Planning Commission Meeting Thu, Oct 15, 2026 · Planning Commission https://santafeminutes.space/meeting/1410-planning-commission-oct-15-2026 == Executive Summary == The Planning Commission meeting on 10/15/2026 began with an Oath of Office for all members, a new city-wide policy. The agenda was approved, and minutes from the 09/01/2026 meeting were corrected and approved after some debate regarding accuracy. The primary focus of the meeting was a comprehensive presentation by Andrew Baca, Director of Operations and Maintenance for Santa Fe Transit, detailing current services, significant staffing shortages, ridership trends, and ambitious future plans including a hybrid microtransit system to expand coverage and support the "15-minute city" concept. Funding challenges and the need for improved bus stop infrastructure were also highlighted, with discussions on developer contributions and a potential "transit impact fee." The Commission also received extensive training on procedural guidelines, covering the hierarchy of laws, specific provisions of Chapter 14, and an overview of Robert's Rules of Order. Key clarifications were provided on abstentions and the differences between postponement and tabling. Vice Chair Smith advocated for more frequent, twice-monthly meetings to allow for more in-depth discussions, a request acknowledged by Director Lamboy. Staff was tasked with several follow-up items, including reviewing the 09/01/2026 meeting video for minute corrections, discussing combining consent agenda items, clarifying details for the 10/22/2026 General Plan meeting, and considering the request for more frequent meetings. Additionally, staff will discuss a proposal for an annual meeting schedule and create a "cheat sheet" for variance training. == Key Decisions == - Approved the meeting agenda. - Approved the 09/01/2026 meeting minutes with corrections. - Confirmed the 10/22/2026 meeting for the General Plan update for the entire Commission. == Motions & Votes == - Approval of the 09/01/2026 meeting minutes with corrections — Passed (3 Yes, 1 Abstain/No Vote from Chair) == Public Comment == No public comment period. == Topics == - Transit Services - Planning Commission Meetings - Oath of Office - General Plan Update - Minutes Accuracy - Staffing Challenges - Development Cycles - Consent Agenda Format - Land Use Appeals - Variances Training == Full Transcript == CITY STAFF: Mr. Gutierrez, Mike, are we rolling? We are live. Th hank you. Good evening. I'd like to call Planning Commission 10/15/2026 meeting to order. If we can all stand for Pledge of Allegiance. Hope we can get a roll call, plea ase. Alright. Can you all hear me? Chair C Clow? Exc cused. Vice Chair S PETER SMITH: Smith? CITY STAFF: Here. Secretary Gutierrez? Here. Commissioner McGhee? Here. Commissioner Ryland? Here. Commissioner SASHA MCGHEE: r Rive CITY STAFF: era? Here. Commissioner McRey KELLY MCREYNOLDS: ynolds? Yes. There, you have a CITY STAFF: quorum. Thank you. Moving on to item number four, the oath of office. It's Holly that's used. Yes. So Dan will NATALIE CAULEY: l be helping me with this, but just for the record and for the commission's awareness, as I believe this may have been communicated to you over email, an appellant... We're having all of the land use boards do an Oath of Office appellant of a land use case challenged the fact that the commissioners had not done Oath of Office. And in that case, the district court agreed with us that Oath of Office is not strictly necessary because your obligation to abide by the laws of New Mexico is implied by your role on the commission. But just to forestall this appealable issue in the future and just simplify things, we're having all of the boards do an oath. As I communicated to you over email, there are two options. So when it's the option that you would like to say, you'll Dan will instruct you. You'll stand and raise your right hand and repeat after him. Okay. So for option one, who's going CITY STAFF: g to o take the oath under option one? And if the minutes could refl NATALIE CAULEY: lect which commissioners are standing for which option, that would be great. Thank you. Okay. So for option one, y CITY STAFF: you're going to say, "I," and state your full name. Peter Smith. Do s PETER SMITH: solemnly swear t CITY STAFF: that I will support the Constitution of the United States. Do solemnly swear SASHA MCGHEE: that I will suppo CITY STAFF: ort the Constitution of the United States. And the ordinanc ces of the City of Santa Fe. The ordinances of the City of PETER SMITH: Santa Fe. And that I wil CITY STAFF: ll faithfully and impartially discharge the duties of the City of Santa Planning Commission. I will faithful PETER SMITH: lly discharge the duties of the City of Santa Fe Planning Commiss SASHA MCGHEE: sion which I am about to enter. On which I a CITY STAFF: am about to enter. To the bes PETER SMITH: st of my ability, so help me Go CITY STAFF: od. To the best of my ability, so hel PETER SMITH: lp me God. Thank you. Perfect. And you wanted on the record, c CITY STAFF: commissioners? Did you get them? Yes. Yes. I believe we got all the commission NATALIE CAULEY: ners. Thank you. Okay. Approval of the agenda. Any changes CITY STAFF: from staff? No changes from staff. Any changes from the commission? No changes. Want to take a motion? Move to approve. Second. We have a MATT EMBRY: a motion and a second. We CITY STAFF: can have a roll call, please, on the agenda. So for the chair's awareness, I was going to c NATALIE CAULEY: cover this in my procedural presentation. But just so you know, for the approval of the agenda, you can just ask, "Are there any objections to the proposed agenda?" And if there are not, then you can say it's approved by unanimous consent. Okay. Any objections, commissioners? No. CITY STAFF: Approved by unanimous consent. Nothing on the consent agenda. Skip over that. We'll go to seven, Approval of Minutes. Are there any changes from staff? No changes, sir. Okay. Any changes from the commission? Okay. I would like to bring to the attention, looking over the minutes on the September 1 meeting. I don't have it open here, but it indicated that Ms. Colley introduced us and welcomed us, and it was actually Minutes More that did that. And then it skipped the whole portion of where we spoke, and I don't know if that's important or not. But seeing that these minutes aren't reflecting accurately, it'd be good if we could... I know we're checking our side as far as commissioners, but if we can have the other side checked also. So, they don't reflect accurately who introduced us. And on the second... On my computer, it just shows blank times that we started and some other things. So I don't know if it's going through on your minutes that way, but they are online. Mr. Chair, you can recommend... You can absolutely make a motio on to deny the minutes, and we'll bring them back at the next Planning Commission meeting. What's the pleasure of the commission? See a correction. Okay. Correction. I have a motion. . Second, please. Second. Okay. And the SASHA MCGHEE: motion was made b CITY STAFF: by Commissioner Ryland. May I have a roll call vote, please? Or can we do that by unanimous also, Ms. Colley, to save time? For this... Well, for this one, there should be a roll call vote. We can get a NATALIE CAULEY: roll call vote, please. This is my first time doing this ever, just FYI. Mine too. I don't know what CITY STAFF: I'm supposed to say. Just okay. Just okay. Ryland? For the record, it's pronounced Rieland, but. ... Yes. Sorry. And am I referrin THOMAS RIELAND: ng to you as chair or secretary today? Okay. Chair Gu CITY STAFF: utierrez z? And I don't vote. Correct? Oh, sorry. Do we have enough? Yes. If there is a vote. Yes. Because it's a MATT EMBRY: a majority of the quorum. Commissioner Rivera? Commiss NATALIE CAULEY: sioner McGhee? Yes. And Commissioner Smith? CITY STAFF: Yes. Motion's passed. Thank you. We'll see those at our next meeting. PETER SMITH: Chai CITY STAFF: ir Gutierrez, jus st to get some clarification, I understood that you found errors in the part of the agenda or th NATALIE CAULEY: he minutes where it stated that I introduced you, and I did not introduce you, so that needs to be corrected. Were there other corrections that you were aware of? I think there were a couple, but I don't hav CITY STAFF: ve them right here. But, yes, I do think there were a couple on that side that need to be corrected. And then on the second set, there were blanks in times where time should have showed up in our minutes. Thank you. Okay. Mr. Chair, we will go over the video again and make s sure that we have those corrected. Thank you. Okay. So moving on, no findings, no consent, no old business s, no new business. So now we're on to monkey business, Staff Communications, Ms. Colley. So the first presentation today will be from Andrew Baca about NATALIE CAULEY: the Santa Fe transportation. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Baca. Mr. Chair, as he's setting up, CITY STAFF: I want to make sure that we have a appropriately introduced our new senior planner, Wesley Ngo. Came in from the State Engineer's Office. Now he's working for the Current Planning Division. Well, welcome. Is that a Ngo, like, no, this isn't going to ge et approved? No, this isn't going to make it through, or is it some other sort of Ngo? Okay. Perfect. Well, welcome. Look forward to working with you. Yeah. Alright. Well, Board of Commissioners, Planning Commi ittee, hello, colleagues. Thank you for having me. I wanted to come in today and kind of give a brief overview that Land Use is working very diligently on a new plan, several plans, but I wanted to come in and kind of give an oversight as to how implicit transit is to those plans and how it affects the city and land use and kind of just introduce who we are. So I'm Andrew Baca. I'm Director of Operations and Maintenance. I have a co-director, Gabrielle Chavez, who's in charge of grants and finance and administration. So I'm here today to kind of inform you on a little bit higher level, at a quicker pace, of how transit would impact what Land Use is trying to develop and how we need to collaboratively work together to make sure that we provide the most connectivity at future developments. So just a brief overview. Santa Fe Transit provides four services at this time, soon to be five. We have our large buses on our fixed route schedule. Those, again, are the large buses that you see out on a fixed route. They have a time schedule. We have complimentary ADA paratransit. What that means is FTA requires that we provide individuals with disabilities the same mobility and access as the large buses when they're incapable to reach those large fixed route bus stops. We also provide the Santa Fe Pickup, which is the downtown circular free shuttle, which helps promote the GRT downtown. We have two of those services that run every 15 minutes. Would it be po MATT EMBRY: ossible to elevate the... I'm assuming this is your presentation? Yes. It is on the side. Yeah. Could it... Would it be possible to elevate it? Just text m KELLY MCREYNOLDS: me. Oh. And thi CITY STAFF: is one, it won't be until like four slides in that you really need to see. This is... I'm just kind of giving you... Those are the four services. So on the top left, we'll say fixed route. On the top right, it says... Mr. Baca, would... Vice Chair Smith, if you put yourself on video off, they might make our presentation. Hey. Thank you. And just scream at us if you want to speak. Problem solver. Awesome. Cool. So the Down ntown Santa Fe Pickup, as I stated, is the downtown circular. Runs every 15 minutes, Wednesday through Sunday, every 30 minutes on Monday and Tuesday. That's absolutely free, and it's utilized through the larger tax as well as NCRTD's GRT is how it is funded and part and parcel with our own transit funds. It's absolutely free, and it's utilized to promote the GRT downtown. Then we have our large fixed route on-demand service, which is... During COVID, we had to... We... The city incentivized retirement, and so we had about 10 members who immediately retired. We had 10 other members who transferred to other departments, and we had five that moved out of state. So immediately, we lost about 50 to 60% of our entire CDL driver employment, and so we had to pivot. Right? We didn't have enough to cover the same routes and perform the same actions we did at the 56 employee CDL level. So what we did is we took our least ridership routes and put them on an on-demand service. So that kind of acts as a crow flies. So say they were on a Route 5, which is the Saint Michael's Corridor, and they were at 5th and Saint Michael's, they could then call and request the bus. Instead of us running that service for the hour and 10 minutes that it took to make a round trip, we then would dispatch that bus out to that bus stop, pick them up, and take them to a connection hub or another inactive bus stop. So it kind of acted again