Historic Districts Review Board Meeting Tue, Oct 13, 2026 · Historic Districts Review Board https://santafeminutes.space/meeting/1168-historic-design-review-oct-13-2026 == Executive Summary == The Historic Districts Review Board met on 10/13/2026, addressing several property status reviews and a proposed remodel. Key decisions included designating 713 Dunlap Street as a contributing historic structure with its south facade as primary, and classifying 1545 Canyon Road as non-contributing due to significant alterations. The Board also approved a remodel and addition project at 330A East Buena Vista Street and designated 311 Old Santa Fe Trail as non-contributing. The meeting also covered administrative items such as approving minutes and findings of fact, and introducing the new Historic Preservation Manager. Discussions were held regarding proposed amendments to city boards and commissions, with concerns raised about the process and communication with the Governing Body. Staff were tasked with providing summaries of these discussions and making a window informational session video available. == Key Decisions == - Approved agenda changes, minutes from 10/27/2026 and 09/22/2026, and six findings of fact and conclusions of law. - Approved the 2027 Historic Districts Review Board Calendar. - Designated 713 Dunlap Street as a contributing historic structure, with the south facade (facade number two) as the primary facade, excluding non-historic materials like the metal door from the designation. - Designated the residence at 1545 Canyon Road as non-contributing, along with the office, freestanding carports, and fence gate. - Designated the building at 311 Old Santa Fe Trail as non-contributing. - Approved the remodel and addition project at 330A East Buena Vista Street, which includes converting an existing garage into living space, adding a new garage and storage, replacing windows, and installing a fence. == Motions & Votes == - Motion to approve agenda changes — Passed by voice vote (aye) - Motion to approve minutes from 10/27/2026 and 09/22/2026 — Passed by voice vote (aye) - Motion to approve six findings of fact and conclusions of law — Passed by voice vote (aye) - Motion to approve the 2027 HDRB Calendar — Passed by roll call vote (all 'yes' except Chair Rios who said 'no' in jest) - Motion to recognize 713 Dunlap Street as 'contributing' with the south facade (facade number two) as the primary facade, with a friendly amendment to exclude any non-historic materials on this facade from the designation — Passed by roll call vote (all 'yes') - Motion to designate the residence at 1545 Canyon Road as non-contributing, and to adopt staff's recommendations for the office, freestanding carports, and fence gate as non-contributing — Passed 3-2 - Motion to designate the building at 311 Old Santa Fe Trail as non-contributing — Passed unanimously - Motion to approve the project at 330A East Buena Vista Street, accepting staff's recommendations — Passed 5-0 - Motion to adjourn — Passed unanimously == Public Comment == Jonathan Mellon, the new Historic Preservation Manager, expressed his pleasure to be in the city and excitement to work with the board. Mr. Purvis, the applicant for 713 Dunlap Street, agreed with staff's recommendation and expressed intent to fix up the building. Courtney Mate, the applicant for 1545 Canyon Road, provided additional context regarding the original layout of the main residence's portal. Jeff Sears, representing the owners of 330A East Buena Vista Street, agreed with the staff report. Frank, an attorney, provided a detailed report on the outcome of the 515 Paseo De Peralta appeal and upcoming appeals. == Topics == - Proposed Code Changes - Appeals to Governing Body - 713 Dunlap Status - 1545 Canyon Road Status - Historic Preservation Manager - HDRB Calendar 2027 - Window Informational Session - 515 Paseo De Peralta Appeal - 1295 Cerro Gordo Road Appeal - 320 Paseo De Peralta Mural Appeal == Full Transcript == AMANDA ROMERO: Okay. CITY STAFF: Chair Rios, we're ready to begin when you're ready. CECILIA RIOS: . Good evening, everyone, and welcome to this meeting of the Historic Districts Review Board. Today, we are 10/13/2026. May we have a roll call, pleas CITY STAFF: se? Member Cher SCOTT CHERRY: rry? He CITY STAFF: ere. Member Simmons? Here. Vice Chair Ben Vanu? Here. Chair Rios? Here. Member Besheide? Here. And Member Degnan? She's here. CECILIA RIOS: . Thank you, Madam Chair. You have a quorum. Thank you very much. Are there any changes to the agenda, either staff or board membe CITY STAFF: ers? Just a few changes of postponed items, Madam Chair. All three items in old business: 2026-012491HGRB for 511 Paseo Del Peralta, item B 2026-012490-HDRB. 507 Paseo de Peralta., and C 20260192691HGRB 216 Maynard are all postponed. Also, new business item D 2026013107HGRB for 817 Vista Catedral is postponed, and item A 2026013245HGRB for 713 Dunlap will be presented by Lanny McCauley. Okay. Those are th CECILIA RIOS: he only changes. Thank you very much. All those in favor of these changes, say aye. Aye. And opposed, say no. Thank you very much. We have two sets of minutes. They are dated October 27, 2026, and September 22nd, 2026. Any corrections to either one of these? Any changes? Board members or staff? Nope. If there are no changes, all those in favor of these two minutes as presented to us in the agenda, say aye. Aye. Opposed, say no. Thank you very much. And we have six findings of fact and conclusions of law. We have one from 01/13/2026, and we have five from 01/27/2026. Any changes to any of these? Anyone? No. All those in favor to adopt these, say aye. Aye. Opposed, say no. Thank you very Matters from the Public. Anyone in this room wishing to come forward to this mic and speak on anything that is on your mind, board-related, not having to do with your case? Is there anyone on Zoom? No hands raised, Madam Chair. Thank you very much. Staf CITY STAFF: ff communications, Heather or Amanda, do we have a CECILIA RIOS: anything? Thank you, Chair Rios. Oops, my voice is loud. I wou AMANDA ROMERO: uld like to introduce formally Jonathan Mellon. He is our new Historic Preservation Manager, and we are thrilled to have him here with us. He has a great diversity of background working in Savannah, Georgia, Washington, D.C., Montclair, New Jersey, and New York City. So he has a lot of technical background and expertise, which will be of great help to us as we proceed forward. And I'd just like to give him a warm welcome. Thank you, Heather, and welcome, welcome, Jonathan. Do CECILIA RIOS: you have anything to say to us? It's a pleasure to be here in your beautiful city, and I JONATHAN MELLON: am very excited to work with you all to help preserve the historic character as it continues to grow. So thank you. Well, thank you very much. So as Amanda stated, there's nothing CECILIA RIOS: g under old business. Those three cases are postponed, and so we move on to new business. Madam Chair, I do have one more item under Staff Communicati CITY STAFF: ions have the 2027 calendar for HDRB. Yes. Please tell us about it. So those are ready to, if you could take a vote on it, so that way we can get it up to the clerk's office. So, move approval of the staff calendar for the HDRB for the calendar JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: year of 2027. Second. And all those in favor, say aye. Aye. And I will say no. Thank you. Now we will move on to new bus MARY ELLEN DEGNAN: siness. A CECILIA RIOS: And I do have to tell you, you probably all know this, but I'll tell you again. Appeals. If you are dissatisfied with the decision that this board renders this evening, you do have the option to appeal. You would be appealing to the City Council, and you have time constraints. So I would suggest that you get together with staff, and they can guide you through the process. Okay? And also, if you are a person that is going, that is part of the public that is going to be speaking on the case, I will limit you to two minutes, and Amanda will help you with that. She'll just raise her finger, or we can see it on the screen. Alrighty. So the first case this evening is located at 713 Dunlap. And Lanny, where is Lanny? Lanny will be presenting. Oh, Lanny, you went way over there. Okay. Please tell us about this case. Okay. Excuse me. Is that mic on? Oh, now I can set her stage. Thank you. Can you hear me now? Yes. Alright. Okay. So this CITY STAFF: s is case 2026013245HDRB for 713 Dunlap LANI MCCULLEY: Street for a status confirmation and primary facade designation. 