. Starting here, we're going to start 10... I don't know why my screen just jumps to the next. Just bear with me on that. We're going to start 10,000 feet up. We're going to look at the general plan, and I'm also going to tell the story of how this project has changed over time. The future land use map designation for the site is transitional mixed use, and the initial request was to amend the future land use map from transitional mixed use to community commercial and rezone from R1 to C2. Now when staff received the application, when we reviewed it, it was very clear that the request was not consistent with the West Santa Fe River Corridor, which was a plan and resolution brought to you by Governing Body in 2017. And part of that resolution and in that plan described what we wanted to see here. We wanted to see R1 not be here. We wanted to see more higher density, multi-family units, specifically, of course, bringing in affordable housing. So, and then, specifically, the plan calls for rezoning ourselves from R1 to mixed use. This is a map generated from that plan. And as you can see here, the subject parcel that was once R1, the plan clearly states that it would want it to be mixed use. And that is convenient because the resolution created what is our Santa Fe River Corridor Overlay. So this has different... This has restrictions to height, restrictions to setback, restrictions to open space. One height restriction is limited in 28 feet for height, and that's for... That's comment that was given by the community to protect the viewshed of that river corridor area. It also calls for greater setbacks along that frontage and a requirement that subdivisions with five to 25 or more homes shall dedicate 10% of land as common open space in lieu of dedication park. So we're already thinking ahead on the park situation. So there's kind of staff's reason why it was determined that a mixed use zone was more consistent with the plans that communities already put together. And at the June 18 Planning Commission, it was recommended by staff that a mixed use zone be approved and the general plan amendment be denied. Again, here is our current R1 zoning. Oops. And we're getting down to our 5,000 foot level. We're at R1. Again, to the north, to the west, even to the portions of the east, there's R1. However, across the street, we have mixed use. And then as you can see in our southwest, it's kind of grayed out, but that's our industrial area. And it's very important that we maintain this trans... this transitional nature of this portion of town, as it goes from highly Denise commercial to single family and Denise multi-family. Now we're on ground level, and this is a street view of the site. To the far right, you can see Acequia Lofts. This driveway is the main driveway accessing all the properties towards the rear, and we're at ground level. Have fun. Thank you. So now if the government body recommends the approval or recommends the decision by Planning Commission, these would be the dimensional standards. So one thing with mixed use, everyone's been zoning away from it. So why are we recommending, why do we think this one's more consistent? Specifically, the density. You can see on the bottom, buildings of 25 feet or less in height shall not exceed a maximum of 12 dwelling units per acre. All the structures in this area are already restricted to 28 feet, so we're limiting. So if you're wondering what the density would be, likely 12 dwelling units per acre. Still does require open space, 250 square feet. And then we do have setbacks that can be a bit constraining to potential development. However, fortunately, through our LDC update that we're currently going through, this is something that we are going to address quickly. I'm going into a little bit of the site schematics. It does abut a FEMA flood zone, and there is, in this overlay district, it does require a 15-foot setback for all structures. But we don't have proposed development. We can't condition this rezoning. But when we do have development proposed, that will be enforced. Utilities on the site currently, there are existing water, sorry, there's dwelling units that are legal non-conforming. They were annexed from the county. And for that reason, the utilities are well, and there is a private well connection. You kind of see it here in red. It bisects the property and then goes into the Arroyo, which connects to our public system. When development is proposed in the future, we will require connections to city services. To poverty the site, it has a 20-foot drop from the Agua Fria to the rear of the property, so we'll see most of that drainage grading go that way once that grading plan and planning and drainage plan comes in. Although we were not expecting comments, we did send this out to DRT for input. Again, everyone deferred to once we get a development plan. Once we see some kind of proposed development, that's when we will request more input and comment. This rezoning has met all the public notice requirements. An ENN was held on 09/20/6024. Again, there were some minor technical difficulties there, but it was all able to be resolved, and I can defer to the applicant for that specific information. This meeting tonight has been duly notified. As you recall, maybe from the October 14 public hearing, you all postponed this to the 28th. Prior to that, the site was noticed in the New Mexican. Site posts and mailers were sent to neighbors on the 15th. We did not need any re-noticing. However, the applicant went out of their way to go ahead and update that sign. The approval criteria for a rezone have been satisfied. Again, this application was submitted under the old code. The approval criteria hasn't changed, just the code sections have changed. And the approval criteria has been met. Those findings for the approval criteria can be found in Attachment A of this memo. As I mentioned earlier, the Planning Commission did recommend a less intensive zoning designation than originally requested from R1 to mixed use. How can that happen? Well, our code fortunately does allow the governing body to review and decide a rezoning to a less intensive zoning district. I reference our old code and