City of Santa Fe Historic Districts Review Board Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law Case #H-19-019 Address – 101, 103, 105, 106, 109, 110, 111, 113, 114, 115, 117, 118, 119, 120, 121 Camino Santiago and 104, 105, 107, 109, 111, 116/120 Camino Matias Agent’s Name – Lloyd and Associates Owner/Applicant’s Name – Plaza del Monte THIS MATTER came before the Historic Districts Review Board (“Board”) for hearing on June 25, 2019. BACKGROUND 101-121 Camino Santiago and 104-120 Camino Matias are 22 residential structures (hereafter the “Relevant Properties”), which along with 122, 124, 125, 126 and the garages at 126 Camino Santiago, comprise the Plaza del Monte subdivision, located in the Downtown and Eastside Historic District. The historic status for all 27 structures in Plaza del Monte as of the date of this hearing is summarized in the table below: Address Construction Date(s) Current Historic Status Recommended Historic Status In HRE Report HDRB Status Review Case 101 Camino Santiago c.1967-68 NC NC H-19-019 102 Camino Santiago c.1965 NC C H-19-019 103 Camino Santiago c.1965 NC C H-19-019 105 Camino Santiago (Units 1-4) 1971 NS NC H-19-019 106 Camino Santiago c.1965 NS C H-19-019 109 Camino Santiago c.1965 NS NC H-19-019 110 Cam. Santiago / 112 Cam. Matias c.1962/c.1968 NS NC H-19-019 111 Camino Santiago c.1965 NS C H-19-019 113 Camino Santiago c.1970 NS NC H-19-019 114 Camino Santiago c.1972 NS NC H-19-019 Finding of Fact Form HDRB Case #H-19-019 p. 2 115 Camino Santiago c.1970 NS NC H-19-019 117 Camino Santiago 1966-67 NS NC H-19-019 118 Camino Santiago c.1973 NS NC H-19-019 119 Camino Santiago c.1965 NS NC H-19-019 120 Camino Santiago c.1971 NS NC H-19-019 121 Camino Santiago c.1971 NS NC H-19-019 122 Camino Santiago c.1971 NC - H-17-098A 124 Camino Santiago c.1968 C - H-17-098A 125 Camino Santiago (Units 1-4) c.1970 NC - H-17-098A 126 Camino Santiago c.1968 C - H-17-098A Garages south of 126 Cam. Santiago c.1968/1977 NC - H-17-098A 104 Camino Matias c.1965 NC C H-19-019 105 Camino Matias 1950 C NC H-19-019 107 Camino Matias 1950 NC NC H-19-019 109 Camino Matias 1950 NC NC H-19-019 111 Camino Matias pre-1960 (moved to site) NC NC H-19-019 116/120 Camino Matias pre-1957 w/c.1984 addition NC NC H-19-019 NS = Non-statused NC = Non-contributing C = Contributing Historic status for 122, 124, 125, 126 and the garages at 126 Camino Santiago were assigned in Case H-17-098A. An extensive case history was provided as an attachment to the March 28, 2018 Plaza Del Monte Historic Resources Evaluation Report, prepared by John W. Murphey, architectural historian (hereafter, “HRE Report”). On March 26, 2019, the HDRB reviewed the status of seven non-statused structures in Plaza del Monte (105, 113, 114, 115, 118, 120, and 121 Camino Santiago) and voted to assign Contributing status to all seven structures because of their association to the Plaza del Monte, an historic planned subdivision, and because they are representative examples of Mid-century Modern influenced expressions of Santa Fe Style. On April 23, 2019, the HDRB rescinded its motion from the March 26, 2019, hearing regarding Finding of Fact Form HDRB Case #H-19-019 p. 3 the assignment of contributing historic status for the seven structures, citing insufficient discussion of each individual structure to justify the assignment of contributing status, including failure to designate primary façades. The conditions of this action were in the form of the following directives: 1) that the Land Use Director provide interpretation of the “50-year rule”; 2) that staff provide information regarding applicability of the provisions in the code for “Historic Compound” designation; and 3) that staff bring all remaining structures in Plaza del Monte back to the HDRB for review under a single status review case. The HRE report was included as an attachment to the staff report for this hearing. At this hearing, Staff presented all structures in Plaza del Monte for which status is not currently assigned for status review, including designation of primary façades as needed for those structures that receive contributing status. HISTORICAL SUMMARY OF PLAZA DEL MONTE The Plaza del Monte subdivision, or Plaza del Monte Retirement Center as it was formerly known, was originally conceived in the late 1950s as a communal living center for retired Presbyterian pastors, missionaries, and other church officials. After the Allison-James School closed in 1958, the United Presbyterian Church decided to plan for re-development of the site, and they selected the architectural firm of Kenneth S. Clark and Phillippe Register to design it as a large retirement community. The architects divided the former campus into two parts – the site of the older buildings termed the “South Area” would be developed first with a congregate building, and the “North Area” would be developed in a second phase with individual residences. A preliminary layout of the development in 1960 showed a cul-de-sac arrangement of the homes built around two new streets. Camino Santiago would run along the northern portion of the property, turning south and terminating in a cul-de-sac, and Camino Matias would be a loop off of Camino Santiago running through the older residences at the southern portion of the property. As is described in the Plaza del Monte Historic Resources Evaluation, Clark and Register conceived the design of the residences as a modified L-plan to which a carport and portal were attached. Architectural details are sympathetic to the Spanish-Pueblo Revival tradition – with room-block stuccoed massing, rounded corners, and vigas, posts and corbels on the portals and carports – but re-framed in mid-century styling. This contemporary influence became more pronounced on the exteriors of the later homes in the development, when the low, horizontal lines of the residences were further accentuated with flat overhanging roofs at times intersected with vertical planes. The latest homes constructed in Plaza del Monte in the early 1970s experimented with angular walls and a more compact massing with carport-dominant façades. SUMMARIES OF INDIVIDUAL PROPERTIES 101 Camino Santiago: Situated near the east entrance to Plaza del Monte, the house is a roughly 1,332 square foot contemporary residence constructed in 1967-68. In plan, the three- bedroom dwelling has a square form with an attached L-shaped portal and garage, giving it a combined square footprint. It presents to the street a long portal with the roof carrying over the garage. It is fenestrated with aluminum windows, primarily of a sliding operation. A paneled wood door gives entry to the residence at the east end of the portal. The garage entry is fitted with a Finding of Fact Form HDRB Case #H-19-019 p. 4 recent vinyl overhead door. Cementitious brocade stucco in a peach tone covers the frame building. The roof consists of a mixture of gravel and asphalt material. An interior parapet outlines the dwelling portion of the mass. While contemporary in form, the vigas across the portal give the residence a regional feel. 102 Camino Santiago: One of the earliest units to be constructed at Plaza del Monte, 102 Camino Santiago is a 2,064 square foot dwelling with one addition. The two bedroom, flat-roof house faces Camino Matias. It shows to the street (west) a façade-long portal, continuing at the south end as a single-space carport. The portal is supported by shiplap wood girders resting on round posts with double-ended corbels. Most of the portal façade is painted white. A line of vigas runs along the top of the wall. The elevation is penetrated by two doors and large windows, with the southernmost window not meeting the ordinance in regard to its distance from the corner. The north elevation facing Camino Santiago displays a variety of window openings holding tall metal casements. A shallow overhang supported by short vigas carries over most of the elevation. At the northeast corner is a roomblock-like projection holding the bedroom wing. The rear (east) elevation presents a number of alterations. The largest is a post-1969 addition, over what was a patio. The 380-square-foot addition is fenestrated with modern windows and is sheltered by a parapet-type portal. The house was constructed in c. 1965, and its designer/architect is unverified but assumed to be Kenneth S. Clark and Phillippe Register. 103 Camino Santiago: Roughly 1,533 square feet, the one-story residence is designed as an L-plan form. The plan puts the bedrooms in a cube-like mass, with the remainder of the functions of the house strung along a linear spine. Its façade is defined by a long portal sheltering its entry and patio doors. The east end of the composition terminates as a one-bay carport. A line of vigas runs along the back (north) elevation supporting a short overhang. An exterior chimney breaks through the overhang, rising several feet above the roof. The house is fenestrated with an array of original and replacement aluminum windows. It is entered under the portal through a stylized wood panel door flanked by one set of sidelights. The dwelling’s flat roof is outlined by a short parapet; the roof is covered with gravel. The frame structure is finished with cementitious brocade stucco in the buckskin tone. While contemporary in form, vigas used across the portal and the roomblock bedroom wing give the residence a Spanish-Pueblo Revival feel. The house was constructed in c. 1965; its architect/designer is unverified but assumed to be architect Phillippe Register. 105 Camino Santiago (Units 1-4): Forming a long, linear composition, 105 Camino Santiago is one of three apartment buildings erected at Plaza del Monte. The carport-dominated structure works its way down the slope as two L-plan units joined together at the center by a laundry room. The structure is bookended by masses holding the apartments. The larger apartments containing two bedrooms are situated in the projecting roomblocks. The apartments share a party wall at the living room. Spanning between the apartments are the carports and the laundry room. The carports are detailed with a viga-roof structure which continues as a portal along the inner apartments. The rear (north) elevation is divided into small patios. The apartments are entered through wood panel doors; solid wood doors give access to the storage units and the laundry. The original multi-light steel casement windows have been replaced with aluminum units. A short parapet follows the outline of the apartments, and is penetrated on the south, east and west elevations with cut-through metal canals. The frame structure is finished with cementitious Finding of Fact Form HDRB Case #H-19-019 p. 5 brocade stucco in a peach tone. While contemporary in form, the vigas used across the portales and carports and the cubed apartment masses give the residence a regional feel. The roughly 4,198 square foot apartment building was constructed in 1971, after a design by architect Phillipe Register. 