713 Dunlap Street is located to the rear of the property on the north side of Dunlap, just to the west of the corner of Agua Fria Street. The residence is documented in the 1928 city directory and has been used for rental and storage for most of its existence. It is constructed in a Spanish Pueblo Revival style and is currently listed on the GIS map as a contributing structure. The adobe structure retains its original footprint. It houses inset windows and doors, with all facades having three-over-one windows, except for the north elevation that houses two-over-one windows. The front of the structure holds an arched portal that exemplifies the Westside Guadalupe tradition of unique hand-hewn designs. The portal has a shed roof, arched headers, wood columns, and exposed square bega ends. Both the 1985 and 1998 HCPI forms recommend the structure as contributing, but neither has been adopted by the board. The applicant is requesting confirmation of the contributing status and primary facade designation. I'm going to note that the staff reports of the HCPI was 1996, but it is actually 1998. And while staff acknowledges that the structure is seriously deteriorated at this time, with all of the windows boarded from the interior, cracked plaster, decaying windows, and the rotting and sagging porch supports, staff requests the adoption of the 1984 and 1998 HCPIs and recommends that the status be retained as contributing, and then recommends that the south elevation or elevation two of the diagram, including the portal, be designated as the primary facade for section 14-4.6c, designation of significant and contributing and non-contributing status within the historic districts. Thank you, Lanny, very much. Would you repeat the age of this building? CECILIA RIOS: ? It was originally in the 19... Sorry, not my case. I have to go back LANI MCCULLEY: a minute. 1928. 1928. Thank you. So it's confirmed in 1928. Thank you. And on the south facade, are you also including the windows? Yes. Okay. Thank you very m CECILIA RIOS: much. It is a building that looks like it needs a lot of TLC, but just l LANI MCCULLEY: lookin CECILIA RIOS: ng at it like that, I really like the building. Any other questions for Lanny? No. The question is for you. And will the applicant please come forward? And that is Mr. Purvis. I'm here. It's here forward and there for you. Not forward. Sorry. So that we can hear you. Good evening. Good evening. Can you please raise your right hand and state your name and addre CITY STAFF: ess for the record? Christopher Purvis, 518 Old Santa Fe Trail. Thank you, Mr. Purvis. Do you solemnly declare and affirm the testimony you have in reference to this item is the truth, the whole truth, and do this under the penalties of perjury? Yes. Thank you, sir. Hi, Chris. Do you agree with staff's recommendation, or what do you want to tell us abou CECILIA RIOS: ut this building? I, yes, I agree with staff's recommendation. I really like that elevation. We're PUBLIC COMMENTER (COURTNEY MATE): going to keep that elevation, except it needs a lot of work. Okay. And do you have anything further to tell us? No. I agree with you. It's a nice little building. We're going to fix it up, add a little in the back, and we'll be done. Thank you, Chris. Any questions for Mr. Purvis? No ques CECILIA RIOS: stions for you. Anyone in this audience wishing to comment on this particular case? No one. Anyone online? No hands raised, Madam Chair. I will entertain a motion. Yes, Madam C CITY STAFF: Chair. I would, in case 2026013245HDRB for 713 Dunlap Str CECILIA RIOS: reet, I would move CITY STAFF: that we, JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: along with staff's recommendation, recognize the building as contributing with the south facade. Is that facade number four? No? Two. With facade number two as the primary facade. I will second with the friendly amendment that we exclude any non-histo oric materials on this facade and the designation, such as the metal door, et cetera. Okay. Yeah. I wasn't aware that there was any non-historic material on the front t of this one, but I would accept that. Did you have something further than the? No. I have a question for the applic CECILIA RIOS: cant before we go forward. Is that door newer than the rest of the building? Would you agree? Madam Chair, yes, that door is newer, and there's actually an old, a new o PUBLIC COMMENTER (COURTNEY MATE): old door behind it, piece of junk door. So I'm really glad Emerald Beach had excluded it. Okay. So there, there's two doors at that opening. One of them is rotting wood, and the other one is the metal was added as a security measure. Thank you. Roll call vote, please. I will make a comment. Yes. I will m CECILIA RIOS: make a comment. Thank you, Madam Chair. I just wanted to say t JOHN BIENVENU: that I agree with the motion, but I wanted to emphasize that this is a case, I think, that illustrates something that is sometimes confused, which is the word integrity in our code means, in my opinion, historic integrity, not physical integrity. So when we talk about the integrity of a structure for contributing status, which it is required to maintain, it could be in very deteriorated condition as this is and still be recognized as contributing to the district, and this is a good illustration of that. Thank you for those comments. And I will take a roll call vote, plea CECILIA RIOS: ase. Member Degnan? Yes. Member Cherry? Yes. Member Simmons? Yes. Membe CITY STAFF: er Bishai? Yes. Vice Chair Benvenues? Yes. Madam Chair, the motion has passed. Thank you. And thank you, Mr. Purvis. Thank you. Next case is located at 1545 Canyon Road. Is that applicant here? CECILIA RIOS: ? The applicant is here. And Lauren will present. Okay. This is case 2026-012883-HDRB. 1545 Canyon Rd. status revi LAUREN VAGTS: iew. Currently designated as non-contributing in the Downtown and East Side Historic Districts. 