as a crow flies. Instead of them waiting or riding a whole bus route, they could instead go from point A to point B a little bit quicker. And it wasn't gross misuse. It was not a gross misuse of services. By the time, those buses would run empty. So what we did is we evaluated with the data that we had on hand to see which ridership had less than 100 passengers a month. Not a day, not a week, a month. So we found that five of those routes, the 5, the 6, the M, the 21, and the 22 had that low ridership. So we placed those in an on-demand so an individual could call and request those at any time. We utilize that platform to test subject what we're going to roll into our microtransit. And I'll get into microtransit a little bit later under this because there's... It gets real in-depth. So currently, we're running with an existing fleet of 63 vehicles in our inventory for operation's sake. And what I mean by operation is I'm not including our fleet service workers who, you know, respond to bus breakdowns, et cetera, but I am including anything that is route-oriented or has to do with passenger relations. So we have 24 large fixed route buses. We have a brand new 20 EV vehicles and a total of 23 paratransit vehicles. Those are the ADA-equipped vehicles that run complimentary to our large fixed routes. We have five cutaways. A cutaway is a fancy way of saying shuttle. And we have 11 administrative or support or meal vehicles, meaning, and they're all hybrid. With the exception of two that we're working on replacement, they should be within the next month and a half. So we are going completely alternative fuel with all of our fleet that we have. Our large buses run on compressed natural gas. Our paratransit vehicles, with the exception of three that are on replacement order, are completely EV, so 20 EV vehicles. Our cutaways are compressed natural gas, and our administrative and MEO vehicles are hybrids. They range from the Ford Fusions to the Ford Mavericks. Down to our staffing capacity, we currently have enrolled 26 CDL drivers for 46 total positions, with 20 vacancies. We currently have non-CDL, meaning not having a CDL, 14 of the 18 vacancies fulfilled. We're missing one administrative assistant, so 50% vacancy in the front administrative staff. We are down one customer service representative, but good news, she should be starting November 6. So that one should be filled at the time that I was making this and it's really been verified. In our shop, we're down 33% in heavy equipment mechanics. One of three is missing. We're down two service workers, so we're at a 50% vacancy. A service worker is an individual who helps with the cleanup, mopping, sweeping, in-depth cleaning, as well as oil changes and tire changes. So we are still currently working at about a 45.5% staff shortage as an institute as a whole. Our service coverage area and how it applies to land use is the goal of transportation, which is to provide that connectivity. It is directly implicit to future developments, current developments, and sustainability. Our ultimate goal is to make sure that we can get people from one end of town to the other and make them perform or connect into the positions where they may be working, or leisure activities. What you're seeing on this map is what's called a UZA, an urbanized zone. That is the jurisdiction that the city of Santa Fe has to operate. We cannot leave or extend outside of that UZA. So when we talk about potentially developing something of a corridor all the way up to Los Alamos Labs or anything of that nature, we would then be crossing into other jurisdictions and lose funding sources for that. So we would have to do it at will, and we also have to worry about infringing on 49 CFR 604, which is charter services. There's a lot of weird 49 Code of Federal Regulations that make the implications that we have to stay within this zone. But with land use and with what we currently have, we're looking to further develop what we can do within that UZA. What you're looking at is the current status and routes that we have developed, and the gray area marking around that is our availability to perform the paratransit complimentary in those zones. Part of the 49 CFR of providing outlets for individuals with disabilities means we can't deviate too far outside of that gray area. We have to stay within a certain zone or area of the large fixed route. A lot of those fixed routes were either archaic or were politicized. So there's a lot of redundancies and overlaps. Working with land use, we helped identify different areas where we could better create efficiency and operational standards. Early for our fiscal year, our ridership in the fixed route is 324,524. We are down about 70,000 from the previous year. ADA paratransit is on par with just over 24,000 and a half. Santa Fe pickup, which didn't exist prior to 2025, it went kind of on an on-demand hiatus for about three years, is back up and running. It's booming. We average somewhere between 2,000 to 3,000 per month. Our on-demand service, which runs as a deviation portion of the large fixed route, is about 10,022. So our total ridership is just above 350,000. Sorry. Why transit matters? Again, we are the persons or institute that provides that access to essential workforce. We provide that access to vital records, sustainability, and social services. We get people connected when they need to go to doctor's appointments, and we do that in a variety of public matters. But why does that matter with planning? Getting with land use and looking at future developments, upgrades, reconstruction, we need to learn how we can make a multimodal system as a whole. Looking at individuals where they're walking to, where they're biking to, how they can utilize multifacet of transportation and still incorporate into public transportation. We've worked with institutes like Homewise when they do future developments. We've worked with several developers. Rabbit Road has something in development. Near Walmart has some, Herrera area has some stuff in development. Swan Park was a huge one, has some things in development. Jesu, who is developing Midtown, along with Cav. Cav has been pivotal. They were able to save over $20,000 by incorporating transit in their design and development just for a temporary bus stop of their current institute. We were able to incorporate into our current route four where we deviated slightly off of it, but did not impact the current time framing. They were able to place a bus stop for active use temporarily right now, which would normally be around $24,000. It cost them a little bit of concrete work, and we provided the bus stop because we had it on hand. It's pivotal that we're on that ground floor of that conversation, and land use has made sure to help incorporate us in that development. Here's me, sir. Sir, PETER SMITH: , can you make the whole screen? Can you put this up to the whole screen? Commissioner Smit CITY STAFF: th, it is the whole screen. It's not on min PETER SMITH: ne. I'm sharing it with blank pictures of you, me, and Natalie. Mike, can yo CITY STAFF: ou make sure that the presentation is on the screen? Presentati ion is currently on the screen. Sure. Vice Chair Smith, Rylan will tell you how to do it. Hey, P THOMAS RIELAND: Peter. So at the top of your screen on the right-hand side, you'll see four little boxes. Click on that and click on speaker view because then you should just be able to see what we're seeing. The speaker view a CITY STAFF: and then maybe pin it. Four little boxe PETER SMITH: es on the upper right-hand side of the screen. Yep. And what CITY STAFF: am I PETER SMITH: clicking on? You wanted t THOMAS RIELAND: the speaker view only because then you should be able to just have the screen. Oh, okay. PETER SMITH: . Well, keep going. I'll play with it. Okay. Sorry. No. No. We definitely w CITY STAFF: want this information to reach everybody. One of the things that we do at Santa Fe Transit that is a little different than just the public accessibility of the daily operations is we provide the community events transportation. We're responsible for the big five. We're responsible for the International Folk Art Market, which spans over five days for their needs, but three days of passenger and public-facing community outreach. We run extra and additional services for Indian Market and Spanish Market. We run the entirety of the transportation need for Zozobra. Last year, or this year, we moved almost 5,000 people in about 45 minutes at the end of the night. Then we run Favalitos Canyon Road Walk or Christmas Eve. In those areas, International Folk Art Market itself was largest this year with over 10,000 individuals. We also provide offshoot services with community partners. It is publicly accessible. We do things like we provide transportation for the Route 66 Community Day. We provide it for the half marathon. We provide when Santa Fe Public Schools can't provide transportation for field trips, we'll coordinate because most of those institutes, we have a bus stop outside of those schools. They walk to the bus stop, and we send out a tripper in order to get them to another bus stop location, kind of how the on-demand service works. We've done about 75 field trips in 2025 and moved over 5,000 individuals in that regard for Santa Fe Public Schools. Let's see. So just kind of an idea of where we're at with fleet renewal. I was interim for almost a year and a half and was awarded this position December 20. Gabrielle herself celebrated her three-year anniversary, September 15th of this year. When we came in, we inherited a very aged fleet, and that fleet itself wasn't staggered. What you want to do in transportation is you want to stagger the enrollment because it runs on two variables: mileage and lifespan aged out. So when we came in, everything was a 2014 and '15, and those are now reaching their end of life use. What we've done, starting with paratransit and now moving towards the fixed route large bus infrastructure, we have been working to re-up and introduce new useful live vehicles. Like I said, we got the five StarCraft. We have the anticipation for seven more on a loan, no grant. We were awarded five large Gillig buses to send our Heimert grant for $3,500,000. On the same loan note with the seven cutaway shuttles, we are working towards an award of five more Gilligs that would go ahead and stagger those 10 buses. We're also working with a vendor to do a rehabilitation on a few of the buses that were underutilized but are aging out to get them refurbished and recertified. So that would help us create a 15-vehicle staggered in the large buses. We actively, in our EV vans, staggered them over a course of her three years when she came in, and that would allow us to go ahead and replenish those vehicles as they go on the staggered nature as transportation should do. So microtransit. When I showed you before the prior with the gray area, what we had before, again, working with land use, especially identifying certain areas and polygons, we compiled tons of data. By tons of data, I mean, we went to the Census Bureau, DataUSA, MVD helped us pull a lot of information. Anywhere we could get anything that was impactful or implicit to our operations, we asked for data. We went everything pre, during, and post-COVID. What we ended up doing was looking where we need service the most and what can we do in that service with what we have. Everybody from Santa Fe knows that these streets were not set up for vehicles for the most part. Not a lot of things run linear. They're old pathways from carriages or horse trails, etcetera. So they're not really equipped in a grid system. What can we do? How can we manage? We want to be the city different. We want to maintain that continuity and appeal and lesser that we have at Santa Fe. How can we write for transit to Santa Fe, not Santa Fe to transit? One of the things we identified is the need for microtransit. Smaller vehicles in certain areas because large buses cannot navigate those roads or turns. We took the entirety of the routes that we had and identified that two corridors or routes that we currently have should maintain their current status, and everything else should be redefined. We found and took the non-conspiratorial versions of a 15-minute city and implemented those to flow into those two large routes that allow people to traverse through the city. One of the things we did was identify where we had a lot of that overlap. So the Route 1 and the Route 24 had a lot of overlap. As I spoke before, the Route 5 and the Route 1, and these might sound kind of esoteric to you right now, but had a lot of overlap where they shared 10 or more stops with routes. We identified those and then redesigned those routes. With that, we took certain areas where we needed to navigate using those smaller vehicles, hence the need for microtransit. Now microtransit for us will not work as most microtransits do. When people think of