BULLETIN~OF THE HISTORIC SANTA FE FOUNDATION VOL.26, No 1 January 2000 THE "ROQUE TUDESQUI" HOUSE The Bulletin is the HSFF's primary publication with the main article providing the results of research on a property placed on the Foundation's "Registry of Buildings Worthy of Preservation." Architec- tural elevations and plans arc reproduced, along with photographs, both old and new, and observations that might add to the genera l know ledge. Other articles discuss various neighborhood associations, recognize special volunteers or projects, furnish information on HSFF awards, and acknowledge educational projects as well as special community acti vities. We welcome suggestions and comments from our readers and hope this publication provides the research and human interest that wil l make reading it a worthwhile and pleasurable endeavor. Ruth Holmes, Publications Chair Table of Contents The "Roque Tudesqui" House Pg 1 Corinne Sze Oia1y ofan Old House Pg 15 Charlotte White The Gustave Baumann House Pg 34 Dana Evans, Sally Hyer and Paul McConnell Preservation Q & A Pg 42 Corinne Sze Corinne Sze Pg 4 7 Ruth Holmes Santa Fe's Acequia Madre Pg 50 Eleanor Bove A Study in Perseverance Pg 52 Phillip Bove TAR' EA Pg 58 Ruth Holmes Historic Neighborhood Association John Pen La Farge Pg 59 THE "ROQUE TUDESQUI" HOUSE 135 East De Vargas Street Cori1111e P S:::e. Ph.D. In 1998 the second i11 a series of co111prehe 11sive histories of the properties owned by the Foundatio n was co111μ /eted Thefol/0 11·- i11g is a sw1111ia1 y ofthejincli11gs oft/wt research. Th e co111μ/ete, a 11- 11otated sto1y of the building and its owners is to be the next in a series ofm onographs publis hed by the Foundation to document each of the 1-fSFF-owned properties. The most startling result of this research was the realization that, although this property has had many interesting owners, definiti ve evi- dence was not found that Roque Tudesqui was one of them. The building owned by the Foundation shares a common wa ll with another residence on the west. The two structures have together been ca lled the Roque Tudesqui House since the mid 1960s, when documentation was prepared for their listing by the Historic Santa Fe Foundation and by the State Register of Cultural Prope1ties. 1 It was believed then that both prope11ics were included in a tract Roque Tudesqui sold in 184 1, and that they re- mained together unti l di vided in 1895. However, an analysis ofrecorded prope1ty transfers indicates that the two, if ever joined, were split before 185 0. Fragmentary earlier evi- dence is inconclusive and neither eonfinns nor rules out Tudesqui's own- ership o f both at some earl ier time. To add further confusion, the two properties were partially mingled in 1874 when a section at the southwest comer of the HSFF prope1ty containing two rooms (apparently no longer extant) was sold to the owners of the property on the west. Twenty years later, Wi ll iam Jones briefly united both "Tudesqui" tracts, buyi ng them separately in April and October 1894. He sold the west property the following Fcbrua1y to the Cartw1ight fam ily and kept the HSFF pmtion as his home until his death just five years later. After a prolonged fight, wi th strong feelings on all sides of the issue voiced, the neighborhood won its case on the basis that the devel- opment was out of character and scale with the historic Eastside, and as the Eastside, along with the downtown area, fo rm the core of historic Santa Fe, it must be protected. The neighborhood then "downzoncd" itself to the density it actually exhibited. Subsequently, the Histo1ic Neighborhood Association has fought many battles over such issues as inappropriate development, inadequate parking and unsuitable re-zoning for commercial uses in residential neigh- borhoods. The boundaries of the Eastside neighborhood start at Camino Monte Vista, go down Old Santa Fe Trail to Pasco de Peralta, along the Paseo to the Santa Fe River, east along the river to PalaceAvenuc, south along Palace Avenue one block until Canyon Road, then down Canyon Road to Camino de! Monte Sol, up the Cam ino to El Caminita and from there to Abeyta Street, then west across the landscape back to Camino Monte Vista. north Today the Associat ion continues to keep an eye on such plans that clash with the fee l and character of the neighborhood as we also encourage neighborhood improvement. We are on the lookout for new board members who are interested and willing to work toward these same ends. For further information, please contact Pen La Farge: 983-8377. 