our new code section for that. The motions required for you tonight are to approve or deny. Again, Bill Number 202617, rezoning approximately 5.96 tract of continuous acres at those parcel numbers and that address from one dwelling unit to mixed use. And before I leave the podium, I would just like to clear two things. I think on the agenda, it says the case number is 61202461, and it's 94, 9461. So I just want to clear that. And in the memo, it did state that a new assessment or survey of the site stated that it was 8.725 acres. However, that surveyor has redone their survey and has confirmed it is the 5.96. It's never changed. That's MICHAEL J. GARCIA: s still good, and I can defer, you can defer to Victoria for that. And I'll stand for any questions. Okay. Th WAYNE DALTON: hank you, Howell. Next up, we have the applicant for their pres ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: sentation, not to exceed 15 minutes. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Counselors, do I need to be sworn in? Lease raise your right hand and state your name and address for the record. Mr. Dalton, do you solemnly declare and affirm that the testimony you have in reference to this item shall be the truth and WAYNE DALTON: d nothing but the truth and do this under the penalties of perjury? The applicant has been sworn in. Thank you, Mayor, Counselors. My name is Wayne Dalton with Dalton Land Insights. Also with me here tonight is Victoria Dalton. Just to clear up, as Joel mentioned, there's a discrepancy between the acreage and the property. This resulted from the surveyor's inclusion of property that is owned by the city, that was previously acquired by Santa Fe County for right-of-way and public improvements within the river corridor. So the appropriate acreage of the requested rezoning is 5.96 acres. Just to give you a, I also want to thank Joel and staff for their review of this application, and keep my comments brief. We are in agreement with staff and Planning Commission's recommendation to rezone the subject property mixed use. We believe mixed use is consistent with surrounding uses and character of the area. Also aligns with applicable general plan policies, including the futur MICHAEL J. GARCIA: re land use map, West Santa Fe River. With that, Mr. Mayor, Counselors, I stand for questions. Okay. We will now move towards sworn public comment. Is there anybody in the audience that would like to provide public comment on this proposal? No ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: ot seeing anybody in chambers. Mr. Assistant City Clerk, can we check if there's anybody online? Mayor STEPHANIE BENONATO: r, Stephanie Beninato would like to make a public comment. She will need to be sworn in again. Ok MICHAEL J. GARCIA: kay. Would you mind swearing her in, Lease? If I was a ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: already sworn in, do I have to be sworn in again? STEPHANIE BENONATO: Yes. Completely separate case, Miss Benina ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: ato. Lease state your name and address for the record. Stephanie Beninato, PO Box 1601 Santa Fe. Do you solemnly declare and affirm that the testimony you have in reference MARY NATALIE: to th STEPHANIE BENONATO: his item shall be the truth and nothing but the truth and do this under the penalties of perjury? Yes. Miss Beninato has been sworn in. Good. Thank you. I think it makes sense to follow the plan to go to mixed use, and I like that better than the C2 designation because at C2, there's really no setbacks, and it's a kind of a free-for-all as to how you use the property, whereas I think mixed use makes more sense there and is not quite as intense use in terms of trafficking. However, what is confusing to me is that somehow the Planning Commission said that it could be for a lesser intensity or lesser intense use than mixed use, and I don't understand what that means at all. And perhaps the applicant o MICHAEL J. GARCIA: or the staff could explain that or if that is ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: s even really on the table for consideration. Th AMANDA CHAVEZ: hank you. Do w MICHAEL J. GARCIA: we have any other public comments online? Mayor, there are no additional public comments. Yeah. Lease. Let's move on to questions of staff, applica ELIZABETH BARRETT: ant, and the public from the governing body. Governing body, you have any questions? Councilor Cassutt. Thank you so much, Mayor. Joel, I think I have questions for you. I just want to clarify something. As you mentioned, mixed use is frequently not used because, I don't fully understand it. But what I've been told is that there's a lot of challenges in the requirements that have created situations where developments can't move forward or, I mean, that they're just too restrictive. In this scenario, you all are thinking that potentially it could work. We do not have a development plan. But you mentioned something about the updated code addressing that issue. And my question becomes, if we approve this now under our current code and our current general plan, and both of those are changing soon, which do we follow? So, for example, this is going to align with the current future land use map. If the next future land use map changes and it is no longer aligned with the next future land use map, are they going to have to go through a general plan amendment? It just, I kind of, I'm feeling a little wishy-washy on which version of JOEL CRUZ-HABER: f things they will be held to when they have to make, you know, choices for development. Mayor Garcia, Councilor Cassutt, thank you for your question. They would have to adhere to the latest version of our zoning ordinance. So whatever latest version of Chapter 14 we have, those would be the dimensional standards, zoning criteria that they would have to meet. In regards to general plan, we're, you know, the general plan, those character frameworks are changing from what we're familiar with. Right. But the intent is that it would be a long time before we see future land use maps and being, coming before this board. But, again, to answer your question, they would have to adhere to the latest version of the