microtransit, they kind of think of Uber. They think, I'm going to ping the request this ride, and that's going to tell the driver picking me up here. Our microtransit is going to be a hybrid fixed route to that deviation of request. So for instance, if we're looking at the Saint Michael's Corridor, instead of having it an entire route that flowed from downtown, we would instead run the corridor from Frenchie's Park up to the hospital and the micro community at Arroyo Chamizo, loop back down, and head back down that corridor, servicing that area. With that, that overlaps four different routes to provide that connectivity if we adjust the other routes surrounding it. Making those adjustments was pivotal because along Saint Michael's, LifeLink has now moved. We have Consuelo's Place. We have the Social Security office, all the hospitals, the Michael community that I mentioned earlier. That corridor has a large essential workforce. It has an 11,000 population, 5,500 jobs in that area. But more specifically, with the data that we pulled from the census, data at USA, the MVD, all of these little subsets of data that we put together and compiled, we found that in that area, there is 20% individuals with disabilities. There is 10% of households that have no registered car to their house. Not a bad car, not a broken down car, absolutely no car registered to that household. There is Housing Urban Development in that area. And working again with land use, helping to understand the population that needs that connection. Microtransit in these three polygons that you're seeing on that board seems to be the most pivotal for individuals with the term we use that qualify for life services. Life services is anybody that would use public transportation that qualifies for discounted or zero fare. Individuals like veterans, individuals with disabilities, but might not be enrolled in our paratransit services, youth, students, elderly, all of them would be able to utilize that qualification as a life service and request the microtransit where we would run that corridor, but deviate to get them. The example I like to use is Housing Urban Development is located on 5th and Mann Street. If that individual is traversing the corridor from Frenchie's to the hospital and then the hospital back to Frenchie's, as he's driving down that normal fixed route corridor, may receive a notification that six schoolchildren need to be picked up on 5th and Mann Street because it's very family oriented in that area and taken to the school that's located on Osage. He would then be able to continue down Saint Michael's, turn on 5th Street deviating from what would be a normal fixed route, go into that neighborhood, provide them with our software, a flex stop, meaning the stop sign at the end of the road or the trash can near the curb. Rather than having six youth individuals sitting on the high traffic Saint Michael's, be able to pick them up and continue along that fixed route pathing till he gets to the school on Osage and be able to deliver them in a more safer manner and at their request. It wouldn't be necessary all the time, maybe before and after school or before and after a school activity, and they would have the option to be able to hang that. With land use, we helped identify those corridors in the most need. Unsurprising, Saint Michael's area. Definitely, Airport Road has a lot in that area. Most surprisingly for me was Henry Lynch to Lopez Lane. Two reasons in that, there's only about 3,300 people in there, but they are near a 30% ADA individual with an over 50% elderly in that. And, of course, that grid is not set up for a large bus to traverse in that area. So those were the three hot zones that we helped identify utilizing the information we have. With the reconfiguration of the routes with the exception of the Route 2, Surreal's Road Corridor and the Route 4, Suringo to Saint Francis to downtown corridor, every other route would need to be touched and reformatted and configured, especially for future developments that was helped identify with land use. If we did it according to our planning strategy out of transit, we would actually be able to utilize slightly more amount of staff that we have, about four more individuals enrollment, and we would be able to roll this out. And we would actually be able to cover 7.5 additional square miles within over 20,000 more population connectivity. The way you would do that, and then I know this is a little bit harder to see, but we would make accessibility available for individuals on several levels. We've again spoke with LifeLink. We've spoke with other case management workers, Consuelo's Place, MicroCommunity at Aurora Chamisa. We have a number of demographics that use different outlays for how they would request a ride. Of course, we would always maintain our customer service call-in center. We also would have the accessibility of an online portal. Let's say the individual didn't want to use any form of technology, they could always walk out to any one of the bus stops. And because those microtransits would continue to traverse on a hybrid fixed route to microtransit level out of the request, it would not necessitate any form of communication outside of just being at the stop and the driver would pull in for them. To the left there where it says passenger partner portal, that's what it would look like. We have been actively testing that through the pilot portal program with a partnership with Consuelo's Place as well as a Royal Chamisa Michael community. We have successfully transported nearly a thousand individuals amongst the two institutes over the last year. So it has been tried and true, and we're ready to go with it. To the right, you're seeing the operations and dispatch interface. Essentially, when somebody puts in a request, it pops up on that dispatch management software and lets them know this driver in this, or this passenger has requested this ride, assign it to this driver who is traversing that corridor. Microtransit provides flexibility. It gives you the ability to share rides, gets your target demographic. It allows you to enable different variations of trips, and it works great with partnering with health and community partnerships. What we need to do and prove to the public is that we are reliable, successful. We have and communicate the different options that we have. We make sure that we right-fit the vehicle to the area. There may be a point that Saint Michael's Corridor doesn't work with a van or doesn't work with the shuttle, and we may need to implement a large bus. We're ready to do that and roll out that action as needed. We would definitely keep a close eye on that reporting scene. And as future developments with the communication with land use evolve, we would be able to incorporate new stops, new routing, new pathing, and new availability for individuals to request those rides with the deviated portions that we have in microtransit. So one of the biggest things is money. Right? Everything costs money. One of the things that I wanted to bring to the attention of the city, but definitely starting here with Planning Commission, is NCRTD currently governs over the county GRT in Resolution 2019-60. It says that they get 1/16th of the gas tax, and then that percent, or they get 1/16th of 1% of the gas tax GRT, and then they distribute it. Well, recently, they've done a feasibility study for sustainability as NCRTD is the blue buses, and they are currently the ones who hold all of the power of the distribution. And we report to them, and there are 10 entities that share it. Rio Metro, which is the Rail Runner as well as their own separate service in Valencia County area, they receive a large portion of that right off the top, about 50%. Then the additional amounts are distributed through nine different entities such as Los Alamos, the tribes, as well as us. We receive a funding portion of about $1,400,000 through that GRT, but just received notice that there may not be a payout in fiscal year 2028. So there's a potential that we need to challenge that because that is a large portion of operating funds. We, at one point, 2017 was the establishment of this GRT. In 2018, the city backed out of it. And then in 2019, they ratified and reintroduced the resolution that allowed us to jump back into it. Again, all money is important when creating that connectivity, especially on the operating front. We can federally grant out for things like capital outlay projects. We can navigate certain build-outs and structures, but operations doesn't have a lot of funding opportunities. That comes from the city primarily and from things like the larger tax and that GRT. But then with the potential of their need to sustain doesn't mean that they need to take from us. Santa Fe County ranges from about 130 to 140, depending on who you ask, thousand individuals. 92,000 of those lie within my or our transit UZA. So a bulk or majority of that tax comes from the city of Santa Fe. So just bringing that to your attention. So how the Planning Commission role in supporting. Right? Helping us continue the coordination with land use and developing our four networks that we provide, soon to be five. Giving us the availability on the ground floor, which land use has been excellent about walking past, safe stops, stop locations, things that they can identify, parks, schools, etcetera, which they have been very helpful. Letting us know when there's plans for new affordable housings, medical, dental institutes, helping us create that multimodal mobility and creating that first and last mile distinction. And then, of course, long-range planning. So I know that they're coming up on their general plan, and they have been coordinating and working with us incrementally and helping us develop things like build-outs for new shelters, getting insight and information on ADA developments when it comes to those bus stops and shelters. So just keeping and helping coordinate that availability with every division or department within the city. And that's it. Thank you, Mr. Baca. Vice Chair Smith, do you have other questions? Actually, yeah, I do. I have one. The, I guess, well, you can do o without my video. That's not important. My question is, more explici PETER SMITH: itly, I think this is implied, but how do the routes that you are describing relate to the emerging neighborhood priorities that the general plan is describing? So they're looking at off Airport Road. They're looking at Midtown. They're looking at places where we're going to try to really encourage a neighborhood and local effect, four or five or six places in the city. How does what you're describing support that? Thank you for the question, Commissioners. What we have done is, again, on the ground floor working with land use and knowing where those developments are helped CITY STAFF: d us make key those microtransits, which give us the ability to evolve them and further in-depth into those neighborhoods, whether currently standing or future projected. And so it allows us, for instance, around the airport where we can go into the airport. We need some access to that area, but knowing of the evolution that is surrounding that. Now, again, near that area of 599 has some jurisdictional conflicts with NCRTD because they have the more rural area, and we operate within that UZA. But having that definition, one of the things that land use is really working on extremely is those defining lines, what the easement is. Two miles this way, two miles that way, helping them, helping us have that knowledge and their development in that is really pivotal to the success of those routes. And knowing when those new build-outs, those new neighborhoods are being developed, gives us the ability to get on the ground floor of, "Do you need a bus stop here? What is your normal flow or mode of transportation?" And how can we get on the ground floor to help you develop that bus stop at a lower rate? It's a lot easier to implement something from the ground floor than it is to try to shove something in and make it work a little bit later, right? That is the first part, and we're very malleable to that. Transportation, you can plan and plan and plan; it never goes off perfectly. But if you hit those little microsyncrasies, then it's a lot easier to further develop. Now, again, having the insight that land use has provided us, knowing where these developments are, we have anticipatory. So, for instance, we created a 0.5-mile deviated cost as well as the route that would—the trajectory that would be implicit after that development is finished. So we have the pre-stage development, and then we have a post-stage, which is easy to roll out to a driver, which incorporates the turn-by-turn as well as the navigational and the mapping that we can provide to the public. So it's already kind of there, and the conversation and partnership we have with land use helps us maintain that development and evolution as it grows. So it sounds—and