Historic Districts Review Board Meeting Tue, Oct 27, 2026 · Historic Districts Review Board https://santafeminutes.space/meeting/1180-historic-design-review-oct-27-2026 == Executive Summary == The Historic Districts Review Board met on October 27, 2026, approving several projects and postponing others. Key decisions included the unanimous approval of a new 6,600 sq ft Spanish Pueblo Revival style home at 817 Vista Catedral, with conditions for specific window and lintel designs. The Board also granted after-the-fact approval for unauthorized alterations at 124 Camino Santiago, allowing installed windows to remain but requiring restoration of the stucco's original texture and color. Significant discussion centered on the Wheelwright Museum's proposed 2,060 sq ft entry expansion. Despite staff recommendations to deny an exception for exceeding 50% of the historic footprint and to reduce the portal size, the Board ultimately approved the application as submitted. This approval included exceptions for constructing an addition on a primary facade, exceeding the historic footprint, and exceeding the maximum allowable height, recognizing the museum's functional needs and the design's aesthetic merits. Public comments also touched on legal issues, quorum legality, and opposition to the plaza obelisk restoration. == Key Decisions == - Approved the agenda and minutes from 10/13/2026. - Adopted findings of fact and conclusions of law from 01/27/2026, 02/10/2026, and 06/23/2026. - Approved the new 6,600 sq ft construction at 817 Vista Catedral (Case 2026-013107-HDRB) with conditions for revised plans showing wood lintels and divided light windows (except under portals) for staff approval. - Granted after-the-fact approval for alterations at 124 Camino Santiago (Case 2026-013210-HDRB), allowing installed two-pane windows to remain, requiring stucco restoration to original texture and a reasonable facsimile of original color, and allowing the applicant to choose their entry door. - Approved the Wheelwright Museum's 2,060 sq ft entry expansion at 704 Camino Lejo (Case 2026013296HDRB) as submitted, including exceptions for constructing an addition on a primary facade, exceeding 50% of the historic footprint, and exceeding the maximum allowable height. == Motions & Votes == - Motion to approve 817 Vista Catedral (Case 2026-013107-HDRB) with conditions for revised plans showing wood lintels and divided light windows (except under portals) for staff approval — Passed unanimously (Member Simmons: Yes, Member Bienvenu: Yes, Member Degnan: Yes). - Motion to allow installed two-pane windows to remain, restore stucco to its original texture and a reasonable facsimile of the original color, and allow the applicant to choose their entry door for 124 Camino Santiago (Case 2026-013210-HDRB) — Passed (Vice Chair Ben Benue: Yes, Member Degnan: Yes, Member Simmons: Yes). - Motion to approve the Wheelwright Museum entry expansion at 704 Camino Lejo (Case 2026013296HDRB) as submitted, including findings that exception criteria were met for constructing an addition on a primary facade and within 10 feet of it, an addition exceeding 50% of the historic footprint, and exceeding the maximum allowable height — Passed (Member Degnan: Yes, Member Van Venue: Yes, Member Simmons: Yes). == Public Comment == Steven Fox discussed a "criminal prosecution of Pfizer CEO Al Boorla" and a potential "City of Santa Fe versus Pfizer" case. Stephanie Benonato argued that 2-1 votes with a four-member quorum are illegal, asserting the chair's non-vote is a prohibition, not an abstention. Richard Martinez reiterated opposition to the restoration of the obelisk on the plaza, advocating for a more community-centered space. Public comments overwhelmingly supported the Wheelwright Museum project, citing improved functionality, respectful aesthetics, and community benefit. == Topics == - Wheelwright Museum Entrance - Voting Procedures & Quorum - Obelisk on Plaza - New Construction 817 Vista Catedral - Pfizer Criminal Prosecution - Meeting Postponements == Full Transcript == CITY STAFF: I don't know if it's Michael, IT. We're ready to go. We are live. Go PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): ood evening, e CECILIA RIOS: everyone, and welcome to this meeting of the Historic District Board. Today is 10/27/2026. Amanda, may we have a roll call? Member Simmons? AMANDA ROMERO: Here. Member Degnan? Present. Vice Ch MARY ELLEN DEGNAN: hair Bien AMANDA ROMERO: nvenu? Here. Member Besheid? Excused. Chair Rios? Here. And Member Cherry? Excused. Thank you, Madam Chair. You have a quorum. Thank you. Are there any changes to the agenda? Good evening. LANI MCCULLEY: . So if any members of the public are here for a few items, I wanted to let you know if you turn to the second page under eight, old business, item A, 2026-012490-HDRB 507 Paseo de Peralta. That has been postponed to the November 10 meeting. As well, item B, 2026-012491-HDRB, right next door, 511 Paseo de Peralta. That has also been postponed to 11/10/26. And then under the next item, new business, item number A, 2026-013336-HDRB. 613 W. San Francisco Street. That has also been postponed to the November 10 meeting. And then also under new business, item number 2026-013108-HDRB. 135 Grant Ave. has also been postponed to 11/10/2026. So four items will be heard on the November 10. Thank you very much. So it looks like ou CECILIA RIOS: ut of seven cases, we will only be hearing three cases this evening. Is there a motion? All those in favor of the, of the motion, I'm, excuse me, I'm going to restate this. Do I hear a motion to approve the agenda? Just a minute. Second move. Is there a second? All those in favor, say aye. Aye. And opposed, say no. Thank you. Are there any changes to the minutes of 10/13/2026? Either staff or board members. It appears there are no changes. Is there a motion to approve these? So moved. Second. All those in favor, say aye. A LANI MCCULLEY: Aye. Opp CECILIA RIOS: posed, say no. Thank you. Under findings of fact and conclusions of law, we have four from 01/27/2026. Any changes to the, anyone? No? And we also have one set from 02/1 JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: 10/2026. Any changes to this one? No changes? And the last one, 06/23/2026. Any changes? It appears that the transcriber m CECILIA RIOS: must have done an excellent job. So all those in favor to adopt these as stated, say aye. Aye. Opposed, say no. Thank you very Matters from the Public. Is there anyone here that wishes to speak not in reference to your case, but in reference to something regarding H point? You may do so at this point. In reference to anything that concerns the historic board that doesn't have anything to do with the, with the case. Sorry. My, my, my, my name is Steven PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): n Fox. I'm founder of a new branch of the United Nations in Santa Fe. It's a work in progress. And I'm just going to read this thing to you so you can get a clear picture of what, as of 30 minutes ago, what's really going on. Okay? So pertaining to the criminal prosecution of Pfizer CEO Al Boorla, the great Greek veterinarian, and other Pfizer and Moderna executives in the context of City of Santa Fe versus Pfizer. That's the case. There's nothing brand new about The Hague case, enlightenments in The Hague case, OTPCR473021 from 12/06/2021. What is new is that as of last week, Mayor Garcia, I have to say it's infinite prominence on his part to recognize that there are so many deaths and injuries from Pfizer that we have to put together some way a, in Santa Fe versus Pfizer. Most of the month's name pharmaceutical, dendrocytes, and one from have, were indicted, and it's not like I'm making this up. They were indicted in, in 12/06/2021. The indictment's been resulting from a 46-page criminal complaint, which was so perfectly done. There's a three prosecutors at The Hague at the ICC from Pakistan, one, two, Pakistan and United Kingdom, two, Fiji, and then the prosecutor from Senegal, who has been a licensed in the AICC a few days earlier, were able to agree to give him an indictment number, OTPCR473021. Well, more recently, you haven't read about this. This is all brand new. You haven't read about this in the New Mexico. They don't, they don't want to. Thank you. There, there's more. There's a lot more. Thank you, sir. Stephanie Benonato. CECILIA RIOS: So I'm again bri PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): inging up the idea that the two-one votes when there's a quorum of four are totally improper, in fact, illegal. Mr. Rubelid used to put in the word, voting members. That is an improper statutory construction. It is members present. And then he decided some school board case from 60 years ago that was not on point. More recently, he has said that the chair is abstaining from voting, and that is not an accurate description. And in fact, it defies the definition of abstention, which is a conscious voluntary choice by a qualified voter present at a meeting to decline to cast a yes or no vote. Whereas the prohibition is an absolute rule or structural restriction that strips the chair of voting privileges on that body entirely, except perhaps to break a vote, to break a tie. Excuse me. So again, an abstention requires the person to have the right to vote, but chooses to withhold it. When rules prohibit the chair from voting, the chair lacks the legal capacity or right to vote on that matter. So they are two very different things. So what Ms. Rios is doing here as chair, or when Mr. Bienvenu is chair, they are not abstaining. They are prohibited from voting. And according to Robert's Rules of Order, really an abstention vote is a non-vote anyway. But in the case, if the rules explicitly require majority or two-thirds of the members present, which is what your rule reads, or a majority of two-thirds of the entire membership, an abstention will have the same effect as a no vote. So I have never seen, despite the fact that Ms. Rubbelle keeps characterizing your non-vote as an abstention, I have never seen that abstention counted yes or no. I believe the city has its own rules on abstention votes that may differ a little bit from Robert's Rules of Order. But again, your so-called abstention has never been counted. So two-one votes are improper, illegal. You need a three-zero and, or ask the person to come back when there's more people present, more members present. Thank you. Thank you, Steph CECILIA RIOS: hanie. Hi. Richard Mar PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): rtinez. I, I just want to say again, that there are a number of us, maybe a majority of us Hispanics, that are opposed to any restoration of the obelisk on the, on the plaza. That we have all seen photographs of the plaza before the obelisk was installed when it was a more community-centered plaza where there was a bandstand in the center, at least for people to gather rather than an object in the center. And perhaps the obelisk represents a time, a place, a community that is long gone, and that we need to do something else in the past. Thank you. Tha CECILIA RIOS: ank you, Richard. Anyone else in this audience wishing to come forward in reference to anything that's on your mind regarding H board matters? It appears not. And is there anyone else online, Maggie? C CITY STAFF: Chair Rios, yeah, I, I see no hands raised right now for public comment. Than CECILIA RIOS: nk you very much. Staff Communications we have anything under staff communications? T CITY STAFF: Thank you, Chair Rios. No, not tonight. I just wanted to clarify that the "Heritage is a Verb" presentation is also being postponed to November 10. Director Lamboy wanted to make sure that we could have the full board, you know, available for that and, and that presentation. So that'll also be taking place on the November 10, if anyone's here for that. Thank you, CECILIA RIOS: Maggie. The lady. Pardon? Yes. That's, that's on the agenda, so you can speak at that point. Okay. So we will move on to the first case this evening, which is under new business, and that is located at 812 East at the block. And that is Lanny's case, and I do need to tell you a couple of things. If you disagree with the decision that this board renders this evening, you do have the option to appeal, and you would be appealing to the City Council. And I would suggest that you get together with city staff. They can guide you through that process. And also, if you are a person of the public that wishes to comment on a case, you will be limited to two minutes on your comments. With that being said, Lanny, we can hear from you on t CITY STAFF: this case. Thank you. Thank you. This is case 2026013107HDRB for 817 Vista Catedral for new construction. The development where Vista Catedral is located sits north of the La Barreta Compound and is accessed by La Bereda Norte. Of the 21 lots, nine are currently developed. The lots are all on sloped. The lots are all sloped. The structures, lots are all sloped. The structures are all in recent Santa Fe style with flat roofs dappled with skylights, solar panels, and HVAC units. The lots have low stucco yard walls that create courtyards. The lot at 817 Vista Catedral is approximately 0.87 acres with a large portion of the lot covered in 30% slopes. The buildable area of the property appears to be located to the east, closer to the street. This buildable area, on-site drainage control, and impervious surfaces will need to be confirmed with terrain management. The applicant is requesting to construct a 6,605 square foot Spanish Pueblo Revival style residence to a height of 19 feet six inches due to the slope. The maximum allowable height is 16 feet. The east street-facing elevation will be at 14 feet. The high, the taller portion will be to the west. The design is consistent with the El Cerro Murano subdivision's character, and a request for additional height is requested