Regular Governing Body Meeting - Second Wednesday Wed, Oct 14, 2026 · Governing Body https://santafeminutes.space/meeting/924-governing-body-oct-14-2026 == Executive Summary == The Governing Body held its Regular Meeting on 10/14/2026, addressing a range of community and administrative issues. Key financial discussions included a review of the city's health benefits performance for Fiscal Year 2026, which showed a positive operating surplus due to strategic plan changes and cost management. The body also approved the 2027 meeting calendar and a significant settlement agreement for a legal case. A major focus of the meeting was the proposed rezone and development plan for 1202 West Alameda Street, which aims to transform a former feed store into a mixed-use property with a restaurant, furniture workshop, and employee housing. This project was ultimately approved unanimously after discussions about building height and permitted uses. Public comments highlighted pressing concerns about the proposed plutonium pit production at Los Alamos National Laboratory and the urgent need for emergency shelter for unhoused individuals, especially with winter approaching. == Key Decisions == - Approved the agenda with one amendment (item 9D pulled for discussion). - Approved the consent agenda as amended. - Approved Option 2 for the 2027 Governing Body Meeting Calendar, scheduling study sessions for the second set of meetings each month. - Approved a settlement agreement and release of funds totaling $1,328,367.74 for the State of Grayson Coon at Alver City of Santa Fe D-101-CV-2024-02345 case. - Approved the rezone and final development plan for 1202 West Alameda Street, changing the official zoning map designation from C2 PUD (feed bin use only) to C2 PUD (residential, retail, food and beverage, office, wood shop, storage, arts and crafts, studio, gallery, school, and restaurant uses), and concurrently approving the final development plan subject to conditions in memo attachment C. == Motions & Votes == - Motion to approve Option 2 for the 2027 Governing Body Meeting Calendar — Passed (Yes: Cassutt, Castro, Faulkner, Garcia, Barrett, Bustamante). - Motion to recess to executive session for attorney-client privileged matters — Passed (Yes: Castro, Faulkner, Garcia, Barrett, Bustamante, Cassutt). - Motion to approve a settlement agreement and release of funds totaling $1,328,367.74 for the State of Grayson Coon at Alver City of Santa Fe D-101-CV-2024-02345 case — Passed (Yes: Faulkner, Garcia, Barrett, Bustamante, Cassutt, Castro; Councilor Chavez recused). - Motion to move to item 21 and then recess until 7:00 PM — Passed 7-0. - Motion to postpone the Bicycle and Pedestrian Advisory Committee appointment (Chandler Moore) to the next City Council meeting — Passed 7-0. - Motion to recess and reconvene at 7:00 PM — Passed 7-0. - Motion to approve Case 20261212047 and Case Number 202612048, adopting Bill 202619, which changes the official zoning map designation for 1.69 acres at 1202 West Alameda Street from C2 PUD (feed bin use only) to C2 PUD (residential, retail, food and beverage, office, wood shop, storage, arts and crafts, studio, gallery, school, and restaurant uses), and concurrently approves the final development plan subject to conditions in memo attachment C — Passed 6-0. == Public Comment == Public comments covered several critical issues. Steven Clark urged the City Attorney to sue Pfizer for vaccine damages, citing actions by other states. Greg Mello highlighted shared responsibility due to the proximity to Los Alamos National Laboratory. Several speakers expressed strong opposition to the proposed plutonium pit production at LANL, citing moral, ethical, and environmental concerns, and urged the Governing Body to pass a resolution against it. There was also significant concern about the lack of emergency shelter for unhoused individuals, with calls for the city to raise the 'Code Blue' temperature threshold, utilize existing pallet homes, and establish a walk-in emergency shelter before winter. One speaker delivered a highly aggressive and offensive rant against the Governing Body and made anti-immigrant remarks. == Topics == - Health Benefits Performance - PUD Rezoning & Development - Property Use & Redevelopment - Building Height Limit - Immigrant Community Support == Full Transcript == MICHAEL J. GARCIA: Alright. I'd like to call tonight's governing body meeting to order. We will start off with the pledge of allegiance from Councilor Bustamante, salute to the New Mexico flag led by Councilor Barrett, and an invocation of remembrance is led by Councilor Garcia. Lease stand as you are e able. Keeping in mind that October 4 was the feast day of Saint Francis of Assisi, also the name of our illustrious city, Avia Real De La Santa Fe De San Francisco De Assis. Keeping in mind all of the trials, tribulations, things that we go through every day, whether we're government, elected officials, those that are working together collaboratively to solve issues in our community. I'd like to recite the prayer of Saint Francis. Lord, make me an instrument of your peace. Where there is hatred, let me bring love. Where there is offense, let me bring pardon. Where there is discord, let me bring union. Where there is error, let me bring truth. Where there is doubt, let me bring faith. Where there is despair, let me bring hope. If there is darkness, let me bring light. If there is sadness, let me bring joy. Oh, Lord, grant that I may not so much seek to be consoled as to console. It'd be understood as to understand, to be loved as to love. For it is in giving that we receive, this is in self-forgetting that we one finds pardon. It's in forgiving that one is forgiven. This is in dying that awakens to us s eternal life. Thank you. Thank you, Councilor. Are there any remembrances from governing body PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: y members? Councilor Faulkner. First, I'd like to send our thoughts out to the 12 people who were taken by ICE yesterday. And I would like to thank Gina House and JP Granio for all we do for the immigrant community and being brave enough to put themselves at risk in order to protect the people who need the most protecting. And then I would also like to remember my uncle, Johnny MICHAEL J. GARCIA: y Mario, who passed away y this morning. Any other remembrances? That being said, let's go ahead and take a time to remember those in our community who need our care and support. Thank you, everybody. Madam C GERALYN CARDENAS: City Clerk, can we get a roll call, Lease? Yes, Mayor. Councilor Barrett? Here. Councilor Bustamante? Here. Councilor Cassutt? Here. Councilor Castro? Presente. Councilor Chavez? Here. Councilor Faulkner? Here. Councilor Garcia? Here. MICHAEL J. GARCIA: Mayor Garcia? Present. Mayor, you have a quorum. Great. Next up is approv GERALYN CARDENAS: val of the agenda. Are there any changes from staff? Yes, Mayor. We're going to pull item 9D for discussion. We need the governin PUBLIC COMMENTER: ng body to approve either option one or option CITY STAFF: two of the calendar, which MICHAEL J. GARCIA: h we can't do on consent. Approve as amended. Okay. So we got a motion and a second. Any discussion? Hearing none, GERALYN CARDENAS: Madam City Clerk, can we get a roll call vote, Lease? Certainly, Mayor. Councilor Barrett? Yes. Councilor Bustamante? Yes. Councilor Cassutt? Yes. Councilor Castro? Yes. Councilor Chavez? Coun MICHAEL J. GARCIA: ncilor Faulkner? Yes. Councilor Garcia? Yes. Motion passed. Thank you. Next item is GERALYN CARDENAS: approval of consent. Any additional items besides item 9D? No, ma'am. No other items have been removed for discussion. Move to ap MICHAEL J. GARCIA: pprove. Second. Okay. We got a motion and a secon GERALYN CARDENAS: nd. Any discussion? There are none. May I get a roll call vote, Lease? Yes. May I Councilor Bustamante? Yes. Councilor Cassutt? Yes. Councilor Castro? Yes. Councilor Chavez? Councilor Faulkner? Yes. Councilor Garcia? Yes. Councilor Barrett? Yes. Motion passed. Next up is presentations. Will you Lease read into the record the presentation that we're about to receive? Yes, ma'am. Item 8A is the fiscal year 2026 health benefits end of year performance presentation. And here to present is Alvin Valdez, Benefits a ALVIN VALDEZ: and Wellness Manager, and Aon's and Aon staff member. Thank you. Good evening, Mister Mayor and Councilors. We're here to give you the fiscal year performance presentation. We have Trey Sa CITY STAFF: arsfiel GERALYN CARDENAS: ld from Aon who will do the presentation on PUBLIC COMMENTER: behalf of the city. Mh CITY STAFF: hm. Mich TREY SARSFIELD: hael, can you Lease come and assist us? I'll just put the wait. Seven. Again, thank you very much for your time today, and apologies for the delay there. My name is Trey Sarsfield. I am with Aon, the benefits consultant to the city for the past several years. My role there is both account executive and lead finance, lead financial actuary. And as such, I have been asked to present the full fiscal year ending 06/30/2026 for the medical and