1545 Canyon Road is located northwest of the, of Canyon Road, bound by East Alameda Street, Camino Copper intersection approximately one mile to the west, Cerro Gordo Road to the east, and the Santa Fe River to the north. Surrounding properties consist of single-story vernacular buildings primarily in the Territorial and Pueblo Revival styles. The buildings are clad in stucco, largely fenestrated with wooden doors and divided light windows with flat roof lines bearing squat chimneys. Buildings either line the street or are set back beyond gravel or stone paved drive, separated from Canyon Road by a mix of stucco and stone masonry yard and retaining walls, coyote fencing, and chain link fencing. The property is set back from the road, separated by an older coyote fence and iron gate, keeping harmony with the surrounding streetscape. Early 20th-century hydrological survey maps show the Santa Fe River Valley east of the city developed as an agricultural landscape with grain crops including corn, wheat, oats, and alfalfa along the valley floor near the Santa Fe River. Surrounding the fields were terraced landscapes cultivated by orchards and smaller fields with associated farm buildings nearby. Historically, 1545 Canyon Road was part of a larger agricultural landscape belonging to the Genijo Martinez, or sorry, to Genijo Martinez, with alfalfa as its primary crop. This lot passed through members of the Trujillo Lujan family, separated into smaller parcels by Jose Lujan in 1928. These parcels were distributed by Jose's younger brothers who established residences at 1523 and 1525 Canyon Road. By 1945, residents Tobias and Humacinda Lujan at 1525 Canyon Road developed an adobe rental property at the neighboring 1545 Canyon Road lot, completed by 1946. The property served as a rental property until the late 1950s, followed by the May 1961 parcel survey and land purchased by John and Francis Lynch, then conveyed to their son and daughter-in-law, William and Angie Lynch. Following the acquisition, the Williams added an L-shaped addition to the north elevation circa 1963. By 1967, William J. Lynch established the Lynch Fence Company, initially storing and working out of a secondary structure. It appears that this building is the workshop area of the extent office workshop with the addition of a carport and shed to the west elevation between 1978 and 1981, and an addition made to the east elevation by 1987. According to the August 7, 2026 Historic Cultural Properties Inventory, a second addition was added to the southeast elevation of the main residence to include a carport and dates between 1970 and 1971. By the 1980s, the secondary office workshop building replaced the shed, likely expanding with the addition of a carport and shed to the west in addition to the east. Historic aerials show the final addition enclosing the northeast corner of the main residence building between 2002 and 2004. In 2022, the Lintz Fence Company closed, and the property was put on the market, but ultimately fell into new ownership under the trust to Cindy Lynch, daughter of William and Angie Lynch. Currently, the 1.351-acre lot consists of a single-family residential dwelling situated on a northwest to southeast axis, a secondary workshop building to the north running parallel to the Canyon Road with a carport and shed connecting to the west elevation, and a freestanding carport on the east side of the lot along the property line. The primary building and main residence has a rectangular footprint situated on a northwest to southeast access, set back approximately 70 feet from the road. The single-story Pueblo Revival style building is three bays wide by two bays deep, clad in cementitious stucco with a tan and white dado pattern under the port hall and carport. The central bay dates to the original building circa 1945 with an elevated entrance door to the left above a three-step staircase and semicircular platform clad in flagstone pavers. To the right is the original port hall elevated on the cement platform clad in flagstone pavers, which is partially enclosed on the south side following the carport addition in the early 1970s. The port hall is supported by three wooden columns and vigas with a central canal. To the right of the port hall is an entrance fenestrated with a metal security gate and a double-pane casement window to the left, constructed of wood or metal, although it is uncertain whether or not it is historic. To the left of the port hall is a small fixed four-light historic window. The right bay contains a carport paved in cement, constructed of a wood frame partially enclosed by a wood fence and latticed to the south. The west-facing elevation has an entrance fenestrated by an obscured non-historic inner door and metal security outer door with a shallow cement platform. To the right are two vinyl sliding windows. The south-facing elevation has two window openings, each fenestrated with two vinyl sliding windows. The left bay has a single central opening with two vinyl sliding windows and a squat chimney at the northwest corner. The south elevation includes a wooden fence and lattice partially enclosing the carport at the southwest corner and an essentially located opening on the right bay with a sliding glass vinyl window. The left bay of the east elevation has a wide eave overhang cladding and a metal fascia covering wooden vigas with a small protruding fireplace massing near the southeast corner. A small split in the roofline between the left and central bays exposes the former parapet of the original circa 1945 building. The central bay has two central window openings fenestrated with a sliding vinyl window on the left and wooden casement windows on the right, and a squat horizontal massing along the foundation. The central and right bay are separated by alternating rooflines with the additions slightly higher than the original roof height. The right bay is fenestrated by two vinyl sliding glass windows with the left in comparable size and placement to the central bay windows, while the north window is in a smaller size. The north elevation has a central entrance with a concrete platform and stairs. A wooden frame overhang covers the entryway with a corrugated metal roof. A modern door is obscured by a metal security door and sidelight surround. Flanking the entrance is a larger sliding vinyl window to the right and a smaller sliding vinyl window to the left. The roofline has a slight overhang with a metal-clad fascia, and the parapet from the circa 1963 addition is partially visible right of the doorway. The north elevation, or I'm sorry, while the street-facing west elevation has been altered from its original historic appearance with additions to the north and south elevations taking place between 1963 and 1971 respectively, the south and west elevations retain their historic form and feeling. Additionally, the building retains its physical and cultural association to the adjacent contributing properties at 1523 and 1525 Canyon Road and meets the 50-year requirement for historic eligibility. Therefore, staff recommends the main residence at 1545 Canyon Road be upgraded to a contributing status with the primary facades designated as the south and west elevations, excluding non-historic materials. Located at the center of the north property line, the single-story office workshop has a rectangular plan with a flat roofline clad in cementitious stucco. The street-facing south elevation has two large garage door openings with wooden lintels and slope cement curb entrances at the left and center bays. The southeast corner has a wood frame port hall covered by a metal roof and a cement slab floor. Under the port hall is the main entrance with a setback wooden door and lintel to the left and a modern six-over-six double-hung setback window to the right. The east elevation is fenestrated with three modern recessed six-over-six double-hung windows topped by hewn wood lintels and a slightly recessed parapet roofline. The north elevation has a wide