60 Located south of the river, Analco extends along De Vargas Street west of the San Miguel Chapel. It is generally accepted that the found ing inhabitants of the barrio (neighborhood or district) were Tlascalan Indians who joined the Spanish colonists in settling Santa Fe. The name Analco means "other side of the river" in Nahuatl, the language of the Tlascalans. On the Urrutia Map (ca. 1766) the neighborhood was described as the "town or distri ct which owes its origin lo the Tia calans who accompa- nied the first Spaniards who entered in the conquest of this kingdom.'"2 However, the Tl asca lan neighborhood in Santa Fe was not des- tined to survive the 1680 Pueb lo Indian Revolt that drove the Spanish from New Mexico. The Puebloans advanced on Santa Fe from the south, sacking the dwellings of Analco and burning the Chape l of San Miguel. When the Spanish fl ed south to El Paso, the Tlascalans went with them. Few of the original Tlascalan co lon ists returned with Diego de Vargas, who began the Spanish reconquest of New Mexico twelve years later. Nevertheless, the Barrio de Analco was soon rcbui It. Vargas made grants of land there, and the San Miguel Chapel was reconstructed by 1710.3 Still on the opposite bank of the river from the ma in settlement, Analco was occupied primari ly by married so ldiers and by genisaros, "detribalized" Indian servants and laborers. After Mex ican Independence from Spain in 182 1, Analco was called the BaITio de San Miguel. The census taken two years later indi- cates that the largest group ofresidents of Ana lco were peop le with a va riety of specialized skills, including that of shoemaker, tailor, musician, silversmith, blacksmith, mason, builder, adobe maker, b1icklayer, carpen- ter, and muleteer. In contrast, the residents of the Barrio de Guadal upe, which lay west of the Santuario de Guadalupe, were primari ly fa rmers. In 182 1 the population of the Ba1Tio de San Miguel was 45 1. Twenty years later it had ri sen by 40 to 49 1. ln 1846, near the onset of the U.S.-Mcxican War, Colonel (soon Brigadier General) Stephen Watts Kearny and the American "Army of the West" occupied Santa Fe. M ilitary maps of the time show a road 3 running parallel to the south bank of the river from the Guadalupe Church to the San Miguel Church, and continuing east. Buildings in the block west of San Miguel were primarily linear but discontinuous. The U.S. territorial government first became a presence south of the river in 1885, when a new capitol was bui lt on fo 1111erly cultivated land south of De Vargas Street. Two years later, plans were initiated to extend Don Gaspar Avenue from its termi- nus at Water Street as a wide, straight~ .- .;;,· .... -----.... ..:.. § avenue south across the river and past _ the east side of the capitol property. ~ In 1907 the continuity of De Vargas Street was broken by the Governor's :g Mansion built north of the capitol and •• @ west of the intersection of De Vargas ~ and Don Gaspar. ._.: ~ · ~ _..._ ~ .....,...______~_~ _._,.-'-_.,_~ ._ __. Ci:'. As the twentieth century pro- East De Va1gas April 1881 gressed, new government buildi ngs further encroached on the Barrio de Ana lco. ln 1937 the State Supreme Couit building was constructed fac ing the river, on the n01theast corner of Don Gaspar Avenue and De Vargas Street. Jn the 1960s several new state bui ldings appeared, including the former State Library ( 1964), on the southeast corner of De Vargas and Don Gaspar; and the new state capitol (known as the "Roundhouse") fa1ther south and east ( 1964- 1965). Under the Urban Renewal program of the late 1960s and early 1970s, the realignment of De Vargas Street and the extension of Sandoval Street fwther altered and divided the historic neighborhood. The Old Santa Fe Association led a four-year struggle to preserve the west end of Analco from the program's efforts to erad icate "urban blight." For its protection the Barrio de Analco was made a National Historic Landmark in 1968. Today, although fragmented by state government buildings and altered by Urban Renewal , the oldest section of the baITio in the block west of the San Miguel Chapel retains the streetscape of pre-American 4 Santa Fe with single-story, fl at-roofed, adobe bui ldings lyi ng close to a narrow, curving street. The "Tudesqui" House is on the north side of the bl ock that runs between the Old Santa Fe Trai l and Don Gaspar Avenue. The San Miguel Chapel faces west down De Vargas Street from across the Old Santa Fe Trail. The only building on the property lies at the south end of the tract, close to the street on a long, narrow lot that slopes sharply down toward the Santa Fe Ri ver. The prope1iy once included the entire lot north from the road down to the ri ve r. There was surely a bui lding on this prope11y before the American occupation of New Mexico in 1846; by 1850 it was a