Case #2024-9461 Rezoning & Case #2025-11164 General Plan Amendment Planning Commission Meeting – June 18, 2026 Page 1 of 30 Planning and Land Use Department Planning Commission Staff Report Case Nos: 2024-9461 & 2025-11164 Site Map Hearing Date: June 18, 2026 Agent: NM Land Solutions, LLC Owner: Larry Boylan Request: General Plan Amendment and Rezoning Location: 1372 Boylan Lane, 2743 Boylan Circle, 2745 Boylan Circle Case Mgr: Joel Cruz-Haber Zoning: R1 (Residential) Future Land Use: Transitional Mixed-Use Overlays: Rivers and Trails Archeological District; West Santa Fe River Corridor Master Plan: None Pre-app Mtg: June 13, 2024 ENN Mtg: September 26, 2024 Applicant Proposal: The applicant requests approval for a General Plan Amendment from Transitional Mixed/Use to Community Commercial and a Rezoning from R1 (Residential) to C-2 (General Commercial). Case #2024-9461 Rezoning & Case #2025-11164 General Plan Amendment Planning Commission Meeting – June 18, 2026 Page 2 of 30 Case #2025 – 11164. General Plan Amendment at 1372 Boylan Lane, 2743 Boylan Circle, and 2745 Boylan Circle. NM Land Solutions, LLC, Agent, for Larry Boylan, Owner, requests approval to amend the General Plan Future Land Use Map from Transitional Mixed Use to General Commercial on a 5.96- acre lot. The property is located within the River and Trails Archaeological Review district and West Santa Fe River Corridor. (Joel Cruz-Haber, Case Manager, jacruzhaber@santafenm.gov). Case #2024 – 9461. Rezoning at 1372 Boylan Lane, 2743 Boylan Circle, and 2745 Boylan Circle. NM Land Solutions, LLC, Agent, for Larry Boylan, Owner, requests approval for a rezoning of a 5.96- acre lot located at 1372 Boylan Lane, 2743 Boylan Circle, and 2745 Boylan Circle from R1 (Residential) to C-2 (Commercial) (Joel Cruz-Haber, Case Manager, jacruzhaber@santafenm.gov). I. STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS: a. City Planning and Land Use Department staff (“Staff”) recommends the Planning Commission recommend the Governing Body deny Case #2025 – 11164, General Plan Amendment from Transitional Mixed Use to Community Commercial. b. City Planning and Land Use Department staff (“Staff”) recommends the Planning Commission recommend the Governing Body approve Case #2024 – 9461, Rezoning to a less intensive zoning designation of C-1 (Office and Related Commercial District) subject to Santa Fe City Code 1987 §14-3.4(B)(2)(b). c. City Planning and Land Use Department staff (“Staff”) recommends the Planning Commission recommend the Governing Body approve Case #2024 – 9461, Rezoning to a less intensive zoning designation of MU (Mixed Use) subject to Santa Fe City Code 1987 §14-3.4(B)(2)(b). Option Motion language: Ranked by staff’s preference 1. Recommend the Governing Body approve or deny Case #2024-9461 Rezoning from R-1 (One Dwelling Unit Per Acre) to C-1. 2. Recommend the Governing Body approve or deny Case #2024-9461 Rezoning from R-1 (One Dwelling Unit Per Acre) to MU. Case #2024-9461 Rezoning & Case #2025-11164 General Plan Amendment Planning Commission Meeting – June 18, 2026 Page 3 of 30 II. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: This application was submitted on November 12, 2024, and is being reviewed under the Land Development Code (“Code”) that was in effect prior to January 1, 2026. The 5.96-acre property is located at 1372 Boylan Lane, 2743 Boylan Circle, and 2745 Boylan Circle (the “Property”). The Property is located just north of Agua Fria Street, and approximately ½ mile east of the Siler and Agua Fria intersection. The Property is currently a mix of vacant land as well as a small mobile home park (approximately 15 units). New Mexico Land Solutions (the “Agent”) on behalf of the property owner, Larry Boylan (the “Owner”) requests the Planning Commission recommend that the Governing Body approve a General Plan Amendment (the “Amendment”) to the Future Land Use Map (“FLUM”) designation for the Property from Transitional Mixed Use (“TMXU”) to Community Commercial (“CCOM”). In addition, the Agent requests a rezoning of the Property from R-1 (1 Dwelling Unit Per Acre) to C-2 (General Commercial District) (the “Rezoning”). Staff’s analysis finds that the Amendment and Rezoning as submitted by the applicant, are not in compliance with the relevant approval criteria (see Tables 6, 7, and 8) and recommends denial of the proposed General Plan Amendment. However, as provided for in Santa Fe City Code 1987 (“SFCC”) §14-3.5(B)(2)(b),1 Staff requests the Planning Commission recommend the Governing Body approve a rezoning in compliance with the General Plan, to a less intensive zone district than requested by the Agent. Staff finds that a rezoning from R-1 to C-1 (Office and Related Commercial District) or to MU (Mixed Use) would meet the required rezoning approval criteria and negate the need for a General Plan Amendment as the C-1 and MU zone districts are compatible with the Site’s FLUM designation of Transitional Mixed Use and the vision for the Property as articulated in the West Santa Fe River Corridor Plan. Subject to SFCC § 14-3.1(E) a pre-application meeting was held on June 13, 2024. Thereafter, a virtual Early Neighborhood Notification (“ENN”) was held on September 26th, 2024, via Zoom pursuant to SFCC §14-3.1(F). A General Amendment and Rezoning application was submitted to the Land Use Department on November 13th, 2024, and transmitted to the Departmental Review Team (“DRT”). Subject to SFCC 14-2.5, the notice requirements for the June 18th, 2026 Planning Commission (“Commission”) public hearing were duly notified; the Agent sent notice of public hearing via certified mail to neighbors within 100’ of the Property, first class mail for the remaining 200’ of neighbors and posted a notice of public hearing sign on May 20th, 2026. In addition, a legal ad with the notice of public hearing was posted in the New Mexican on May 20th 2026. At the June 2nd, 2026 public hearing, the Planning Commission voted to postpone hearing the Agent’s request to June 18th, 2026. 1 The governing body may approve a rezoning to a less intensive zone district than originally requested by the applicant . In such cases, no re- application or re-processing of the original application shall be required. Case #2024-9461 Rezoning & Case #2025-11164 General Plan Amendment Planning Commission Meeting – June 18, 2026 Page 4 of 30 III. PROJECT ANALYSIS A. General Plan & Future Land Use Map The rezoning approval criteria require the Planning Commission and the Governing Body to make complete findings of fact that all criteria have been met before recommending or approving any rezone One such finding of fact is that all rezonings be consistent with the applicable policies of the 1999 General Plan (“General Plan”), including the Future Land Use map. According to the Future Land Use Map (see Figure 1: “Future Land Use Map”) the Site is currently designated as TMXU. TMXU designation allows for a “mixing of compatible land uses within the same tract which may include such uses as residential, including single-family and multi-family residential where the scale and intensity are deemedappropriate…and appropriately scaled retail/services that are intended to primarily serve the residential uses as an added local amenity.” – Mixed Use & Transitional Definitions. (Attachment A) While the Applicant is requesting an amendment to the General Plan to accommodate their desired zoning, other more compatible zone districts are available which will both facilitate a desirable redevelopment of the property and the support the vison for this area of Santa Fe as articulated in the General Plan and the West Santa Fe River Corridor Plan. An amendment to the GP is unjustified and approval of an unencumbered rezone to C-2 will open the door to a number of incompatible uses of the property including vehicle service and repair, gas stations, cannabis testing, research, and manufacturing (see Table 5). Figure 1 Future Land use Map "FLUM" Case #2024-9461 Rezoning & Case #2025-11164 General Plan Amendment Planning Commission Meeting – June 18, 2026 Page 5 of 30 A rezone to C-2 is inconsistent with the Transitional Mixed Use (“TMXU”) designation because C-2 zoning permits certain uses, as outlined in Table 5, that are not “appropriately scaled retail/services that are intended to primarily serve the residential uses as an added local amenity”. The intensity of these uses could have negative impacts on neighboring existing uses and are not consistent with the intent of the General Plan or the West Santa Fe River Corridor Plan for this Property. The nearby properties zoned C-2 at 1400 and 1411 Boylan (Ord. 2014-32) and 2751 and 2749 Agua Fria (Ord. 2015-34) achieved their zoning in 2014 and 2015 respectively, prior to the adoption of the West Santa Fe River Corridor Plan. The Acequia Lofts residential development to the east of the Property is zoned C1-PUD and the mixed-use development across the street with Escondido is zoned Mixed-Use. The properties surrounding the Site have a range of designations on the Future Land Use Map. To the east and west of the Site, the properties are designated as Community Commercial (CCOM), Transitional Mixed Use (TMXU), and Office. The properties across Agua Fria Street to the south are designated as Transitional Mixed Use (TMXU). The Site to the north is the Santa Fe River and designated as Open Space. When the applicant requested a C-2 zone district, staff expressed concern regarding the wide variety of uses that would be incompatible with surrounding uses. During review, Staff recommended that the Agent include a Master Plan or Development Plan with the Amendment and Rezone to constrain development of the Property. A Master Plan could have been used to limit certain uses, ensuring compatibility with the General Plan, the West Santa Fe River Corridor Plan and surrounding developments. A Master Plan or Development Plan would have allowed for the review the site’s feasibility to connect to City infrastructure or to measure consistency with the surrounding neighborhood uses and could have potentially led to a positive recommendation for approval. However. due to this deficiency in the Agent’s application, staff cannot discern whether future development of the Property will be consistent with the Transitional Mixed Use land use category and the overall vision for this area as articulated in the General Plan and West Santa Fe River Corridor Plan. Therefore, staff recommends denial of the General Plan Amendment, and recommends approval of a rezoning to either C-1 or MU, but not to C-2. The C-1 and MU zone districts are consistent with the existing future land use category. Case #2024-9461 Rezoning & Case #2025-11164 General Plan Amendment Planning Commission Meeting – June 18, 2026 Page 6 of 30 B. Overlay Districts The Property lies within the River and Trails Archaeological Review District Overlay and the West Santa Fe River Corridor Overlay. 1. Rivers and Trails Archeological Review District Subject to SFCC 1987 §14-5.3(D) and §14- 3.13(B)(2), an archeological clearance permit shall be provided at the time of development when located in the Archeological Review District. An archeological clearance permit is not required for a rezoning when a development plan or plat are not proposed. Figure 2 River and Trails Archeological Review District Figure 3 West Santa Fe River Corridor Plan Case #2024-9461 Rezoning & Case #2025-11164 General Plan Amendment Planning Commission Meeting – June 18, 2026 Page 7 of 30 2. West Santa Fe River Corridor Plan and Overlay On December 13, 2017, the Governing Body adopted the West Santa Fe River Corridor Plan (the “Plan”) (Resolution 2017-87), the result of a year’s long collaboration between multiple city departments and a citizen’s working group of “local residents, business owners, architects, Planning Commission and members of the Agua Fria Traditional Historic Community”. There was robust engagement including 22 weekly meetings with City staff and the working group and several open houses to allow local residents an opportunity to review and discuss the plan recommendations. The Plan led to the adoption of the West Santa Fe River Corridor Overlay district (Ord. 2017-25) which sets specific development standards for the plan area. The Property under review is located within the Plan’s “Mixed Area” (see Figure 3). The Plan acknowledges that the city’s default zoning of R1 is, “not appropriate for the Mixed Area as many of the parcels already contain business uses and because warehouses with industrial zoning are located directly across Agua Fria Street.” The Plan proposes re-zoning to, “create a reasonable transition from more intense commercial uses near Siler Road to less intense residential uses near Frenchy’s Park.” Further the Plan specifies that Parcels zoned R-1 with a Future Land Use as Transitional Mixed Use should be rezoned to Mixed-Use. The Plan led to the adoption of the West Santa Fe River Corridor Overlay (see Figure 4) which ensures future development adheres to the design criteria and purpose of the River Corridor Plan. The Overlay design criteria include setbacks to Agua Fria and the Santa Fe River, limits to building height, and additional open space requirements as described in Table 1. The West Santa Fe River Corridor Overlay will be the primary guide for design and the base zoning district will address other Figure 4 West Santa Fe River Overlay with Property Case #2024-9461 Rezoning & Case #2025-11164 General Plan Amendment Planning Commission Meeting – June 18, 2026 Page 8 of 30 dimensional standards related to lot coverage and density as described in Table 3 or 4 of this report. Table 1: West Santa Fe River Corridor Overlay Requirements Maximum Height 28’ Setbacks From Street In the case of residential development, the setback applies when proposing a minimum of two lots or two housing units. Minimum setbacks from the street for new developments and new subdivisions fronting: 1.Agua Fria Street: 30 feet, or 20 percent of lot depth, whichever is less, from the Agua Fria Street frontage property line. 2. West Alameda Street: 50 feet from the West Alameda Street frontage property line. Building Setbacks from Santa Fe River A minimum of fifteen (15) feet from whichever one of the following is the most restrictive: (1) River Greenway Boundary, or (2) 100-year Floodplain Boundary (FEMA), or (3) City code setback measurement for streams and watercourses, [14-8.2 (D)(4)(e)(i)]. Minimum Frontage Width for Development along West Alameda St. Minimum street frontage width of two hundred and fifty (250) feet along West Alameda Street is required for any subdivision, unless approved by the traffic engineer. Common Area Open Space In lieu of park dedication to the city, residential subdivisions or developments with a density of five (5) dwellings per acre or greater, or a minimum of twenty-five (25) total housing units or lots, shall have a minimum of ten (10) percent of the total land area of the proposed subdivision or development reserved as common area open space. [See also Land Development Code, "Residential Common Open Space Standards," 14-7.5(B)]. Case #2024-9461 Rezoning & Case #2025-11164 General Plan Amendment Planning Commission Meeting – June 18, 2026 Page 9 of 30 C. Zoning and Dimensional Standards The Property was a part of the City initiated annexation located in Area 2 phase 1 in 2013 as described in Ordinance 2013-36 (Attachment A). When annexed, the Property was given an R-1 zoning district designation and has remained the same, “Figure 5: Existing Zoning.” ‘The R-1 zoning district allows for 1 dwelling unit per acre and a number of accessory uses which are compatible with low density residential development. Table 2 below describes the zoning and existing land uses in the area surrounding the Site. Table 2: Adjacent Zoning and Land Uses Direction Zoning Existing Land Use North R-1 (Residential) Santa Fe River and River Trail West C-2 (Commercial) and R-1 (Residential) Variety of residential uses (both single family and multifamily) and commercial uses (offices and service-oriented businesses) East C-2 (General Commercial) and C- 1 PUD (Commercial) Vacant land and multifamily residential (Acequia Lofts) South (across Agua Fria Street) MU (Mixed-Use) Residential uses (single family and multifamily) and commercial uses (Escondido Restaurant) If the Amendment is approved as requested by the Applicant, the requested C-2 zone Rezoning would not be consistent with the Future Land Use Map or the West Santa Fe Corridor River plan. Staff’s recommendation to rezone from R-1 to C- 1 or MU zoning district is consistent with the current FLUM designation of Transitional Mixed-Use (TMXU) and if followed would not require an amendment to the General Plan. Figure 5: Existing Zoning Map Case #2024-9461 Rezoning & Case #2025-11164 General Plan Amendment Planning Commission Meeting – June 18, 2026 Page 10 of 30 Table 3. Residential and Non-Residential Dimensional Standard Differences Between C-1 and C-2 per Table 14-7.2-1 & 14-7.3-1 (Old Code) Standard Type C-2 C-1 Height (feet)* 45’ 36’ Setbacks ** Street: 15’ Rear: 10’ Side: 0’ Nonresidential Uses: Street : 10 Side: 5 Rear: 10 Residential Uses: Same as for R-21 district. (Established through Development Plan) Open Space*** (Square Feet) 250 SF/ dwelling unit Single-family dwellings or multiple-family dwellings : 250 square feet of common and/ or private open space for each unit (Defers to R:21 Open Space). Lot Coverage 60% maximum Nonresidential Uses: 60% (Non-residential Open Space subject to 14-7.5(D). Residential Uses: 40% Density None (Density is determined as a result of max. height, setbacks, lot coverage, and parking) R-10=10; R-12, R-21 and R-29=10 or per development plan or special use permit approval (see 14-7.2(F)). If public sewer and water are not provided, see Note 15: The maximum gross density in districts that permit residential use is 0.4 dwelling units per acre if neither public sewer or water is provided, and one dwelling unit per acre if either public sewer or water is provided, and 0.8 dwelling units per acre if the lot was created through an inheritance or family transfer subdivision that resulted in only one additional lot . * Height of structures shall be 28’ when located in West Santa Fe River Corridor Overlay. (Table 1) ** Setbacks shall also adhere to Santa Fe River and Street backs defined in West Santa Fe River Corridor Overlay. (Table 1) *** Additional Common open space standards shall be met for future development. (Table 1) Table 4. Residential and Non-Residential Dimensional Standards for Mixed Use 14-7.3-1 (Old Code) Standard Type Mixed Use Height (feet) A maximum height of 35 feet shall be permitted where two or more stories are included in a building ; where the mixed-use development is located adjacent to residential uses or residential zoning, all buildings and structures within 70 feet of the adjoining residential property line shall not exceed 25 feet in height. Also see §14-7.3(B)(1) for step-back requirements. Setbacks Street : Equivalent to the minimum yard requirements in any adjoining residential zoning district if not separated by a street ; otherwise none is required. Side: 30 feet from property line when abutting a residential district; 5 feet from property line if not abutting a residential district. Right of way may be counted as part of setback . Rear: 30 feet from property line when abutting a residential district; 10 feet from property line if not abutting a residential district. Right of way may be counted as part of setback . Also see §14-7.3(B)(1) for separation requirements. Open Space Each dwelling unit shall be provided with a minimum of two hundred fifty (250) square feet of qualifying private or common open space . Case #2024-9461 Rezoning & Case #2025-11164 General Plan Amendment Planning Commission Meeting – June 18, 2026 Page 11 of 30 Lot Coverage None, except as may be needed to satisfy other limitations applicable to a MU district Also see §14-7.3(B)(1) for footprint requirements and residential requirements Density Buildings of twenty-five (25) feet or less in height shall not exceed a maximum of twelve (12) dwelling units per acre and buildings of between twenty-five (25) feet and thirty-five (35) feet or less in height shall not exceed fourteen (14) dwelling units per acre. Each dwelling unit shall be provided with a minimum of two hundred fifty (250) square feet of qualifying private or common open space . Additional Mixed-Use Standards include the following; • Architecture Step-Backs o Third floors shall have a step-back (balcony or roof area) of a minimum of five (5) feet from all the building’s facades at ground level. • Separation of Uses o Where any of the following uses exist on an adjoining site, group living or household living uses shall be separated from the following uses by a minimum distance of fifty (50) feet:  a drive-through use or facility, including gas stations, car washes, restaurants and banks;  animal hospitals or clinics with external overnight boarding;  child day care facilities with more than thirty children;  outdoor storage of material;  restaurants and bars operating between the hours of 10:00 p.m. and 7:00 a.m.;  liquor stores;  hotels and motels ; and  any land use that the planning commission determines will produce environmental impacts, processes or products that are incompatible with residential uses, and that is noted on the approved master plan or development plan. • Building Tenant Space o No single commercial tenant space shall exceed a total of twenty thousand (20,000) square feet. • Residential Uses o Residential uses shall consist of at least forty percent of the development's total floor area if located adjacent to residentially zoned districts. If not, residential uses shall consist of at least twenty percent of the development's total floor area. The master plan, plat and development plan shall show this residential /commercial mix. • Formerly Zoned Industrial Park o Any property previously zoned industrial park with master plan approval on or before the date of adoption of the BIP zoning district shall be governed by and subject to the approved master plan. Where a conflict exists between the approved master plan and the requirements of this Section 14-7.3, the more lenient standard shall prevail. o • The Mixed-Use district standards address the mitigation of potential negative impacts on adjacent residential uses, which is why the regulatory framework of Mixed-Use was set forth in the West Santa Fe River Corridor Plan. Case #2024-9461 Rezoning & Case #2025-11164 General Plan Amendment Planning Commission Meeting – June 18, 2026 Page 12 of 30 D. C-1 vs C-2 Uses The Applicant’s request to Rezone to C-2 did not include a master plan, or development plan request which would have provided in staff and the DRT an opportunity to make conditions of approval to ensure compliance with compatible uses, ity infrastructure, transportation and traffic requirements, and emergency service improvements. As a result, staff is unable to determine if the site can accommodate the level of improvements needed for future developments within the requested C-2 zone district. Therefore, staff is recommending a less intensive zone district of C-1 or MU to ensure consistency with the Future Land Use Map designation of Transitional Mixed Use and the West Santa Fe River Corridor Plan. All future development shall adhere Summary Use Table set forth in Santa Fe City Code 2026 (“SFCC 2026”), §14-5.2(D) Table 5-1. Table 5, shows a handful of uses that are not allowed, permitted, or require conditional use permit comparing MU, C-1 and C-2. Table 5. Comparison Summary of Allowed Uses – MU vs C-1 vs C-2 Use MU C-1 C-2 Light Assembly Manufacturing Not Allowed Not Allowed Permitted Service and Repair Garage, including Gas Station Not Allowed Not Allowed Permitted Tire recapping and retreading Not Allowed Not Allowed Permitted Continuing Care Community Permitted Permitted Conditional Use Permit Foster Home Permitted Permitted Not Allowed Group Residential Care Facility, Large or Small Permitted Permitted Conditional Use Permit Cannabis Manufacturing Light Not Allowed Not Allowed Permitted Cannabis Producer Micro-business Not Allowed Not Allowed Permitted/ Conditional Use Permit Cannabis Producer Not Allowed Not Allowed Conditional Use Permit Cannabis Testing or Research Laboratory Not Allowed Not Allowed Permitted Commercial Cannabis Retailer Permitted with Use Specific Standards Not Allowed Permitted E. Legal Lot of Record The Applicant has provided documentation confirming that the subject properties are legal lots of record. See Attachment C: “Applicant Submittals” Case #2024-9461 Rezoning & Case #2025-11164 General Plan Amendment Planning Commission Meeting – June 18, 2026 Page 13 of 30 F. Infrastructure The City Code requires that infrastructure be able to accommodate the impacts of the proposed development. “[T]he existing and proposed infrastructure, such as the streets system, sewer and water lines, and public facilities, such as fire stations and parks, will be able to accommodate the impacts of the proposed development.” SFCC 1987, § 14-3.5(C)(1)(e). The Property is located within the County Fire District and approximately 1.12 miles from Fire Station No.3 located at the intersection of Third and Cerillos. When a development project is reviewed, Santa Fe Fire Department shall provide site specific recommendations based on the intensity and type of use being proposed in the future. For example, future development would likely require fire hydrants be placed and water connections be made to the City’s public water system. The site does not currently connect to City water however, it does access City wastewater services from the Santa Fe River via a private water line shown in red in Figure 6 of this report. The Property’s wastewater needs are currently serviced by an 8- inch PVC sewer line that is privately owned and will need a new public sewer line when development is proposed. The Development Review Team’s (“DRT”) review of the rezoning request concluded that City resources and infrastructure are available to the Site. The types of uses allowed in C-1 or MU zoning can likely be accommodated in this location, subject to specific requirements and improvements that will be identified during Development Plan review. See Attachment A: “DRT Comments”. Figure 6: Utility Connections Yellow Line = Site Boundary Red Line = Private Sewer Blue Line = Water Connection Green Line = Wastewater Connection Case #2024-9461 Rezoning & Case #2025-11164 General Plan Amendment Planning Commission Meeting – June 18, 2026 Page 14 of 30 GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT APPROVAL CRITERIA Section 14-3.2(E) and (E)(2) SFCC 2001 sets forth approval criteria for General Plan Amendment as follows: (1) The planning commission and the governing body shall review all general plan amendment proposals on the basis of the following criteria, and shall make complete findings of fact sufficient to show that these criteria have been met before recommending or approving any amendment to the general plan: Table 6: General Plan Amendment Approval Criteria Criterion a (14-3.2(E)(1)(a)): consistency with growth projections for Santa Fe, economic development goals as set forth in a comprehensive economic development plan for Santa Fe and existing land use conditions such as access and availability of infrastructure; Criterion Met: (Yes/No) NO Applicant’s Response: The proposed General Plan Amendment is consistent with Chapter 3-1 of the Land Use Themes as provided below: • Quality of Life: The proposed General Plan Amendment has the potential to enhance the quality of life at the time the property is redeveloped from the existing non-conforming mobile home park that was established prior to the 1981 adoption of the Santa Fe County Code. • Economic Diversity: The proposed amendment facilitates the creation of both construction-related jobs and long-term employment opportunities through the development of commercial uses. This is consistent with the General Plan’s economic development objectives, which emphasize creating jobs and promoting balanced economic growth within the city. • Sustainable Growth: The existing homes on the property are served by two private wells along with a private sewer line which is connected to the trunk line located north of the property across the Santa Fe River and eventually flows into the city’s system. As with the non-conforming mobile home park, the two water wells that are currently feeding the existing homes is not sustainable. Redevelopment will require capping of the two wells allowing the diversion of ground water in the amount of a total of 6.0 afy of water per year. Capping of the wells directly conserves groundwater, which is a natural resource and has been severely depleted over time by the existing drought. Connection the city’s water system will also require an approved water budget that will assist on restriction of water along with collection of