then I'll shut up—like there's a lot of collaboration between you and land use so that you're mutually agreeable on the benefits that you bring to reinforcing the kind of community PETER SMITH: development that is emerging in the general plan. Absolutely. And I will state that they're really good at what they do. Dan is amazing and helps and provides insight. They're super communicative. There's never a time where I've had an unanswered e CITY STAFF: email or when I say, "Hey, I'm thinking about this," they come back with an opinion or something that even evolves it higher than the standard or status that I was thinking. Again, we're there to help serve and service that community. They're more telling us how that community operates and where it's going. They're the experts in that part, and then I just tell them how we can get something through there. Terrific. Mr. Chairman, that's it for me. Thank you, Vice Chair Smith. Mr. Rivera. Thank you. I have a few questions. I won't take a whole time. I'll cede some point. Just for clarity purposes, whe PETER SMITH: en you describe some of the funding and the funding CITY STAFF: that may disappear at some point, can you h SASHA MCGHEE: help clarify whether or not the county contributes to the city or not? So the county itself—are you speaking to their NCRTD blue buses? They do. They operate about 12.6% inside of our UZA, but they also receive stip and tip funding out of that in a collaborative effort of how we balance through NM CITY STAFF: MDOT state funding. Federally, they do not receive funding. They defer that entirely within our UZA to us. They receive 5311 funding, which is more for the rural aspect. We're an urbanized small urban area, so it's a kind of a separate funding source. When we're talking about the funding that will disappear, that is very specific to a 2019-60 resolution of that gas tax. Thank you. And they're the proprietor of it. Thank you. The other questions I have regarding the communication, you were describing how there's a site or some other way of communicating and that somebody needs a ride or a pickup, and you displayed that on the screen. It goes to t SASHA MCGHEE: the driver. Does the user get feedback to say someone will be there or it's coming? Does it work kind of like in an Uber fashion, or is somebody just going to hope that a bus shows up? Yeah, no, I totally understand where you're coming from. It does in a sense, not directly. So we have the Passio Go app, as well as we'll be utilizing a secondary app that is in the preliminary stage. But it will give them feedback—the acknowledgment that the ride was received. As soon as the dispatcher places it in a vehicle, it' CITY STAFF: 'll give them an onboard. We have what's called AVLs, automatic vehicle locator. That will give them the projected estimated time off of our Google mapping system that says your vehicle is approximately eight minutes out, and they will be able to visually see that vehicle on the map as it arrives. Right. Thank you. Of course. The other thing—the other question I have is, and you touched on this a little bit, the airport itself. The airport, Airport Road in particular. We'll talk about the Airport Road first. Throughout the community, you get some feedback that there isn't enough transit there. They could desire more transit. Specifically, I get feedback from E SASHA MCGHEE: Earthcare that they wish they had more routes and routes to the library, for example, the Southside library. Has this feedback made it back to you guys? Is it— Absolutely. So, one of the things that we have done, and we haven't really publicized this, but we have already ordered an airport-specific shuttle. So if you've taken the Albuquerque shuttle when you park in their parking lot and then go down to the terminals, in the b CITY STAFF: back, it has a large luggage capacity area. We have that on order through ABC California. We're waiting for that to be delivered fairly soon. It is a specific modification, so it takes a little bit longer to receive that. We do have the direct routing and pathing to go to the airport. Initially, when—so I've been with transit for eight years, and I started on the bottom and worked my way up, getting my CDL and then going through the various ranks. The conversation had started back then to get to the airport, but there was some pushback from the FAA for security purposes. But with the redevelopment of the airport and having the lanes for pickups and drop-offs, there is now a potential, especially since I did it for Uber and Lyft, to have us have a specific load-in, load-out area, which creates safety for the passenger, but also doesn't make vulnerable for those safety and securities on the FAA. So now that they have navigated all that, it now makes it an eligibility for us to go into that area. There was and is currently conversation jurisdictionally. Again, the UZA states that this area is in county, but because the city owns that specific property, traversing through jurisdictionally becomes this kind of weird gray area. But we have been having conversations with NCRTD's planning committee and working on a way to counterbalance that, meaning maybe Santa Fe Transit is responsible for the pickups of flights, and they're responsible for the departures. And then we share in the jurisdiction, but also share in the funding source in the sense of who's paying out or being paid for. And then it keeps everything pretty even keel. So we're looking and working on navigating those waters, but we're already putting the cart before the horse in regards to buying the shuttle. That. And then the last question I have for now, and I'll let others ask, is the bus stops themselves, is that under your jurisdiction to maintain or create? And if so, is there thoughts about some of the existing stops that we have that maybe need shade coverage or overhead coverage that don't h SASHA MCGHEE: have them? No, that's a great question. Another thing we've been working on is with our sustainability committee. We've identified 17 hot zone areas. We've located and identified 1088 non-compliant bus stops. And heavily impacting in our success to this is CITY STAFF: s going to be sustainability and MPO, which we are currently actively working together. Gabrielle Chavez has found a funding source to help upgrade certain portions of it, and Erica with sustainability is currently working towards funding sources and grant proposals for the 17 hot zones. MPO is helping us with the ADA accessibility. It is within our jurisdiction, but you know, there is the bureaucratic process in enrolling in the RFP, et cetera, and finding the right individual who can help us construct. ADA regulations is one of the hardest things in transit to navigate, especially when it comes to bus stops. So definitely having the right contractor to provide that service is key. So, but we are definitely in the process. And MPO, sustainability, and myself have an ongoing email thread and have identified and located, like I said, 17 hot zones, 1088, five that just need some certain conditioning, and four that we think are very pivotal to you. I'm glad to hear that. Absolutely. That's all the questions I have for right now. Thank you. Thank you. Commissioners? Thank you so much for the presentation. It was really informative. You mentioned—so you mentioned the different SASHA MCGHEE: t types of stops that you have, including the set routes and then those that are on demand. I'm curious, so I know yo MATT EMBRY: ou did analysis and determined which ones you should make what. Are you continuing to analyze calls to assess whether you should change those, change those designations? Yes. I mean, all the data is implicit to the new designs that we have, whether it's calls and requests on the on-demand service. It is definitely a facet or function that we incorporated in the redesign of these routes. But then agai CITY STAFF: in, other things like population, density, ADA, and accessibility, use seniors, the central workforce, the surrounding institutes in those areas, and the connectability. When we did our initial survey and study, we found that people will drive 26.4 minutes to find and/or get to work with parking or work, and we found that they'll drive 19.7 minutes for leisure activity. So our routes are designed based on those areas, like I said, non-conspiratorial versions of 15-minute cities. But also, they are designed because most people travel within 3.4 miles of their house for school, religion, restaurants, and stores. The most pivotal accessibility is the hospitals, Presbyterian and Saint Vincent's being two of the largest. They are kind of outlier from residential. So we know that the connectivity of those is strong, and making sure that we have that overlap was big when we were doing it. And then, of course, evaluations. We do know that we get quite a few from IAIA, and as well as Santa Fe Community College. This is where I stress that GRT as well because Santa Fe Community College, IAIA, Rancho Viejo, 599 rail station, all fall within the county UCA jurisdiction. Through that resolution, we have the right to traverse jurisdictionally onto theirs and be compensated with that GRT. If we lose that GRT, we no longer have that jurisdictional authority nor the capability to go into those areas, and now we'll be underserving individuals who utilize those areas. That's why I brought that up kind of as well. But yes, we have evaluated the calls that we have for the on-demand process. We have an ongoing—we also evaluate the Santa Fe pickup shuttle as well and the stops in there. When we brought back the Santa Fe pickup, it is a different route than previously existed. We incorporated Canyon Road into that because we were getting some requests up near, like, Chris Array and up towards Saint John's College, but not a sufficient amount. We did find that everybody wanted to go to Canyon Road. And because this promotes the GRT, it kind of makes sense in the greater historic Downtown Santa Fe area. So, yes, ridership is definitely the primary evaluation of anything that we do with route design. Then this may just be for my clarification and understanding. So you talked a bit about a lot of our funding is based on routes within the city. But if we wanted to create a route from Santa Fe up to, say, Los Alamos, for instance, we would lo MATT EMBRY: ose that funding. I just want to understand current state. Isn't there a shuttle that goes up to Los Alamos? And if yes, who owns that? I believe that's New Mexico DOT contracted to All Aboard America, which is their park and ride services that provides that shuttle. They have a larger range and cross-jurisdictional. Again, we are represented as the city for the city of CITY STAFF: f Santa Fe Transportation and can only operate within the greater city UCA. Okay. So you would never collaborate with them because they already— Well, we... They are definitely partners, and CRTD, Realmetro, The Rail Runner, and All Aboard America are definitely partners. We try our best to collaborate whe MATT EMBRY: en it comes to new routes, scheduling, times, etcetera. So because we know CITY STAFF: that individuals from Santa Fe may want to travel up to Los Alamos, so we try our best to create the connectivity. Part of that 2019 GRT resolution is connection with Realmetro Rail Runner. So we must make sure that our route two or route four time stops are within a certain threshold of meeting those trains. So with all our partner agencies, we definitely tell them and collaborate with them prior to just throwing out new routes or new time frames to make sure we promote that connectivity. Awesome. Thank you. Anything else? Mr. Rivera? So much. Just... I have a couple more. At the earlier stages of the presentation, you mentioned about compressed natural gas vehicles that we have as well as the EV. Can you remind us about that MATT EMBRY: mix and maybe the p SASHA MCGHEE: preference cost b CITY STAFF: benefit? I know ma KELLY MCREYNOLDS: any cities have tried to SASHA MCGHEE: o go all EV, and I know Mexico is still stuck on the compressed natural gas, but I'm hearing that there's benefits to it. Maybe you can just update us for that, please. Yeah. So one is longevity. Right? Our compressed natural gas vehicles are cleaner, last longer. The engines are Cummings engines. So with compressed natural gas, one, the fuel source makes it easier for maintenance and shop renewal. It makes it easier for testing, calibrating. W CITY STAFF: We currently have a partnership with Clean Energy that provides us our terminals for fueling and fuel source, which also provides a public accessible version of that. With the longevity of a compressed natural gas, I can run my bus for two days nonstop on any route versus an EV or a diesel vehicle. A diesel vehicle would give us longevity of about three quarters of a day for that route, and EVs, at best maximum threshold, might, if properly conditioned over time, give me 100 miles. One of my heaviest routes