Historic Districts Review Board Meeting Tue, Nov 10, 2026 · Historic Districts Review Board https://santafeminutes.space/meeting/1169-historic-design-review-nov-10-2026 == Executive Summary == The Historic Districts Review Board meeting on November 10, 2026, began with Member Besheide elected as acting chair and the agenda approved, though several items were postponed to December 8, 2026. The board heard an inspiring presentation by Sean Evans titled "Heritage is a Verb," which challenged traditional preservation methods and advocated for a dynamic, community-led approach to cultural perpetuation. This led to a commitment to continue hosting such presenters and forming a new "Design and Preservation Committee" for the Land Development Code update. The board then addressed several property cases. They approved alterations for 216 Maynard Unit A and B, including replacing historic windows, with a 2-1 vote. For 507 and 511 Paseo De Peralta, updated designs for multifamily structures were approved, with 507 Paseo De Peralta receiving a height exception. A major project at 616 Acequia Madre, involving extensive renovations and additions to an Old Santa Fe style residence, received unanimous approval for all requested exceptions for both the main house and guest house, as well as for new construction of a studio and garage. Public comments for this case were overwhelmingly supportive, emphasizing the need for practical flexibility in maintaining historic homes. Finally, the board designated the main residence and yard wall at 481 Arroyo Tenorio as "contributing" to the historic district, while the garage was deemed "non-contributing," following extensive discussion on integrity and alterations. == Key Decisions == - Member Besheide was voted in as acting chair. - Agenda was approved with two items postponed to 12/08/2026. - Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law for three cases were approved. - Staff's recommendation for alterations at 216 Maynard Unit A and B in the West Side Guadalupe Historic District was approved, including replacing historic steel casement windows with aluminum-clad windows, replacing a garage door, constructing a front yard wall, and removing non-historic wood paneling. An exception for replacing historic windows on primary facades was granted. - Updated designs for two adjacent multifamily structures at 507 Paseo De Peralta and 511 Paseo De Peralta in the Downtown and Eastside Historic District were approved. A height exception for 507 Paseo De Peralta was granted. - All requested exceptions and design changes for the main house at 616 Acequia Madre were approved, including removing openings, changing windows, demolishing a sauna, infilling a wall, constructing a bay window, and constructing a portico. - All requested exceptions and general maintenance requests for the guest house/carriage house at 616 Acequia Madre were approved, including retroactive shed removal, widening a garage door, changing doors/windows, and an addition. - New construction of a 1,581 sq ft studio and a 1,024 sq ft garage at 616 Acequia Madre was approved. - Construction of a 3 ft 6 inch high yard wall at 616 Acequia Madre was approved. - The main residence at 481 Arroyo Tenorio was designated as "contributing" to the historic district, with specific facades (R22, R1, R2, R3, R4, and R5) designated as primary. - The garage at 481 Arroyo Tenorio was designated as "non-contributing." - The yard wall at 481 Arroyo Tenorio was designated as "contributing." - Several agenda items (F through K) were postponed to the 12/08/2026 meeting. == Motions & Votes == - Motion to approve staff's recommendation for alterations at 216 Maynard Unit A and B — Passed (2 Yes, 1 No). - Motion to approve staff's recommendations for 507 Paseo De Peralta and 511 Paseo De Peralta as submitted — Both passed. - Motion to approve all requested exceptions and design changes for the main house at 616 Acequia Madre — Passed (unanimous). - Motion to approve all requested exceptions and general maintenance requests for the guest house/carriage house at 616 Acequia Madre — Passed (unanimous). - Motion to approve the construction of a 1,581 sq ft studio and a 1,024 sq ft garage at 616 Acequia Madre — Passed (3-0). - Motion to approve the construction of a 3 ft 6 inch high yard wall at 616 Acequia Madre — Passed (3-0). - Motion to designate the main residence at 481 Arroyo Tenorio as "contributing" with specific primary facades — Passed (3-0). - Motion to designate the garage at 481 Arroyo Tenorio as "non-contributing" — Passed (unanimous). - Motion to designate the yard wall at 481 Arroyo Tenorio as "contributing" — Passed (unanimous). == Public Comment == No public comments were received on non-agenda items. For Case 616 Acequia Madre, public comments were overwhelmingly supportive of the proposed renovations and additions, emphasizing the need for practical flexibility to maintain and occupy the historic home. For Case 481 Arroyo Tenorio, public comment highlighted the historic integrity of the east facade and the quality of later additions by well-known Santa Fe designers. == Topics == - Historic Preservation Philosophy - Santa Fe Style & Appropriation - Building Contributing Status - Impact of Preservation Policies - Vernacular Architecture & Traditions - Specific Property Case (1200 Old Pecos Trail) - Future of Preservation - Architectural Review Committee Role - Staff Introduction & Background - Meeting Logistics & Agenda == Full Transcript == JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: Member Besheide, we are live. Alright. Thank you, everyone, for your patience. I'll call this meeting of the Historic Design Review Board to order at 5:48. And we have a roll call vote e. I would need a vote to vote in Member Besheide as acting chair. I JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: make a motion to vote to make Member Besheide active chair. I. JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: Member Simmons? Here. Member Cherr JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: ry? Yes. Are we voting on the motion or... Yes, voting on the motio JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: on. Yes. Member Degnan? Yes. The motion has passed. I will go to the roll call. Chair Rios? She's excused. Member Simmons? Here. Member Cherry? Here. Chair Besheide? Here. And Member Degnan? Here. Madam Chair, you have a quorum. Thank you. The next item on the agenda is the approval of the agenda. Are there any changes to tonight's agenda? Yes, Madam Chair. We have Item D under New Business is going to be postponed to the December 8th hearing, and Item J will also be postponed to t JOHN BIENVENU: the December 8th hearing. And that's 722 Gildersleeve and 924 Paseo De JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: e Peralta, so folks know. Any other changes? No, Madam Chair. Okay. Can I have a motion to a SCOTT CHERRY: approve the AMANDA ROMERO: e agenda as a JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: amended? So moved. Second one. We'll move on to approval of findings of fact and conclusions of law for three cases. Are there any changes to the findings of fact on or conclusions of law? Hearing none, may I have a motion to approve th he three Findings Con SHAWN EVANS: nclusions? So moved by JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: y Degnan. And second by Degnan. All those in favor, please say aye. Aye. Opposed? The next item Matters from the Public. We'll take any comments from the public that are not related to cases on the agenda tonight. The opportunity for public comment on the cases tonight will be held with each case. So if there's anything from the public, please come forward or raise your hand on the Zoom. No hands raised on Zoom. I think he has seen no one in the audience eit JOHN BIENVENU: ther. We'll move on Staff Communications. Thank you, Chair Besheide. I would like to introduce Sean Evans, who is principal with MAS Design Group. MAS is a remarkable organization because it's the model of architecture serving society design group. And that describes Sean quite a bit because he has done a lot of things. He went to Texas A&M University for his undergraduate, which I'll have to forgive him for because I went to UT Austin. He went to the University of Pennsylvania for his graduate program, Master of Architecture with Certificate in Historic Preservation. He was a board member of the New Mexico Heritage Preservation Alliance for many years and also president of the AIA, past president of the AIA, and has done a lot of work throughout the state. And I had the honor of watching him at a National Town Builders Association conference. He gave a presentation, and I was so impressed. I thought it was a good message for the H Board to hear, and if you hear his pers SHAWN EVANS: spective. So please, Mr. Evans, continue. Thank you, Heather. Let's see if this will load up. I know those items were moved. What's happening? I'm so sorry. Oh, it's because I closed the. Can I get so LANI MCCULLEY: omeone who's not as SHAWN EVANS: wiggly as I am to help me? Okay. There it is. Don't know what all these ladies are on the right. Well, thank you. So as Heather mentioned, I'm Sean Evans, principal with MAS Design Group. We're a 125-person nonprofit 501(c)(3) architecture firm that was started in Kigali, Rwanda. And we still have about 50 people there, big office in Boston, and we're a small but mighty team here in Santa Fe. I'm also the immediate past president of AIA Santa Fe, as Heather mentioned, although I'm going to be speaking to you tonight as myself, not as the AIA. Many years ago, I was a member of the Architectural Review Committee of the Philadelphia Historical Commission. So those of you that are seated, we're about to hear hate cases. I've been in your chair, and I know that I know the what you're going through. So today, I'm going to make a bold declaration. Despite what the dictionary says, where I've crossed out the symbol for noun, I believe that heritage is a verb. For too long, preservation has been something controlled by a few so-called experts. I've been one of them, often with a primary goal of encouraging tourism. While this is certainly good for the economy of any city, particularly Santa Fe, we've not been paying enough attention to the ripple effects. Most definitions of heritage like this one are too passive, fixed, and focused on the past. I propose that we think about heritage as an active process in which each community decides how to carry its past into the future. Since time immemorial, this place, Santa Fe, Okapoga, has been a place of vernacular heritage. It was a place without architects, where buildings weren't designed but came to being through community tradition, cultural beliefs, and climactic specificity. Adobe buildings were pulled up out of the earth and were continually modified, adapted, enlarged, demolished, changed to meet the continually changing requirements of daily life. The communities who have called this place home, whether they called it Oga Poga or Santa Fe, living under Pueblo Spanish, Pueblo Spanish, Mexican territorial US, and finally US statehood, navigated changes in governance and self-determination. At the dawn of statehood in 1912, our civic leaders determined that our physical character had quickly become too American and that the burgeoning tourism industry would be our savior. Beginning in 1912, the recently Americanized plaza was changed to physically re-represent an idealized image of Santa Fe. These are the same buildings with the exception of the two on the left. That is the building that used to be there on the top. The others are the same. They've just been modified. I want to move this thing about items moving. Google. Just ignore it. I'll try. The discipline of historic preservation was in its infancy at the time, and there was little concern paid to authenticity and integrity, and no concern paid to the impacts that policy and peer pressure would have on the residents of Santa Fe. Good Lord. Here we go. Architects and anthropologists began a colonialist enterprise to document the traditional buildings of the region in order to codify a Santa Fe style. This stolen intellectual property was utilized by outsiders to create a fantasy of what Santa Fe should look like. The buildings in these images were broken down into bits and pieces, academically, not literally, which eventually resulted in the paint-by-number approach to design that we face today. To further the insult, the meaning of the elements taken from Pueblo villages were ignored, resulted in sacred geometries and architectural features being copied and pasted around town no matter the context. The traditional construction methods that provided true character began to disappear, replaced with simulations. This culminated in the late 20th century with places like the Loretto Hotel, a cartoon of Taos Pueblo, upper left, and the El Dorado Hotel with its chimney caps unbelievably based on conquistador helmets, upper right. Even on mundane buildings such as gas stations and storage units, the style was pasted without critical thought, transforming our timeless cultural ways of building into a slop that would make an AI agent proud. We packaged and commodified regional culture, stripping it from the communities that built this region. This imagined Santa Fe is a product of the world expositions, which housed indigenous peoples in zoos of cardboard and a Western architecture spectacle driven by railway tourism. Santa Fe became a place to visit, a place to consume, and most recently, a place to have a second, third, fourth, almost fifth house. It's no wonder that heritage has become a flashpoint. Santa Fe's landmarks like the 1917 New Mexico Museum of Art seen here purport to honor history. However, this is a brick building in costume, aestheticizing deterioration and colonialism. The facades of the museum are literal copies from the mission churches in the Pueblos, among the first actions taken by Western culture to suppress indigenous peoples. The Santa Fe style and preservation and design ordinances that grew from it are appropriative, cheapening the extraordinary cultures that made this place. And the impact of this commodification and the needlessly strict preservation controls is clear. Massive gentrification and cultural erasure have undeniably been a result. Hispano families can no longer afford to live in the older parts of town where humble dwellings now sell for millions of dollars, while the median family income of our city remains less than $75,000. It's time for a new approach. Across the country, communities are realizing that status quo preservation is not serving their interests. Even preservation stalwarts like the National Trust and Landmarks Illinois are clamoring for change. Preservation should be for people. This is not to say that the bricks and sticks are not important. They are. Yet preservation is meaningless if the communities who made these places are no longer present. Let's dismantle the culture of preciousness and focus on sustaining the communities that make places true. Who's doing this well? San Francisco and San Antonio. They lead the way with policies that favor dynamic cultural perpetuation rather than just obsessing over minimizing change to buildings. Heritage policies can focus on retaining legacy businesses where regional culture thrives, grocers, restaurants, and family-owned shops for craft and music. New heritage policies are beginning to reward continuing traditional construction practices and to require deconstruction when buildings can't be saved so that the older material can be reused. This is actually the law in San Antonio. Educational programs and rehabber clubs are regenerating lifeways that carry knowledge for generations. I'm hopeful for cultural perpetuation in New Mexico. Our history of places made by the community rather than by contractors is a powerful foundation of a preservation for people. As is the tradition of acequia governance in which these centuries-old man-made irrigation ditches are managed and maintained by the farmers who use them and the community who benefit. Acequias remain essential for community agriculture in this parched environment. These vernacular traditions are threatened by industrial practices and the challenges of a money economy, but many are fighting to continue these beautiful practices grounded in equity. And a number of communities are returning to the community maintenance practices of mud plastering adobe walls, removing the cement stucco that was applied with the best of adobe walls, removing the cement stucco that was applied with the best of intention but actually damages the earthen walls that the impermeable cement prevents from breathing. I believe there is no place better than New Mexico to reform preservation. This is a place where living culture is thriving despite our attempts to freeze the built environment. The Hispano and indigenous cultures are celebrated and significant income is generated by artisans in these communities whose craft and food is very much in demand. The annual Spanish and Indian markets demonstrate that heritage is profoundly present and can be both traditional and contemporary all at once. Why can't our buildings demonstrate this dynamism and creativity? Santa Fe should be a heritage laboratory, a place in which preservation and perpetuation of both tangible and intangible heritage is experimented with by and for the community. Tangible heritage, objects, and buildings are important, of course, but it is the culture they represent that is most significant. Intangible heritage, music, craft, food, faith, dance, stories, and yes, ways of building are living aspects of culture. This diagram on the right is from UNESCO, from their program on intangible heritage. It's an interactive tool. You can find it on their website. It's really a remarkable, remarkable thing. In the couple minutes I have left, I want to talk a bit about an ongoing project I've been blessed to be involved with for over twenty years. This is the traditional village of Okayawinghe, just forty-five minutes north of here. This is the oldest known photograph of the village. It was taken in 1877 by John Hillers. This image is nearly 150 years old, and yet the village at the time this picture was taken was at least five to six hundred years old. More than half the homes in this image still have no doors. They are accessed through ladders and roof hatches, yet many other homes have embraced new ways of life and have installed doors. Whereas historic preservation is most often focused on buildings designed by architects and returning buildings to an original or earlier appearance, to the people of Okay Owingeh, this image demonstrates the absurdity of an originalist approach in their vernacular context. They taught us that this village has never not been in the midst of tremendous physical change. As we facilitated conversations around how the buildings would be repaired and revitalized, it became clear that the kitchen tables were more important than the walls that surrounded them. Returning daily life to these homes, most of which had long ago ceased being primary dwellings, was our highest priority. Whereas several other Pueblos have developed protocols that limit change, some even going so far as to forbid utilities, the people of Okay Owingeh saw a unique balance between the past and the future. They're just one of the 19 Pueblos of New Mexico demonstrating that there is an extraordinary beauty to a diversity of heritage approach. Cement stuccos were removed and earthen plasters have been reapplied, which are being maintained by the community again. This is not a museum, and signs of contemporary life such as that satellite dish are a common sight. Why should we be offended at a satellite dish? Nearly 50 homes have been returned to daily life. We've returned second stories to many of the homes, and the community has guided us as to which elements seen in the old photograph should be returned and which should be left in the past. While we are certainly proud of the architectural revitalization, this project was always more about restoring life, love, and laughter. And it has been an extraordinary economic development story as well. Avanyu General Construction hired and trained many native employees who had previously not worked in construction. About half the crew was from Okay Wenge, and well over a million dollars has flowed back into tribal households. The Adobe Masons have now worked throughout the Southwest and as far South as Chile and as close as the Georgia O'Keeffe Museum. Many of the folks involved in design and preservation here in Santa Fe are hoping for big change. I spoke earlier about a dream of this remarkable place as a heritage laboratory. I envision a future where Santa Fe is known not for a collection of picture postcards of attractive but inauthentic buildings, but rather as a place of multiple authentic and varied futures where the earth guides a sustainable way of life that is affordable and grounded in local values. Visitors will come from around the world, not to look at a static place where culture is consumed, but to experience a relationship, a complex relationship between the past and JOHN BIENVENU: the future. Our embracing of varied protocols and beliefs will fuel a rich tapestry of the cultures who call this place home and continually remake it in the name of perpetuation. Thank you. Sheriff Beechad, you may be questioning, so why is Sean Evans speaking? It's because I think it is the launch of a look at how we approach historic preservation in the city, and there's a lot of discussions. And I know there's contentious discussions and a lot of concerns that are being expressed across the community. And I think that by having a series of presenters on the issue of preservation in Santa Fe will be helpful as we embark on the dialogue in phase two of the land development code update. Just a quick update on the Historic Preservation Subcommittee of the Land Development Code update committees. There's a Code Advisory Team that is going to be managing the larger sort of dialogue and input for the update of the code for phase two. There will be a subset of that, and we have engaged with a consultant, Matt Goble and Partners, and we met with several community members while we were in town. And it was decided that we will have a Design and Preservation Committee, not divorcing historic preservation, but also not excluding the rest of the community because there's a lot of opportunity for dialogue on how we, as Santa Fe, want to look as a whole. And right now, JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: it's somewhat a tale of two cities. So, I appreciate Mr. Evans for being here, and we'll continue this series as we lead up to our phase two code update. Thank you very much, Heather, for organizing that, and thank you, Mr. Evans, for what I think were inspiring and chall CITY STAFF: lenging remarks that needed to be said. And I appreciate you sharing that perspective with us, and I hope that we continue the dialogue as a community. Madam Chair, I wanted to pass along to the board that, as I think we mentioned in a previous board meeting, the governing body has set up a special meeting to hear two H board appeals under Planning Commission appeal that is going to be Wednesday, November 18 at 2:00. Originally, there were appeals of case number 2026, 11871, regarding a status review at 118 Camino Santiago. But that appeal has been withdrawn. The property owners sent an email to me that I passed along to Heather, and they indicated they no longer want to appeal that. So the only other appeal that will be heard on November 18 will be the appeal of case number 202612571, which was the denial of some alterations at 1295 Cerro Gordo Rd that was heard by the H board on 06/23/2026. So that is still on the agenda for November 18, and that special governing body meeting is set to start at 2:00 or 1:00 in the afternoon. So, land use cases are quite frequently at the very end of the governing body agenda. So this shouldn't go till midnight like some of those we JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: ent. And there will also be a Planning Commission appeal that will be heard at that same agenda. Thank you. Thank you. Any other Staff Communications, Chair. Thank you. Thank you. We'll move on to old business. But before we do, I'll just mention that appeals, if there's a decision that an applicant is or anyone else is unhappy with, there's an opportunity to appeal that decision. They'll be heard by the City Council. There are some time constraints associated with that process. So if you plan to appeal, please work with staff to make sure that you adhere to the time constraints for that process. The first case under old business, excuse me, is item A, case number 2026012691HDRB at 216 Maynard Unit A and B. And, Amanda, this is your case? Yes. And Jonathan Mellon, the Historic Preserva AMANDA ROMERO: ation Manager, will be presenting on my behalf. That's great. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Mellon. Good evening. Thank you all for being here, for being patient. I'm going to do my best to pinch it here and apologize if I'm a little off my game. As noted, the first application is for 216 Maynard Street, Unit A and B. This is located in the West Side Guadalupe Historic District. Unit A, which is on the right-hand side of your screen, was constructed in the mid-1930s by the Vigil family. And Unit A, which is on the left side of your screen at the rear of the lot, the date of construction is a little bit unclear. However, it was constructed before 1944. Both of these buildings were constructed in the Spanish Pueblo Revival style. Originally, they were given non-contributing status. However, as some of you who were on the board, I guess, at the time, I'm new, so I don't know who exactly was on it. But in April of this year, this board designated Unit A as contributing, with the east facade number one, south facade numbers two, three, four, and five, and north facade number 11 as primary, excluding non-historic materials. And Unit A was also designated as contributing with the east facade, number one as primary. Alright. So in terms of the proposed scope of work here, the applicant is proposing primarily to replace the windows, the existing windows. And as you saw in your packet, they did do a pretty thorough examination of the existing conditions of the windows. So they're proposing to replace all the windows. They are also proposing to replace the garage door on Unit A with a fixed panel, but it will have the look of a carriage house door. In addition, they're proposing to construct a four-foot, four-inch yard wall in the front yard. And under the front porch, I have to learn the local lingo, the portal, they're proposing to remove the wood paneling that is not historic. So these are just some images here of... This is Unit A, and I'm going to just jump ahead. I know we have a long agenda. I should also note, in the image at the photograph at the bottom, excuse me, but the mic, there are these non-historic canopies over some of the windows. Those are proposed to be removed. As you can tell, a number of the windows on the building on A are steel casement windows. And we all know how special steel casement windows are. But as I noted earlier, the applicant did do a thorough analysis of the existing conditions, that they are quite deteriorated. Here's the front elevation, and I think you can see where my cursor is. This is the area I was talking about underneath the portal that has the wood paneling that's proposed to be replaced. In addition, the windows are all proposed to be replaced. One of the really... Let me just jump ahead here. These are some images of the rear building, Unit A. I'm just going to jump ahead here. So the main thing to look here, on the right-hand side, this is the existing garage door that I mentioned earlier. It's proposed to be replaced by this fixed piece that will do a good job in our estimation of referencing the original opening. The opening itself is not going to be changed, but allowing for some use of the space. In addition, there will be stucco repair with... I know this has come up. This came up at the last meeting, my first meeting that I was at. But let's see if we have... I don't know if we have an image of the front, but one of the really nice changes is on the front of the house on unit directly over here to the right. I don't know. Amanda, I don't know if we have the picture here. Right here, there is a single plate glass window that is going to be replaced with a multi-lite window. All of the steel casement windows, they're not being... I know we got into a discussion here at our last meeting of in kind. They are not being replaced in kind. So they are not being replaced with steel casement windows. They're being proposed to be replaced, I should say, with aluminum clad windows that will have the same light pattern and dimensions as the steel casement windows, but they will not be made of... They will not be steel casement windows. Given all of this, staff is recommending approval. There is one exception that is being requested to section 14-4.6 E41A for replacing historic windows on primary facades. We talked a lot about this as a staff. I have quite a bit of experience in my previous positions with steel casement windows, having worked in Washington D.C. where the federal government has many wonderful buildings, as you probably know, on the National Mall that originally had steel casement windows. Replacement steel casement windows have come a long way. They used to be very chunky, and when you saw them replaced, they looked pretty bad. However, the window manufacturers have realized there's a market for this. And so, I've seen some very successful examples of aluminum-clad windows for replacement of steel casement windows. As such, we are recommending approval for the replacement of the windows, the construction of the new wall, and the replacement of the garage door. There are going to be no changes to the actual sizes of the openings, but there will be stucco repair required, as I think board member Cherry correctly pointed out at our last meeting. So with that, I hope that made some sense. And I'm here to answer any questions, or I know the owner, I believe, i JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: is right there in the front row. Their window contractor was not able to attend, but I think we've got a pretty good handle on this one. Thank you. Thank you for that report. Just a point of clarification. I think the staff report mentions that there's a mix of windows on the structure now, both steel and wood. Yes, exactly. Yes. And they would be replacing with a single... With aluminum clad. Yes. Thank you. And the AMANDA ROMERO: e drawings... Per the staff recommendation, the drawings do not reflect the divided line. Yes. So I'm sorry. Thank you for pointing that out, Chair. The specs that are included in your packet are correct. Some of the drawings, that picture window on the front, which is arguably the most important window on the drawing, still shows the picture window there, but that is to be replaced with one of the aluminum clad, mimicking the look of a JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: a steel casement window. So that's a huge improvement. It's going to really ch SCOTT CHERRY: hange the whole architecture back to what it should be of the building. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Any questions from the board members AMANDA ROMERO: s? Mr. Simmons? Jonathan, have you compared the sizes of the mullions and frames of the replacement windows to the existing, and how do they compare? Yes, they look to be a good match, but we're going to, as part of... Excuse me. As part of our final review before we approve the permit, JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: we're going to make sure they're a match, excuse me, to make sure that all the... Yes, because that's the key. As I noted, you don't want them to be too chunky. . Other questions? Anyone? Oops. Sorry. The applicant. Thank you for bearing with me. As the PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): e applicants, please come forward and give your JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: r presentation. Thank you. Yeah, of course. Please raise your right hand and state your name and address for the record. Jennica Kilbride, 216 Maynard Street A and B. Do you solemnly declare and affirm t the testimony you have in reference to this item is the truth, t PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): the whole truth, and do this under the penaltie JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: es of perjury? I do. Thank you, Madam Chair. She has been sworn. Welcome. Anything you would like to tell us about your project? I'm just excited to do it. Yeah, that's great. Any questions from the board members for the applicant? Any members of the public with comments on this case? Please come for PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): rward, and if you wouldn't mind limiting your comments to two JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: o minutes just because we have a long agenda. I'm up here. Yep. Thank you. Please state your name and address for the record. Elizabeth West, 318 Center Street PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): t in the South Capitol area. Do you solemnly declare and affirm the testimony you have in reference to this item is the truth, the whole truth, and do this under the penalties of perjury? Yes, I do. Thank you. Great. I agree with staff. I think this... I've been following this a little bit through the days that it's... or the couple of years that this JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: s has been going on, and I really like how the owners and also staff and board guidance se eem to be working together in a way that I admire. PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): And so I think this is a good t JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: thing. Thank you. PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): . Tha JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: ank you. Are there comments from the public? Is there anyone on Zoom wishing to comment? No hands raised. Oh, wait. Hold on. We've got one. Can you hear me? PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): David, please, to be sworn in. Yes. Do you solemnly declare and affirm the testimony you have in reference to this item is the truth, the whole truth, and do this under the penalties of per JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: rjury? Yes, I do. Thank you. Thank you. Madam Chair, I do believe that the board must make a positive finding of fact JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: t that the exception criteria have been met to remove historic material. PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): . Thank you. Thank you. Yes, that's correct. I'll return it to the board if there's any further discussion or questions or a motion. I have a question. Is there... What's the stucco specification? Stucco specification as far as fixing around the windows? Or I'm sorry. My... I'm up here by my lonesome because my JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: contractor and window guy could not come, so I might not have the best answer for you. Yeah, I just wonder... I know this building has, like, a mix of different stuccos on it, including a lot of elastomeric stucco. So I was just curious what the restuccoing of... Of course, you're going to have to p AMANDA ROMERO: patch stucco around the windows, but then, is that an elastomeric stucco? Or is there no... I know in the last hearing, we discussed that, and I'm just not seeing a spec for the stucco, like, what it is. If it's just page five, it says, excuse me, "Restore the wall area around each window using jumbo text building paper properly integrated with the existing weather r JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: resistive barrier, followed by metal lath. Apply cement plaster system consisting of scratch coat and brown coat, followed by pr AMANDA ROMERO: rimer and synthetic Pueblo color coat to blend the window pa JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: atches with the existing wall." Okay. So it SCOTT CHERRY: t's just a synthetic stucco patch, and the rest of the building won't be restuccoed. Is that what's proposed? Yes, that's what it looks to be. Yep. Okay. Thanks. PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): Thank you. Further que JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: estions? I'll entertain a motion. I'll make a motion. In the case of 2026012691HDRB at 216 Maynard Unit A and B, I move that we accept staff's recommendations and allow these windows to be repl SCOTT CHERRY: laced. That's finding effect. Is JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: s there a second? Second. I might just mention that the drawings need to be updated to o reflect the light pattern presente ed in the packet, if someone can make that as a AMANDA ROMERO: a friendly amendment. JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: I'll make that as an amendment. The second hold? Okay. Second accept. Thank you. Any discussion? Roll call vote, please. Member Simmons? Yes. Member Cherry? No. Member Degnan? Yes. The motion has passed. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. The next case under old business is item B. And it's just a question for staff. Should we be hearing B and C together or as separate cases? The two cases can be heard together. Okay. LANI MCCULLEY: Thank you. And is the applicant here for this case? Yes. Okay. And the case is 2026-012490HDRB at 507 Paseo De Peralta, and case number 2026012491HDRB at 511 Paseo De Peralta. Lenny, this is your case. Thank you for presenting. I'm actually doing partially together and partially separate, because we do have to have two motions on it. So I'm going to start. So the development of 507 and 511 Paseo De Peralta came before the board in 2014 under case H14034. Subsequently, a development plan was approved by the Planning Commission in 2014. However, that approval expired. In 2023, the project was reviewed and approved again by the Planning Commission. The applicant received a one-year extension in 2026 and has since recorded their development plan, solidifying their approval. The project came back before the board in June 2026 under case 26012490 and 012491 for approval of the updated design. The board expressed concerns about the new design, including the cantilevered roofs, steel elements, windows too close to the roofline, the more modern style, and the setbacks at the streets and corners. The board also expressed concern about the structure's proportion to the streetscape, especially the residences to the north, and recommended single-story structures along the street with taller portions at the rear of the lot. The board also questioned the accuracy of the building height calculation. Staff has read on all of the calculations and concludes that per Section 14-4.6 F13B, the maximum allowable height for the site is 22 feet 2 inches for the 507 Paseo De Peralta. That is in disagreement with the previous calculation of 25 feet. The difference between the calculations is that the previous calculation did not take the streetscape along Magdalena into consideration. This is a corner lot, and that it has to take both streetscapes into consideration. Public comments showed concern for the narrow driveway, lack of fall protection, poor condition of the existing retaining wall, setbacks not being compatible with the proximity to neighboring properties, the height of the structures, drainage, the design not matching the existing neighborhood, the modern style, and site visibility at the corner of Magdalena and Paseo. The case was postponed for a redesign, taking into consideration the comments from the board and the public. The applicant has addressed the cantilevered roofs by changing to parapets, eliminating the metal elements by using wood, insetting the windows 3 feet, and bullnosing the corners with a 3-inch radius. The drawings were corrected to show the windows at a more accurate distance from the roofline. And while the overall lot coverage is not altered, the applicant confirmed that the corner at Magdalena will have site visibility due to the setbacks and the careful location of an open portal. So at 507 Paseo De Peralta, the applicant has provided updated elevation drawings specifying the maximum heights, the midpoint of the streetscape, the street-facing facades along Paseo De Peralta at 24 feet 11 and a half inches, and at Magdalena at 23 feet 5 and a half inches. This is all per Section 14-4.6 F23A, wherein Historic District, height shall be measured as, and I quote, "the vertical distance measured between the highest part of the structure and the existing grade or finished grade, whichever is more restrictive at the midpoint of the street-facing facade, excluding rooftop appurtenances." The applicant is requesting a height of 25 feet, where staff's calculation provides for a maximum allowable height of 22 feet 2 inches. The vacant property is located at the northwest east corner of Paseo De Peralta Magdalena Road. There are existing retaining walls along the north and east property lines and short retaining walls on the southwest. So the applicant at 507 is proposing to construct a 4,235 square foot multifamily structure with four residential units to a height of 25 feet, where the maximum allowable height is 22 feet 2 inches. All buildings are of Pueblo Revival design with earth tone stone finishes, designed with flat roofs and parapets. Each building uses a variety of setbacks and offsets to break up the massing. The proposed project includes four condominiums in a two-story building. This tract is zoned BCD Marcy, which allows for greater lot coverage than residentially zoned lots. The tract has an approved 2023 development plan with the city which matches this request. The buildings will form a U around the central courtyard. The perimeter of the courtyard will be covered with portales to protect residents' entrances. All exposed framing will be out of wood. Roofs will be flat and concealed by parapets. Each unit will have chimneys that are clad with stucco and have stone caps and steel exhaust pipes. Exterior corners will have a minimum radius of three inches. Second-floor balconies will have stucco parapet walls and be partially covered by 30-inch deep cantilevered metal roofs supported by wood beams. That is incorrect. Oh, no, that's the balconies. Yes, that's correct. Ground-level units will include a patio covered by metal-roofed portales with wood frames and wood vertical columns at the outside corners. There will be two carports at each end of the central parking area with sides open to the parking area. The carport adjacent to Paseo De Peralta will have small windows in the south wall to break up the massing. Exterior light will be dark sky compliant sconces in dark bronze. Windows will be set within the walls for a minimum of three inches and located a minimum of 36 inches from any outside corner. Glazing on all facades is under 40%. The windows will be aluminum-clad wood with simulated horizontal muntins in a dark bronze and will feature non-reflective glazing. Stucco will be synthetic in an earth tone. A swimming pool will be located in the courtyard. They will also install a wrought iron fence to a height of six feet for the entrance to the units on the east side of the courtyard and increase the street yard walls to a height of four feet, which is the maximum in the BCD District, to define the perimeter of the tract. The project works in unison with project plan at 511 Paseo De Peralta. The overall project with both addresses will have a roofed area of 10,447 square feet. The full project will have a single driveway entrance to the shared parking area. The applicant has taken some points of discussion from the previous