under the provision of section 14-4.6 F2FF22F, which allows the HDRB to increase the allowable height for proposed buildings and additions located on a sloping site. The residents will have several portals with heavy wood headers and columns. The windows and doors will be aluminum clad wood single light windows in copper with a patina similar to dark bronze. Windows will have wood lintels. Windows and doors will be deep inset. Garage doors will be typical roll-up doors. There will be four chimneys. Canales will be copper-lined wood. Corners of the structure will be bullnosed at approximately two to three inches. The applicant further re-process, proposes to construct six-foot high stucco walls to create courtyards on the north, northwest, and southwest areas of the lawn, install metal railings in a dark color, install exterior lighting with aged copper sconces, and install hardscaping using brick pavers and cut stone. Staff recommends approval of the proposed project and finds that the application complies with section 14-4.6E, general design standards for all Historic District, and 14-4.6G2 for the Downtown and East Side design standards. I stan CECILIA RIOS: nd for questions. Thank you, Lanny, for the report. What is, would you describe the public visibility CITY STAFF: of this project? This is actually a, a behind a closed gate, so the whole, developmen CECILIA RIOS: nt is private. Also, am I seeing a lot of undivided lights, windows? And is that permitted? We are in the, this is CITY STAFF: Downtown East Side. It isn't, it, so in Downtown East Side, we generally ask for 36-inch lights. However, this entire development has single light. Repeat? The, the entire development in, in Vista Catedral. All of those houses hav CECILIA RIOS: ve undivided lights. Thank you. So because one project has undivided light, the next one, I think that's something that is up to the board. Any other questions, board JOHN BIENVENU: members, at this point? Member Simmons? Just a simple question. Lanny, you said that, there will be wood lintels over these windows, but the elevations don't indicate that. Is that any CITY STAFF: kind of a problem for you? No. The wood lintels were under consideration. They're not confirmed at this point. If they decide to put the wood lintels, they'll need to u CECILIA RIOS: update their drawings with us. Any other questions? Ap AMANDA ROMERO: pplicant, would you come forward? Hi. Please state your name. Can you raise your hand and state your PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): r name and address AMANDA ROMERO: s for the record? Michael Bodelson. Lebanese Wildflower Drive, San Bernardino, Mexico. Thank you, Michael. Do you solemnly declare and affirm the testimony you have in reference to this item is the truth, the whole truth, and do this under the pen CECILIA RIOS: nalties of perjury? Thank you. Thank you. Maybe, Mister Bodelson, what do you have to add to PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): this project? Oh, I would clarify the lentils. You look at those drawings so often and so closely. There was a drafting commission. The intention is, and the actual subdivision requirements are, to expose solid. And then, just to clarify a little bit on the divided lights, we were intending under the portals, which I believe is the next of planning or airport. Divided lights wouldn't be required under the rentals, but we would need the requiremen CECILIA RIOS: nt as stated in the ordinance for all other divided. In reference to the square footage, this is a very large house, 6,600 square feet. Yeah. Of that, how much of that is porch area? Yeah. I don't have, or you might want to answer, how much of that is PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): s heated space? Yeah. Actually, the heated space is about 4,800. So there's a couple thousand square feet for a garage. And then there's an addition to that would be the covered hotels, which is probably, I would estimate it, you know, somewhere around a maybe less. We CECILIA RIOS: have a port out the front and on t JOHN BIENVENU: the north. The larger one. Other questions for them or comma? I don't see in the packet, and it doesn't appear in your presentation, that there are any perspective views. This is something that we continue to request of applicants. It just helps the public and board members, including myself as an architect, t PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): to get a better sense of the three-dimensionality of the project. Right. And I would agree. I, you know, I talked to staff a little bit about actually providing that. I ran a little short on time to do that, but I thought it was off. I mean, I would en CECILIA RIOS: ncourage it to be, you know, a requirement. I mean, I think they are. There are no questions from board members. I will ask if anyone in this room wishes to comment on this partic AMANDA ROMERO: cular project. If so, please come forward. You will nee PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): ed to get sworn in. Hi. Please state your name and address for the record. Stephanie Benonato. PO Box 1601, Santa Fe, New Mexico. Stephanie, do you solemnly declare and affirm the testimony you have in reference to this item as the truth, the whole truth, and do this under the penalties of perjury? Yes. Thank you. I just want to say that probably Mister Bodelson's remarks were totally inaudible to anybody who was on Zoom because he was not right at the microphone. And I can tell you from being on Zoom a lot that this is extremely frustrating not to be able to hear people. I am happy to hear that there are supposedly going to be lentils on these windows and that all but the windows under the portals are going to be divided lights. But given that it is not shown in the drawing, given that the renderings that Mister, sorry, your, Joseph, I'm sorry, I can't see your last name, just mentioned, and that would help us all to understand what this house, this 6,600 square foot house or 606,000 square foot house looks like. I would wonder if you could request a postponement and come back at the next meeting with the appropriate drawings and with the, you know, showing the lentils, showing the divided lights, and having that model so that people can really understand what's here. CECILIA RIOS: . Thank you. Okay. I do appreciate that there were rounded corners, that's not a point of discussi CITY STAFF: ion. Anyone else in this room wanting to comment CECILIA RIOS: on this particular project? No one else? A JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: Anyone online? Chair Rios, I see no hands raised for this item. CECILIA RIOS: Thank you. Board members. Oh, AMANDA ROMERO: , this member. Thank you. I'll make a motion unless you have further discussion. I will. Chair Rios, I'm sorry. I've never been to a meeting like this before, so I didn't. Oh, thank you. Swear you in. Please state your name and address for the record and speak right into the microphone if you would. Robert Kersey. 230 Rodriguez. Do you solemnly declare and affirm th JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: he testimony you have in reference to this item as the truth, the whole truth, and do this under the penalties of perjury? I do. Say, we live just on Rodriguez Street, and, you know, we see on here they want to go to 19 feet and when the allow, allow the height to 16 feet. We see this from our house, and it's going to block more of our view. And we know on Rodriguez, we're in the escarpment, and there are certain things we can't do. I just wonder, is this not on the escarpment too? Don't they have to keep to a certain level? So that's a question. Okay. The other thing is we think that the, there's a, you cannot go in there and see these signs because it's a gated community. So neighbors like us and Rodriguez can't even know what's going on. When the other house up there was built, the 7,000 square foot house about five years ago, we never knew what was CECILIA RIOS: s going on, and it blocked a big part of our view of Sangre de Cristo. And I would, you know, I would prote CITY STAFF: est this for that reason. Thank you. Very much for your comments. Excuse me? I said thank you very much for your comments. Thank you. Hey. You're at planning. I can actually answer some of his questions. Yes CECILIA RIOS: s, please do. They are LANI MCCULLEY: e an escarpment. Escarpment limits height to 14 feet, except on the downside of the slope where they can go up to 20 feet. Thank you. Mm-hmm. And we did our tour earlier today, and I b CECILIA RIOS: believe there was a sign pos LANI MCCULLEY: sted on the actual gate to this development on the pu PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): ublic street right at the end in addition to one actually at the site. So I think this was, this, right. Outside. Yes. At the entrance to this private community. Yes, Mister Bodelson? Yeah. Just confirmation. There were two signs posted. One at the front gate, which is on public side, and one at the lot on the interior. No more for the neighbors. I was at the request of staff. We were glad to comply. It is, it is this department. It is terrain management. We're meeting the requireme CECILIA RIOS: ents to terrain management. Been through a city review for terrain management. And not terrain management, I'm sorry, for this department. W PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): We've done a preliminary, we wanted. Sir. Everyone. Right. You can repeat that, Mister Bodelson. And everyone, when you come, alrighty, to the podium. Excuse me. Mister, I'm sorry. Can you hear me now? Okay. So I was just reiterating there were two signs posted, one at the front gate, which is on a public view, one on the interior at the lot. So they were CECILIA RIOS: posted at, you know, as directed by its, city staff. And the property is escarpment. It has been reviewe JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: ed by city staff for department standards. It does meet those standards. Board members, if you have no further comments or questions, I will entertain a motion. Mister Remington. Thank you, Madam Chair. So I will make a motion in this case, 2026-013107-HDRB. 817 Vista Catedral.. Just a couple comments. First, the, with respect of views, we, the board has no jurisdiction over that. That's really a question for other divisions of the city who appropriately address that. Our jurisdiction is over whether or not it meets our height requirements, which staff has indicated it does. And, you know, we're, of course, sensitive to the fact that views are often blocked by new construction. This particular property is on a ridge where there'd be no possibility of constructing on, I don't think, without blocking views. So I think this is an unfortunate situation for others, but I think that's just the way that property is going to work. I'd also just comment that for such a large building, I think the design is quite effective in complying with our ordinance as well as sort of minimizing the, the bulk that's going to be visible from the neighbors and anyone in that area. And I think it's, it's, you know, it's very consistent with that, the neighborhood character as well. So with that said, I would move to adopt staff's recommendations, approve the project as submitted on condition that JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: t revised CECILIA RIOS: d plans be submitted sho AMANDA ROMERO: owing the lentils CECILIA RIOS: s and divided light windows other than under the port halls as indicated by the applicant, would be a part of this application for final staff approval. Second. Roll c LAUREN VAGTS: call vote, please. Member Simmons? Yes. Member Bienvenu? Yes. Member Degnan? Yes. Madam Chair, the vote has passed. Mister Bodelson? Next case is located at 124 Camino Santiago. And, Lauren, that is your case. Sorry. This is case 2026-013210-HDRB. 124 Camino Santiago. for window and door replacement on primary facade with an exception to 14-4.6e41a and change in historic stucco color and texture with the exception to 14-4.6e42b. 124 Camino Santiago two-bedroom single-family residence, is located in the Downtown and East Side Historic District the east side of the street bound by Camino Santiago the north, Bishop's Lodge Road to the east, Paseo de Peralta to the south, and Old Taos Highway to the west. In 2018, the residence and shallow rear yard wall were designated as contributing with the west elevation as the primary facade. The board made no explicit exclusions for non-historic materials, such as windows and doors, and the 2000, or 2018 Historic Cultural Properties Inventory indicates the windows and doors were replaced at an unknown date, but based on, quote, drawings and material as in visual evidence, unquote. The historic building is located on a private residential road as part of a mid-century cul-de-sac land development known as Plaza del Monte. Buildings in the development are situated either at the center or near the back of the lot lengthwise along the street with concrete driveways connecting to carports. Residential structures are single-story, flat roof, and stucco clad sympathetic to the Spanish Pueblo Revival traditions while incorporating ranch house plans in contemporary forms with later developments integrating angular compositions and carport-dominated facades, including 124 Camino Santiago. The 124 Camino Santiago was constructed around 1968 as part of the Plaza del Monte Presbyterian Retirement Center development. Formerly the site of the Allison James School to the north, the private neighborhood was constructed over several phases between the late 1950s and 1977 as a communal living center for retired Presbyterian pastors, missionaries, and other associated church officials. Earlier planned designs were completed by Kenneth S. Clark and Philippe Register Architects with the south developing first as a communal