106 Camino Santiago: Likely the third unit to be constructed at Plaza del Monte, 106 Camino Santiago is a 2,031 square foot dwelling with a portal across two elevations (north and east). In plan, it has an L-shaped foundation with an attached carport. The flat-roof dwelling holds three bedrooms confined to a wing at the west end. The rear (south) elevation is focused on a small patio cut into the southwest corner of the home. The southeast corner is terminated by a one-space carport. The two-sided portal runs along the north and east elevations. The structure is made of vigas which sit on square girders held up by round posts with corbels. The portal elevations are painted white and fenestrated with doors on each exposure. Small rectangular windows penetrate the bedroom wing. The remaining windows vary, including large picture and grouped casements and sliding units. The roof is finished with rolled asphalt which carries over the inner parapets. A squat stucco-faced chimney rises at the northeast corner. The house is finished with textured cementitious stucco in a light buckskin tone. The residence was constructed in c.1965. Its designer is unverified but is suspected to be an early Clark and Register design. 109 Camino Santiago: Composed of a series of angled walls, the carport dominated residence was constructed in 1966, after a design by architect Phillipe Register. The house presents to the street a tall and wide carport framed with a viga roof. The west end of the carport is sheltered by a double splayed wall. The angled wall composition is echoed across the east elevation. In plan, the residence is roughly an L with its form obscured by the carport. The approximately 1,220 square foot dwelling holds two bedrooms in a cube-like mass anchoring the east end. Between the bedroom mass and carport is a small enclosed patio and portal sheltering the main entry and a pair of oversized wood windows. The rear (north) elevation has a small viga canopy protecting a patio door. A tapered chimney breaks the wall plane on this elevation. Fenestration consists of mainly aluminum windows. The frame structure is finished with cementitious brocade stucco in the buckskin tone. The contemporary style home was constructed in 1965 and is one of the earliest residences to be constructed in Plaza del Monte. 110 Camino Santiago: Located at the west end of the common area are two residential units which were joined together at some point after 1970. The older unit, addressed as 110 Camino Santiago, takes up the east end of the footprint. Constructed in c.1962, after a design by architect Kenneth S. Clark, it is roughly an L-shaped box with a rear portal and connected carport. The street facing façade (north) is defined by a small recessed entry. The remainder of the façade is divided into rectangular window openings holding sliding units. Smaller, rectangular sliding windows are applied across the east bedroom wing. A shallow portal runs across the rear (south) elevation historically leading to a single-space carport. The portal elevation is fenestrated with a patio door, sliding windows, and a louvered door leading to a utility room. The house is outlined by parapets and finished in buckskin cementitious stucco. It holds three bedrooms. Attached to the west end of the original Clark design is a post-1966 addition. Arranged at a lower height, the approximately 864 square foot appendage is a rectangular box with overhanging eaves and a porch. The addition, most likely designed by architect Phillipe Register, introduces a contemporary vocabulary. A shallow overhang supported by squared rafters carries across the north and south elevations. Finding of Fact Form HDRB Case #H-19-019 p. 6 Similar beams extend out from the west elevation to create the porch. A tall angular wall rising above the roofline defines its south edge. The addition is fenestrated with a few doors and square window openings, holding single-light metal casements. Most likely occurring with the addition, the carport was widened (or constructed anew) to hold two vehicles. Set back from the addition, the roughly 1,054 square foot structure is supported by a viga and post system. 111 Camino Santiago: Arranged at an east-west orientation, the house is a one-story, approximately 1,616 square foot, flat-roof dwelling erected in c.1965. The dwelling has an L- shaped plan with its two bedrooms confined to a rectangular wing at the west end. The remaining house holds the living room, kitchen and dining area. The front (south) façade is market y along portal which continues across to an attached one-bay carport. The portal shelters the front entry and a sliding patio door. The structure is supported by round poles holding a viga roof. The house is fenestrated with common windows, most of them appearing to be replacement units. It is entered through a raised wood panel door flanked on one side by a sidelight. The rear (north) elevation contains a few windows and a door sheltered by a shallow viga-supported visor. A tapered chimney breaks through the visor, terminating with a terra cotta cap. The frame building is finished in a smooth cementitious stucco in a buckskin tone. The flat roof is covered with asphalt, which carries over the east exposure to the bedroom wing. While contemporary in form, the vigas used across the portal give the residence a Spanish-Pueblo Revival feel. The placement and restrained size of the carport helps maintain the regional tradition. The building was constructed after a design by architect Phillipe Register. 113 Camino Santiago: Sitting on a slight rise, the house shares a party wall at the carport with its neighbor at 115 Camino Santiago. The roughly 1,281 square foot dwelling contains two bedrooms arranged at the front of the structure in a small L-shaped volume. The remainder of the footprint holds the living functions of the house. It presents to the street two roomblock-like volumes penetrated by horizontally oriented aluminum casement windows. A viga-framed carport and short portal terminate the west end of the footprint. The house is entered through a raised wood panel door with a center view light. The rear (north) elevation has a few windows and a sliding glass door. A shallow overhang supported by square wood beams carries across the elevation. The frame dwelling is finished in cementitious peach color stucco worked into a brocade pattern. Tall parapets outline the perimeter of the bedroom wing. The roof is covered in asphalt which carries over the west exposure of the bedroom mass. It was erected in c.1970, and its designer/architect is unknown. 114 Camino Santiago: The house presents to Camino Santiago a traditional design of a cube-like mass projecting from a linear arm. In plan, it is roughly L-shaped with a large connecting carport attached to its southeast corner. The west end holds two bedrooms; the remainder of the footprint contains a large living room, kitchen and utility closet. The south exposure of the bedroom wing is penetrated by sliding glass doors. East of the bedroom wing, the front façade (north) is divided into a recessed entry and a large casement-framed picture window. The entry holds a raised square panel wood door with center view light. It is sheltered by a short overhang resting on vigas. A similar combined picture and casement window is found on the east elevation of the living room. The carport makes up most of the secondary street elevation (north, set back). It is supported by a wood viga-and-post system. The structure shelters a patio door and single raised panel wood door leading to the utility room and storage area. Wood, trough-like canales Finding of Fact Form HDRB Case #H-19-019 p. 7 penetrate the parapets on the east and west elevations. The roof is covered in rolled asphalt, which carries over the bedroom wing’s east exposure. A short stucco-clad chimney topped with a terra cotta cap rises from the center of the roof. Erected in c.1972, the residence was designed by Register, Ross & Burnett Architects. 115 Camino Santiago: Sharing a wall with the dwelling to the east (113 Camino Santiago), the small house contains two bedrooms. The dwelling portion of the building is composed of a rectangular bedroom wing. Attached to this are the living room, kitchen, and a one-space carport. Connecting these elements is a beam portal. Together, both areas hold about 1,290 square feet. The front (south) façade presents a simple canvas of a projecting mass balanced on one end with the void of the carport at the other. In between is the portal with its few window and door openings. The portal is supported by double round posts toped with corbels. The rear (north) elevation contains a few windows and a sliding glass door sheltered by a shallow viga-supported overhang. The windows in the residence are tall, single-light aluminum casements. A raised panel-and-view- light door gives entry to the dwelling under the portal. Short parapets outline the perimeter of the bedroom wing. The roof’s asphalt material carries over the east exposure of the parapet. The house was erected in c.1970, and the designer/architect is unknown. 117 Camino Santiago: Tucked into the northwest corner of the development, the house is a single-story, flat-roof dwelling characterized by its viga carport and continuous overhang. In form, its two box-like volumes are arranged in a modified L-plan. The house holds two bedrooms slung along the west wall. A large living room occupies the foot of the L. With its carport included, the house contains 1,422 square feet. The unarticulated flat front façade is penetrated by non- historic casement windows. A wood panel and view light door gives entry to the dwelling under the front portal. The rear (west) elevation is fenestrated with an asymmetrical pattern of tall aluminum casement windows. The frame building is finished with brocade-type stucco rendered in the buckskin color. It was constructed in 1966-67, after a design by architect Phillipe Register. Window replacements appear to have removed the pedimented heads shown on Register’s drawings. 118 Camino Santiago: Erected in c.1973, the stucco-over-frame, two bedroom house sits on a rise a the southeast corner of Camino Santiago and Camino Matias. In plan, it is a modified L shaped structure with a carport attached to its front (north) façade. The roughly 1,245 square foot dwelling has its bedrooms segregated to a wing across the west elevation. This volume is taller than the rest of the house and is outline with parapets. The lower volume contains a living room, kitchen and dining area. The north (front) façade is divided between the carport and the north face of the bedroom wing. The single carport is erected over a wood structure supported by round posts. The outside beam continues across the façade, sheltering the front entry. As with the door under the carport, the entry holds a raised square panel unit. The secondary elevations are fenestrated with single-light metal casement windows. The south (rear) elevation has an array of casement windows and an enclosure giving access to the carport. A shallow overhang resting on vigas outlines the elevation. The house is finished with cementitious brocade stucco in a peach pigment. The roof is covered with rolled asphalt, which carries over a portion of the bedroom wing’s east exposure. Large, trough-like wood canales pierce the west parapet. It was designed by Register, Ross & Burnet Architects, and is one of the last houses to be completed in Plaza del Monte. Finding of Fact Form HDRB Case #H-19-019 p. 8 119 Camino Santiago: Arranged slightly above grade, the box-like house is characterized by its continuous portal and horizontal emphasis. In plan it is a compact rectangle framed by angled walls on its north and south exposures. Large windows, a wood panel door and a three-panel sliding glass door appear on the front (east) façade. The rear (west) elevation has double sets of sliding windows and a patio door arranged under an overhang. The house’s windows appear to be mostly replacement units. The south end of the dwelling is weighted with a large carport. A tall double splayed wall creates the south exposure. The portal is supported by vigas resting on a square beam. Round posts topped with double ended corbels carry the weight to the floor. The roughly 1,485 square foot structure contains two bedrooms placed along the west wall. The building was constructed in c.1965, after a design by architect Phillipe Register. The main alteration is the removal of most of the angled wall along the northeast corner. Originally, this feature enclosed a small patio. 