wooden eave overhang with exposed brackets and a central door recessed on an elevated curb with a wooden panel door frame and lintel. Flanking the entrance are two recessed window openings. To the left is a modern six-over-six double-hung window, and to the right is a historic metal frame three-light casement window with a double-light transom. The west elevation has a central door opening with a wooden door and a historic metal frame three-light casement window with a double-light transom similar to the northwest window on the north elevation in a recessed opening. Covering the adjacent cement slab is a metal-framed carport with a corrugated metal roof. Attached to the west and partly covered by the carport is a single-story shed clad in corrugated metal with a hipped roof and hinged double doors on the south elevation. The west elevation of the shed has a wood-framed port hall and corrugated metal roof. While part of the office workshop building may date to the late 1960s, the removal of historic materials, non-historic additions, and fenestrations have altered the structure significantly, diminishing the overall historic integrity. Therefore, staff recommends the building retains its non-contributing status. At the center of the eastern property line is a detached carport. The structure is constructed of steel posts and beams and corrugated panel roofing. According to historic aerials, the structure was erected between 1996 and 2002, and the structure does not meet the 50-year requirement. Therefore, staff recommends the structure be designated as non-contributing. And, overall, staff recommends the historic status of the main residence be upgraded to contributing with the south and west elevations designated as primary facades, R1, R2, R3, and R4, with the exclusion of non-historic materials per 14-4.6c designation of significant contributing or non-contributing status within historic districts. Staff also recommends the status of the secondary building retain its non-contributing status as it does not retain enough historic integrity with the majority of the building additions and fenestrations falling outside the 50-year period of significance, per 14-4.6c designation of significant contributing or non-contributing status within historic districts. And staff recommends the status of the freestanding carport be designated as non-contributing as the structure does not fall within the 50-year period of significance per 14-4.6c, designation of significant contributing and non-contributing status within historic districts. And I'm open to questions. Thank you for that long report. In terms of the building with the corrugated roof, that's also... you were indicating that for non-contributing st CECILIA RIOS: tatus? Mm-hmm. Okay. Are there any other questions, board members? Member Simmons? Lauren, could you explain the logic of the upgrade, the staff's logic of upgrading this from non-contributing to contributing beyond the 5 MARY ELLEN DEGNAN: 50-year threshold being met? Yes. So, I'll go back here. So, as you can see with the aerial here, the south and the west elevations, and then you see in the corner in the nor LAUREN VAGTS: rtheast is where the circa 2004 addition was made. Being that it's only on that corner in the back there, I think this shows a progression of, I guess, historic, the history of the building itself over time. Thank you. Any other questions? Board members? Member Beachay. Thank you, Lauren. So, just staying with this, so you're including t CECILIA RIOS: the additio MARY ELLEN DEGNAN: on circa 196 CECILIA RIOS: 63 because it meets the 50-year threshold, even thou JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: ugh it's not part of the original structure, but, R... I guess it's R2 and R2 includes the enclosed portal, right? So that... there was a wrap-around portal originally. Mm-hmm. And, can you... I guess, can you just talk to that to what... you know, how we can justify the altering of an enclosed portal, which is prohibited by code now, in this designation of primary facade and also the R4 designation, which is, I think, a 1971 addition. Right? Yeah. Yeah. I think, I guess with those, with those four, R1 through R4, those fall within the 50-year period of significance, LAUREN VAGTS: , so that is why I included it. And the enclosed portal, we're not, you know, considering that to be a significant alteration of the character of the original. I think the wrap-a JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: around portal is kind of a unique feature that I would, I would say, should have been preserved, but it's now altered. So I don't know how the R2 especially, fits within what we would consider characteristic about the building without alteration. I don't know if you have anything more to say about that. No, I don't have anything more to know. Yeah. Anything further, board members? Nothing present? Will the applicant please come forward to sp LAUREN VAGTS: peak? Hello. Hi, Courtney. Can you please stat CECILIA RIOS: te your name and address for the record? Courtney Mate, 574 West San Francisco Street, Santa Fe 8 PUBLIC COMMENTER (COURTNEY MATE): 87501. CITY STAFF: Do you solemnly declare and affirm that the testimony you have in refere PUBLIC COMMENTER (COURTNEY MATE): ence to this item is the truth, the whole truth, and do this CITY STAFF: under the penalties of perjury? Yes, I do. Thank you, Madam Chair. He has been sworn. Yes, sir. Hello. Thanks for giving us your time tonight. Overall, we feel like there's been a lot of changes to this buildin CECILIA RIOS: ng over the PUBLIC COMMENTER (COURTNEY MATE): e course of time. The area that is most original is a portion of R1. Can I go over here and point at this for a second? This portal that's still exposed used to wrap all the way around. So it was... I'm going to interrupt you for a little second so that they can get the mic over there. Sorry. I had you up on the recording without it. You mi CECILIA RIOS: ight have spoken. Alright. So the original portal up here was this part, and it went CITY STAFF: t over to here. It was L-shaped. So when this got added in '71, this wall here was PUBLIC COMMENTER (COURTNEY MATE): s added. The original wall was back here. So this has all been enclosed now with a main entry here, and then there's another door over here, etcetera. But yes, we feel like this area right here, all of this, really obscures a lot of the original building. We totally agree that the original building has a lot of character to it. We would maintain that character. We haven't really discussed... I know we're not talking about any design at this point, but we would want to maintain the integrity and the character that's presented on R1. But we... By the same token, given the number of changes that have happened over time and the fact that all this stuff on the south is obscuring a lot of what used to be the original structure and the original portal was enclosed, we don't find that any of those should be considered contributing. Our historic consultant was John Murphy. John wanted to point out that the Secretary of the Interior Standards recognized that changes to a property over time may acquire historic significance, but age alone does not establish that. So we feel like all the stuff that was added in the seventies, there's really nothing special about it. It's got vinyl windows that panes are too big. It's nothing unique to the significance of this structure at all. So we feel like none of the proposed