living facility, congregate home, later Casa Grande, and later as individual retirement cottages to the north. Later contemporary designs moved to the exterior of the buildings with elongated footprints and flat roof house forms. Eventually, Register's design elements became more radical, including experimentation with angular composition. By 1967, Register formed a partnership with architects James Abelardo Burnett and Terrence Ross, forming RSP Architects using triangular-shaped walls and dividers and then pieces seen on the south elevation of 124 Camino Santiago and neighboring 126 Camino Santiago near the south end of the development. Between 2024 and 2025, a small cul-de-sac between 124 and 126 was filled in and landscaped as part of a 2021 development plan approved by the City Planning Commission. During this time, the driveway and sidewalk leading to the west elevation were elongated and slightly routed in an obtuse L shape to meet Camino Santiago the northwest corner of the lot. According to aerials, between 2025 and 2026, the flagstone pavers along the south elevation were partially removed with a narrow walkway left along the south elevation. The 1,148 square foot building has a modified L-shaped plan with a flat roofline, metal fascia, slightly overhanging eaves bearing exposed brackets, clad in a tan cementitious stucco with fenestrations painted white. The west primary facade elevation has a curvilinear cement slab driveway leading to a carport to the right, a port hall with three support columns at the center, and a window opening to the northwest corner with three casement windows. The north elevation is a solid wall with no fenestration. While the 2018 HICP submitted by John Murphy includes the description of mostly non-historic replacement windows throughout, there is no indication of which windows are historic or the definite material composition due to storm covers. However, the 01/18/2018 HICP of neighboring duplex built circa 1967 at 126 Camino Santiago lists steel casements as the original window material and form, which was likely the same historic form and material used at 124 Camino Santiago 08/14/2026, a stop work order was placed on 124 Camino Santiago for building without a permit issued by the City of Santa Fe Historic Preservation Division inspector. The hold indicates that the owners replaced the windows and doors without approval or a permit and need approval for proposed changes in stucco texture and color. Windows and doors have been replaced throughout the entire building. At today's site visit, it was determined that the north and south doors under the carport were enclosed, and the stucco color and texture were changed, all without approval or permits. Unfortunately, these openings were partially obscured by a parked car and a garbage can during the initial site visit photograph shown in the later slide. Unapproved work includes removal and replacement of all fenestration on the primary west elevation, and the window opening located under the port hall was expanded to fit the new window design prior to board review. The following descriptions reflect the fenestrations prior to recent unauthorized remodeling as seen in the left image. The carport has three wooden entrance doors: one at the northeast corner of the east elevation, one at the northeast corner of the north elevation with an exterior aluminum screen door, and one at the south corner of the south elevation. Under the portal is a double pane casement window to the right of the main entrance door. The northwest corner of the building has a single opening with three casement windows. The east elevation has a two-over-five divided light French door entrance to the left and a historic picture window flanked by casements to the rig AMANDA ROMERO: ght. To the south i LAUREN VAGTS: is a large window wall, stepping out onto the flagstone paved patio with a shallow contributing yard wall at the southeast corner of the lot. Sorry about that. The applicant requests approval after the fact for the following exterior alterations: replacement of six windows and one sliding glass door with bronze clad wood units from Pinnacle Windows and enclosure of two historic openings on the primary facade. No fenestration changes are proposed to the north elevation, but the historic stucco color and texture has been replaced without approval. On the east elevation, proposals after the fact include removal of a historic wooden picture window and two casement windows and replacement with an egress casement window, and removal of French doors, partially enclosed a historic opening, and replaced with a fixed horizontal window. On the south elevation, proposals after the fact include enclosing historic door opening and removal of a glass wall and replacement with sliding glass doors. On the west primary facade, proposals include bedroom three window configurations replaced with larger, two window casement units to meet required egress opening sizes, replacement of main entrance door with new design, reconfiguration of opening size to match manufacturer for the window opening under the portal, and enclosure of two historic door openings under the carport on the north and west elevations. Finally, for the entire building envelope, the applicant proposes exterior stucco replacement and change in color from existing historic terracotta tan to a Dunn Edwards Swiss Coffee. Staff finds that the exception of the criteria have not been met and recommends denial of the exceptions to section 14-4.6 E four one A for altering openings on a primary facade and 14-4.6 E four two B for changing the historic stucco color and texture. Otherwise, staff recommends approval of other portions of the application as they comply with section 14-4.6 E general design standards for all Historic District and 14-4.6 G two downtown and east side design standards. And as a note, while staff recommends denial of the proposed exceptions in reference to City of Santa Fe Land Development Code, no documentation exists providing original or preexisting opening dimensions for the window replacements on the west primary facade or other non-primary facades. Additionally, visual evidence of the preexisting window openings on the west elevation compared to the unapproved alterations do not present a si CECILIA RIOS: ignificant alteration. Therefore, staff defers to the Historic District Review Board's recommendations for project remedy. Stand for questions. Thank you for your report, Lau PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): uren. So a CECILIA RIOS: as you just stated, this is a contributing house where the owners went forward and made ma LAUREN VAGTS: any changes without a permit. Correct? Is it your opinion that this house still remains contributing? Notice you are hesitating. Yes, I guess, as my opinion, I think because the stucco, although it has been replaced, I do think it's reversible. Also, as mentioned in the staff report and in my presentation, the openings on the west elevation, that's the primary facade. I do think that the two door openings that were enclosed, that is also reversible. And as I CECILIA RIOS: I mentioned, it is still kind of undetermined whether or not the rest of the fenestrati JOHN BIENVENU: ions were historic or not. So, I guess the answer is yes. Thank you, Lauren. Other board members have comments or questions? Me LAUREN VAGTS: ember Simmons? Lauren, do you have any evidence that the original windows were the steel casement type that we see in the neighborhood? I don't. That's why I referenced the neighboring HICP from the same year just because the buildings at 124 and 126 were built within the same JOHN BIENVENU: year and designed by the same archi AMANDA ROMERO: itects, so j JOHN BIENVENU: just based off of neighboring properties and the original historic fenestrations. But it's conjecture? Okay. Yes. In the photograph to the left, there's three divisions in that window. Correct? And we see that pattern in the neighborhood in steel LAUREN VAGTS: l casement windows. Was there any, is there anything in the record that showed that these windows were replaced in a... I, unfortunately, wasn't able to uncover any historic images other than JOHN BIENVENU: from the 2018 of the facade. The only historic photograph was from the yard wall. Okay. So then, on the topic of remaining integrity, the only things that I see that have changed are the windows within the same openings and then the stucco color and texture. And so I don't know if we're on a slippery slope or not about integrity, but the fact that things were done without permits and wit LAUREN VAGTS: thout a st JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: taff review, CECILIA RIOS: , I think that JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: things could have been avoided as they stand now. I agree. Thank you. The questions have been beneath. Thank you, Madam Chair. So I'm just trying to understand exactly what's before us here. So, let me start with the, what maybe is the simplest one, which is the stucco. So before the unauthorized work, what was the condition, color, and texture of the stucco? What unauthorized work has been d LAUREN VAGTS: done? And is there still a request to do further work on the exterior stucco? I believe all the work has been done, other than the stucco color is proposed to change to Swiss Coffee. It's kind of l JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: like an off-white, you can see on the bottom left of the slide. So what was it LAUREN VAGTS: t, before the unauthorized work was done, what was the stucco? The stucco, if you can, you can see the, unfortunately, the 2018 HICP photographs are not quite clear, but it's a little bit lighter, and it is a textured JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: d stucco similar to adjacent properties that are on the block. Okay. Okay. So they changed, you're saying they definitely changed both the texture and the color when they restuccoed it? Correct. And is, okay. And you think that this, that's reversible? Yes. And the color that's on there, even though they just restuccoed it, you're saying they want to chang CITY STAFF: ge the co JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: olor from what they just... That's the, yes, the p LAUREN VAGTS: proposal. Correct. To what color from the one that it is right now? It's, it's on the, in JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: the bottom left-hand corner. It's like a, it's called Swiss Coffee. And what's the, like a light, compared to what, and what is it that they put on it? Is it darker, lighter? I, dark, it's a darker. Yeah, it's darker. So they want, even though they just restuccoed it in a certain color, they want to now paint over that and make it lighter? And according to the proposal, yes. Okay. Well, I guess we can get clarification from the applicant on that. So then on the windows and doors, it's always hard, of course, when there's unauthorized work. The typical way we, at least I tried to approach, and I think generally speaking, that's how the board approaches it, is less about punitive measures and more about restoration measures, punitive being more something for the city attorney to handle in the courts and our job being more to enforce our ordinance. So, of course, it's always extremely concerning when a property owner does work on a building without receiving permission, especially in our Historic District when we very recently status this building. The problem, I think, though, for me at least is really, to what extent the work they've done can be remedied. I think the windows, the windows, apparently, that are publicly visible on the front facade are already modified from the original. So I think you have some speculation as to what maybe was there when the building was originally built, but that's not what was there when they did the unauthorized work nor when the building was status. It was already a non-historic, well, we don't know if it was non-historic, but it was already not the original, and it was vinyl clad. Right? So I guess from my perspective, it's not hugely dissimilar, but it is somewhat dissimilar. The light pattern's different, and the color is different. I guess I'm, and the door, the door is a very different design than what was there originally. It's, it's interesting. It's, it's not a design I've ever seen before. It's a little bit, somewhat consistent with the sort of modernist, you know, fifties modernism aesthetic of the building. But, I, I guess I just, this is where I get a little stuck, which is this whole complex and this building, as part of that complex, don't really conform to our style standards to begin with. So we don't necessarily just want to say you need to make it look, the windows look like what our ordinance requires for recent Santa Fe style because that's not necessarily what the style of these buildings ever was. I think it's more important to make them consistent with the style of the subdivision and the original intention of the architect. So, and that, I think, is even more applicable to the facade that has put the sliding glass doors in because that really stands out to me as being a very dramatic alteration of the aesthetic of that particular facade. I think that the sliding glass doors are something that if it had been requested for approval prior to having done it, they would not have received that. The question to me is, do we require return to what was there before? And are those, do we believe those to LAUREN VAGTS: be historic, what's shown on the top of your elevation drives? The 2018 Hickey states that they wer JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: re not historic, but staff has a different opinion. Okay, I guess to me, whether they're historic or not, the issue for me is primarily because it's not a primary facade. So the historic nature is not quite as critical as whether