substantial fi vc- room house. Although the connection between the HSF F prope11y and the Italian trader Roque Tudcsq ui is not established, the sto1y of its vcri fi- ablc owners is equal ly compelling. This very old neighborhood of sub- stantial homes attracted an interesting array of characters in the early years of the New Mexico tcrritmy that was organized in 1850. The "Tudesqui" House attracted a succession of owners, drawn from th e ranks of the leading military and business leaders of the day, both Hispan ic and Anglo.4 In 1850-1 85 1, the property was owned by Major Lafayette Head. A Missourian, Head had come to New Mex ico in 1846 with Co lonel Stirling W. Price's Second Mis- souri Volunteers. He married a lo- cal woman, Mattina Ma1tinez, and remained in the Southwest to en- gage extensively in trade and poli- tics. He served as an Indian agent, deputy U.S. Marshall forno1them New Mexico, and Rio Arriba County sheriff. Elected to both houses of the New Mexico terri- toria l legislature, he was chosen president of the council (senate). East De Vw ga.1· Street ca. 1882 5 In 1854 Head led about 50 families north to found a settlement in the San Luis Valley, then still within the boundaries of the New Mexico territory. He became a citizen of Colorado when that territory was cre- ated in 186 1and its southern .--------------~ ~ ;; border with NewMex icoes-'O "_ tablished to include the San ~ ~ Luis Valley. He was later ,_, elected to the Colorado ter- ~ ri torial counci l ( 1873) and ~ was Colorado's first lieuten- ] ant-governor after statehood '-£"""'"as-·1_D_e_Va_1_g-as-· c-a-.-18_8_4________. o... in I87 6. There is no evidence that Head actually occupied the house on East De Vargas Street. In 1850 he was living in Rio Arriba County, and most of his career was in northern New Mexico. If he was speculating, he did well. Having paid $180 for five rooms in January 1850, he more than doubled hi s money 17 months later when he so ld the property, now con- taining six rooms, for $400. From 1851 until 1865 the property was owned variously by the prominent merchant and rancher Manuel Salustiano Delgado and his equally illustrious children: Simon, Pablo, Fernando, Felipe S., Josefa, and Estefana, with their respecti ve spouses. For much of the 1850s, it was Pablo Delgado's home. Manual Salustiano apparently purchased the property from Lafayette Head for one of his sons, as within a few month s it was referred to as the house and lot occupied by Pablo Delgado. Like his brothers, Pablo ( 1822- 1873) was a Santa Fe Trail merchant and a politi- cian, serving in the te1Tito1ial legislature and as territorial treasurer. After Manuel Delgado died in 1854, the property was divided among his children, fomofwhom sold their interest to Pablo and Fernando. In 1857 Pablo sold his interest to Fernando, who in 1865 sold the prop- erty and its six rooms to Francisco Lopez and Figenia Sandoval for $1,000. 6 Lopez and Sandova l owned the property from the mid 1860s to the mid 1880s. It has recently been learned through studying the histo1y of the Candalario store on San Fran- cisco Street th at Lopez was the son ofDamaso Lopes. A nat ive of Spa in, the cider Lopes was a min- ing cxpcr1 and a trader. At his death in 185 1, his son Fra ncisco and three siblings inherited interests in severa l valuabl e trac ts on Sa n Francisco Street (including the eventual Candelario propc1iy) and on the west side of the Plaza. Fran- cisco Lopez was a miller and may have had a mill on the De Vargas Street propert y. When the census taker fo und Lopez and Sandoval i\fa1111el S. Delgado .., / in 1870, they \Vere apparently living there with their two young children. Locario and Francisco. In 1874 Figcnia and Francisco sold two rooms at the southwest corner of the tract to Crcscncia Dias for S50. D ias and Lopez sold these tvvo rooms in September 1876 to Fe liciana Quintana de Blu mncr, who had used an inheritance from her father to purchase the adjoining trnct on the west the preceding February. Quintana's husband, Charles Blurnner, had di ed the preceding June. In I885 Francisco Lopez and Figenia Sandova l transferred the property (minus the previously sold two rooms) fo r 5> I, I 00 to Ludlcna Thomson. Thomson was divorced from John Thomson fou r years later. At some poi nt after 1890 the property was transferred to Harry L. and Lucy M. Wa ldo .5 Judge Waldo ( 1844-1 9 15) was an influential New Mexico lawyer as well as fonner New Mexico attorney general and chief justice of the New Mex ico Supreme Cowt. At the ti me he purchased this 7 property he was exclusively employed as the New Mexico lawyer for the AT&SF Railway. In February 1894 Judge Waldo sold the property to Will iam L. Jones, who purchased the tract adjoining on the west the fo llowing Octo- ber. Thus were joined (for the first time in the documentary records) the two units now known as the "Tudesqui " House.