contributing standards should apply to the structure. That's my main comment. I'd be glad to take any questions. Thank you. So the portion of four... of R1, you are not indicating any portion of that as, in your view, as contributing? If yes, can you go and show us w CECILIA RIOS: which portion you would consider? The view of this side of the house has changed really from here on over. The green line, all of this, this was changed from here on over when this got enclosed and this whole area becam PUBLIC COMMENTER (COURTNEY MATE): me enclosed. So potentially anything from here up, but certainly nothing from here down. We don't feel like any of that is contributing at all. Thank you. Any other questions, board members? Yes. Member Degner. Thank you, Madam Chair. Sir, I'm going to address you directly, if I may. Yes. Do I understand, or am I sensing that you are not CECILIA RIOS: agreeing that this should be designated as a contributing historic JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: c structure? No. I'm sa CECILIA RIOS: aying JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: we don't find any of it to be contributing, is our opinion. Yes. Well, that's the question I'm asking. Okay. So you don't agree that it is a contributing structure and theref PUBLIC COMMENTER (COURTNEY MATE): fore should not have the designation that we're considering tonigh JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: ht? Yes. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. If there are no questions from board members, I will ask if anyone in this audience wishes to comment on this particular case. If so, come forward. It appears not. Anyone online? CECILIA RIOS: No, Madam Chair. Board members, I will entertain a motion, please. Member Beachside. Thank you, Madam Chair. In case number 2026012883HDRB at 1545 Canyon Road, I move to designate the residence as non-contributing, noting that due to the additions and the enclosure JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: of the wraparound port hall and addition of the carport in particular, that the facades no longer maintain or convey the characteristics that would have been worthy of preservation. And I move to adopt staff's recommendations for the office, freestanding carports, and the fence gate as non-contributing. And do I hear a second? Second. Anything further to add? Nothing further? Roll call vote, please. Member Cherry? Nope. Member Degnan? No. Member Beechai? Yes. Member CECILIA RIOS: r Ben Vanu? Yes. Member Simmons? Yes. Madam Chair, the motion has passed. Thank you. Thank y CITY STAFF: you. Thank you all. We appreciate it. Thanks, Lauren. Next case is located at 311 Old Santa Fe Trail. And, Lauren, you will present. This is case 2026-013211-HDRB. 311 Old Santa Fe Trl. Trail PUBLIC COMMENTER (COURTNEY MATE): l, for a status CECILIA RIOS: review. The subject building is currently non-status in the Downtown and East LAUREN VAGTS: Side Historic Districts. The building's located on the east side of Old Santa Fe Trail near the southeast corner of the lot, bound by East Alameda Street and the Santa Fe River to... or sorry, and Santa Fe River to the north, Paseo De Peralta to the east, and East De Vargas Street to the south. Concrete paved alleyway, flanked by stucco and stone wall, separates the property line from the neighboring building at 329 Old Santa Fe Trail. The streetscape is a mix of single-story historic Pueblo Revival style buildings clad in stucco with flat roof lines with either street-facing or adjacent portals, single-pitched roof building with a portal at the southeast end of the street, two and three-story buildings including the New Mexico State Land Office circa 1960 to the northwest, and the Territorial style Lamy Building 1878 to the south, the Spanish Colonial style San Miguel Chapel, and two large parking lots. The sidewalk is largely clad in red and brick masonry pavers, with occasional concrete slip curbs to accommodate driveways and ADA compliance. On the west side of Old Santa Fe Trail, building facades begin at the sidewalk without walls or fencing apart from the state landed use building, which sits back from the street behind a shallow iron fence. The east side of the street has a mix of shallow yard walls, coyote fencing, and stone retaining walls to the south. Established in 1923, 311 Old Santa Fe Trail was originally developed as an auto camp by John Catron for travelers who could not afford the expensive hotels. This development followed a nationwide trend of municipalities and emerging entrepreneurs built on the expansion of automobile travelers and associated land development, including filling stations, motorist camps, wash houses, and so forth. By the early 1940s, Orchard Camp further developed, adding a swimming pool, additional cabins, restrooms, and rest stop, and officially the first downtown motor court in Santa Fe. In October 1957, Orchard Camp changed ownership to Clyde and Goldie Tyler, and the two-story Desert Inn officially opened following demolition of the entire site while preserving a single residence at the southeast corner of the property. The new motel took the name of the infamous motel on the Las Vegas Strip with design inspiration from the Desert Sands and Desert Inn motels in Albuquerque. In the mid-1970s, the motel changed hands again to the Garrett family and reopened as Garrett Desert Inn, with the current site maintaining much of its historic footprint. According to historic aerials placing the subject property build date between 1990 and 1995, the building does not show to exist or associate within the historic context of the adjacent motel and its development. However, both historic maps and aerials show the Southwestern Yard wall throughout the historic period of development. The subject building at 311 Old Santa Fe Trail, once addressed as 317, is set back approximately 40 feet from the street behind a coyote fence flanked by yard walls clad in cementitious stucco in the Downtown and East Side Historic Districts. The single-story building has a rectangular footprint in a simplified Pueblo Revival style clad in cementitious stucco and flat roof. The street-facing west elevation is two bays wide, each with two large three over 12 vinyl sliding windows. The north half of the elevation has a slightly higher roof line with a wooden frame port hall above a cement slab and wooden entrance door to the far left. The north elevation is two bays wide clad in stucco with no fenestration with a cement walkway separating the neighboring yard wall that connects to 315 Old Santa Fe Trail. The east elevation has a single wood panel door entrance slightly raised above a cement slab on the right with a mass at the southeast corner connecting to a neighboring motel to the east and yard wall to the south. The south elevation has no fenestration with the bottom half below grade connecting to the retaining wall to the west and connecting to the adjacent motel to the east. The south elevation connects at the southwest corner with a stucco retaining wall that connects to a larger L-shaped yard wall bordering the southwestern corner of the lot. While the lot shows, while the lot shows in historic aerials and maps, the entire west elevation was approved for demolition by the board in 2003. Unfortunately, no historic documentation for construction of the building exists prior to alteration permits between 2000 and 2004 and has not been surveyed. However, aerials date the building between 1990 and 1995, which is outside the 50-year period of significance. Therefore, staff recommends the status of the building be designated as non-contributing. Additionally, while the yard wall does meet the 50-year requirement, demolition to the west wall has significantly compromised the structure and does not retain enough historic integrity to meet the requirements as a notable or contributing structure. Open to questions. Thank you very much, Lauren. Let's see if the board has any questions for you. Any questions for Lauren? It app CECILIA RIOS: pears they do not. Applicant or applicants, can you come forward? Good evening. How are you all tonight? We're good. Good. How are you? Good. Please state your name and PUBLIC COMMENTER (COURTNEY MATE): d address for the record. Daniel Luhan. CECILIA RIOS: . 