120 Camino Santiago: The small two bedroom house presents a contemporary carport-dominant design. Located along the east side of Camino Santiago, it sits back from the street. In plan, it is a modified T form with an attached carport projecting from the front (west) façade. Its two bedrooms are confined to a wing making up the north elevation. Higher than the rest of the house, it is outlined with shaped parapets. The parapets are pierced with canales across the north and south exposures. The lower volume, historically containing a living room, kitchen and music room, is faced with a shallow overhang resting on vigas. The overhang shelters sliding glass doors, a window and a pedestrian entry. The secondary elevations are fenestrated with aluminum casement windows. The front (west) elevation is dominated by the carport. The structure is erected over a viga-and-post support system. The portal’s outside beam continues across the façade, sheltering the front (west) entry. A wood raised square panel door with a center view light gives entry to the residence. Including its carport and utility room, the building contains 1,804 square feet. The house was built in c.1971 after a design by Register, Ross & Burnet Architects. 121 Camino Santiago: Reflecting a carport-dominant design, the small vernacular dwelling sits at grade on the west side of Camino Santiago. The roughly 1,309 square foot structure holds one bedroom. In plan, it is a compact square enclosed by an angled wall across its south exposure. Unlike most units in Plaza del Monte, it has a low pitched roof. The front (east) façade is dominated by the one-vehicle carport. The remainder of the façade is divided into windows and doors. The windows are uniformly multi-light steel casements in various standard sizes. The gabled north elevation has three identical windows. The rear (west) side of the house has more articulation, expressed through its beamed canopy over a pair of sliding doors. The frame house is finished with heavy brocade cementitious stucco in a peach like color. A shallow square-beam supported overhang runs along the east and west elevations. It was constructed in c.1971, after a design by Register, Ross & Brunet Architects. 104 Camino Matias: One of the first units to be constructed at Plaza del Monte, 104 Camino Matias is an L shaped dwelling with a combined carport and portal. The approximately 1,143 square foot, flat roof structures holds two bedrooms. The bedrooms are placed in a wing forming the north end of the residence. Its front (west) façade presents a Spanish-Pueblo Revival plan, with its cubic, battered mass and viga roofed portal. Unlike many houses in the development, the carport plays a secondary role on the façade. The single-bay structure, arranged behind the portal, is less exuberant in its display of wood elements. The bedroom mass is fenestrated with Finding of Fact Form HDRB Case #H-19-019 p. 9 small, rectangular windows; the remaining elevations have windows arranged in a more traditional pattern. The windows are mostly aluminum casement units. The portal elevation is painted white. A line of vigas runs along the top of the wall. It is supported by shiplap wood girders resting on round posts with corbels. The house was constructed in c.1965. It represents the closest interpretation of the original 1960 Kenneth S. Clark and Phillipe Register template design for the development. 105 Camino Matias: This small house is one of three units constructed in 1950 for married staff employed by the Allison James School. Arranged in a terrace-like fashion, each unit is a rectangular plan, side-gabled dwelling with an attached garage. The house has a telescoping roof form evident in its north exposure. The roof extends over the walls on the north and south elevations to form small porches. The house is fenestrated with a mix of original and non-historic windows and doors. The windows are terminated with stuccoed concrete sills. Views from the house are oriented north toward the commons area. The north elevation contains a large picture window flanked by casements. Public entry is through an original ½-glass wood door on the south elevation. The garage door is a recent vinyl paneled unit. The roof is covered with three-tab asphalt shingles. Wood fascia has been applied to the north and south roof ends, obscuring (or removing) the original exposed rafters. A short stuccoed chimney rises from the north roof slope. The approximately 1,102 square foot house holds three bedrooms. A non-historic, 220-square foot carport has been erected over the driveway. 107 Camino Matias: This small house is one of three units constructed in 1950 for married staff employed by the Allison James School. Arranged in a terrace-like fashion, each unit is a rectangular plan, side-gabled dwelling with an attached garage. The gabled roof extends over the walls on the north and south elevations to form small porches. The dwelling is fenestrated with a mix of original and non-historic windows, terminated with stuccoed concrete sills. Views from the house are oriented north towards the commons area of Plaza del Monte. The north elevation contains a large picture window flanked by casements. Public entry is through an original ½-glass wood door on the south elevation. Two vertical [solar?] panels have been applied to the south façade. The garage door is recent vinyl paneled unit. The roof is covered with three-tab asphalt shingles. Wood fascia has been applied to the north and south roof ends, obscuring (or removing) the original exposed rafters. A short stuccoed chimney rises from the north roof slope. The house originally had an exposed pedimented entry on the north elevation, which was reduced at some point in depth after 1969. The approximately 1,145 square foot house holds two bedrooms. Its association is with the Allison James School (demolished in 1960) rather than with Plaza del Monte. 109 Camino Matias: This small house is one of three units constructed in 1950 for married staff employed by the Allison James School. Arranged in a terrace-like fashion, each unit is a rectangular plan, side-gabled dwelling with an attached garage. The house has a telescoping roof form evident in its north exposure. The roof extends over the walls on the north and south elevations to form small porches. The front (south) façade reveals an altered composition. At some point after 1960, a 131 square foot addition was appended to the southwest corner creating a sunroom. The dwelling is fenestrated with a mix of original and non-historic windows, which are mostly double hung sash and are terminated with stuccoed concrete sills. Views from the house are oriented north toward the Plaza del Monte commons area. The north elevation contains a large Finding of Fact Form HDRB Case #H-19-019 p. 10 picture window flanked by casements. Public entry is through an original ½-glass wood door on the south elevation. The garage door is a recent vinyl paneled unit. The roof is covered with three- tab asphalt shingles. Wood fascia has been applied to the north and south roof ends, obscuring (or removing) the original exposed rafters. A short stuccoed chimney rises from the north roof slope. The approximately 1,141 square foot house contains two bedrooms. Its association is with the Allison James School (demolished in 1960) rather than with Plaza del Monte. 111 Camino Matias: Moved to the site prior to 1960, 111 Camino Matias is an altered three bedroom house. The house is arranged on a north-south axis, facing west, and in plan consists of two telescoping gabled sections. To this basic form was added an L-shaped porch and connected carport in c.1966. The medium pitch roofs are covered with asphalt shingles and extended with overhangs. A short stuccoed chimney rises from the ridgeline. Small wood louvers are attached to the gabled ends. The house is fenestrated with an array of original and non-historic windows, recessed from the walls and terminated with concrete sills. The combined porch and carport are supported by a framework of wood girders resting on grouped square posts. The single carport includes double storage units. A short breezeway leads from the carport to a back door. The 1,712 square foot house is finished with textured cementitious stucco in a light buckskin color. 116/120 Camino Matias: The vernacular, two unit residence was erected before 1957 and modified nearly 30 years later with the addition of a cross-gabled entry. The combined residence is aligned along a north-south axis on the west side of Camino Matias. In plan, it is a side-gabled rectangle with a cross-gable appended to its northeast corner. The north unit (120) holds about 1,256 square feet with three bedrooms. A window wall spanning the northeast corner signals its contemporary design. The north elevation under the gable is marred by a c.1984 shed- roof structure enclosing the furnace and water heater. The front façade faces east and is dominated by the non-historic cross gable entry. A recessed entry at the south end leads to 116. The interior, encompassing approximately 939 square feet, is arranged like an apartment. A similar non-historic stuccoed enclosure around the furnace and water heater is attached to the south elevation. The rear (west) elevation of the combined units faces onto a common area. A continuous overhang characterizes this façade. It is penetrated with three sliding glass doors and a mixture of fixed and sliding windows of different sizes. The roof is sheathed with rib metal panels. It is unclear who designed the original house. The c.1984 addition of the cross gable and furnace and water heater enclosures was drawn in Phillipe Register’s shop. Built prior to 1958 and substantially modified in the mid-1980s, the historic integrity of the house has been compromised, and the style of the home neither harmonizes with the district nor with Plaza del Monte. As with the other Allison James School-era residences on Camino Matias, the house neither harmonizes with the district nor with Plaza del Monte, and its association is with the Allison James School rather than Plaza del Monte. FINDINGS OF FACT 1. After conducting a public hearing and having heard from the Applicant and all interested persons, the Board hereby FINDS, as follows: 2. Staff Recommendation: Staff generally agreed with the status recommendations provided in the “Plaza del Monte Historic Resources Evaluation” but deferred to the Board for individual status assignments, per Section 14-5.2(C) Designation of Significant and Contributing Structures. Finding of Fact Form HDRB Case #H-19-019 p. 11 3. Under Section 14-5.2(A)(1)(a), the general purpose of City’s historic preservation ordinance is to preserve the qualities relating to the history of Santa Fe, and a harmonious outward appearance, s in order to preserve property values and attract tourist and residents alike. These purposes are effectuated through the continued existence and preservation of historical areas and buildings. 