hearing into consideration. Additionally, staff finds that the design and height comply with the design standards for recent Santa Fe style as articulated in Ave Downtown Eastside Historic District standards. So, I'm just going to go through the rest of the slides so you guys can see the rest of the design here. And these are some renderings that they provided for you to get more of a 3D idea. So, for the case at 2026012490HDRV at 507 Paseo De Peralta, staff finds that the exception criteria to section 14-4.6 f two for exceeding the maximum allowable height have been met and recommends approval of the exception. Staff recommends approval of the JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: e other elements of the application as they comply with 14-4.6 e, general design standards for all Historic District, a LANI MCCULLEY: and 14-4.6 g two for Ave Downtown and Eastside Historic Design Standards. Thank you, Elani. Just to clarify, there is an exception required for each case to exceed the maximum allowable height. Actually, that is not 100% accurate. The 507 is required to have a height exception JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: n. The 511 is not. I have not LANI MCCULLEY: t gone into the details of the 511 case as of yet. Oh, sorry. Thank you. Do you want us to discuss this one first and then have a second presentation? I can continue with the 511 if you would prefer. That'd be great. That's up to you. Yes, thank you. Okay. So for 511 Paseo De Peralta, they have again updated the information based off of the height requirement. So they are now requesting a height of 22 feet 5 where staff's calculation provides for a maximum allowable height of 23 feet and 10 inches. Due to the change in the height, a height exception is no longer necessary. The property is located to the east of the corner of Paseo De Peralta Magdalena Road on the north side. And there are existing retaining walls along the north and east property lines and a short rock retaining wall along Paseo De Peralta on this property. So the plan is to construct a 6,212 square foot multifamily structure with five residential units to a maximum height of 22 feet 5. All buildings are of Pueblo Revival style with earth tone stucco finishes designed with flat roofs and parapets. Each building uses a variety of setbacks and offsets. The proposed project includes five condominiums in a two-story building. This tract is actually zoned R-21, which allows for multiple units on the lot. The tract has an approved 2023 development plan with the city, which matches this request. The design elements of this building are pretty much identical to the 507, so I don't want to reread all of that in the interest of time. I think I hit too many slides. Sorry. Now, this side of the lot will actually have two garages at the end of each of the central parking areas. The garage adjacent to the Paseo De Peralta will also have small windows to break up the mass. The exterior lighting will match. Windows, again, have been changed so that there's 36 inches from any outside corner. Glazing is under 40%. There will also be a wrought iron fence at the six feet for the courtyard, and there will be yard walls to a height of four feet to the interior of the existing stone wall on the south property. There will be no changes to the existing stone wall, which is designated as contributing. The project is, of course, proposed in unison with 507. And again, they have taken into consideration some of the points of the discussion from the previous hearing. And then we'll go through some of these so you guys can see what it's going to look like. And there's our renderings again. And then, so for case 2026012491 at 511 Paseo De Peralta, staff finds that, well, we found that the exception criteria was met, but it's no longer required. And staff recommends approval of the application as submitted, as it complies with sections 14-4.6 e general design standards and 14-4.6 g two for Ave Downtown and East Side District. And our applicant provided us with some additional images here that I want to share. So this is the overall site with both properties. So it's the overall site plan that's proposed. And then these are the approximate location and view of the buildings as they would sit at 507 here on the corner of Magdalena and then 511 as it is next to that. And that's kind of them sitting together from Paseo. And I stand for any JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: questions. Thank you, Elani. I had just a couple of questions and clarifications. Is the wrought iron gate only for the vehicles? Or is it, does it go around the entire property? It's only o LANI MCCULLEY: on the interior of the courtyard. So it's access to the courtyards from the parking area. So it'll only be for the homeowners and their guests. Okay. And then, I know you cov JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: vered this, but just to be clear, there's a few cantilevered coverings over the second-story balconies. Yes. And staff's interpretation is that those have met the code by including projecting beams that go beyond the 30 inches, or is it, it appears to me that it's all stopping at 30 inches, which I think is not maybe the intent of the code. There's only a cou LANI MCCULLEY: uple of them above some of the windows on the second floor, and they are only at 30 inches. Okay. And the JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: en the beams underneath them, this is clearer than the drawings, I think, with several beams underneath supporting that cantilevered roof. Yes. And then there's a couple of facades on the Paseo De Peralta side and the Magdalena side that appear to be, you know, without setbacks that are two stories. Could, but staff, could LANI MCCULLEY: you just explain staff's interpretation of that compliance? Okay. So, setback requirements are different on each of the two lots. So the R-21, which is the 511 Paseo De Peralta, they have to meet residential setbacks, but 507 is in the Business Capital District or the BCD District, and they have different setback requirements. So the 507 right there on the corner has smaller setback requirements, and that's why it looks closer. That might be a first. Okay. JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: And then I just, just because several people from the public and neighbors mentioned this last time around, and I don't think it's part of our purview, but did the applicant address the stability of the retaining wall behind this project? The retaining wall that is currently existing on the north side of the building and the north and the east side o LANI MCCULLEY: of the buildings, those retaining walls are required to be stabilized per part of their development plan. So that'll be addressed, but it's not part of this case. Thank you. And then finall JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: ly for me, is there an elevator in the project? I do not believe so. Okay LANI MCCULLEY: y. All right. Thank you. Any JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: y other questions for staff? Member Terry? Thanks. Can you just JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: clarify the heights on 507? Because when I look at the drawing, there's a dashed line that indicates 27 foot maximum height. So it's, I just, I just wanted to know if you could repeat the maximum height and then the height that the building is proposed at, and then what portions of that, of the building exceed the maximum height if it's the total top of the building or just, just like chimn LANI MCCULLEY: neys and protrusions and things like that. So this is the elevation you're looking at. I'm sorry, that's the West. You want the South? Yeah, I'm looking JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: g at the East 03, I think it says. Okay. So, that mi LANI MCCULLEY: ight not be part of this interpretation of the code on how we measure the height in the Historic District the height in the Historic District not necessarily the highest to the lowest point in the building. It is the street-facing center portion of the building. So on the south elevation, we would look at, let me find the south elevation. Sorry. Oops, I keep skipping right past it. Sorry. So, so it's not necessarily, so on our south elevation here, we would measure straight up the middle here, and that, that should be our, that's our overall height calculation for the height of the building. The calculation for the streetscape was 22 feet 5. No, that's the building. Sorry. 507 is going to, lost my place. I'm sorry. I don't have this memorized as well as I used to. Let's see. So they're going to 24 feet 11 along Paseo De Peralta, and the maximum allowable height, I believe, was 25. So we, no, they're requesting 25. The maximum allowable height is 22 feet 2 because this is 507. So they're asking for the exception for those extra three feet. Okay. Three feet. So what is the 27 foot maximum height on the drawing an indication of? I, I think that's the old height calculation that we used. Let's see this. Like, mine says 27. Okay. JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: But, regardless of that, the height of the building is 25, and the allowable height is 22. Correct. And, and why do you agree that the exception criteria was met? What's the reasoning for that agreement? The lot size is a lot of that. Smaller lots have a harder time doin LANI MCCULLEY: ng low single story. You're looking at five condominiums. So it's, you know, because the lot is so small, they're looking at going up instead of out. And, and, Chair, if I may. Yes. Thank you, Chair Beechai. Member Cherry JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: y, the 27 feet is the maximum zoning height that is perm JOHN BIENVENU: mitted. Oh, okay. That, that's, thank you, Heather. Thanks for that. Okay. But, so I JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: I guess my last question just to clarify, I'm not relating how the size of the lot. I, I can totally relate to and understand how the size of a lot makes building on a lot more difficult, full stop. But I'm not sure I relate to how that makes rationale for accepting of hardship or, or the criteria. I'm just more curious about you guys have accepted the exception criteria. So I'm wondering what, what the rationale for staff's exception of this exception criteria is. Sorry. Need a quick refresher course here. The, part of it is the streetsca LANI MCCULLEY: ape in which it's on. You have several two-story buildings right in that streetscape, including some multifamily residential and some commercial. Part of it has to do with the infill of the property. We have the small lot size. We feel like it's actually a pretty decent transition from the two-story buildings to the single-story buildings. Great. Okay. Is that it? Well, there's two pages of documentation on it. I'm trying to summarize JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: e it. Okay. Alright. Mr. Simmons, LANI MCCULLEY: questions? Hi. I just have a couple questions about colors. In the submittal, they're showing window JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: colors, but nothing is identified. SCOTT CHERRY: Also, stucco colors, can you speak to that? Let me see. Did I not call that out in the... I think you did say dark bronze for the windows, but just earth tone for the LANI MCCULLEY: stucco. Do we have a stucco? They hadn't JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: landed on an exact color just yet, but they will LANI MCCULLEY: l make sure that it's one that's in the guidelines that's approvable by staff. So maybe that's something we should condition in a motion that staff approves that color choice in the end. JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: That would be fine. Yeah. Any other questions for Lanny? Okay. Is the applicant here? Please come forward. You just need to be sworn in. Thank you. Hi. Please state your name and address for the record. Braden Furry, PO Box 238, Santa Fe, New Mexico 87504. Braden, do you solemn nly declare and affirm the testimony you have in referen PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): nce to this item is the truth, the whole truth, and do JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: o this under the penalties of perjury? I do. Thank you. Madam, as per he has been sworn. Thank you. Mr. Furry, would you like to tell us more about your project? Just a brief refresher of the history of this. This design, except t for the comments that were presented in the June historic meeti PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): ing, was previously approved in 2021. That subsequently had expired due to changes in contractors and also architects. So I took it over when it had already been approved with generally this design. Before we could move on it, that approval expired, so we were required to come back to the board to resubmit it and to represent. So the first time we brought it back, we just brought it back with the exact same design that had been approved. That was in June. In June, there were comments, and so this submittal captures those changes that were requested. Things like it used to have flat roofs with exposed beams. Those are now flat, hidden behind parapets. We had steel members instead of the wood members that are shown now, the exposed wood timbers. Part of the comment of view from the corners, we used to have stucco-clad columns that held up these exterior portales. Those have now been reduced to just wood columns. They take up less space, allow more view. So that's where this submittal has come in from since this summer. Thank you. So are all of the columns now wood? Correct. Thank you. To clarify your earlier question, the color we were intending was Pecos, and JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: you are correct with the dark bronze windows. Okay. Thank PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): k you. Any JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: y questions PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): from the board members for the applicants? Simmons? Hi, Braden. Thank you very much for this. Unfortunately, I was not JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: in attendance to that meeting. Otherwise, I would have advocated for stee JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: el, so I a SCOTT CHERRY: apologize for that. I just have one question here about the horizontal windows. Those seem to be kind of unique in just a couple of locations. Could you tell us what the rationale is for deviation of the more vertically orie JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: ented w SCOTT CHERRY: windows? Those were more based on function of the room that's interior to that space. Yeah. Bathrooms and such that the client didn't want necessarily a taller PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): window. Yeah, I can certainly understand that. You're also using some horizontally oriented windows at the garages in the 511 project. Is that something that y SCOTT CHERRY: you're kind of trying to pick up a... Horizontal in 511? I think it's 511. Yes. Uh-huh. Sorry. Oops. Sorry. You can show the right thing. There you go. We did add small, their two-foot by two-foot windows. You ca PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): an see the garage SCOTT CHERRY: e on the right. Those were just there to PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): o break up a large stucco wall, blank stucco wall, and it's the same on... It's on the left here, on the top one. It's just the same on 511 and 507. Yeah, but those aren't two-foot by two-foot. Oh, I'm sorry. They used to be. Sorry. Yeah. Yeah. They're two-foot tall by two-foot six wide. That seems more rectilinear. Was there any study done with those horizontal strips to look more like the individual windows in the garages as opposed to a strip? It's just SCOTT CHERRY: that a strip window is sort of a foreign object in this composition. Not necessarily, but that can be... That would be an easy change if it were so required. Could you describe the function from corner to corner of the room that's behind it? PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): I'm not asking for the exact... Is that all bathroom? On the top left here? On this one SCOTT CHERRY: e specifically? Your... The lower elevation, there's... Lower elevation. There's two masses there that had the horizontal windows. It's been a PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): a little bit since I've SCOTT CHERRY: e looked at this. Yeah. Yeah. They're both bathrooms. You can see them on the... Yes. Upper left there. So they're over bathtubs and in PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): showers. Would it be too difficult to take a second look at that? No. And again, that's how it was when I received the design, and so I just... That was not something that was SCOTT CHERRY: s changed before. I see. And that was not made... A comm PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): ment was not made about that in June? No. Okay. Alright. Thank you. I have a question. Member Terry. Yeah. Hey. Thanks. So as you mentioned the... And I might have missed one of the design iterations. There's been a lot of the SCOTT CHERRY: em. So... Y JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: Yep. Is it... Would JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: d it be prefer AMANDA ROMERO: rred to have the portales JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: in steel, or is this... We started that way just for durability and for maintenance. It was the preference of the client and the contractor at the time, but when we received the comment, we didn't feel that it was necessarily something that we had to fight. We were okay wit PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): th the changing to the wood. Okay. And was that for the portales along with the pen roofs? Correct. Yep. Okay. Basically, all exposed wood was steel before. Gotcha. Yea JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: ah. Because there was a lot of difference in the... Because the previous one had a lot of flat roofs that ha PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): ad a lot of cantilevered beams underneath them. Right. So but this JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: s... Was this with steel ever presented? This version here? PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): No. Okay. But that would be preferred? For the durability sake, yes. Understood. Okay. Yeah. I just... Just when it's m JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: multifamily and, you know, not... It's easier maintenance. And if it were steel, how would you envision that steel to look and be represented? It would be more in line with t PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): the window colors, other similar materials on the JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: e building. Okay. So and the wrought iron gates and... Like a painted steel like a... Yeah. Or... Okay. Yeah. Okay. Thanks. PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): . Any other questions for the applicant? We'll open it up to public comment. Anyone in t JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: the room wishing to comment on this case? I've forgotten. I don't think I need to be sworn in again. I think you JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: u've already sworn. Yes. Please go ahead. Let's see. I think this is vastly improved. It's subtle, and I'm glad that the own PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): ners and the builders are interested in using the wood, partly because the color variation is really pleasing to me. And I like... It's less boring than having everything match. If the steel were going to be used, I would hope it would be a different color. I like the idea of the two different setbacks. I know it's required or it's permitted or both, but I think it's kind of marvelous to have some slight differences. You may not notice a particular difference, say, with a series of steps going in a certain way, but your... And your eye doesn't tell you, oh, everything is exactly the same, but you feel that it's boring or it's trivialized in my opinion. So, I like the idea of the two different setbacks, and I like the changes. I just think it's really impressive. And when somebody new comes in and takes over something that's already been played with, that's particularly impressive, and I think is vastly improved. Thank you. And please let the record reflect that was Elizabeth West. Thank you. Please state your name and be sworn in before you speak. Hi. Quincy Sweeney. 310 Magdalena. Thank you. Do you solemnly d JOHN BIENVENU: declare and affirm the testimony you have in reference to t JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: this item is the truth, the whole truth, and do this under the penalt PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): ties of perjury? Yes. So we are t JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: the uphill neighbors right along Magdalena. And... Oh, sorry. And we're agreed. It's nice to see the changes that have been made. We live there full-time and are... Continu PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): ue to be lack of setback, both to our property as well as to the streetscape. While there are multi-story buildings in the neighborhood, they have significant setbacks from the street, which visually really improves the overall feel. Yeah. And I know there are two, like, two building standards, but it is a residential building being built in a residential area. It seems like that's not an unreasonable standard to apply. Thank you. Please state your name and be sworn in. Shahaan Pearl. 