612 Old Santa Fe Trail. Daniel, do CITY STAFF: o you solemnly declare and affirm that the testimony you have in reference to this item is the truth, the whole truth, and do this under the penalties of perjury? Yes. Thank you. Good evening, Mr. Luhan. Do you agree with staff's recommendation that this PUBLIC COMMENTER (COURTNEY MATE): s shou CECILIA RIOS: uld be a non-contributing building? Agree. And do you have anything further to add? I do not. Okay. Board members, do you hav PUBLIC COMMENTER (COURTNEY MATE): ve any q CECILIA RIOS: questions for Mr. Luhan? No questions for Mr. Luhan. Anyone in this audience wishing to comment on this particular project? No one. And anyone online? No hands raised, Madam Chair. Thank you. I will entertain a motion. Yes. I understand. In case number 2026-013211 HDRB, 311 Old Santa Fe Trail, I move that we accept staff MARY ELLEN DEGNAN: f's recommendations. Second. Degner. Roll call vote, please. Member Cherry? Yes. Member Simmons? Yes. Vice CECILIA RIOS: e Chair Bienvenu? Yes. Member Beechai? CITY STAFF: ? Yes. Member Degner? Yes. Madam Chair, the motion is pas CECILIA RIOS: ssed. Thank you very much, and thank you, sir. Thank you, board. Thanks, Lauren. Our last case this evening is located at 330A East Buena Vista Street. I'm going to take it that the applicant is here. And may we hear from Lauren again? Okay. This is case number 2026-013212-HDRB. 330A E. Buena Vista, fo LAUREN VAGTS: or a remodel and addition that includes turning the existing 400 square foot garage into living space, a new north-facing garage and storage measuring 508 square feet and 11 feet in height with a maximum allowable height of 16.7 feet, window replacement, and fence installation. Status is not surveyed. 338 East Buena Vista Street, 1,645 square foot single-family residential duplex is located in the Don Gaspar Historic Districts the north side of the street, bound by Old Santa Fe Trail to the east, East Berger Street to the south, and Gildersleeve Street to the west. The duplex shares a common wall with 330B to the West and part of a fourplex lot built in 2005. The residential street is lined primarily with single-story, flat-roofed, and stucco-clad buildings in the Pueblo Revival and Territorial styles, with occasional pitched roofs and contemporary and Craftsman-style houses. The street cuts through a natural slope with the north side of the street overlooking the south, including a below-grade compound. Houses to the north are primarily set back from the street, centrally located within their lots, and surrounded by large wooden landscapes. The southern houses are either situated up against the sidewalk or slightly set back. Coyote fences are dominant to the east, with shallow stucco yard walls incorporating stone foundations to the west, lining nearly the entire street with a mix of gravel and paved drives. At the southeast corner of the street is a tall, curved stucco yard wall partially enclosing the parking lot for the end of the Turquoise Bear. At the center of the street, where Weber Street begins, a large gravel parking lot opens to a basketball court and fields. 330A East Buena Vista Street was part of a multi-duplex project first submitted to the Historic Districts Review Board in October 2003 and completed in 2005. Historically, the site belonged to a larger area associated with the Flora Conrad House, designated as significant at 313 East Berger Street. 330A East Buena Vista Street, oh, sorry, is the easternmost duplex of the quad, set back behind a low coyote fence along the sidewalk with a wooden gate entrance. The single-story residence is clad in cementitious stucco with a gravel drive extending the length of the east elevation, separated from the east lot by a coyote fence and modern irrigation ditch, and a cementitious stucco yard wall to the south. The north elevation is two bays wide with a slightly larger massing to the left, with two-over-two fixed wooden windows flanked by two canals. The right bay has an alcove entrance with a single canal overhead, the opening bearing a wooden lintel. Inside the alcove are two or three two-over-six casement windows on the street-facing elevation and an obscured wooden entrance door on the left, left of the partition wall. The east elevation is three bays wide with a horizontal two-over-six rectangular window flanked by two canals on the left, a single two-over-six window in the center bay with a single canal to the right, and an eight-panel-wide wooden garage door with two-over-two fixed wooden openings above each panel. The south elevation is, sorry, the, yeah, the south elevation is three bay AMANDA ROMERO: ys wide LAUREN VAGTS: with a horizontal, or with each bay declining in height from left to right. The left bay has a three-panel doorway, each with two-over-six glazed panels and two-over-six casement windows to the right with a single canal centered above. The central bay is two centered large two-over-six casement windows, while the right bay has two-over-six casement windows off-center to the right. Proposed remodeling work includes the addition of a 508-square-foot, 11-foot-in-height, one-car garage and storage area on the east side of the existing property, with the maximum existing garage door enclosed behind a four-foot fence. The south elevation of the new addition will have a single three-foot-by-six-foot entrance door installed to the left. Oops. On the north elevation, there is a proposed overhead wood-clad garage door measuring eight feet by eight feet with four two-over-two glazed square windows above four wooden panels on the left and a three-foot-by-five-foot divided light window to the right, partially obscured by a four-foot fence with the maximum allowable height of four feet two inches. Additionally, the remodel of the existing 400-square-foot garage into a family room to the existing 1,645-square-foot residence. Wood-clad window replacement on the east elevation, with two three-foot-by-four-foot two-over-two windows at the center of the south and central bays. And staff finds that the application complies with Section 14-4.6E, General Design Standards for all Historic Districts, and 14-4.6G1, Don Gaspar Area Historic Districts Design Standards, and recommends approval of the proposed project at 330A East Buena Vista Street. Thank you very much, Lauren. Board members CECILIA RIOS: s, do you have questions for Lauren? They do not have any questions for you at this time. Will the applicant please come forward? Mr. Sears. Hi. Please state your name and address fo CITY STAFF: or the record. Jeff Sears, 122 Lorenzo Road. Do you solemnly declare and affirm that the testimony you have in reference to this item is the truth, the whole