4. The project is subject to requirements of the following sections of the Santa Fe Land Development Code: • Section 14-5.2(D)(9), General Design Standards, Height Pitch Scale and Massing (of any structure); • Section 14-5.2(D), General Design Standards; and • Section 14-5.2(C), Regulation of Significant and Contributing Structures. 5. The property is located in the following district and subject to the related sections of the Santa Fe Land Development Code: • Downtown and Eastside Historic District (Section 14-5.2(E)). 6. Under Section 14-5.2(C)(2)(a), the Board has the authority to designate status as "significant," "contributing," or "noncontributing" based upon the definitions of these terms in Section 14-12. 7. Under Section 14-12.1, a “contributing” structure is defined as “a structure, located in a historic district, approximately fifty years old or older that helps to establish and maintain the character of that historic district. Although a contributing structure is not unique in itself, it adds to the historic associations or historic architectural design qualities that are significant for a district. The contributing structure may have had minor alterations, but its integrity remains.” 8. Under Section 14-12.1, a “noncontributing” structure is defined as “a structure, located in an H district, that is less than fifty years old or that does not exhibit sufficient historic integrity to establish and maintain the character of the H District.” 9. Under Section 14-12.1, “significant” structure is defined as “a structure located in a historic district that is approximately fifty years old or older, and that embodies distinctive characteristics of a type, period or method of construction. For a structure to be designated as significant, it must retain a high level of historic integrity. A structure may be designated as significant: (A) for its association with events or persons that are important on a local, regional, national or global level; or (B) if it is listed on or is eligible to be listed on the State Register of Cultural Properties or the National Register of Historic Places. 10. Under Section 14-12.1, a “primary façade” is defined as “[o]ne or more principal faces or elevations of a building with features that define the character of the building's architecture.” 11. Under Section 14-5.2(C)(2)(b)(i), the Board is authorized to change the status of a structure or to designate a status for a structure with no status designated. 12. Under Section 14-5.2(C)(2)(b)(ii), a “change in status or the designation of a status shall be based upon an evaluation of data provided through survey or other relevant sources of information and the definitions of ‘significant,’ ‘contributing,’ or ‘noncontributing.’” 13. On Tuesday June 25, 2019, the Property Owner through their representative, Karl Sommer, provided the City with a letter contesting the Board’s proposed adjudication of status of the properties under this case number scheduled for that same day. Finding of Fact Form HDRB Case #H-19-019 p. 12 14. Under Section 14-5.2(C)(2)(c), the Board may review status designations upon the City’s request, provided that Staff must notify the property owner. 15. Pursuant to Section 14-5.2(C)(2)(d), Staff provided notice by mailing a letter dated June 7, 2019, by certified mail return receipt requested, to the property owner and by securely and prominently posting notice posters on June 10, 2019 at the Bishops Lodge entrance and Old Taos Highway entrance, which are visible from a public street. 16. The information contained in the Application and provided in testimony and evidence establishes that all applicable requirements for Board review as herein described have been met. 17. The Board discussed the fact that the HRE report applied the 50-year-rule as a bright-line rule. 18. In the Staff report, Staff provided guidance about how the “50-year Rule” set forth in the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966 has been interpreted and explained that exceptions to this standard have been applied to sites, structures, and places that are less than fifty years old but which have demonstrated “exceptional importance,” independent of age. 19. At the hearing, the Board considered Section 14-1.9(G), which provides that “[w]ords and phrases shall be construed according to the common and approved usage of the language, but technical words and phrases that may have acquired a peculiar and appropriate meaning in law shall be construed and understood according to that meaning.” 20. The “Summaries of Individual Properties” and the “Historical Summary of Plaza Del Monte” above were originally included in the hearing packet and are incorporated into the findings of fact by reference. 21. Section 14-5.2(K) requires the preservation of a historic compound listed on the City’s historic compound register. “Historic compounds shall be comprised of a group of at least three buildings that are historically, physically, and/or spatially related. In order for a compound to be considered historic, at least fifty percent of the buildings in the compound shall be designated contributing, significant or landmark.” Section 14-5.2(K)(2)(a). FINDINGS AS TO SPECIFIC PROPERTIES 101Camino Santiago: 1. This structure was built over 50 years ago between 1967-68. The footprint has not changed since original build, and the windows appear to have their original opening dimensions. This property is an adaptation of mid-century modern, incorporating Santa Fe style into a more contemporary motion and as such, the property is very unique to Santa Fe. The heavy traditional posts and extension of the portal over the garage set this property as a good example of Santa Fe Style. Additionally, this property is associated with Plaza del Monte, a master planned community by significant architects Clark and Register. This structure meets the definition of “contributing” set forth in Section 14-12.1. 102 Camino Santiago: 1. This structure, built over 50 years ago in 1965, is representative of the original be Kenneth S. Clark and Phillippe Register design template for Plaza del Monte residences and is a good example of Mid-Century Santa Fe Style, with the combined portal and carport as a Finding of Fact Form HDRB Case #H-19-019 p. 13 character defining feature of that style. The Board adopts the recommendation of the HRE that this structure should be designated as contributing. 103 Camino Santiago: 1. This structure, built over 50 years ago in 1965, is representative of Mid-century Santa Fe Style due to its L-plan, portal, carport, and front door side lights, which are character defining features of that style. Additionally, this property is associated with Plaza del Monte, a master planned community by significant architects Clark and Register. The Board adopts the recommendation of the HRE that this structure should be designated as contributing. 105 Camino Santiago (Units 1-4): 1. This structure, constructed approximately 50 years ago in 1971, has large lot masses on the sides with the portal in the middle, which is representative of Mid-Century Modern Santa Fe style. Additionally, this property is associated with Plaza del Monte, a master planned community by significant architects Clark and Register. Further, this property was constructed after a design by significant architect Phillipe Register. This structure meets the definition of “contributing” set forth in Section 14-12.1. 106 Camino Santiago 1. This structure, built over 50 years ago in 1965, is characterized in the HRE Report as a great use of Mid-Century Modern Santa Fe style. Additionally, this property is associated with Plaza del Monte, a master planned community by architects significant Clark and Register. The Board adopts the recommendation of the HRE that this structure should be designated as contributing. 109 Camino Santiago: 1. This structure, built over 50 years ago in 1965, is a good example of Mid-Century Modern Santa Fe Style. Additionally, this property is associated with Plaza del Monte, a master planned community by significant architects Clark and Register. This property is a good example of significant architect Phillipe Register’s work. This structure meets the definition of “contributing” set forth in Section 14-12.1. 110/112 Camino Santiago: 1. These structures are greater than 50-years-old: 110 Camino Santiago was constructed circa 1962, and 112 Camino Santiago constructed circa 1966. Additionally, the structures are a good example of Mid-Century Modern Santa Fe Style, having each been designed by significant architects Clark and Register: 110 Camino Santiago having been designed by Kenneth S. Clark and 112 Camino Santiago having been designed by Phillipe Register. Additionally, this property is associated with Plaza del Monte, a master planned community by significant architects Clark and Register. This structure meets the definition of “contributing” set forth in Section 14-12.1. 111 Camino Santiago: 1. The HRE Report recommended designating this structure, constructed over 50 years ago in1965, with contributing status. Additionally, the structure is a good example of Mid- Finding of Fact Form HDRB Case #H-19-019 p. 14 Century Modern Santa Fe Style and is associated with Plaza del Monte, a master planned community by significant architects Clark and Register. The Board adopts the recommendation of the HRE that this structure should be designated as contributing. 113/115 Camino Santiago: 1. These properties were constructed very close in time, approximately 50 years ago, and were constructed circa 1970. In all likelihood, these properties were planned in early 1969 and construction begun in 1969. These structures are a good example of Mid-Century Modern Santa Fe Style due to the incorporation of defining characteristics of that style into the architecture, including the flagstone paving leading to the carport, vertical window pattern, and blocked massing on the ends. Additionally, the property is associated with Plaza del Monte, a master planned community by significant architects Clark and Register. This structure meets the definition of “contributing” set forth in Section 14-12.1. 114 Camino Santiago: 1. This structure, constructed circa 1972, is approximately 50 years old. This structure is a good example of Mid-Century Modern Santa Fe Style due to its character-defining characteristics, which include a carport and double posts and flagstone leading to the carport. Additionally, the property is associated with Plaza del Monte, a master planned community by significant architects Clark and Register. This structure meets the definition of “contributing” set forth in Section 14-12.1. 