runs about 143 miles. One of my lower routes runs about 89. An EV bus would not make that threshold even at the highest performance and conditioning. So that's the benefit to CNG compressed natural gas. It does cost more than EVs, so to charge an EV. But I would assume, because I haven't done the comparative, but I would be charging three times as much than fueling with compressed natural gas. So it might be similar. Thank you. Just curiosity, and I don't know that I'm going to ask this the right way, but the compressed natural gas, is that sourced from New Mexico? It is. Yes. And it's sourced through a variety, but primarily New Mexico. And we actually r SASHA MCGHEE: receive credits in regards to it because we're pulling from the... those emissions, you know, caps, etcetera. And so, because we're doing that rig CITY STAFF: ght now with the routes that we're running and the evolution of our fleet, we're at a point zero two negative offset. So we are actually pulling from the atmosphere and making it a little better in the emissions output. So when we gave our information to sustainability, they came to find that we're doing pretty good. Yep. Yep. One last question. Do you get a lot of calls directly or on-demand requests to go to the hospital? And if so, has there been any collaboration with the fire department about maybe taking advantage of that versus hospi SASHA MCGHEE: ital versus ambulance calls? Yeah. So one of the first things we did for COVID is they were being inundated with COVID calls to get to the hospital. We retrofitted a shuttle that had the right separations and air intake. So we put a separate filtration syste CITY STAFF: em in the cab versus the driver, and we helped alleviate a lot of that EMS. With that, we developed a great partnership with the fire department and EMS institutes and the hospital themselves. We do get a lot of calls for release from the hospital, but not necessarily to the hospital. And the hospital knows that they can contact us at any time, primarily St. Vincent's because it is on those on-demand routes. Presbyterian does have an active route 26 that runs at a scheduled timing, so we don't get a lot of calls for that area unless it's prior to 7:30 AM. So between 7:00 and 7:30 AM, we've maybe had a couple, but not enough to say that we've been inundated. But we do have an open partnership. I have been contacted personally on several occasions from EMS or fire department that say, "Hey, we have this individual. Can you please..." And we are constantly called for the on-demand request from St. Vincent's Hospital. Thank you very much. Absolutely. That's the extent of my questions. Thank you. Yeah. Thank you. Miss Lamboy. Yaris, I'd just like to point out a couple of things. As we're reviewing development propos SASHA MCGHEE: sals, one of the things that we can do, the question regarding bus stops, we c CITY STAFF: can ask KELLY MCREYNOLDS: k the developers to actually set up the infrastructure for the bus stop and possibly make a financial contribution for when the bus stop is ready to be constructed. And we need to start making financially in a different manner. For instance, we are going to be taking over our capital improvements program from public works, and part of that is planning for public investments. And so making sure to prioritize and get feedback from our transit team will help us as we proceed forward. Maybe not this year yet, but we need to make sure we address that in future years. And something like an impact fee, a transit impact fee, I don't think we have right now, but we do have impact fees for police, fire, parks, and the like. So there's a lot of avenues that we have the opportunity to collaborate on so that we can provide transit. Because this major part of the general plan update is people want better transportation and mobility. And Mr. Baca and his team are trying to do the best they can, but the staffing challenges as well as equipment and just maintenance, to serve the public in the best manner possible, it just takes a lot. So I'm looking forward to working with Mr. Baca more on that. Thank you. I had a question kind of to that. I know that in past packets, there was solid waste that had their input on dumpster placement, trash routes. There was just various different departments. I don't think I CITY STAFF: I ever saw transit. Is that something that's included now or not in the development review? And if I can speak to it just a little bit, yes. I mean, in regards to the input, it might not be labeled on the form and represented as "this is transit." The... and to land uses, to speak on that behalf is we've recently undergone a whole changing of the guard and, you know, and I don't mean on the larger level leadership, mayor, administration, but internally of transit, it was previous neglect and lackadaisical behavior and no push to reach out to them just the same and make us part of that conversation. It was easier to kind of want to be neglected. And now the new team with Gabrielle and myself have presented ourselves forward and been received openly and warmly and been taken in. It might not be labeled and say, "Andrew Baca, director of transit" or "transit implicit in itself," but they are definitely opening those lines of communication and having that feedback and format where we know we can go to land use now. And I think I was asking on that line, but just a little deeper because, let's take the Pulte off 599, you know, that's being built right now. I don't know if you're running buses over there. I don't know about Alcon, Ohio, or anything g. But when I was on the commission previous to that, there was no transit included in saying, "Well, this is going to be a brand new road, and maybe we need to take right away for the bus to stop here for five minutes while we're waiting to get back on route," or something to that effect, or getting back to the commissioner or if the packet's going on to the council saying that, they've spoken with you and this is your plans and this is in our package so we can actually see it. And so I was, to land use. Is that something that's included today, or is it not included the way a solid waste dumpster would be signed off or something to that effect? Sure. Gutierrez, thank you for the question. I think we probably need to make sure that they're involved in our development review team. I'm not sure with staff transition on our part as well as others. You know KELLY MCREYNOLDS: w, maybe we just make sure that we collaborate more. Mr. Baca, what we do is we get memos that we include in the packet from the different agencies like the MPO as well as, you know, different public works divisions and so on, and they let us know. Like, we recommend, well, in your case, I recommend a bus stop here, or there should be some sort of contribution from the developer. We have another housing development that'll be coming from Lascellas in the near future or the Planning Commission review. So we'll make sure to reach out to you so that all the things that are in the hopper, you can take a look at, and we'll establish that relationship with. Mr. Chair, I'd also like to add is the transit is on our DRT list, and they are invited to our DRT meetings when we have them. And the staff, the senior planners identify which DRT members are to receive which pack CITY STAFF: ket. Like, you wouldn't want to send a sign variance to water and sewer because they don't have anything to look at. So our team will identify which projects need to go to which DRT members for their review and analysis. So they are on that DRT list. With regard to when it's actually required, Chapter 14 does have a specific section in the big box only, where bus stops are required to be addressed as part of that big box requirement. But outside of that, it's incumbent upon our senior planners when they get a case to analyze who needs to see it. And if they see that transit needs to be a part of that review, they'll send them a packet. Okay. Just something to... with the general plan going forward. But you say big box only. Explain to us what you mean by big box only. Within the architectural review section of Chapter 14, there's a separate section directly underne eath that which addresses much larger buildings that are 30,000 square feet and above that are retail. And it incorporates that devel lopment with transit for those bus stops to integrate those bus stops for them. So, like, a good example of a big box would be the Ville in the mall or the Santa Fe Place Mall, the De Vargas Mall, where you're going to want to establish, you know, some sort of stop at that location, maybe even a bus stop so people can get on and off. I know that the Santa Fe Place Mall used to be a destination spot. I don't know if it still is. It's still current, man. Well, if it's a subdivision of 100, 200 homes, that won't trigger transit coming to the table and talking with you guys. Again, that's... that would be a decision of the senior planner to identify that this needs to go to transit. And we always send it to our MPO division, wh hich is working with the tran nsit, so that's how we get that coordinated. Alright. Well, just on the bigger ones, it'd be nice to see input from transit on these bigger subdivisions that are going to be out there. I'm almost done. I have some, just, I'm nosy. Mr. Baca, I have a few questions. You u said you go out to the 599 Rail Runner stop? Correct. Okay. And then, you said you're getting a shuttle that will have a luggage area on the back of it to pick up from the airport. Where do you think you'll be dropping people off? I mean, you're going to take them to Southside Hub and leave them there? So right now, we're in development of our Southside Transportation Hub, which is located on Camino Entrava in that roundabout. We're entering into phase one for that development. Hoping to, we're waiting on the funding source f for the carryover bars with the city, and everybody kind of did it at once. So hoping at the end of October, it's about 180 days from there. That would be a primary area. It's not feasible to take them all the way downtown when we can provide the transfer where they can get on, and our large buses do have a luggage capacity area on them where they could jump on that, which is about a 26-minute ride to getting downtown from that connection location. But that location, once fully developed, which is currently Santa Fe Play small, shares that pathing with both NCRTD, All Aboard America, Park And Ride. So we create the connection if they are not just staying within Santa Fe but traveling elsewhere further, you know, Chimayo, Los Alamos, etcetera. But then do create the direct route connection with our route two, route four, route one services that would all be at that connection hub. Now we could drop them at somewhere like the South Side Library utilizing that same shuttle because it would be the deviated portion of that micro transit, but we would then connect them to a larger bus area, much like bigger cities such as Las Vegas. I went there recently and got out of the airport, went to the major hub, caught the other one that went downtown. I was staying at the Shuttlesbury. And your big buses, what's the rider capacity on those? Yeah, so there is 30 available seats. You lose two with the ADA accessibility mobility device, but it has the federal availability of 46 sitting and standing. And what's the average capacity on those buses? It varies depending on what route you're talking about. If we're talking about the Sur Rios Road corridor, that average is about 18 to 23,000 a month. And per vehicle, per r route, it runs for the first two hours every 30 minutes, and then 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM runs every 20 minutes. We found was a sweet spot. We tried 10 minutes, we tried 15 minutes. Of course, 30 minutes is always feasible. But we found that 20 minutes wasn't a gross misuse of resources. We weren't running into the back of another bus, having passengers transfer over, deadheading the bus ahead, etcetera. So every 20 minutes with an average capacity of 23. Perfect. I want to say I noticed lights around some of your bus stops. I don't know if they're LEDs. I don't know if they're solar panels. I don't know what. But I think that makes wayfinding a lot easier and appreciate the work you guys do. My aunt is deaf, and she was riding the bus till she was displaced from Santa Fe, and she knew every bus route. And so you guys have been doing good work, and we appreciate everything you do for us. Vice Chair Smith, any more questions for Mr. Baca? Anyone else? Go ahead, Mr. Reenie. Not for me. Not for me. Great job. Thank you. You mentioned in your presentation the 2028 of potential budget shortfall. With the current ridership fee that you have, what is that percentage going towards the o PETER SMITH: operation for you guys? So, or I can't speak specific to the operation portion of THOMAS RIELAND: it. Like, I don't have the finite number. I'm