truth, and do this under the penalties of perjury? Yes. Thank you, sir. Good evening, Madam Chair PUBLIC COMMENTER (COURTNEY MATE): r, members of the board. On Zoom this evening are the owners, Patrick and Tracy Gallagher. And I would like to thank Lauren for the preparation and presentation of a very comprehensive staff report that we agree with. So with that, we stand for any questions. Thank you. Any questions for Mr. Sears at this time? CECILIA RIOS: ? No questions. Yeah. Member Bicheck. Sorry. Thank you, Madam Chair. Could you please clar JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: rify, are there two colors of blue being proposed on the project, or are they intended to match? Intended to match. Okay. Thank you. Any other questions? Did your clients want to CECILIA RIOS: speak or no? Hi, Patrick and Tracy. Anything you want t PUBLIC COMMENTER (COURTNEY MATE): to say? They'll have to get sworn in if they do CECILIA RIOS: o. The Gallaghers. Please raise your hand CITY STAFF: d if you wish to speak. They do not have their hands raised. CECILIA RIOS: Okay. It's all you, Jeff. There appear to be no other questions. Anyone in this audience wishing to comment on this project? No. And anyone online? No, Madam Chair. Members of the board, I will entertain a motion on this project. Member Simmons. I move, in the case of 2026-0 MARY ELLEN DEGNAN: 012, I'm sorry, 013212 HDRB 330A East Buena Vista Street, that we accept staff's recommendations. And do I hear a second? Degnan. Sec CECILIA RIOS: cond. Roll call vote. Member Cherry? Y CITY STAFF: Yes. Vice Chair Bienvenu? Yes. Member Besheide? Yes. Member Tegman? Yes. Member Simmons? Yes. Madam Chair, the motion has passed. Thank you. Thank you, Jeff. And thank you, board members. Thank you. That's the end o CECILIA RIOS: of this evening's cases. Staff, do we have anything under Discussion Items, Chair. Yes. No AMANDA ROMERO: ot at this time. Madam Chair, I do have, oh, yes. I can, CECILIA RIOS: , Attorney Rubalit. I wanted to re SCOTT CHERRY: eport to the board that in an appeal hearing we had regarding a project application that was heard by the board on 05/26/2026. And this was a proposal to build a 3,400-square-foot addition to a height of 24 feet, granting exceptions for the removal of historic material and to exceed 50% of the historic footprint of a significant structure at 515 Paseo De Peralta. A neighboring property owner appealed that, and that appeal was heard by the City of Santa Fe Governing Body on September 30. And it was the vote of the City of Santa Fe Governing Body to uphold the Historic Districts Review Board's decision on that and approve the project. And I think it was, I think it was a good hearing in the sense that they asked a lot of detail about the board's decision-making process, and I was able to show them sections of the packet that showed exactly what you were looking at when you made your decision on May 26 and how you formulated the criteria for the exceptions and facts that you found. And I think it was a good hearing, and it reflected well on the H Board. Than CECILIA RIOS: nk you, Frank. Any board members have any comments in reference to this appeal? What PUBLIC COMMENTER (COURTNEY MATE): was the basis of the appeal from a neighbor, which they were obje MARY ELLEN DEGNAN: ecting to? I'm sor CITY STAFF: rry, sir. We can't, we cannot pick you up without a mic. Can you please repeat? I'm so sorry. Was the basis of the appeal from an adjacent neighbor who had an i MARY ELLEN DEGNAN: issue with the height of the building and views or something like that? Presumab SCOTT CHERRY: bly, yes. Madam Chair and Member Simmons, the appellant was an adjoining property owner that was higher on the elevation of that hill on the north side of Paseo De Peralta. And he did claim that the one-foot discretionary allowance that the H Board approved that addition for its situation on a sloping site would obstruct his view and that the size of the addition was out of character for the neighborhood. The board may recall, Madam Chair and members, that it exercised a discretionary allowance for a height variation on a sloping site without considering exception criteria. And that was one of the questions that the governing body had to consider was whether the H Board should have considered, should have required the project applicant to conclusively demonstrate the exception criteria for a height variance. And the governing body found that the H Board was within its authority to grant that discretionary allowance on a sloping site. Thank CECILIA RIOS: k you very much. Yeah. Thank you. Any other pending appeals? The SCOTT CHERRY: ere are. And in fact, thank you, Madam Chair and members. Thank you for asking that. The governing body has actually set a special governing body hearing, which will take place, I would say, November 18, Wednesday, November 18. And I'm very thankful that hearing will start at 1:00 PM because, as you know, sometimes land use hearings, which are all the way at the end of that governing body agenda, are heard at 9:00, 10:00, 11:00 at night. But there will be a special governing body hearing to consider two Historic Districts Review Board appeals and one Planning Commission appeal. So they will all be heard at one time with, as I understand, nothing else on the agenda but those appeals on November 18. It's a Wednesd JENNIFER BIEDSCHEID: day. Wednesday, the 18th. Can you repeat the time? I'm sorry. SCOTT CHERRY: That is 1:00 PM. And let me, let me double-check that date by looking at my Outlook calendar. Do you recall, Heather? AMANDA ROMERO: ? Is that the date? The date is Wednesday, the 18th, at 1:00 PM. Yeah. T MARY ELLEN DEGNAN: That's correct. 1:00 PM. Okay. Do you know the cases that they're appealing to th AMANDA ROMERO: hat, historic review cases? Yes. It's 1295 Cerro Gordo Road as well as, that's for the addition that was greater than 50% of the footprint and removal of contributing walls adjacent to Cerro Gordo Road, as well as for the mural at, I believe, it's 320 Paseo De Peralta of the Fox that s CECILIA RIOS: sort of covers the entire building. Okay. Th JOHN BIENVENU: hank you. Matters from the Board? Member Benjamin Young. Thank you, Madam Chair. So speaking of appeals to the governing body and the governing body, we've had a few meetings that have been arranged, and thank you, Director Lamboy, for taking the initiative to set up some meetings between some of the members of the governing body and some of the members of the H Board. I think there have been three so far. I attended one, so I can't speak to the others. But I think these seem like a good idea, but I just like to make some suggestions because it's not clear to me exactly how these meetings are proceeding. It's not clear to me how the members of, from the board are being selected or the members of the governing body and whether there's continuity or discontinuity from meeting to meeting or exactly what is it we're attempting to accomplish. So it seems to me that maybe we could, I mean, just a suggestion to the chair and the director that potentially this could be formalized a bit so that there is actually designated, if there's an attempt to continue these discussions, as a working group of some sort that there'd be some designation of Matters from the Board to participate in that, whether it's one designation for all meetings or whether that changes, that could, it could go either way. And that also the same be true on the governing body side and also that