revenue by the city for use of water. The existing private sewer line was installed over 40 years ago and will need to be Case #2024-9461 Rezoning & Case #2025-11164 General Plan Amendment Planning Commission Meeting – June 18, 2026 Page 15 of 30 adequately sized and upgraded to city standards for future dedication to the City to ensure proper construction and maintenance. • Mixed Use: Santa Fe is currently experiencing a steady growth rate of 0.54% annually, with the population having increased by 2.19%. The proposed general plan amendment from Low Density Residential to Community Commercial zoning will allow for a mix of commercial and or high-density residential uses which is consistent with the mix of uses established in this area after the City/County annexation occurred in 2009. The proposed General Plan Amendment allows flexibility to re-develop the property consistent with the area by providing the ability to establish a range of permitted uses without the rigid residential-to-commercial ratio specified in the transitional mixed-use future land use designation flexibility supports the City's economic development goals. Transportation and Mobility: The proposed development also aligns with the General Plan’s transportation goals by enhancing connectivity and providing alternative transportation options. The property’s adjacency to the Santa Fe River Greenway Trail, which accommodates both pedestrians and cyclists, supports the General Plan’s vision for expanding and improving the city’s pedestrian and bike infrastructure. The Greenway Trail connects key parts of the city, contributing to the city’s transportation and mobility policies. • Infrastructure and Public Services: The proposed amendment is consistent with the General Plan’s goals related to infrastructure and public services. Although the existing mobile home park is currently served by a domestic well, redevelopment of the property will require connection to city water, ensuring that the development aligns with the city’s water infrastructure policies. The new sewer system, which will be installed to meet city standards and maintained by the city after one year, is also consistent with the General Plan’s commitment to ensuring adequate, sustainable public services and infrastructure to support growth. The amendment is also consistent with the guiding policies within Chapter 4 of the 1999 General Plan, specifically regarding the promotion of infill development, efficient use of existing infrastructure, and recognition of water demand and conservation. By aligning with these policies, the amendment contributes to the balanced growth of Santa Fe, promoting both residential development and new employment opportunities in a sustainable manner. Additionally, the proposal is consistent with the existing land use conditions, including the availability of access and infrastructure. Staff Response: The Applicant has not provided sufficient evidence to address this approval criteria. Staff finds that the criteria is not met and recommends denial of the applicant’s request to amend the General Plan’s Future Land Use Map from Transitional Mixed-Use to Community Commercial. The General Plan and the West Santa Fe River Corridor Plan were adopted after extensive data analysis, rigorous public engagement and represents the community’s collective vision for development of this area. The property is currently lacking Case #2024-9461 Rezoning & Case #2025-11164 General Plan Amendment Planning Commission Meeting – June 18, 2026 Page 16 of 30 in sufficient infrastructure to support the non-conforming 15 mobile home units, but redevelopment of the property can occur without amending the existing FLUM designation of Transitional Mixed Use. A rezoning to a less intense zone district such as C-1 or Mixed-Use would allow for a diverse set of compatible residential, commercial and office uses, without the need to amend the City’s General Plan. Furthermore the less intense MU zone district is the preferred district as articulated in the City’s adopted West Santa Fe River Corridor Plan. Criterion b (14-3.2(E)(b)): consistency with other parts of the general plan ; Criterion Met: (Yes/No) NO Applicant’s Response: The proposed General Plan Amendment is consistent with several key elements of the Santa Fe General Plan, Specifically the Guiding policy described in Chapter 3 of the 1999 General Plan and provided below: Guiding Policy 3-G-3 States “There shall be infill development at densities that support the construction of affordable housing and designated mix of land uses that provide an adequate balance service retail and employment opportunities to address residential growth throughout the Urban Area, including the Railyard property” The subject property is considered as infill located within the Urban Area as describe in the 1999 General Plan and has the potential to redevelop at higher residential densities and or other commercial uses that could create employment opportunities. Staff Response: The Applicant has not provided sufficient evidence to address this approval criteria. Staff finds that the criteria is not met and recommends denial of the applicant’s request to amend the General Plan’s Future Land Use Map from Transitional Mixed-Use to Community Commercial. The General Plan and West Santa Fe River Corridor Plan were adopted after extensive data analysis, rigorous public engagement and represents the community’s collective vision for development of this area. The site is currently lacking in sufficient infrastructure to support the non-conforming 15 mobile home units, but redevelopment of the site can occur without amending the existing FLUM designation of Transitional Mixed Use. A rezoning to a less intense zone district such as C-1 or Mixed-Use would allow for a diverse set of compatible residential, commercial and office uses, without the need to amend the City’s General Plan. Criterion c (14-3.2(E)(1)(c)): the amendment does not: (i)allow uses or a change that is significantly different from or inconsistent with the prevailing use and character in the area; or (ii)affect an area of less than two acres, except when adjusting boundaries between districts; or (iii)benefit one or a few landowners at the expense of the surrounding landowners or the general public; Criterion Met: (Yes/No) NO Applicant’s Response: Case #2024-9461 Rezoning & Case #2025-11164 General Plan Amendment Planning Commission Meeting – June 18, 2026 Page 17 of 30 (i.) The proposed amendment does not introduce uses or changes that are significantly different from or inconsistent with the prevailing use and character of the surrounding area. Over time, particularly following the city/county annexation, the area has undergone significant changes ,allowing for the future redevelopment of infill properties with access to city utilities as well access to sufficient city maintained roadways. Many of the surrounding properties have been rezoned within the past fifteen years to accommodate higher-density residential uses, including multifamily apartment buildings, reflecting the city's growth and evolving urban landscape. Currently, the area includes a mix of residential and commercial uses. Some commercial properties are legal non-conforming, while others were established through previous general plan amendments and rezonings. The proposed general plan amendment is consistent with this pattern of development, as it allows for a combination of residential and commercial uses that align with the existing mix of land uses in the area. The amendment would further complement the surrounding properties by providing additional opportunities for both residential and commercial growth, without significantly altering the established character of the neighborhood. Thus, the amendment is in keeping with the area's ongoing transition and growth, and it aligns with the existing mix of residential and commercial uses that have developed over time. The proposed change is not a dramatic departure from the current land use pattern but rather a continuation of the evolving character of the area. (ii.) There are four adjoining legal lots of record with a total of 5.96 acres. (iii.) The proposed amendment will provide benefits not only to the applicant but also to the surrounding landowners and the broader community. The property in question is currently occupied by an aging mobile home park that has been in place for over forty years, predating the Santa Fe County Code and prior to being annexed into the City of Santa Fe. This property is in need of redevelopment to address current deficiencies and enhance the area’s overall character. The existing site is encumbered by several electric power poles and a large stockpile of dirt along the Agua Fria Street frontage, both of which negatively impact the aesthetics and functionality of the area. The proposed amendment will facilitate a sustainable and diverse redevelopment that connects the property to city utilities, addressing key infrastructure challenges. Specifically, the redevelopment will allow for the relocation and undergrounding of electric services, improving both the visual appeal and safety of the area. These infrastructure improvements will directly benefit the surrounding landowners by reducing existing eyesores and enhancing the overall neighborhood environment. Additionally, by redeveloping the site, the amendment creates the potential for a more vibrant and well- integrated community with better access to essential services. The redevelopment is designed to integrate seamlessly with surrounding properties, offering opportunities for both residential and commercial growth that will benefit the area as a whole, not just a select few. Case #2024-9461 Rezoning & Case #2025-11164 General Plan Amendment Planning Commission Meeting – June 18, 2026 Page 18 of 30 This approach ensures that the amendment does not disproportionately benefit one landowner at the expense of others but instead supports the broader public interest by improving infrastructure, enhancing the built environment, and contributing to the neighborhood’s long-term sustainability and growth. Staff Response: Through the General Plan and the West Santa Fe River Corridor Plan the city has articulated a vision for development of this Property. The Applicant’s request to amend that collective vision in support of a single property owners request has not been justified. Staff does not recommend approval of the applicant’s request to amend the General Plan’s Future Land Use Map from Transitional Mixed-Use to Community Commercial, but supports a Rezone to a more compatible zone district such as MU or C-1, which would not necessitate a GP Amendment. The proposed amendment would permit uses that are significantly different from or inconsistent with the prevailing use and character in the area. Existing areas that were permitted to be rezoned to C-2 were rezoned prior to the adoption of the West Santa Fe River Corridor plan and likely were the impetus for the development of the corridor plan. Criterion d (14-3.2(E)(d)): an amendment is not required to conform with Subsection 14-3.2(E)(1)(c) if it promotes the general welfare or has other adequate public advantage or justification; Criterion Met: (Yes/No) NO Applicant Response: The proposed amendment is in conformance with Subsection 14-3.2(E)(1)(c) as stated in the above responses (c) i,ii,iii. Staff Response: Staff does not recommend approval of the applicant’s request to amend the General Plan’s Future Land Use Map from Transitional Mixed-Use to General Commercial and finds that the current designation of Transitional Mixed use continues to promote the general public welfare. The Applicant has not provided sufficient evidence to justify the Amendment. Criterion e (14-3.2(E)(1)(e)): compliance with extraterritorial zoning ordinances and extraterritorial plans; Criterion Met: (Yes/No) NO Applicant’s Response: This criterion is no longer relevant since the adoption of Subdivision Platting and Planning Zoning Ordinance (SPPaZO), and the relinquishment of the land use regulatory authority outside the city limits and the transfer of authority from extraterritorial jurisdiction to the City. Staff Response: Not Applicable. Case #2024-9461 Rezoning & Case #2025-11164 General Plan Amendment Planning Commission Meeting – June 18, 2026 Page 19 of 30 Criterion f (14-3.2(E)(f)): contribution to a coordinated, adjusted and harmonious development of Santa Fe that in accordance with existing and future needs best promotes health, safety, morals, order, convenience, prosperity or the general welfare, as well as efficiency and economy in the process of development ; and Criterion Met: (Yes/No) NO Applicant’s Response: The proposed amendment will contribute to the coordinated, harmonious development of Santa Fe by addressing both current and future needs, and it will promote health, safety, and general welfare of the community. The existing mobile home park, currently designated as transitional mixed-use, does not comply with the current land use regulations and is limited in its ability to undergo meaningful upgrades or redevelopment due to its non-conforming status. This limitation restricts opportunities for investment, which in turn can lead to deterioration and neglect of the site. By encouraging the redevelopment of this property, the amendment will not only provide an opportunity to modernize the site but also help prevent blight and disrepair, thereby improving the overall quality of life for residents and the surrounding community. Redevelopment will ensure that the site is brought into compliance with modern land use standards, improving both the physical and environmental aspects of the area. These improvements will enhance public safety, aesthetics, and infrastructure, contributing to the general welfare of the neighborhood. The amendment also aligns with the City of Santa Fe’s long-term growth goals by supporting infill development and more efficient use of land. The proposed redevelopment is consistent with the city’s vision of creating sustainable, vibrant, and diverse neighborhoods that meet the needs of both current and future residents. By facilitating development that connects to city utilities and enhances the surrounding infrastructure, the amendment helps promote efficiency and economy in the development process, aligning with the city’s broader planning objectives for growth and sustainability. In summary, the proposed amendment will foster a coordinated and harmonious development that supports Santa Fe’s growth objectives, improves public health and safety, and contributes to the economic and social well-being of the community. Staff Response: Staff does not recommend approval of the applicant’s request to amend the General Plan’s Future Land Use Map from Transitional Mixed-Use to General Commercial. The Applicant has not provided sufficient evidence to counter the collective vision for the future needs of the city as articulated in the General Plan and the West Santa Fe River Corridor Plan. Criterion g (14-3.2(E)(1)(g)): consideration of conformity with other city policies, including land use policies, ordinances, regulations and plans. Criterion Met: (Yes/No) NO Applicant’s Response: Case #2024-9461 Rezoning & Case #2025-11164 General Plan Amendment Planning Commission Meeting – June 18, 2026 Page 20 of 30 The City has a policy of promoting a mix of land uses, this property is located within an area where there is a mix of residential, retail and entertainment. The recent changes to the City code now permit residential uses within a C-2 commercial district. Staff Response: Staff does not recommend approval of the applicant’s request to amend the General Plan’s Future Land Use Map from Transitional Mixed-Use to General Commercial. The request is contrary to the vision articulated in the West Santa Fe River Corridor Plan as adopted by the Governing Body and endorsed by the community. Case #2024-9461 Rezoning & Case #2025-11164 General Plan Amendment Planning Commission Meeting – June 18, 2026 Page 21 of 30 (2) In addition to complying with the general criteria set forth in Subsection 14-3.2(E)(1), amendments to the land use policies section of the general plan shall be made only if evidence shows that the effect of the proposed change in land use shown on the future land use map of the general plan will not have a negative impact on the surrounding properties . The proposed change in land use must be related to the character of the surrounding area or a provision must be made to separate the proposed change in use from adjacent properties by a setback, landscaping or other means, and a finding must be made that: Table 7: SFCC §14-3.2 (E)(2): Additional Criteria for Amendments to Land Use Policies Criterion a (14-3.2(E)(2)(a)): the growth and economic projections contained within the general plan are erroneous or have changed; Criterion Met: (Yes/No) NO Applicant’s Response: When the existing General Plan was adopted in 1999, it failed to recognize the complexity of land use of this part of the urban area. It is not a matter of the growth and economic projections being is an error as it is the failure to observe the diversity of existing land uses and assign a zoning district that best fit those land uses. Land use patterns in this area have changed over time especially with the city/county annexation recognizing infill development that can provide greater housing densities and a variety of commercial uses that are consistent with the current land use patterns. Staff Response: Staff does not recommend approval of the applicant’s request to amend the General Plan’s Future Land Use Map from Transitional Mixed-Use to General Commercial. Criterion b (14-3.2(E)(2)(b): no reasonable locations have been provided for certain land uses for which there is a demonstrated need; or Criterion Met: (Yes/No) NO Applicant’s Response: There are other locations in Santa Fe where general commercial is available, however the current zoning does not allow for the existing residential density associated with the existing mobile home park. The intent of the property owner is to redevelop the property with more options that will maintain a higher density residential component while having an option to develop both commercial and residential uses on the subject lot. Staff Response: Staff does not recommend approval of the applicant’s request to amend the General Plan’s Future Land Use Map from Transitional Mixed-Use to General Commercial as it is inconsistent with the West Santa Fe River Corridor Plan. Criterion c (14-3.2(E)(2)(c): conditions affecting the location or land area requirements of the proposed land use have changed, for example, the cost of land space requirements, consumer acceptance, market or building technology. Criterion Met: (Yes/No) NO Case #2024-9461 Rezoning & Case #2025-11164 General Plan Amendment Planning Commission Meeting – June 18, 2026 Page 22 of 30 Applicant’s Response: While the City continues to recognize the existing mobile home park as a legal non-conforming use, this grandfathered status is contingent upon no substantial improvements, expansion, or damage beyond repair. Should such circumstances arise, the property would revert to its R-1 zoning with a transitional mixed-use land use designation, which allows for only one (1) dwelling unit per acre, a density that no longer aligns with the area’s evolving development patterns. Over the past fifteen years, since the annexation of this property into the city, significant changes in land use patterns and zoning have occurred. The recent rezonings in the area, which have permitted higher-density multifamily residential and commercial uses, have notably increased the cost of land and shifted the market dynamics. These changes have rendered the existing mobile home park site less viable for long-term use under its current configuration, especially as surrounding properties have transitioned to more intensive uses. Additionally, advances in building technology and changes in consumer preferences have further driven demand for higher-density housing and more diverse land uses. The costs associated with maintaining the existing mobile home park, particularly given the high land value in this growing area, make it increasingly difficult to sustain its non- conforming use. Redeveloping the property in accordance with the proposed general plan amendment will not only accommodate the evolving market but also provide a more efficient and sustainable use of the land, aligning with the city’s current zoning and development goals. This amendment is therefore a response to the changing land use patterns, market conditions, and technological advancements that have altered the feasibility of the existing mobile home park and support the need for a more appropriate and compatible development for this location. Staff Response: Staff does not recommend approval of the applicant’s request to amend the General Plan’s Future Land Use Map from Transitional Mixed-Use to General Commercial. Case #2024-9461 Rezoning & Case #2025-11164 General Plan Amendment Planning Commission Meeting – June 18, 2026 Page 23 of 30 IV. REZONING APPROVAL CRITERIA Section 14-3.5(A) and (C) SFCC 2001 sets forth approval criteria for rezoning: (1) The Planning Commission and the Governing Body shall review all rezoning proposals on the basis of the criteria provided in this section, and the reviewing entities must make complete findings of fact sufficient to show that these criteria have been met before recommending or approving any rezoning. *Staff has found that the Applicant’s request to rezone to C-2 does NOT meet the approval criteria. The following staff findings are made in support of the rezoning to either Mixed-Use or C-1. Table 8: Rezoning Approval Criteria Criterion 1 (14-3.5(C)(1)(a)): one or more of the following conditions exist: (i) There was a mistake in the original zoning; (ii)There has been a change in the surrounding area, altering the character of the neighborhood to such an extent as to justify changing the zoning; or (iii) A different use category is more advantageous to the community, as articulated in the general plan or other adopted city plans; Criterion Met: Yes* Criterion 1(i): Applicant Response: N/A Staff Response (i.): Staff finds that there is no mistake in the original zoning created by the annexation agreement in 2013 to establish R-1 zoning or compatible zoning, and was consistent with the standard that all annexed properties be assigned the R-1 zone district. (Attachment A) Criterion 1(ii): Applicant Response: With the city/county annexation that occurred approximately fifteen years ago, the surrounding area has changed significantly where there have been at least four rezoning approvals which includes nine tracts of land all within less than 1,000 feet of the subject property(s) that have been redeveloped as mostly apartments. Prior to the city annexing the area north of Agua Fria Road there was little development activity. With the availability of utilities and provision of City services within this urban area there have been more requests for development or re-development in this urban area of the City. Staff Response (ii.): Staff acknowledges that there has been change to the surrounding area including the addition of more housing and commercial uses (particularly multi-family housing and mixed-use development). For example, from 2018 to 2024, multiple multifamily complexes were constructed in the surrounding area such as: Homewise condominiums, Siler Yard apartments, Acequia Lofts, and the Boylan apartments. Furthermore, a review of forthcoming project proposals indicates this trend will likely continue with the addition of more housing, commercial Case #2024-9461 Rezoning & Case #2025-11164 General Plan Amendment Planning Commission Meeting – June 18, 2026 Page 24 of 30 and mixed-use developments along the West Santa Fe River Corridor Plan area. However, staff does not recommend a rezoning to C-2 but rather to C-1 or Mixed-Use due to the type of uses that would be permitted under the C-2 zone district. The nearby properties referenced by the Applicant zoned C-2 at 1400 and 1411 Boylan (Ord. 2014-32) and 2751 and 2749 Agua Fria (Ord. 2015-34) achieved their zoning in 2014 and 2015 respectively, prior to the adoption of the West Santa Fe River Corridor Plan. The Plan was adotped in 2017 and lays out of clear vision for the zoning for this property, Mixed Use. The Acequia Lofts residential development to the east of the Property is zoned C1-PUD and the mixed-use development across the street with Escondido is zoned Mixed-Use. Criterion 1(iii): Applicant Response: The City General Plan identifies this property and other properties between Agua Fria and the Santa Fe River as “Transitional Mixed Use”. The predominate land use for this area is a mix of commercial and single family and rental housing. The R-1 zoning assignment is not consistent with the underlying zoning therefore it is necessary to rezone the property to maintain consistency with the overall area. Staff Response (iii.): The applicant’s response to criterion 1 (iii) does addresses how the General Plan encourages mixed-use developments while implying the existing zoning district, R-1 limits through density and uses. However, in staff’s review of the C-2 rezoning request to R-1 is inconsistent with the Transitional Mixed-Use Future Land Use Map (“FLUM”) designation as articulated in the General Plan. A C-2 rezoning request, if approved, could allow uses to be developed onsite that divert from the residential, agricultural, and neighborhood-oriented themes within the West Santa Fe River Overlay district and General Plan’s Mixed-Use Theme. For example, C-2 districts allow cannabis retail, automotive repair, and non- proprietary commercial uses that would otherwise not exist in new neighborhoods. Therefore, staff recommends a rezone from R-1 to C-1, community commercial, a zoning district that promotes high density development based on height restrictions, encourage a variety neighborhood-oriented uses such as market, childcare, and laundromat, and restricting uses that can be considered a nuisance in residential areas. Case #2024-9461 Rezoning & Case #2025-11164 General Plan Amendment Planning Commission Meeting – June 18, 2026 Page 25 of 30 Criterion 2 (14-3.5(C)(b)): all the rezoning requirements of Chapter 14 have been met; Criterion Met: YES* Applicant Response: Currently the existing zoning is R-1, Single Family Residential, one dwelling per acre, which creates a non-conforming status for this property. Rezoning of the property to C-2 uses would bring this property into conformance with the historic land use patterns and uses that have taken place on this property. Staff Response: Staff finds that the rezoning requirements of Chapter 14 have been met: specifically, §14-3.1 “Applicable General Provisions” (the authority to file; form of the application; fees paid; pre-application conference and ENN requirements, sign posting and public notice) and the provisions, procedures, and additional requirements of §14-3.5 “Rezonings.” Staff finds that the applicant has met this criterion and recommends rezoning to C-1 or MU. Criterion 3 (14-3.5(C)(1)(c)): the rezoning is consistent with the applicable policies of the general plan, including the future land use map; Criterion Met: YES* Applicant’s Response: Rezoning to C-2 (General Commercial) is consistent with the policies of the General Plan as it aims to recognize the development of infill properties where city infrastructure is Available. Furthermore, rezoning of the property is consistent with the Transitional Mixed-Use designation in that it offers the property the ability to develop with a mix of residential and commercial uses. The rezoning is also consistent with Chapter 3-1 of the Land Use Themes as provided below: • Quality of Life: The proposed General Plan Amendment has the potential to enhance the quality of life at the time the property is redeveloped from the existing non-conforming mobile home park that was established prior to the 1981 adoption of the Santa Fe County Code. • Economic Diversity: The proposed amendment facilitates the creation of both construction-related jobs and long-term employment opportunities through the development of commercial uses. This is consistent with the General Plan’s economic development objectives, which emphasize creating jobs and promoting balanced economic growth within the city. • Mixed Use: Santa Fe is currently experiencing a steady growth rate of 0.54% annually, with the population having increased by 2.19%. The proposed general plan amendment from Low Density Residential to Community Commercial zoning will allow for a mix of commercial and or high-density residential uses which is consistent with the mix of uses established in this area after the City/County annexation occurred in 2009. The proposed Case #2024-9461 Rezoning & Case #2025-11164 General Plan Amendment Planning Commission Meeting – June 18, 2026 Page 26 of 