operations and maintenance. Gabriel is a genius and takes care of finance administration. I do help here and there and have CITY STAFF: knowledge and help me, you know, budgetarily. Yeah. Overall, we're about 14,000,000 a year. It's 1,400,000, 10%, right, essentially, but operations portions, I believe, would be out of, you know, payroll, etcetera. I believe we budget at 5,300,000 or 5,600,000 overall for that operations portion. Current ridership throughout the city, you have an idea of how much that's actually covering of your budget? The, so our fares? Yes. If you're including all four, well, the Santa Fe Circular, the pickup is free. But if you're including the THOMAS RIELAND: e three that are revenue driven with revenue hours, we're about 200,000 in fares. We maintain a low barrier fare sy CITY STAFF: ystem for two reasons. One, we want to provide the most connectivity to everyone. We charge a dollar one way, $2 all day for full fare, half price for elderly and ADA, free for veterans, students of any age with an active valid ID, and youth are absolutely free 18 and under. We want to maintain that low barrier, but we don't want to be fare free because that little box in the front allows individuals to not take the service for granted. So, and it helps us not need to offset that free fare with security. We have response to our supervisor in few and far between. We just landed a new Flowbird through Arrive, which is your downtown parking pass structure to do our fare box system, which is significantly cheaper, does allow for credit card use, accessibility purchases online, as well as kiosks that will have strategically placed throughout the city, primarily at the hubs. So we want to maintain that, but we haven't raised our fares intentionally to maintain low barrier. We want to allow to provide that connectivity. We also have a 10 code for individuals when they are at a bus stop and need to utilize a service, but may be indigent or forgot their wallet. And we utilize that 10 code to prove to the FTA that we're not just, there's no embezzlement or anything. So it keeps that marker of that fare system. If we have 550,000 passengers for the year, why are we only making 200,000 wallets? Because we provided this free fare. We provided this community outreach service like Zozobra, you know, all of these markers that are implicit to the reporting mechanism that we do for our NTD report now in October for the federal government. And so, again, we don't want to raise fares. The national average for a one-way trip is $4 to $7. We're a dollar, half price for everybody else. Our job is to provide that connectivity. It's just keeping those little idiosyncrasies in place for people not to take things for granted. And, yeah, so it's not huge, our fares, and that's all three revenue services. Yep. Mr. Chair, I have one more question. Just a yes, no. Does Zozobra pay you anything for those five events that I described, International Folk Art Market, Indian Market, Spanish Market, Zozobra, and F PETER SMITH: Favolitos are all under that $20.19 dash 60 GRT compensation. So Zozobra would potenti CITY STAFF: ially lose that availability to utilize our service, International Folk Art, Spanish Market, Indian Market, all those drivers of our GRT. Why? Because we're 92,000 individuals of that 130 to 140 providing that GRT, and those events are so huge, they help promote that GRT. So it's not a lot to ask to maintain that money. Yep. Good luck on that. I took a bus for the World Cup, and it was well executed, and it was a pleasure. And I know you guys are doing the same. I had somebody lodging by me that actually y went somewhere for Zozobra and got on the bus, and they were very happy with your service. So thank you for the presentation, Mr. Baca. Yeah. Thank you all for being here. Thank you for having me. I appreciate it. Thank you, guys. Yeah. Okay. Moving on, it will be training procedures governing Planning Commission, including Robert's Rules Order, Ms. Scully. Good evening, Commissioners. Can you all see the presentation alright, including online, Vice Chair Smith? Yeah. Great. Well, for the record, my name is Assistant City Attorney Natalie Cauley. Toni NATALIE CAULEY: ight, I'm here to present to you about the procedural guidelines that cover your work, to follow up on m PETER SMITH: my pres KELLY MCREYNOLDS: sentatio NATALIE CAULEY: on from last time about the ethical and statutory guidelines. So today, I'll be discussing parts of Chapter 14, one specific section that provides some procedures and framework for land use boards. Then I'll be going into the governing body rules for city committees, of which Planning Commission is one, and then Robert's Rules Order. Before the hearing or the meeting tonight, I provided some handouts to each of you, and Vice Chair Smith, I also emailed them. These can serve as reference guides as you apply this information going forward, especially for Robert's Rules. These versions are for you to keep. We're hoping that at one of the next Planning Commission hearings that we'll put together a binder for each of you with these guides and potentially some more information. And those binders will live here at City Hall, and we'll just put them at your seat each evening or each evening meeting before you arrive. But the ones that I provided for you are for you to keep. Before we jump in, I wanted to quickly discuss the weight of different authorities. So as you all know, there are many different areas of law that cover the work that the Commission does. When those areas of law conflict, this pyramid shows you which law wins out. So the highest law is, of course, constitutional law. The biggest way that affects the Planning Commission work is that the federal and state constitutions require due process. Then we have state statutes like the Open Meetings Act and the Inspection of Public Records Act that we discussed last time. Next are city ordinances, so that's Chapter 14. And then we have the governing body rules, which we'll discuss today, and lastly, Robert's Rules if two of these areas of law directly conflict on an issue, the area of law that's higher on the pyramid would carry the day. So Chapter 14 provides a bit of detail about the Commission and its structure. Section 2-2, subpart C has provisions for all land use boards. So it requires officers to serve for one-year terms and delineates their different roles. It also requires meetings to be held at least once a month unless there are no agenda items and says that a majority of members constitutes a quorum and actions require a majority vote of the quorum. This is just, it might sound obvious, but it is a bit distinct that actions require majority vote of the quorum because many bodies or commissions or Robert's Rules, for example, actions require a majority vote of the members voting, which actually can matter when you have abstentions. So as we'll touch on later, it does matter that our code provides that it's a majority vote of the quorum, which means a majority vote of all members who are present even if they're not voting. So this section of Chapter 14 also gets into communication with members. So interested parties cannot communicate with members outside a public meeting or hearing about the merits of a quasi-judicial item. If this does occur, Commissioners must disclose any communications on the record and recuse if you're unable to be fair and impartial. Relatedly, you cannot inspect any subject property outside of a publicly noticed site visit. So you're not supposed to go by a property that might be considered for Planning Commission case and look around and have your own, or, yep, look around the property, unless there is a publicly noticed site visit that the property owner knows is happening in advance. This part of chapter 14 also touches on attendance. So failure to attend three consecutive regular meetings or 33% or more of regular meetings in a year is an automatic tender of resignation, which the mayor may accept or reject. Subpart D of this section of chapter 14 has specific details about Planning Commission. So it outlines the authority, powers, and duties of the commission. It also defines how members are selected. As you know, they're appointed by the mayor with the advice and consent of a majority vote of the governing body, and provides for two-year terms. It also allows the creation of ad hoc subcommittees, and either the mayor or the chair of the committee, of the commission, can appoint those committees. Next, we have the governing body rules for city committees. If you have the presentation, the title in the slide links to those rules because they can be a little difficult to find. These rules repeat many of the areas I already covered from chapter 14, so I won't get into all of it. I do want to note that these are different than the procedural rules for the governing body. That is a separate document with different and actually much more detailed rules. Later, I'll discuss some of the ways that their rules are different. But a few things to note is that these rules provide that for voting, each member has one vote. The chair votes only to break a tie or if their vote is necessary to achieve a number required by law to take an action. Passage of a motion requires a majority of members present voting. There's no proxy voting, so you can't have someone else vote for you if you can't attend in person. And the rules provide, these rules provide that all meetings shall be conducted in accordance with Robert's Rules. The rules also provide what should be on an agenda for a land use board or for a city committee. So in the next few slides, I'm going to kind of go systematically through the agenda and talk about each item. One thing I just did want to note while we mentioned voting is that, as some of you might recall or have noticed, often when we do a roll call vote, the vote starts with the first person alphabetically, the first commissioner alphabetically, and goes through. And then the second vote of the evening starts with the second person and goes through alphabetically from there. And it's that sort of, that sort of rolling beginning person. I haven't found anything in any of the rules that actually requires the commission to do that. And just from my limited experience working with the commission the last few months, I've seen that it can lead to some confusion, and sometimes members are accidentally skipped because of the different vote order that's taken with each vote. So happy to discuss this now or at a later time, but I would recommend that we switch to just voting alphabetically from beginning to end with each motion just to simplify things. But, of course, happy to defer to what the commission prefers. Let's postpone that, but I'd like to discuss it because I think there's a real advantage to doing it the way we do it. Great. We can postpone that unt PETER SMITH: til next time, Vice Chair Smith, and I agree. It might be a good conversation to have with Chair Clough here as well. So thi NATALIE CAULEY: is is a sample agenda. I'm going to talk more specifically about what the different items mean. Some of this might be different than what we've done historically, but through my research for this presentation, I learned some procedures that I think we can amend and help streamline these meetings, sort of like at the beginning of the meeting when I recommended for the Approval of Agenda didn't have to do a whole roll call vote. One of the handouts I provided to you, I think it's the last item in the packet, is a specific guide for the chair of the meeting as to how to run a meeting and what the different parts of the agenda entail, like I'm about to cover. So every meeting starts with Call to Order. That's the formal opening of the meeting. That's where the chair says, "I call this meeting to order." Then we get into Pledge of Allegiance, then the roll call, which checks attendance and establishes a quorum. Of course, no problem. If a member shows up after roll call, they can still participate in votes after their arrival. Next, we have the approval of the agenda. This is the opportunity to amend the agenda before final adoption. After it's approved here, you can only amend the agenda later through a vote with two-thirds members voting to change the agenda. So as I said at the beginning of the meeting, no need for a formal motion is necessary here if there is unanimous consent. So the chair can just ask, "Are there any objections to the proposed agenda?" And if none are raised, the chair declares it approved. Next, we have Approval of Consent Agenda. The consent agenda allows the approval of routine, non-controversial items with a single motion. So any single member can remove an item from the consent agenda to the regular agenda. There's no vote, no explanation needed. It's just removed as soon as it's requested to be removed. The Approval of Consent Agenda requires a formal motion and vote to approve all bundled items at once. And, of