<• The proper- ties did not remain together more than a few months. In February 1895 Jones sold the west portion to Bertha L. Cartwright. Th is was the approx im ate property that Roque Tudesqui had so ld in 184 l. About I 00 years later, in 1939, the Cartwright heirs so ld it to James (Jimmie) Caldwell. .• ! He111:r L. Waldo Jones and his wife Florence retained the east tract, now owned by the HSFF, as their ramil y home. Having arri ved in Santa Fe about l 88 1, Jones became the bookkeeper of the First National Bank in 1889 and also served four years as the Santa Fe city treasurer. Nei ther he nor his wife lived long to enjoy the De Vargas Street home. She died in March J 899, and he just a year later. They had no children and Wil liam left the property to Elizabeth Bolander. ("[H]is home residence with its orchard, p/acita, and kitchen garden .. .for her sole use and benefit during her life- time.") At Bo lander's death the prope1ty was to go to the trustees of the Protestant Episcopa l Church in New Mexico for the use and benefit of the Church of the Holy Faith at Santa Fe. Bolander, a si ngle woman, li ved in the house for about twenty years. A month after her death in 1922, the rector of Holy Faith sold it to another single woman, Sophie Knapp. She and her younger brother, Dr. David Knapp, lived there until their deaths. As the new centUJy progressed, 8 a strong co nnecti on bctwcen this and th e property on the west was created by a fri endship that began in Texas. T he Caldwell and Allen families were neighbors in Amarillo. In the 1920s Jimmi e Ca ldwell brought the Allens' teenage daugh- ter, Ma1jori e, on her first trip to Santa Fe as a baby sitter for his older daughter, Jamie. Later, as a young woman , Maijorie led her brothers to Santa Fe. Their parents soon fol- lowed. In 1939 Jimmie Caldwell converted the Ca1twright house into three apartments. In the early 1940s the older Allens rented one of them D1: Dan' ' rr ..-_ ,,.., ,.-._. [. ~~~J.~.t.~?:::~7:; :y:-(lfr:J·0::;~: ~ north -~ --·-.. ' _·1 -.- .I '; 1. • ! ... ; . • 1" ..at.• Iii ., -=---__:':__-• o • ., •o ~' O• • · ~ re t a-~ ~ ··------!. ~ :.. - ·~ -... ' I Urrutia map of Santa Fe (ca. 1766) 2 HSFF Mission To own, preserve and p rotect historic properties a nd resources of Santa Fe an d environs and to provide historic preservatio n educat ion. 1999 BOARD OF DI RECTORS Executive Committee President Ist Vice Chair Treasurer Secretary Members at Large Jesse Monfort Bopp Eleanor Bove Dana Evans Karen Heldmeycr Corinne Sze (honora1y ) Executive Director Peter Wirt h Greg Walke Jack Pressler Sally I Iyer Wi lliam Heckel.Jr. James Kcnnicott Ramon Jose Lopez Paul McConnell Lois Snyderman THE HISTORIC SANTA FE FOUNDATION PO Box 2535 Santa Fe, NM 87504-2535 983-2567 City/State_ ______ _____ ___Zi p____ Individual Family C ommercial Annual Mem bership Dues $15.00- - - - $25.00- --- $50.00- --- Patron Sustaining Life I would like to volunteer.- - --- $75---- $150---- 1000---- Images are from City of Santa Fe staff’s site visit at 129 E de Vargas September 10, 2026 at approximately 8:30am during the initial site visit. Images were taken by senior planner, Lauren Vagts, who was assigned to the case August 28, 2026 following the applicant’s submittal. Figures 1 and 2. Replacement sconces on south elevation, partial view of repainted trim. Figure 3. Replacement railing and decking, north elevation. Partial view of painted stucco under portal. Figure 4. Detail of replacement decking and siding. Figure 5. Northwest elevation showing grading, replacement railings, and repainting of wooden fenestration. Figure 6. North elevation showing regrading and ground disturbance for newly installed stairs. Figure 7. North elevation. Replacement of historic railings and stairs. Figure 8. Gate installation within historic yardwall separating 129 and 135 E de Vargas Street, north elevation. Figure 9. River rock removed from historic yardwall set in the northeast corner of the parking lot. Figure 10. Newly installed stone pavers, north elevation. Figure 11. Stairs and railings installed on north elevation. Figure 12. New stairs and railings installed on north elevation. Figure 13. North stair foundation, looking east. Figure 14. Wood cladding replacement, north elevation. Figures 16-19. Replacement sconces, north elevation showing painted trim and stucco. Figures 20 and 21. Decking and railing replacement with historic support columns. Figure 22. Replacement railings and wood flooring where historic brick pavers were in place.