RX plans with Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Mexico. First and foremost, we want to give a little bit of history. We know that going into the end of '24, the beginning of '25, the city had been with Cigna for their health and for their health medical and RX benefits for a number of years and issued a request for proposals to ensure that going forward, they were with the most cost-effective and just generally effective healthcare partner. As a result of that RFP, Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Mexico showed up as the best bidder from a network standpoint, from a cost standpoint, and from a fixed fee standpoint. As such, we then set the budget for the fiscal year '25-'26, with the intent, of course, of coming in exactly at the total costs. So those total costs would be the variable claims and the fixed known costs, both admin fees and stop loss premiums. So to briefly wrap up this history lesson, for fiscal year '25-'26, the overall total budget was set at $24,400,000. What we did for this particular analysis was look at each individual month and took the enrollment in each plan and each tier, and used that budgeted rate by plan and tier to come up with what would the entire total budget for this for the plan year be. That turned into the $24,400,000 that is shown here. We know that there is an employee contribution required by each plan and by each tier. And so the overall split there is that the city's budgeted portion was $18,700,000, and the employee contributions were $5,700,000. This reflects about a 76.6% city and 23.4% employee split. However, in the approval of the budget for '25-'26, one of the items that we discussed were a couple options related to employee contributions. One option was a 3% reduction from the '24-'25 rates. Another was go ahead and keep the '24-'25 employee contribution rates in place for '25-'26, but allow for a single paycheck premium holiday. And that was the that was the motion that was carried. That was the budgeting for employee contributions that was brought forward. As a result of that, one month of, in this, in this fiscal year was only one employee contributions, setting instead of two, which means that the effective budget was reduced by approximately $220,000, or the effective budget came in at $24,200,000. Now we would like to look at how this how this shook out over the course of the year. As we said, the effective budget was $24,200,000. The total expenses by category, the paid claims for Blue Cross Blue Shield, both medical and RX became $21,100,000. The administrative services fee for Blue Cross was $660,000, and the overall stop loss premiums were $2,100,000. What that translates into, on a on an isolated year budget would be total gross costs of $23,900,000 or an 80, sorry, a 98.9% loss ratio. So 98.9% of that $24,200,000 was spent to arrive at that $23,900,000 expense. However, in the first year, we want to point out a few of these exceptions, credits, and reimbursements. So in the first year of Blue Cross Blue Shield, there were also some run out claims that were that were administered by Cigna and that were, you know, that were incurred before the beginning of the plan year. That is a very typical piece. We know that under a self-funded arrangement such as City has, it is the incurred claims over the over the course of the year that reflect your true liability, not the paid claims that come in by themselves. So that first piece isolated incident, if you will, would be $2,000,000 worth of run out claims from the '24-'25 plan year. As part of the award of business, Blue Cross Blue Shield agreed to waive half of their first year administrative services fee credits, their administrative services fee. That reflects a $330,000 credit. They also reflected, much like the one paycheck for the employees, they decided to offer a stop loss premium credit of effectively half of one month or $74,000. And then two items that are actually related to the experience that you had, one would be large claims reimbursements. When I mentioned stop loss, that is insurance that you have such that you only have to pay a certain amount per individual, and the amounts above that for each individual are paid via the stop loss arrangement. Those reimbursements totaled $895,000, and then the pharmacy rebate credits that you received over the course of the fiscal year, totaled up to $1,600,000 of credits. When we add all of those to the effective budget, what we see to the total gross costs, on the on the first half of this slide, the overall net cost there turn into $23,100,000. That is a 95.4% loss ratio or over the course of the year, a $1,100,000 operating surplus. The next to last page here just shows each of these on a monthly basis. I will not I will not read this month by month or column by column, but the pieces that I will mention would be, if you look at the calculated funding column, the furthest left into December there, you see that to be roughly $220,000 to $230,000 below the rest of the of the calculated funding months. That is the impact of that one paycheck premium credit to the employees that came in December. The rest of these, I will I will just state are certainly month by month. These are the these are the variable claims that you saw. These, this reflects the first six months of administrative credits. And then in the last six months of the year, that's when some of the individuals really started bringing in some larger claims cumulatively over the course of the year such that the overall stop loss credits, stop loss reimbursements came into play. So long story short, if we were to look isolated at the Blue Cross Blue Shield loss ratio that we showed on the prior page, this is where we came up with the 98.9%. And if we then factor in the Cigna run out claims and all the credits and stop loss reimbursements that we had over the course of the year, this is how we arrive at that effective $95,400,000 total on the bottom half of the prior page. Finally, and just to summarize it one final time, the overall total budget rates for '25-'26 were set at $24,200,000. Total costs came in at approximately $23,100,000 or a 95 and a half percent loss ratio or, effectively, a $1,100,000 surplus. Thank you very much for listening, and I' MICHAEL J. GARCIA: 'm happy to take any questions at this time. Thank you for the presentation. Any questions from governing body members? Councilor Garcia. Thank you, Mister Mayor. Thank you for the presentation. And so, from what I recall, there was, it was mostly because we're going to we're going to save quite a lot of money with this new program, Blue Cross Blue Shield. Correct? What was the total overall savings from TREY SARSFIELD: m Cigna, which we were utilizing to now Blue Cross Blue Shield? I would have to bring that back as a as a as a takeaway. What I can state is that the projections into the '25-'26 year would have been substantially higher than this $24,200,000 and, of course, also would have been higher than the net $23,100,000. I do not want to I do not want to state a n MICHAEL J. GARCIA: number that I do not have full confidence in, but I understand I appreciate the question, and we'll take it as a as a takeaway. Sure, and that's okay. I just want to make the point that the reason we moved over is because of the cost savings and the benefits. I think that, as of what I know, individuals are receiving adequate or at least equal benefits through the new program. So, again, we budgeted for X amount based upon what the projections were, and we're right within there. So, thank you so much for bringing that tonight. My plea asure. Thank you ver JAMIE CASSUTT: ry much. Any other questions? Councilor Cassutt. Thank you, Mayor. Along those same lines, I think Councilor Garcia is bringing up the need for us to try to save money as much as possible. I think you said the city covers 76.6% of the cost. How does that employee-employer breakdown usually work? Because if I recall correctly, the city, we take on a larger portion of the premium than we frequently would see in o TREY SARSFIELD: other plans. Is that correct? I would state that 76% is certainly a generous employer subsidy. It is not unreasonably so. However, as is the case with many governmental bodies and corporate entities, it is different. The subsidy amount is different if the individual has chosen employee-only coverage. That is typically covered at a higher subsidy percentage, versus if they cover some of their spouses or dependents under the family coverage. The city will pay a higher dollar amount, but a lower percentage. Again, you are very much in line with benchmarks and with pieces there. However, it is certainly something that we considered when we set the initial rates. When we set the, as is a bit outside of the scope of this, but the 2627 rates for the city and for the employees' budgets are entirely unchanged as well. So, whichever plan you look at, whichever membership you look at, and whichever tier you look at, all of those are identical from the 2526 year into 2627. Also, Councilor Garcia, to