310 Magdalena Road. Do you solemnly declare and affirm the testimony you have in reference to this item as the tru JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: uth, the whole truth, and do this under the penalty of perjury? I do. Tha ank you. Yes. So to begin with, once again, I would say I do appreciate the effort that has been made and some specific changes that have shown some sensitivity to the comm PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): ments we made the last time that this case came before the board. My personal recollection is that the approved version that Eric Enfield drew was actually quite different, and it did not have a zero lot line setback to our lot. Cody North asked us for the possible variance at one corner that was going to encroach on it slightly. But this is a new prospect for us to have this building so large be built literally to within inches of our driveway. As I noted the last time, the way it's drawn, I don't think it's physically possible for it to be built without them coming onto our property. We would not be able to go up and down our driveway if there was even a person standing or a wheelbarrow or a ladder or a scaffold there. So we really do not feel inclined at all to grant permission for construction, and it is my understanding that we could only be compelled to do so if a judge determined that the contractor had no reasonable alternative. And in this case, I think there is a very reasonable alternative, which is simply to honor a residential setback. Thank you. Thank you. Mr. Evans, please be sworn in and state your name for the record. Sean Evans. 1121 North Luna Circle. Do you solemnly decl JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: lare and affirm the testimony you have in reference to this item is the truth, t SHAWN EVANS: the whole truth, and do this under t JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: the penalty of perjury? I do. Thank you. I just wanted to state that in the context of what we're going through with the land use plan improvements and that are the land SHAWN EVANS: use code, land development code, and the general plan updates, this is exactly the kind of multifamily that we need to be seeing in Santa Fe, and we need to be allowing for slight adjustments to heights and things in order for this to happen. This is a lot that is quite steep, and the streets are steep. And so, I think, you know, the proximity of this development to the neighbors, I assume, is a lot different in reality than one would imagine a two-story next to a one-story. So thank you, Braden. Great job. Thank you. Any public comments on Zoom? No hands raised, Madam Chair. I'll bring it back to the applicant and the board. Would you like to respond to anything that w JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: was said? I guess I would just mention that with the heights, yes, it is a small lot. So to get any kind of density, you do have to go vertical. These heights are also from PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): existing grade, and especially 507, where we're asking for the exception, is sloped steeper than it seems by viewing it. And so when we hit the middle ground to balance cut and fill, we start measuring from above where the existing grade is now on the south streetscape because that's the low end of the lot. So that's the parameters. It's worst-case scenario, existing or new, so existing was that. So to get any kind of decent ceiling heights in both floors, plus structure, plus parapet heights needed for proper drainage, this was about the bare minimum we could do for the overall height once you add all of that up compared to the existing topography. And are you able to speak to the setback on the north side of the building and why that's within inches of a residential property? The one in question is 507, which is in BCD, JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: , so there is no setback. And I guess the original design just took advantage of that. Also, that is the smaller lot, so every square inch c PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): counted for floor plans. We are separate from the existing retaining wall, so we're not on the retaining wall. We're not right next to it, but there is a slight separation. Well, we are for a short bit of it, but then the rest do have the setbacks that also accommodate the required open space, private open space, and such. Member Simmons? Go ahead. Could you address the constructability of that wall that's up against the retaining wall and how that's going to be sealed? Has that been thought through at this stage? Not yet. No. That's, ag JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: gain, this was ju SCOTT CHERRY: ust the plan that was kind of in the works the whole time. So that's part of the process of going through the construction documents. I see. And that wall belongs to the neighbor next door? No, it doesn' PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): 't. No. I was going to say it is part of this property. Okay. All right. Well, that makes it easier to SCOTT CHERRY: deal with. Thank you. And just hearing the concerns of your neighbors, is there any flexibility on the part of th PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): he applicant to consider a different design that would be worked out with your neighbor perhaps? Is there an opportunity for anything other than wha JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: at's proposed? I mean, obviously, it can be done. It's not really my call. It would be more the clients, but definitely, we can bring it up with them. Sure. Sorry. If you're going to speak, you need to be sworn in, please. Thank you. Please raise your right hand and sta PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): ate your name and address for the record. Marissa Ortiz. I am not picking. Marissa Ortiz, 6 La Viva Trail, Santa Fe, Mexico. Do you s solemnly decl JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: lare and affirm the testimony you have in reference to this item is the t truth, the whole truth, and do this under the penalties of perjury? Yes. Thank you. To li PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): isten to what the neighbors in Magdalena are saying, we will be hap JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: ppy to accommodate them while the bull is getting stucco or for any inconvenience that this might inquire to their daily life. So we'll be happy to look for something for th PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): hem to be while we are working on their in the wall. Thank you. If I heard them correctly, I think they're concerned about the proximity of the wall to their property. I don't know if there was a design change that might be considered. We have done everything we could in order to not lose some square footage JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: e on the plan, on the this line, so we will have to start all over again in order to make that happen. Okay. Anything else from the board? A motion? I have a couple comments here. I w PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): want to applaud the owner and the applicant and the architect. I think this is a very well-articulated building, just exactly what I think, as Mr. Evans said, our land use code is working JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: towards and what it currently says now. The s SCOTT CHERRY: scale is adequately broken down into room-sized forms, which is really what we like to see. I appreciate the neighbor's concern about setbacks. I'm just not sure what five feet is going to give you. I think that wall is tall enough that I just would think that it's part of an approved development plan from many years ago, and I think there's, it's kind of late in the game to be making this request. And then I would just suggest to the architect and the owner to take a second look at those strip windows. And then I would also like to amplify what Member Cherry says. I think that, again, like I said, I think that the steel structure at the Portales, I think, is an appropriate expression, especially in this system. It's something that I've taken to the board here on my recent appointment that when you build a new building in Historic District, you need to make a distinction between what the contributing buildings are and what the new buildings are, and I think that's a nice maneuver to do that, and I think it really expresses it well. It picks up the traditional forms, but it renders it in a modern material. So, that said, I think we need to have two motions just to be sure, one for 507 and one separate one for 511. Okay. I'm happy to make a motion. In the case of 2026012490 HDRB 507 Paseo De Peralta, I move to accept the staff's recommendations to approve the project. I will restate t JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: that I would suggest that the owner and architect take a second look at the strip windows. I don't make that mandatory, bu SCOTT CHERRY: ut if that's something that you could square away, I think it would help just fit the neighborhood better and that I'm certainly okay with rendering the Portel structure, all the Portel structures, not just the central one, but the ones on the corners, with steel beams. Could I ask a brief question here? Would you, never mind. I'll just, I'll just leave it alone. I'll let the architect figure that out. I think he's capable of designing a nice building. Heather? Thank you, Chair Scheider. I'm sorry. We can't redesign the project from the dais, so I would suggest that we act on the project that's available before us. Then I will just restate the motion that I move that we accept the staff's recommendations to approve the project as submitted. And did JOHN BIENVENU: you address the exception criteria for 507? It's always a mystery to me about the exception criteria, but I think staff has done a good enough job to contextually SCOTT CHERRY: justify an increase in height, especially if they were previously told to raise parapets from a previously approved project. T JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: Thank you. Any discussion? Yes. Rich Terry. Director La SCOTT CHERRY: amboy, I have a question regarding redesigning. Wouldn't it not, or I don't want to use the double negative. Would it not be acceptable to say, you know, that this is acceptable, however, grant permission for an alternate material for the cantilevered structures JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: and portal structures as an JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: n opt JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: tion? So we'r JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: re not redesigning. We're just accepting another material or approving the use of another material if the architect chooses to use that in their design. Chair Beach, Member Cherry, there are conditions of approval that the board can render. The message can be given to staff to work with them, but it's not clear to the applicant. You know, you could do this, you could do that. It's, we're acting on the case that is in front of us, unless there was a condition of approval. And, i JOHN BIENVENU: if I may, Member Cherry, Chair Beach, I'd like to Member Cherry. A departure from the design criteria, under both the Fair Open Meetings Act and just the tenor of the code. There's a departure from the design criteria, an exception has to be noticed to the public in the agenda, and so to allow an exception to the design criteria that we're requiring exceptions CITY STAFF: to be posted to the agenda and uploaded to Civic Clerk, I think, would run afoul of due notice to the public, which is required by due process considerations. Okay. Yeah, I understand that. It's just, I wanted clarification on that because it is, I totally understand what you're saying, Attorney Rubley, because it is something that would require an exception request. That makes a lot of sense. However, it seems as though we substitute materials often, so the line can be kind of blurry. You know, we make decisions often of s JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: saying, well, we'll approve this if you use, you know, these kind of, something's not defined. We'll say these kind of light fixtures or this kind of material. So we do some of that, but I can understand since it would be something that would require an exception criteria and need to be noticed that it falls into there. But I do feel like it feels a little murky to me, because we also go the other direction. We exclude non-historic materials. So we do make, which is, okay. I think if the applicant, having heard some of the opinions that the board may choose to come back with a separate application if they'd like to change something about the design. Member Simmons? Would an exception be required to use steel instead of wood? I don't know that's in the code. Chair Beach, Member Simmons, it has been the practice of this board to not accept steel a JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: as a predominant material in the past, and it's not abundantly clear in the code that would be something that would be consistent with either Old Santa Fe style or recent Santa Fe style. So, it would be the SCOTT CHERRY: e recommendation of staff that a code amendment would be required in order to clarify that, and we JOHN BIENVENU: e need to be consistent in order to not be arbitrary with past practices of the board and interpretations. But wouldn't portal columns and beams be considered details rather than overall materials? And I just want to say, I have a steel beam on my house, and I have spiral culvert for columns. Chair, Member Simmons, you're located in the West Side Guadalupe Historic District, which has a different set of standards. I don't think they're that different, but, okay. All right. We have a, excuse me. SCOTT CHERRY: . Member Degnan. Thank you, Chair. I would, as a maker of the second to the motion, I would like to have it restated. I think it's all very confusing to me right now. What is the mo JOHN BIENVENU: otion? Could you restate it for me, please? Member Sammis? That we accept staff's recommendation to approve the project as SCOTT CHERRY: s submitted, and agree that the exception criteria has been met JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: t. Second. Thank you. If there's no MARY ELLEN DEGNAN: o further discussion, roll call vote, please. Member Cherry? Yes. Member Degnan? Yes. Member Simmons? Yes. The motion has passed. Thank you. Is there a motion for 511 Paseo JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: o De Peralta? I'm happy to make that moti SCOTT CHERRY: ion. In the case, 2026012491 HDRB 511 Paseo De Peralta, I move the same motion as to accept staff's recommendations as terms o JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: of approval. Second. There's a motion and a second. Is there any discussion? A vote call vote, please. Member Cherry? Yes. Member Degnan? Yes. Member Simmons? Yes. The motion has passed. Thank you. Good lu SCOTT CHERRY: uck with your project. Thank you. It's a long-term memory. All right. We're moving on to new business, and I just want to let everyone know that we have this room until JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: l 9:00. So if we can, we'll do our best to get through everything, but let's try to be a bit more succin nct going forward. The first case of new business is 616 Acequia Madr re. Is that applicant here? Yes. Yes. Great. Lann SCOTT CHERRY: ny, please give us your p JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: presentation. Okay. I'm going to purchase one kind of the same way. It's a major project, and we've broken it into three cases. So we have the main residence, the guest house, and then freestanding buildings that are to come. So they're all pertaining to 616 Acequia Madre, known as the Acequia Madre PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): House. The proper JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: rty consists of a significant main reside LANI MCCULLEY: ence, a significant guest house, which is also known as the carriage house. And the property is located in Ave Downtown and Eastside Historic District property is located on the south side of Acequia Madre between Delgado Lane and San Antonio Street. The Acequia Madre House sits in a residential neighborhood and is unique to the neighborhood in that it is one of the only sites within the district to embody the concept of an estate. There's a garage caretaker building located to the southeast of the main residence, and then there's an abandoned structure within a low-walled area located in the southwest corner of the property. A low-walled garden is located directly west of the main residence, and there's a low open brick landscape wall to the north of the house. The construction of the estate's buildings is similar to that of adjacent properties. So in case 2026013419, HDRB is for the main residence. The main residence is a combination of Territorial Revival and Spanish Pueblo Revival, most appropriately referred to as Old Santa Fe style, which embraces both genres. The property was developed in the 1920s and is associated with significant people such as Eva Scott Fényes, Leonora Scott Muse Curtin, Leonora Curtin. I'm terrible with names, sorry. Plus architects Arthur Rossiter, William Lumpkins, and Irving Parsons. The addition of a partial basement vault hall and storage room on the east, and the enclosure of the sleeping porch on the west, and the addition of the screened sleeping porch in the southwest took place in 1931. The addition of the sewing room and bath in 1937. Infill of the 1930 sleeping porch was done in 1974. The vigas, screened porch, and middle bedroom were removed, and the back hall door was replaced after 1992. Otherwise, the house appears largely as it did originally in 1926. The applicant is requesting to demolish the sauna and changing rooms and storage, approximately 140 square feet, at the southeast corner. The sauna and changing rooms were associated with a 1970 swimming pool that no longer exists. They want to construct a 150 square foot portal to a height of 10 feet 6 inches, where the maximum allowable height is 12 feet 4, on the southeast corner. The portal will be 1 foot 10 inches below the height of the current residence. They'd like to make some window and door changes. This will include replacing a window on the south elevation at the eastern end with a double door for access to the residence end of the new portal, infilling two window openings on the west side of the sunroom at the southwest corner, infilling a pair of stained doors and a transom window on the north side of the, it used to be a sleeping porch, it's now a sunroom, at the southwest corner. Create a 1 foot 4 by 3 foot 4 window on the south elevation at what is currently an infilled opening of that old porch. Repair and replace rotten window and door box by replicating them as needed, and rebuild warped and rotten wood with window screens to match the existing dimensions and materials, and replace those that are currently missing. They propose to construct a 23 square foot bay window on the south elevation at the west end to replace an existing three-unit window. This will result in the relocation of the downspout in this location. Repair wood elements that are currently embedded in the stucco and those with less than 50% rot. Replace by replicating wood elements with 50% rot where it's necessary. Replace the wood canales with wood canales with metal liners, replicating the zigzag wood trim. Replace the viga ends and caps with vigas similar in size, diameter, and length, and cap with a patina copper flashing. Remove the grills at the windows on either side of the entry on the north elevation. Repair adobe behind the stucco where it's missing. Repair the brick coping with metal cap as needed. Stucco using cementitious turion and cementitious marble white. The stucco is currently approximately 2 inches thick, and this will be thinned to the ideal 1 inch thickness as part of the restucco work. Paint trim at the doors and windows using Sherwin Williams High Reflective White. Paint the shutters in Enchanting Ivy, and stain the main entrance, main entry columns, beams, corbels, viga ends, and canales in River Wood. Remove uneven brick and other paving and replace with brick pavers. Install a new painted wood guardrail on the south elevation on the west end. Replace brick at the existing partial height wall top at the southwest end, and replace the cracked or failing concrete window sills with matching shape and size. Those that can be repaired will be repaired rather than replaced. So there are three exceptions requested for removing openings on primary facades. That's for section 14-4.6 E41A. So that is to infill the existing door and transom on the north elevation of the enclosed sleeping porch, infill the existing window openings on the west elevation of the enclosed porch, and to remove the window opening on the south elevation at the east end. There's an exception to section 14-4.6 E42 for removing historic material in order to demolish the sauna and changing rooms, and two exceptions to 14-4.6 E22A for constructing additions on primary facades. One is for the portal and the other for the bay window addition. Now I have circled in red the larger portions of work on each elevation to help focus on these points. This is the north elevation. It will reflect the change to the sleeping porch door on your right-hand side there. This is the east elevation where the portal will be located and the sauna and changing rooms will be removed. The south elevation shows the change to the sleeping porch windows, the addition of the bay windows, and the removed sauna and changing rooms, as well as the portal on the east elevation, and the change of the window to a door under that portal. The west elevation shows the enclosure of the sleeping porch windows and the removed sauna and changing rooms. These are the color samples for the overall project. The colors are in keeping with the existing colors of the structure. And so staff recommendation