it's consistent with the design aesthetic of the subdivision. So I just don't know. Are there other administrations of this type with windows and a door and these large divided lights and this geometric pattern in this subdivision that we can point to as saying that's what this should have looked like? I think staff would have to LAUREN VAGTS: do further research to det JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: termine whether or not. Okay, yeah. And what about the door? Do you think that the door design is consistent with anything else in this subdivision, or is it completely new and unique and idiosyncratic? On the west elevation, on the primary ele LAUREN VAGTS: evation? I believe that's probably quite unique to the subd JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: division. Unique in the sense that there are no others in this subdivision with that. And what was the door LAUREN VAGTS: before? The door before, it looks like there was a screen door, and I'm not sure what ma JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: aterial. Okay, yeah. Do you know if there's any consistency in the doors on other structures in this LAUREN VAGTS: subdivision? I can't for the reason, 100%. Yeah. JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: Okay, th CECILIA RIOS: hanks. Lauren, would you comment? There's a wall, a short wall in th LAUREN VAGTS: he backyard. Yes. Is that co CECILIA RIOS: ontributing in reference to its historici LAUREN VAGTS: ity? The yard wall predates the house, and I don't recall the date. It's in the 2018 HICP, but it is designated as contributing as of 2018. CECILIA RIOS: And this application is not wanting to do anything to that? No, there's no proposed work for the yard wall. Any other questions? Ye JOHN BIENVENU: es, just a quick question. Is the south elevation listed as contributing, or I mean, significant, primary? Just the LAUREN VAGTS: west elevation is primary. Okay, thank you. I'm just going to ask JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: k one CECILIA RIOS: other question. The footprint of this house has not changed, correct? Correct. Thank you, Madam Chair. Just JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: t on that last point, I was thinking the same thing, but I would note that our code does require a certain type of window and door for every facade that is publicly visible. So regardless of whether it's primary, the primary facade issue would affect its historicity and whether or not it could be replaced rather than repaired. But this is where I was trying to, where I'm struggling a little bit because our code would normally say, if the applicant had come before us originally, we would say, well, anything, any facades that are publicly visible, not only the primary facade, need to conform in terms of the windows and doors to our code requirements. And our code requirement says they need to conform to the old Santa Fe style if they're publicly visible. But that doesn't seem to work in this particular subdivision. So it leaves us with, well, what is it supposed to conform to? And my answer would be it probably needs to conform to the design aesthetic of the entire division. I agree. I presume. Okay, Madam Chair, just in looking at the aerial photograph here, it indicates to me CECILIA RIOS: that the JOHN BIENVENU: south elevation is not publicly visible from the street. I think, and I also, I looked at the aerial and came to that conclusion. However, from the street view, y LAUREN VAGTS: you can see it. You can see on the left here that the south elevation is visible from the street. I don't know under what circumstances that the owners went forward and made these changes, but this is a good CECILIA RIOS: example of why it's important to come before this board to find out. You're living in a historic city. You're living in a historic area. I don't know. To me, it would make sense to delve into perhaps that your house might be historic or what you should do. Because if you come before the city and you come before this board, the city is wanting to work with you. So is this board. But when you do things on your own and things get, in Spanish, we say, you make a mess. So we'll go forward and listen to what the, and we still, we're in a position where we still have to work with the applicants, with the owners. So, who is the owner or applicants? Please come forward and get sworn in. Hi, please state your name and address for the record. Reem Edwards, 306 Bunnell Howland Road. Do you solemnly declare and affirm AMANDA ROMERO: the testimony you have in reference to this item is the truth, the whole truth, and do this under the penalties of perjury? Yes. Good evening. Thank you for hearing our case. I don't know if you had any questions, or you want to tell us, first of PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): f all, why you went forward? What is your position that you didn't go before the city, or yo CECILIA RIOS: ou just didn't know? No, I'm, it's not, I'm not a big person on excuses. We did start the process. There wasn't a lot of help from really t PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): the board or our HOA. So we, it's, we've sat on it for about a year, and we're going into our second year of owning the home. Both my wife and I are native New Mexicans, born and raised here. Her family's been here a long time, same with mine. I understand the significance of the historic area of what Santa Fe is. So it wasn't a matter of trying to subvert that. This is a mid-century modern area. We tried to make it as close to that as possible. If you actually go through the neighborhood, there's a hodgepodge of everything. And I know that in your 2018 meeting about making this particular building contributing, the staff recommended that it wasn't. I know the board noted that it was, but no one could determine exactly when the structure was built, what was in it. There was a question about the windows, the doors, all of that. That really has nothing to do with why we subverted the process. So we're here to make that correct. So we just want to know what you guys want us to do so we can get it done. And right now, you are wanting to paint the building? So we originally were looking within the palette of what you guys have under your historic, and CECILIA RIOS: d we had a miscommunication with the individual that d PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): did the stucco. So that's why it's brown. And the original one was orange for lack of a better word for it. But really, just whatever you guys tell us you want us to do, we just need to get this project completed. So we're not here to be combative. It's just more about how can we work with you guys now that we're here. Board members, do you have questions or comments? I do have, I'm going to ask member Simmons to comment on this. When a building is stucco CECILIA RIOS: oed such as this one, and then they want to paint it, is that a bit of a minus in terms of the longevity of the paint job? Madam Chair, that's a great question. The finish that's on the building right now is an elastomeric stucco, which is bre JOHN BIENVENU: eathable, where paint is not. This is a framed building. I would never advocate to paint a brick building. I would never recommend to put elastomeric stucco on an adobe building just simply because it'll trap water. Here, I don't believe that is as much of an issue. However, my personal opinion would be that the stucco should be restored back to its original texture. I could entertain a slight shift in color, but the predominant color of the buildings in this, on this block, are that kind of, I would use the term peach, kind of a peach color with the brocade texture. So when we're dealing with contributing buildings in Historic District that are altered over time, one of the big criteria that we like to look at is the integrity. We had a couple of very good examples in our last meeting where we had a very, very small building in a very terrible condition, maintained a lot of integrity. And yet, there was another project that had numerous additions over time that lost its integrity. This building, in my opinion, maintains a lot of integrity. The mullion pattern on the window is minor in my estimation. I also have a personal opinion about what our job is as board members here of balancing the rights of individuals in their property with the needs of the public. And when it comes to front doors, I think front doors are rather like jewelry and that it should be a personal, it could be a personal choice. I have less of a concern about changing the door, especially given that the door that's shown in the original photograph or the older, the Hickby photograph and the window patterning is not dissimilar. I don't have an objection to changing the door the way it would be. I would recommend that we entertain the idea that the stucco get restored back to its brocade text and a color more compatible with the neighborhood rather than an off-white. Thank you for your comments. Any other questions for the applicant? Anyone on the public wishing to come forward and comment on this partic CECILIA RIOS: cular case? Stephanie, you have been sworn. Stephanie Benonato. I took, I asked for a permit to take down part of a wall, 13 feet by 3 feet down. It took six months to get PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): that permit. I didn't say, gee, this is taking too long. I'm just going to go take down the part of the wall that I want to take down. So I know that it's frustrating to have to wait and try to work with the scheduling in both permitting and the historic application, but I don't really think that's a very good excuse. And I would suggest definitely that they restucco it in the somewhat original color with the brocade, that they replace the window on the west with the three-light window, and that on the sliding glass doors that they at least make them divided lights so that it has a somewhat similar feel to the very large glass divided lights that were there to begin with. And I think that these are rather small changes really on some level compared to just, well, who cares? We're just going forward even though we know that we should be waiting. Thank you. Thank you. Hi, please state your name and address for the record. Elizabeth West at 318 Selma Street. Do you solem CECILIA RIOS: mnly declare AMANDA ROMERO: e and affirm the testimony you have in reference to thi PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): is item as the truth, the whole truth AMANDA ROMERO: h, and to this under the penalties of perjury? Yes, I do. Thank you. Madam Chair, she has been sworn in. I would like to commend the people here who own this house and their willingness to comply with what you'r PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): re doing now. That's great, and that's a change, and I welcome that. I happen to agree right away in a pretty strong way about the windows that have three lights in them. I agree with member Simmons about that. I think it has a totally different look, and that was probably somebody's intention some time ago. And keeping that, I, so I agree that's important. The eccentricity of mid-century modern is really exemplified in this rather interesting building. And I believe we were told it was Philip Register design. Is that correct? Pardon? Yes. Okay. And I think that's worth something as far, part of Santa Fe's history. So, I, those are my comments to add to what you're working on. Thank you. Anyone else in this audience wishing to come forward in reference to this particular project? Yeah. Anyone online? CECILIA RIOS: Yes, sir Rios. I don't see any hands raised at this time. Thank you. Mr. Richard Martinez is coming forward. Pl CITY STAFF: lease state your name and address for the record. Richard CECILIA RIOS: Martinez, PO Box 925. Do you solemnly declare and aff AMANDA ROMERO: firm the testimony you have in reference to this item is the truth, t PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): the whole trut AMANDA ROMERO: th, and do this under the penalties of perjury? I do. Thank you. I believe that window in the front, it does look better as a three-bay window, but that's in front of... Tha PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): at's the only window of a bedroom, I think. And I believe that we have to... They have to comply with the egress size of a window for a bedroom. That may be why it went to a two-bay instead of a three-bay window. Okay. Thank you, Richard. Even though you did this without a permit, I do want to say something in reference CECILIA RIOS: to you buying this home and being Santa Feans and wanting to stay here in Santa Fe, which we don't see that very often. I've been on this board for a bit of a while, and that does not occur. I am sorry that you went through this process without a permit, but I'm happy that you have... That you're wanting to stay here in Santa Fe and that you're wanting to... You bought a home and you're trying to improve it for yourselves. So that being said, I will see what this board renders in terms of emotion. Is there... Can I just add one? I did... That is the reason why we went to the two-pane is because the three- PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): -pane didn't match egress. So it wouldn't have passed any... Even if we'd gotten approval from you guys, the city would have told us no, I assume, right, or they would have been okay with that? Madam Chair? Actually, the International Residential Code with existing windows, if they don't meet egress, they' JOHN BIENVENU: 're not required to be replaced to meet egress. However, when a window is removed and then a new window put in, then the code would require it to be an egress window. I'd like to also comment on Mr. Martinez's question about the three versus two, and then a couple others. What we're dealing with... Windows are always very difficult, and what we're dealing with is, we're looking at a replacement window. There is no photographic documentation of what the original windows look like. It's only conjecture, at best, that it would have been a three-paned window, as we look at the other windows in the neighborhood. It quite possibly was a three-unit window with two casements and a center fixed, but we just don't have that information. So with the idea that we, as a board, want to help the applicants here move forward with their project, I really don't think that the that the three versus two divisions is much of an issue. The fact that the window was replaced from a three-light to a two-light now brings in the International Residential Code, and then the code now will require that window to be at least an egress. I don't know that the window is... Could be reconfigured to the minimum egress standards. It's... I don't want to get into all the measurements and the requirements of the code for egress windows, but I think that the two-light window currently meets egress. And in my opinion, it's not such a huge infraction that I would support replacing the window back to a three-unit one simply because going backwards, it's already been replaced. The code now requires whatever was put in to be egress capable. Everything being said, I will make a motion. I can make a motion? Simon? In case 2026-013210-HDRB. CECILIA RIOS: . 