your point about benefits, there were no plan design changes whatsoever. So, as far as the cost sharing goes, deductibles, coinsurance, co-pays, those were maintained entirely into the 2526 year, and the same is true for the 2627. Wonderful. Thank you. And just another quick question. I know that I have heard mixed reviews JAMIE CASSUTT: s as to whether or not the move to Blue Cross Blue Shield has been beneficial for employees versus not. I personally, in my own use, I love it. But then I have spoken to employees that have had challenges. I did have an issue with one of my prescriptions not being covered, and I had to go through the process of getting that taken care of. For any of these issues where people are feeling like there are things that should have been covered that weren't covered, who do we go to? I mean, Alan, do we, or Alvin, do we go to you? How do we address those? Because when I have heard of some of these cases, it sounds to me like things that should have been just fine. Of course, I'm not in the nitty-gritty of it all, but who do we talk to? Well, what I can say for the record and with confidence is that you do have a very good, very capable account management team with Blu TREY SARSFIELD: ue Cross Blue Shield. I do not want to overstep my boundaries around which of their team members directly address network issues or coverage issues or those types of items. However, I can confidently state that both Mr. Valdez and his team and the Blue Cross Blue Shield team do take these considerations very seriously and are willing to either explain or change their procedures as appropriate in order to make sure that the plans that you have are the plans that are under contract and are the plans that are the intent. Okay. So, that being said, which is wonderful. I'm glad to hear that. And again, my experiences have been wonderful. Should I send them to you initially and then you can assist? Mr. Mayor and Council JAMIE CASSUTT: lor Cassutt, that is correct. It would come to me initially. We do escalate quite often. In reference directly to the pharmacy, there was an 80 or 98.4% match. So there's a 2.6 that we f ALVIN VALDEZ: found some people in the city do use, and we address those. We've spoken to Express Scripts, and we are trying to mitigate those issues that do arise. But it does come through me, and then I escalate accordingly. Okay. Wonderful. Thank you so much. I'll be sure to send them your way. Thank you. Yes, sir. Any other questions? Hearing none, thank you for the presentation. Appreciate the update. All for your time. Next item, Lease, Madam City Clerk. Next item on th JAMIE CASSUTT: he agenda is 9D. This is a request for approval of the 2027 Governing Body Regular Meet MICHAEL J. GARCIA: ting Study Session and Council Standing Committee Meeting Calendar. Here to answer your questions i TREY SARSFIELD: is Assistant City C MICHAEL J. GARCIA: Clerk, Xavier Behel. Yours, sir. Tha GERALYN CARDENAS: ank you, Mayor Garcia, members of the governing body. This calendar follows the same scheduling sequence as we used last year and the years before. The only difference is we've provided you two options for the scheduling of the study sessions. Option one MICHAEL J. GARCIA: e will have t XAVIER VIGIL: the study session scheduled for the first set of meetings each month, and option two has them scheduled for the second set. It will follow the sequence of one month will be after Public Works, the next month after Quality of Life, and then the next month after that, it will be after the Finance Committee. The dates for the study sessions in November and December are the same on both options due to the limited number of meetings scheduled for that time frame. With that, I stand for questions. Thank you. Councilor Cassutt? Thank you so much. I really appreciate it. I personally don't care which set, in terms of which meetings we go to, but my question is actually for staff and which is best for you all. Is the beginning of the month a better time for this extra lift with presentations MICHAEL J. GARCIA: s? Maybe this is more for Merc JAMIE CASSUTT: cy and her team or the City Manager, but I think that, at least for me, it doesn't really matter in terms of my calendar, but I'm curious if it does in terms of the flow of your workload throughout the month. Sorry, making you get some steps today. Mayor, Councilor Cassutt, thank you for that question. I guess I would say that there are positives and negatives about all of the different things. I'm kind of wondering. Yeah, I think it's fine. Okay. Either way, I don't really think of anything right now. And, okay, awesome. Well, thank you. I'm GERALYN CARDENAS: agnostic on which one we go with. Any other comments f CITY STAFF: from the governing b GERALYN CARDENAS: body? What's the what? No. Councilor Castro. I was going to move that we approve the second option with the end of the month. Second. Okay. So we've got a motion and a second to move fo JAMIE CASSUTT: orward with option number two. Any discussion? Hearing none, Madam Ci ALMA CASTRO: ity Clerk, can we get a roll call vote, Lease? Certainly, Mayor. Councilor Cassutt? Yes. Councilor Castro? Yes. Councilor Chavez? Councilor Faulkner? Yes. MICHAEL J. GARCIA: Councilor Garcia? Yes. Councilor Barrett? Yes. Councilor Bustamante? Yes. Motion passed. Okay. With that, next item on the agenda, Lease. I'm sorry. Next item on the agenda is matters from the City Manager. Mayor, nothing for me to GERALYN CARDENAS: onight. Okay. Next item will be matters from the City Attorney. Thank you. Members of the governing body, Mayo MICHAEL J. GARCIA: or, I recommend that the governing body recess to GERALYN CARDENAS: executive session for the matters noticed in the agenda. I move tha MICHAEL J. GARCIA: at in accordance with the Open Meetings Act GERALYN CARDENAS: t, NMS 1978, Section 10-15-1, Subpart H7, meetings MARCOS MARTINEZ: s subject to attorney-client privilege pertaining to the pending litigation in which a city is or may become a participant, including but not limited ALMA CASTRO: to the State of Grace Coon versus the City of Santa Fe, D-101-CV-2004-02345. Sorry. Yeah. We've got a motion and a second. Any discussion? Hearing none, Madam City Clerk, can we get a roll call vote, Lease? Yes, Mayor. Councilor Castro? Yes. Councilor Chavez? Councilor Faulkner? Councilor Garcia? Yes. Councilor Barrett? Yes. Councilor Bustamante? Yes. Councilor Ca MICHAEL J. GARCIA: assutt? Yes. Motion passed. Okay. We will now enter into executive session. Pursuant to the Open Meetings Act, Section 10-15-1J, I move that the governing body reconvene in open s GERALYN CARDENAS: session and state for the record that the matters discussed in closed session were limited to those specified in the motion for clo MICHAEL J. GARCIA: osure. Second. Okay. We've got a motion and ALMA CASTRO: d a second. Any discussion on the motion? Madam City Clerk, can we get a roll call vote, Lease? Yes. Councilor Chavez? Yes. Councilor Faulkner? Yes. Councilor Garcia? Yes. Councilor Barrett? Yes. Councilor Bustamante? Yes. Councilor Caset? Y MICHAEL J. GARCIA: Yes. Councilor Castro? Yes. Motion passed. Okay. Next item is executive session action items. 13A is approval of a settle GERALYN CARDENAS: ement agreement and release of funds in the total amount of $1,328,367.74 resolving a State of Grayson Coon at Alver City of Santa Fe D-101-CV-2024-02345. Mayor, I'll need to re MICHAEL J. GARCIA: ecuse myself from this. Okay. Councilor Chavez GERALYN CARDENAS: is going to recuse herself from this action item. I'm going to wait. We'll second that motion. And then let's wait until. Okay. So we've got a motion and a second on the floor. Any dis AMANDA CHAVEZ: scussion on the motion? Hearing none, Madam MICHAEL J. GARCIA: m City Clerk, can we get a roll call vote, Lease? May I confirm who made the motion? Thank you. Councilor Faulkner? Yes. Councilor Garcia? Yes. Councilor Barrett? Yes. Councilor Bustamante? Yes. Councilor Cassutt? Yes. Councilor Castro? Yes. Motion passed. Okay. Next item on the agenda, Lease, Madam City Cl GERALYN CARDENAS: lerk. Next item on the agenda is matters from the City Clerk. I have nothing to report at this time, Mayor. We'll move on to item 15, which is communications from the go MICHAEL J. GARCIA: overning body. Okay. Thank you. Just going to move from GERALYN CARDENAS: m the left to the right, Councilor Bustamante don't have anything tonight, Mayor. Thank you. Councilor Cassutt. Thank you, Mayor. Don't have much. Just want to wish my brot MICHAEL J. GARCIA: ther a very happy birthday a few days ago. He is celebrating it in Korea, actually, where his wife's family is from, and with my mom and stepdad. JAMIE CASSUTT: So it sounds like they're having a great time. I'm not there, but happy birthday to him nonetheless. Councilor Castro. Thank you, Mayor. Just echoing Councilor Faulkner's sentiments about all the work that went into the past few days. We're tired, but we're doing a great job. So thank you, Santa F ALMA CASTRO: Fe. Also, happy Indigenous Peoples' Day. We had a great event downtown. Councilor