there be some kind of an agenda for these meetings. The meeting I attended, I thought, was pretty chaotic, to be honest, because tempers flared. Passions were high. It was extreme. There was a lot of anger expressed in the room, and I thought that the discussion just went in multiple directions without any clear understanding of what exactly was on the table that we were trying to resolve. So, that would be my suggestion. There'd be someone that's chairing those meetings, that it would be understood who the participants are and what is intended to be accomplished, and that there be an agenda. I'd be curious about other people's point of view that's attended, and also, of course, Director Lamboy, who's made the arrangements, sort of AMANDA ROMERO: serving as an intermediary between the two entities. Yes. Thank you, Vice Chair Bienvenu. So the first meeting truly was to sort of get through what was being proposed, and that wasn't... It was just a proposal, and there was no agenda. My apologies for not doing that. But on the second meeting that we had, there was an agenda. There are some things, and we're going through everything. The counselors that are involved are those who are sponsoring the bill. So that's the basis for the decision on who's involved from the council in these meetings. And some of the amendments that are being proposed apply to all boards and commissions. So one would be the term limits that are being proposed. That would be for the Arts Commission, the Planning Commission, all of the different boards and commissions, not just the Historic Districts Review Board. And there are some other changes that are being proposed that aren't specific to the HDRB. And I think what we're trying to do right now is to have discussions on what is good. And we've also had some discussions internally with MetGlobal of Global Partners to talk about really what is the best approach, whether we add it to part of the phase two of the code update or whether we have the counselors proceed. There are strong feelings on behalf of the council regarding the timing and what they want to do now. At this point, the counselors feel pretty strongly that there's not going to be another convening and that they're going to propose what they propose. But there is a process for any code change that has to go through a public review process, and that would be the Historic Districts Review Board would review and make recommendation to the governing body. So it's not like there isn't a public process, although staff has suggested to have more p JOHN BIENVENU: public input. And no answer on that yet. Didn't mean to interrupt, but are you referring now to this bill that's separate from phase two that would also require coming back before the board before it goes to a vote? Yes. That AMANDA ROMERO: t's correct. Okay. Any change... Any text change to Chapter 14 needs to be reviewed by the appropriate body, and Planning Commission actually might need to act on that as well as HDRB before it g JOHN BIENVENU: goes to governing body. Thank you for that. Is there a timeline that you're aware of where this is expected to take place? Not a AMANDA ROMERO: at this time. It's still... There has been a legislative request that's been submitted to our legislative office. They have a very large backlog, so those priorities are determined by the City Council, or I'm sorry, the City Manager as to what comes through first. And so I would anticipate that it's JOHN BIENVENU: going to be at least several months. Okay. Thank you for all that CECILIA RIOS: t information. That's helpful. Thanks. So, Heather, since the city councilors that were involved in these meetings indicated that they more than likely will not proceed with any more meetings for the meantime, would you be so kind as to send us all an email in reference to the proposals that will be presente AMANDA ROMERO: ed to the governing body? Yes, Chair Rios. We can do that for sure. Although, it's not finally determined what is going to impact more than one board and commission and what's going to impact just the Historic Districts Review Board. So, but we will make sure to parse that out and let you know what it is w CECILIA RIOS: well in advance. Okay. Thank you. Any other questions or comments in reference to this subject matter? Nothing. Okay. Our next meeting is going to be on 10/27/2026. Question. Were the City Council Chambers being occupied tonight? Yes, Madam Chair. So we'll go back to the City Council Chambers? I didn't know if this is a new location. This will be temporary for this evening, and also, the firs CITY STAFF: st hearing in November will be here. But for the next hearing, we'll be back in chambers, and then we'll be back here in November. O JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: Okay. Thank you. I had a thing from Matters from the Board. PUBLIC COMMENTER (COURTNEY MATE): . Pardon JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: n? Well, you had asked if there was anything else on that Matters from the Board, but I have another Matters from the Board. Yes, Mister Cherry. Yes. Yeah. Well, I was just going to comment on this window informational session that we did today and ask that others make, inform the board when you post the... Or when you post the video so people have access to it because the feedback I got was that it was fairly helpful for people in understanding Windows. AMANDA ROMERO: Yes. Absolutely. Member Cherry was super helpful, and the video is going to be approximately twenty-four minutes. I sort of cut in between when we're moving from one room to another. So I just need to put everything together, and I might share it through a Dropbox link or... Because it's hard to transmit because of the size of the video. So we'll have to figure something out, but we'll definitely share with the entire staff as well as the board and eventually maybe depending upon whether the board members might feel it might be helpful posted onto our website. Okay. And I'm a JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: available to do those again or, again, with more of a curriculum, so to speak, if we want to incorporate it into how it relates to our code. Thank you. Question fo CECILIA RIOS: or Member Terry. You did that today and you did it to what audience? Everyone... The field trip audience. Oh, okay. Yeah. It was on the... Unable to make the field trip, so that's why it wasn't a fault. Yeah. So we can do... Yeah. So JOSEPH E. SIMMONS: we could do a similar thing or we could evolve it like we talked, Heather and I talked about evolving it with, like, some kind of curriculum or, just, you know, a... It was fairly free form. So... Okay. Thank you. Memb JOHN BIENVENU: ber Can Hear. Thank you, Madam Chair. So just coming back to the issue of the City Council, the governing body, is it possible... I was going to ask you separately, but it seems to me in thinking about it that it would be useful for all the board to know since only a few members attended the meetings. Can we have a just a really brief summary of who attended and what the discussion was in the three meetings? Sure. Absolu AMANDA ROMERO: utely. I'd be happy to put that together. Okay. Thanks. Okay. Thank you. CECILIA RIOS: . Anything else, anybody? Nope. So, motion to adjourn, someone. So moved. And is there a second? Second, General. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. And I'm not going to entertain any opposed. Okay. Good night, everyone. This is a very short meeting.