30 General Plan Amendment allows flexibility to re-develop the property consistent with the area by providing the ability to establish a range of permitted uses without the rigid residential-to-commercial ratio specified in the transitional mixed-use future land use designation flexibility supports the City's economic development goals. • Transportation and Mobility: The proposed development also aligns with the General Plan’s transportation goals by enhancing connectivity and providing alternative transportation options. The property’s adjacency to the Santa Fe River Greenway Trail, which accommodates both pedestrians and cyclists, supports the General Plan’s vision for expanding and improving the city’s pedestrian and bike infrastructure. The Greenway Trail connects key parts of the city, contributing to the city’s transportation and mobility policies. • Infrastructure and Public Services: The proposed amendment is consistent with the General Plan’s goals related to infrastructure and public services. Although the existing mobile home park is currently served by a domestic well, redevelopment of the property will require connection to city water, ensuring that the development aligns with the city’s water infrastructure policies. Staff Response: The applicant’s findings in criterion 3 encourage a rezoning from R-1 to C-2 that is inconsistent with the Mixed Use/ Transitional Land Use Classification 3.5 established by amendment via Resolution 2001-82 (Attachment A): “Mixed-Use/Transitional This designation is Intended to allow for a mixing of compatible land uses within two development scenarios. The first scenario, or “Mixed-Use” land use designation, allows for mixing of uses within the same development site which would include, in all cases, residential and limited non-residential uses where there is strong emphasis on site design that is sensitive to compatibility of building scales and massing, land use intensities and pedestrian orientation. The mixed-use scenario may include such uses as residential, including single-family, and multi-family residential where the scale and intensity are deemed appropriate and compatible with the other proposed uses, office, civic and religious uses, live/work units, educational uses and appropriately-scaled retail/services that are intended to primarily serve the residential uses as an added local amenity. Light industrial uses may also be considered in a love-work development scenario provided there is adequate buffering and protection to surrounding residential. The mixed-use development should be designed in a planned, landscaped setting and the land uses should be selected and arranged to create a vibrant, yet comfortable, interactive place. Both restrictive and permissive language may be used in a zoning ordinance to create a viable mix of uses so that the most profitable use does not dominate. The second scenario, or the “Transitional” land use designation also promoted mixing of compatible land uses but is intended to occur within several abutting tracts of land where commercial and residential uses are adjoining. The intent of the designation is to create a unified land use pattern between varying land use intensities. This would be accomplished through the introduction of uses of intermediate scale and intensity that would allow for a transition from the commercial to residential through reduction, or “step-back”, in land use intensity, building scale and massing, additional buffering and a re-orientation of the uses and structures to promote interaction and connectivity through pedestrian orientation and “walkability.” The applicant's application submittal (Attachment C) does not include a formal Master Plan or Development Plan request to allow staff and the City’s Departmental Review Team (“DRT”) the opportunity to apply the Land Development Code and provide recommendations for conditions or technical corrections to the Planning Commission. Therefore, staff recommends rezoning the Property from R-1 to C-1 or MU to be consistent with the Future Land Use Case #2024-9461 Rezoning & Case #2025-11164 General Plan Amendment Planning Commission Meeting – June 18, 2026 Page 27 of 30 Map land use classification of Transitional Mixed-use and the West Santa Fe River Corridor Plan. Criterion 4 (14-3.5(C)(d)): the amount of land proposed for rezoning and the proposed use for the land is consistent with city policies regarding the provision of urban land sufficient to meet the amount, rate and geographic location of the growth of the city; Criterion Met: YES* Applicant Response: There are four (4) adjoining legal lots of record with a combined total of 5.96 acres which will be consolidated upon approval of the rezoning request. The proposed C-2 use for the land is consistent with city policies as it continues to recognize development of infill property and is consistent with the current land use patterns that have developed for a mix of uses from commercial to medium to high density residential. Staff Response: The 5.96-acre Property, made up of 4 contiguous parcels in which three of the four have existing/ occupied dwellings onsite. Combined, all of the parcels provide the amount of land that can be consistent with urban land uses and growth consistent with the General Plan. However, One out of the four parcels meet the 2-acre minimum requirement to be rezoned by itself. Therefore, it is critical that future development of the Property be of the 5.96 are Property and not individual parcels. The applicant’s submittal does not include a formal Master Plan or Development Plan request to provide a condition of approval to require a consolidation of parcels at the time of development. A rezoning request to C-2 would be inconsistent with the Future Land Use Map, West Santa Fe River Corridor Plan, and potentially allow dimensional standards that are inconsistent with the surrounding area. Whereas staff recommendation to C-1 which has a density of 21 dwelling units per acre or Mixed Use which limit density by massing and architectural design that not only meet the growth demands in the area but be characteristically consistent with transitional intent of the General Plan. General Plan Figure 4-4, Urban Sub-Areas, designates the subject site and surrounding area as an “Infill Area.” The Growth Management Chapter of the General Plan , such as Section 4.1, specifically calls for prioritization of infill development in Santa Fe to maximize the efficient use of public infrastructure, while meeting the demand for urban land or development and directing new growth towards the historic core of the city rather than on the undeveloped fringes. The proposed rezoning is aligned with these strategic directives and is responsive to community needs for housing in this area of the City. Criterion 5 (14-3.5(C)(1)(e)): the existing and proposed infrastructure, such as the streets system, sewer and water lines, and public facilities, such as fire stations and parks, will be able to accommodate the impacts of the proposed development. Criterion Met: YES* Case #2024-9461 Rezoning & Case #2025-11164 General Plan Amendment Planning Commission Meeting – June 18, 2026 Page 28 of 30 Applicant Response: Public utilities are available on Agua Fria, including water, gas and electric lines, cable, and telephone lines. The City has completed street improvements and widening of Agua Fria adjacent to the subject property including upgrades to the Agua Fria and Siler Road intersection. Siler Road has been completed from Agua Fria to West Alameda providing alternative routes to Agua Fria. In fact, the traffic volumes on Agua Fria have declined with the extension of Siler to West Alameda. Santa Fe River Greenway pedestrian and bicycle trail has recently been completed and is located north of the subject parcels. The closest Fire Station to this site is located on Cerrillos Road near Third Street within a five- minute service radius to this property. Staff Response: Staff from the relevant City departments, including water, wastewater and traffic engineering have reviewed the rezoning request and have determined that infrastructure is generally sufficient for the types of uses allowed in C-1 and MU zoning and that more specific needs can be determined at the time of Development Plan submittal. Criterion 6 (14-3.5(C)(2)): Unless the proposed change is consistent with applicable general plan policies, the planning commission and the governing body shall not recommend or approve any rezoning, the practical effect of which is to: (a) allow uses or a change in character significantly different from or inconsistent with the prevailing use and character in the area; (b) affect an area of less than two acres, unless adjusting boundaries between districts; or (c) benefit one or a few landowners at the expense of the surrounding landowners or general public. Criterion Met: N/A Applicant’s Response: N/A Staff Response: As the findings state that the proposed C-2 rezoning is not consistent with the General Plan. However, staff’s recommendation to rezone to C-1 is consistent with the General Plan therefore, this criterion is not applicable in this case. Case #2024-9461 Rezoning & Case #2025-11164 General Plan Amendment Planning Commission Meeting – June 18, 2026 Page 29 of 30 V. CONCLUSION: The Land Use Department, together with the development review team, have analyzed the project. The Applicant’s findings and request for a General Plan Future Land Use Map from Transitional Mixed-Use to General Commercial and Rezone from R-1 to C-2 are inconsistent with the guiding policies, land classifications, and Future Land Use Map of the General Plan and the vision for this Property as articulated in the West Santa Fe River Corridor Plan. The zoning districts that promote the highest and best use while being consistent with the General Plan is C-1 (office and related commercial) or Mixed-Use. Case #2024-9461 Rezoning & Case #2025-11164 General Plan Amendment Planning Commission Meeting – June 18, 2026 Page 30 of 30 VI. ATTACHMENTS ATTACHMENT A: 1. 12-20-24 Initial Staff Report Memo 2. Development Review Team compiled comments 3. Annexation Map Phase 2 Area 1 4. Ordinance 2013-36 5. Mixed Use & Transitional Definition Res. 2001-82 6.) West Santa Fe River Corridor Plan 12-14-17 ATTACHMENT B: Maps and Photos 1. Future Land Use Map 2. Existing Zoning Map 3. Street View 4. Utility Map 5. Vicinity Map 6. West Santa Fe River Corridor ATTACHMENT C: Applicant Materials 1. General Plan Amendment Application 2. Rezoning Application 3. Request Letter 4. GPA & Rezoning Development Report (11_12_2024) 5. Applicant Response to Initial DRT Letter 6. GPA & Rezoning Development Report REVISED (7_31_25) 7. GPA & Rezoning Development Report REVISED (8_8_25) VII. APPROVED AS TO FORM BY THE PLANNING AND LAND USE DEPARTMENT: Title Name Initials Department Director Heather Lamboy, AICP HLL Assistant Department Director Maggie Moore MRM Planning Division Manager Dan Esquibel Planner Senior Joel Cruz-Haber JCH ATTACHMENT A: Documents from Staff 1 City of Santa Fe, New Mexico 200 Lincoln Avenue, P.O. Box 909, Santa Fe, N.M. 87504-0909 www.santafenm.gov Alan Webber, Mayor Councilors: Signe I. Lindell, Mayor Pro Tem, District 1 Alma G. Castro, District 1 Michael J. Garcia, District 2 Carol Romero-Wirth, District 2 Lee Garcia, District 3 Pilar F.H. Faulkner, District 3 Jamie Cassutt, District 4 Amanda Chavez, District 4 December 20, 2024 NM Land Solutions Victoria Dalton 915 Mercer Street Santa Fe NM 87501 Re: Case# 2024-9460 and 2024-9461: 214 Boylan General Plan Amendment and Rezoning at 1372 Boylan Lane, and 2743 and 2745 Boylan Circle Dear Ms. Dalton, Your application was received on November 13, 2024. It has been reviewed by the Planning Division (Staff) and the City’s Development Review Team (DRT). The request is for a General Plan Amendment from Transitional Mixed Use (TMXU) to Community Commercial (CCOM) and Rezoning of four parcels from R-1 (1/dwelling/acre) to C-2 (General Commercial). Attached are the initial Land Use staff and DRT review comments, including any necessary technical corrections. I would like to highlight and summarize the following items of note: A. Initial Review Summary Your Rezoning application has been reviewed by Land Use staff and the following necessary revisions have been identified: 1. Contact the City Wastewater Division to confirm in writing the status of system capacity and the ability of the existing infrastructure to accommodate the additional impacts of the proposed C-2 zoning at the subject property. Have you verified with Parks, Police/Fire/EMT, Santa Fe Public Schools, and Public Works (i.e., streets) that each of the systems and services currently have ample capacity to absorb the impacts of the uses allowed within a C-2 zone district? The existence or availability of infrastructure and services in the vicinity is not sufficient assurance of adequate system capacity for new impacts that would result from the proposal. Explain how each system or service can or cannot accommodate the anticipated increment of added impacts. If the impacts of the proposed rezoning cannot be accommodated by the existing infrastructure and public facilities, the City may require the developer to participate wholly or in part in the cost of construction of off-site facilities in conformance with any applicable city ordinances, regulations or policies (see § 14-3.5(D)). 2 2. Describe the water rights associated with the well that would be transferred to the City upon redevelopment. 3. Based on the required criteria: wherever applicable, cite the specific themes and policies of the General Plan (by name and/or number) that will be advanced or complied with by the amendment and rezoning proposal. 4. Concept plans are not actionable items on the agenda. Future conceptual development (such as the undergrounding of utilities, removal of mobile homes and soil stockpiles, or the potential provision of affordable housing) cannot be considered by the Land Use staff or the decision makers in analyzing the rezoning request unless they are included in the current application as a development plan or master plan. The analysis for the rezoning is strictly limited to the proposal to change from one zone district to another. Discussion of future development plans that are not part of the current request cannot be used to respond to the Code criteria. Please only include the elements that are part of the current request. Please revise or submit the report and/or include a master plan to accompany the rezoning application. 5. In Appendix D (“Warranty Deeds”), Tract D and Tract A-1 have cover sheets that state the following documents are warranty deeds; however, the deeds that follow are both quitclaim deeds. Do warranty deeds exist for these parcels? Please revise the Appendix D cover sheet as well as the Tract D and Tract A-1 cover sheets to reflect the correct type of conveyance documents attached thereto. Quit Claim deeds can only be accepted in conjunction with a chain of title to prove equitable interest that existed within the transfer. 6. Please note that rezoning requests require public notice by Certified Mail to property owners within 100 feet of the subject property. Refer to § 14-3.1(H) for details on rezoning request public notice requirements. B. Initial DRT Review Summary Your Rezoning application has been reviewed by the City’s Development Review Team (DRT) and the following necessary revisions have been identified: 1. Dee Beingessner [Land Use/Terrain Management/City Engineer] – One issue identified: Soil Stockpile without a permit and appropriate sediment control is a violation of City Code and must be remedied before new plat or development can be approved; see attached DRT response letter. 2. Leah Yngve [MPO] – No issues were identified with the General Plan amendment and Rezoning request; see attached DRT response letter. 3. Leroy Pacheco [Traffic] - No issues were identified with the General Plan amendment and Rezoning request; see attached DRT response letter. When the subject property is redeveloped, a traffic study will be required. 4. Zoe Isaacson [Parks] - No issues were identified with the General Plan amendment and Rezoning request; see attached DRT response letter. 5. Clinton Peterson [Water Engineering] – No issues were identified with the Rezoning request; see attached DRT response letter. Additional plan information, such as an approved Water Plan and an Agreement to Construct and Dedicate (ACD), will be required at the time of Development Plan application for any new water and fire infrastructure. This DRT reviewer also notes that each lot shall be served by separate City water service at the time of development. Regarding the existing domestic well onsite, this reviewer required that the Applicant work with CoSFW Engineering before Water Plan approval to ensure that no cross-connection occurs between the domestic well system and the public water system. 3 Once all DRT comments have been addressed, a Planning Commission hearing date can be scheduled. Please let me know if you have any questions or concerns. Thank you, Janice Biletnikoff Janice Biletnikoff, AICP Long-Range Strategic Planner, Planning and Land Use Department R5 C1PUD R1 C2PUD AG U A FRIA ST AGUA FRIA ST JARDIN LN QUA I L VIEW LN R I V ERA LN MONTOYA PL BOY L AN CIR FERG U S O N LN CAMI N O CARLOS RAEL BORREGO PASS BOYLAN LN MAEZ RD AGUA FRIA ST SILER RD CALLE CARMELITA AGUA FRIA ST MAEZ CT LA CIENEGUITA CAMINO CARLOS RAEL COOKS LN PAS AD A DEL B E N SAN ISIDRO CT CALLE LINDA CALLE CONTESSA JO R DAN LOGAN RD BU R RO L N CO Y O TILLO CT GALLEGOS L N R A MO N LN FAMILY LN HARRISON RD MACLOVIA ST SILER PARK LN CALLE ANGELINA Acres Population Housing Units 233.25 254 106 AREA 1 (S West Alameda) Annexation Phase 2 Legend Roads to be Transferred from County to City for Maintenance City Limits Agua Fria THC Zoning City Waste Water Collection Pipe City Water Distribution Pipe *Census 2010 Exhibit B From: victoria jwsiebert.com To: LINDQUIST, NATHAN J. Cc: ESQUIBEL, DANIEL A. Subject: RE: Boylan Date: Friday, October 10, 2025 2:47:55 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Good afternoon Nathan, Please allow this email to serve as postponed indefinitely. This will give us a chance to draw up a plan per the meeting we this morning and resubmit to request a C-2 PUD zoning designation. Additionally, Mr. Boylan is in agreement with the preparation of a plan and C-2 uses that should be restricted. Thank you, Victoria Dalton NM Land Solutions LLC 915 Mercer Street Santa Fe, New Mexico 87505 (505) 983-5588 From: LINDQUIST, NATHAN J. Sent: Friday, October 10, 2025 2:43 PM To: victoria jwsiebert.com Subject: Boylan Hi Victoria did you get to a final decision on what you would like to do with Boylan? Nathan Lindquist Senior Land Use Planner City of Santa Fe 200 Lincoln Avenue E: njlindquist@santafenm.gov We’re excited to announce Santa Fe Forward, a visionary plan to prepare our city for a vibrant future through 2050! Stay in the know! Subscribe to PLUS, our free quarterly email newsletter with the latest on how we're working with you to build a more modern, vibrant, and inclusive Santa Fe. Form Updated: September 2023 Development Review Team (DRT) Comment Form Date: 12/9/2024 DRT Member: Dee Beingessner Dept/Div: Land Use/Engineering Case No.: Case #2024-9460 and 2024-9461: Boylan General Plan Amendment and Rezoning. Case Planner: Janice Biletnikoff Conditions of Approval and Technical Corrections Tables Review by this division/department has determined that this application will meet applicable standards if the following Conditions of Approval and Technical Corrections are met: Conditions of Approval: Must be completed by: Applicant response: 1. Soil Stockpile without a permit and appropriate sediment control is a violation of City Code and must be remedied before new plat or development can be approved Prior to Final Plat 2. Technical Corrections: Must be completed by: Applicant Response: 1. 2. 3. 4. Explanation of Conditions or Corrections (if needed): Form Updated: March 2024 Development Review Team (DRT) Comment Form Date: 11/26/24 DRT Member: Clinton Peterson Dept/Div: Public Utilities/Water Division Case No.: Cases #2024-9460 and #2024-9461– Boylan Genal Plan Amendment and Rezoning Case Planner: Janice Biletnikoff DRT Review Schedule – 9-12+ weeks* Initial DRT Comments are due to the case planner within three weeks of the DRT Application Intake meeting. Initial DRT review should confirm that the application is complete (i.e. Water Budget has been submitted) and/or identify additional submittals or corrections (i.e. Water Budget needs revision). The case planner will review and convey all Initial DRT Comments to the applicant via a Review Memo. The applicant must respond to all Initial DRT Comments and submit a revised application for Final Review. Final DRT Comments are due to the case planner within two weeks of receipt of the revised application. The case planner will review and convey all Final DRT Comments to the applicant in a Final Review Memo. The complete DRT Review Timeline can range from 9-12+ weeks, depending on the complexity and quality of the application and the total number of applications under review. Timing of Conditions of Approval + Technical Corrections While all DRT conditions of approval and technical corrections must be met by the applicant, the timing of compliance varies. In the “Must be completed by” column in the following tables, please time your conditions of approval and technical corrections to the following development review stages: a. Prior to Public Hearing – these conditions/technical corrections must be addressed before the case may move forward to the public hearing phase of the Development Review Process. b. Prior to Recordation – these conditions/technical corrections may be resolved after the public hearing but must be addressed before the Development Plan or Subdivision plat is recorded. c. Prior Building Permit Approval – these conditions/technical corrections can be addressed during the building permit review process, but prior to issuance of the permit. d. At the time of Construction – these conditions/technical corrections can be addressed during the construction and inspection processes. Initial DRT Comments Review Memo Revised Application Final DRT Comments Final Review Memo Form Updated: March 2024 Development Review Process Flow Chart *See the 2024 Development Review Schedule for details Conditions of Approval and Technical Corrections Tables Review by this division/department has determined that this application will meet applicable standards if the following Conditions of Approval and Technical Corrections are met: Conditions of Approval: Must be completed by: Applicant Response**: 1. An approved Water Plan will be required for all new public water infrastructure and fire services. Prior to approval of Development Plan 2. An approved Agreement to Construct and Dedicate (ACD) will be required for new public water infrastructure and fire services Prior to building permit approval 3. Each lot shall be served by separate City water service at the time of development. At the time of development 4. 5. 6. Technical Corrections: Must be completed by: Applicant Response**: 1. There is an existing domestic well noted at the mobile home park. Applicant must work with CoSFW Engineering to ensure no cross- connection occurs between the domestic well system and the public water system. Prior to Water Plan approval 2. 3. 4. **The Applicant must respond to the condition of approval or technical correction, indicating they have met the requirement and providing a reference in their revised submittals. If the applicant has not met the requirement, they must indicate as much and provide a response. The applicant should be aware that the following code provisions or other requirements will apply to future phases of development of this project: 1. [list any additional items] 2. Explanation of Conditions or Corrections (if needed): (see following pages for notes required) Form Updated: March 2024 Development Review Team (DRT) Comment Form Date: 11/25/2024 DRT Member: Zoe Isaacson/Melissa McDonald Dept/Div: Public Works/Parks and Open Space Case No.: Cases #2024-9460 and 2024-9461: Boylan General Plan Amendment and Rezoning Case Planner: Janice Biletnikoff, AICP DRT Review Schedule – 9-12+ weeks* Initial DRT Comments are due to the case planner within three weeks of the DRT Application Intake meeting. Initial DRT review should confirm that the application is complete (i.e. Water Budget has been submitted) and/or identify additional submittals or corrections (i.e. Water Budget needs revision). The case planner will review and convey all Initial DRT Comments to the applicant via a Review Memo. The applicant must respond to all Initial DRT Comments and submit a revised application for Final Review. Final DRT Comments are due to the case planner within two weeks of receipt of the revised application. The case planner will review and convey all Final DRT Comments to the applicant in a Final Review Memo. The complete DRT Review Timeline can range from 9-12+ weeks, depending on the complexity and quality of the application and the total number of applications under review. Timing of Conditions of Approval + Technical Corrections While all DRT conditions of approval and technical corrections must be met by the applicant, the timing of compliance varies. In the “Must be completed by” column in the following tables, please time your conditions of approval and technical corrections to the following development review stages: a. Prior to Public Hearing – these conditions/technical corrections must be addressed before the case may move forward to the public hearing phase of the Development Review Process. b. Prior to Recordation – these conditions/technical corrections may be resolved after the public hearing but must be addressed before the Development Plan or Subdivision plat is recorded. c. Prior Building Permit Approval – these conditions/technical corrections can be addressed during the building permit review process, but prior to issuance of the permit. d. At the time of Construction – these conditions/technical corrections can be addressed during the construction and inspection processes. Initial DRT Comments Review Memo Revised Application Final DRT Comments Final Review Memo Form Updated: March 2024 Development Review Process Flow Chart *See the 2024 Development Review Schedule for details Conditions of Approval and Technical Corrections Tables Review by this division/department has determined that this application will meet applicable standards if the following Conditions of Approval and Technical Corrections are met: Conditions of Approval: Must be completed by: Applicant Response**: 1. N/A: Parks and Open Space has reviewed the proposed rezoning and has no comments. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Technical Corrections: Must be completed by: Applicant Response**: 1. N/A: Parks and Open Space has reviewed the proposed rezoning and has no comments. 2. 3. 4. **The Applicant must respond to the condition of approval or technical correction, indicating they have met the requirement and providing a reference in their revised submittals. If the applicant has not met the requirement, they must indicate as much and provide a response. The applicant should be aware that the following code provisions or other requirements will apply to future phases of development of this project: 1. [list any additional items] 2. Explanation of Conditions or Corrections (if needed): (see following pages for notes required) From: YNGVE, LEAH X. To: BILETNIKOFF, JANICE I. Subject: Re: Cases #2024-9460 and 2024-9461: Boylan General Plan Amendment and Rezoning Date: Monday, December 9, 2024 2:28:59 PM Hi Janice, No comments from the MPO at this stage. I apologize for being late, I was confused that 12/5 was called the deadline for additional materials! We used to have one of those in the past, but it seems like the process has been changed. Thanks! Leah From: Leroy Nicholas Pacheco, PE To: BILETNIKOFF, JANICE I. Cc: Gallegos, Phil; Luna, Robert; MORROW, JENNIFER L. Subject: Case #2024-9460 Boylan General Plan Amendment and Rezoning Date: Thursday, November 14, 2024 5:10:30 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. Hi Janet - I am not sure if the developer submitted any traffic engineering related materials for review in what was sent forward to you. If he did, please send them over or send me a link to download. For a zoning change and master plan amendment with unknown development as was described at DRT today, there will not be comments submitted that are related to traffic engineering. If the zone change and master plan amendment are approved by the City, a traffic study for any specific proposed future development plan of the site will be required. Thanks, Leroy Nicholas Pacheco, PE Email: engineer@leroypacheco.com Phone Number: 505-218-6853 Cell Phone: 505-423-4068 Sent with Proton Mail secure email. 