124 Camino Santiago. move that we allow the JOHN BIENVENU: e windows as they have CECILIA RIOS: e been i JOHN BIENVENU: installed to remain. I would move that the stucco be restored back to its original texture and a reasonable facsimile of the original color. And then I would also move that we allow the applicant to use the door that they choose just simply because it's, to me, it's appropriate that they have a personal choice there. Is there a second to this motion? I'll second for purposes of seeking a friendly amendment, would be that the sliding glass doors on CECILIA RIOS: n the south facade be replaced wit JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: th doors or windows more closely matching what existed before the unauthorized work to be approved by staff. Well, no. I'm not sure I'm willing to accept that amendment just simply because the divided lights... I think staff said that th JOHN BIENVENU: hey were not original to the building, that somewhere along the line, those were replaced. 2018 Hickey says that they were not original. However, staff finds that to be in question whether or not they were historic o LAUREN VAGTS: or original. So what those windows were, when we purchased the home was they had enclosed what was like a patio. And it wasn't... It was just kin PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): nd of a makeshift, you know, two by four with some... I don't even know if they were actual windows that were in between it. So somebody just kind of enclosed that back area. So it wasn't weatherproof. It was actually... You had to go into another door inside the house to get into the house. So they just closed off the port hall that was there. Okay. Yeah. Given that testimony, I withdraw the friendly amendment request. Thank you. We will vote on the motion. There's a motion and a s JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: second, and we're going to have a roll call vote, please. Vice Chair B MARY ELLEN DEGNAN: Ben Benue. Y CECILIA RIOS: Yes. Member Degnan. Yes. Member Simmons. Yes. The motion has passed. Thank you. And the last case this evening is located at 704 Camino Lejo. This i AMANDA ROMERO: is the Wheelwright Museum. And Lanny, this is your case? Oka CECILIA RIOS: ay. This is case 2026013296HDRB for the Wheelwright Museum at 704 Camino Lejo. Camino Lejo is a juniper-covered rise, whi CITY STAFF: ich slopes gently to the north and steeply to the southeast and west. Known as Museum Hill, the area houses the Wheelwright Museum, International Folk Art Museum, and Botanical Gardens, as well as residences to the West. Constructed in 1937 and designed by William Penhallow Henderson, the Wheelwright Museum of the American Indian at 704 Camino Lejo was an original... Was originally modeled after Navajo Hogan. It is distinctive within Santa Fe. It is associated with important local and regional persons, including the institution's founders, Mary Cabot Wheelwright and Hastin Claw, a Navajo medicine man, singer, and weaver. The site was donated by Amelia White to assemble, preserve, and study articles and recordings of the Navajo religion that Claw and other Navajo people consented to share for the study and preservation of the practice of the Navajo religion. The museum was placed on the New Mexico State Register of Cultural Properties on 10/05/1990 and on the National Register of Historic Places on 12/18/1990. The property is located within the Historic Review Historic District and is designated as significant with the understanding that the 1997 and 2014 additions are not historic. The significant status is due to its unique architectural character, date of construction, association with William Penhall Henderson, and its long-standing contribution to the Santa Fe community as an educational institution representing the Native American. The original building remained unchanged until 1968 when the rear west stairwell and public restroom facilities were added. In 1997, a 668 square foot addition was constructed to the rear of the 1968 addition. During the status review in 1997, it was noted that the 1968 edition was not historic. This edition has since aged so that it is considered historic now. In 2014, a 4,363 square foot addition was connected to the 1997 addition. It was determined during the hearing for the 2014 addition under case H1297B that though the addition was greater than 50% of the historic footprint and higher than the maximum allowable height, it did not detract from the original historic integrity of the building. This was in part due to the connection to the non-historic addition and in part due to its location going down the hill to the west and south. The applicant tonight proposes to construct a 2,060 gross square foot addition to a height of 22 feet where the maximum allowable height is 16 feet on a sloped site. The new roofed area will be 1,030 square feet in each of the two stories, and a 324 square foot portal will be constructed at the top of the slope on the north and east sides of the addition. They're requesting exceptions to 14-4.6E22B for constructing an addition on a primary facade as well as within 10 feet of another primary facade and 14-4.6E22C for exceeding 50% of the historic footprint, and a request for additional height is requested under the provision of section 14-4.6F22F. And the applicant has provided the exception criteria or the height as well just to add for clarification. The addition will step down the slope, so the overall height of the structure from the bottom of the slope is 22 feet. The overall height of the previous non-historic conditions is stepped up so that the parapets are found at 15 feet and then some at 25 feet from the bottom of the slope. The original historic structure stands at 25 feet on top of the hill. All of the additions are lower than the full height of the Hogan portion of the structure because of the step down in the slopes. The maximum allowable height is 16 feet, and so we've requested that exception for the height. The 1,030 square foot addition will encompass the 1968 addition and connects to the 2014 addition. The addition is on the historic 1968 facades and within 10 feet of the historic Hogan structure. The new addition will house an L-shaped 324 square foot entry port hall to a height of 11 feet. The port hall is within 10 feet of the primary facade of the original Hogan structure. The original historic structure is 1,570 square feet, and the historic 1968 edition was 270 square feet for a total historic footprint of 1,840 square feet. The existing non-historic additions are from 1997 at 668 square feet and 2014 addition at 4,363 square feet. The new addition at 1,354 square feet will create a total of 6,385 square feet of non-historic additions. The total non-historic additions will be at 347% of the historic structure footprint. Therefore, we've asked for the exception to exceed the 50%. The new addition will be constructed with a flat roof of parapets in recent Santa Fe style to match the design of the 1997 and 2014 additions. The corners of the edition will be at two-inch radius to match the radius of the 2014 edition. The insets of the windows and doors will also match that, the insets from the 2014 edition. And windows and doors will be anodized aluminum to match the 2014 edition. The stucco would be cementitious buckskin in a floated sand finish to match the existing stucco. Portal columns will be 10-inch sealed fir, or tall floor will be brick to match the existing terrace. The proposed construction minimizes the impact on the significant status of the building and preserves the original Hogan structure. So, therefore, staff finds that the addition would not alter the landmark status, though staff finds that the portal in addition should be decreased in size to further mitigate the impact on the structure. Okay. So this is the north elevation. The addition will be in the same location as the existing main entrance to the building, and we'll have a portal attached to the front and eastern side. This is the location of the 1968 addition. So this little door here. And then this is the west elevation, which shows where the addition steps down the slope of the property and joins to the 2014 addition. The south elevation is not impacted by the proposed addition. The 2014 addition in this photo is to the left of the screen in the lighter color. The original structure is the darker color. The east elevation here shows what is visible from standing at the lower level as well as being on the upper level since the entrance to the original structure is on the roof, the lower portion of the structure. To assist with further clarification, the applicant will be providing some renderings as part of their presentation. So the staff finds that the exception criteria to section 14-4.6 E22B for constructing an addition on a primary facade and within 10 feet of the primary facade have been met and recommends approval of the exception with the condition that the portal size be decreased to minimize the impact on the Hogan portion of the structure. Staff finds that the exception criteria to section 14-4.6 E22C for exceeding 50% of the historic footprint have not been met and recommends denial of the exception for the size of the addition in portion. Staff finds that the exception criteria to section 14-4.6 F2 for exceeding the maximum allowable height have been met and recommends approval of the exception for the height of the addition. Otherwise, we would recommend approval of the other elements of the application as they comply with 14-4.6 E general design standards and 14-4.6 G3 for historic review, historic district design standards. Thank you, Bonnie, for your report. So you were staff's indicating that the portal should be decreased. Is that correct? Yes, ma'am. And CECILIA RIOS: d also, the building itself should be decreased. So... Right. If you look at the site plan, oh, this roof plan shows it because it's so well shaded, but the portal is actually reall CITY STAFF: ly deep. It's about 11 feet deep, and it's within one foot of that Hogan. So staff would like to see that pulled in so that it's a smaller portal. We don't mind the L going around, but we would like it as small as possible so that it's not quite as close to the Hogan. The questions are coming. Mr. Simmons. Thank you, Madam Chair. Lani, could you clarify something for me? First of all, in the sub CECILIA RIOS: bmittal, it shows the second, the first ad JOHN BIENVENU: ddition to the principal, the original structure was done in 1966. In your presentation, you've said it was in 1968. That's neither here nor there. You mentioned, though, that the 1966 addition is historic? It is now. Yes. It is now. Has that gone through? You do. Okay. I want to go on record about something here. 50 years does not automatically make a building historic. 