Faulkner. Hey. It's that time of year. Toy Drive La Posada. Toy Drive La Posada. Toy Drive La Posada. I'd like to thank the City Manager, who's been amazing, and the Fire Department, who MICHAEL J. GARCIA: also has been amazin PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: ng, and the City Clerk's office, who. Okay. So I'd like to thank all the support from staff, and then I just volunteer. Whatever we can do, these are great events. I think the toy drive serves 10,000 children. Approxima CITY STAFF: ately 6,000 of PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: f them are in Santa Fe. So although it's a Northern New Mexico toy drive, the majority of people that they serve are in the Santa Fe area. So anything we can do to get the word out about the toy drive, especially with the economy, I think the number is going to be more. And then we have the Posada coming. Councilor Garcia and I are pumped up because it's our second event that we do in the year. So I will be begging all of you to participate. Actually, a lot of you do already, including the Mayor, so I appreciate it, but let's make it even better every year. Now, Councilor Garcia. What she said. But yeah, no, thank you to everyone who helped to make that event a success in the last few years and all the work that's put in by the team. Thank you. MICHAEL J. GARCIA: Mr. Chavez. Thank you, Mayor. I just want to thank Jonathan Gordon and the Board of Directors for NAMI for putting on a great behavioral health community forum last week. I was able to s AMANDA CHAVEZ: sit on a panel with Interim Chief Ben Valdez, our Interim Behavioral Health Manager Matthew Martin, and Anne Ryan, the Santa Fe County Community Services Director. We had a great discussion about behavioral health, but I think what made it more powerful was we had community members begging for help, literally begging for their kids who are suffering from behavioral health and have nowhere to turn, who have lost family members to incarceration because there's no behavioral health supports, to losing family members to death because there's no behavioral health supports. I'm begging for people in power to step up and actually see this as a crisis that it is. It was super powerful, and I give so many kudos to NAMI for just emphasizing this conversation and initiating the discussion and trying to find solutions and how we could be better in this service. So, super honored to be part of it, and I look forward to continuing work with them. And I just want to say, we have to do more. We're losing lives, and the individuals in front of us that day were evidence that is the case. So, anyone who wants to partner on anything behavioral health-wise, reach out to me, Lease. Thank you. Councilor Barrett. I just have one thing. I want to wish my daughter, Zoe, a happy tenth birthday. So, happy birthday, Zoe. Yeah. Happy birthday, Zoe. I know next meeting we will have a presen ALMA CASTRO: ntation for folks that are going to be retiring, whether it's soon or in the coming months, but definitely want to give an init MICHAEL J. GARCIA: tial shout-out to our budget officer, Andy Hopkins, whose last day with us will be next week. So, for anybody that's around, stop by, go visit him because I believe the 21st is his last day serving in office. So, Lease stop by. And then, just another shout-out to the great work and leadership of our Interim City Manager. His leadership has shown, and I think for the city to thrive and to deliver high-quality results, you need somebody that could lead a stable environment. And thank you, City Manager. And so with that, I had hoped that you would be with us long-term, but that's not going to be the case. He's going to ride off into the sunset here soon. And so, hopefully, that horse doesn't buck you off, sir. But with that, I wanted to make sure that I share the plan for the City Manager recruitment process. And so, in the coming month, I will be bringing forward a national search that will include emphasis on local as well as national, and we really want to ensure that we bring in the best person possible to fill in the big shoes that Brian is going to be leaving us. And so, with that being said, come the beginning of next year, I will begin the interview process. Part of that process will involve the governing body. I hope to have somebody identified and appointed in the spring. That way, the plan is the person will start after we pass the operating budget for fiscal year 28, and then the Interim City Manager will return to Fire Chief life. So, but that's the initial plan. And as we all know, things can adjust and change, but that's the plan we had been working on. It's a very diligent plan that we thoughtfully thought through, and we want to make sure that as we are addressing the significant issues that our city is working to address, that we do so in a very diligent manner. So, thank you all for being patient as we work to fill this important position. With that, I believe we've completed our evening portion of the agenda. We could potentially go to appointments or introduction. Sorry. Go ahead, Madam City Clerk. Okay. We're at item 16. It's introduction of legislation. 16a is consideration of Bill 2026-20 and adoption of an ordinance. This is sponsored by Councilor Amanda Chavez and Councilor Pilar Faulkner. It's a bill authorizing the execution and delivery of a Water Project Fund Loan/Grant Agr GERALYN CARDENAS: reement by and between the New Mexico Finance Authority and the City of Santa Fe, New Mexico, in the total amount of $2,550,000, including a loan in the amount of $1,020,000, evidencing an obligation of the borrower/grantee to utilize the loan/grant amount solely for the purpose of financing the cost of designing upgrades to the chemical feed equipment incorporated in the water utility system owned and operated by the city for the purpose of improving the water utility system and solely in the manner described in the loan/grant agreement, providing for the pledge and payment of the loan amount and an administrative fee solely from the net revenues of the water utility system of the borrower/grantee, certifying that the loan/grant amount, together with other funds available to the borrower/grantee, is sufficient to complete the project, approving the form of and other details concerning the loan/grant agreement, ratifying actions heretofore taken, repealing all actions inconsistent with this ordinance, and authorizing the taking of other actions in connection with the execution and delivery of the loan/grant agreement. Okay. First up, we've got Councilor Chavez. Here. I think that was plenty of information, so I think it speaks for itself. Thank you. Okay. Councilor Faulkner. I have a 20-PowerPoint that I'd like to present on the... Just kidding. It was good. Thank you. Hey. Than MICHAEL J. GARCIA: nk you. If I could make a motion that we m AMANDA CHAVEZ: move on to item 20 and continue on with the agenda and then do public comment closer to 7:00 PM, if that would be amenable to PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: the... We can't do 20 because it's a public hearing. We would have to suspend our r MICHAEL J. GARCIA: rules. Public hea ALMA CASTRO: arings usually are after 7:00. So... Correct. So, I guess either way, we'd have to suspend our rules to do public comment or to do the public hearing. I don MICHAEL J. GARCIA: n't know what... Or we would move up item 21 and take a break until 7:00 so that we could then have the p ALMA CASTRO: public be present for those items. However the committee feels, but yes, it seems that we would have to take a break or move something up by suspending our rules. What's the will of the body? Move to move item 21 and then go into break until 7:00 PM where we would move forward with public comment and our public hearing. Second. Okay. So, we have a motion and a second to move directly to 21a right now. Any discussion? MICHAEL J. GARCIA: ? There are none. Madam City AMANDA CHAVEZ: Clerk, can we get a roll call vote, Lease? Councilor Garcia? Yes. Councilor Barrett? Yes. Councilor Bustamante? Yes. PUBLIC COMMENTER: Counci MICHAEL J. GARCIA: ilor Cassutt? Yes. Councilor Castro? Yes. Councilor Chavez? Yes. Councilor Faulkner? Yes. Motion passed. Next item. Next item is item 21, ap GERALYN CARDENAS: ppointments. Bicycle and Pedestrian Advisory Committee, Chandler Moore appointment with term ending June 2028. And there is a correction to this. He's been appointed as the BPAC mem MICHAEL J. GARCIA: mber to the GERALYN CARDENAS: e Public Safety Committee. I'm happy to return this to the next agenda if you don't want to take action on it, or if it's okay that I publicly stated that it is for the Public Safety Committee appointment of the BPAC member. However you want to proceed. City Attorney? I have comment. Sure. Why don't we go to comment first? I'm a little hesitant on placing anyone on Public Safety when we have this item on our agenda to add members to our vacancy on Tuesday next week. AMANDA CHAVEZ: So, we have applicants for Public Safety for our vacant chair, for our vacancy