course, if there's, if there's no items listed under the consent part of the agenda, there's no motion to approve necessary. Next, we have Approval of Minutes. Again, this is a bit different than we've done in practice. So with the Approval of Minutes chair can just ask, "Are there any corrections to the distributed draft minutes for this date?" If no, no one has any corrections, then the chair can just declare it approved or, yes, approved by unanimous consent. Any member can point out an error or suggest a change. No formal motion is necessary. If no one disagrees with that change to the minutes, then, again, the chair can just declare it approved. If someone does disagree with that change to the minutes, then that would require a formal motion to amend the minutes. And, yes, once all the changes are addressed, the chair states the minutes stand approved as corrected by unanimous consent. Next is Approval of Findings/Conclusions. This does require what's called a main motion or a motion as you would typically think of it, a second, and a majority vote. Just some examples of language would be, "I move to approve the draft findings," or, "I move to approve the draft findings with two amendments, changing this and changing that." Next is the consent item. This lists the items for the consent agenda. This doesn't actually require a separate motion and vote. The motion vote occurred through the earlier item for the Approval of Consent Agenda. Old business covers matters on prior agendas that are still outstanding. New business covers new matters. Staff Communications where staff can raise items that are not listed on the agenda. As we discussed last time, staff can bring up items or in the next, next item, commissioner member, commission members can bring up items. But if it's not on the agenda, then the commission cannot take action on anything. There can only be discussion of the item. And then finally, we have the final item, which is to adjourn. If there are no questions on Natalie, Natalie, I have a question. If you can go back to the previous slide. When th PETER SMITH: he consent list, no separate motion is needed. But if there's an objection to the consent list, then it can be discussed. Yes. So, so an objection to the consent list would be discussed at Approval of Consent Agenda at that item. NATALIE CAULEY: And so I believe, typically, an objection to the consent agenda would just be someone saying, "This shouldn't be on the consent agenda. I want to discuss it." And so that doesn't need to have a motion or be debated. It is just automatically moved from the consent agenda to the regular agenda. Got it. Thank you. Next, I'll discuss Robert's Rules Order. Robert's Rules of Order is a type of parliamentary procedure. These are rules for conducting orderly meetings that accomplish goals fairly. Robert's Rules the most widely used parliamentary authority in the United States. It was developed by a US Army officer, Henry Martin Robert, and published in 2476. Just kind of interesting background story. So in 1863, Officer Robert was asked to preside over a public church meeting in New Bedford, Mass, and he didn't have any experience or procedural guidelines. So, apparently, the meeting quickly just descended into chaos and open conflict. And Officer Robert was so deeply embarrassed by this experience that ten years later, he was snowed in Milwaukee. He was stationed there at the time. And so with all of his time during that winter, he studied parliamentary procedure and came up with these rules that we have today. It's, they're loosely based on the rules of the US House of Representatives, but adapted for non-legislative groups. And the twelfth edition was published in 2020. So why do we use Robert's Rules? What function or purpose does it serve? Robert's Rules makes sure that all members have equal rights, that the majority rules but minority rights are still protected, that one question is considered at a time, and that all sides of an issue can be heard. So I'll go more deeply into a few parts Robert's Rules. We'll start with the role of the chair in meetings, then discuss the different types of motions that can be brought and their hierarchy between each other. Robert's Rules very long and comprehensive. If you've ever seen the rule book, it's a very large book and with very small font. So I obviously, today, I'm just doing an overview of items and not getting into very specific motions. But your reference sheets that I provided to you get into a bit more detail about what type of motion you would make if you're trying to achieve a specific objective. So the role of the chair is really important Robert's Rules. The chair is the presiding officer that runs the meetings impartially, maintains orders, facilitates business, and protects all members' rights. So that's, there are three main roles as part of that. The chair opens the meetings. As I said, they say, "The meeting will come to order." They check the quorum and then follow the agenda systematically. They process motions, so they state the motion clearly, ask for debate, put the question to a vote, and then announce the result. And then they maintain order, so they recognize speakers fairly, keep debates on topic, enforce time limits, and remain neutral. So onto the types of motions, the most significant are main motions. These are the most important motions that are considered where Planning Commission really does the work that you think of when, when you think of the Planning Commission work. So this introduces a new item Old Business. You start with saying, "I move that," followed by the proposal. It requires a second. It's debatable, and it can be amended, and it typically requires a majority to vote to pass except for a few, a few exceptions. And then here on the screen is an example of a typical main motion you would have in Planning Commission hearing. Next are subsidiary motions. These help the assembly process main motions. They can modify, delay, delay, or dispose of them. So a few common examples would be a motion to amend, which changes the wording of the main motion, a motion to refer to committee for further study, or a motion for the previous question, which just means that debate is ended immediately, and this requires a two-thirds vote to, to take place. Next are privileged motions. So these are of such urgency that they take precedence over all other matters. So motion to adjourn. This ends the meeting. Not debatable. Requires a majority vote. Motion to recess. Obviously, temporary break. Again, not debatable. And then a question of privilege or a point of privilege, which addresses comforts or comfort or rights. So you might say, "I bring a point of privilege. Can we turn up the temperature? It's cold in here." That sort of comfort or rights issue. Finally, we have incidental motions. These arise from pending questions and must be decided before business can proceed. So one example is point of order. This calls attention to a rules violation, and the chair rules immediately. An appeal where the decision of the chair is appealed. This requires a majority vote. And then parliamentary inquiry, which asks the chair a question about procedure. So another way that Robert's Rules tries to create order in meetings where a lot of different things can be happening at once is by instituting a hierarchy of motions that can be made at any one time. So on one of the documents I provided to you, the first one labeled Robert's Rules Cheat Sheet, there are two tables. I've reflected that on the screen. I think it's much easier to read on the paper in front of you than on the PowerPoint. But the first table on that paper details motions and points and their established order of precedence. So if one of those is pending, you can only introduce an item that is above that type of motion. The second lower table on the sheet provides motions, points, and proposals that can be introduced at any time, except when the commission is deciding one of the first three items on the first table. So that's a motion to adjourn, recess, or a point of privilege. I got this question from Dan a minute ago about adjourning. So the motion to adjourn is if the commission wants... someone wants to adjourn early. If the commission's hearing is just naturally over, the chair can just declare the matter adjourned. It doesn't require a motion. I did inherit this sheet from a former assistant city attorney, so I have full confidence in its accuracy. But please let me know if you realize something is inaccurate so I can correct it. Lastly, I just want to touch on a few areas that are commonly confused. So one of these is the difference between postponing and tabling something. Obviously, very similar language, but technically are different types of motions. So to postpone something to a certain time puts off an issue until a set time. It has to be before the end of the next regular meeting. It requires a second debatable and amendable, and then it returns at the set time automatically. There's no vote needed to bring it back. This is different than a motion to table or to lay something on the table. This temporarily sets aside a pending motion to address an urgent higher priority matter. This is brought back by a motion to take from the table, so it doesn't automatically come back. You have to have another motion to take it from the table. And if it's not taken back from the table by the end of the next meeting, then the motion just automatically dies. Another area of common confusion are abstentions. I'm going to explain how this works for Planning Commission, which is actually different than how it works for the governing body. So after this, I'll just quickly touch on how it works for the governing body, for anyone who's interested. So because the commission does not have specific rules that cover abstentions, that means we use Robert's Rules Order. Under Robert's Rules abstention is a non-vote. It's neither a yes or a no. It does not affect quorum, so abstaining members are still present and considered part of the quorum. But this is where it gets a little sticky is that our Chapter 14 and committee rules require a majority of members present to pass a motion. So that means an abstention can make passage a bit harder and effectively operate as a no vote. So just an example, let's say we have eight commissioners who are present, four vote yes, three vote no, and one abstains. So under the commission's rules that require a majority of the members present to pass a motion, if there are eight members present, you need five to pass a motion. Even though one person's abstaining, they're still present, so they're still part of that calculation. So because you need five, you only have four, the motion fails. This is different than how many bodies might treat this. As I kind of mentioned before, many bodies require a majority of the members voting to pass a motion. So in this instance, we would have seven members voting. Four vote yes, four is a majority of seven, and the motion would pass. So this is unlikely to come up, but just a place where, you know, abstentions can make things a little complicated. I'll quickly describe the governing body. The governing body has much more specific rules for themselves. The procedural rules document that they have is maybe four times longer than the governing body rules for city committees. They're much more detailed, and so they go into detail about how abstentions are treated. So for the governing body, if there's an abstention when they're voting on an ordinance or a resolution, it's counted as a no vote. If no results in a tie, then the motion fails. It doesn't result in the mayor voting because the mayor votes in the case of a tie, when there's typically a tie. If it's anything besides an ordinance or a resolution, then abstention is acquiescence with the majority. So if the vote is tied before the abstentions are considered, then there isn't a majority. Abstentions are not counted and the motion fails. But if there is a majority, then the abstention just gets added to their tally of votes. That's all I have for this evening. Are there any questions I SASHA MCGHEE: can answer? Commissioner Rivera? Thank you. I have a question, going back to the earlier part of the presentation regarding the ability to speak with others for a quasi-judicial matter. I don't know what slide it was on. I'm going to think it's five. I lost track here. My silly question on this is, is there a time limit or an event that would allow that to happen? So, for example, I just read it from here, and it says, "cannot communicate with members outside of public meeting or hearing about the merits of any quasi-judicial item." Is that until the item passes, fails, completes? Is it forever? I mean, I'm just curious about the time-bound or a NATALIE CAULEY: any event-bound phase. Thank you, Commissioner Rivera. That's a great question. The Chapter 14 does not delineate a specific time for the