is a little long here. So staff finds the exception criteria to 14-4.6 E41A for removing openings on primary facades have not been met and recommends denial of the exception to infill the existing door and transom on the north elevation of the enclosed sleeping porch. Staff finds the exception criteria to 14-4.6 E41A for removing openings on the primary facade have not been met and recommends denial of the exception to infill the existing window openings on the west elevation of the enclosed sleeping porch. And staff finds the exception criteria to 14-4.6 E41A for removing openings on primary facades have not been met and recommends denial of the exception to remove the window opening on the south elevation and at the east end. Staff finds that the exception criteria to 14-4.6 E42 for removing historic material have been met and recommends approval of the exception to demolish the sauna and changing rooms. Staff finds that the exception criteria to 14-4.6 E42 for removing historic material have been met and recommends approval of the exception to remove portion of the stucco infill wall on the south facade of the sleeping porch for a window. Staff finds that the exception criteria to 14-4.6 E22A for constructing the bay window addition on the primary facade has not been met and recommends denial of that exception. Staff finds that the exception criteria to 14-4.6 E22A for constructing the portal addition on primary facades have not been met and recommends denial of the exception. Otherwise, staff recommends approval of the other elements of the application as they do comply with 14-4.6 E general design standards and 14-4.6 G2 downtown and east side standards. Any questions on the main residence? Thank you, Lanny. Member Stevens, you have a question? Hi, Lanny. Could you tell us when the sleeping porch was originally constructed? That was part of the 1920s. Okay. And then when... '30s. Thank you. '30. Okay. So it's been there for a while. And then when was it enclosed? In the '90s? '70s. '70s. And was that H Board approval at that time? There's no, there's no cases from the 1970s. I don't have proof of that. Alright. Very good. Thank yo JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: ou. Other questions for Lanny, board members? Let's see SCOTT CHERRY: e. I'm ready to hear from the applicants. You'd be sworn in and let us know what y LANI MCCULLEY: you have to say. I looked at it twice. T SCOTT CHERRY: Things around. Wrong glasses. Barbara, if you could raise your right hand and state your name and address for the record. Barbara Felix, 1828 Cri LANI MCCULLEY: istobal Lane SCOTT CHERRY: e, Santa Fe. Do you solemnly declare and affirm that the testimo LANI MCCULLEY: ony you have in reference to this item is the truth, the whole truth, and do this under the penalties of perjury? Th JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: hank you. Thank you. First off, I would just want to say I am struggling with a little allergy, so if my voice comes and goes, patience. I want to first off start by say LANI MCCULLEY: ying thank you t JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: to Sean PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): n for the JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: presentation that he gave. And I think this is a really great example of a vernacular proj PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): ject that start JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: ted by a woman who then passed it on to her daughter, who then passed it on to her granddaughter. And this is the best of what vernacular architecture can be in Santa Fe. And Sean made a comment that things should PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): not be frozen in time. I think when I had the, at the status hearing in June, I made a similar comment that architecture wasn't meant to be locked in amber. So I just want you to keep that as we're moving through this discussion today. Can I see it on here? No. It's okay. I'll figure it out. The presentation. Oh, but your presentation is not on the screen. It is. No. No. No. This is, I know. That's what I'm saying. Hold, please. Can IT help with the presentation? No worries. Do you want me to do it in PowerPoint? Oh, okay. You're good. Okay. Great. Okay. First off, I think everybody in this room knows that this is an iconic and beloved residence and property within Santa Fe. It has not been used as a home or a residence since the late 1970s when the granddaughter of Eva Scott Fénye LANI MCCULLEY: es, Leonora Frances Curtin Palahimo, passed away. It has been used for meetings, gatherings, and collections in storage JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: e by the Palahimo Foundation and the AMANDA ROMERO: e Women's Int PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): ternational Study Center. And it was open to the public by appointment only to go and visit those collections. Obviously, I think everybody in this room has a goal to make this a single-family residence again. So I want to tell a little bit of why we are where we are and the decisions that we've made for the reasons of what we're asking. So, if you look at the north side, you can see that there is the covered portal that Lanny mentioned, which is the Pueblo style, Pueblo Revival style, and that is the only covered opening on this property. The door underneath that portal is 38 inches wide, but you have to go up steps to get to it. The other door that is 36 inches wide is at the very southwest corner, so you can see the garden on the left. And if you look just underneath that, you can see where it says 36 inch wide door. So the two doors that actually would allow somebody in a wheelchair accessible to get into the house are very far from the driveway on the east and the parking on the east. Additionally, where you see the 36 inch door, there's an existing brick platform. In order to make that actually a fully accessible entry, we would need to make that platform larger, which obviously can happen. But really what I'm trying to show is that the existing two doors that potentially would allow somebody to get into the building via wheelchair are actually pretty far away from the parking. The two existing doors that are on the east side, so the one at the kitchen is just under 32 inches wide, and then the door that is the green door, which I think staff recommends for, maybe we could just widen that, is actually less than 30 inches wide. So we made a calculated decision in concert with the owners. This really does move for choosing what was most important and what we really wanted to keep. And it was deemed more important to keep those two door openings on the east side, whereas the window that is on the south side that I'll talk about in a second, that seems like it was more hidden and it was less out of the way, less out of the public way. And so that seemed like an easier way to make an additional opening to allow for accessibility into the building. I think our dream is always to age in place, and so this is part of the requirement that the owner gave to us when they hired us is how do we make this house a place that they love. They've been walking by the house for years. They've looked at the house for years. This is a place they actually want to gracefully age in. So as I said, that was the site. You can see where I've marked the doors, the 38, the 36. Again, the door into the kitchen on the right, and then you can see down in the bottom right, the door into that basement storage area. Both of those are too narrow to let a wheelchair in. Minimum standard width for wheelchair is 32 inches. So both of those openings are less than 32 inches. I just want to clarify that. Inside the building, at which I understand you do not have purview, but this is also part of why the decisions were made. The majority of doors were also less than 36 inches. So we have worked carefully with the client to go through and look at where doors need to be open, where doors need to be wider in order to make, again, the structure accessible. When you look at the far... Oh, I love this. It actually works. Okay. So when you look at this far left corner, this is the sleeping porch that Lonnie was mentioning, and you can see this is a large space. The existing bathrooms, which there is an existing bathroom here, a smaller existing bathroom here, a third existing bathroom here. All of those are surrounded by adobe structural walls. And so in order to make those bathrooms larger, we're having to do some pretty invasive work in order to kind of structurally change that. And, again, that is... I know you all care about the exterior of the building. We also care about the interior of the building and trying to make sure those spaces also retain that historic story that they're telling when possible. So you can see I've put these little notes up in the corner. There was not... I don't know what has happened. We're going to let it be blue for a minute. You'll see a note up in the kitchen. There is not at the moment an accessible path into the kitchen. And you will also see down in that bedroom, where you can see there's the more notes. There's really not an accessible path to any of the bathrooms, and the bathrooms themselves are not accessible. So knowing that, again, from the site, we wanted to make sure because this is an iconic building and obviously a significant building, to make sure that the interventions that we were doing made sense and were for the most part on the South Side. That doesn't mean that's not a primary facade, but it actually does mean we've been very thoughtful and worked with the client in terms of trying to really determine the minimal amount of exterior changes we can make. Again, you saw where there is the potential for a path from the carriage house, which we'll talk about in a second, actually, in the second job, to get into this portal. And then you will see in the new work that's being proposed, there's a garage that is being proposed back here. So, again, it makes sense the southeast corner to have that be the accessible entry into the building. In terms of continuing to look at accessible paths, you can see... And again, your purview is not the inside, but I just want to help lay the land for what we're doing. All of the bathrooms were last remodeled in the seventies. They're not in great shape, so all of the bathrooms are being remodeled. The kitchen is also last remodeled in the seventies. And so, again, we were tasked with how can we make this building livable for the twenties while also trying to keep the primary spaces as intact as possible. Part of that decision was to make bathrooms larger where we could, knowing that this existing three bathroom locations still were not going to be large enough to make them accessible. So knowing that, and understanding that the owner wanted to... I don't know how to... The owner was interested... How do I where's my little guy? Okay. So, the owner was very much interested in having... Why does it turn blue? Okay. Well, under the blue, the owner was very interested in having that southwest corner of the big building become their primary master bedroom and master suite. Part of that was because they actually really like the views out of that part of the building. And partly, it was because they knew there was an opportunity in this sunroom to actually be able to do something that was more accessible. So you can see we have worked to have an accessible toilet, accessible bathroom, accessible closet. And again, there is access off this back, but as we talked about, it's very, very far away from where cars would be parked. You can kind of see the blue dashed lines. This is... It's a big rambling beautiful house. And the reality is even in a big rambling beautiful house, if this is the accessible entry, someone is still going through this bedroom and or sitting room, right, to get into the kitchen or to go to the master bedroom. If we do not have this as the entry, and if we were to make this door wider, which again leads to a whole host of other issues, that means we are now potentially going through two different bedrooms, into a hallway, through the living room, through the dining room, through the kitchen. So again, part of the decisions that get made on the exterior have to do with how we think about the interior. So the enclosed sleeping porch on the north facade. As Lanny said, we think this was enclosed in the nineteen seventies. There's a photo saying, hey. Look. This is Andersen windows from the nineteen seventies, which I think is in your packet. It is clear that we are not intending to use this as a door into a sleeping porch anymore, and it's unclear if prior to the seventies it was a door into the sleeping porch. We know that when Mrs. Palahaimo died, again, this space started to be used for different things, and so we're not sure... In 2018, this space was used for office space. So we are asking to infill this door and the transom with the idea of keeping the wood trim there. So the memory, the idea of that sleeping porch does not go away. It's just that the door, in fact, goes away. As we move around the west side of the sleeping porch, again, as Lonnie said, you can see on the backside at some point. It is unclear and staff notes this in their comments. It's unclear if there were ever windows in these two locations. We can't find that. It seems like there may have been, but we don't know. But there's clearly precedent for infilling windows with stucco. And so the proposal again is to infill these two front windows, again, where we have the closet. There's pros and cons to everything. Right? If we leave the windows, we have more moisture, we have more issues with dampness. If we leave the door, we have potential for pests. We can absolutely add walls on the insides of that. Right? We can leave the door, add a wall inside. We can leave the windows, add a wall inside. We end up with maintenance issues. We end up with potentially bigger issues with condensation, and we also end up with windows that are not going to reflect the same anyway. So even though we would be doing something on the inside, it would still change the look on the outside. So, again, not publicly visible. So that green door on the north side is on the north side. Understanding all four sides are primary facades. Okay. So the enclosed sleeping porch. Staff is saying that it would be possible to add a window here because, again, they don't know if, at what point these were filled in or not filled in. In both this case and the green door on the front, the other recommendation that staff made or an option was to actually go ahead and put in plate glass and awning windows similar to what is in the rest of the sleeping porch. That is, I have to say, as a historic architect and an AFMA, because we don't know what is there. And the idea of having a significant structure where we're putting something in that actually is trying to mimic something that may or may not have been there, is not actually according to the secretary of interior standards. And we want old to be old and we want new to be new. So, moving around to the south, east corner of the building, Lanny mentioned that, and again, this is in the staff report. So I talked about this is that kitchen door that is just under 32 inches. This is the green door that goes into the basement that is 30 inches. And, again, this seems like the more opportune place to actually go ahead and do an opening. And we could... Truthfully, we made a choice of... We could do a single door which would need... Still may need this, let me slow down for a second. If we did a single door, this width is just under 34 inches. And so we would still need the ability to actually widen that opening in order to get the full, ideally, 36 inches. So the decision was made knowing that the majority of windows on the building are actually much narrower to actually go with two French doors that were two foot eight inches wide, so, or two foot six. So five foot total because that's in keeping with the language and the vocabulary of the architecture of the building. So the port hall knew this was going to be controversial. The reality is ideally, anytime you're aging in place, you have protected covering particularly for accessible entries or entries where you're coming in. One of the staff comments was, well, there's not accessible or there's not coverings from the garage or the carriage house to the main house, and so maybe this is too little too late. I'm putting words in your mouth. That's not exactly how you said it. I think any covering is better than no covering. And so, again, in talking with the owner, and understanding that the idea of having a port hall in this area would first... It would protect the opening. So it would allow some protection from the elements, and it would also allow us to better protect these this existing historic window and this existing historic door. It also allows us an opportunity to change these really dreadfully awful downspouts. And, again, this is not publicly visible. Right? This is tucked back around the corner. And the reason I say, and bring this up again is because when we get to the carriage house, staff makes a number of recommendations that it is possible to do things on the south side of that building because it's not publicly visible. Okay. So the bay window, also knew this was going to be controversial, so open to discussion. The reality is this window here is a Home Depot replacement that we have no idea when it was replaced. It is an aluminum inside outside. It's not even aluminum clad. It's just an aluminum window. The seals have failed, so at a minimum, this window needs to be replaced. Again, because we don't have any documentation of what window was in there, the decision was made to say, instead of doing some kind of false narrative of what this could have been, maybe we should actually just go ahead and do something different. I understand the complication that staff notes about the canted or the angled bay window and that may not be ideal. So if a box window is more appropriate by this board, we are potentially open to that. In all cases, this window has to be replaced. And again, this is about making the house livable as well, making sure there's adequate space within the building for maneuverability. Old house, pool house, and sauna, I don't think we need to talk about. And then again, Lonnie mentioned general repair. So I think some of you know I worked on this project in 2018 with the Palahama Foundation. So I have watched this building for years deteriorate, and so I am very excited about having somebody who is very interested in fixing it. One of the things that again, we noticed, and you can see down here, there's this kind of little flap of tar paper. We did a number of different kind of truth windows in 2018 to understand what was happening with the stucco in the base of the wall. And what we found, as Lanny mentioned, is that the stucco in the majority of the building is an inch and a half to two inches thick, and it is actually delaminating. So the stucco is so heavy, it's starting to crack and pull off of the wall. So the entire building is going to need to be restuccoed. The other thing that we found, and you can see that this is purposely down at the base of the wall, is it's not as visible on the main house as it is on the carriage house, which again is the next case number. But it's very clear at some point the stucco started to fail, and who knows when, and this was a very common thing in the seventies. The contrapoured came in, right, that concrete base. And so, there is a significant amount of basal wall damage down at the base. And so, again, removing the stucco will give us an opportunity to also take out that concrete base as well as do repairs to the walls themselves. The Vigas that Lonnie mentioned in terms of the Viga extensions, on this building, there's only the three that remain. And again, the idea is to repair those. They're pretty rotten, so I think they're probably getting replaced. And then actually come back in with a copper cap. Again, we know that's not historic, but part of actually taking care of a historic building is also setting it up for the future to make sure that it doesn't continue to fail. And then again, structural wood, and this is true at the front. All of the structural wood traditionally is stained, whereas all of the milled wood is painted. And so, the base of the columns at the front are also quite rotten at the bottom. And so, we're determining how far up that rot goes and how far deep the rot goes. So, anything that we're doing with structural wood, we will be replacing in kind. And again, we're taking an opportunity when the stucco is off to make sure that we are... do not have damage to the window box beyond because we definitely have indication of water penetration on the interior of the building. And with that, I stand for questions on the main house. Thank you very much for your presentation. Board members, any questions? Not at this time. Let's see, so we should maybe go to the public. Comments from the public. Anyone from the public i JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: in the room wishing to speak? Please come forward and get sworn in. Sir, please raise your right hand and state your name and address for the record. Sir, please raise your right hand and state your name and address for the record, and speak right in that microphone so we can hear you, please. Joe Scheps, 303 East Alameda, Santa Fe, New Mexico 87501. Do you solemnly declare and affirm the testimony you have in reference to this item is the truth, the whole truth, and do this under the penalties of perjury? Thank you. I just wanted to speak as a preservationist to tell you what respect is in this community for Barbara, but also for me for many, many, many projects. And I have jus PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): st seen historical styles begin to micromanage every project, and I don't see anything wrong with the end result of this