1 LINDQUIST, NATHAN J. From: VALORA SANDOVAL, SERGIO A. Sent: Tuesday, August 5, 2025 4:10 PM To: LINDQUIST, NATHAN J. Subject: RE: Boylan rezoning - wastewater review Hello Nathan, It was a pleasure meeting you. Regarding the rezoning application for Boylan Circle, the wastewater section has been properly addressed. It is confirmed that the existing 8-inch PVC sewer line is privately owned, and a new public sewer line will need to be proposed at the time of redevelopment. Our division has no objections to the rezoning as submitted. Best regards, Sergio Sergio Sandoval, PE Engineer Associate Wastewater Management Division Public Utilities Department City of Santa Fe Phone: (505) 955-4630 Mobile: (619) 753-1408 email: savalorasandoval@santafenm.gov 73 Paseo Real Santa Fe, NM 87507 From: LINDQUIST, NATHAN J. Sent: Tuesday, August 5, 2025 1:19 PM To: VALORA SANDOVAL, SERGIO A. Subject: Boylan rezoning - wastewater review Hi Sergio, I’m a new planner at the city and Joel gave me your name to contact for development review comments. Attached is the Boylan rezoning app. There is no development plan with it, only a rezoning. Do you have a free minute to chat? Thanks! Nathan Lindquist Senior Land Use Planner City of Santa Fe 200 Lincoln Avenue E: njlindquist@santafenm.gov 2 We’re excited to announce Santa Fe Forward, a visionary plan to prepare our city for a vibrant future through 2050! Stay in the know! Subscribe to PLUS, our free quarterly email newsletter with the latest on how we're working with you to build a more modern, vibrant, and inclusive Santa Fe. 1 CITY OF SANTA FE, NEW MEXICO 2 ORDINANCE NO. 2013-36 3 4 5 AN ORDINANCE 6 ANNEXING APPROXIMATELY 4,100 ACRES (PHASE 2) IN ACCORDANCE WITH 7 THE "ANNEXATION PHASING AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY OF SANTA FE 8 AND SANTA FE COUNTY" EXECUTED IN FEBRUARY 2009 AND AMENDED IN 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 JUNE 2013; PHASE 2 ANNEXATION INCLUDES AREAS 1, 2, 4, 5, 7, 12 AND THE NEW MEXICO HIGHWAY 599 RIGHT-OF-WAY BETWEEN INTERSTATE 25 AND THE CURRENT CITY CORPORATE BOUNDARY EAST OF THE CAMINO LA TIERRA INTERCHANGE. BE IT ORDAINED BY THE GOVERNING BODY OF THE CITY OF SANTA FE: Section 1. Pursuant to Section 3-7-17.1 NMSA 1978 (2003), the areas of land 16 described as Phase 2 of the city-initiated annexation and shown on the accompanying annexation 17 phasing maps, Exhibit A through H, attached hereto (the "property") are annexed to the city of 18 Santa Fe, thereby extending the corporate limits of the city. Exhibit A shows the contiguous 19 relationship of the annexed lands to the city's corporate limits. 20 Section 2. A petition (the "petition") prepared and submitted by the city, has been 21 presented to the duly established Extraterritorial Land Use Commission for recommendation and 22 the Extraterritorial Land Use Authority for approval. The Extraterritorial Land Use Authority did 23 review and grant approval of the Phase 2 Annexation petition on September 26, 2013, attached 24 hereto as Exhibit 1. 25 Section 3. It is in the best interest of the city and county that the areas specified in 1 1 the Phase 2 annexation be annexed into the city of Santa Fe. The city is ready, willing and able to 2 serve the areas included in the Phase 2 annexation, in accordance with the various city-county 3 service agreements, previously approved by the city and county. 4 Section 4. This ordinance shall be published one time by title and general summary 5 and shall become effective January 1, 2014. 6 PASSED, APPROVED and ADOPTED this 131h day ofNovember, 2013. 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 DAVID COSS, MAYOR ' APPROVED AS 1''0' F~RM: . BRENNAN, INTERIM CITY ATTORNEY M/Melissa/Ordinances 201312013-36 Annexation-Phase 2_Sub 2 COUNTY OF SANTA FE STATE OF NE~J MEXICO ss ORDINANCE PAGES: 12 I Hereby Certify That This Instrument Was Filed for Record On The 27TH Day Of November, 2013 at 03:09:55 PM ~nd Was Duly Recorded as Instrument ~ 1724309 Of The Records Of Santa Fe County Witness My Hand And Seal Of Office ~ ~ Geraldine Salazar Deput~~--~-:!~1-~----- County Clerk, Santa Fe, NM ITEM# 13-0s'i5 City Of Santa Fe Petition for Auexation 2013-1 CITY OF SANTA FE PETITION FOR ANNEXATION OF PHASE 2 INCLUDING AREAS 1, 2, 4, 5, 7, 12 and the Highway NM 599 Right-Of-Way from Interstate 25 to the City Corporate Limits east of Camino La Tierra as shown on the PHASE 2 ANNEXATION MAP. Petitioner states that: In accordance with§§ 3-7-1 through 3-7-18 NMSA, the CITY OF SANTA FE hereby petitions the City of Santa Fe Governing Body for annexation of the land descn"bed below into the city limits of the CITY OF SANTA FE. The areas to be annexed and identified below are consistent with"AMENDMENT NO. 1 TO THB ANNEXATION PHASING AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY OF. SANTA FE AND SANTA FE COUNfY (Exhibit I; June 10, 2013). Pursuant to§ 3-7-17.1 NMSA, the following infonnation is provided by the petitioner: A. The land to be aaaexed is generally deseribed as: Land generally surrounded by. or adjoining, the current City corporate limits and including the following description of the individual amiS to be annexed: Phase 2, Entire Annexation (Exhibit A); Area 1 covers lands generally bounded by West Alameda (north), current city limits (east), Agua Fria Street (south) and the Agua Fria Traditional Historic Community bounchuy (west) (Emihit B); · Area 2 covers lands generally bounded by Highway NM 599 (northwest), the Agua Fria Traditional Historic Community boundary (east). the Santa Fe River (south and west) (Emibit C); Area 4 covers lands generally bounded by the Santa Fe River (north), Agua Fria Traditional Historic Community boundary and current City corporate limits (east). Airport Road/current City corporate limits (south) and Highway NM 599 (west) (Ewbit D); Area 5 co'vers lands generally bounded by Airport Road/current City corporate limits (north), current City corporate limits (east and south) and Highway NM 599 (west) {EUibit E); Area 7 covers lands generally bounded by the current City corporate limits (north), Cerrillos Road and Interstate-25 (east and southeast), and Highway NM 599 (southwest and west) (Exhibit F); Area 12 covers lands generally bounded by Rodeo Road/current City corporate limits (north), Richards Avenue/current City corporate limits (east), current City corporate limits (south) and euttent City corpcmite limits (west) (Exhibit G); Highway NM 599 (Veterans Memorial Highway) Right-Of-Way between Interstate 25 to the southwest and the current City corporate limits to east of Camino La Tierra to the northeast (Emibit B). B. The total land area included in this annexation contains 4,100.63 acres of land, more or less. C. The CITY OF SANTA FE provides current municipal services to this area as follows: 1) Water and/or Wastewater provided by the city to some of the areas included in the annexation; (Solid Waste service is scheduled to begin August, 2013), 2) Police service through a mutual aid agreement with Santa Fe County; 3) Fire/EMS service through a shared service agreement with Santa Fe County; 4) Land Use Administration. 1 Exhibit j_ ::Q I:Tl i:) 1:) :~ ~~ D. In addition, the CI1Y OF SANTA FE is prepared, willing and able to provide the following services upon annexation: l) Roadway maintenance service will be provided according to the "ROADWAY IMPROVEMENTS MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING BETWEEN THE COUNTY OF SANTA FE AND THE CITY OF SANTA FE" (June 10, 2013). 2) Water, Wastewater and Solid Waste services will be provided according to the "AGREEMENT REGARDING WATER, WASTEWATER AND SOLID WASTE REQUIRED BY TilE SEITLEMENT AGREEMENT AND MUlUAL RELEASE OF CLAIMS" (June 10, 2013). 3) Law Enforcement service will be provided according to the "COUN1Y OF SANTA FE AND THE CITY OF SANTA FE MUTUAL AID AGREEMENT FOR LAW ENFORCEMENT SERVICES" (June 10, 2013). 4) Fire and EMS service will be provided according to the "COUNTY OF SANfA FE AND Tim CITY OF SANTA FE MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING FOR FIRE PROTECTION AND EMS SERVICE" (June 10, 2013}. . F. The ~ity of Santa Fe and Santa Fe County "SE11LEMENT AGREEMENT AND MUTIJAL RELEASE OF CLAIMS" (February 10, 2009). G. The Governing Body of the CITY OF SANTA FE, requested annexation of those unincorporated portions of the Urban Area. (Resolution 2006-29; February 8, 2006) WHERFORE, the CITY OF SANTA FE hereby Petitions the City of Santa Fe Governing Body in accordance with§§ 3-7-17.1 NMSA for the annexation of the land as described above. ATTEST: 2 '\. ... 4 - I 3 2013 DATE CITY OF SANTA FE ]2--2.~DAVID COSS, MAYOR CITY OF SANTA FE 6) l. PHASE 2 ANNEXATION ANNEXATION AREAS DATA SUMMARY Acres AREA 1 (S West Alameda) 233.25 AREA 2 (SF River to NM 5991 507.56 AREA 4 (Ai_I])Oft_ Rd to SF River)_ n2.s1 AREA 5 (Airport Rd. to Trerra Contenta) 592.34 AREA 7 (South of Tierra Contenta) 1,320.74 AREA 12(Rodeo Roadffown & Coul'ltry Sub.}_ 123.77 NM599ROW 550.00 L. ________TOIAL~ 4,100.~3- Estimates based on Census 2010 Block Level data. Population 254 1,664 6,670 3,484 1,023 156 L__ 13,_2~ The Agua Fria Traditional Historic Community (THC} is not part of The L.J CityUmits CJ Areas To Be Annexed This Annexation Map is based upon Santa Fe County Clerk and Assessor Records and that the boundaries are based upon established road right-of-ways and parcels ~ Santa Fe County Clerk and Assessor Records. ~· -qMattheW eiUy, Land Use Director Exhibit A Housing Units 106 472 2,154 1,310 340 63' - 4,~ Annexation. N W~E s 0 0.5 1 Mile ~Dale: WlldMsd:lr. Apf128, 2010 11:39AM AS00'1lQS Cly of Sarita Fe 200 Utcdn ,....1P.O. lbr 90iiJ sna~.NM87~ Phone(505)95$6f90Emel.~p Prepllt8d By:ASMfT,GS LPP .,.,.__ NAD 1li835:talaPIIwtBNew llaldcoCenntRPS30112Feel 081Um:NGri!Amerieat1t83 ~ TN1 inbnM11Dn i11Dfrefann:l8 ady._ lheCiyol'&nl. Fe. ......_no~lremniiMOCIII8d-'-'.,.11Md ttiSdiRU.. .. tiCIIItf,.....,..foralrlln'*lg dllaa::ctn~~:¥"'-'~·~pwpo-.uniJ i i £ iti£/~Z/i i ('.Ej(UjO~i::iG Jll'lrl· J.J ;JifS ... r nnexation Phase 2 AREA 2 (SF River to NM 599) Acres Population Housing Units 507.56 1,664 472 ............................ Legend £::!City Limits lSSJ Area4 !:::: :[ Santa Fe County *Census 201 o I~~~~1~~#P/' ·························································································································................................................................................................................................................................................................... ~ til~~::s:. ~ \ COTIO r 0 VILLAI "dl ~ ::s:. / ~ -~ ~'-~s ( -~~BACA-RANCH-I:W _.-"'---- .-~~·< . ".J!f/: /: . /:?/ ~----- -- ••••••••••• ~j1#599'~ ':/'% ~"'/./-:. . 0~~ ~~:::::::::::::: ~:: ~:: ~::::::::::::: :::: :y;t::::;>. ......... ~~4-·a···························· -~,.,~0-· ::::::l!!l::::::::::IT4!W1~W:::::::::::~MJ~~ ·.................................... r:lll)" ifll? // i n /~JL~t~rt~~~. I .................. /// /<'/ !' ~b~ ::s:::J ~ // o:-_. z (!) ...J 0 ~ ·-~ --~-~_; ' ~ - .- ~ ~ 0:: ~a.l w :X: r···································;·"···Ph·a·59··2··············1·· t Rd to SF River) I~ ' .res Population Housing Units IAc 77~ Housing Units 2,154:.97 6,670 2,154 ~z:/ .,1 *Censu 1 J----··········---------······· ----------·-············--- --------······ Legend a••·~ .11.....; C1ty Limits ~AreaS [SSI Area2 1:::::: :I Santa Fe County I _-. Voter Precincts Parcel Lines NM599 Right-of-way :fll' :::::/ :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: ':j - ' //)~;\ ·································· ~ ~ /.~,- ~ -'C /.: ~,_~<~~;:::~;. '\,~~-·c .·,.·./',• ''~"----_/.." -·'·~-, _,... ,, ' / _::_=t=FA.~~vyA't';;: ~2 ~ · ,.,. .. VILI2AGE >,· ~·~«FO~•e'.. ,·¥··:~~~~/~}~{{~~~~ Precin~t.ao~.:~~-~ Rr•~'l~! z._ oo~~ ::~~ -;-/ /.,<'~- ~L:;- ~~·~~ 64 COUNTRY CLUB.~ GARDENS MHJ:!>'.c ·~~~:~;:t------ ELKHORN ::::=.- ' -~ .---·t · DR -+3 ~~~~ RD s~; ""· = ~::~-~ ~-g·.__;tf_""' ~~+H+;-'~~ __,---~--:-\ \~VISTA'--~ / 1U 1 · · ~. --- c:- •. 1'1 ..~-~ · ~---: · ~" RIVERSIDE 2~_:;,-:0_.~/>_:~-tl~. ... ,.__· . ' .. "~::-J,.C';~·ce.;-··MHP 'J.r"::;:;,e~·VE~D!;;\ .. · · L--· ' •:~ @j\: :-;ilr ~x-~\:\:\\;. . ·.. · : -~ i--~ •• : · ~ ~~~jllir~ . _l~r---~1s; r - Annexation Phase 2 AREA 5 {Airport Rd. to Tierra Contenta) Acres 592.34 Population Housing Units Legend .......IL•• ..; City Limits G}Area4 ~Area2 L::::I Santa Fe County L , Voter Precincts CJ Parcel Lines Exhibit E 3,484 1,310 *Census 2010 I I I ',,,,,\ I ',', .,. -- ..,\...." .00::: "- = !..l~/LG/1.~ / \ } I\ ,,,,\I TIERRA CONTENTA ,-1 ¥' I.,/ I .., I .., ..... / a~udOJd~ x~~w J~S / / / I I I I ------1 I I I Annexation Phase 2 AREA 7 (South of Tierra Contenta) ( /.....--- Acres 1,320.74 Population 1,023 Housing Units 340 TIERRA CONTENTA Legend ,...."••..; City Limits I:::::j Santa Fe County L 1 Voter Precincts ; · Parcel Lines // J / NM599 Right-of-way •census 2010 I /~a' 3::I: / ' ~ " . -~=-- ' ,, 0 '_ ---"=-P.A• I ~ ~ -. ~ ':."'"'···~ .J~IE>GE~ '"' __----- 0 Q:: '1:1> J!)N z ~ · ::0 - ... tr.. ·--·---C ........ _ m.pA~- < ___ ' 9 -- z ~ _________.. < 0 ~ _____j_---::;- ' --I' ' . ' "' z!ll----ci:J we( a= " :....___: ' i --~--~---w---~ .J z m c:l z w--- --~--~ ""'"'· ..~'fRAY0N·E>R a! tr SANTAF OUTLET I ±-i<§!J~ / ..··..,.:cc""ce~w·I'RIIIIC.E,RI!l~-""'.E'I'!RINeE:RE>'--- ..., :p rr______ ~ m- ::t= <--- __ _ -~ , · --;a·-- ----2-- --1~ --~----~ 0 0:: en ~ ~ w , u.· 1 0:::0 ~ 'jC ~ ~-j:5 __ g -=----=~--'""--- __ ...::MiliB':NEI:S.0N;BE>-:).-,-- -~-~--,_-"F ---,--~~()=---· 1 1 - ·-'--~-~ ( / --.. --~ 1~ - -- --,..; - :E : • i -., ~-~-::;~- 1------" / ~ [J~1-r--:- . ~--~--- J ;3__: :.:.::.~ i / cf'ANElki:N --~--:----'-~-~ ~ ,-II!-'-·;----~-----------::=1 \ / en , • l: ~ • :____________ -!______ 0 \ _ ·=--~:_______: ·- 1!:N. / ,~~=: ~ Prec·•n~~---A--lr-- ~A-~§>~//_ !9~~~:_:_~~ \ // 1::a: "" 1: -~-'------ ~k / ./ J)_ / Ill' .. -- ~ ____ --l=::l~~,~:-/r- · · ) f --'0 ?:~--~~- =- / I ~~============-~~~~~----i-- ~iff/NO HINe"~ / .::::::::::::: ,____ /r"'\\-- )!,- . ;$/(#r/j_----~- cKAf'~~\-'-"'1----~ _ -------: :c~~- ~ I~~.. : ---~.., -..,.,..:::::::::::::::;;I;;·\ \ ·6E-I:EM0NIA- ,:::::::::::::;:::::: ::::~ ...tJ r<~ ~¥<'el'< - . ~ ....... ······••······· ·····~~ ("'' 0~ \ ,· ~~· .\ ·. .Jf/- . /.....-' ::.,. -~· / ~t;;JfJ"";J; . \ ·10~- _/,- ·/~- T.OBAS~e:t;N /-;- :'",,' / f TOWN-AND COUNTRY SUB -- -~ i ~C!: ~ ~ i ! : N :::1 It (l) ~w 1"-w ..u ..u ~ i "l I I I . a:0 cb--·C)_ Z' ~· :::1 o, 'l , I ~ \ .. '- :_~_'- -- n- -_.:..:._:.:___::_:_'_L ___ --·-~-~ •u••••oiiZo•••••••· eAMII)IG.::JAI:IS_ee___ __ . _ I I I I £ i il/LZ/i i U.i:IUdi .lhi:Q uiilW'ibillaai iaawla."i:.u••••u•u•u•n•u•u1 ----- _t:~~~~ ~,a~~ l~t! .."'"! ~ CITY OF SANTA FE ANNEXATION AREA NM599 RO NM599ROW Estimates based on Census 2010 Block Level data. The Agua Fria Traditional Historic Community (THC) is not part of The City Annexation. Legend .. NM599 Right-of-Way ~··-·,·, • City Limits ·-··-- {j.cl>_i ~- , ATTACHMENT B: Maps and Photos ATTACHMENT C: Applicant Submittals Page 1 of 3Revised 5/16/2024 CITY OF SANTA FE GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT PLUD(04 APPLICATION RESOURCES PLANNING AND LAND USE DEPARTMENT RESOURCES MISSION : The mission of the Planning Division is to review development applications for compliance with the City’s land development code and department policies while providing information, guidance, and the highest possible level of customer service to applicants, neighborhoods, and the City’s quasi-judicial decision-making bodies. OFFICE : Santa Fe City Hall 200 Lincoln Avenue Santa Fe, NM 87501 WEBSITE : https://santafenm.gov/land-use/current-planning CURRENT AND UPCOMING PUBLIC MEETINGS : https://santafe.primegov.com/public/portal INTERACTIVE GIS MAPS : https://santafenm.gov/information-technology-telecommunications/gis SANTA FE CITY CODE (SFCC) : https://library.municode.com/nm/santa_fe/codes/code_of_ordinances APPLICATION SUBMISSION AND FEES : All applications shall be submitted electronically as PDF files to planning@santafenm.gov. Incomplete applications, including those missing required submittals will be returned without processing. Application fees will be assessed and invoiced upon acceptance of the application for initial review. Fee tables may be viewed online. GENERAL QUESTIONS : zoningcounter@santafenm.gov DEVELOPMENT REVIEW PROCESS PRE-APPLICATION PHASE For many applications, the development review process begins with a pre-application conference, where the applicant presents their proposal to the City’s Development Review Team (DRT) for initial review and feedback. If the applicant wishes to proceed, a city planner is assigned to assist the applicant through the remaining steps of the process. For administratively reviewed applications, a pre-application conference is usually not required. For all applications requiring a hearing before a land use board, the applicant shall schedule, notice and host an early neighborhood notification (ENN) meeting in coordination with the city planner. The intent of the ENN is to provide for an exchange of information among the applicant, residents, and property owners, prior to application submittal. ENN notification requirements are set forth in SFCC §14-3.1(H). Applications that qualify for administrative review and some variances are not required to conduct an ENN meeting. DEVELOPMENT REVIEW PHASE Once an application and all required submittals are prepared by the applicant, they or their agent submits the Application to the City via planning@santafenm.gov. The applicant will receive an email confirming receipt of the application, and an invoice for applicable development fees which can be paid online or at the cashier’s office at City Hall. The city planner and the DRT review the application for completeness and compliance with all applicable codes, ordinances, plans and regulations. During the review process, the city planner or members of the DRT may request additional information or amendments from the applicant to complete the review process. The review timeline can range for 9-12 weeks or more depending on the complexity of the application and the total number of cases under review. PUBLIC HEARING PHASE When the City determines that the application is complete, the case is scheduled for a public hearing before the applicable Land Use Board. Notification requirements for public hearings are set forth in SFCC §14-3.1(H). If the application is approved at the public hearing, the city planner will prepare the findings of fact and conclusions of law (FOFCOL) documenting the approval findings, any conditions of approval and an expiration date for the approval, as required. POST APPROVAL PHASE When the applicant has met all necessary conditions of approval and technical corrections, the plan or plat is recorded at the County Clerk’s office and filed with the City’s plat room. The case planner prepares an action letter detailing the approval record. The applicant may then proceed to building permitting and construction. If you have questions about the requirements please contact your assigned case planner or planning@santafenm.gov. Page 2 of 3Revised 5/16/2024 CITY OF SANTA FE GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT PLUD(04 SUBMITTAL CHECKLIST LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE REFERENCE GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT PROCEDURES (SECTION 14-3.2(E) SFCC) Purpose: The general plan is a guide for the city’s land use decisions. The regulations, restrictions and policies of the city affecting development of Santa Fe shall be in accordance with the general plan as provided in Section 3-21-5 NMSA 1978. When necessary, the general plan shall be amended in accordance with this section. Applicability: The general plan must first be amended before any proposed changes in the city’s policies on urban area boundaries, annexation, growth, economic development, special review districts or other long-range planning items not in conformance with the general plan may be approved. 1. Criteria for all Amendments to the General Plan The planning commission and the governing body shall review all general plan amendment proposals on the basis of the following criteria, and shall make complete findings of fact sufficient to show that these criteria have been met before recommending or approving any amendment to the general plan: a. Consistency with growth projections for Santa Fe, economic development goals as set forth in a comprehensive economic development plan for Santa Fe and existing land use conditions such as access and availability of infrastructure; b. Consistency with other parts of the general plan; c. The amendment does not: i. Allow uses or a change that is significantly different from or inconsistent with the prevailing use and character in the area; or ii. Affect an area of less than two acres, except when adjusting boundaries between districts; or iii. Benefit one or few landowners at the expense of the surrounding landowners or the general public; d. An amendment is not required to conform with Subsection 14-3.2(E)(1)(c) if it promotes the general welfare or has other adequate public advantage or justification; e. Compliance with the extraterritorial zoning ordinances and extraterritorial plans; f. Contribution to a coordinated, adjusted and harmonious development of Santa Fe that in accordance with existing and future needs best promotes health, safety, morals, order, convenience, prosperity or the general welfare, as well as efficiency and economy in the process of development; and g. Consideration of conformity with other city policies, including land use policies, ordinances, regulations and plans. 2. Additional Criteria for Amendments to Land Use Policies In addition to complying with the general criteria set forth in Subsection 14-3.2(E)(1), amendments to the land use policies section of the general plan shall be made only if evidence shows that the effect of the proposed change in land use shown on the future land use map of the general plan will not have a negative impact on the surrounding properties. The proposed change in land use must be related to the character of the surrounding area or a provision must be made to separate the proposed change in use from adjacent properties by a setback, landscaping or other means, and a finding must be made that: a. The growth and economic projections contained within the general plan are erroneous or have changed; b. No reasonable locations have been provided for certain land uses for which there is a demonstrated need; or c. Conditions affecting the location or land area requirements of the proposed land use have changed, for example, the cost of land space requirements, consumer acceptance, market or building technology. Development Plan (as defined by Section 14-3.8 SFCC 1987, if applicable) Statement addressing approval criteria Letter of water and sewer availability Application Letter (intent, location, acreage) Proof of compliance with conditions of annexation approval (if applicable) Legal lot of record, legal description Submittal requirements may vary based on the individual application. The City reserves the right to request additional information during the review process. Please submit each of the following items as separate PDF files saved with unique and descriptive file names: Page 1 of 3Revised 5/16/2024 CITY OF SANTA FE REZONING PLUD(07 APPLICATION RESOURCES PLANNING AND LAND USE DEPARTMENT RESOURCES MISSION : The mission of the Planning Division is to review development applications for compliance with the City’s land development code and department policies while providing information, guidance, and the highest possible level of customer service to applicants, neighborhoods, and the City’s quasi-judicial decision-making bodies. OFFICE : Santa Fe City Hall 200 Lincoln Avenue Santa Fe, NM 87501 WEBSITE : https://santafenm.gov/land-use/current-planning CURRENT AND UPCOMING PUBLIC MEETINGS : https://santafe.primegov.com/public/portal INTERACTIVE GIS MAPS : https://santafenm.gov/information-technology-telecommunications/gis SANTA FE CITY CODE (SFCC) : https://library.municode.com/nm/santa_fe/codes/code_of_ordinances APPLICATION SUBMISSION AND FEES : All applications shall be submitted electronically as PDF files to planning@santafenm.gov. Incomplete applications, including those missing required submittals will be returned without processing. Application fees will be assessed and invoiced upon acceptance of the application for initial review. Fee tables may be viewed online. GENERAL QUESTIONS : zoningcounter@santafenm.gov DEVELOPMENT REVIEW PROCESS PRE-APPLICATION PHASE For many applications, the development review process begins with a pre-application conference, where the applicant presents their proposal to the City’s Development Review Team (DRT) for initial review and feedback. If the applicant wishes to proceed, a city planner is assigned to assist the applicant through the remaining steps of the process. For administratively reviewed applications, a pre-application conference is usually not required. For all applications requiring a hearing before a land use board, the applicant shall schedule, notice and host an early neighborhood notification (ENN) meeting in coordination with the city planner. The intent of the ENN is to provide for an exchange of information among the applicant, residents, and property owners, prior to application submittal. ENN notification requirements are set forth in SFCC §14-3.1(H). Applications that qualify for administrative review and some variances are not required to conduct an ENN meeting. DEVELOPMENT REVIEW PHASE Once an application and all required submittals are prepared by the applicant, they or their agent submits the Application to the City via planning@santafenm.gov. The applicant will receive an email confirming receipt of the application, and an invoice for applicable development fees which can be paid online or at the cashier’s office at City Hall. The city planner and the DRT review the application for completeness and compliance with all applicable codes, ordinances, plans and regulations. During the review process, the city planner or members of the DRT may request additional information or amendments from the applicant to complete the review process. The review timeline can range for 9-12 weeks or more depending on the complexity of the application and the total number of cases under review. PUBLIC HEARING PHASE When the City determines that the application is complete, the case is scheduled for a public hearing before the applicable Land Use Board. Notification requirements for public hearings are set forth in SFCC §14-3.1(H). If the application is approved at the public hearing, the city planner will prepare the findings of fact and conclusions of law (FOFCOL) documenting the approval findings, any conditions of approval and an expiration date for the approval, as required. POST APPROVAL PHASE When the applicant has met all necessary conditions of approval and technical corrections, the plan or plat is recorded at the County Clerk’s office and filed with the City’s plat room. The case planner prepares an action letter detailing the approval record. The applicant may then proceed to building permitting and construction. If you have questions about the requirements please contact your assigned case planner or planning@santafenm.gov. Page 2 of 3Revised 5/16/2024 CITY OF SANTA FE REZONING PLUD(07 LAND DEVELOPMENT CODE REFERENCE REZONING PROCEDURES AND APPROVAL CRITERIA (SECTION 14-3.5(C) SFCC) Procedures: All rezonings shall be submitted to the planning commission for review and recommendation at a public hearing. The review shall be based on the approval criteria and a balancing test that considers the prevailing uses and character in the area. Rezoning requests specified in Section 14-4 Zoning Districts and 14-5 Overlay Zoning Districts, must be accompanied by a Development Plan application to be reviewed in coordination with the rezoning request. The Planning Commission shall transmit the application to the governing body, with a recommendation for approval or disapproval. Before taking action, the governing body shall hold a public hearing and may request additional information necessary to ensure compliance with Chapter 14. The governing body shall take final action to approve, approve with conditions or deny the proposed rezoning. After approval the official zoning map shall be amended in accordance with Section 14-4.1(C) to note the new zoning designation. If denied, the applicant must wait 12 months to reapply. Approval Criteria 1. The planning commission and the governing body shall review all rezoning proposals on the basis of the following criteria, and must make complete findings of fact sufficient to show that these criteria have been met before recommending or approving any rezoning: a. one or more of the following conditions exist: i. there was a mistake in the original zoning; ii. there has been a change in the surrounding area, altering the character of the neighborhood to such an extent as to justify changing the zoning; or iii. a different use category is more advantageous to the community, as articulated in the general plan or other adopted city plans; b. all the rezoning requirements of Chapter 14 have been met; c. the rezoning is consistent with the applicable policies of the general plan, including the future land use map; d. the amount of land proposed for rezoning and the proposed use for the land is consistent with city policies regarding the provision of urban land sufficient to meet the amount, rate and geographic location of the growth of the city; and e. the existing and proposed infrastructure, such as the streets system, sewer and water lines, and public facilities, such as fire stations and parks, will be able to accommodate the impacts of the proposed development. 