117 Camino Santiago: 1. This structure, constructed between 1966-67, is over 50 years old and has a distinct “modified L” or “boomerang” shape. As such, the structure is exemplary in the evolution of design in Plaza del Monte and of Philippe Register’s efforts to comply with the historic district design standards while exercising a modernist expression. Further, it is associated with Plaza del Monte and is a compelling example of Mid-Century Santa Fe Style due to how the structure conforms to the site and balances with the landscape, as noted above. This structure meets the definition of “contributing” set forth in Section 14-12.1. 118 Camino Santiago: 1. This structure was the most recently built of the Plaza Del Monte properties reviewed in the HRE report, having been built in 1973. While this property is associated with Plaza del Monte, a master planned community by significant architects Clark and Register, the structure lacks character-defining features. This structure does not meet the definition of “contributing” set forth in Section 14-12.1. 119 Camino Santiago: 1. This structure, constructed in 1965, is over 50 years old and is a clear expression of Mid- Century Modern Santa Fe Style due to the long, low projecting roofline and south fin wall, which are character defining of that style. Further, this structure is associated with Plaza del Monte, a master planned community by significant architects Clark and Register. This structure meets the definition of “contributing” set forth in Section 14-12.1. Finding of Fact Form HDRB Case #H-19-019 p. 15 120 Camino Santiago: 1. This structure, constructed in 1971, is approximately 50 years old, and is a clear expression of Mid-Century Modern Santa Fe Style due to its character-defining elements, which include the carport, outdoor storage rooms, and overall massing. Further, this structure is associated with Plaza del Monte, a master planned community by significant architects Clark and Register. This structure meets the definition of “contributing” set forth in Section 14-12.1. 121 Camino Santiago: 1. This structure is approximately 50 years old, having been constructed circa 1971. This structure is a good example of Mid-Century Modern Santa Fe Style, utilizing steel casement windows with three divisions, storage cabinets in the carport. Additionally, the property is associated with Plaza del Monte, a master planned community by significant architects Clark and Register. This structure meets the definition of “contributing” set forth in Section 14-12.1. 104 Camino Matias: 1. This structure is over 50 years old, having been constructed in 1965, and is one of the first constructed Plaza Del Monte structures reviewed in the HRE Report. The structure is a good example of Mid-Century Modern Santa Fe Style and is associated with Plaza del Monte, a master planned community by significant architects Clark and Register. The Board adopts the recommendation of the HRE that this structure should be designated as contributing. 105 Camino Matias: 1. This structure is greater than 50 years old and is associated with the Alison James School. The structure’s defining characteristics include concrete seals, pitched roof, and the presence of some original doors and windows. The structure exemplifies post-WWII construction. This structure, along with 107, 109 and 111 Camino Matias, anchor the orientation of Plaza del Monte around a common space. This structure meets the definition of “contributing” set forth in Section 14-12.1. 107 Camino Matias: 1. This structure is over 50 years old, having been constructed in 1950. This structure is associated with the Alison James School. The structure’s defining characteristics include concrete seals, pitched roof, large picture windows, and other elements that are also reflected in the neighboring properties at 105 and 109 Camino Matias. These structures exemplify post-WWII construction. This structure, along with 105, 109 and 111 Camino Matias, anchor the orientation of Plaza del Monte around a common space. This structure meets the definition of “contributing” set forth in Section 14-12.1. 109 Camino Matias: 1. This structure is over 50 years old, having been constructed in 1950. This structure is associated with the Alison James School. The structure’s defining characteristics include concrete seals, pitched roof, and casement windows, and the structure exemplifies post- WWII construction. This structure, along with 105, 107 and 111 Camino Matias, anchor Finding of Fact Form HDRB Case #H-19-019 p. 16 the orientation of Plaza del Monte around a common space. This structure meets the definition of “contributing” set forth in Section 14-12.1. 111 Camino Matias: 1. This structure was moved to its current property location in 1966, and as such, was constructed over 50 years ago. This structure is associated with the Alison James School and includes Plaza del Monte-era additions that provide visual association with the planned development. This structure meets the definition of “contributing” set forth in Section 14- 12.1. 116/120 Camino Matias: 1. This structure is over 50 years old, having been constructed in 1957. However, this structure has been extensively modified from its original construction, and those disharmonious additions result in a lack of defining characteristics. These structures do not meet the definition of “contributing” set forth in Section 14-12.1. CONCLUSIONS OF LAW Under the circumstances and given the evidence and testimony submitted during the hearing, the Board acted upon the Application as follows: 1. The Board directs Historic Preservation Division Staff to prepare and present an evaluation of Plaza del Monte for possible designation as a historic compound under Code Section 14-5.2(K). 2. The Board has the authority to initiate, review, and approve the status designation of the Relevant Properties. 3. The Board designates the following statuses and primary façades for the Relevant Properties: Address Historic Status Primary Façade(s) 101 Camino Santiago Contributing South (1) 102 Camino Santiago Contributing West (1) & South (2) 103 Camino Santiago Contributing South (1) 105 Camino Santiago Contributing South (1) 106 Camino Santiago Contributing North (2) & East (1) 109 Camino Santiago Contributing South (1-5) 110/112 Camino Santiago Contributing South (5) & West (2, 3, 4) 111 Camino Santiago Contributing South (1) 113/115 Camino Santiago Contributing South (1, 2, 3) 114 Camino Santiago Contributing North (1) & East (2) 117 Camino Santiago Contributing East (1 & 2) and South (7) 118 Camino Santiago Non-contributing N/A 119 Camino Santiago Contributing East (1) & South (4) 120 Camino Santiago Contributing West (1 & 2) 121 Camino Santiago Contributing East (1) & South (4) 104 Camino Matias Contributing North (1 & 4) 105 Camino Matias Contributing North (3) 107 Camino Matias Contributing North (3) 109 Camino Matias Contributing North (3) 111 Camino Matias Contributing West (1) & South (2) 116/120 Camino Matias Non-contributing N/A Finding of Fact Form HDRB Case #H-19-019 p. 17 IT IS SO ORDERED ON THIS 13th DAY OF AUGUST 2019, THE HISTORIC DISTRICTS REVIEW BOARD OF THE CITY OF SANTA FE. _______________________ _____________ Chairperson Date: FILED: ______________________ ______________ Yolanda Y. Vigil Date: City Clerk APPROVED AS TO FORM: _________________________ ______________ Gabriel A. Smith Date: Assistant City Attorney -1liiP CITY OF SANTA FE, NEW MEXICO PROJECT DESCRIPTION: Lloyd and Associates, agent for Plaza del Monte LLC, owners, historic status review and designation of primary fac;ades, if applicable, for all residential structures in the Plaza del Monte Subdivision, except those reviewed for historic status in Case #H-17-098A (122, 124, 125, 126, and garages south of 126 Camino Santiago). Case number: Project Type: PROJECT LOCATION (S): H-19-019 HDRB 101,102,103,105,106,109,110,111,113,114,115,117,118,119, 120,121 CaminoSantiagoand 104,105,107,109,111, 116/120CaminoMatias PROJECT NAMES: OW- Plaza del Monte LLC 8814 Horizon Blvd. Suite 400 Albuquerque, NM 87113 AP- Lloyd and Associates 321 West San Francisco Street Suit A Santa Fe, NM 87501 PROJECT DATA: HISTORIC DISTRICT Don Gaspar A:rea D Downtown and Eastside 0'/ Historic Review D Transition D Westside-Guadalupe D HISTORIC BUILDING STATUS ____./" Non-Contributing [!a// Contributing B ___/ Significant D Landmark D PRIMARY ELEVATIONS: PUBLICLY VISIBLE FACADE-EAST PUBLICLY VISIBLE FACADE-NORTH PUBLICLY VISIBLE FACADE-SOUTH PUBLICLY VISIBLE FACADE-WEST HISTORIC DISTRICT INVENTORY NUMBER YEAR OF CONSTRUCTION PROJECT TYPE North D Sonth D West D East D Yes~o D Yes O/)\!o D Yes GrNo D Yes~-D N/A D N/A~ Status ~-· Primary Elevations w· Remodel D Demollition D New D Other _____ USE, EXISTING Residential [l~(/ Non-Residential D/ Residential~/ Non-Residential D Vacant D USE, PROPOSED HISTORIC BUILDING NAME Plaza del Monte --- 1@fit1w ®ft ~(1lllJGe of klllna IS...~. I ITc-..sl-~-&t.~..sl Ice (Yn.l Co SanWgo Fcul'plex 690 J-1-l ~ ~ ...~ I 126c: c-inll Sand.ago n:utp1ex 690 3-l-l 126d Cc:11>o Sand.a90 Fcul'plu 690 J-l-1 21 120 C'.'m£no SantiA90 S.lnqle-naaily 1,259 5-l-2 18 ~ ) ...I •. . 114 Cimino Santi.ac;o Sin;lc-naaily 1,318 .. 4-2-2 17 !•;:; Figure 5: iPhone image of c.l988 Plaza del Monte appraiser report referenced at April 24, 2018 hearing. 85ft~I' Aerial1: Portion of February 28, 1968 aerial photograph. Source: NMDOT- 02_28_68_0021. 86(0 Aerial 2: Portion of February 27, 1969 aerial photograph. Source: NMDOT- 1969_2_27_4071. 87Aerial 3: Portion of May 11, 1973 aerial photograph showing 118 Camino Santiago under construction. Source: NMDOT· 05-11-73_0053. 