50 years is simply the minimum threshold that a building has to cross for it to even be considered for other reasons to be historic. It does not automatically confer the historic designation. It really has to go through a process, and we have several processes in this city to do that. And I want to make that clear because we've had a couple of other instances where we've had presentations where something, now a building has, now meets the 50-year criteria, but that, and it was the case we had last time, the case up at, on, I think it was 1545 Canyon Road, where the street-facing portal now met the 50-year rule. However, we ruled on that project that the integrity of that house, that structure was so lost that the original building was not. So I just want to make sure that, if it is part of the landmark designation, then that's one thing. If it's just simply a staff statement that it's now historic due to its age, that's incorrect. It is what our mark for being historic is 50 years. It is over 50 years of age. It is historic. However, it's part of the designation as a significant building. In 1990, when this was designat CITY STAFF: ted as a significant building, 1966 was not 50 years of age yet, and it was noted in the significant designation that it was not historic yet. Well, it's still not historic. It is. It's over 50. Yep. Thank you, Madam Chair. Just for clarification on this, I think it's just really a question of the implication of the terms here JOHN BIENVENU: e. When staff uses the term hist JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: toric, they don't mean that it has any particular status for protection purposes. It's literally just a description that it is 50 years or older, which is literally defined in our code as what a historic structure is, something 50 years or older. But that, there's no protection for that automatically unless it's designated as contributing or significant. That's the way our code works. It's one of the correct. It's just a definitional issue. Staff's not suggesting that it necessarily receives protection just because it's 50 years or older. It's just historic under the definition of our code. Other things that contribute to the, to its definition. Right. Does this contribute to the? That's just the threshold. Yeah. Are there a few changes? Well, I think that we all know the definition. CECILIA RIOS: We're all familiar with. So that's one of numerous. So that is one of them. Yes. Member Dickman. Thank you, Madam Chair. I would just like to throw in my opinion here. What I've always thought about is a point of departure is a place to start. It JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: t has to be 50 years old. It doesn't make it historic. That's all. Mhm. It does make it historic. It just doesn't. The code literally defines a historic structure as a structure that's 50 years old, 50 years or older. Literally, definition in our code adopted JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: by the governing body. Any other questions or problem? No. Applicant or applicants, will you come forward to get sworn in, please? Well, she's getting you set up there to. Sandro contractor, 924 supervisor CECILIA RIOS: r. Do you solemnly declare and affirm the testimony you have in reference to this item as the truth, the wh AMANDA ROMERO: hole truth, and do this under the penalti MARY ELLEN DEGNAN: ies of perjury? I do. Thank you. AMANDA ROMERO: . I am used to a Mac. Bear with me for a sec. We'll go to the screen. Speaking, Chair Rios and members of the board, we appreciate the service you provide our community, and MARY ELLEN DEGNAN: d it is our pleasure and honor to present to you this evening our proposed improvements to the Wheelwright Museum of the American Indian. This is a unique and historic building originally constructed in 1937 as depicted in this photograph by Ernest Knee. Our proposed modest addition has evolved out of our profound respect of the significance of this front. This historic photograph of the original claw interior gallery interior shows the two stairs that enter the gallery from below, which we will speak of more later in this presentation. You can kind of see them on both these sides, right? Wheelwright Museum of the American Indian was the first museum constructed on what's now known as Museum Hill. The Museum of International Folk Arts sits immediately to the north property, which is accessed off Camino Lejo know some of this is a repeat of what Lani went through, but I'll try to go through it quickly. An aerial photograph of the site plan overlay that describes the disposition of the various buildings on the Wheelwright property. We'll be looking at the building that's circled. This is the timeline that you saw earlier in Lani's presentation, the different phases of the project. These are some drawings that we found of the original cloth structure. It shows the entry. You come in through these doors. You go down, immediately go down the stairs. So there are a bunch of code violations there. You come back up and you enter into the file gallery. There was no direct connection from this entry into the gallery. In 1966, the addition added a staircase and then on the lower level, a bathroom. It also allowed for a future Case Trading Post to move into the downstairs area. There's a nice relationship that it created between the Case Trading Post and the staircase. What it did, though, was open up this entry vestibule so that access was through log gallery. Later additions were the elevator and the storage. This is the 2014 addition, which created some more gallery spaces and curatorial and community spaces and public bathrooms downstairs. This photograph shows, it depicts how separated the Wheelwright Museum is from the streetscape along Camino Lejo. All the image on the lower right-hand corner says the inherent wayfinding issue associated with finding the front door to the museum. This is the current disposition. We'll, I'll show you in the next slide what you, we didn't go into the building or you didn't go into the building today. But this is the current disposition parts. The entry to the north is, like, this piece right here is actually an emergency egress door. Essentially, the claw is one of the finest and extraordinary spaces in the city, and it now functions as a lobby and circulation spine for the rest of the museum. This is problematic on many levels as the interior of the claw and any art hung in the space is subjected to extreme climate fluctuations. So what the owner has done in order to continue having art shows and maintaining their programmatic needs is they've constructed a temporary entry vestibule on the north side, shut off the primary doors on the east side, and this is the current pattern of circulation. As the Wheelwright Museum of the American Indian envisions its role within our community and its mission, the museum has implemented several temporary and essential changes to the building. These include moving the front entry from the east side to the north by adding the temporary vestibule that was in the previous slide. This has allowed the museum to use the claw gallery for more extensive and culturally significant shows and participate in the Site Santa Fe Biennial. The proposed improvements that we're presenting to you today are an attempt to formalize and dignify what is necessary and compelling for the museum to do while also replacing the antiquated elevator from the 1997 addition, which is no longer serviceable. Design also relocates public stair where it was post during the 1966. But we're adding us the relocating stair here. It came down from. So they can be, all the primary circulation happens within this core, and the gallery spaces at the center of the building open up. This has tremendous benefit to the owner from a programming, security, and climate control perspective. This is the current plan configuration downstairs. You can kind of see how labyrinthian is. The pathway is move art from the art storage building via an underground tunnel through the Case Trading Post around obstructions upstairs and through a small tiny elevator. Our proposed addition clarifying open up the Case Trading Post so that it's easily visible when you come down the staircase. It also allows for future, thinking of future phases for the museum. This would be an easy connection that allows them to take it directly in and access the elevator without having to go through the trading post. This is a statement of our building areas. We are in general compliance with zoning. We have our PRZ. This is the addition from the north elevation. We see this, this addition, the portal addition. It's fairly minimal in nature. It's porous. And see it from the side right here for Powell. This is the addition. The height of the addition is set by the elevator overrun, which is what had set the previous 1966 addition height. It's not perceptible from this side of the building. You can see it here. What I want to emphasize as we look at this slide is, one of the images that was in the previous presentation was a study we did on shortening the portal. We want this building to be as minimal as possible, but it also needs to meet the needs of the user. The inability of the museum to have shows they need to show their incredible collection. We upgrade the project is essential to viability of the institution. An entry off of the north side, which we did study, is not appropriate to this museum. Entry has to be on the east side. It's where the original entry was. It has a ritualistic significance. And what you see in this rendering is the. what the shadow would look like on the summer solstice. Kinda tuck it back in so that it's a protected area off the side of the building. The programming that the Wheelwright hosts engages in includes events outside. This connection between this portal and this terrace will be an essential, important feature for the building and for the institution. You can kinda, you can see this is a photograph taken earlier today, actually, from the same perspective and see how the trees obstruct part of the part of the claw right there. Just an image of what the new addition would look like. And our intention here is to celebrate the claw. The, what we're trying to do right here is the, I mean, parking is to the north. And so we're trying to create an entryway that connects within a crossing, that connects to the main plaza and providing the entry on the east side of the building where the way in which we pulled the portal back from the claw allows light to penetrate that piece so that it creates a point of desire, the sensuous nature, the claw structure, something that guides for a sense of wayfinding and a desire. That's what that entry looks like right now. Our, this rendering, we don't have landscaping put in. We've just been showing you the masking of the building. We will be obviously landscaping it. We want to minimize the number of trees we take out. But having this many trees that close to a wood, historic wood structure, is problematic for us as well. It's not best practices, based on what the fire marshal tells us. I want to go back to this slide. It's important to understand what the potential of this building can be once the entry has been moved. This is a tremendous, it's a historic gallery space that needs to be celebrated that way. It needs to be restored as a gallery, not as kind of a lobby vestibule, all circulation space. And that's the essence of our, of our proposal. Happy to take questions. First of all, I want to thank you for your very thorough presentation. I think that when you come before the board, you alway CECILIA RIOS: ys give a very thorough presentation. I thank you for that. I would like to know what your comments are in reference to staff's recommendations. No. The, it boils, it boils down to all our exceptions boiled down to one thing, hardship. The, this addition will re MARY ELLEN DEGNAN: eally alleviate a lot of hardships that our client has. In order for them to have the shows they need to have, to participate in the community, to do the things they need to be doing, this addition becomes essential. So I can, we've, in our, in the report, staff report, our written responses to all three criteria are written, are expressed, and I'm happy to read through those. But essentially, I'll, you know, I can give you the brief answer. Thank you. Member Siman. Devinder, staff had suggested that the size of the portal be pulled to the west, the east side of the portal. I'd like CECILIA RIOS: e to hear your, In doing JOHN BIENVENU: g that, we reduced our ability to have an overhang protection at the vestibule point. It becomes an unprotected entryway, which we d MARY ELLEN DEGNAN: don't recommend for this type of building. It, it allows, and we want that entryway to be glass sliders as, as was in the earlier report that was read. And, you know, I think there's good reason why glass is put under an overhang, tucked back in there for a number of reasons. Some of them are how it looks, but it's also, it's best ecological practices. It just wouldn't function as well. I mean, we, we'd be forced to use the north as a primary entry, which then defeats the purpose of connecting the, the plaza to the east and, and making the strong connection. We did study it. We went through a number of different studies. Sure. Thank you. Any other questions or comments? Thank you, madam. Thank you for the presentation. But, yeah, just following up on that last one. And my understandi CECILIA RIOS: ing of staff's recommendation is t JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: that they agree with everything, but they would like to see the portal size be decreased, not eliminated. So most of the hardship you've described really just relates to the entire project, which staff seems to already be recommending approval for. So what, I'm just curious what discussions went on between you and staff about what they would have accepted as something that they would have recommended. Understand that, I assume that there still would have been a portal. They're just asking for it to be decreased in size. So, so can you address that and maybe staff could as well? No. But you can go ahead. No. The, the conversations working, you pull it back so it doesn't obscure the claw. In our mind, in, from our perspective and our client's p MARY ELLEN DEGNAN: perspective, the portal is a permeable element. It's not really obstructing it. What we're doing is allowing, the entire proposal is to allow the car to stand proud and to be legible. And so, you know, if we pull the portal back, the vestibule stops working as well. If we push the vestibule into the lobby space, the needs of what happens in a museum have a tiny abbreviated lobby space. We're trying to keep this as small as possible, for a number of reasons. Okay. Could I, could I have staff address that question? Seth Lenny, can you come forward? So the question really is what would hav JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: ve been acceptable to staff? I'm sure you had multiple discussions on this point. But I understand from your presentation and the staff report that really you were only disagreeing with the size of the portal and the location of it. Correct. And everything else you were recommending approval for. So what would have been acceptable in your mind for the portal? Well, we, we wanted as small as possible, but still capable of serving the building as it needs to be. Right now, it sits CITY STAFF: s within a foot of the claw