project. And so much of it is not even visual to the public. And number two, I agree completely that it's fine to change a building's exterior if it's in the genre and taste of the neighborhood to make it more functional. And that is the issue to me is that I don't really quite understand what the problem is unless a bunch of neighbors have complained. And I just, I'm hopeful that you would give these owners a chance to, you know, breathe life back into that beautiful property. So thank you. Thank you. Please state your name and address for the record. Andrew Harris, 428 San Antonio. Andrew, do you solemnly declare and affirm the testimony yo JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: ou have in r reference to this project is the truth, the whole truth, and do this under the penalties of perjury? Yes, I do. I can't hear you in the microphone, sir. Yes, I do. Thank you. My wife and I, we own a historic home immediately Southeast of 166 Acequia Madre at 428 San Antonio Street that shares a wall with the Acequia PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): Madre house. Our property also shares the same ownership history as the Faneus Curtin family built both houses within one year of each other, and both carry the significant designation. I am here to support the application for the requested improvements to the residence. This is one of the most important territorial revival houses on the East Side, and the goal should be to keep it occupied, maintained, and lived in, not empty in a way that makes continued residential use impractical. And I'd like to appreciate Mr. Evans and think his interpretation of heritage and preservation should apply to this property as well. Our own significant property received approval previously for a new portal, and more recently, in 2024-25, a new garage, exceptions for our casita, and a brand new window on the main house. The same practical flexibility should be available here so the house can continue to function as a residence. This house has already adapted over a century while remaining significant. Approving these carefully limited exceptions, not only the one staff supports, but the ones that improve the habitability without harming the public street case or streetscape will help it ensure that it stays lived in as a home rather than becoming vacant. I respectfully urge the board to approve this application. Thank you. Thank you. Anyone else in the room wishing to comment? Hi. Please state your name and address for the record. Ceci JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: ily Hughes, 725 West Galena Avenue, Telluride, Colorado o. Thank you. Do you solemnly declare and affirm the testimony you have i PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): in reference to this item is the truth, t JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: the whole truth, and do this under the penalty of perjury? It's the truth. Yes, I swear. Thank you. Hi, my name is Cecily, and I lived in Santa Fe off and on for m PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): many years. And I have been working with the owners of this property for many years on many properties. The neighbors, the neighborhood would benefit greatly from them restoring the house. And I think Barbara has shown a lot of integrity in doing a lot of the research to get us to this point. So I would like the committee to understand, moving forward, that this family would like to live here and also, as you say, age out in the house. They're very spry. I don't think that's happening soon. But being in the house, going through the house, there are many ups and downs and windows and stairs, and I think pulling it together to make it a property that they will use is very important to them and also to the neighborhood. I love the idea that this is still going to be a single-family home. I grew up in Santa Fe and used to go to this house as a child. So I love the idea of it being a family home again. Thank you. Thank you very much for your comments. Anyone else in the room? Elizabeth? This is a wonderful house. I'm a n JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: newcomer. I came in 1966, but I was lucky to live i PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): in the n MARY ELLEN DEGNAN: next... Can you p PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): please speak into the microphone so we can hear you? Thank JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: you. I'm a newcomer. I came in 1966, and I kind of lived in that area for a while and just salivated over th PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): his house. It's just wonderful. I grew up in a wonderful old, old house in Cambridge, Massachusetts, and this doesn't look at all like, you know, colonial arts and crafts from the 1880s, but it has the same feel. So as far as feelings go, I just love it. I generally have a lot of respect for what staff says. And in this case, I think they've really done a careful job. However, I like the idea of many of the changes that the architect has suggested that the family wants. I'm, there's a lot to absorb. So I, I really appreciated hearing about the inside, although I know that's not the purview of the H-board. But actually, the work that Mr. Evans has been working on recently at Saint John's, an exception was given because of the importance of protecting an interior Gerard painting. And that was a method of understanding things, and I thought that was excellent. I've, in recent years, I've had visits there with the previous people who were taking care of it, and it's a magnificent place, so I'm thrilled about this. Okay. One or two specific things. I think a box window would be better than the bay window, but I definitely think a bump out there in some way is a very good idea. Doesn't, I don't mind the copper covering of the Vigas. They'll eventually look kind of greenish and wonderful. I, I think everything that's been proposed, almost everything that I heard is being done in a very respectful way. And so I, in general, am very much in support of this. I like the idea of the two French doors. The portal doesn't bother me at all, but I think I'm going to leave that up to the H-board to discuss that. And so I think this is a great project. Thank you. Thank you. Any other public comments in the room? Seeing none, we'll go to Zoom for public comments. No hands raised. Oh, wait JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: t. Hold on. Somebody has joined. David Rash, you've been previously sworn. Yes, thank you. David Rasch, 21 El Toro Road, El Dorado at Santa Fe. I really wa ant to thank staff, Lanny, for looking throu PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): ugh the exception criteria specifically to see if the applicant has conclusively demonstrated that the exception is necessary and met. This board doesn't do that enough. So I want to make sure you hear that. I'm very happy that Lanny is bringing that back in this way. It's necessary that you make a positive finding of fact that the applicant has conclusively demonstrated that they've met the exception. So thank you, Lanny. And Barbara's presentation from the inside out was excellent because the interior access really does affect the exterior in an interesting way, but a necessary way because I'm so proud there's someone finally going to take care of this building. It needs it very much. So, you know, Barbara did an excellent job of describing the need for what they're asking. It is excessive in my experience with the code, especially on a significant property. So this is where I just want to mention the exception criteria requests have to be essential. If they are not, once you buy a significant building, you buy the preservation that is required on every facade. So I ask the board to be very careful with each of the exception requests and make a finding for each whether you think they've met it or not. Thank you. Thank you. Any other members of the public on Zoom wishing to speak? No other hands raised. Thank you, JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: , Amanda. I'll bring it back to the board. Are there any questions for the applicant? Discussion? Sorry, Member Simmons, I'd like to make kind of an extensive comment here. I'm not sure when Santa Fe adopted the code to crea SCOTT CHERRY: ate significant structures. Santa Fe's code does not comport with the Department of Interior standards, and it seems to me that, I mean, I'm not sure why that was made necessary, but it's something that we have to deal with. I think that significant building is asking for exceptions everywhere. I think that the intent of the significant building is that nothing would happen and that everything that would happen would have to come to this board. Widen the focus a little bit. The 1957 ordinance was written by people who were concerned about aesthetics and had really nothing to do with historic preservation. As a matter of fact, the Historic Preservation Act didn't even come until ten years later, and then the standards for the Department of Interior didn't come for ten years after that. So, having said that, I think that everything in a significant building, and especially this building, is up for negotiation. And with respect to former planning director, Mr. Rasch, I think that, especially in this case and especially with the quality of the architect that this project has and with the cogency of her presentation, having demonstrated all along down the line the reasoning why this is necessary, I think that this board can be very accommodating to the proposal. With the exception of a north-facing door, everything else in this presentation is not visible from the public way. Everything is subordinate. There are minor programmatic changes to the buildings. Certainly, we need to get accessibility in a house like this. There's a criterion that the Department of Materials Standards deals with in removing historic materials: in removing historic materials to make way for something else, the requirement is, can it be reversed? And I think that every indication that Ms. Felix has given us is that any maneuver in this proposal can be reversed. I would make one request of the architect to possibly look for an alternative way of dealing with the sun porch, that sun porch is now 50 years old. And, as Mr. Evans said, buildings change over time. This building is changing over time. I would just like Ms. Felix to possibly look at an alternative rendering of those infills. Instead of stucco, there's possibly something else. I totally agree with you that it would be wrong to leave those windows and then put a wall on the inside because that's an impossible maintenance issue that would leave the windows there. But, I can understand the program of the closet and the master suite there. So I am very much in support of this proposal, and I believe that without having to get into the minutiae of lawyering through the exception criteria, I believe that the exception criteria is met in that this is largely maintenance, largely accommodating necessary programmatic changes. Thank you, Member Simmons. Any other discussion by the board? I think just in my experience, and maybe Attorney Rubi JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: iley can weigh in, I think we do need to address each of the exception criteria explicitly in the motion for the record. So, sorry that there's a lot of them, but it might be helpful to refer to Lanny's staff report, which lays those out. And as she summarized in the beginning, there's three exceptions required for modifications to the sleeping porch that remove openings on the primary facade. There's two exceptions for removal of historic material, and then three exceptions for, or sorry, two other exceptions for the addition of the port hall and the bay window. And Chair Beachside and Member Simmons, I would assume that's from Ms. Felix, and I hope I pronounced your last name cor CITY STAFF: rrectly. There is a letter where she addresses a lot of the exception criteria in light of the fact that the staff recommended against some of the exceptions. There needs to be something in the record that you can point to that you approve as articulating the exception criteria, and I believe that it would be appropriate, so that we don't go all night on this, to refer to some of the exception criteria that Ms. Felix put in her letter. Thank you. Any discussion from the board or a motion? Yes, may I be taken in? Thank you, Madam Chair. Mr. City Attorney, could you tell me a litt JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: tle bit more specifically how the motion should go? I MARY ELLEN DEGNAN: mean, do you want us to actually identify, enumerate, not only enumerate, but explain the exceptions for the record? I don't think you have to articulate each exception criteria, but I think that it would be important for you to JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: o note which exceptions are being grant CITY STAFF: ted. You know, that is to say, we are granting the exceptions, not going into the detail, but enumerating, naming them, identifying them. And for the reason stated in the record by Ms. Felix in her application letter or the reason stated by the staff in their staff report, assuming that the staff report did give the exception criteria. Okay. But if the staff said, I recommend this exception not be granted, then you can't rely on, you can't rest on the staff report. Right. But MARY ELLEN DEGNAN: t you c CITY STAFF: can rest on Ms. Felix's letter. I see. Thank you. That would probably be the clearest, you know, so that. Thank you. Alright. I guess it might be possible to take these in groupings if that's easier for a board member. We could address the groupings of excepti JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: ion criteria or the changes individually. Yeah, it's a complicated case, so we'll give you a minute to gather some thoughts. This is just the main house. And I also can't help but notice that Mrs. McCauley had a terrific slide where she showed all the exceptions that were being requested and she CITY STAFF: e broke out. So perhaps, Lanny, could I trouble you to put that slide back up? Because that, I really thought that it specific exceptions that were required. I think that's the one. Yeah. If he could, let me make it big for you. Yes. There you go. If everybody can read that, but it does a nice job of breaking out the exceptions. Mm-hmm. Thank you. Thank you, LANI MCCULLEY: , Lanny. Alright. I'll entertain CITY STAFF: a motion if anyone's ready. I'll make a motion. Thank you. In, where am I here? In the case of 2026-013419- JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: -HDRB. 616 Acequia Madre., I move that we approve the application as submitted with th SCOTT CHERRY: he following comments about the exception criteria. Exception criteria number one, 14-4-.6E41A, removing openings on primary facades for the existing door and transom on the north elevation. I think that we, I believe that we should accept that solution as appropriate, even though it does make a change to what's existing, that I believe that the programmatic requirements inside can have significant weight to allow this exception. I think we should go through and vote on each one of these exception criteria individually unless we want to make the world's longest motion. Chair of each item, Member Simmons, it's not a bad idea. I think, you know, I know we may end up with seven motions, but, you know, you're right. Otherwise, we have this big long motion t CITY STAFF: that somebody may not vote for because there's one element in there they don't like. So, you know. Yeah. Okay. Thank you. Will all the exception criteria votes capture everything in the submittal? I don't, I don't think so. If you state that on the record, you know, that for the reasons s JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: set forth in the record. I think I just, I'm referring to the changes that don't require exceptions. Can we captu CITY STAFF: ure those in a, you can capture those in a separate motion too. Okay. So you made up with eight or nine motions. A JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: Alright. Sounds good. Okay. So Member Simmons hasn't made a motion. Is there CITY STAFF: a second? Oh, second. So motion and a second for the first exception criteria for the door and transom on the sleeping porc JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: ch. Can I have a roll call vote, please? Member Simmons? Yes. Member Cherry? Yes. Member Degn MARY ELLEN DEGNAN: nan? Yes. The JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: e motion has passed. Thank you. And Ms. Evans, if you want to continue, that'd be great. Yes. I will make the same motion for exception criteria 14-4.6E41A, for changing windows on the west elevation of that sleeping porch. And are y SCOTT CHERRY: you stating for the record that the reasoning is the same based on testimony? Yes. Same reasoning. Second. Member Simmons? Yes. Member Cherry? Yes. Member Degnan? Yes. The motion has passed. Thank you. JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: Then the third motion is in 14-4.6E41, Roman numeral two, for removing historic material for the sauna and chan nging rooms. Those rooms are no longer pr rogrammatically functional, and I don't think the repu SCOTT CHERRY: urposing is appropriate in this case, and I think that the exception criteria to demolish those is met. I would second that, but did you miss, I think you missed one. Oh, you missed the third one? You skipped the third one. Oh, I'm sorry. Why don't we go back to that one, if that's okay? Sure. Yeah. Let's just keep th JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: hese in order. I seconded that. Thank you. Roll call vote on the demolition of the sauna and changing rooms. Member Simmons? Yes. Member Degnan? Yes. Member Cherry? Yes. Demolition is passed. Continuing on in criteria 14-4.6E41A, removing openi JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: ings primary facades, for the window opening on the south elevation at the east end. Second. Sorry. Were you finished with your motion? Yes. That's, yeah, tha SCOTT CHERRY: at's it. Okay. A roll call vote, please. Member Simmons? Yes. Member Cherry? Yes. Member Besheig? I mean, Member Tagmere? Yes. Thank you. The motion has pass JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: sed. Continuing 14-4.6E41, Roman numeral two, for removing historic materials. Infill wall of the south facade of the sleeping porch, same reasoning goes for the previous two. Second. Second. Sorry. Roll call vote. Member SCOTT CHERRY: Cherry? Yes. Member Degnan? Yes. Member Simmons? Yes. The motion is passed. Moving on, 14-4.6E2, Roman numeral two A, for constructing a bay window addition on the primary facade. I ag MARY ELLEN DEGNAN: gree with the ar JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: rchitect's summation is that window's been, it's not a historic window, and putting a bay window in the s SCOTT CHERRY: same opening to me is, is acceptable. So I recommend we accept that exception. Second. Little amendment here. I would, I would grant the architect and the owners to determine the configuration of that bay window themselves, whatever is appropriate. Second. Thank you. Vote. Member Simmons? Yes. Member Cherry? Yes. Member Degnan? No. The motion has passed. Moving on, 14-4.6E2, Roman numeral 2A, for constructing a portico on the South Side. I believe that exception criteria can be accepted. Second. Sorry. I broke off, but. JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: Member Cherry? Yes. Member Degnan? Yes. Member Simmons? Yes. The motion has passed. Th SCOTT CHERRY: hen, staff recommends approval for all other elements. So, of the design changes for the basic maintenance of the building, I recommend that we accept JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: all that. And second. Roll call vote. Member Cherry? Yes. Member Degnan? Yes. Member Simmons? Yes. The motion has pas SCOTT CHERRY: ssed. Thank you. We'll move on to the related case for the guest house at 616 Acequia Madre. Member, be shy. I'm sorry. Thank you, Amanda. What have I missed? JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: Thank you, Chair. I just wanted to let you know we only have the space until 9:00. Building closes. So, one suggestion that I might make is that just considering the time we have that we postpone items F through K to 12/08/2026 as we cannot get a quorum for t JOHN BIENVENU: the second meeting of November. So you think we, we have time for the next three cases? We can try and make it as fast as we can. And so I just wanted to provide the audience with notice that we probably won't get to those. I think I agree. Is there a motion to postpone the agenda from JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: m items F through K to a date certain, which is the first meeting in December? So moved. Second. JOHN BIENVENU: Thank you. Roll call vote. Member Simmons? Yes. Member Cherry? Yes. Member Degnan? Yes. The motion has JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: passed. Thank you. Thank you for that reminder. Now we'll go on to the guest house at Acequia Madre, 616 Acequia Madre. Lani, please give u SCOTT CHERRY: us your report. T JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: Thank you. Okay. So this next case for 616 Acequia Madre is case number 2026013420HDRB for the guest house, also known as the carriage house. So it depends on what page you're looking at what it's called. This structure is significant in Ave Downtown Eastside Histo JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: oric District. Aga LANI MCCULLEY: ain, the guest house is a territorial style building with Pueblo Revival portal elements, constructed of adobe and frame, which contains a small two-car garage, a separate single-car garage, and an adjoining L-shaped apartment. Nestled between the garages and on the south side of the building, the garage doors are carriage doors. The