88PLAZA DEL MONTE Santa Fe, New Mexico Historic Resources Evaluation Second Amendment to March 28, 2018 Report May 17, 2018 Client: Wayne S. Lloyd, A.I.A. lloyd and Associates, Architects 100 N Guadalupe Street, # 201 Santa Fe, NM 87501 Consultant: John W. Murphey Architectural Historian 2833 Plaza Verde Santa Fe, NM 87507 89Introduction This second amendment addresses issues the Historic Districts Review Board brought up at the April 24, 2018 hearing, information requested by the City of Santa Fe Historic Preservation Division after that hearing, and additional comments made by the Board at the follow-up May 17, 2018 hearing. Retaining Walls: 124 and 126 A Camino Santiago David Rasch, the case manager for the project, communicated to the applicant after the April 24 hearing that the retaining walls of the two units granted demolition by the Board required documentation. On May 3, 2018, the consultant recorded the retaining walls at 124 and 126 A Camino Santiago (the combined garage/carport structure), associated with the two units granted demolition. Both units include low concrete-and-stone walls which work as retaining walls and/or transitions between building pads. The wall for 126 A retains the dirt between the apartment building (126) and the parking stalls. It is constructed of non-reinforced concrete, mixed with heavy stones most likely taken from the adjacent arroyo {Figure 1). The wall is erected over a concrete walkway and stands approximately 32" above the sidewalk and 14" above the contained earth. The 10"-thick structure presents an angled face similar to a dam. It is topped with rounded concrete coping. The wall runs the length of the parking structure before tapering to the ground on the west and rising above grade to the east as a pathway entry. A wall of similar composition but of lesser height edges the south and east exposures of the back yard of 124 Camino Santiago {Figure 2). It begins at 9%'' above grade at the patio, and continues in a northerly direction, ranging between 18" to 26" above inside grade. Near the northeast tangent, it connects with another wall erected with the construction of 122 Camino Santiago. Based on aerial photographs, neither the 124 nor 126 A retaining walls predate the construction of their associated units. And while this fact is inconclusive, neither wall is visible on the February 28, 1968 aerial photograph (Aerial 2). The retaining walls are apparent on a 1 90February 27, 1969 photograph, indicating the completion of the units and their landscaping (Aerial3). Given their low architectural value, and assumed c.1968+ construction date, neither is recommended for Contributing Structure status to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District. Additional Walls As stated in the Historic Resources Evaluation, the Plaza del Monte landscape includes a number of retaining walls. The retaining walls, constructed of formed concrete or concrete and stone, were built over several phases, dating generally between 1950 and 1973. The walls were constructed to retain earth or to separate building pads (Figure 3). Very few of them rise above grade. A few lots have above-ground property line walls. These are made of stucco-dad concrete masonry units (Figure 4). From aerial photographs, both retaining and property line walls appear to post-date the construction of their associated units. Given their recent date of construction and utilitarian quality, the retaining and property walls are not recommended for individual or collective Contributing Structure status to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District. Aerial Imagery To address the Board's concern over the lack of c.1968-69 aerial imagery for the west side of Plaza del Monte, the consultant approached the NMDOT seeking additional photographs after the April 24 hearing. The head of aerial photography, Alane Wainwright, confirmed in an April 30 email to the consultant that the February 27, 1969 aerial (1969_02_27_ 4072) presented in the Historic Resources Evaluation represented the end of the flight line. The email supported her January 17, 2018 communication, which asserted that the image was all that the NMDOT could offer. Wainwright explained in that email that the image didn't "get the entire area." 1 However, given the importance of the case, Wainwright performed an additional due-diligence search and found three 1968-69 era photographs that are not available to the public. 2 These 1 Alane Wainwright, email communication to John Murphey, January 17, 2018. See chain of communication in Appendix A. 2 Ibid., April 30, 2018. 2 91include two secondary images from the February 27, 1969 flight and one from February 28, 1968. Wainwright additionally provided several photographs from May 1973. Both the 1968 and 1969 aerials show the southwest quadrant of Plaza del Monte to be populated with only two structures: 124 and 126 Camino Santiago (Aerials 2 & 3). The newly revealed aerial photographs present a strong case that only a handful of units were fully completed by February 28, 1968. The 1973 image shows most of the units finished, and 118 Camino Santiago still in the framing stage (Aerial 4). At the follow-up May 15, 2018 hearing, member Powell expressed suspicion over the fact that additional aerial photographs had surfaced after the initial hearing. The consultant includes with this amendment the entire email communication with NMDOT's Alane Wainwright. The communications on January 16, January 17, April 26, April 30 and May 1 are specific to this subject (Appendix A). Construction Dates At the April 24, 2018 hearing, a few members of the Board expressed apprehension about the report's assigned construction dates. The dates were premised on the consultant's methodology which used various sources (primarily aerial photographs, city directory entries, and architectural drawings), to arrive at a relative- though most often accurate- "circa" date of construction. Sowing confusion was mention of a 1988 appraiser's estimate of dates introduced during sworn testimony. This information was neither viewed by the Board nor officially introduced into the record. Given the Board's questioning, the consultant reviewed the sources again, examined the 1988 appraiser's estimates, and evaluated the additional aerial photographs recently made available. This analysis is presented in Table 1. At the follow-up hearing, member Powell continued to question the dates of construction provided by the consultant, pointing to differing years he found on the Santa Fe County Assessor's parcel map website, from his cell phone during the hearing. The consultant had already discarded the county's dates as being mostly inaccurate, as noted in the Table of Surveyed Resources in the March 28 report. But given Powell's insistence, the consultant reviewed the assessor's dates again on May 17, and identifies the errors in the county's 3 92Address estimates in Table 2. In general, the county's dates do not comport with evidence found on aerial photographs. At conclusion of both exercises, the consultant believes that the Historic Resources Evaluation's assigned dates of construction are mainly accurate. The consultant, however, because of timing issues, did not get to review additional material that may have surfaced at the Santa Fe Presbyterian church library or the Menaul facility. Table 1: Year of Construction Year Built"' Date of Drawings 1988 Appraiser's Consultant's Original Source and Justification Estimate"'"' and/or Revised Estimate""""' CAMINO SANTIAGO 101 c.1967-68 Unknown 1968 c.1967-68 Aerial photographs and first city directory 102 c.1965 Kenneth S. Clark & 1962 Before 1966 May 2, 1966 aerial photograph and first R-2 Philippe Register, Appraiser assigns city directory entry assumed address to Camino Matias 1.03 c.1965 Philippe Register 1968 Before 1966 May 2, 1966 aerial photograph and first (-12 1962 city directory entry 105 1971 Register, Ross & Burnet 1962 1971 Does not aQQear on either Ma~ 2, 1966 R-14 1970 or Februar~ 27, 1969 aeriaiQhotograQhs Drawing, aerial photographs and first city directory entry 106 c.1965 Kenneth S. Clark & 1962 Before 1966 May 2, 1966 aerial photograph and first R-3 Philippe Register, Appraiser assigns city directory entry assumed address to Camino Matias 109 c.1965 Philippe Register 1963 Before 1966 May 2, 1966 aerial photograph and first R-15 1963 city directory entry 110 c.1962/ Kenneth S. Clark 110: 1962 110: c.1962 Drawings, aerial photographs and first (112) c.1968 1962, original house; 112: 1968 112: c.1968 city directory entries R-5 Register, Ross & Burnet, addition 111 c.1965 Philippe Register Unknown; Before 1966 Drawings, aerial photographs and first 1963 remodeled, 1962 city directory entry 113 c.1970 Unknown 1970 c.1970 Does not aQQear on February 27, 1969 Appraiser assigns aeriaiQhotograQh address as 115 a Drawings and first city directory entry 4 93ddress Year Built* Date of Drawings 1988 Appraiser's Consultant's Original Source and Justification Estimate** and/or Revised Estimate"'""" 114 c.1972 Register, Ross & Burnet 1971 c.1972 Does not a1212ear on FebruarY 27, 1969 R-26 1971 aerial12hotogra12h 115 c.1970 Unknown c.1970 First city directory entry 117 1966-67 Philippe Register Unknown; May 2, 1966 aerial photograph and first 1965;1966 estimated 1963- city directory entry 1968 118 c.1973 Register, Ross & Burnet 1972 1973 Does not a1212ear on Februar~ 27, 1969 1971 aerial12hotogra12h Register & Burnet 1972 Drawings and first city directory entry 119 c.1965 Philippe Register 1963 May 2, 1966 aerial photograph and first 1965/1968 citydirectory entry 120 c.1971 Register, Ross & Burnet 1970 c.1971 Does not a1212ear on Februar~ 27, 1969 R-25 1970 aerial photogra12h ,21 c.1971 Register, Ross & Burnet 1970 c.1971 Does not atmear on Februar~ 27, 1969 .-20 1970 aerial photograph Drawings and first city directory entry 122 c.1971 Register, Ross & Burnet Unknown; c.1971 Does not am:Jear on Februar~ 27, 1969 1967 estimated 1963- aerial photograph 1968 124 · c.1968 Philippe Register 1964 c.1967 R-23 1967 125 c.1970 Register, Ross & Burnet 1969 c.1970 Does not atmear on Februar~ 27, 1969 R-21 1969 aerial photogra12h Drawings and first city directory entry 126 c.1968 Philippe Register . 1967 c.1967 Drawings, aerial photographs and first R-24 1967 city directory entry 126 c.1968/ Unknown No covered c.1968/ Drawings and April9, 1975 aerial Garage 1977 1977 photograph CAMINO MATIAS 104 c.1965 Kenneth S. Clark & 1962 Before 1966 May 2, 1966 aerial photograph Philippe Register, assumed; Philippe Register 1963, alteration 5 94ddress Year Built* Date of Drawings 1988 Appraiser's Consultant's Original Source and Justification Estimate** and/or Revised Estimate *** 105 1950 Unknown Unknown; 1950 Carolyn Atkins, The Allison-James R-10 remodeled 1962 Picture Book, 1866-1959, (Albuquerque: Menaul Historical Library of the Southwest, 1983), 25; aerial photographs 107 1950 Unknown Unknown; 1950 Carolyn Atkins, The Allison-James R-9 remodeled 1962 Picture Book, 1866-1959, (Albuquerque: Menaul Historical Library of the Southwest, 1983), 25; aerial photographs 109 1950 Unknown Unknown; 1950 Carolyn Atkins, The Allison-James R-8 remodeled 1962 Picture Book, 1866-1959, (Albuquerque: Menaul Historical Library of the Southwest, 1983), 25; aerial photographs 111 Pre-1960, Unknown Unknown; Pre-1960, Aerial photographs R-6 moved to remodeled 1962 moved to site • site 116/120 Pre-1957, Unknown; 110: Unknown; Pre-1957, Drawings and aerial photographs R-7 with c.1984 Philippe Register and renovated 1967; with c.1984 additions Associates remodeled 1986 additions 1984 120: remodeled/ Renovated 1962 Key: *The year the consultant originally estimated, as presented in March 28, 2018, Plaza del Monte, Santa Fe, Historic Resources Evaluation report. **Taken from "As of 1988" table of appraiser's estimate of construction dates. The table was referenced in sworn testimony during the April24, 2018, Historic Districts Review Board hearing. The Board did not see the table nor was it introduced in the record. The consultant took an iPhone image of the table at the hearing (Figure 5). ***The consultant's original and/or revised estimate based on best sources available, including dated aerial photographs, dated architectural drawings and dated city directory entries, and previously unavailable February 28, 1968 and February 27, 1969 aerial photographs, NMDOT provided to consultant on April30, 2018. 