communication. Generally, I think it starts once it becomes apparent that this item will be a quasi-judicial item in front of the commission, and then it ends... It could end after passage. One issue that could arise, though, is if Planning Commission were to approve or deny something, and then it goes up to the governing body. And after the vote to approve or deny, a commissioner were to communicate with the applicant about the item, and then the governing body were to remand it to Planning Commission for further proceedings, that commissioner might have to recuse themselves because of the communications that they had with the applicant. Obviously, remands from the governing body don't happen all the time, but I would generally suggest that the communications are limited until after it has gone past the governing body. Okay. Thank you. I think that would be help SASHA MCGHEE: pful. We just recommend even for future versions of this that be added, because I think the way things happen throughout some of these meetings, things line up going to another location for another vote, another study, and back. And that would include even the historic board, our board, governing body. I just... For me, as somebody new on here, I think that would be very helpful to know. Great. Thank you. That's great feedback CITY STAFF: k. That was my only question NATALIE CAULEY: n. Question? Vice Chair Smith? Questions CITY STAFF: s? It does not appear he is online anymore. I have a question. I get the agenda items E through F, Approval of Consent Agenda, and then H consent. So what' NATALIE CAULEY: 's the difference in the two? So consent... The consent one is just where the items are actually listed, where it would say all of the specific things that are being approved through the vote on the approval. The approval for the consent agenda is where the motion is actually made. They don't actually need to be delineated as two separate things, because as you said, they're both addressing what the consent items are and approving them. But the consent item is just where the items are listed. That's the format that we have for Planning Commiss CITY STAFF: sion at this time. Mr. Estegabel? Commissioner Smith's back. Vice Chair Smith, do y PETER SMITH: you have questions, Mr. Smith? I have one. It's not pertaining to this book. What is what it to? First, the other members of the commission have gotten your material, but I hope you'll call them and talk with them through this so that they get the sa NATALIE CAULEY: ame exposure we've had. Thank you, Vice Chair Smith. I communicated with Commissioner McReynolds, and she intends to watch the recording. And I was going to communicate that wit PETER SMITH: th Chair Clough as well. Good. That's great. I think the other thing that I have and which is material to this, I think I and I think my colleagues would like to meet two times a month, period. That is what we were told was happening to get briefings, to work as a board, to learn about each other and our interests. And I think given the general plan and the code, we should have an agenda twice a month. I know everybody's overworked, but to have us understanding how to work as a board and really being briefed on all the issues as a board, I think is very important. And I... I've never been told that the code said one meeting a month. We were always told to, but one meeting a month isn't enough for us to maintain a presence, a policy presence in my estimation. If my colleagues disagree with me, so be it. That's happened before, and I'll live with it. But I think we... I really want to have us meet twice a month to discuss either issues before the commission or the policies of the ge NATALIE CAULEY: eneral plan of the code. Thank you, Vice Chai KELLY MCREYNOLDS: ir Smith. Director Lamboy. Yes. Thank you. We... What we have done is we have grouped all of the cases that we receive into the first agenda of the month. And because we have so many special projects, including the general plan update, the land development code update, we anticipate there's going to be many more meetings. We did have a bit of a lull there for a while when it comes to the general plan and the land development code update, but things are proceeding along. There's also the policy subcommittee that had... In the past, when Councilor Faulkner was chair of that committee, met once a month and talked about particular issues of, you know, interest, including the ENN and so on. So I understand and I'm sympathetic to Vice Chair Smith's request, and I think we will definitely be meeting more in the future. I understand the desire to learn more, and we'll certainly try to accommodate something if you bring a suggestion to us. We're not going to have a meeting just for the sake of having a meeting, but we do like to make sure Planning Commission is educated and feels co PETER SMITH: omfortable in their CITY STAFF: role. Thank you. Anything else, Vice Chair? You good? Commissioners? Okay. Miss Colley, if we can just get back to the E and H, can we just delete H and put what's on consent under E? Or NATALIE CAULEY: r does it make it as confusing? Thank you, Chair Gutierrez. That certainly seems appropriate to me. I'll discuss it with the city attorney to make sure I'm not missing any reason that we need to have them listed as two separate items. But assuming we don't, if that's the will of the commission, CITY STAFF: I think we can absolutely do that. Yeah. That's the... Just saying one step if it's the same thing, and we've already voted to ei THOMAS RIELAND: ither approve or pull the consent. So our... When we're approving the consent agenda, we're just saying we agree with the items that are there, but the actual consent aspect of the meeting comes up at that later time. That's my und CITY STAFF: derstanding. Unless I'm completely don NATALIE CAULEY: ne. Oh, that... I guess that makes sense. That's correct. The motion that needs to take place to approve the consent items is at the item Approval of Consent Agenda. So I think to Chair Gutierrez's point, once consent actually comes up on the agenda, commission actually isn't taking any action. They're just kind of skipping over that. So it does seem reasonable to me at this time to just combine them into one. But, again, this is an issue I'd like to look more CITY STAFF: e into before I provide a definitive answer. Th hank you. Thank you for that, Mr. Esquivel. I do want to remind everybody we have a special meeting on the 22nd regarding the general plan, so I'm hoping everybody can participate in that. We do need a quorum. The other thing I'd like to just give my observation on that, 22nd meeting evenin KELLY MCREYNOLDS: ng. Can you tell me about it? The meeting scheduled for October 22nd, Chair Gutierrez, is to... It's a combination technical working group committee meeting as well as Planning Commission. In the past, the entire commission has expressed interest in participating in those technical sessions. And so, this is a report out on where we've come from through the visioning phase and also an opportunity to react to our character frameworks and future line use map. We have a preliminary map, and we want to vet that with the commission and the technical work. Okay. I think I CITY STAFF: just misinterpreted that email. I thought it was for people that were on the general plan subcommittee meeting is how I interpret it. So I was... So it will be KELLY MCREYNOLDS: e an evening meeting in the chamber or something else? Yes. I'll have to double check the time, but we'll make sure to correct the record and send out another email. Actually, PETER SMITH: , Mr. Chair, acting chair, I think it's actually two in the... Or three or four in the afternoon. It is earlier. It's from MATT EMBRY: 2:00 PM to 4:00 PM. And I thought it was the long range planning subcommittee as well. So, yeah, I think we should clarify. Yep. My a SASHA MCGHEE: apolog KELLY MCREYNOLDS: gies. It is at two in the afternoon. I misspoke. Okay. But we will definitely send out a confirmation. There's not necessarily needed a quorum because Planning Commission is a participant, but not everybody is required to attend. So if we have no quorum, it's not going to be an issue. But, of course, we encourage the commission to attend if possible. We'll see what we can do about recording it. Although, it's going to be a challenge because we're going to be looking over maps on tables and all of that. Mr. Esquivel? I al CITY STAFF: lso want to just let everybody know the development cycles. You get a lot of people who are going to go through the process because they need to start their next job, so they start their applications early on. And then they start working on the construction portion of it towards the latter half. And when that... When those tend to drop down, you get the smaller projects that flood the market, people who want to get their lot splits done right away so they can take advantage of paying their taxes at the end of the year and all those other developments that come in that are more administrative. So the staff maintains a busy presence of applications that come in, but Planning Commission starts to slow down a bit because those bigger projects are on a different phase of their development project. So just understand that towards the end of the year, you don't get as many of them. You do get some, but not as many. And, likewise, sometimes it's hard to get a quorum at the end of the year. November and December, the governing body only has one a month, because of the holidays. It just makes it very difficult to make quarantines. So just wanted to throw that out so that you understand how things... Why things tend to slow down. I mean, taxes play a big part. All the imports that get taxed and shoot the price of construction up. That also plays a key factor in it too. But, overall, that's kind of how development works. It oscillates PETER SMITH: s. Daniel, my proposal is that you schedule the two meetings every month and look at the year. And if it's December or Thanksgiving or Easter or 4th of July, you cancel a meeting. But we need to know, not just month to month, we need to know when the hell we're meeting. And then you can cancel a meeting if you have to. But the point... We should... Sorry. We should have an annual schedule because the mayor... When I was talking to the mayor, he wanted to know we would be at the meetings. So that's CITY STAFF: s my two cents worth for what it's worth. Fine. Mr. Esquivel, just hold off. You don't answer that just yet. I think a better way to go about this is Vice Chair Smith has planted a seed for us, and we can... You guys talk about it in your department, and commissioners can talk about it. And we'll bring it back up and edit out a little further at another time. But, you know, the wish of Vice Chair Smith and even... It sounds like he's saying something as simple as the state in this state, we're here, and if it's canceled, then it's happened. So anything else, Vice Chair Smith? Amen, brot PETER SMITH: ther. I appreciate your addition. You're much more thoughtful than I am. We're stil CITY STAFF: ll Staff Communications. Anything els SASHA MCGHEE: se from staff? I would ju NATALIE CAULEY: ust let the commission know that this does not affect your work, but that a special hearing is scheduled for the governing body in November to hear a few land use appeals, including an appeal from the 1802 Cerritos Road project that was approved in June for a self storage facility. So once we have an update after that hearing, we'll, of course, bring it to you. Thank you s CITY STAFF: so much. Director Lamboy, anything? No other updates. Thank you, Chair. Thank you. Mr. Esquivel, any other updates? Anything? No, Chair. Thank you. No. No. Yes. No. Alright. Matters from the commission... Commissioners? Commissioner McGhee? Ju MATT EMBRY: ust to mention that Director Lamboy mentioned a couple weeks ago that there is a planning conference in Albuquerque, Monday through Wednesday of next... It's here. Oh, I'm so glad you just said that because I knew it was here, but I keep going to Albuquerque. Thank you. Thank you. Here, and I plan to attend, at least Monday and Tuesday, if not parts of Wednesday. So C KELLY MCREYNOLDS: Chair, we have repurchase tickets, and so we're just getting all the names and everything organized. But, yes, for those who are interested, we purchase CITY STAFF: ed. Great. Good. Thank you. Anything else, commissioners? I planted the seed, I think, Miss Colley on the first one, and it was on variances. And I'd still like to see in-depth training on variances at some point. And what I said initially was before we see a variance, , a request for variance. Okay? Mr. Chair? Yes, Mr. Escamilla? I do... I am creating a cheat sheet on that, and we can go over many items on that cheat sheet. And variance happens to be one of the em. Yeah. Just like a formal training for us as a commission on that. Any other business? No motion. We're adjourned. Everybody, thank you.