coming forward to that committee next Tuesday. Mayor, I just want to understand this correctly. So, you want to hold this and approve them altogether? Well, we're going to hopefully have a recommendation of who to put in that seat after we see it, but I'm pretty sure thi ALMA CASTRO: is individual was not on that list. So, that's a different issue. Yeah. This is a Bicycle and Pedest AMANDA CHAVEZ: trian Committee. The resolution says that one member from the BPAC shall serve on the Public Safety Committee. So, there's already a seat on that committee that must be filled by a GERALYN CARDENAS: BPAC member, and so this individual is filling that requirement. I thought we only had one seat vacant. So, that's where my concern is becau MICHAEL J. GARCIA: use then we have all of these other applicants that just applied for that same seat then. Have to look into that. I'm not sure. Y AMANDA CHAVEZ: Yeah. So, I would say, if possible, we would just hold and maybe... Yeah. Let's make sure we confirm that no other seats are filled by a BPAC member. If they are, then this nomination is null and void. And then, as Councilor Chavez mentioned, they've got the whole other recruitment proce MICHAEL J. GARCIA: ess, and they could move forward with that. But let's just double-confirm that there are no other members from BPAC on that consent. So, can we confirm that now, or do we have to wait to get confirmation? There's a recommendation to postpone. I need to dig into it and look into it. Motion to postpone. Motion to postpone to a date certain, the next City PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: y Council meeting. Second. And so, just discussion. I would make sur GERALYN CARDENAS: re if we can confirm this, that way Councilor Chavez can take this information to the meeting in preparation for Tuesday. Okay. PILAR F.H. FAULKNER: . Okay. So, that addresses this item. W MICHAEL J. GARCIA: We've done it. The vote. Oops. There we go. Keep us in mind. Okay. Councilor Barrett? Yes. Councilor Bustamante? Yes. Councilor Cassutt? Yes. Councilor Castro? Councilor Chavez? Yes. Councilor Faulkner? Yes. Councilor Garcia? Yes. Motion passed. Okay. So GERALYN CARDENAS: o, the next two items left on our agenda are public hearing items. Move to recess. Second. Okay. So, we've got a motion to recess. Do we come back at 7:00? Is that part of the MICHAEL J. GARCIA: motion? Yes. Sorry. Okay. It's a motion to recess, reconvene at 7: AMANDA CHAVEZ: :00 PM. Motion a MICHAEL J. GARCIA: and a second. Any discussion? There are none. Madam City Clerk, can we get a roll call vote, Lease? Yes, Mayor. CITY STAFF: . Coun MICHAEL J. GARCIA: ncilor Bustamante? Yes. Councilor Cassutt? Yes. Councilor Castro? Yes. Councilor Chavez? Councilor Faulkner? Yes. Councilor Garcia? Yes. Councilor Barrett? Yes. Motion p GERALYN CARDENAS: passed. Okay. We stand in recess till 7:00 PM. Moving right along. Okay. It is 7:00, so we will return from recess. We will now move to petitions from MICHAEL J. GARCIA: m the floor. This is the opportunity GERALYN CARDENAS: y for any members of MICHAEL J. GARCIA: f the public to provide comments to the governing body. As always, a two-minute time limit. Once you hear the chime, Lease wrap up your comments. So, anybody in the chamber that would like to provide public comment, now is the time to do so. Alright. Alright. Can I get to one minute? We're going to say one. That's too something. Wait. Okay. Well, I'm Steven Clark, founder of PUBLIC COMMENTER: f United Nations, Santa Fe. I think it's really important that the City Attorney takes seriously this effort to sue Pfizer for damages to people in Santa Fe. The State of Florida, the State of Kansas, the State of Texas, they've all got suits against Pfizer. Our Attorney General is maybe a little too slow on the uptake to jump on this. Therefore, yeah, it's a big deal. Royal is asking... Royal Attorney General is asking $10,000 per person and $15,000 if you're over 65. That's some change compared to what these vaccine injuries are doing. Let's get real. Okay. I mean, Emily giving you all this evidence, and the court case, the filings in Florida. I don't have any other ones. The ones in Florida are very important. One minute. Okay. There's something. I want to recommend some books to you, and then when they're listening and the people that are watching this on television. We'll start with one, Alma Castro, among me that I can't find. I'm going to actually call, "Think Truths of Power." It's about Fidel Castro. I also recommend the book of Isaiah, Stuart Unal's book, "Mitzvah August." And this book on my lexical materialism, "Unbankments My." He was the Egyptian Secretary General of the United Nations, and he proves what a liar Menachem Netanyahu was about accidentally bombing some place in Lebanon. Recommending UN Charter? I recommend "Between Worlds." My... And then... And then I got a lot more than talking about, but within three minutes stuff comes up, not a million. May have a feeling of three minutes for people. I don't know when. Hopefully, really soon. Thank you. Thank you. Next speaker, Lease. My name is Greg Mello. I'm the director of the Los Alam MICHAEL J. GARCIA: mos Study Group. Having lived in Sant PUBLIC COMMENTER: ta Fe for many years, I now live in Albuquerque. Thank you for the opportunity to speak to you tonight and for your attention amidst your other responsibilities, which I know are awaiting. Our proximity here, our shared proximity, and more or less unwitting involvement with the world's most lavishly funded center for weapons of mass destruction brings with it a kind of shared privilege, power, and therefore also responsibility. We can either object to the most extreme part of what Los Alamos National Laboratory is doing in our name on orders from President Trump or not. And be clear, the latest turn of the screw up there is coming directly from President Trump. Many people mistakenly think that LANL is a science laboratory. It derives prestige from that. It really is not that. The LANL budget allocates 1% for science per se. Roughly 90% of LANL's budget is directed towards nuclear weapons and nuclear nonproliferation. It's a technical laboratory directed towards certain specific missions that is roughly the opposite of open-ended science, especially science with a moral conscience as many of Los Alamos' original scientists felt was necessary. The effort to acquire a factory to make plutonium nuclear weapons cores or pits is by far the largest capital project ever attempted in this state. We could pretend that President Trump knows exactly what he is doing, or we could say in an advisory way that you don't approve of that particular program. That's what we hope will happen. We hope you will consider the resolution we've drafted for your consideration. We can answer some, most we hope, of the questions you might have. I know you've got to think not just about the immediate issues and opportunities, but also the expression and continuity of the city's ideals and traditions, which help sustain the city as much as anything else. We think this falls directly in that pocket. Thank you. Next speaker, Lease. Good evening, counselors. My name MICHAEL J. GARCIA: is Ella Katz. I'm a s PUBLIC COMMENTER: student at UNM and vice president of Albuquerque Students for Nuclear Disarmament. I want to thank you for the hard work you do for the people of Santa Fe and for listening to the voices of the young people that spoke on behalf of the study group's resolution in the last public comment. Feeling that your voice is heard is an incredibly important thing, especially for people my age who so often feel we are screaming into a void as we engage in politics and fight for our futures. Witnessing this council listening to us matters hugely. Thank you. Moving forward, we hope that this was just the beginning of real momentum. The nuclear weapons industry in New Mexico is an issue that has much too easily been swept under the rug. The state has so many immediate, often life-altering concerns that impact people every day. It becomes easy to forget about the existential threat that so often underlies this suffering. For this reason, I hope that this resolution is something that we can pass quickly so that you can continue to take care of the people that need you right now. We do not want to clog your meetings, your emails, and your time with our calls to action, but we will, should it prove necessary. We do this because we care and know that weapons production is not sustainable for New Mexicans. We care about the future of our state, our country, and the world. We are lucky enough to have the time or education or hearts, whatever it may be, that give us motivation to fight for the world we want to see. You city councilors are similarly lucky. It is a great privilege to have influence and drive to serve a community in the way that you do. The offices you hold have real power over this city, and I am sure it is sometimes a thankless and tiring job, but this is the privilege and cost to be a person who cares. You get to make decisions for