2. Unless the proposed change is consistent with applicable general plan policies, the planning commission and the governing body shall not recommend or approve any rezoning, the practical effect of which is to: a. allow uses or a change in character significantly different from or inconsistent with the prevailing use and character in the area; b. affect an area of less than two acres, unless adjusting boundaries between districts; or c. benefit one or a few landowners at the expense of the surrounding landowners or general public. Statement addressing rezoning approval criteria Traffic impact analysis (if applicable) Archaeological Clearance (if applicable) Application letter (purpose, intent, location, acreage) Terrain management plans (as required by Section 14-8.2 SFCC 1987) Development plan (see Section 14-3.8 SFCC 1987) (if applicable) Sewer and Water Plan (including profiles and details), letter of availability (if applicable) Legal lot of record and legal description ENN meeting notes SUBMITTAL CHECKLIST Submittal requirements may vary based on the individual application and the requested zoning district. The City reserves the right to request additional information during the review process. See Section 14-4 and 14-5 SFCC 1987 for rezoning regulations related to specific zones. Please submit each of the following items as separate PDF files saved with unique and descriptive file names: Page 3 of 3Revised 5/16/2024 CITY OF SANTA FE REZONING PLUD(07 PARCEL INFORMATION PROPERTY OWNER INFORMATION APPLICANT/AGENT INFORMATION (IF DIFFERENT FROM OWNER) AGENT AUTHORIZATION (IF APPLICABLE) SIGNATURE Project Name: Name (First, Last): Name (First, Last): I/we authorize Signed: Signed: Signature: Date: Date: Date: to act as my/our agent to execute this application. Company Name: I am/We are the owner(s) and record title holder(s) of the property located at: Address: Address: Street Address Street Address City City Suite/Unit # Suite/Unit # State State ZIP Code ZIP Code Correspondence Directed To: Address: Current Zoning: Does a Development Plan application accompany this application? Proposed Zoning: Property Size: Yes No Phone: Phone: E-mail Address: E-mail Address: Owner Applicant Both I hereby certify that the documents submitted for review and consideration by the City of Santa Fe have been prepared to meet the minimum standards outlined in the Land Development Code, Chapter 14 SFCC 1987. Failure to meet these standards may result in the rejection of my application. I also certify that I have met with the City’s Current Planning staff in a pre-application meeting to verify that the attached proposal is in compliance with the City’s zoning requirements. Uniform Parcel Code Number: Early Neighborhood Notice (ENN) Meeting Date:Pre-application Conference Date: NM LAND SOLUTIONS LLC. (Dba. Siebert & Associates Inc.) 915 Mercer Street Santa Fe, New Mexico 87505 Phone: 505-983-5588 E-mail: victoria@jwsiebert.com nathan@jwsiebert.com wayne@jwsiebert.com Website: NMLandSolutions.com November 12, 2024 Dan Esquibel City of Santa Fe Planning Manager PO Box 909, 200 Lincoln Ave., Santa Fe, NM 87504 Re: Boyan Rezoning Dear Mr. Esquibel: On behalf of Larry Boylan, I am submitting an application to request General Plan Amendment from Transitional Mixed Use (TMXU) to Community Commercial (CCOM) and Rezoning from R-1 (1/dwelling/acre) to C-2 (General Commercial) for four legal lots of record located at, 1372 Boylan Lane, 2743 Boylan Circle (includes two lots) and 2745 Boylan Circle. The combined acreage of the four subject lots is approximately 5.96 acres. Three of four subject lots are encompassed by a legal non-conforming mobile home park that has been in existence prior to the adoption of the Santa Fe County Development code as the lots were previously under county jurisdiction prior to the City/County initiated annexation. A development plan is not proposed in conjunction with the subject application requests, however, the subject property(s) are considered infill and a zoning designation that allows for higher density is not only beneficial to the property owner it is also beneficial to the city of Santa Fe as it promotes use of existing infrastructure and city utilities, additional housing, where there continues to remain a housing shortage and or commercial development which leads to generation of gross receipts tax to the City of Santa. The following material is submitted with this request. • General Plan Amendment application • Rezoning Application Dan Esquibel Boylan GP Amendment/Rezoning App November 12, 2024 Page 2 of 2 • Report containing the following information o Warranty Deeds o Legal Lot of Record o Certificate of Compliance Please review for completeness and acceptance of the application material to allow for placement onto a Planning Commission agenda. Sincerely, Victoria Dalton Victoria Dalton NM Land Solutions LLC 2743, 2745 BOYLAN CIRCLE AND 1372 BOYLAN LANE GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT / REZONING DEVELOMENT REPORT PREPARED FOR: MR. LARRY BOYLAN PREPARED BY: NM LAND SOLUTIONS LLC NOVEMBER 2024 TABLE OF CONTENTS Project Description & Location 2 Ownership & Legal Lot of Record 3 Existing Conditions & Adjoining Land Uses 3 General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Request 4-5 Access 5 Archeology 5 Utilities 5-6 Water Sewer Dry Utilities Early Neighborhood Notification (ENN) 6 Response to General Plan Amendment 6-11 Response to Criteria for Rezoning of the Property 11-14 APPENDICES Appendix A Lot 1 Legal Lot of Record Plat Appendix B Legal Lot of Record Plat E-1 & A-1 Appendix C Certificate of Compliance (Tract D) Appendix D Warranty Deeds FIGURES Figure 1: Vicinity Map 2 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report PROPERTY LOCATION AND SUMMARY DESCRIPTION There are four (4) legal lots of record associated with the request for General Plan Amendment and Rezoning. The lot fronting Agua Fria Street is located at 2745 Boylan Circle, consists of 1.08± acres and is vacant. The remaining three (3) legal lots of record encompass a legal non-conforming mobile home park addressed as 2743 Boylan Circle and 1372 Boylan Lane. 2743 Boylan Lane is assigned to two (2) lots. The total combined acreage of the four (4) subject lots equals 5.96 (±) acres. In addition, a separate lot consolidation plat to combine all four (4) lots into one (1) lot will be submitted to staff for administrative review upon approval of the proposed general plan amendment and rezoning request. Figure 1 is a vicinity map indicating the location of the subject property relative to the city street system and other known landmarks in the area. Figure 1: 3 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report OWNERSHIP AND LEGAL LOT OF RECORD The four (4) subject lots are owned by Mr. Larry Boylan. The legal lot of record for the Lot 1 (2745 Agua Fria St.) is established by a plat entitled Haile Subdivision, which was approved by the Extraterritorial Zoning Commission on February 13, 1986, and recorded in the Office of the County Clerk in Book 238 Page 12 and is located in Appendix A of this report. The legal lot of record for Tract E1 (2743 Boylan Lane) immediately north of Lot 1 and Tract A1 (1372 Boylan Lane) is established by a lot line adjustment plat prepared for the Estate of Tom and Larry Boylan administratively approved by City Land Use Planning staff, recorded in the Office of the Santa Fe County Clerk in Book 687 page 39 and is located in Appendix B of this report. The legal lot of record for remaining lot adjoining the Santa Fe County River Greenway trail is established by a certificate of compliance based on the condemnation and purchase of property by Santa Fe County for its construction and maintenance of the Santa Fe River Greenway trail. The certificate of compliance was approved by the city of Santa Fe planning staff on November 5, 2019, and recorded in the office of the County Clerk as instrument #1901539. The subject Certificate of compliance is located in Appendix C of this report. Proof of ownership warranty deeds for the subject four lots are located in Appendix D of this report. EXISTING CONDITIONS & ADJOINING LAND USES As stated, three (3) of the four (4) subject lots are encompassed by a legal non-conforming mobile home park which was developed prior to the adoption of the County Extraterritorial Zoning Ordinance and Land Development Code. The vacant tract fronting Agua Fria contains a large stockpile of dirt which will be used as fill dirt for future construction of utilities and or roads. The subject lots also contain several PNM power poles which will be removed and relocated underground at the time of future development. The lot immediately east has been rezoned to C-2 as well as development plan approval to allow for an apartment complex which has started construction. The property northwest of the mobile home park has also been rezoned to C-2 and is used as a plumbing and Heating business. The property located west is zoned R-1, which is the designation assigned to all properties without prior zoning entitlements prior to the city/county annexation. The Santa Fe County River Greenway trail is north of the existing mobile home park and consists of land that was part of a condemnation of the subject lots by Santa Fe County to allow for the restoration of the river as well as continuation of the trail. Directly across Agua Fria Street, there is a mix of zoning designations which includes MU (Mixed Use) and I-1 (Light Industrial) zoning districts. 4 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT & REZONING REQUEST The future land use designation assigned to the subject lots requesting General Plan Amendment & Zoning is “Transitional Mixed-Use” while the zoning designation is R-1 (1 dwelling unit/acre). The R-1 zoning designation was assigned to the subject lots during the city/county-initiated annexation. Since the city/county annexation, there has been several approved general plan amendments and rezonings requests within the surrounding area. At this time the property owner is proposing General Plan Amendment from Transitional Mixed Use (TMXU) to Community Commercial (CCOM) and Rezoning from R-1 (1/dwelling/acre) to C-2 (General Commercial). A development plan is not proposed in conjunction with the subject request, as it has become evident with the recently approved rezonings in the area that the R-1 zoning designation is not consistent with the surrounding area. Furthermore, the 1999 General Plan promotes higher density development in urban infill properties which includes the greater Agua Fria area. 5 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report Once a determination has been made on how the property will be redeveloped, the existing legal non-conforming mobile home park will be removed. The owner / applicant anticipates a future multifamily development, possibly a small-scale apartment complex to replace the current mobile home park, as Mr. Boylan is aware of the need to provide housing for the community. The property fronting Agua Fria Street would seem more appropriate to develop small-scale stand- alone retail / commercial use(s) that can be enjoyed by the new residents of the area. ACCESS Access to the subject lots is off of Boylan Circle via Agua Fria Street. Boylan Circle is a dirt road with an approximate width of twenty (20’) feet. Within the past several years, the City has completed street improvements and widening of Agua Fria adjacent to the subject property including upgrades to the Agua Fria and Siler Road intersection. Once the property is redeveloped, the existing access will be required to be upgraded to city standards based off the traffic / use of any future development. ARCHAEOLOGY The consolidated acreage of the subject lots is over 2.00-acres in size and is within the River and Trails Archaeological Review District, which requires an archaeological clearance at the time of development plan or final plat. Since there is not a development plan or plat associated with the request, an archaeological clearance is not required at this time. WATER & WASTEWATER Water The existing mobile home park is served by an on-site domestic well. There is a 12-inch waterline in Agua Fria Street that would need to be extended into the subject lots at the time of redevelopment of the property. Utilization and or transfer of water rights associated with the well will be determined upon redevelopment of the property as a future connection to City water will be required at the time of new development. Sewer The existing mobile home park is served by a private 8-inch sewer line that connects to the city trunk line across the Santa Fe River which eventually flows into the city wastewater treatment plant. 6 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report At the time of redevelopment of the property, a new sewer line will be designed and constructed to city standards at which time the sewer line will be dedicated to the city for public use. Dry Utilities Electric, telephone and gas are available to this property with adequate capacity to serve future development. EARLY NEIGHBORHOOD NOTIFICATION (ENN) An ENN meeting was held on September 26th, 2024, with city staff, along with the property owner, and agent NM Land Solutions LLC were present. In addition, an unidentified participant that was having technical difficulties later called via phone to inquire about process and other unrelated questions regarding his prior approved rezoning located at 2749 B Agua Fria St. Also, a phone call was received prior to the ENN meeting from a property Adjoiner that was in favor of the project and agreed that obtaining general plan amendment and rezoning seemed like the proper path forward for the lots in question. RESPONSE TO GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT (1) Criteria for All Amendments to the General Plan The planning commission and the governing body shall review all general plan amendment proposals on the basis of the following criteria, and shall make complete findings of fact sufficient to show that these criteria have been met before recommending or approving any amendment to the general plan : (a) consistency with growth projections for Santa Fe, economic development goals as set forth in a comprehensive economic development plan for Santa Fe and existing land use conditions such as access and availability of infrastructure ; Response: Santa Fe is currently experiencing a steady growth rate of 0.54% annually, with the population having increased by 2.19%. The proposed general plan amendment to community commercial zoning will allow for a mix of commercial and high-density residential uses, providing flexibility in development without the rigid residential-to-commercial ratio specified in the transitional mixed-use future land use designation. This flexibility supports the City's economic development goals by allowing for both affordable housing options and commercial development that complements surrounding uses. Higher-density residential development will contribute to the availability of affordable housing through the City of Santa Fe Affordable Housing Program, addressing the ongoing need for affordable units. This development approach also supports the local economy by facilitating the potential for employment opportunities tied to the proposed commercial uses. 7 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report The amendment is consistent with the guiding policies within Chapter 4 of the 1999 General Plan, specifically regarding the promotion of infill development, efficient use of existing infrastructure, and recognition of water demand and conservation. By aligning with these policies, the amendment contributes to the balanced growth of Santa Fe, promoting both residential development and new employment opportunities in a sustainable manner. Additionally, the proposal is designed with consideration of existing land use conditions, including the availability of access and infrastructure, ensuring that development occurs in a manner that makes efficient use of resources while accommodating future growth. (b) consistency with other parts of the general plan ; Response: The proposed General Plan Amendment is consistent with several key elements of the Santa Fe General Plan, particularly those related to housing, economic development, transportation, and infrastructure. • Affordable Housing and Quality of Life: The amendment is in alignment with the General Plan’s goals of providing more affordable housing options, which directly supports the city’s efforts to meet the growing demand for safe, secure, and affordable living spaces. The potential for high-density residential development will increase the availability of the affordable housing stock, improving the quality of life for residents in line with the General Plan’s housing policies. • Job Creation and Economic Development: The proposed amendment facilitates the creation of both construction-related jobs and long-term employment opportunities through the development of commercial spaces. This is consistent with the General Plan’s economic development objectives, which emphasize creating jobs and promoting balanced economic growth within the city. • Transportation and Mobility: The proposed development also aligns with the General Plan’s transportation goals by enhancing connectivity and providing alternative transportation options. The property’s adjacency to the Santa Fe River Greenway Trail, which accommodates both pedestrians and cyclists, supports the General Plan’s vision for expanding and improving the city’s pedestrian and bike infrastructure. The Greenway Trail connects key parts of the city, contributing to the city’s transportation and mobility policies. • Infrastructure and Public Services: The proposed amendment is consistent with the General Plan’s goals related to infrastructure and public services. Although the existing mobile home park is currently served by a domestic well, redevelopment of the property will require connection to city water, ensuring that the development aligns with the city’s water infrastructure policies. The new sewer system, which will be installed to meet city standards and maintained by the city after one year, is also consistent with the General Plan’s commitment to ensuring adequate, sustainable public services and infrastructure to support growth. (c) the amendment does not: 8 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report (i) allow uses or a change that is significantly different from or inconsistent with the prevailing use and character in the area; or Response: The proposed amendment does not introduce uses or changes that are significantly different from or inconsistent with the prevailing use and character of the surrounding area. Over time, particularly following the city/county annexation, the area has undergone significant changes, allowing for the development of infill properties with access to city utilities. Many of the surrounding properties have been rezoned within the past fifteen years to accommodate higher- density residential uses, including multifamily apartment buildings, reflecting the city's growth and evolving urban landscape. Currently, the area includes a mix of residential and commercial uses. Some commercial properties are legal non-conforming, while others were established through previous general plan amendments and rezonings. The proposed general plan amendment is consistent with this pattern of development, as it allows for a combination of residential and commercial uses that align with the existing mix of land uses in the area. The amendment would further complement the surrounding developments by providing additional opportunities for both residential and commercial growth, without significantly altering the established character of the neighborhood. Thus, the amendment is in keeping with the area's ongoing transition and growth, and it aligns with the existing mix of residential and commercial uses that have developed over time. The proposed change is not a dramatic departure from the current land use pattern but rather a continuation of the evolving character of the area. (ii) affect an area of less than two acres, except when adjusting boundaries between districts; or Response: There are four adjoining legal lots of record with a total of 5.96 acres. (iii) benefit one or a few landowners at the expense of the surrounding landowners or the general public; Response: The proposed amendment will provide benefits not only to the applicant but also to the surrounding landowners and the broader community. The property in question is currently occupied by an aging mobile home park that has been in place for over forty years, predating the County Code established prior to being annexed into the City of Santa Fe. This property is in need of redevelopment to address current deficiencies and enhance the area’s overall character. The existing site is encumbered by several electric power poles and a large stockpile of dirt along the Agua Fria Street frontage, both of which negatively impact the aesthetics and functionality of the area. The proposed amendment will facilitate a sustainable and diverse redevelopment that connects the property to city utilities, addressing key infrastructure challenges. Specifically, the redevelopment will allow for the relocation and undergrounding of electric services, improving both the visual appeal and safety of the area. These infrastructure improvements will directly benefit the surrounding landowners by reducing existing eyesores and enhancing the overall neighborhood environment. 9 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report Additionally, by redeveloping the site, the amendment creates the potential for a more vibrant and well-integrated community with better access to essential services. The redevelopment is designed to integrate seamlessly with surrounding properties, offering opportunities for both residential and commercial growth that will benefit the area as a whole, not just a select few. This approach ensures that the amendment does not disproportionately benefit one landowner at the expense of others but instead supports the broader public interest by improving infrastructure, enhancing the built environment, and contributing to the neighborhood’s long-term sustainability and growth. (c) an amendment is not required to conform with Subsection 14-3.2(E)(1)(c) if it promotes the general welfare or has other adequate public advantage or justification. Response: The proposed amendment is in conformance with Subsection 14-3.2(E)(1)(c) as stated in the above responses (c) i,ii,iii. (d) compliance with extraterritorial zoning ordinances and extraterritorial plans; Response: This criterion is no longer relevant since the adoption of Subdivision Platting and Planning Zoning Ordinance (SPPaZO), and the relinquishment of the land use regulatory authority outside the city limits and the transfer of authority from extraterritorial jurisdiction to the City. (e) contribution to a coordinated, adjusted and harmonious development of Santa Fe that in accordance with existing and future needs best promotes health, safety, morals, order, convenience, prosperity or the general welfare, as well as efficiency and economy in the process of development ; and Response: The proposed amendment will contribute to the coordinated, harmonious development of Santa Fe by addressing both current and future needs, and it will promote the health, safety, and general welfare of the community. The existing mobile home park, currently designated as transitional mixed-use, does not comply with the current land use regulations and is limited in its ability to undergo meaningful upgrades or redevelopment due to its non-conforming status. This limitation restricts opportunities for investment, which in turn can lead to deterioration and neglect of the site. By encouraging the redevelopment of this property, the amendment will not only provide an opportunity to modernize the site but also help prevent blight and disrepair, thereby improving the overall quality of life for residents and the surrounding community. Redevelopment will ensure that the site is brought into compliance with modern land use standards, improving both the physical and environmental aspects of the area. These improvements will enhance public safety, aesthetics, and infrastructure, contributing to the general welfare of the neighborhood. The amendment also aligns with the City of Santa Fe’s long-term growth goals by supporting infill development and more efficient use of land. The proposed redevelopment is consistent with the city’s vision of creating sustainable, vibrant, and diverse neighborhoods that meet the needs of 10 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report both current and future residents. By facilitating development that connects to city utilities and enhances the surrounding infrastructure, the amendment helps promote efficiency and economy in the development process, aligning with the city’s broader planning objectives for growth and sustainability. In summary, the proposed amendment will foster a coordinated and harmonious development that supports Santa Fe’s growth objectives, improves public health and safety, and contributes to the economic and social well-being of the community. (f) consideration of conformity with other city policies, including land use policies, ordinances, regulations and plans. Response: The City has a policy of promoting a mix of land uses, this property is located within an area where there is a mix of residential, retail and entertainment. The recent changes to the City code now permit residential uses within a C-2 commercial district. (2) Additional Criteria for Amendments to Land Use Policies In addition to complying with the general criteria set forth in Subsection 14-3.2(E)(1), amendments to the land use policies section of the general plan shall be made only if evidence shows that the effect of the proposed change in land use shown on the future land use map of the general plan will not have a negative impact on the surrounding properties . The proposed change in land use must be related to the character of the surrounding area or a provision must be made to separate the proposed change in use from adjacent properties by a setback , landscaping or other means, and a finding must be made that: (a) the growth and economic projections contained within the general plan are erroneous or have changed; Response: When the existing General Plan was adopted in 1999 it seems that the General Plan failed to recognize the land use complexity of this part of the urban area. It is not a matter of the growth and economic projections being in error as it is the failure to observe the variety of existing land uses and assign a zoning district that best fit those land uses. Land use patterns in this area have changed over time especially with the city/county annexation recognizing infill development that can provide greater housing densities and or a variety of commercial uses that are consistent with the current land use patterns. (b) no reasonable locations have been provided for certain land uses for which there is a demonstrated need; or Response: There are other locations in Santa Fe where general commercial is available, however the current zoning does not allow for the existing residential density associated with the existing mobile home park. The intent of the property owner is to maintain a higher density residential component while having an option to develop both commercial and residential uses on the subject lot. 11 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report (c) conditions affecting the location or land area requirements of the proposed land use have changed, for example, the cost of land space requirements, consumer acceptance, market or building technology. Response: While the City continues to recognize the existing mobile home park as a legal non- conforming use, this grandfathered status is contingent upon no substantial improvements, expansion, or damage beyond repair. Should such circumstances arise, the property would revert to its R-1 zoning with a transitional mixed-use land use designation, which allows for only one (1) dwelling unit per acre, a density that no longer aligns with the area’s evolving development patterns. Over the past fifteen years, since the annexation of this property into the city, significant changes in land use patterns and zoning have occurred. The recent rezonings in the area, which have permitted higher-density multifamily residential and commercial uses, have notably increased the cost of land and shifted the market dynamics. These changes have rendered the existing mobile home park site less viable for long-term use under its current configuration, especially as surrounding properties have transitioned to more intensive uses. Additionally, advances in building technology and changes in consumer preferences have further driven demand for higher-density housing and more diverse land uses. The costs associated with maintaining the existing mobile home park, particularly given the high land value in this growing area, make it increasingly difficult to sustain its non-conforming use. Redeveloping the property in accordance with the proposed general plan amendment will not only accommodate the evolving market but also provide a more efficient and sustainable use of the land, aligning with the city’s current zoning and development goals. This amendment is therefore a response to the changing land use patterns, market conditions, and technological advancements that have altered the feasibility of the existing mobile home park and support the need for a more appropriate and compatible development for this location. RESPONSE TO REZONING APPROVAL CRITERIA The planning commission and the governing body shall review all rezoning proposals on the basis of the criteria provided in this section, and the reviewing entities must make complete findings of fact sufficient to show that these criteria have been met before recommending or approving any rezoning: (a) one or more of the following conditions exist: (i) there was a mistake in the original zoning. Response: Since the Annexation of this property, the City has used R-1 zoning designation for annexed areas where it serves as a holding zone until another use is proposed for the land. R-1 is the lowest density zoning district designated in the Land Development Code and the designation of this district is inconsistent with the policies of the General Plan. 12 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report (ii) there has been a change in the surrounding area, altering the character of the neighborhood to such an extent as to justify changing the zoning; or Response: With the city/county annexation that occurred approximately fifteen years ago, the surrounding area has changed significantly where there have been at least four rezoning approvals which includes nine tracts of land all within less than 1,000 feet of the subject property(s) that have been redeveloped as mostly apartments. Prior to the city annexing the area north of Agua Fria Road there was little development activity. With the City commitment of utilities and provision of City services, this area is now experiencing requests for development or re-development. (iii) a different use category is more advantageous to the community, as articulated in the general plan or other adopted city plans; Response: The City General Plan shows this property and other properties between Agua Fria and the Santa Fe River as “Community Commercial or Transitional Mixed Use”. The predominate land use for this area is a mix of commercial and single family and rental housing. From the time that this area was brought into the “Presumptive City Limits” and zoned R-1, single family residential, one (1) dwelling per acre, many of the existing uses have become non- conforming. The landowners are now limited in the expansion of the existing structures on the property and given the inconsistency between the zoning and the actual land use it would be more advantageous to recognize the existing land use pattern for the area. It does not make planning sense to create non-conformity out of 70 to 80 percent (70% - 80%) of the ownership in the vicinity of this request. Such non-conformities discourages investment in the property and can lead to inconsistent development in the subject area. (b) all the rezoning requirements of Chapter 14 have been met; Response: Currently the existing zoning is R-1, Single Family Residential, one dwelling per acre, which creates a non-conforming status for this property. Rezoning of the property to C-2 uses would bring this property into conformance with the historic uses that have taken place on this property. (c) the rezoning is consistent with the applicable policies of the general plan, including the future land use map; Response: Rezoning to C-2 (General Commercial) is consistent with the policies of the general plan as it aims to recognize the development of infill properties where city infrastructure is available furthermore rezoning of the property is consistent with the transitional mixed-use designation in that it offers the property the ability to development both a mix of residential and commercial uses. (d) the amount of land proposed for rezoning and the proposed use for the land is consistent with city policies regarding the provision of urban land sufficient to meet the amount, rate and geographic location of the growth of the city; and 13 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report Response: There are four (4) adjoining legal lots of record with a combined total of 5.96 acres which will be consolidated upon approval of the rezoning request. The proposed C-2 use for the land is consistent with city policies as it continues to recognize development of infill property and is consistent with the current land use patterns that have developed for a mix of uses from commercial to medium to high density residential. (e) the existing and proposed infrastructure , such as the streets system, sewer and water lines, and public facilities, such as fire stations and parks, will be able to accommodate the impacts of the proposed development . Response: Public utilities are available on Agua Fria, including water, gas and electric lines, cable and telephone lines. The City has completed street improvements and widening of Agua Fria adjacent to the subject property including upgrades to the Agua Fria and Siler Road intersection. Siler Road has been completed from Agua Fria to West Alameda providing alternative routes to Agua Fria. In fact, the traffic volumes on Agua Fria have declined with the extension of Siler to West Alameda. the Santa Fe River Greenway trail which can accommodate both pedestrian and bicyclist. The Santa Fe River Greenway pedestrian and bicycle trail has recently been completed and is located north of the subject parcels, The closest Fire Station to this site is located on Cerrillos Road near Third Street within a five- minute service radius to this property. (2) Unless the proposed change is consistent with applicable general plan policies, the planning commission and the governing body shall not recommend or approve any rezoning, the practical effect of which is to: (a) allow uses or a change in character significantly different from or inconsistent with the prevailing use and character in the area; Response: The proposed C-2 zoning request, the character of the neighborhood will remain unchanged from the current mixed use and high-density multi-family residential that has been approved within the past fifteen (15) years with the annexation area of the subject property(s). (b) affect an area of less than two acres, unless adjusting boundaries between districts; or Response: The combined total of acreage included with the request consist of 5.96 acres, additionally the subject property immediately adjoins a tract of land that was approved to be rezoned in 2014, and was officially adopted via Ordinance 2014-32 14 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report (c) benefit one or a few landowners at the expense of the surrounding Response: The proposed amendment will benefit the surrounding landowners as the property is in need of redevelopment. The existing mobile home park has been in existence for over forty (40) years prior to the County Code taking effect. The property fronting Agua Fria Street is encroached by several electric power poles as well as a large stockpile of dirt. The amendment will allow for a sustainable and diverse development with connection to city utilities, relocating and undergrounding electric services. APPENDIX A LOT 1 (2745 AGUA FRIA) LEGAL LOT OF RECORD PLAT APPENDIX B TRACT E 1 (2743 AGUA FRIA) & A-1 (1372 BOYLAN LN.) LEGAL LOT OF RECORD PLAT APPENDIX C TRACT D CERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE APPENDIX D WARRANTY DEEDS LOT 1 (2745 BOYLAN LN.) WARRANTY DEED TRACT E-1 (2743 BOYLAN CIR.) WARRANTY DEED TRACT D (2743 BOYLAN CIR) WARRANTY DEED TRACT A-1 WARRANTY DEED (Deed for entire property within river prior to condemnation NM LAND SOLUTIONS LLC. (Dba. Siebert & Associates Inc.) 915 Mercer Street Santa Fe, New Mexico 87505 Phone: 505-983-5588 E-mail: victoria@jwsiebert.com nathan@jwsiebert.com wayne@jwsiebert.com Website: NMLandSolutions.com MEMORANDUM To: Janice Biletnikoff, ACIP From: Victoria Dalton, NM Land Solutions LLC. Date: May 28, 2025 Re: Case 2024-9460 & 2024-9461 1. Contact the City Wastewater Division to confirm in writing the status of system capacity and the ability of the existing infrastructure to accommodate the additional impacts of the proposed C-2 zoning at the subject property. Have you verified Parks, Police/Fire/EMT, Santa Fe Public Schools, and Public Works (i.e., streets) that each of the systems and services currently have ample capacity to absorb the impacts of the uses allowed within a C-2 zone district? The existence or availability of infrastructure and services in the vicinity is not sufficient assurance of adequate system capacity for new impacts that would result from the proposal. Explain how each system or service can or cannot accommodate the anticipated increment of added impacts. If the impacts of the proposed rezoning cannot be accommodated by the existing infrastructure and public facilities, the City may require the developer to participate wholly or in part in the cost of construction of off-site facilities in conformance with any applicable city ordinances, regulations or policies (see § 14-3.5(D)). Response: There are currently fourteen (14) existing manufactured homes on the subject property(s). A private sewer line on the property is connected to the existing city manholes allowing current wastewater service to the existing residential development. Prior to redevelopment of the property, the existing sewer line will be required to be upgraded and extended into the property to serve future development, which in turn will be dedicated to the City. Furthermore, the city wastewater Division authorized construction and installation of two Janice Biletnikoff Boylan GP Amendment/Rezoning May 28, 2025 Page 2 of 6 additional sewer manholes with stub outs to serve future development (Please see attached City Wastewater letter). The installation of the manholes was proposed during utility construction of the adjacent development in order to prevent reopening of the utility trench. An email dated 1/2/2024 was sent to City Wastewater including a phone call with Mr. Sergio Valora, Engineer Associate with the City Wastewater Division, confirming the request to provide a statement regarding capacity of the City of Santa Fe sewer system. Review from City parks and City traffic both confirm there are no issues with the proposed General Plan Amendment and Rezoning Request. Additionally, a Traffic Impact Analysis (TIA) will be required at the time of development. The TIA for a specific development will determine the size and intensity of future development based on whether Agua Fria Street has capacity to be further upgraded from its current standards. All required on-site and off-site road improvements will be required with future development and not at this point or with the subject request. Police/Fire/EMT, currently provide services to the subject properties which includes the existing residential manufactured home park. The permitted uses within the C-2 district are no more intense than which currently exists, due to much of the surrounding area having already been rezoned since the 2009 City/County annexation. Correspondence is with the Santa Fe Public Schools in not required unless the development is determined to be residential in nature and should be reserved for future developments once the property is granted approval for rezoning. 2. Describe the water rights associated with the well that would be transferred to the City upon redevelopment. Response: There are two (2) existing domestic wells on the property, each of which allow the diversion of 3.00 ac/ft/yr for a total of 6.00-acre feet. At the time of redevelopment, connection to city water is required. The City water division can allow future use of the well for irrigation purposes or require capping the wells as may be required. If the water rights associated with the existing wells are sufficient to offset the future water budget/water use, then said water rights would be transferred to the city water bank for future development / future uses. Janice Biletnikoff Boylan GP Amendment/Rezoning May 28, 2025 Page 3 of 6 3. Based on the required criteria: wherever applicable, cite the specific themes and policies of the General Plan (by name and/or number) that will be advanced or complied with by the amendment and rezoning proposal. Response: This item was addressed on page 7 of the Development Report and also within the overall General Plan Amendment and Rezoning Report previously submitted November 15, 2024. Below are the specific themes from chapter 3-1 of the 1999 General Plan as referenced on page 7 of the previous report: • Job Creation and Economic Development: The proposed amendment facilitates the creation of both construction-related jobs and long-term employment opportunities through the development of commercial spaces. This is consistent with the General Plan’s economic development objectives / goals, which emphasize creating jobs and promoting balanced economic growth within the city. • Transportation and Mobility: The proposed development also aligns with the General Plan’s transportation targets by enhancing connectivity and providing alternative transportation options. The property’s adjacency to the Santa Fe River Greenway Trail, which accommodates both pedestrians and cyclists, supports the General Plan’s vision for expanding and improving the city’s pedestrian and bike infrastructure. The Greenway Trail connects key parts of the city, contributing to the city’s transportation and mobility policies. • Infrastructure and Public Services: The proposed amendment is consistent with the General Plan’s goals related to expanding / improving infrastructure, and public services. Although the existing mobile home park is currently served by a domestic well, redevelopment of the property will require connection to city water, ensuring that the development aligns with the city’s water infrastructure policies. The new sewer system, which will be installed to meet city standards and maintained by the city after one year, is also consistent with the General Plan’s commitment to ensuring adequate, sustainable public services and infrastructure to support growth. Janice Biletnikoff Boylan GP Amendment/Rezoning May 28, 2025 Page 4 of 6 4. Concept plans are not actionable items on the agenda. Future conceptual development (such as the undergrounding of utilities, removal of mobile homes and soil stockpiles, or the potential provision of affordable housing) cannot be considered by the Land Use staff or the decision makers in analyzing the rezoning request unless they are included in the current application as a development plan or master plan. The analysis for the rezoning is strictly limited to the proposal to change from one zone district to another. Discussion of future development plans that are not part of the current request cannot be used to respond to the Code criteria. Please only include the elements that are part of the current request. Please revise or submit the report and/or include a master plan to accompany the rezoning application. Response: The applicant/owner has contacted PNM to allow for the relocation of the PNM Power poles. Prior correspondence with land use staff indicated that relocation of the poles would be required to be relocated underground. The underground of the electric facilities is not a conceptual in nature. Mr Boylan intent is to remove the existing power pole encroachments in order to prepare the property for future development. Furthermore, Mr. Boylan along with NM Land Solutions LLC., has met with PNM to start the process, however PNM cannot design the request until a specific use has been contemplated The stockpile has been in existence for quite some time and the property owner has been working with City wastewater and Land Use Engineer to accept a permit to allow for the construction of two manholes at which point the dirt from the stockpile will be used to bury the trenches. The existing mobile home park is legal non-conforming, and the homes are older model mobile homes none of which are on permanent foundation. Once a future development permit for redevelopment is submitted, compliance with Chapter 14 will be required, which in turn will require removal of the mobile homes therefore this is not a conceptual in nature and will take place, it is the timing that is unknown. The affordable housing element has been removed from the overall report and is resubmitted with this letter since that is indeed conceptual as it is unknown whether the project will entail residential development. A Masterplan is not warranted at this time due to there being no anticipated phasing of the area once rezoning is authorized. The discussion / refences to future development were added for informational purposes only and were not intended to acquire any approvals other than the subject rezoning and general plan amendment request. 5. In Appendix D (“Warranty Deeds”), Tract D and Tract A-1 have cover sheets that state the following documents are warranty deeds; however, the deeds that follow are both quitclaim deeds. Do warranty deeds exist for these parcels? Please revise the Appendix D cover sheet as well as the Tract D and Tract A-1 cover sheets to reflect the correct type of conveyance Janice Biletnikoff Boylan GP Amendment/Rezoning May 28, 2025 Page 5 of 6 documents attached thereto. Quit Claim deeds can only be accepted in conjunction with a chain of title to prove equitable interest that existed within the transfer. Appendix D has been revised to include the correct warranty deeds. The deed for Tract A-1 and Tract D will not have matching metes and bounds as the deed and legal lot of record plat was drafted prior to the purchase of a portion of the property’s by Santa Fe County for the River Trail project. Appendix D, includes the deeds to the county which describes the current configuration of the lots. 6. Please note that rezoning requests require public notice by Certified Mail to property owners within 100 feet of the subject property. Refer to § 14-3.1(H) for details on rezoning request public notice requirements. Response: NM Land Solutions is aware of this requirement and has no issues with sending certified notices to the property adjoiners within one hundred feet of the subject property B. Initial DRT Review Summary Your Rezoning application has been reviewed by the City’s Development Review Team (DRT) and the following necessary revisions have been identified: 1. Dee Beingessner [Land Use/Terrain Management/City Engineer] – One issue identified: Soil Stockpile without a permit and appropriate sediment control is a violation of City Code and must be remedied before new plat or development can be approved; see attached DRT response letter. Response: The subject stockpile has been in existence prior to the annexation of the property into the city limits. A permit application to allow the stockpile to remain on the property has been submitted and is pending approval. The stockpile will eventually be used for future construction. 2. Leah Yngve [MPO] – No issues were identified with the General Plan amendment and Rezoning request; see attached DRT response letter. 3. Leroy Pacheco [Traffic] - No issues were identified with the General Plan amendment and Rezoning request; see attached DRT response letter. When the subject property is redeveloped, a traffic study will be required. 4. Zoe Isaacson [Parks] - No issues were identified with the General Plan amendment and Rezoning request; see attached DRT response letter. Janice Biletnikoff Boylan GP Amendment/Rezoning May 28, 2025 Page 6 of 6 5. Clinton Peterson [Water Engineering] – No issues were identified with the Rezoning request; see attached DRT response letter. Additional plan information, such as an approved Water Plan and an Agreement to Construct and Dedicate (ACD), will be required at the time of Development Plan application for any new water and fire infrastructure. This DRT reviewer also notes that each lot shall be served by separate City water service at the time of development. Regarding the existing domestic well onsite, this reviewer required that the Applicant work with CoSFW Engineering before Water Plan approval to ensure that no cross-connection occurs between the domestic well system and the public water system. Response: At the time of development, waterline plans will be submitted to the COSFW for review and further discussion of future use or transfer of existing water rights form the subject wells. 2743, 2745 BOYLAN CIRCLE AND 1372 BOYLAN LANE GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT / REZONING DEVELOMENT REPORT PREPARED FOR: MR. LARRY BOYLAN PREPARED BY: NM LAND SOLUTIONS LLC NOVEMBER 2024 (Revised 7/31/2025) TABLE OF CONTENTS Project Description & Location 2 Ownership & Legal Lot of Record 3 Existing Conditions & Adjoining Land Uses 3-4 General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Request 4-5 Access 5 Archeology 5 Utilities 5-6 Water Sewer Dry Utilities Early Neighborhood Notification (ENN) 6 Response to General Plan Amendment 6-11 Response to Criteria for Rezoning of the Property 11-14 APPENDICES Appendix A Lot 1 Legal Lot of Record Plat (2745 Boylan Circle) Appendix B Legal Lot of Record Plat E-1 & A-1 Appendix C Certificate of Compliance (Tract D) Appendix D Warranty Deeds FIGURES Figure 1: Vicinity Map 2 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report PROPERTY LOCATION AND SUMMARY DESCRIPTION There are four (4) legal lots of record associated with the request for General Plan Amendment and Rezoning. The lot fronting Agua Fria Street is located at 2745 Boylan Circle, consists of 1.08± acres and is vacant. The remaining three (3) legal lots of record encompass a legal non-conforming mobile home park addressed as 2743 Boylan Circle and 1372 Boylan Lane. 2743 Boylan Lane is assigned to two (2) lots. The total combined acreage of the four (4) subject lots equals 5.96 (±) acres. In addition, a separate lot consolidation plat to combine all four (4) lots into one (1) lot will be submitted to staff for administrative review upon approval of the proposed general plan amendment and rezoning request. Figure 1 is a vicinity map indicating the location of the subject property relative to the city street system and other known landmarks in the area. Figure 1: 3 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report OWNERSHIP AND LEGAL LOT OF RECORD The four (4) subject lots are owned by Mr. Larry Boylan. The legal lot of record for the Lot 1 (2745 Agua Fria St.) is established by a plat entitled Haile Subdivision, which was approved by the Extraterritorial Zoning Commission on February 13, 1986, and recorded in the Office of the County Clerk in Book 238 Page 12 and is located in Appendix A of this report. The legal lot of record for Tract E1 (2743 Boylan Lane) immediately north of Lot 1 and Tract A1 (1372 Boylan Lane) is established by a lot line adjustment plat prepared for the Estate of Tom and Larry Boylan administratively approved by City Land Use Planning staff, recorded in the Office of the Santa Fe County Clerk in Book 687 page 39 and is located in Appendix B of this report. The legal lot of record for remaining lot adjoining the Santa Fe County River Greenway trail is established by a certificate of compliance based on the condemnation and purchase of property by Santa Fe County for its construction and maintenance of the Santa Fe River Greenway trail. The certificate of compliance was approved by the city of Santa Fe planning staff on November 5, 2019, and recorded in the office of the County Clerk as instrument #1901539. The subject Certificate of compliance is located in Appendix C of this report. Proof of ownership warranty deeds for the subject four lots are located in Appendix D of this report. EXISTING CONDITIONS & ADJOINING LAND USES As stated, three (3) of the four (4) subject lots are encompassed by a legal non-conforming mobile home park which was developed prior to the adoption of the County Extraterritorial Zoning Ordinance and Land Development Code. The vacant tract fronting Agua Fria contains a large stockpile of dirt which will be used as fill dirt for future construction of utilities and/or roads. A permit to allow the existing dirt pile has been approved until such time as the property is redeveloped. The subject lots also contain several PNM power poles which will be removed and relocated underground at the time of future development. The lot immediately east has been rezoned to C-2 as well as development plan approval to allow for an apartment complex which has started construction. The property northwest of the mobile home park has also been rezoned to C-2 and is used as a plumbing and Heating business. The property located west is zoned R-1, which is the designation assigned to all properties without prior zoning entitlements prior to the city/county annexation. The Santa Fe County River Greenway trail is north of the existing mobile home park and consists of land that was part of a condemnation of the subject lots by Santa Fe County to allow for the restoration of the river as well as continuation of the trail. 4 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report Directly across Agua Fria Street, there is a mix of zoning designations which includes MU (Mixed Use) and I-1 (Light Industrial) zoning districts. GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT & REZONING REQUEST The future land use designation assigned to the subject lots requesting General Plan Amendment & Zoning is “Transitional Mixed-Use” while the zoning designation is R-1 (1 dwelling unit/acre). The R-1 zoning designation was assigned to the subject lots during the city/county-initiated annexation. Since the city/county annexation, there has been several approved general plan amendments and rezonings requests within the surrounding area. At this time the property owner is proposing General Plan Amendment from Transitional Mixed Use (TMXU) to Community Commercial (CCOM) and Rezoning from R-1 (1/dwelling/acre) to C-2 (General Commercial). A development plan is not proposed in conjunction with the subject request, as it has become evident with the recently approved rezonings in the area that the R-1 zoning designation is not consistent with the surrounding area. 5 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report Furthermore, the 1999 General Plan promotes higher density development in urban infill properties which includes the greater Agua Fria area. Once a determination has been made on how the property will be redeveloped, the existing legal non-conforming mobile home park will be removed. The owner / applicant anticipates a future multifamily development, possibly a small-scale apartment complex to replace the current mobile home park, as Mr. Boylan is aware of the need to provide housing for the community. The property fronting Agua Fria Street would seem more appropriate to develop small-scale stand- alone retail / commercial use(s) that can be enjoyed by the new residents of the area. ACCESS Access to the subject lots is off of Boylan Circle via Agua Fria Street. Boylan Circle is a dirt road with an approximate width of twenty (20’) feet. Within the past several years, the City has completed street improvements and widening of Agua Fria adjacent to the subject property including upgrades to the Agua Fria and Siler Road intersection. Once the property is redeveloped, the existing access will be required to be upgraded to city standards based off the traffic / use of any future development. ARCHAEOLOGY The consolidated acreage of the subject lots is over 2.00-acres in size and is within the River and Trails Archaeological Review District, which requires an archaeological clearance at the time of development plan or final plat. Since there is not a development plan or plat associated with the request, an archaeological clearance is not required at this time. WATER & WASTEWATER Water The existing mobile home park is served by two on-site domestic well. There is a 12-inch waterline in Agua Fria Street that would need to be extended into the subject lots at the time of redevelopment of the property. Utilization and/or transfer of water rights associated with the well will be determined upon redevelopment of the property as a future connection to City water will be required at the time of new development. 