structure, and we would see it pull up. How much? I don't think we came up with a square, like, depth. But, you know, if we could even go half the depth that it is currently, I think it would still serve its purpose. Okay. Would, and that's not, would not be acceptable to the applicant? I mean, it's, let me tell you what's that. S JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: See, we have sliding doors here. I think doors work really well for museum CECILIA RIOS: ms because people do MARY ELLEN DEGNAN: har CECILIA RIOS: rdware, in which MARY ELLEN DEGNAN: h people use the doors. We just, on most of our museum projects, we're having to replace inch doors with sliders. Yeah. You can kinda see this is the extent of it right here. And, you know, sure, we could pull it in six, eight, 12 inches, maybe. You don't want to reduce the size of the doors. You know, certainly, they could be breakaway doors, so they still need to be grasped. But we'd like them to be at least three feet plus wide. You bring the portal in on this face. Right now it's 11 foot eight. Remember we could bring that in a couple of feet so that it doesn't, well, like this alignment right here, we want to capture this angle of light. But we're open to moving this, abbreviating the overhang on, on the east sides at several feet, but not more. Yeah. Thank you. That's what I was trying to understand. Can you give us the d JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: dimensions of the, of the portal as you have, as you are recommending in terms of its d CECILIA RIOS: depth and its height? Right now, the portal stands 11 feet tall. And on the north side, it is six foot nine. And on this, on the east side, MARY ELLEN DEGNAN: , it's 11. We'd be, we couldn't abbreviate it on the east side to eight feet use. But, you know, we, we'll take as much portal depth as possible in the, the events that they, the Wheelwright hosts, the artists that they host. You know, we have folks from the Wheelwright here that'd be glad to talk to you about that. This will be used, appreciated, and it's, it's highly functional. So we don't want to give it up. Just, we, we want to talk to you about it and be reasonable. Very divisive. Lanny, you also indicated you wanted the building itself to be reduced in size. Is that corr CECILIA RIOS: rect? It's more the portal than the building itself. More the portal? You were focusing on the portal? Yes. T CITY STAFF: Thank you. Board members? No questions? No othe CECILIA RIOS: er questions at this? I will open it to the public. If you're interested in, in giving a comment, please come forward. You will get, you will need to get sworn in. This light up? You have to speak in the microphone. Okay. Karen. Please state your name and address for the reco AMANDA ROMERO: ord. Karen Crew, 1491 Camino Corrals. Do you solemnly declare and affirm the testimony you have in reference to thi PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): is item is the tr AMANDA ROMERO: ruth, the whole truth, and do this under the penalties of perjury? I do. Thank you. Good evening. I'm Karen Crow. I live directly across the street. Yeah. I'm gonna inter PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): rrupt you. I think that, I don't know if you're not speaking righ CECILIA RIOS: ht into that mic. Okay. Let, let me just start again. I'm Karen Crow. I live directly across from the Wh PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): heelwright, and I'm here to express my enthusiastic support for the proposed, new entryway. The Wheelwright has been wonderful neighbors. We feel very fortunate to live across from the oldest private museum in New Mexico, and we very much appreciate the significance of having such an important cultural institution in our neighborhood. The Wheelwright really is one of the Santa Fe's gems. It's deeply connected to the native communities, respected and supported nationally, and brings a very distinctive and important perspective to the Santa Fe's cultural landscape. We think that the proposed entryway is a thoughtful improvement that accomplishes three objectives. It respects the aesthetic and cultural integrity of the existing museum. The design honors what makes the Wheelwright such a special place. Second, it makes the museum more welcoming and functional. It creates a clear intuitive entrance for first-time visitors and provides an appropriate space for gathering and receptions without having to use the gallery space where food and beverages can be problematic. And third, the project is fully funded by private donors, which demonstrates the strength of the museum's support and commitment to the future. As neighbors, we see this proposal as a wonderful example of how a treasured historic institution can evolve while preserving the qualities that make it so special. We wholeheartedly support the proposal and encourage the board to approve it. Thank you. Thank you for your comments. Next. Elizabeth West again. I appreciat CECILIA RIOS: te the, PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): , the, designer, the architect's decision or acceptance of willingness to go along with a bit of a compromise, in relation to what staff has recommended. I too agree that this is, in some ways, gonna make things more inviting for the public, and I'm particularly interested in what I think I understand about the importance of an East entry. I'm not Native American, and I, I'm not up on my, ethnological background about that. But I think it, it's an improvement. I like what, what is being proposed, and I do hope you can make a compromise that makes sense to me as a layperson speaking. Thank you. There, members of the board. My name is Stuart Ashman. Stuart, I need to swear you AMANDA ROMERO: u in. Yep. Please state your name and address for the record. My name is Stuart Ashman PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): n. I live at 10 Angelitos Road, NFV 87506. Do you solemnly declar AMANDA ROMERO: re and affirm the testimony you have in reference to this item is the truth, the whole truth, and do this under the penalties of perjury? I do. Thank you. Madam chair, memb PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): bers of the board, thank you for giving me an opportunity to speak. I served as secretary of cultural affairs under Governor Richardson for his terms and really became really familiar with historic preservation. And one of the main issues that we encountered was not trying to duplicate the historic. I think this project really respects, the original building while creating a contrast between the old and the new in the way that when we built the history museum, we didn't infringe on the Palace of the Governors. And what happened was that the Palace of the Governors becomes an even more important artifact because we have this other new history museum next door. The Wheelwright is going to be 90 years old next year. It's an incredible institution for New Mexico and really for the world. And Devendra is the most respectful architect for this project. I think 50 years from now, we won't be here. Some of us won't be here. I certainly won't. But Santa Fe will look back at the architects that contributed to Santa Fe. And those will be John Gaw Meem, Antoine Predock, the Rapp brothers, and Devendra Contractor. So thank you, and I hope you can approve this. One more thing. We're talking about 84 square feet of portal. 84 square feet. Think about that, how small that is. I mean, it could have been much bigger, but it's not. So thank you again for giving me the opportunity. M CECILIA RIOS: Mr. Ashwin, thank you for your comments. Pl AMANDA ROMERO: lease raise your right hand. State your name and address for the record. Lesl PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): lie, 100 Avenida Malaguenas in New Mexico. D AMANDA ROMERO: Do you solemnly declare and affirm the testimony you have in reference to this item is the truth, the whole truth, and to this under the penalties of perjury? Thank y PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): you. Hi, my name is Jenny Lasley. I'm chair of the Board of Trustees at the Wheelwright, and I wanted to give you some additional context to our request. In 2024, the museum signed a gift agreement with a longtime friend of the Wheelwright, Charlotte and Midler. And this gift, which is going to create new exhibit space on the lower level of the museum, provided us opportunity to review the overall design of the building and plan for the addition of a proper entryway into the museum, one that provides a much better visitor experience. It's important to understand that the museum's original exhibit space, as you've heard, created almost 90 years ago, was only a single gallery with 1,600 square feet. Today, we have five galleries and 5,300 square feet, a 330% increase. But what we lack, what most other museums in Santa Fe have, is a permanent entrance into the museum that is separate from the main gallery exhibits. Also, one that includes a portal, which we believe is rightly sized, a visitor reception area, restrooms, and coat closet. BNCA's design of the new entrance ideally meets these needs for us while also paying respect to Navajo traditions in having an east-facing entryway. We believe this design is a very modest one architecturally, but it will certainly enhance visitor experience, so I encourage your CECILIA RIOS: approval of our requ AMANDA ROMERO: uest. Thank you very much. Please state your name and address for the record. Ramon Sarazon, 2942. Thank you, Ramon. Do you solemnly declare and affirm the testimony you have in reference to this item is the truth, the whole truth, and do this under the penalties PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): s of perjury? I do. Thank you, sir. Good evening, Madam Chair and members of the board. I'm happy to be here. I'm grateful to be here to wholeheartedly put my support behind the de CECILIA RIOS: esign as pro PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): oposed. Thank you very much. Thank you. Stephanie Beninato. The Wheelwright Museum has been one of my favorite museums since I came here in 1975. And it is true that when you had to enter into the Claw Gallery, that it was congested, and I can understand the need for a new entrance. And when they had another entry on the sort of north side, I guess it is, it was never really very visible. So I think that this entry will improve people finding and coming into the museum. I appreciate that they are observing the Diné tradition of having an east opening, rather than north or south or whatever. I do feel that it's a very large space, that it will hopefully never have to increase, and that it will allow receptions without being in the galleries. I do, however, think that the portal could be decreased. And I don't think that pulling it in, even if it's 11'9", pulling it into 6'9", being symmetrical with the other side of the portal, that would really decrease the use of that portal or its efficiency in protecting those doors. And although they may use it sometimes when they do have outdoor activities, it goes way beyond the CECILIA RIOS: portal anyway. Thank you. Anyone else PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): in this room come forward? Good AMANDA ROMERO: evening. I'm Nancy Steedman. Hi, Nancy. Will you please state, do you solemnly swear and affirm that the testimony you have in reference to this item is the truth, the whole truth, and do PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): o this under the penalties of perjury? I do. Yes. And I just need you to state your address for me. It's 37 Calle Cantando here in Santa Fe. Thank you. I am the Interim Executive Director at the Wheelwright Museum and have the privilege of working with Devendra on this. I am here obviously to support our original design. We worked very hard with Devendra to come up with this. I think if you see where he actually ended the portal, it is exactly at that angle where the building changes. And I think even a compromise in pulling that back is going to cut off into that section of wall. It is transparent. You can see right through it, and it really plays to having an entryway that I think the Wheelwright is worthy of. We're trying to respect that east entry that is the doorway that we can no longer use. We discovered when we were doing the renovation to the plaza in early 2025 that we were trying to make the doors more secure. They're heavy. If you've ever tried to come in that entranceway, they would swing. They were just a hazard to people coming in and walking into the main gallery rather than having a lobby way. So it was a security issue. It's an environmental issue. We have a big exhibit getting ready to open, and we are not able to have some works of art that we can't confirm have climate control and environmentally controlled. So that is what a new entryway will be able to do for us. And we do have many more donor events. We have really broadened our interaction with the community. We can't have any events in the gallery spaces where we have artwork, and we can't do any reception, food and drink, anything else that goes with that. So I ask you to look at, really look at how Devendra and his team designed the original portal. If it was up to me, I would double the size of this portal. I think that we could really use the space, but we've tried to be respectful and only request a small variance. So thank you for listening to me. No problem. Yes. No problem. My name is Henriette CECILIA RIOS: e Litchi, and I live 42 Alond PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): dra Road in Santa Fe. Do you solemnly declare and affirm the testimo AMANDA ROMERO: ony you have in reference to this item as the truth, the whole truth, and to this under the penalties of perjury? I do. Thank you. So I'm speaking to you here as the forme PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): er Executive Director of the Wheelwright Museum. And I just want to say that this development that we're speaking about today solves three major issues. So the major issue is entry and orientation of our visitors. Another issue is conformity to ADA so that it allows people a much clearer sense of entryway. It gives great access to an elevator, and it also allows easy ingress into the museum. As my colleague has just said, we have in the past had problems with control of temperature and humidity to do with the east-facing door, the original door. And the door is subject to fluctuations to do with temperature or humidity. So the portal is respecting the original intention of the institution. It respects the architecture. It provides a much clearer sense of the entryway of the institution, and it allows the institution to conform to 21st-century requirements as regards museums. Thank you. Anyone else in this room wishing to come forward at this moment to spe CECILIA RIOS: eak on this project? We heard from a lot of you. Thank you for those comments. Anyone online? Yes, thank you, Chair Rios. I do see a few hands up, so I will all CITY STAFF: low you to talk. Please state your name and be sworn in before you provide your public comment. Thank you. And this is Danielle Means. Miss Danielle, can you unmute yourself? There you go. Danielle Means, 13 Reads Peak. Do you solemnly declare AMANDA ROMERO: e and affirm th PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): he testimony you have in refer AMANDA ROMERO: rence to this item is the truth, the whole truth, and do this under the penalties of perjury? I do. Thank you. Good evening, Chairwoman Rios and board members. I'm Dan PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): nielle Means, a proud member of the Oglala Lakota Nation and Executive Director of the Museum of Indian Arts and Culture. I'm here as a colleague and neighbor on Museum Hill to express my support for the Wheelwright's proposed entrance. The Wheelwright has a significant history of connection with Native communities. Its founding grew from friendship and shared purpose of Mary Cabot Wheelwright and Hastiin Klah, a Diné ceremonial practitioner and weaver. That relationship is a part of the museum's foundation and reflects the importance of listening, learning, and building relationships across generations. At MIAC, we value our relationships with our Museum Hill neighbors. Working alongside institutions with distinct histories and missions makes this a richer place for visitors and strengthens the cultural community we share. We want each museum to have the spaces it needs to welcome people and carry out its work. A thoughtful entrance is an important part of that welcome. I support the Wheelwright's proposal as an investment in the museum's future and its ability to continue serving Native communities and the public. I encourage you to support it as well. Thank you for allowing me to speak. Thank you very much. Okay, CECILIA RIOS: , thank you, Chair. W CITY STAFF: We have Joseph Aguilar. There we go. Thank you. Good evening, Madam Chai PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): ir and board members. Thank you for the opportunity to speak in support of the proposed entrance and portal at the Wheelw AMANDA ROMERO: wright. Can you please state your name and address for the record and be sworn in? Sure. Joseph Aguilar, 24 Battl PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): leship View Road, Santa Fe, New Mexico 87506. Thank AMANDA ROMERO: you, Joseph. Do you solemnly declare and affirm the testimony you have in reference to this item is the truth, the whole truth, and do this under the penalties of perjury? I do. Thank you. You may proceed. PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): Again, I'm Joseph Aguilar from San Ildefonso Pueblo, and I'm a current board member at the Wheelwright Museum. So obviously, the Wheelwright Museum is a pretty remarkable example of architecture inspired by Navajo cultural and ceremonial traditions. And although its design evokes a traditional Navajo hogan, we have to remind ourselves that it's a secular museum, not a ceremonial building. Its architecture pays homage to Navajo traditions while serving a public and educational purpose. The proposed east-facing entrance continues that architectural tradition, acknowledging the significance of eastern orientation in Navajo culture while making the museum more accessible and welcoming to visitors. So I understand the board's concern that the proposed portal might obscure the original hogan-inspired building, but I believe the design preserves the building's distinctive form, roofline, and architectural identity. So what concerns me now listening to the discussion here is that the discussion now seems to center on reducing the portal's dimensions by a matter of feet rather than identifying any meaningful impact on the historic structure. If reducing the portal by a matter of a few feet does not materially improve the visibility or preservation of the original building, what exactly is gained by that reduction? Historic preservation should be guided by architectural principles and demonstrable impacts, not by negotiating dimensions simply to arrive at a compromise. A smaller portal is not necessarily a better portal. Its proportions, relationships to the original building, and ability to provide a welcome public entrance are all important considerations. The appropriate measure of this proposal is not how much smaller we can make the portal, but how well it respects the historic architecture. The Wheelwright was conceived as an architectural interpretation of Navajo tradition. This addition continues that approach while allowing the museum to better serve the public. I respectfully ask the board to evaluate the design on its architectural merits and actual impact on the historic building and to approve the portal CECILIA RIOS: as proposed. Thank you. Thank yo CITY STAFF: ou very much. Anyone else? Yes, Chair Rios. We have Natalie. And again, Natalie, please state your name and address and be sworn i PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): in before your testimony. My name is Natalie Fitzgerald. I live at 10 AMANDA ROMERO: 005 East Alameda, Santa Fe. Do you solemnly declare and affirm the testimony you have in reference to this item as the truth, the whole truth, and do this u PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): under AMANDA ROMERO: the penalti PUBLIC COMMENTER (STEPHANIE BENONATO): ies of perjury? I do. Thank you. I thank you for the opportunity to give you my ideas. As a board member and longtime Santa Fean, I appreciate the significance of having the oldest private museum in the state located on Museum Hill. The museum contributes a distinct perspective to the cultural landscape of Santa Fe, and I'm grateful for all that it brings to the city and Museum Hill. Following the museum's expansion in 2015, visitorship has increased, for which we are very grateful. The proposed new entry will fix so many things with which the museum has struggled since then. Donor appreciation events are currently limited because there's no space to accommodate these gatherings. Likewise, special member exhibit viewings are curtailed because of lack of space. A museum cannot use gallery space for gatherings. Refreshments do not play well with art. The proposed entry expansion as designed by DNC Architects will give the visitor a clear place to start their visit to the museum and bestow on the Wheelwright an entryway worthy of this institution. To diminish the size of the space will not be beneficial. The historic significance of the Navajo Hogan design is not jeopardized in any way with the design presented. The beautiful plaza and original William Penhallow Henderson 1937 entry with the magnificent doors remain unobstructed. I would just like to say that Mary Cabot Wheelwright and Huston Clark and Frances Newcomb and William Penhallow Henderson were prescient in their, in what they did at the time. This is in 1937 that they built a modernist architecture that was inspired by Adinae Hogan. And I think Nancy brought up a very good point when she said if you m CITY STAFF: move... Thank you very much for your comments. Thank you. Yes, to CECILIA RIOS: Rios. I see no other hands raised for public comment online. Board members, if nothing's ordered, it appears that the one will be ther JOHN BIENVENU: re. That's it. No. I have a motion. Oh, oh, you have something? Yeah. I would like to make a comment first before a motion. I would like to contest staff's recommendation to reduce the size of the portal, in that I believe that it was somewhat of a knee-jerk response to how the architects have designed this entry. The perspective rendering that Davinder showed that shows the shadowing and the light coming into that little triangular space, I think, is an extremely skillful architectural maneuver. And I do not believe at all that the roof of the portal compromises in any way the visual integrity of the original building. It is my opinion that it is, we're off on kind of a wild goose chase looking for sort of the medium place where the fewest number of people are going to object. I know there's been a few objections to the portal, and few people have recommended that be shortened, but I am not in agreement with that. I believe that the architectural maneuver that the architects have done actually is going to improve and enhance the quality of the original building, and I think that the, CECILIA RIOS: , I think that this proposal should be accepted as it has been su JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: ubmitted. Thank you. There are comments. I will entertain a motion. Mister... Thank you, Madam Chair. So, yeah, I'm generally in agreement with those comments. So just to add to that, that I very much respect staff's concern over this significant building, and I think their instincts are all correct to try to avoid it being overwhelmed by new additions. My perspective is that's, it's already a little too late for that. This original Henderson Building is a bit overwhelmed already by the many large additions that have already taken place, and I'm not objecting to those. I think the core, the heart of what Henderson did still remains and is being highly protected by this museum in exactly the way it should be. I think it was necessary to expand beyond that original conception, and I think doing so was done probably given the amount of space that was needed and the functions that were needed as well as could be done. But, nonetheless, I do believe that the original building's been more or less engulfed by subsequent additions, and this will continue that. But I do not believe that's a reason to oppose. I think that the historic integrity of the original structure is no longer completely there, but the significance of the structure remains 100% in terms of the original intent that Henderson and Wheelwright had in building it, the stewardship of the building over time, and the functions that it continues to provide, extremely important services it provides to our community today, all of which I think is, these, this final addition, perhaps, is made necessary by the expanded services that are being provided. As far as the setback, the additional few feet, I do think that would actually, I agree with staff, that would probably help to further, to prevent further obscuring of the original Henderson Building. However, I think that in this case, it's important to defer to the design of the architect who considered all the options. And I always fear that anytime there are minor modifications being given to a design that's been thoughtfully considered, that often the outcome, though well-intended, is, you end up in a much worse place than you started. So I personally feel that we should defer to the architect on the placement of the and size of the portal. So with that background, Case 2026013296HDRB at 704 Camino Lejo would move that the findings be entered, that the exception criteria have been met by the applicant for constructing an addition on a primary facade and within 10 feet of the primary facade for the reasons given by the applicant and by staff in recommending approval. I would additionally have findings entered that the applicant has conclusively demonstrated that the exception criteria have been met for an addition exceeding 50% of the historic footprint for the reasons given by the applicant in that case. And finally, that the exception criteria have been met for exceeding the maximum allowable height. And, therefore, the application be approved as submitted. Go ahead, CECILIA RIOS: hear a second. Second. Further to add? Further to add? Roll call vote, please. Member Degnan? Yes. And JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: I had a birthday while you were joking. T CECILIA RIOS: That was JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: an amazing, amazing motion. Thank you. Happy b AMANDA ROMERO: birthday. Thank CECILIA RIOS: k you. Member Van Venue? Yes. Member Simmons? Yes. Madam Chair, the motion has passed. Thank you. Thank you all for coming out this evening, and good luck on your project. Good work. We'll move on to the next agenda item, discussion items. Anything from staff? Nada? Nothing? Matters from the Board, ma'am. Matters from the Board? Nope. Matters from the Board? Moving right along, our next meeting is going to be November 10 AMANDA ROMERO: 0. Oh, okay. Madam Chair? I will do my best. Yes. I just wanted to remind the board the November 10 meeting will be back at Midtown, and we would need to close up that by 9:00 PM. CECILIA RIOS: Oh, and it's at what time? Five? At 5:30. Okay. The regular scheduled time, but it's at that, the location over there. Thank you. And do I hear a motion to... So moved. Second. All those in favor, say aye. Aye.