many. Should you decide to oppose nuclear pit production or should you decide to sweep it under the rug as is so common, that is your choice, but people will know. I trust in your care as I trust in my own and hope that this is not a problem passed on to future counselors, but a decision made by you all. Thank you. Th MICHAEL J. GARCIA: hank you. Next speaker, Lease. A PUBLIC COMMENTER: Alright. I come up here again and again and again. I see you guys don't care. I'll come every week just to piss you off because that's all I do when I come is piss you off, and I'm glad to do that. Do you know why? Because no one else in this town will. Because they won't come up and say anything. Because this town will tear them apart. People are afraid to come and talk to you if they talk against you. I'm not. Come after me. Come at me. I'm not afraid of you guys. You're all worthless to me. You've not done a damn thing you've promised. All you do is create division and hate. I want to come to these meetings, and I want to be happy. I want to understand and respect you. I don't. I probably never will, and you'll never respect me, and that's fine. Because you know what? At the end of the day, you may make decisions in this city, but you don't make the decisions for my life. I am here because ICE is awesome. They're doing a beautiful job. Round up another dozen. Round up another 24. Send them home. You want to do that? You want to play pity for them? Well, you know what? The local drug dealer, he gets to go to jail. His kids get to get picked up by CYFD, but no pity for him. He's an American citizen. Well, so help me God. It's an illegal. It's blasphemy. Fuck that. We need to take care of us. Those people don't care about us. They don't. You just want their vote. They are voting illegally in our elections. You know it. They don't deserve to ha ave driver's licenses. Pick and do a better job. Allison Lee, and I am a resident of District 1. And I am a member of the advocacy committee of the Housing for All Collaborative. And I am concerned, as many of us are, that there is no emergency shelter for people who are on the streets these days. And there's a lot of them and a lot more than there ever has been. And we're going into a winter that is supposed to be colder and wetter than what we've had the last few years, and we need a solution for these people that are on the streets. In the rains that we had a few weeks ago, we heard about an unhoused person who was wearing three pairs of pants and still got hypothermia. And luckily, he got... Somehow he got to the emergency room, so he wasn't a statistic of somebody who died. But, you know, that was way before we've got to the code blue temperatures. So, I'm concerned that the request to the state legislature for funding does not include anything about an emergency shelter. And, of course, you all voted down the ROC, which was a shovel-ready... is a shovel-ready project. So I'm looking at you, like, what is your plan for an emergency shelter for homeless people? We need one now. I hear various talk about something in the future, but we need something this winter. And the city, we were able... The city was able to find $2,200,000 for drones for the police department, and they're and they're asking for $7,000,000 for median beautification. What d MICHAEL J. GARCIA: does that say about our priorities when we've left out the unhoused? Are there any other members of the audience that would like to provide public commen GERALYN CARDENAS: nt? Being done, Madam City Clerk, can we check if there's anybody online? Yes PUBLIC COMMENTER: s, Mayor. There are people in the Zoom room. We'll start with Jean Nichols. Thank you very much. I'm, oops. Can you hear me? Yes, we can. Yes. Okay. I'm from Llano, New Mexico, and I know that the resolution against pit production at LANL is not on the agenda tonight, but I would like you to urge you to put it on an upcoming agenda and pass it as the other councils have in the past. Have we moved past peace and sanity in the world? The pits being planned have increased from 30 to 60 a year or more. They are not for national security or to ensure our stockpile is safe and secure. We already have 5,000 for that. These new pits are for a whole new weapon design much larger than what we dropped on Hiroshima. The budget is increasing from $1,300,000,000 this year to $2,500,000,000 next year. Do we see this well spread among our communities? No, we don't. These pits are for global nuclear domination at a time when the leadership of our country is increasingly corrupt and cruel and have proven that they do not care about ordinary citizens. They are heading us straight for an unimaginable future of AI warfare when our Mother Earth that we all depend on is suffering. Meanwhile, Project Velocity would have us go at warp speed and lower safety standards. Santa Fe, the city of holy faith established in the name of Saint Francis, should not be opening its arms to this madness. I'm sure you are all caring individuals who want the best for the city and the state. We need to stop, slow down, take a real assessment of the world and the planet's health, and stand up against war and nuclear weapons. No amount of MICHAEL J. GARCIA: f profit or political pork is worth sacrificing our GERALYN CARDENAS: precious planet. Thank you. PUBLIC COMMENTER: . Thank you. Next speaker, Lease, Madam City Clerk. We'll go to Marsha Emerton. Good evening. Hi. Many of you know that... Oh, District 4, Marsha Emerton. Many of you know that I am an advocate for the unhoused, also a member of the advocacy committee for the Santa Fe Housing for All Collaborative. We really need, and I'm echoing part of what Allison Lee said a little earlier. We need to get people inside for the winter. We have no plan for this. It seems the pallet homes that we have would only actually be 30 people also are not up and running. You may know that Smith's grocery store put up a sign, and it looked like it was available. I called them today, and it's already under contract. Good for them, bad for us. But we need to raise this 15-degree threshold. It is ridiculous for a code blue. Denver's is 40 degrees. Why not take the pallet homes we have that no one seems to know how many there actually are and put them inside a building? Many other places have done this. It's not some far-out thought. Denver has done several of these, Portland, Oregon, many other places, and get them inside. And then maybe in the same building, we could also have a walk-in emergency shelter, which Santa Fe does not have one. We have no place for people to get in out of the cold and the snow. We've outlawed camping. What are these people supposed to do? None of us can figure that out. We're also trying to figure out what the cost of a code blue is per night and do some simple math here. We've heard also that the city has only allowed $30,000 per year for code blues. Once we find out how much maybe it costs per night, we could divide that and figure out how many nights that is, and take the temperature up a much few degrees to get it to something where people could maybe stay on. Miss Emerton, your time has expired. If you can Lease wrap up your comment. Oh, go GERALYN CARDENAS: ood. No, I'm ready to wrap up. I can't see a clock from MICHAEL J. GARCIA: m what I'm looking at, but thank you. But help us do something. Goodbye. There are no other GERALYN CARDENAS: r hands raised in the Zoom room. Okay. That being said, let's go ahead and move on to our next item on the agenda, Lease. Next item on the agenda is 20. It's public hearings. This is for land use cases, appeals, and other items required to have a public hearing. 20a is consideration of Bill 2026-19, adoption of an ordinance. This is a bill rezoning an approximately 1.695 acre lot at 1202 West Alameda Street C2 PUD General Commercial Planned Unit Development with an existing permitted use limited to a feed bin store to C2 PUD General Commercial Planned Unit Development with expanded permitted uses to include residential, retail, food and beverage, office, wood shop, light assembly and manufacturing, storage, and arts and crafts studio, gallery, or school, and concurrent approval of a final development plan for the property pursuant to SFCC Section 14-4.1a3 MICHAEL J. GARCIA: 3. Case number 202612047 and 202612048. And here to present is Planner Senior, CITY STAFF: Claudia Kath. Miss Kath, might yo MICHAEL J. GARCIA: ou have a procedure process sheet that we can work off of? Sorry, Mister Mayor. I understand. It outlines how much time is going to be allocated towards each person that is part of the process, how much time is allocated to staff, how much time is allocated to the applicant for the rezone. It just helps us CITY STAFF: s make sure that we stay i MICHAEL J. GARCIA: in alignment with what we're setting forth at the beginning of the process. So, am I supposed to distribute something? I don't quite understand. Usually, that's provided at the beginning to me. That way, I can outline the process. So, Mister Esquibel, I see in the back, do we possibly have one of