6 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report Sewer The existing mobile home park is served by a private 8-inch sewer line that connects to the city trunk line across the Santa Fe River which eventually flows into the city wastewater treatment plant. At the time of redevelopment of the property, a new sewer line will be designed and constructed to city standards at which time the sewer line will be dedicated to the city for public use. Dry Utilities Electric, telephone and gas are available to this property with adequate capacity to serve future development. EARLY NEIGHBORHOOD NOTIFICATION (ENN) An ENN meeting was held on September 26th, 2024, with city staff, along with the property owner, and agent NM Land Solutions LLC were present. In addition, an unidentified participant that was having technical difficulties later called via phone to inquire about process and other unrelated questions regarding his prior approved rezoning located at 2749 B Agua Fria St. Also, a phone call was received prior to the ENN meeting from a property Adjoiner that was in favor of the project and agreed that obtaining general plan amendment and rezoning seemed like the proper path forward for the lots in question. RESPONSE TO GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT (1) Criteria for All Amendments to the General Plan The planning commission and the governing body shall review all general plan amendment proposals on the basis of the following criteria, and shall make complete findings of fact sufficient to show that these criteria have been met before recommending or approving any amendment to the general plan : (a) consistency with growth projections for Santa Fe, economic development goals as set forth in a comprehensive economic development plan for Santa Fe and existing land use conditions such as access and availability of infrastructure ; Response: Santa Fe is currently experiencing a steady growth rate of 0.54% annually, with the population having increased by 2.19%. The proposed general plan amendment to community commercial zoning will allow for a mix of commercial and high-density residential uses, providing flexibility in development without the rigid residential-to-commercial ratio specified in the transitional mixed-use future land use designation. This flexibility supports the City's economic development goals by allowing for both affordable housing options and commercial development that complements surrounding uses. 7 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report Higher-density residential development will contribute to the availability of affordable housing through the City of Santa Fe Affordable Housing Program, addressing the ongoing need for affordable units. This development approach also supports the local economy by facilitating the potential for employment opportunities tied to the proposed commercial uses. The amendment is consistent with the guiding policies within Chapter 4 of the 1999 General Plan, specifically regarding the promotion of infill development, efficient use of existing infrastructure, and recognition of water demand and conservation. By aligning with these policies, the amendment contributes to the balanced growth of Santa Fe, promoting both residential development and new employment opportunities in a sustainable manner. Additionally, the proposal is designed with consideration of existing land use conditions, including the availability of access and infrastructure, ensuring that development occurs in a manner that makes efficient use of resources while accommodating future growth. (b) consistency with other parts of the general plan ; Response: The proposed General Plan Amendment is consistent with several key elements of the Santa Fe General Plan, particularly those related to housing, economic development, transportation, and infrastructure. • Job Creation and Economic Development: The proposed amendment facilitates the creation of both construction-related jobs and long-term employment opportunities through the development of commercial spaces. This is consistent with the General Plan’s economic development objectives, which emphasize creating jobs and promoting balanced economic growth within the city. • Transportation and Mobility: The proposed development also aligns with the General Plan’s transportation goals by enhancing connectivity and providing alternative transportation options. The property’s adjacency to the Santa Fe River Greenway Trail, which accommodates both pedestrians and cyclists, supports the General Plan’s vision for expanding and improving the city’s pedestrian and bike infrastructure. The Greenway Trail connects key parts of the city, contributing to the city’s transportation and mobility policies. • Infrastructure and Public Services: The proposed amendment is consistent with the General Plan’s goals related to infrastructure and public services. Although the existing mobile home park is currently served by a domestic well, redevelopment of the property will require connection to city water, ensuring that the development aligns with the city’s water infrastructure policies. The new sewer system, which will be installed to meet city standards and maintained by the city after one year, is also consistent with the General Plan’s commitment to ensuring adequate, sustainable public services and infrastructure to support growth. 8 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report (c) the amendment does not: (i) allow uses or a change that is significantly different from or inconsistent with the prevailing use and character in the area; or Response: The proposed amendment does not introduce uses or changes that are significantly different from or inconsistent with the prevailing use and character of the surrounding area. Over time, particularly following the city/county annexation, the area has undergone significant changes, allowing for the development of infill properties with access to city utilities. Many of the surrounding properties have been rezoned within the past fifteen years to accommodate higher- density residential uses, including multifamily apartment buildings, reflecting the city's growth and evolving urban landscape. Currently, the area includes a mix of residential and commercial uses. Some commercial properties are legal non-conforming, while others were established through previous general plan amendments and rezonings. The proposed general plan amendment is consistent with this pattern of development, as it allows for a combination of residential and commercial uses that align with the existing mix of land uses in the area. The amendment would further complement the surrounding developments by providing additional opportunities for both residential and commercial growth, without significantly altering the established character of the neighborhood. Thus, the amendment is in keeping with the area's ongoing transition and growth, and it aligns with the existing mix of residential and commercial uses that have developed over time. The proposed change is not a dramatic departure from the current land use pattern but rather a continuation of the evolving character of the area. (ii) affect an area of less than two acres, except when adjusting boundaries between districts; or Response: There are four adjoining legal lots of record with a total of 5.96 acres. (iii) benefit one or a few landowners at the expense of the surrounding landowners or the general public; Response: The proposed amendment will provide benefits not only to the applicant but also to the surrounding landowners and the broader community. The property in question is currently occupied by an aging mobile home park that has been in place for over forty years, predating the County Code established prior to being annexed into the City of Santa Fe. This property is in need of redevelopment to address current deficiencies and enhance the area’s overall character. The existing site is encumbered by several electric power poles and a large stockpile of dirt along the Agua Fria Street frontage, both of which negatively impact the aesthetics and functionality of the area. The proposed amendment will facilitate a sustainable and diverse redevelopment that connects the property to city utilities, addressing key infrastructure challenges. Specifically, the redevelopment will allow for the relocation and undergrounding of electric services, improving both the visual appeal and safety of the area. 9 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report These infrastructure improvements will directly benefit the surrounding landowners by reducing existing eyesores and enhancing the overall neighborhood environment. Additionally, by redeveloping the site, the amendment creates the potential for a more vibrant and well-integrated community with better access to essential services. The redevelopment is designed to integrate seamlessly with surrounding properties, offering opportunities for both residential and commercial growth that will benefit the area as a whole, not just a select few. This approach ensures that the amendment does not disproportionately benefit one landowner at the expense of others but instead supports the broader public interest by improving infrastructure, enhancing the built environment, and contributing to the neighborhood’s long-term sustainability and growth. (c) an amendment is not required to conform with Subsection 14-3.2(E)(1)(c) if it promotes the general welfare or has other adequate public advantage or justification. Response: The proposed amendment is in conformance with Subsection 14-3.2(E)(1)(c) as stated in the above responses (c) i,ii,iii. (d) compliance with extraterritorial zoning ordinances and extraterritorial plans; Response: This criterion is no longer relevant since the adoption of Subdivision Platting and Planning Zoning Ordinance (SPPaZO), and the relinquishment of the land use regulatory authority outside the city limits and the transfer of authority from extraterritorial jurisdiction to the City. (e) contribution to a coordinated, adjusted and harmonious development of Santa Fe that in accordance with existing and future needs best promotes health, safety, morals, order, convenience, prosperity or the general welfare, as well as efficiency and economy in the process of development ; and Response: The proposed amendment will contribute to the coordinated, harmonious development of Santa Fe by addressing both current and future needs, and it will promote the health, safety, and general welfare of the community. The existing mobile home park, currently designated as transitional mixed-use, does not comply with the current land use regulations and is limited in its ability to undergo meaningful upgrades or redevelopment due to its non-conforming status. This limitation restricts opportunities for investment, which in turn can lead to deterioration and neglect of the site. By encouraging the redevelopment of this property, the amendment will not only provide an opportunity to modernize the site but also help prevent blight and disrepair, thereby improving the overall quality of life for residents and the surrounding community. Redevelopment will ensure that the site is brought into compliance with modern land use standards, improving both the physical and environmental aspects of the area. These improvements will enhance public safety, aesthetics, and infrastructure, contributing to the general welfare of the neighborhood. 10 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report The amendment also aligns with the City of Santa Fe’s long-term growth goals by supporting infill development and more efficient use of land. The proposed redevelopment is consistent with the city’s vision of creating sustainable, vibrant, and diverse neighborhoods that meet the needs of both current and future residents. By facilitating development that connects to city utilities and enhances the surrounding infrastructure, the amendment helps promote efficiency and economy in the development process, aligning with the city’s broader planning objectives for growth and sustainability. In summary, the proposed amendment will foster a coordinated and harmonious development that supports Santa Fe’s growth objectives, improves public health and safety, and contributes to the economic and social well-being of the community. (f) consideration of conformity with other city policies, including land use policies, ordinances, regulations and plans. Response: The City has a policy of promoting a mix of land uses, this property is located within an area where there is a mix of residential, retail and entertainment. The recent changes to the City code now permit residential uses within a C-2 commercial district. (2) Additional Criteria for Amendments to Land Use Policies In addition to complying with the general criteria set forth in Subsection 14-3.2(E)(1), amendments to the land use policies section of the general plan shall be made only if evidence shows that the effect of the proposed change in land use shown on the future land use map of the general plan will not have a negative impact on the surrounding properties . The proposed change in land use must be related to the character of the surrounding area or a provision must be made to separate the proposed change in use from adjacent properties by a setback , landscaping or other means, and a finding must be made that: (a) the growth and economic projections contained within the general plan are erroneous or have changed; Response: When the existing General Plan was adopted in 1999 it seems that the General Plan failed to recognize the land use complexity of this part of the urban area. It is not a matter of the growth and economic projections being in error as it is the failure to observe the variety of existing land uses and assign a zoning district that best fit those land uses. Land use patterns in this area have changed over time especially with the city/county annexation recognizing infill development that can provide greater housing densities and or a variety of commercial uses that are consistent with the current land use patterns. 11 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report (b) no reasonable locations have been provided for certain land uses for which there is a demonstrated need; or Response: There are other locations in Santa Fe where general commercial is available, however the current zoning does not allow for the existing residential density associated with the existing mobile home park. The intent of the property owner is to maintain a higher density residential component while having an option to develop both commercial and residential uses on the subject lot. (c) conditions affecting the location or land area requirements of the proposed land use have changed, for example, the cost of land space requirements, consumer acceptance, market or building technology. Response: While the City continues to recognize the existing mobile home park as a legal non- conforming use, this grandfathered status is contingent upon no substantial improvements, expansion, or damage beyond repair. Should such circumstances arise, the property would revert to its R-1 zoning with a transitional mixed-use land use designation, which allows for only one (1) dwelling unit per acre, a density that no longer aligns with the area’s evolving development patterns. Over the past fifteen years, since the annexation of this property into the city, significant changes in land use patterns and zoning have occurred. The recent rezonings in the area, which have permitted higher-density multifamily residential and commercial uses, have notably increased the cost of land and shifted the market dynamics. These changes have rendered the existing mobile home park site less viable for long-term use under its current configuration, especially as surrounding properties have transitioned to more intensive uses. Additionally, advances in building technology and changes in consumer preferences have further driven demand for higher-density housing and more diverse land uses. The costs associated with maintaining the existing mobile home park, particularly given the high land value in this growing area, make it increasingly difficult to sustain its non-conforming use. Redeveloping the property in accordance with the proposed general plan amendment will not only accommodate the evolving market but also provide a more efficient and sustainable use of the land, aligning with the city’s current zoning and development goals. This amendment is therefore a response to the changing land use patterns, market conditions, and technological advancements that have altered the feasibility of the existing mobile home park and support the need for a more appropriate and compatible development for this location. 12 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report RESPONSE TO REZONING APPROVAL CRITERIA The planning commission and the governing body shall review all rezoning proposals on the basis of the criteria provided in this section, and the reviewing entities must make complete findings of fact sufficient to show that these criteria have been met before recommending or approving any rezoning: (a) one or more of the following conditions exist: (i) there was a mistake in the original zoning. Response: Since the Annexation of this property, the City has used R-1 zoning designation for annexed areas where it serves as a holding zone until another use is proposed for the land. R-1 is the lowest density zoning district designated in the Land Development Code and the designation of this district is inconsistent with the policies of the General Plan. (ii) there has been a change in the surrounding area, altering the character of the neighborhood to such an extent as to justify changing the zoning; or Response: With the city/county annexation that occurred approximately fifteen years ago, the surrounding area has changed significantly where there have been at least four rezoning approvals which includes nine tracts of land all within less than 1,000 feet of the subject property(s) that have been redeveloped as mostly apartments. Prior to the city annexing the area north of Agua Fria Road there was little development activity. With the City commitment of utilities and provision of City services, this area is now experiencing requests for development or re-development. (iii) a different use category is more advantageous to the community, as articulated in the general plan or other adopted city plans; Response: The City General Plan shows this property and other properties between Agua Fria and the Santa Fe River as “Community Commercial or Transitional Mixed Use”. The predominate land use for this area is a mix of commercial and single family and rental housing. From the time that this area was brought into the “Presumptive City Limits” and zoned R-1, single family residential, one (1) dwelling per acre, many of the existing uses have become non- conforming. The landowners are now limited in the expansion of the existing structures on the property and given the inconsistency between the zoning and the actual land use it would be more advantageous to recognize the existing land use pattern for the area. It does not make planning sense to create non-conformity out of 70 to 80 percent (70% - 80%) of the ownership in the vicinity of this request. Such non-conformities discourages investment in the property and can lead to inconsistent development in the subject area. (b) all the rezoning requirements of Chapter 14 have been met; Response: Currently the existing zoning is R-1, Single Family Residential, one dwelling per acre, which creates a non-conforming status for this property. Rezoning of the property to C-2 uses 13 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report would bring this property into conformance with the historic uses that have taken place on this property. (c) the rezoning is consistent with the applicable policies of the general plan, including the future land use map; Response: Rezoning to C-2 (General Commercial) is consistent with the policies of the general plan as it aims to recognize the development of infill properties where city infrastructure is available furthermore rezoning of the property is consistent with the transitional mixed-use designation in that it offers the property the ability to development both a mix of residential and commercial uses. (d) the amount of land proposed for rezoning and the proposed use for the land is consistent with city policies regarding the provision of urban land sufficient to meet the amount, rate and geographic location of the growth of the city; and Response: There are four (4) adjoining legal lots of record with a combined total of 5.96 acres which will be consolidated upon approval of the rezoning request. The proposed C-2 use for the land is consistent with city policies as it continues to recognize development of infill property and is consistent with the current land use patterns that have developed for a mix of uses from commercial to medium to high density residential. (e) the existing and proposed infrastructure , such as the streets system, sewer and water lines, and public facilities, such as fire stations and parks, will be able to accommodate the impacts of the proposed development . Response: Public utilities are available on Agua Fria, including water, gas and electric lines, cable and telephone lines. The City has completed street improvements and widening of Agua Fria adjacent to the subject property including upgrades to the Agua Fria and Siler Road intersection. Siler Road has been completed from Agua Fria to West Alameda providing alternative routes to Agua Fria. In fact, the traffic volumes on Agua Fria have declined with the extension of Siler to West Alameda. the Santa Fe River Greenway trail which can accommodate both pedestrian and bicyclist. The Santa Fe River Greenway pedestrian and bicycle trail has recently been completed and is located north of the subject parcels, The closest Fire Station to this site is located on Cerrillos Road near Third Street within a five- minute service radius to this property. (2) Unless the proposed change is consistent with applicable general plan policies, the planning commission and the governing body shall not recommend or approve any rezoning, the practical effect of which is to: (a) allow uses or a change in character significantly different from or inconsistent with the prevailing use and character in the area; 14 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report Response: The proposed C-2 zoning request, the character of the neighborhood will remain unchanged from the current mixed use and high-density multi-family residential that has been approved within the past fifteen (15) years with the annexation area of the subject property(s). (b) affect an area of less than two acres, unless adjusting boundaries between districts; or Response: The combined total of acreage included with the request consist of 5.96 acres, additionally the subject property immediately adjoins a tract of land that was approved to be rezoned in 2014, and was officially adopted via Ordinance 2014-32 (c) benefit one or a few landowners at the expense of the surrounding Response: The proposed amendment will benefit the surrounding landowners as the property is in need of redevelopment. The existing mobile home park has been in existence for over forty (40) years prior to the County Code taking effect. The property fronting Agua Fria Street is encroached by several electric power poles as well as a large stockpile of dirt. The amendment will allow for a sustainable and diverse development with connection to city utilities, relocating and undergrounding electric services. APPENDIX A LOT 1 (2745 AGUA FRIA) LEGAL LOT OF RECORD PLAT APPENDIX B TRACT E 1 (2743 AGUA FRIA) & A-1 (1372 BOYLAN LN.) LEGAL LOT OF RECORD PLAT APPENDIX C TRACT D CERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE APPENDIX D WARRANTY DEEDS LOT 1 (2745 BOYLAN LN.) WARRANTY DEED TRACT E-1 (2743 BOYLAN CIR.) WARRANTY DEED TRACT D (2743 BOYLAN CIR) WARRANTY DEED TRACT A-1 WARRANTY DEED 2743, 2745 BOYLAN CIRCLE AND 1372 BOYLAN LANE GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT / REZONING DEVELOMENT REPORT PREPARED FOR: MR. LARRY BOYLAN PREPARED BY: NM LAND SOLUTIONS LLC NOVEMBER 2024 (Revised 8/8/2025) TABLE OF CONTENTS Project Description & Location 2 Ownership & Legal Lot of Record 3 Existing Conditions & Adjoining Land Uses 3-4 General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Request 4-5 Access 5 Archeology 5 Utilities 5-6 Water Sewer Dry Utilities Early Neighborhood Notification (ENN) 6 Response to General Plan Amendment 6-12 Response to Criteria for Rezoning of the Property 12-14 APPENDICES Appendix A Lot 1 Legal Lot of Record Plat (2745 Boylan Circle) Appendix B Legal Lot of Record Plat E-1 & A-1 Appendix C Certificate of Compliance (Tract D) Appendix D Warranty Deeds FIGURES Figure 1: Vicinity Map 2 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report PROPERTY LOCATION AND SUMMARY DESCRIPTION There are four (4) legal lots of record associated with the request for General Plan Amendment and Rezoning. The lot fronting Agua Fria Street is located at 2745 Boylan Circle, consists of 1.08± acres and is vacant. The remaining three (3) legal lots of record encompass a legal non-conforming mobile home park addressed as 2743 Boylan Circle and 1372 Boylan Lane. 2743 Boylan Lane is assigned to two (2) lots. The total combined acreage of the four (4) subject lots equals 5.96 (±) acres. In addition, a separate lot consolidation plat to combine all four (4) lots into one (1) lot will be submitted to staff for administrative review upon approval of the proposed general plan amendment and rezoning request. Figure 1 is a vicinity map indicating the location of the subject property relative to the city street system and other known landmarks in the area. Figure 1: 3 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report OWNERSHIP AND LEGAL LOT OF RECORD The four (4) subject lots are owned by Mr. Larry Boylan. The legal lot of record for the Lot 1 (2745 Agua Fria St.) is established by a plat entitled Haile Subdivision, which was approved by the Extraterritorial Zoning Commission on February 13, 1986, and recorded in the Office of the County Clerk in Book 238 Page 12 and is located in Appendix A of this report. The legal lot of record for Tract E1 (2743 Boylan Lane) immediately north of Lot 1 and Tract A1 (1372 Boylan Lane) is established by a lot line adjustment plat prepared for the Estate of Tom and Larry Boylan administratively approved by City Land Use Planning staff, recorded in the Office of the Santa Fe County Clerk in Book 687 page 39 and is located in Appendix B of this report. The legal lot of record for remaining lot adjoining the Santa Fe County River Greenway trail is established by a certificate of compliance based on the condemnation and purchase of property by Santa Fe County for its construction and maintenance of the Santa Fe River Greenway trail. The certificate of compliance was approved by the city of Santa Fe planning staff on November 5, 2019, and recorded in the office of the County Clerk as instrument #1901539. The subject Certificate of compliance is located in Appendix C of this report. Proof of ownership warranty deeds for the subject four lots are located in Appendix D of this report. EXISTING CONDITIONS & ADJOINING LAND USES As stated, three (3) of the four (4) subject lots are encompassed by a legal non-conforming mobile home park which was developed prior to the adoption of the County Extraterritorial Zoning Ordinance and Land Development Code. The vacant tract fronting Agua Fria contains a large stockpile of dirt which will be used as fill dirt for future construction of utilities and/or roads. A permit to allow the existing dirt pile has been approved until such time as the property is redeveloped. The subject lots also contain several PNM power poles which will be removed and relocated underground at the time of future development. The lot immediately east has been rezoned to C-2 as well as development plan approval to allow for an apartment complex which has started construction. The property northwest of the mobile home park has also been rezoned to C-2 and is used as a plumbing and Heating business. The property located west is zoned R-1, which is the designation assigned to all properties without prior zoning entitlements prior to the city/county annexation. The Santa Fe County River Greenway trail is north of the existing mobile home park and consists of land that was part of a condemnation of the subject lots by Santa Fe County to allow for the restoration of the river as well as continuation of the trail. 