addition of the one-car garage on the east was in 1927. The addition of three rooms on the southeast and the northern porch was sometime between '27 and 1940. The addition of the shed-roofed frame garden shed on the south was sometime between 1974 and 1978. The applicant is requesting to remove the shed on the southeast corner of the guest house. The shed was removed prior to making this request, so this request is for retroactive approval. They also proposed to construct an 82-square-foot addition to a height of nine feet 10 inches, not 92, nine feet 10 inches, where existing height is 11 feet six inches on the southeast corner of the guest house. There is an existing toilet and sink stub out and vent pipe in this location, which provides the necessary piping for the addition. The addition will house a single exterior door on the east elevation and a single window on the south elevation. They want to repair the port halls. At the North Port Hall, the existing concrete slab will be demolished and replaced. And at the South Port Hall, the existing rotten wood posts and caps will be removed and replaced. Replacement of posts will match the size, detailing, and finish. The existing slab will be removed and replaced. Replace windows and doors. Under the South Port Hall is a window at the existing pantry. This window will be removed and replaced with a wood exterior door to create a storage closet. An exterior door on the west side will be replaced with a two-foot 10-inch by three-foot window, which will match the divided lights of the existing windows. Wood trim around the windows will be repaired. Concrete window sills will be replaced where they are failing with new concrete to match the existing shape and size, and repair all windows and screens in need due to damage and cracks. We will repair the south elevation garage doors if it is possible to make them functional. The applicant does propose to replace these doors if they find they are not repairable. The replacement would require another exception and should not be considered a portion of this request. These doors are considered one of the defining features of this facade. Increase the size of the garage door opening on the east facade, facing north. An exception is requested to 14-4.6E41B for altering the opening on the primary facade. The door opening is currently nine feet wide. The opening will be increased to 10 feet to fit modern vehicles in the garage. This replacement will result in a new wood lintel above the doors and a new wood door. Repair the adobe behind the stucco. Repair the adobe on the south elevation that's still laminating from the walls. Replace rotten wood features, and cover the vigas with copper flashing. Replace the canales with metal liner, and replace gutters, downspouts, and fascia. The metal fascia wrapping the parapet will be removed and replaced with new metal coping. Repair parapets, and repair the port hall decking. They also plan to replace the existing concrete slab on the east elevation, replace the basement covering on the south elevation, remove the roofing material that was previously used to patch a damaged area of the west wall, stucco using cementitious and marble white, stain using the enchanted ivy, and paint trim in a high reflective white. Exceptions are requested for 14-4.6E42 for removing historic material for the retroactive removal of the shed in the southeast corner, 14-4.6E41B for altering an opening on the primary facade for the widening of the easternmost garage door, 14-4.6E41A and B for replacing historic windows, for changing a door to a window on the south elevation under the portal, and for changing a window to a door on the west elevation under the portal. And to 14-4.6E22A for constructing an addition on a primary facade for the addition in the southwest corner. Again, I've placed red circles around the major alterations on each elevation. Here on this south elevation, the doors on the left will be widened. The port hall will be repaired including the replacement of some rotten wooden elements without replacing the port hall. This is the east elevation. The new addition on the southeast corner will be visible. This is the south elevation. The portal will be repaired with some replacement of rotten wood elements. The door will be replaced with a window, and the new addition will replace the removed shed structure. This is the west elevation. The addition will extend beyond the repaired port hall, and the window under the port hall will be converted to a door. The proposed colors will match the existing colors of the structure. Few exceptions on this one too, not quite as many. Staff finds that the exception criteria to section 14-4.6E42 for removing historic material have been met and recommends retroactive removal of the shed in the southeast corner. Staff finds that the exception criteria to section 14-4.6E41B for altering an opening on a primary facade have been met and recommends approval of the widening of the easternmost garage door. Staff finds that the exception criteria to section 14-4.6E41A and B for altering an opening on the primary facade have been met and recommends approval of the changing of a door to a window. Staff finds that the exception criteria to section 14-4.6E41A and B for altering an opening on a primary facade have been met and recommends approval of changing a window to a door. Staff finds that the exception criteria to section 14-4.6E22A for constructing an addition on a primary facade have been met and recommends approval of the addition in the southwest corner. Staff also recommends approval of the other elements of the application except for the replacement of the garage doors, as that request would require an exception and further review as these elements all comply with 14-4.6E general design standards and 14-4.6G2 for Ave Downtown and east side design standards. Thank you, Lanny. So you agree with the exception criteria being matched in every case, except for the replacement garage doors, which you're considering a separate ask. Correct. So the way that they wrote it was to repair those doors with the possibility of replacement. Okay. And so this case is actually for the repair. If they need to replace it, JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: they'll need to come back for that exception. Okay. Thank you. Any questions for staff from the board? Yes. I just have a detailed question here. The door that's bei LANI MCCULLEY: ing replaced and the opening widened, your recommendation or your staff report is that you say the criteria has been met? Yes. That's for the easternmost garage door. Could you tell me what the basis of that is? I can go back to my criteria. Sorry. I mean, it's op JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: pening on a prim SCOTT CHERRY: mary facade. Right. It's, right now the door is nine feet wide. Right. Standard vehicle is wider than that. So the idea is to widen it by one foot, staying within the parameters of that addition, an LANI MCCULLEY: nd so that they can use it for a SCOTT CHERRY: an actual vehicle. So standard parking space in Santa Fe i LANI MCCULLEY: is nine feet wide? The vehicles aren' SCOTT CHERRY: 't 10 feet or nine feet wide. Ye LANI MCCULLEY: eah. It's the opening standard, not a vehicle standard. Okay. Barbara has corrected me. So the doors are currently eight feet and they're widened to nine feet. Okay. Sorry. It's right there on the dimension. Okay. Thank you very much. Other questions for Lani? Miss Felix, SCOTT CHERRY: , if you'd like to give us your presentation. Yes. So I JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: think, in light of the timing, I'm not going to give you a presentation, and hold it to the new work. I do want to LANI MCCULLEY: o, yes, the existing garage doors are eight feet. And so, again, working with the owner and in consultation, it w SCOTT CHERRY: was like, we cannot change all of them. That's not going to ge JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: et through historic, and it really is going to change what the north side of the PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): building looks like. So if we can at least get one semi-working garage out of what is traditionally the garage building, that's really the goal. So, and in terms of the pair of doors that are underneath the portal, Lanny is correct. We did say that the doors are actually, they look great on the outside and on the inside. They have been, walls have been added and all kinds of crap is on the inside of those. So I'm pretty sure we can repair those and leave them as is. That is the goal. But we really are not going to know until we start pulling off the back of that wall. And so, yes, we will be happy to come back if something changes that. Any questions from the board for the applicant? Any public comments from people in the room? Anyone on Zoom wishing to speak? No hands raised. We'll come back to the board for any discussion or a motion, please. I have a, I have a question. Secretary. Just seems slightly different than the other case and that we could probably capture this all in motion if the motion were JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: to agree with staff's recommendation because there's no disagreements. So would you agree with that, attorney Rubeliet, or as an efficient path forward? Well, it would speed things up, just the same concern JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: I had with the last one, at Cherry Beach High and member Cherry is that you might get in with a thing where you have this long motion and somebody votes against it just because they're opposed to one element. You know? And so then the motion has to be recast and somebody votes against it because they, or they could CITY STAFF: d, that person could make a friendly amendment. Well, that, that could be too, but, you know. Alright. So it's, it's up to you. But. Why don't we give that a try? One motion? Yeah. Yep. I'll go for it. Thank you. So, in case 20260132420HTRB616, Secu Madre, I would move to approve the application as proposed, finding that all the exception criteria have been met for the removal of the shed in the southea JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: ast corner, widening the CITY STAFF: east most garage door, changing the, changing of the door to the window, changing of the window to the d JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: door, addition, in the southeast corner, and for, and for the restoration of the double garage doors. Second. Any discussion? Roll call vote, please. Member Simmons? Yes. Member Degnan? Yes. Member Cherry? Yes. The motion has passed. Yes. I'm sorry. That included all of the exceptions, but it did not include the general maintenance components of the. Okay. I'll make a second motion. Thank you. To. Thanks, Lanny. So, in case 2026013420HDRB616 Acequia JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: Madre would move to accept all the general maintenance requests in the application. And the second. Second. I need Member Degnan. Second. LANI MCCULLEY: . Third. Welcome to that, please. Member Degnan? Yes. Member Cherry? Yes. Member Simmons? Y JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: Yes. Motion has passed. Good work. Thank you. Thank you, Lanny. SHAWN EVANS: Thank JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: k you, guys. And for the last related case, for the new construction at 616 Acequia Madre, please. You'll be happy to find this one has no exceptions. So SCOTT CHERRY: the foll JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: lowing case for 616 Acequia Madre is case number 2026013425 HDRP for the new construction elements of the overall project. So this is a slightly over three-acre property. Currently has the main residence, guest house, and old corral. The applicant is proposing to construct two fr LANI MCCULLEY: reestanding structures on the property and a new yard wall on the east, west, and south sides of the property. The walls will average six feet and will be masonry with cementitious stucco. The plane will be broken by 32-inch pilasters spaced 32 and 37 feet along the wall. Windows and wood shutters will further break up the massing of the wall. The top of the wall will vary in height as required by the fence and wall guidelines. The arbol does not extend to the north side. The existing open wire fence along the arroyo, as well as the existing stucco yard wall and wood gates leading into the property, will be remaining. And the applicant is planning to construct a 1,872 square foot territorial style garage to a height of 12 feet eight inches, where the maximum allowable height is 15'1". The garage will have brick coping lined with metal. On the east elevation, the vehicle doors will be carriage style doors with glazing. There will be a four-inch wood trim above the vehicle doors. There are no openings on the north elevation. The south elevation will house two sets of windows that are two over two in triple sets. The west elevation will hold a pedestrian door and two windows, each being two over two, as well as a port hall with wood corbels, post, and beams. The will be covered with patina copper caps. The floor will be flank stone. The roof will be metal with, the canales of the garage will be wood with metal lining, and the garage will be stuccoed in cementitious, and marble white under the portal and the inset around the vehicle doors. The wood will be stained in enchanting ivy. That's the wrong color. Hawthorne. Thank you. That's not the right color. And on structural members of the portal, finished trim around windows will be high reflective white paint. And, I did put some slides here together for your elevations just so you have them. This is the north and east elevations of the garage, and then the south and west elevations. So the drawings that are being shown on the screen now are old drawings that have been updated. Are they updated drawings in the packet? I took these out of the packet, so my guess is this is I'm the wrong pick... wrong ones are in there as well. Do we have the updated drawings? With it... Does the city have the updated dra JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: awings? Yeah. Are we able to determine if the packet was complete, if we are able... Oh, okay. Oh, is it? Yes. Okay. So apparently, I h LANI MCCULLEY: had it right in the packet, not in the presentation. I apologize. Let me go back a little bit. I'm going to j JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: just describe the Maybe we can just move the recommendation and defer to Miss Felix to provide a bit of an overview of what the changes maybe. Okay. I'm going to finish the p PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): proposal l if that's LANI MCCULLEY: okay. Mm-hmm. So the, the rest of the proposal is to construct a 1,283 square foot territorial style studio JOHN BIENVENU: to a height of 12 feet eight inches where the maximum allowable is 15'1". The studio will have brick coping lined on with metal. The north elevation will... LANI MCCULLEY: . has the main entrance, which will be a double door. The entrance will sit between, are these details correct still, between two matching windows of two over two lights in triple sets with wood headers. The entry and windows will be under a portal with wood corbels, posts, and beams. The will be covered with patina copper caps. The floor will be flagstone. Roof will be metal with drip edging. The east elevation will have four windows of two over two lights with wood headers. South elevation will have no openings. The west elevation will have two entry doors with a single window between them and a second window set back on the larger massing. The windows will be two over two. The canales of the studio will be wood with metal lining. Stucco will be cementitious tourion and marble white. And, trim again will be in reflective white paint. And then they're also going to construct a three foot six inch high yard wall at the studio to create a small courtyard area. And my guess is my drawings are still wrong, so I'm just going to flip through those. The proposed colors will match those of the main residence in the guest house, and staff is recommending approval of the proposed project and finds that the application does comply with sections 14-4.6e, general design standards for all Historic District, and 14-4.6g2 for Ave Downtown and East Side standards. And I will close this so you can open Thank you, Lanny. The correct times. I'm sorry. Any questions for staff? Alright. That's yours. I'm sorry. Member Cherry? Yeah. I guess, I'm just curious about what's different about the draw... We were just looking at the drawing on the packet and the one up there, and they look the same. So it's Yeah. Can we just have the applicant address the changes? Yea JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: ah. Thank you. Miss Felix, if you wouldn't mind JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: d telling us where the differences are from what we receive on the screen versus what's in the packet incorrect? Okay. So I'm going to get us right to those then. So I can tell you what happened is, the size of the, the size of the studio and the, JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: garage and the, mysterious barn as well as the carriage house and the main house, the five structures just tipped us over 10,000 square feet. PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): . And so, we made a change again with the owner because we are not interested in going after a development plan. So, knowing that the main house, the barn, and the carriage house are not changing size other than the small additions that we added, we actually made both the garage and the studio both just a titch smaller so that we're now total under 10,000 square feet. So visually, we also changed the port holes, because we didn't think that was actually appropriate when we started thinking about it. So this is what I have in your packet. This is what shows in my packet. So I think this is what is in your packet as well. So, what was originally proposed was we were going to actually have, a cantilevered roof that was going across the, the front, where we have the portals, and we actually have gone ahead and built portals with posts and beams and corbels, which again, we have done these in a different style than what's on the main house because new is new, old is old. We don't want to match those completely. We are showing that there would be metal caps on the top of the Vigos, metal caps on the end of the corbels because we actually have them extending out past. We went around and looked at different historic details in the city. So conceptually, they're very, very similar, but both structures are a little bit smaller. And, again, the portal really changed on both of them. So, again, garage is the same thing. We didn't change the doors conceptually. The building is a little bit smaller, and, again, we changed the corbel portal design, so it's no longer cantilevered. Thank you. Yes. We do have the updated drawings in our packet. Thank you for confirming that. Are there any questions for, Miss Felix? Member Cherry? Sorry. I thought you were getting ready to say something. Any Matters from the Pu JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: ublic wishing to speak? In this case, in the room? Anyone on Zoom? No hands raised. No. We appreciate it. Alright. I'll entertain a motion. I'll make a motion. So in case 202601342580TRB616 Secu Madre. For the proposal to construct a 1283 square foot studio and a 1,876 square foot. Are those numbers correct? No. Okay. The studio is 1,581 square feet, and the ga JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: arage is 1,024 square feet. 1,024. Correct. And because the sizes are smaller, it still comports with public notice requirements. Gotcha. So, I'll just start over. In case, 2026 PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): 6013425 HDRB 616 Acequia Madre in Ave Downtown Eastside Historic Distr JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: rict would move JOHN BIENVENU: to approve the application as submitted, to construct a 1,581 square foot studio. Sorry. I we JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: ent back... Did I go backwards on that? The studio is 1,024 square feet. The garage is. Okay. So 1,000... Got gotcha. So I had it right. The 1,581 square foot studio and a 1,024 square foot garage. Finding that all the criteria for the construction within the district have been met. Is ther PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): re a second? Second, Degnan. Than JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: nk you. Roll call vote. Member Simmons? Yes. Member Cherry? Yes. Yes. Member Degnan? Yes. The motion has passed. Yeah. I'll make a second motion regarding the yard wall then. S JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: So in case, 2026013425 HTRB 616, Acequia Madre, Downtown Eastside Historic District would move to approve the construction of the proposed yard wall, JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: , finding that meets the criteria set forth in the standards in the district. Daigne. Second. Thank you. A roll call vote, please. Member Cherry. Member Dagnon. Yes. Yes. Member Simmons. Yes. The motion is passed. Thank you. Thank you, Lanny, for catching that. Alright. And may I make one JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: e small comment? I'd like to commend the architect on her recessing the garage doors on the garage, picking up the design element of the existing garage. I just think this is an extremely sensitive maneuver on your part, and I want to commend you for that. Alr SCOTT CHERRY: right. I will move on to the last case that we'll hear this evening, which is at 481 Oreo Tenorio. This case is by Mister Mellon. Sorry. Case number D was postponed. That was set at the beginning of JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: f the reports from the staff. The