those? And if not, if you can just, that way, we can make sure it kind of sets the ground rules. That way, we understand who's going to be doing what at what particular time, and we can say this person has ten minutes, this person has five minutes, and that's kind of, again, our ground rules. So, Mister Esquibel? CLAUDIA KATH: What was your question? Process. Usually, a process chart is given for whether it's a rezoning bill or an appeal. So, Mayor, Council, there's just an ordinance. The ordinance is a PUD, which is an overlay. So we're going to amend that overlay to add uses. That's it. Then it's a development plan after that. So it's pretty straightforward as a case. Claudia will present her case, which will include a combined PU MICHAEL J. GARCIA: UD explanation, development plan explanation. The applicant will then provide their presentation on that, on both again, and then it's open to the public and then deliberation and then the vote. Okay. So then what we'll do is we'll have staff present for no more than ten minutes. We'll have the applicant present for no more than ten minutes. We'll then go towards public comment where as many folks are willing to provide public comment, then we can go to the governing body for any questions of anybody that's provided testimony. After that, we'll have any final comments, whether it's from staff or the applicant. And then what we'll do is we'll close the public hearing portion, and then we will have any final deliberations, potential motion from the governing body. Is that okay? That's correct. And I'll make sure that is always included in every packet from here on out. Okay. No worries. We just, it just helps to set the kind of ground rules in the front end of the proc CLAUDIA KATH: cess. So with that, if we can get a ten minute timer up and then CITY STAFF: staff can present, and then we'll go to the applicant for the rezone. Mike, can you help with the presentation on the screens? Good evening, Mister Mayor and Councilors. Tonight, I am presenting the rezone and development plan for 1202 West Alameda Street. The applicant requests approval of a rezoning and final development plan for the 1.695 acre lot at 1202 West Alameda to establish a new PUD overlay, expanding the allowed uses in the existing PUD overlay. The agent is Jenkins Gavin. The applicant is Boyden Allister, and Buddy Kath. I'm the case planner. So just to orient you, this is the site here. This is the Solana neighborhood, the Solana shopping center, Saint Francis. This is Alameda and Alto Park. The site has the existing feed bin on it and the existing hay barn, and the applicant does not want to change the underlying zoning. It would still stay as C2, but the current PUD only has the use of a feed bin store. So they just, the new owner wants to expand that PUD to include other uses. This is a photo of the feed bin currently, and this is the Hay Barn building. So this actually is the third time this property is coming before the governing body for a rezone. So according to the county assessor's office, the feed bin was constructed in 1958, and it was known as Dually Feed. And then in 1999, it was rezoned from R10 to C2 PUD. And in 2001, the Planning Commission approved a development plan for the site, but then it expired. And also, at that time, rezones had an expiration as well. So in 2006, it came before the governing body a second time, and there is an extension granted for the development plan, and the rezone was approved. And then in February 2007, the applicants applied for the development plan, and that is when the hay barn was constructed. And then in 2023, the feed barn closed. Now in August 2026, the Planning Commission heard this case and recommended the governing body approve the rezone and the development plan. So then there's five criteria for the rezone, and the first is, requires that one or more of the following conditions exist. So there's no mistake to the original zoning, but there has been a change to the surrounding area. The feed bin closed. It was much loved by the community. And now there's a new owner, and there's a different use that's more advantageous to the community. So there will be, if this rezone is approved, then there will be more services available from this site and will provide employment, and it will fit in with the mixed use character surrounding neighborhood. And basically, that's what I said. And this is the current zoning. And then criterion two is, has it followed the requirements of Chapter 14? Yes. There's, the applicant had a pre-op conference and early neighborhood notification meeting in February and went before the Planning Commission in August. And there is a development plan currently for the buildings. Although they are pretty much mostly going to stay the same, but you can see this is the first floor of the feed bin. It's being divided up into more spaces for the applicant, and then the applicant is proposing second floor with three units in it. And you can see here, these are existing shots around the feed bin and then what the applicant is proposing. So you can see the existing front portal, and then they're proposing second story here in the back, and you can see the second story. And then, on the east and the west sides. And same way with the hay barn, the proposed use is a restaurant. So, this side faces Alameda, and this is where the back of house kitchen storage would be, and then the restaurant would be here, and then this would be an added patio at the back. So, where these doors are, they would be converted into possibly, like, glass walls, and that's where the restaurant would be. And then, back here is where the patio would be. And criterion three requires that the rezoning is consistent with applicable policies, and there's no change to the underlying zoning. This is in alignment with the general plan themes and policies that there's economic diversity, mixed use, infill housing, sustainable community. The site has been vacant for the last three years. Now it will be occupied and contributing to the community. And it is in alignment with the future land use map because the underlying zoning is not changing. Criterion four, the amount of land proposed for the rezoning is consistent with city policies. Again, no change to the underlying zoning. It's just expanding the uses of the PUD. And you can see, again, this neighborhood is mixed use with the shopping center, the neighbor, salon and neighborhood, park, school. And five, there's adequate infrastructure to support the site. This has been reviewed by the DRT, and there is sufficient infrastructure. There's water and sewer in Alameda, and that would serve the site. And the last item, if this were, the rezone is consistent with policies in that we're not changing the underlying. It's just the PUD overlay uses. The effect of the area is less than two acres, but again, it's just the uses that we're changing. And lastly, this benefits the community. The building is no longer vacant. There's infill development, redevelopment opportunities. And along with the pro city Chapter 14, there is a development plan that accompanies the rezone that we're asking you to approve tonight that it will not adversely affect public interest, so revitalize this property. The use of the buildings is adaptable and compatible. They're existing structures. They will be rehabilitated and provide infill housing. And at the Planning Commission, there was a condition added that the height of the buildings be limited to two stories. This is a C2 zone district. The applicant could go up to 45 feet, which is four stories. In the applicant's development plan, they indicate for the feed bin, a height of approximately 30 feet and for the hay barn of 25 feet. The applicant probably noticed again for the ENN and Planning Commission and tonight. And the staff's recommendation is that the governing body should approve cases 2026, 12047, and 12048 for the rezone and the development plan. Two motions will be requir MICHAEL J. GARCIA: red in this case. That's it. Thank you. Okay. Thank you. If we can now m GERALYN CARDENAS: move towards the applicant. Madam City Clerk, if you'll Lease state your name. Wilkins. Go ahead. 