4 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report Directly across Agua Fria Street, there is a mix of zoning designations which includes MU (Mixed Use) and I-1 (Light Industrial) zoning districts. GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT & REZONING REQUEST The future land use designation assigned to the subject lots requesting General Plan Amendment & Zoning is “Transitional Mixed-Use” while the zoning designation is R-1 (1 dwelling unit/acre). The R-1 zoning designation was assigned to the subject lots during the city/county-initiated annexation. Since the city/county annexation, there has been several approved general plan amendments and rezonings requests within the surrounding area. At this time the property owner is proposing General Plan Amendment from Transitional Mixed Use (TMXU) to Community Commercial (CCOM) and Rezoning from R-1 (1/dwelling/acre) to C-2 (General Commercial). A development plan is not proposed in conjunction with the subject request, as it has become evident with the recently approved rezonings in the area that the R-1 zoning designation is not consistent with the surrounding area. 5 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report Furthermore, the 1999 General Plan promotes higher density development in urban infill properties which includes the greater Agua Fria area. Once a determination has been made on how the property will be redeveloped, the existing legal non-conforming mobile home park will be removed. The owner / applicant anticipates a future multifamily development, possibly a small-scale apartment complex to replace the current mobile home park, as Mr. Boylan is aware of the need to provide housing for the community. The property fronting Agua Fria Street would seem more appropriate to develop small-scale stand- alone retail / commercial use(s) that can be enjoyed by the new residents of the area. ACCESS Access to the subject lots is off of Boylan Circle via Agua Fria Street. Boylan Circle is a dirt road with an approximate width of twenty (20’) feet. Within the past several years, the City has completed street improvements and widening of Agua Fria adjacent to the subject property including upgrades to the Agua Fria and Siler Road intersection. Once the property is redeveloped, the existing access will be required to be upgraded to city standards based off the traffic / use of any future development. ARCHAEOLOGY The consolidated acreage of the subject lots is over 2.00-acres in size and is within the River and Trails Archaeological Review District, which requires an archaeological clearance at the time of development plan or final plat. Since there is not a development plan or plat associated with the request, an archaeological clearance is not required at this time. WATER & WASTEWATER Water The existing mobile home park is served by two on-site domestic well. There is a 12-inch waterline in Agua Fria Street that would need to be extended into the subject lots at the time of redevelopment of the property. Utilization and/or transfer of water rights associated with the well will be determined upon redevelopment of the property as a future connection to City water will be required at the time of new development. 6 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report Sewer The existing mobile home park is served by a private 8-inch sewer line that connects to the city trunk line across the Santa Fe River which eventually flows into the city wastewater treatment plant. At the time of redevelopment of the property, a new sewer line will be designed and constructed to city standards at which time the sewer line will be dedicated to the city for public use. Dry Utilities Electric, telephone and gas are available to this property with adequate capacity to serve future development. EARLY NEIGHBORHOOD NOTIFICATION (ENN) An ENN meeting was held on September 26th, 2024, with city staff, along with the property owner, and agent NM Land Solutions LLC were present. In addition, an unidentified participant that was having technical difficulties later called via phone to inquire about process and other unrelated questions regarding his prior approved rezoning located at 2749 B Agua Fria St. Also, a phone call was received prior to the ENN meeting from a property Adjoiner that was in favor of the project and agreed that obtaining general plan amendment and rezoning seemed like the proper path forward for the lots in question. RESPONSE TO GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT (1) Criteria for All Amendments to the General Plan The planning commission and the governing body shall review all general plan amendment proposals on the basis of the following criteria, and shall make complete findings of fact sufficient to show that these criteria have been met before recommending or approving any amendment to the general plan : (a) consistency with growth projections for Santa Fe, economic development goals as set forth in a comprehensive economic development plan for Santa Fe and existing land use conditions such as access and availability of infrastructure ; Response: The proposed General Plan Amendment is consistent with Chapter 3-1 of the Land Use Themes as provided below: • Quality of Life: The proposed General Plan Amendment has the potential to enhance the quality of life at the time the property is redeveloped from the existing non-conforming mobile home park that was established prior to the 1981 adoption of the Santa Fe County Code. 7 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report • Economic Diversity: The proposed amendment facilitates the creation of both construction-related jobs and long-term employment opportunities through the development of commercial uses. This is consistent with the General Plan’s economic development objectives, which emphasize creating jobs and promoting balanced economic growth within the city. • Sustainable Growth: The existing homes on the property are served by two private wells along with a private sewer line which is connected to the trunk line located north of the property across the Santa Fe River and eventually flows into the city’s system. As with the non-conforming mobile home park, the two water wells that are currently feeding the existing homes is not sustainable. Redevelopment will require capping of the two wells allowing the diversion of ground water in the amount of a total of 6.0 afy of water per year. Capping of the wells directly conserves groundwater, which is a natural resource and has been severely depleted over time by the existing drought. Connection the city’s water system will also require an approved water budget that will assist on restriction of water along with collection of revenue by the city for use of water. The existing private sewer line was installed over 40 years ago and will need to be adequately sized and upgraded to city standards for future dedication to the City to ensure proper construction and maintenance. • Mixed Use: Santa Fe is currently experiencing a steady growth rate of 0.54% annually, with the population having increased by 2.19%. The proposed general plan amendment from Low Density Residential to Community Commercial zoning will allow for a mix of commercial and or high-density residential uses which is consistent with the mix of uses established in this area after the City/County annexation occurred in 2009. The proposed General Plan Amendment allows flexibility to re-develop the property consistent with the area by providing the ability to establish a range of permitted uses without the rigid residential-to-commercial ratio specified in the transitional mixed-use future land use designation flexibility supports the City's economic development goals. • Transportation and Mobility: The proposed development also aligns with the General Plan’s transportation goals by enhancing connectivity and providing alternative transportation options. The property’s adjacency to the Santa Fe River Greenway Trail, which accommodates both pedestrians and cyclists, supports the General Plan’s vision for expanding and improving the city’s pedestrian and bike infrastructure. The Greenway Trail connects key parts of the city, contributing to the city’s transportation and mobility policies. • Infrastructure and Public Services: The proposed amendment is consistent with the General Plan’s goals related to infrastructure and public services. Although the existing mobile home park is currently served by a domestic well, redevelopment of the property will require connection to city water, ensuring that the development aligns with the city’s water infrastructure policies. The new sewer system, which will be installed to meet city standards and maintained by the city after one year, is also consistent with the General Plan’s commitment to ensuring adequate, sustainable public services and infrastructure to support growth. 8 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report The amendment is also consistent with the guiding policies within Chapter 4 of the 1999 General Plan, specifically regarding the promotion of infill development, efficient use of existing infrastructure, and recognition of water demand and conservation. By aligning with these policies, the amendment contributes to the balanced growth of Santa Fe, promoting both residential development and new employment opportunities in a sustainable manner. Additionally, the proposal is consistent with the existing land use conditions, including the availability of access and infrastructure. (b) consistency with other parts of the general plan ; Response: The proposed General Plan Amendment is consistent with several key elements of the Santa Fe General Plan, Specifically the Guiding policy described in Chapter 3 of the 1999 General Plan and provided below: Guiding Policy 3-G-3 States “There shall be infill development at densities that support the construction of affordable housing and designated mix of land uses that provide an adequate balance service retail and employment opportunities to address residential growth throughout the Urban Area, including the Railyard property” The subject property is considered as infill located within the Urban Area as describe in the 1999 General Plan and has the potential to redevelop at higher residential densities and or other commercial uses that could create employment opportunities. (c) the amendment does not: (i) allow uses or a change that is significantly different from or inconsistent with the prevailing use and character in the area; or Response: The proposed amendment does not introduce uses or changes that are significantly different from or inconsistent with the prevailing use and character of the surrounding area. Over time, particularly following the city/county annexation, the area has undergone significant changes ,allowing for the future redevelopment of infill properties with access to city utilities as well access to sufficient city maintained roadways. Many of the surrounding properties have been rezoned within the past fifteen years to accommodate higher-density residential uses, including multifamily apartment buildings, reflecting the city's growth and evolving urban landscape. Currently, the area includes a mix of residential and commercial uses. Some commercial properties are legal non-conforming, while others were established through previous general plan amendments and rezonings. 9 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report The proposed general plan amendment is consistent with this pattern of development, as it allows for a combination of residential and commercial uses that align with the existing mix of land uses in the area. The amendment would further complement the surrounding propeties by providing additional opportunities for both residential and commercial growth, without significantly altering the established character of the neighborhood. Thus, the amendment is in keeping with the area's ongoing transition and growth, and it aligns with the existing mix of residential and commercial uses that have developed over time. The proposed change is not a dramatic departure from the current land use pattern but rather a continuation of the evolving character of the area. (ii) affect an area of less than two acres, except when adjusting boundaries between districts; or Response: There are four adjoining legal lots of record with a total of 5.96 acres. (iii) benefit one or a few landowners at the expense of the surrounding landowners or the general public; Response: The proposed amendment will provide benefits not only to the applicant but also to the surrounding landowners and the broader community. The property in question is currently occupied by an aging mobile home park that has been in place for over forty years, predating the Santa Fe County Code and prior to being annexed into the City of Santa Fe. This property is in need of redevelopment to address current deficiencies and enhance the area’s overall character. The existing site is encumbered by several electric power poles and a large stockpile of dirt along the Agua Fria Street frontage, both of which negatively impact the aesthetics and functionality of the area. The proposed amendment will facilitate a sustainable and diverse redevelopment that connects the property to city utilities, addressing key infrastructure challenges. Specifically, the redevelopment will allow for the relocation and undergrounding of electric services, improving both the visual appeal and safety of the area. These infrastructure improvements will directly benefit the surrounding landowners by reducing existing eyesores and enhancing the overall neighborhood environment. Additionally, by redeveloping the site, the amendment creates the potential for a more vibrant and well-integrated community with better access to essential services. The redevelopment is designed to integrate seamlessly with surrounding properties, offering opportunities for both residential and commercial growth that will benefit the area as a whole, not just a select few. This approach ensures that the amendment does not disproportionately benefit one landowner at the expense of others but instead supports the broader public interest by improving infrastructure, enhancing the built environment, and contributing to the neighborhood’s long-term sustainability and growth. (c) an amendment is not required to conform with Subsection 14-3.2(E)(1)(c) if it promotes the general welfare or has other adequate public advantage or justification. 10 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report Response: The proposed amendment is in conformance with Subsection 14-3.2(E)(1)(c) as stated in the above responses (c) i,ii,iii. (d) compliance with extraterritorial zoning ordinances and extraterritorial plans; Response: This criterion is no longer relevant since the adoption of Subdivision Platting and Planning Zoning Ordinance (SPPaZO), and the relinquishment of the land use regulatory authority outside the city limits and the transfer of authority from extraterritorial jurisdiction to the City. (e) contribution to a coordinated, adjusted and harmonious development of Santa Fe that in accordance with existing and future needs best promotes health, safety, morals, order, convenience, prosperity or the general welfare, as well as efficiency and economy in the process of development ; and Response: The proposed amendment will contribute to the coordinated, harmonious development of Santa Fe by addressing both current and future needs, and it will promote health, safety, and general welfare of the community. The existing mobile home park, currently designated as transitional mixed-use, does not comply with the current land use regulations and is limited in its ability to undergo meaningful upgrades or redevelopment due to its non-conforming status. This limitation restricts opportunities for investment, which in turn can lead to deterioration and neglect of the site. By encouraging the redevelopment of this property, the amendment will not only provide an opportunity to modernize the site but also help prevent blight and disrepair, thereby improving the overall quality of life for residents and the surrounding community. Redevelopment will ensure that the site is brought into compliance with modern land use standards, improving both the physical and environmental aspects of the area. These improvements will enhance public safety, aesthetics, and infrastructure, contributing to the general welfare of the neighborhood. The amendment also aligns with the City of Santa Fe’s long-term growth goals by supporting infill development and more efficient use of land. The proposed redevelopment is consistent with the city’s vision of creating sustainable, vibrant, and diverse neighborhoods that meet the needs of both current and future residents. By facilitating development that connects to city utilities and enhances the surrounding infrastructure, the amendment helps promote efficiency and economy in the development process, aligning with the city’s broader planning objectives for growth and sustainability. In summary, the proposed amendment will foster a coordinated and harmonious development that supports Santa Fe’s growth objectives, improves public health and safety, and contributes to the economic and social well-being of the community. (f) consideration of conformity with other city policies, including land use policies, ordinances, regulations and plans. 11 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report Response: The City has a policy of promoting a mix of land uses, this property is located within an area where there is a mix of residential, retail and entertainment. The recent changes to the City code now permit residential uses within a C-2 commercial district. (2) Additional Criteria for Amendments to Land Use Policies In addition to complying with the general criteria set forth in Subsection 14-3.2(E)(1), amendments to the land use policies section of the general plan shall be made only if evidence shows that the effect of the proposed change in land use shown on the future land use map of the general plan will not have a negative impact on the surrounding properties . The proposed change in land use must be related to the character of the surrounding area or a provision must be made to separate the proposed change in use from adjacent properties by a setback , landscaping or other means, and a finding must be made that: (a) the growth and economic projections contained within the general plan are erroneous or have changed; Response: When the existing General Plan was adopted in 1999, it failed to recognize the complexity of land use of this part of the urban area. It is not a matter of the growth and economic projections being is an error as it is the failure to observe the diversity of existing land uses and assign a zoning district that best fit those land uses. Land use patterns in this area have changed over time especially with the city/county annexation recognizing infill development that can provide greater housing densities and a variety of commercial uses that are consistent with the current land use patterns. (b) no reasonable locations have been provided for certain land uses for which there is a demonstrated need; or Response: There are other locations in Santa Fe where general commercial is available, however the current zoning does not allow for the existing residential density associated with the existing mobile home park. The intent of the property owner is to redevelop the property with more options that will maintain a higher density residential component while having an option to develop both commercial and residential uses on the subject lot. (c) conditions affecting the location or land area requirements of the proposed land use have changed, for example, the cost of land space requirements, consumer acceptance, market or building technology. Response: While the City continues to recognize the existing mobile home park as a legal non- conforming use, this grandfathered status is contingent upon no substantial improvements, expansion, or damage beyond repair. Should such circumstances arise, the property would revert to its R-1 zoning with a transitional mixed-use land use designation, which allows for only one (1) dwelling unit per acre, a density that no longer aligns with the area’s evolving development patterns. 12 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report Over the past fifteen years, since the annexation of this property into the city, significant changes in land use patterns and zoning have occurred. The recent rezonings in the area, which have permitted higher-density multifamily residential and commercial uses, have notably increased the cost of land and shifted the market dynamics. These changes have rendered the existing mobile home park site less viable for long-term use under its current configuration, especially as surrounding properties have transitioned to more intensive uses. Additionally, advances in building technology and changes in consumer preferences have further driven demand for higher-density housing and more diverse land uses. The costs associated with maintaining the existing mobile home park, particularly given the high land value in this growing area, make it increasingly difficult to sustain its non-conforming use. Redeveloping the property in accordance with the proposed general plan amendment will not only accommodate the evolving market but also provide a more efficient and sustainable use of the land, aligning with the city’s current zoning and development goals. This amendment is therefore a response to the changing land use patterns, market conditions, and technological advancements that have altered the feasibility of the existing mobile home park and support the need for a more appropriate and compatible development for this location. RESPONSE TO REZONING APPROVAL CRITERIA The planning commission and the governing body shall review all rezoning proposals on the basis of the criteria provided in this section, and the reviewing entities must make complete findings of fact sufficient to show that these criteria have been met before recommending or approving any rezoning: (a) one or more of the following conditions exist: (i) there was a mistake in the original zoning. Response: Since the Annexation of this property, the City has used R-1 zoning designation for annexed areas where it serves as a holding zone until another use is proposed for the land. R-1 is the lowest density zoning district designated in the Land Development Code and is inconsistent with the existing future land use designation of transitional mixed use. (ii) there has been a change in the surrounding area, altering the character of the neighborhood to such an extent as to justify changing the zoning; or Response: With the city/county annexation that occurred approximately fifteen years ago, the surrounding area has changed significantly where there have been at least four rezoning approvals which includes nine tracts of land all within less than 1,000 feet of the subject property(s) that have been redeveloped as mostly apartments. Prior to the city annexing the area north of Agua Fria Road there was little development activity. With the availability of utilities and provision of City services within this urban area there have been more requests for development or re-development in this urban area of the City. 13 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report (iii) a different use category is more advantageous to the community, as articulated in the general plan or other adopted city plans; Response: The City General Plan identifies this property and other properties between Agua Fria and the Santa Fe River as “Community Commercial or Transitional Mixed Use”. The predominate land use for this area is a mix of commercial and single family and rental housing. The R-1 zoning assignment is not consistent with the underlying zoning therefore it is necessary to rezone the property to maintain consistency with the overall area. (b) all the rezoning requirements of Chapter 14 have been met; Response: Currently the existing zoning is R-1, Single Family Residential, one dwelling per acre, which creates a non-conforming status for this property. Rezoning of the property to C-2 uses would bring this property into conformance with the historic land use patterns and uses that have taken place on this property. (c) the rezoning is consistent with the applicable policies of the general plan, including the future land use map; Response: Rezoning to C-2 (General Commercial) is consistent with the policies of the general plan as it aims to recognize the development of infill properties where city infrastructure is available furthermore rezoning of the property is consistent with the transitional mixed-use designation in that it offers the property the ability to development both a mix of residential and commercial uses. (d) the amount of land proposed for rezoning and the proposed use for the land is consistent with city policies regarding the provision of urban land sufficient to meet the amount, rate and geographic location of the growth of the city; and Response: There are four (4) adjoining legal lots of record with a combined total of 5.96 acres which will be consolidated upon approval of the rezoning request. The proposed C-2 use for the land is consistent with city policies as it continues to recognize development of infill property and is consistent with the current land use patterns that have developed for a mix of uses from commercial to medium to high density residential. (e) the existing and proposed infrastructure , such as the streets system, sewer and water lines, and public facilities, such as fire stations and parks, will be able to accommodate the impacts of the proposed development . Response: Public utilities are available on Agua Fria, including water, gas and electric lines, cable and telephone lines. The City has completed street improvements and widening of Agua Fria adjacent to the subject property including upgrades to the Agua Fria and Siler Road intersection. Siler Road has been completed from Agua Fria to West Alameda providing alternative routes to Agua Fria. In fact, the traffic volumes on Agua Fria have declined with the extension of Siler to West Alameda. the Santa Fe River Greenway trail which can accommodate both pedestrian and bicyclist. The 14 Boylan General Plan Amendment & Rezoning Report Santa Fe River Greenway pedestrian and bicycle trail has recently been completed and is located north of the subject parcels, The closest Fire Station to this site is located on Cerrillos Road near Third Street within a five- minute service radius to this property. (2) Unless the proposed change is consistent with applicable general plan policies, the planning commission and the governing body shall not recommend or approve any rezoning, the practical effect of which is to: (a) allow uses or a change in character significantly different from or inconsistent with the prevailing use and character in the area; Response: The proposed C-2 zoning request, the character of the neighborhood will remain unchanged from the current mixed use and high-density multi-family residential that has been approved within the past fifteen (15) years with the annexation area of the subject property(s). (b) affect an area of less than two acres, unless adjusting boundaries between districts; or Response: The combined total of acreage included with the request consist of 5.96 acres, additionally the subject property immediately adjoins a tract of land that was approved to be rezoned in 2014, and was officially adopted via Ordinance 2014-32 (c) benefit one or a few landowners at the expense of the surrounding Response: The proposed amendment will benefit the surrounding landowners as the property is in need of redevelopment. The existing mobile home park has been in existence for over forty (40) years prior to the County Code taking effect. The property fronting Agua Fria Street is encroached by several electric power poles as well as a large stockpile of dirt. The amendment will allow for a sustainable and diverse development with connection to city utilities, relocating and undergrounding electric services. APPENDIX A LOT 1 (2745 AGUA FRIA) LEGAL LOT OF RECORD PLAT APPENDIX B TRACT E 1 (2743 AGUA FRIA) & A-1 (1372 BOYLAN LN.) LEGAL LOT OF RECORD PLAT APPENDIX C TRACT D CERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE APPENDIX D WARRANTY DEEDS LOT 1 (2745 BOYLAN LN.) WARRANTY DEED TRACT E-1 (2743 BOYLAN CIR.) WARRANTY DEED TRACT D (2743 BOYLAN CIR) WARRANTY DEED TRACT A-1 WARRANTY DEED