Gildersleeve St was postponed. Yes. We have a, Member Cherry, had to recuse himself from that case, so that case is automatically postponed until we have a quorum. I'm sorry. We announced that in the beginning g of the hearing that post... that case was postponed, and, also, I believe, Manager, Mellon reached out to the, agents this afternoon when we found that out. I'm sorry about that. We can't hear it without a quorum this evening. Okay. I'll just go ahead and hear case, at 48 81 Arroyo Tenorio, please. I... Yeah. Just in terms of, Gildersleeve St did send an email, I don't know what time it was, 3:00 or something, saying that it was not going to be heard because, Member Cherry has to recu AMANDA ROMERO: use himself. So then we only have three members, so we can't take any action on it. So I did send that. I can check the time, but it was about 3:00 today. What was the reason for refusing? Because Mister Cherry, I believe, was involved in... Again, this was not my project, but, was involved in this in some... Yeah. I was... I di JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: id the window assessment. He's not allowe AMANDA ROMERO: ed to do it. So when... If I've worked on a project, I mean, some... Sometimes, I think I remember you. Yeah. So sometimes, when I work... Because I work on a lot o JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: of projects, I can, I can sit on the board and vote on them? But, you know, in consulting Attorney Rubelie that... with this one that I mentioned in the in the application, and so it just... it was recommended that I recuse myself. Yeah.... Curious? No. That's fine. Yeah. I can understand you wanting to understand. Oh, yeah. I'm sorry. Yeah. Thank you, Member Bishaid. I think we need to move on to the next... And it's live entertainment. Thank you all. Thank you. Let's move on to a real scenario, please. Alright. We wil JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: ll try to be brief here but, touch on all the important points. This is case number 20 dash... Excuse 2026-013370-HDRB. 481 Arroyo Tenorio.. This is a building that's lo AMANDA ROMERO: ocated in Ave Downtown and Eastside Historic District applicant is requesting historic status review and primary facade designation, if applicable, for the main residence and also for two secondary structures, including a garage building and yard wall. I am going to skip through a little bit about the history. This is a site I walk by quite often. It's located behind a very tall river stone yard wall, northeast of the winding gravel road to the south in Ave Downtown and Eastside Historic District house was constructed circa 1934 in the Territorial style, and both the house and the secondary garage building are currently designated as non-contributing, while the yard wall has no historic status. The street that this is on is an interesting mix of both contributing and non-contributing buildings. As noted, the main residence was constructed circa 1934. It's a 1480 square foot building. It's historically associated with Pennsylvania Catherine Fairley. She was a long-term resident, living there from 1935 to 1970. I'm going to skip through a little bit about the history. I will note on this, following her death in 1970, the Western Guest House was connected to the main residence, the portal added to the south elevation, and an addition made to the central north elevation between 1973 and 1978. While these are not obviously associated with her period of ownership, the development does meet the 50-year historic threshold for contributing status. Alright, we're going to keep going. The south elevation, which is up before you, is quite wonderful. It presents some of the oldest features on the residential building, with the central and eastern sections demonstrating the oldest features in the Territorial style and additions adjoining semi-detached buildings along the western side of the building. The historic hotel is located at the center of the elevation setback from the southeast massing, and it has this wonderful kind of shape to it that it's acquired over time, which staff has talked about, which I think is pretty wonderful. I'm going to keep going here since we're short on time. To the southwest of the building is a second portal built shortly after the longtime owner Farrelly's death, somewhere between 1970 and 1973. As noted, this historic development joined the guest house to the main residence. Okay, keep going here. The west elevation is part of the office or guest house building with attributes of the 1970 circa 1973 addition. The north elevation shows the majority of the alterations that have occurred primarily from 2008, so non-contributing, when owners Karen Mancini and Don de Sankres used the architect John T. Midgett the Third. He designed two additions. Keep going. The southeast corner of the east elevation retains the historic tile style materials and association with the Territorial Revival style section of the residence. Keep going. North of the gated stucco wall begins the section of the building associated with the 2008 addition that was designed by Mr. Midgette, architect Midgette. As you can see, it's a little bit different and clearly can be seen. The garage structure is quite old. It's dated to circa 1940. However, in looking at aerial photos and other resources, it has seen a number of considerable alterations, and that gets to the recommendation. The difference in the garage door dimensions when you compare the aerials, it appears that the eastern section of the building is a non-historic addition. And as a result, the garage has seen considerable alterations. And we'll get through the recommendation in a minute. Sorry. The yard wall, which you're going to walk by often, is quite lovely. It runs the length of the property lying along Arroyo Tenorio present in historic aerials. I mean, it has a pretty prominent presence on the streetscape and limits the view into the site. Okay. So let me get to what the recommendations are. So in a nutshell, what is being recommended, due to the series of alterations to the garage, we are recommending that it retain its non-contributing status. The yard wall, given its apparent age and its integrity, we are recommending that the yard wall be upgraded to a contributing structure. And then in terms of the house itself, I apologize for the technical problems here, we're recommending that the residential structure be upgraded to contributing with the south and east elevations as the primary facades, R1, let me see if I can get back here, sorry. There we go. R1, R2, R3, R4, R5, and R22 per 14-4.6C designation of significant contributing or non-contributing status within Historic District. So quick recap, upgrade the primary residence to contributing, upgrade the wall to contributing, keep the garage as non-contributing. I hope that makes some sense. Thank you for speeding that along. Any questions from the board? We'll go to the applicants. Please be sworn in. Hi. Please state your name and ad JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: ddress for the record. Paul Mifsud, 557 Onate Place, Santa Fe. Do you solemnly declare and d affirm the testimony you have in reference to this item is the truth, the whole truth, under the penalty of perjury? I do. Thank you. It has been sworn. Thank you. Please let us know anything you'd like to tell us about the case and whether or not you agree with staff's recommendation. Yeah. First, I'd like to make one correction to John's presentation. The square footage of the house is not 1,480 square feet. It wa PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): as originally in 1975 or 1935 when it was constructed. Now it's over 5,000 square feet. Constructed in 1934 or 1935, don't really know. It was originally constructed at 1,480 square feet with a relatively simple L-shaped plan. Successive additions have expanded the residence to approximately 5,205 square feet, absorbing the original building within a much larger and more complex composition and substantially altering its historic form, scale, and mass. Following the original owner's death, the property underwent a more substantial series of alterations as successive owners expanded and updated the approximately 40-year-old residence at the time. There was an addition, an enclosed passageway as John described. Five years after that, the formerly semi-detached guest house was enclosed on all sides except for its portal and was connected to the existing garage, which is no longer a garage. The final major phase of the expansion occurred in 2008. Architect John Midgette, my fellow Tulane alumni, designed two additions along the north elevation. He combined forms and materials derived from traditional adobe architecture with a contemporary design. The eastern portion of the north elevation opens onto a large roofed patio. The irregularly shaped roof and apparently much of the fenestration beneath it resulted from alterations designed by John Midgette and approved by the Historic District Review Board in 2008. And I'd be curious to know why the board didn't designate it as contributing then. Although this area includes traditional materials and detailing, the scale, irregular configuration, and extensive glazing clearly distinguish it as a later addition. The irregular footprint wraps around the earlier building mass and contributes substantially to the complexity of the residence's present plan. The addition contains large modern windows with applied wood lintels intended to evoke traditional vigas. Through these cumulative additions and connections, the residence grew from approximately 1,480 square feet to approximately 5,205 square feet, an increase of nearly 252%. More importantly, the addition substantially altered the building's historic spatial organization and architectural character. The original residence is no longer readily discernible as an independent architectural volume. Instead, it has been incorporated into a much larger assemblage of formally detached buildings and later additions. What had been a relatively modest residence with associated secondary buildings now reads as a single, sprawling, interconnected composition. As a result, the building no longer retains sufficient integrity of design, materials, workmanship, feeling, and association to convey its historic character during the period of significance. The Santa Fe Land Use Code describes a contributing structure as, "The contributing structure may have had minor alterations, but its integrity remains." We don't feel that the integrity of the original structure remains, and we believe it should remain non-contributing. Thank you. And I know that's consistent with the HICCPE report that was prepared in part of the packet. Any quest JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: tions from the board for the applicants? Mr. Simmons? Did I hear that the original house had an attached garage at one time? A small detached garage. A small detached g PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): garage. And a detached office. Can you... And they were all absorbed into it in the forties or fifties? No, I'm sorry, in the seventies. Can you outline on that on that plan there what was the original core of the house? Sorry. Can you use the microphone? Sorry SCOTT CHERRY: y. Mr. Mifsud. Original. It's the front portion right along here. Like that. Oh, I' JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: 'm looking at it over there. Yeah. Sorry. We don't see that on the screen. Let me see if I can AMANDA ROMERO: n go back to some of the i PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): images so yo AMANDA ROMERO: ou can see... There you go. Laser pointer. So t JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: that's the front. T AMANDA ROMERO: Then if we go back to what is being record... This is the portal on the front that we saw there, that kind of wonky. And then it just, as the owner said, it kept getting expanded and kind of... And that portal is going to fall on somebody and kill them. So we're going to reconstruct. Sir, you have to be on the microphone in order for it to be on the record. When we come back next mon PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): nth, we're going to request to tear down that portal and rebuild it so it doesn't fall on stock. Ma'am, we're only discussing the status here, not what might be done to the project. So please share that. Thank you. Any que JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: estions for the applicant? Oh, I have a question for staff. So what... Why, I mean, it is quite an altered building based on the definition. I t JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: think the applicant makes kind of a compelling case, you know, reflecting on the definition of what makes a building contributing. Why do you consider it to be contributing? Right. Yes. I mean, let's go back here. So I did talk about this with Lauren, and it would be similar to... You menti AMANDA ROMERO: ioned Tulane. I have some relatives in New Orleans. There are many historic buildings in New Orleans, but in many other cities, Savannah, Georgia, where I used to work, where you have the front portion of a building that is the historic building that's still there. And then on the back, right, you know, additions were put on and more additions. Where I am from the Northeast, it's quite common, up where we have a house in Connecticut to have the historic more... We used to own a house from the 1700s. It was a very modest little box, and then there were additions that were added on to it. So the argument that we're making here is that... And, again, we're not proposing that, if we go back to here, as I mentioned, what's basically saying would be the contributing facades would be right around here. And so I guess the other example I would use is if you've seen a lot of the developments that are done in urban centers where you have a historic, like, bank building, and then there's new construction added on to it either, you know, many years ago or more recently, the front portion is still considered a contributing building. You can have contributing elements and non-contributing elements within a within a building if that makes sense. Mhm. So that was the rationale here. If what we're looking at right now, by your fellow Tulane alum, had been completely, you know, encased with a new addition on the front like was done on the back, we would not be saying that this should be a contributing building, because then there wouldn't be anything left. But there's still enough here. I think one of the board members talked about the Secretary of the Interior standards. Obviously, the owner is not going to do this. Future owners probably wouldn't do this, but you could remove later additions. And I've actually seen that in the Northeast where some people actually, this may sound strange, but they've actually reduced the size of their buildings and taken them back to much smaller structures. So I hope that all makes some sense. Yeah, what I disseminate from that is you're saying that enough of the origin JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: nal character of the building on those facades that you've identified, 5, 4, 3, 2, 1, and 22, remain intact as they were originally for the entire building to be designated contributing in your opinion with those as the primary facade. Correct? Yes, that's the case we're making. Okay. Is everything we see in this picture part of the AMANDA ROMERO: original construction except for the entry door p SCOTT CHERRY: pump outs? Yeah, that's the belief. Yes. I mean, that, I mean, there have been changes over time, o AMANDA ROMERO: obviously. But, but, but my question is, is this, is this the original structure that we're looking at? Yes, on the fron SCOTT CHERRY: nt. Right, the dining room on the end. But the, yes, the Portel, I mean, obviously this is not a 1980s o AMANDA ROMERO: or 70s addition. This is the front. This was the modest structure that, thank you for correcting if I misspoke, the original very modestly scaled, you know, 1,500 square feet roughly, building that then was added on to as the applicant noted and as we noted in the staff report and also kind of where things were kind of combined. So you ended up with a very large house. And the dining room is at the far right hand side of that photo. And when was that added? R JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: Right over there. I, okay. So it may not be original, but it's just, right. Potentially, but again, it's historic AMANDA ROMERO: c, though. We're getting into, yes, it may, I'm going to date myself, but yes, things from the seventies and or almost to the point in the eighties where things are becoming, quote, historic if they're fifty years. Okay. I think, sorry, wait, sorry, one more question. We need to move on. I think we're o JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: over time now. I have a question. Yep. Sorry. Member typed in? Oh, thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. AMANDA ROMERO: Mr. Mellon. Yeah, I gue JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: ess I think I know the answer, but I wan MARY ELLEN DEGNAN: nt to be clear on it. So in a situation like this, in a situation like this, the core, the original house is historic. Can part of that actual structure be not historic? Where I'm going with that is, you know, you'd like to have a little tidy thing where one building is and the addition isn't, but I mean, can part of the original be historic and part of it not? Part of the original building. Yeah, I mean, because of all of it. I mean, I'm j AMANDA ROMERO: just, oh, yeah. Or I JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: mean, would, I mean, obviously, because of the additions and I have not been inside the hous AMANDA ROMERO: se, obviously, I would assume that many of the, I mean, all, all the windows and doors that would have used to be facing out, mhm, are gone. I don't know how many of the interior walls that used to be exterior walls, like on the back, right, if they're still there. I, I don't, no, I haven't, you know, been inside. Okay, thank you. They're probably gone, I would guess. But I don't know. Often people to save money would keep, you know, walls when they add it on. Okay. Number seven. So is Elevation R 22, is that part of the o JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: original house or SCOTT CHERRY: was that the nineteen seventies addition? Let's see here. Let me get to, sorry. That is an addition, AMANDA ROMERO: but the argument that is being made is that it's still due to its date would be historic. So that was built in the seventies. Yes, exactly. So you'r SCOTT CHERRY: re now, yes, we've reached the time where the seventies are a long time AMANDA ROMERO: ago. Yes. Do you know when in the seventies? Because that becomes somewhat critical. I do not know R 22. I, we can check JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: k on that. I'm going AMANDA ROMERO: g to take, so I'm going to take public comment n JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: now if there's anyone in the room that would like to comment or anyone online. We have one member of the public online. David, you have been sworn. Thank you. Yes, David Rausch. So this is a very d PUBLIC COMMENTER (JENNICA KILBRIDE): difficult case, but I have to first divulge that at least one of these remodels was one of my cases at the age board. But the east facade is historic and it is intact. It has its integrity. That's why I also recommend contributing status. But even more so, because I know this building so well, the designers of the additions, the later additions, are very well known as Santa Fe designers. And I believe the additions on this building are some of their best work. So it also deserves preservation in the future. So I would highly recommend being careful about how you designate contributing and include other significant elevations by these later well known Santa Fe designers. Thank you. Thank you. Okay. Thank you. I'll bring it JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: t back to the board for discussion or a motion. You know, integrity is just a huge thin SCOTT CHERRY: ng. And, you know, I really respect Jonathan's perspective on things. You know, he's been on, he's seen a lot. So with that said, I am prepared to make a motion to accept staff's recommendation to designate facades R 22, R 1, R 2, R 3, R 4, and R 5 as contributing, and all the other facades as non contributing. So, and let's not forget to status th JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: he garage and the wall as well. I would also include that the front wa SCOTT CHERRY: all on the street is contributing and that the garage is non contributing. Can I make a friendly amendment? W JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: We need a second first. I'll sec JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: cond it. And friendly amendment would j JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: just be a technicality, but that you're designating the building is contributing with R 5, 4, 3, 2, 1, and 22 as primary facades. That's what I meant. Okay. Because you said contributing and not, that, that was the intention. Okay. But, yeah, I'm just clarifying. Thank you. Yep. Thank JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: you. Roll call votes. Member Simmons? Yes. Member Cherry? Yes. Member Daigman? Yes. The motion has passed. Thank you. I think that concludes the cases that we'll hear this evening. Any Discussion Items, not at this time. Solution? Yes. I, thank you. Discussion Items, Matters from the Board the next meeting is not on November 24. Is that right? That's correct, Cherry. It is December 8. Expedited is December 8. Thank you. And motion to adjourn? To move JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: e. Second JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: d. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. Aye. Thank you.