6 95Table 2: Santa Fe County Assessor Dates Address Consultant's Original Santa Fe County and/or Revised Assessor Estimate** Estimate* CAMINO SANTIAGO 101 102 R-2 103 R-12 105 R-14 106 R-3 109 R-15 110 112) R-5 111 113 114 R-26 115 117 118 119 120 R-25 c.1967-68 Before 1966 Before 1966 1971 · Before 1966 Before 1966 110: c.1962 112: c.1968 Before 1966 c.1970 c.1972 c.1970 1966-67 1973 Before 1966 c. 1971 1964 1964 1964 1964 1964 1964 1969 No Date Provided 1964 No Date Provided 1964 1964 1969 1968 Errors with County Estimated Dates Does not appear on May 2, 1966 aerial photograph . Only May 2, 1966 aerial photograph available for the period Does not appear on May 2, 1966 aerial photograph Does not appear on either May 2, 1966 or February 27, 1969 aerial photographs Only May 2, 1966 aerial photograph available for the period Only May 2, 1966 aerial photograph available for the period Appears on May 2, 1966 aerial photograph Does not appear on either May 2, 1966 or February17, 1969 aerial photographs Does not appear on either May 2, 1966 or February 27, 1969 aerial photographs Only May 2, 1966 aerial photograph available for the period Does not appear on February 27, 1969 aerial photograph; still under construction on May 3, 1973 aerial photograph Appears on May 2, 1966 aerial photograph Does not appear on February 2L.ll69 aerial photogr_'!Qh 7 96ddress Consultant's Original Santa Fe County and/or Revised Assessor Estimate** Estimate* 121 c.1971 1969 R-20 122 c.1971 1968 124 c.1967 1968 R-23 125 c.1970 No Date Provided R-21 126 c.1967 No Date Provided R-24 126 c.1968/ No Date Provided Garage 1977 CAMINO MATIAS 104 .OS R-10 107 R-9 109 R-8 111 Before 1966 1968 1950 1964 19SO 1964 19SO 1964 Pre-1960, 1969 R-6 moved to site 116/120 R-7 Key: Pre-1957, No Date Provided with c.1984 additions Errors with County Estimated Dates Does not aQQear on Februar'i 27, 1969 aerial QhotograQh Does not aQQear on Februar'i 27, 1969 aerial QhotograQh AQQears on Ma'i 2, 1966 aerial QhotograQh Documented as constructed in 1950 in Carol'in Atkins, The Allison-James Picture Book, 1866-1959, (Albuquerque: Menaul Historical Librar'i of the Southwest, 1983), 25, and aQQears on 1951 aerial QhotograQh Documented as constructed in 19SO in Carol'in Atkins, The Allison-James Picture Book, 1866-1959, (Albuquerque: Menaul Historical Librar'i of the Southwest, 1983). 2S, and aQQears on 19S1 aerial QhotograQh Documented as constructed in 1950 in Carol'in Atkins, The Allison-James Picture Book, 1866-1959, (Albuquerque: Menaul Historical Library of the Southwest, 1983), 2S, and aQQears on 19S1 aerial QhotograQh AQQears on Ma'i 2, 1966 aerial QhotograQh *The consultant's original and/or revised estimate based on best sources available, including dated aerial photographs, dated architectural drawings and dated city directory entries, and previously unavailable February 28, 1968 and February 27, 1969 aerial photographs, NMDOT provided to consultant on April30, 2018, and additional review of images after May 15 hearing. **Dates as taken from Santa Fe County Assessor parcel map (http://assessor.santafecountvnm.gov/map.php) on May 17, 2018. Web page states the information was accurate as of April3, 2018. 8 97Figures and Aerial Photographs Figure 1: 126 A Camino Santiago, Garage/Carport Structure, retaining wall, May 3, 2018. 9 98Figure 2: 124 Camino Santiago, rear retaining wall, May 3, 2018. 10 99Figure 3: c.1950 concrete retaining in front of 107 Camino Matias. January 18, 2018. 11 100Figure 4: Stucco-on-block property wall between 114 and 118 Camino Santiago, January 18, 2018. 12 101•• }4 . I.D. R·l R-2 R-3 R-4 R·Sa R·Sb G.<.:. R-6 - R-7a - R·7b R-8 R-9 R-10 , R·ll R-12 R·l4a R·l4b R-l4c R·l4d c..P R·lS R-16 R·l7a R·l7b R-18 Rfl -R-19 115 "J R-20 Th~- R-2111 R·2lb R-2lc R·2ld R-22 R-23 R-24& R·24b' R•24c R-24d R-25 "1!- • R-26 ... ...... . . . -. .?.. . ,. ,.: ~ j I .. ' . ... .. .. ·. ·, ,. .: . !- . .. • • . : . ;,......• ... · ~ ~~\- •. . ... ... .4. N.!U .·.·. , ' ,. ~ ... P $1.§... 6 . J_.t:Qi....# Street Address Area Roan ClcNnt 104 Camino Matias '1)'!?! of ~llina CSa.Ft.) CTotaH!eclrOCIIIS-Baths ) 1<>e CYrs.) Ccmrents Single-FIIi!iily 944 4·2-l.S 26 - I q .- 2-- 102 Camino Matias Single-Fulily 944 4-2-1.5 :2"6 .., 106 Camino Matias Single-Fulily 944 ,4-2•1.5 26 118 Camino Santi.ago Single-fllllll.ly 1,141 5-2-2 16 110 Camino Matias ~lex 897 5-2-1 26 112 Camino Matias ~lex 839 4-l-1 26 ~tiel\ 1968 lll Cami.no Mlitias Sinqle-l'aniUy 1,433 6-3-2 ttlknown llelrocleleci/IW.ovatecl 1962 .116 Camino Matias ~lex ).,072 q 7. 'I 4-2-2 ttlknown •Renovated 1967. Ra!o:!elecl 1986 120 Cami.no Matias ~lex 1,099 4-2-2 ttlknown Renovated 1962, JlonQ!elecl 1986 109 camino Matias Single-Fu\ily r 1,0""9 • 5-2-l !Wa\own llemoclel~Uld 1962 107 camino Matias Single-flllllily 932 4-2-l " ~ -..:!eleclll\enavaUld 1962 lOS 0111\ino Matias Sinqle-FIIJiily N..z 5-Z·l ttlknown llemocleleci/IW"ooYaud 1962 101 Camino Santiago Sinqle-FIImily l, 3 4-2-1 20 103 camino Santiago Sinqle-FIIIIily 1,064 5-2-2 "'2'11 10511 Cami.no Santiago Fourplex 926 • 4-2-l 26 l05b Cami.no Santiago Fouqllex 699 3-2-l 26 lOSe CUiino Santiago Fourplex 699 3-2-1 26 lOSd Cllmi.no Santiago Fouq>le:x ~26 4-2-1 26 109 Cllmi.no Santiago Single-Fu\ily 1,029 //C. . (. 4-2-2 25 lll Camino Santiago Single-Family '1 ,o8f 4-2-2 25 USa C11mi.no Santiago ~lex 1,052 4-2-2 18 Wb Camino Santiago ~lex 1,179 4-2-2 18 117 Camino Santiago Single-Fu\ily 1,356 1((.. 6-2-2 lkUcnown E:stilnatecl effective age 2D-25 yrs. "119 Camino Santiago Single-Family 1,105 5-2-l 25 121 Calllino Santiago Single-nani1y 1, 15~ 5-2-2 18 12511 CAmino Santiago Fouq>l.X . 944 • 9 :t 4.:2-r 19 Jl2Sb Camino Santiago fbllrplex 676 3-2-1 19 12So CAmino Slnti&go Fourplex 676 3tl 19 "' ,,, 9 l25d camino Santiago Fourplex 944 4-2-1 }.9 122 Cami.no Santiago Single-Fu\ily 1,218 5-2-2 llnlcnc:wn Estilnatecl effective age 20-25 yrs. 124 Cami.no Santiago Single-FIIIIi1y 1,153 4-2-2 w ~ ·126& Camino Santiago Fourplex 690 3-1-l ,.,126b Camino Santiago Fourplex 690 3-1-1 I 126c Camino Santiago Fourplex 690 3-1-1 126d Cami.no Santiago Follq)lex 690 3-1-1 120 Cillllino Santiago Sing1e-fllllli1y 1,259 5·2·2 18,. ; .114 Camino Santiago Single-F'IIInily 1,318 / ' '• 4-2-2 17 /·J . Figure 5: iPhone image of c.1988 Plaza del Monte appraiser report referenced at April 24, 2018 hearing. 13 102Aerial1: Portion of May 2, 1966 aerial photograph. Source: NMDOT- 05-02-66_0015. 14 103ft-. r Aerial 2: Portion of February 28, 1968 aerial photograph. Source: NMDOT - 02_28_68_0021. 15 104(C Aerial 3: Portion of February 27, 1969 aerial photograph. Source: NMDOT -1969_2_27 _4071. 16 105Aerial 4: Portion of May 11, 1973 aerial photograph showing 118 Camino Santiago under construction. Source: NMDOT- 05-11-73_0053. 17 106Appendix A: Complete Email Communications between John Murphey and Alane Wainwright, January 16 to May 4, 2018. (see attached) 18 107Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Base Form (FORM 1) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs use only: 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte 5. Property Type: j_ Buildings: Structures: _ Site _ Object 6. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 7. Previous Survey Date(s): Yes: _x_ No: 8. Name of Project: HDRB status review Plaza del Monte 9. Lat/Long: 35.693490, -105.934887 District 2. Location: 101 Camino Santiago Downtown and Eastside Historic District 10. Photo Information Negative: John Murphey View of: Front, south elevation, facing north. 11. Brief Description of the Property: Situated near the east entrance to Plaza del Monte, the house is a rough ly 1,332-square-foot contemporary residence constructed in 1967-68. In plan, the three-bedroom dwelling has a square form with an attached L-shaped portal and garage, giving it a combined square footprint. It presents to the street a long portal w ith the roof carrying over the garage. It is fenestrated with aluminum windows, primarily of a sliding operation . A pane led wood door gives entry to the residence at the east end of portal. The garage entry is fitted with a recent vinyl overhead door. Cementitious brocade stucco in a peach tone covers the frame building. The roof consists of a mixture of gravel and asphalt material. An interior parapet outlines the dwelling portion of the mass. While contemporary in form, the vigas across the portal give the residence a regional feel. _x_Known 14. Setting: _x_ Suburban _ Rural _ Village _ Urban If Urban: Commercial lndustrial _x_ Residential Public 15. Relationship to Surroundings: _x_ Similar Dissimilar Comments: N/A 108(Continued from other side) Source: Google Imagery, 2018 19. Is Property Endangered? Unknown _x_ No Yes How? 17. Surveyor: (your name, address, telephone number, and any group affiliation) John W. Murphey Architectural Historian Firstlight Consulting 505-5 77-7 593 John@archhistorvservices.com For: Wayne S. Lloyd, A.I.A., Lloyd and Associates, Architects 18. Owner (if known) and other knowledgeable people: Plaza del Monte, LLC J. Significance to Current Community: _x_ Unknown _ None _ Low _ Moderate _ High Describe: Unknown 21. Other Significance or Information of Interest: (such as historical, legendary, structural, former ownership, etc.) The house was constructed as part of the independent living section of Plaza del Monte, a Presbyterian residential community for retired clergy, missionaries and other professional staff. Developed between 1960 and 1977, Plaza del Monte operated as a retirement center until1988. The first resident identified with the house is Sam M. Dean, who is listed as a tenant in the 1970 Santa Fe city directory. 22. National or State Register: Is this property individually listed on a historic register? _ Unknown _x_ No Yes If yes: _State National If 'no' or unknown, do you think this property is eligible for listing? No _x_Yes Wh ? See Anal sis of Historical Status. 23. National or State Historic District: Is this property in a historic district? Unknown No _x_ Yes If yes: _ Contributing _x_ Non-contributing _ No Status If 'yes', what is the name of the district? _State _National _x_ City of Santa: Downtown and Eastside Historic District 24. Supplemental Forms: None _x_ HCPI Detail Form (FORM 2) _ Continuation Sheets, # pages: ______ Recommended Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District, March 28, 2018 109Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs Plaza del Monte 101 Camino Santiago Downtown and Eastside Historic District 6. Visible Construction Material: Adobe Brick Concrete: Concrete: Cast Stone Poured Metal: Metal: Corrugated Structural Siding Stone: Random Stone: Coursed River Rock _x_Stucco: Tile: Clay Wood: Horizontal Wood: Siding Jacal _Wood: Tongue and Groove 10. Windows* Operation Material Casement Aluminum Sliding Aluminum _ Composition Concrete: Block Earth Plaster Metal: V-Crimp Stone:- Rusticated Vinyl Siding Wood: Log N/A Glazing Single 1-1 _Masonry: Simulated Stone: Random Ashlar Stone: Tabular Wood: Board and Batten _Wood: Shingle Other: Frame Number•• 11 2 *Because of storm covers, the operation and material information is not definite. 