Chapter 14 code. It would not be our, you know, they would not adhere t ELIZABETH BARRETT: to the prior version of our code, any prior amendments. Okay. So, so, basically, when they bring forward a development plan, they're going to have to adhere to whatever the code is at that moment in time. Correct. I have heard conversation that we are going to scrap mixed use zoning because of how it does not work. I don't know if that is true and that we're kind of, so I think that's why I'm having a little bit of a moment here because so often we're like, mixed use just, it doesn't work. It's not, it's in very rare scenarios. And so there's been conversations to kind of scrap it or drastically modify it. So I guess at this point, I don't, I don't quite know what we're, what we're approving. And I actually have, you know, we've talked about we need to increase density in a number of parts of the city, but I also don't want to put us in a scenario where we are approving a zoning because it is a less, a less intensive zoning, and it's, you know, less laborious for them because they don't have to go through full general plan amendment, which is difficult. But then we're setting them up for a scenario where development's not going to be very probable because this, you know, we've recognized a lot of issues with this zoning categor JOEL CRUZ-HABER: ry, and we're, we're ready to scrap it or drastically alter it. Mayor Garcia, Councilor Cassutt. I definitely would like to speak to the less intensive zoning and how that works. I don't think staff had ever done anything like that prior to. So, but our code allows us to. So when the applicant submits a zoning request, the Planning Commission, well, the governing body can review and decide to reduce that to a less intensive zoning. And staff recommended that C2 is, right, that's the highest zoning that we have relative to industrial. So let's talk about intensity of that, what will happen there. Mixed use C1, those were two recommendations given to the Planning Commission. However, in discussion at the Planning Commission with the applicant, the uses that they wanted to have were prohibited in C2. So, and required conditional use permits in C1. So having these outright permitted uses and mixed use made it a lot easier or what the applicant wanted to have happen there. Got it. So you're right. Every parcel, every project's going to be a ELIZABETH BARRETT: lot different, but for this one, it made sense. Alright. Well, there's unicorns everywhere, I guess. We just have No. That... Great question. Thank you. That was al MICHAEL J. GARCIA: ll I had. Thank you, mayor. Thank you, councilor. Any other questions from governing body members? Seeing none, we will go ahead and close this public hearing. We will move forward now to any discussion or pot ALMA CASTRO: tential motion and a second. Councilor Castro. Move to approve bill number 2026-17, recognizing the proximity of 5.96 tract of contiguous parcel. Those numbers located at 2045 Boylan Circle, 2743 Boylan Circle, 1372 Boylan Lane from R1, one dwelling to mixed use, the case number 2024-61. Second. AMANDA CHAVEZ: . We've got a motion and a second. Any discussion? Just point of clarification. I think it is case number 2024946 ALMA CASTRO: 61. 202-2024-61. 9469461. PUBLIC COMMENTER: . It's sev JOEL CRUZ-HABER: verance memo AMANDA CHAVEZ: o. That was what he That was my intent. MICHAEL J. GARCIA: Yeah. Okay. We've got a motion and a second. Any discussion on the motion? Don't see councilor Cassutt raising her hand. Just want to double confirm. Okay. With that, mister assistant city clerk, can we get a roll call vote, Lease? Yes, mayor. Co ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: ouncilor Barrett? Yes. Councilo MARY NATALIE: or Bus ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: stamante? Yes. Councilor Caset? Yes. Counci JAMIE CASSUTT: ilor C ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: Castro? Yes. Councilor Chavez? Yes. Counc JAMIE CASSUTT: cilor ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: Falconer? Yes. Councilor Feghali? Yes. The motion to approve bill 2026-17 has passed. Okay. So I believe that ha MICHAEL J. GARCIA: as completed the agenda for a regular governing body meeting, so we will end this session. And then I will go ahead and move forward to call to order an emergency meeting of the governing body meeting. Yes. So with that, call the meeting to order. Mister assistant city clerk, can we get a roll call, Lease? Yes, mayor. Councilor ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: Barrett? I'm here. You never C ALMA CASTRO: Councilor Bustamante? ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: ? Here. Councilor Cassutt? Still here. Council ALMA CASTRO: lor Castro? H ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: Here. Councilor Chavez? Councilor Faulkner? Here. Councilor Feghali? Here. Councilor Garcia? Excused. Mayor Ga MICHAEL J. GARCIA: arcia? Present. You have a quorum, mayor. Okay. So we, next item is approval of the agenda. Move to approve. Second. Alright. We've got a motion and a second. Any discussion? Hearing seeing none, mister assistant city clerk, can we get a roll call vote, Lease? Yes, mayor. Councilor Barrett? Yes. Council ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: lor Bustamante? Yes. Councilor Cassutt? Yes. Councilor Castro? Yes. Councilor Chavez? Councilor Faulkner? Yes. Councilor Feghali? Yes. Council... Oh, a motion has passed. Excuse me. Okay. Th MICHAEL J. GARCIA: hank you so much. Next item. If you wouldn't mind reading that into the record, Lease. Mayor, ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: the next item on the agenda is action items discussion. Item A, extension of the emergency proclamation for severe weather to Thursday, 11/05/2026. Shou PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: uld you approve? Second. We h MICHAEL J. GARCIA: had a motion and a second. Any discussion? Seeing none. Mister assistant city clerk, can we get a roll call vote, Lease? Yes, mayor. Councilor Bustamante? Yes. Co ASSISTANT CITY CLERK: ouncilor Cassutt? Yes. Councilor Castro? Councilor Chavez? Councilor Faulkner? Yes. Councilor Feghali? Yes.