130 Grant Avenue. You solemnly declare and affirm that the testimony you have in reference to this item shall be the truth and nothing but the truth, and do this un JENNIFER JENKINS: nder the penalties of perjury. I do. Thank you. You want me to promote you? Yes, you could promote me on Zoom. Good evening, Mayor, Councilors. I'm Jennifer Jenkins with Jenkins Gavin here this evening on behalf of Boyd and Allister in request for a new planned unit development and a development plan with the former feed bin location. I'll introduce my client, Jonathan Boyd with Boyd and Allister, who is the new property owner. And we are really excited. This is, you know, I've worked on a lot of cool projects. This is a cool project. It's really fun to do adaptive reuse. We take some property that has been beloved by a neighborhood for decades, and we get the opportunity to breathe new life and create something very dynamic for the neighborhood and the larger community. And so, we are going to be repurposing these existing buildings. The only real changes to the site, because one of the things that is important is the character that it's been such a fixture in the neighborhood. So, the most significant change as a second phase of development is, Mister Boyd wants to add three dwelling units on top of the bin structure, which would be so amazing because views over the river, which is directly south, really creates some really lovely living space, and he wants that for his employee. It's a great opportunity for him to generate some employee housing. So that's really the most significant modification, and we did agree to limit any new development on the property to two stories. So the feed bin is, Mr. Alister, excuse me, Mr. Boyd of Boydhill, has a furniture company, and he builds beautiful, magnificent wood furniture. So he's going to be moving his workshop into the ground floor space of the building, which is so suitable for that type of use. And there'll be storage areas for the furniture as it's built, and then it gets collected and delivered, and some office space and flex space. And then the Hay Barn Building, which is actually a very cool building, is going to be converted into a full-service restaurant. And so, Mr. Boyd is one of the partners in Leo's restaurant. You've had a chance to eat at Leo's. It's been getting a lot of amazing national press, and so he's expanding his restaurant offerings into this site, which is very exciting. And so, we're really thrilled to be here. So the PUD, as Ms. Kath mentioned, we're not changing the C2 zoning. Oh, C2. The C2 zoning remains. But the PUD is the most restrictive planned unit development I've ever seen in my career because it was one use and one use only was permitted on that property, and that's it. So we just want to expand those permissible uses, which would be detailed in the new PUD ordinance. And then, of course, we prepared a development plan that addresses all the various standards relative to terrain management, drainage, parking, and landscaping, all those components as well. So I have a lot of imagery and different elements I can pull up to respond to any questions that you may have, but MICHAEL J. GARCIA: t I'd be happy to stand for questions. Are you done with the presentation, Ms. Jenkins? Okay. Thank you, Ms. Jenkins. Let's move on to the public comment portion of this item. If there are any members of the public that would like to speak to this item, now is the time to do so. I'm not seeing anybody in chamb GERALYN CARDENAS: ber. Is there anybody online, Madam City Clerk? There are no MICHAEL J. GARCIA: o hands in the Zoom room raised at the moment. Okay. With that being said, now is the opportunity for any final comments before we move to governing body questions from staff. Any final comments? No? How about applicant? None? Okay. So now w PUBLIC COMMENTER: we w MICHAEL J. GARCIA: will turn to the g ALMA CASTRO: governing body for any questions. Councilor Castro. I was just going to ask for a little bit of a review of that agreement to not build past two stories. I know there are a lot of constitue JENNIFER JENKINS: ents in the area concerned. If we could get a little update. So this was, thank you, Mayor and Councilor Castro and councilors. So prior to the Planning Commission hearing, I was contacted by a couple of neighbors that expressed some concern about that, and we have no problem limiting it to two stories. So it'll be a note on the development plan that will, and that is our formal entitlement, that nothing can exceed ALMA CASTRO: two stories on the property. So that's how we document that for austerity. Perfect. MICHAEL J. GARCIA: . Thank you very much. No further questions, ma'am. Okay. Councilor Garcia. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. On the property itself, is there a JENNIFER JENKINS: any, is there ability to build other buildings on this property in the future? And is there an intent for that at some point? There's really not an intent for that. For example, what we could probably see, Mayor and councilors, is where we're proposing the rear patio behind the restaurant, probably a little bit of a shade structure back there would be part of the rear patio. But a new standalone building, there's not the space. We need to provide parking. So we are over-parked by a handful of spaces, but there's really not the physical space to, because our property extends into the river. So although the property is 1.6 acres, we have a fair amount of acreage that's b MICHAEL J. GARCIA: basically in. So we're pretty maxed out in terms of new structure. Thank you. And then the, so the one, the barn, I guess, is it going to JENNIFER JENKINS: be the restaurant? The restaurant. The other, is it going to be multi-use as well with retail and housing? Yes. So the Hay Barn, which is to the west, the pitched roof building, that will just be the restaurant. And then the feed bin building will, on the ground floor, will be kind of the furniture operation. And then on the second floor would be the residential units. And we included in the permissible uses, sometimes Mr. Boyd gives classes on woodworking, so we included that sort of, you know, arts and crafts and school kind of, we thought that was a bit important to incorporate that. We also occasionally would have somebody come and actually purchase furniture on the spot, so the retail component needs to be tossed in there, right? So, and so that is, but that primarily over there, you're going to see the furniture operation and associated kind of ancillary MICHAEL J. GARCIA: uses associated with that. Thank you. Question real quick for staff member. So the original PUD was limited to just a feed store. Correct. This new PUD, what's the broad spectrum of what's allowable there for now and future use? Now is there, the purpose now is just explained by the applicant, but what's the potential for anything else that can be there? The spe CITY STAFF: ectrum of the PUD that's being proposed. Thank you, Mayor and councilors. The applicants held pre-app in E&N and went to the Planning Commission and listed these items only, which is residential, retail, food and beverage, office, wood shop, storage, arts and crafts, studio, gallery, or school. So what you would be voting on for tonight, this applicant would only be able to do those items. If they wanted to, say, have a hair salon in there, they would have to come back and go through the E&N process, go to the Planning MICHAEL J. GARCIA: g Commission again, and come here again. Okay. Yeah. And just, thank you. I just kind of wanted to get a baseline of what it was and what we're, what we're votin ng on tonight. So that's all I have. Thank you. Thank you, Councilor. Any other comments or question? I mean, any other questions? If not, we can go to any final closing comments from staff before we close the hearing. None? And then, and from the applicant? I don't. Okay. We will officially now close the public hearing, and now we'll turn to the governing body for any AMANDA CHAVEZ: y commentary or mo MICHAEL J. GARCIA: otions and deliberations o AMANDA CHAVEZ: on a motion. I have a motion. Sure. Councilor Chaffetz. Move to approve Case 20261212047 and Case Number 202612048, adopting Bill 202619, changing the official zoning map designation for plus minus 1.69 acres located at 1202 West Alameda Street from C2 PUD, feed bin use only, to C2 PUD, residential retail, food and beverage, office, wood shop, storage, arts and crafts, studio, gallery, school, and restaurant uses, and concurrent approval of the final development plan for the property subject to the conditions in memo attachment C. Second. Okay. We got a motio MICHAEL J. GARCIA: on and a second. Just to make sure, I know that staff had said there's going to be two separate motions, but is that one motion okay, or do you want two separate motions? The sample motion and the memo. Two separ AMANDA CHAVEZ: rate motions, Lease. Okay. Is T MICHAEL J. GARCIA: Theres JENNIFER JENKINS: sa sample, put that up on the screen? It might help. Yeah. T AMANDA CHAVEZ: The sample motion is just the both combined. Okay. Because one motion will be required in this case. Mr. MICHAEL J. GARCIA: City Attorney, looks like you've got a comment. Yes, MARCOS MARTINEZ: Mr. Mayor, members of the governing body, Councilor Chavez. I think, though, that you can make one motion as has been indicated in the memo. I think the sample motion includes both case numbers, and so I think it is comprehensive and, understanding that the staff will also have to prepare findings of that, inclusions of law as well. Okay. Than MICHAEL J. GARCIA: nk you for the clarification, sir. Any discussion on the motion? There are none. Madam City Clerk, can we get a roll call vote, Lease? Yes, Ma GERALYN CARDENAS: ayor. Councilor Cassutt? Yes. Councilor Castro? Yes. Councilor Chavez? Yes. Councilor Faulkner? Yes. Councilor Garcia? Yes. Councilor Bustamante? Yes. Motion passed. Ok MICHAEL J. GARCIA: kay. Thank you. So,