11. Doors Type Single-Leaf Single-Leaf Garage 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte lnvento 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 8. Foundation: Not visible _x_ At Grade Materials: _x_ Concrete Other: _____ Notes: 9. Roof: N/A Shape: _x_Fiat None Raised Stone _ Hipped _ Pyramidal Shed Other: Pitch: None Low _ Medium _ Steep Features: Eave: _x_ Parapets Materials: _Asphalt Earth _x_ Gravel _ Composition shingle _ Metal: Pressed _Composition Roll _Metal: Corrugated Metal: Standing Seam Metal: V- Crimp _Tile: Terra Cotta _Wood: Shingle Other: N/A Style Material Raised Square Panel Wood %-Light Wood Sectional Vinyl 13. Porches N/A Number 1 1 1 Type: _x_ Entry- portal Wrap Partial-Width Full-Width 14. Other Si nificant Features N/A 15. Modifications: .! No known modifications #1 Date: Unknown; replaced garage door; and material and visual evidence. 110HCPI Detail Form FORM 2) (Continued from other side) 16. Primary Architectural Style Art Deco/Streamline Moderne . Bungalow/Craftsman Colonial Revival Folk Victorian Notes: Gothic Revival International ltalianate Mediterranean 17. Documents Available and Their Locations New Mexico Historic Preservation Division 407 Galisteo Street, Suite 236 Santa Fe, NM 87501 (505) 827-6320 Are associated properties eligible for listing? No 19. Site Plan: Current plan is not available Mission Revival Neo-Classical Northern NM Prairie Pueblo Queen Anne Ranch _Spanish-Colonial _ Spanish-Pueblo Revival Territorial Territorial Revival Tudor Revival Other: Contemporary with Spanish-Pueblo Revival ornamentation Historic Preservation Division Land Use Department City of Santa Fe 200 Lincoln Avenue Santa Fe, NM 87504 (505) 955-6605 111-,~~fitii Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 1. Name of property: 2. Location: Plaza del Monte 101 Camino Santiago Downtown and Eastside Historic District Evaluation of Historical Status Plaza del Monte lnvento 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Representing a Contemporary design, the house does not harmonize or contribute to the historical character of the district. For this reason, the recommendation is to maintain 101 Camino Santiago a Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District. Ordinance Definition - "Contributing Structure" A structure, located in a historic district, approximately fifty years old or older that helps to establish and maintain the character of that historic district. Although a contributing structure is not unique in itself, it adds to the historic associations or historic architectural design qualities that are significant for a district. The contributing structure may have had minor alterations, but its integrity remains. 112Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs - ,r HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 101 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte lnvento_!Y Downtown and Eastside Historic 4. County: Santa Fe District 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Illustrations Figure 1: May 2, 1966 aerial photograph. Building not present. Courtesy NMDOT. 113Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -<>r HPD Office use only: ,CPINo. District No. 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: 101 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic 4. County: Santa Fe District 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Figure 2: February 27, 1969 aerial photograph Building present. Courtesy NMDOT. 114Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -1r HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 101 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic 4. County: Santa Fe District 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Survey Photographs (All images taken by John Murphey on January 18, 2018, except where indicated) Photo 1: Street elevation and north elevations, facing northwest. 115Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -1r HPD Office use only: PINse complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPI No. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 101 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic 4. County: Santa Fe District 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 2: Street and west elevations, facing northeast. 116Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -1r HPD Office use only: _.CPINo. District No. 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: 101 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 3: North elevation, facing south and southwest (Sharon Joyce, February 23, 2018). 117Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Base Form (FORM 1) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs Office use only: 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Residence 2 5. Property Type: 1._ Buildings: Structures: _ Site _ Object 6. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 7. Previous Survey Date(s): Yes: _x_ No: 8. Name of Project: HDRB status review Plaza del Monte 9. Lat/Long: 35.693288, -105 .935161 10. Photo Information 2. Location: 102 Camino Santiago Downtown and Eastside Historic District Negative: John Murphey 11. Brief Description of the Property: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: N/A Plaza del Monte mv~•nrnrv 4. County: Santa Fe One of the earliest units to be constructed at Plaza del Monte, 102 Camino Santiago is a 2,064-square-foot dwelling with one addition. The two-bedroom, flat-roof house faces Cam ino Matias. It shows to the street a fa~ade-long portal, continuing at the south end as a single-space carport. The portal is supported by shiplap wood girders resting on round posts with double-ended corbels. Most of the portal fa~ade is painted white . A line of vigas runs along the top of the wall. The elevation is penetrated by two doors and large windows, with the southernmost window not meeting the ordinance in regard to its distance from the corner. The north elevation facing Camino Santiago displays a variety of window openings holding tall metal casements . A shallow overhang supported by short vigas carries over most of the elevation. At the northeast corner is a room block-like projection holding the bedroom wing. The rear (east) elevation presents a number of alterations. The largest is a post-1969 addition, over what was a patio . The 380-square-foot addition is fenestrated with modern windows and is sheltered by a parapet-type portal. The house was constructed in c.1965; its designer/architect is unknown but assumed to be Kenneth S. Clark and Philippe Register. entries Rural Vi Urban If Urban: Commercial Industrial Residential ic " · Relationship to Surroundings: _x_ Similar Dissimilar Comments: N/A 118(Continued from other side) North Box Indicates Post-1968 Addition Source: Google Imagery, 2018 19. Is Property Endangered? Unknown _x_ No Yes How? 17. Surveyor: (your name, address, telephone number, and any group affiliation) John W. Murphey Architectural Historian Firstlight Consulting 505-577-7593 John@archhistoryservices.com For: Wayne S. Lloyd, A. I.A., Lloyd and Associates, Architects 18. Owner (if known) and other knowledgeable people: Plaza del Monte, LLC J. Significance to Current Community: _x_ Unknown _None _Low _Moderate _ High Describe: Unknown 21. Other Significance or Information of Interest: (such as historical, legendary, structural, former ownership, etc.) The house was constructed as part of the independent living section of Plaza del Monte, a Presbyterian residential community for retired clergy, missionaries and other professional staff. Developed between 1960 and 1977, Plaza del Monte operated as a retirement center until1988. The first resident identified with the house is Gaylord Knox, who is listed as a tenant in the 1966 Santa Fe city directory. 22. National or State Register: Is this property individually listed on a historic register? _U nknown _x_ No Yes If yes: _State National If 'no' or unknown, do you think this property is eligible for listing? No _x_Yes Wh ? See Anal sis of Historical Status. 23. National or State Historic District: Is this property in a historic district? Unknown No _x_ Yes If yes: _Contributing _x_ Non-contributing_ No Status If 'yes', what is the name of the district? _State _National _x_ City of Santa: Downtown and Eastside Historic District 24. Supplemental Forms: None _x_ HCPI Detail Form (FORM 2) _ Continuation Sheets, # pages: ______ Recommended Contributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District, March 28, 2018 119Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: 102 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte lnvePlaza del Monte Residence 2 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe Adobe Brick _ Composition Concrete: Block Concrete: Concrete: Earth _Masonry: Cast Stone Poured Plaster Simulated Metal: Metal: Metal: Stone: Corrugated Structural V-Crimp Random Siding Ashlar Stone: Random Stone: Stone: Stone: Tabular- Coursed River Rock Rusticated _x_Stucco: Tile: _Vinyl Wood: Board Clay Siding and Batten Wood: Horizontal Wood: Wood: _Wood: Shingle Siding Jacal Log _Wood: Tongue and Groove Other: Frame 10. Windows* N/A Operation Material Glazing Number** Casement Aluminum Single 9 Fixed Aluminum Single 3 Fixed Aluminum Single, flanked by 1 Casement Fixed Aluminum 12 4 *Because of storm covers, the operation and material information is not definite. **Includes units 12. Chimneys 11. Doors Type Single-Leaf Single-Leaf Double 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 7. Number of Stories: N/A Number: _x_1 _11/2 2 21/2 Other· 8. Foundation: N/A Not visible None _x_ At Grade Raised Materials: _x_ Concrete Stone Other: _____ Notes: 9. Roof: N/A Shape: _x_Fiat Hipped Pyramidal Shed Other: Pitch: None Low _ Medium _Steep Features: Eave: _x_ Parapets Materials: _Asphalt Earth _x_ Gravel _Composition shingle _ Metal: Pressed _Composition Roll _Metal: Corrugated _Metal: Standing Seam_ Metal: V- Crimp _Tile: Terra Cotta _Wood: Shingle Other: N/A Style Material Raised Square Panel Wood Full-Light Aluminum Carport Storage Doors Wood 13. Porches N/A Number 2 1 2 One, stucco-clad inside parapet Type: _x_ Entry· portal Wrap Partial-Width Full-Width #1 Date: Post-1969; addition to rear, northeast corner; aerial photographs and material and visual evidence. 120(Continued from other side) 16. Primary Architectural Style _Not Applicable Art Deco/Streamline Moderne _Bungalow/Craftsman Colonial Revival Folk Victorian Notes: Gothic Revival International ltalianate Mediterranean 17. Documents Available and Their Locations New Mexico Historic Preservation Division 407 Galisteo Street, Suite 236 Santa Fe, NM 87501 (505) 827-6320 Are associated properties eligible for listing? No 19. Site Plan: Current plan is not available. Pueblo Queen Anne Ranch Mission Revival Neo·Ciassical Northern NM Prairie _ Spanish·Colonial Other: Historic Preservation Division Land Use Department City of Santa Fe 200 Lincoln Avenue Santa Fe, NM 87504 (505) 955-6605 _x_ Spanish-Pueblo Revival Territorial Territorial Revival Tudor Revival 121Plaza del Monte Residence 2 Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: 102 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte lnuon•n•·u Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Evaluation of Historical Status Constructed before 1968, and representing the original Clark and Register design template for the Plaza del Monte retirement homes, the house is a good example of the "Santa Fe style." For this reason, the recommendation is to designate 102 Camino Santiago a Contributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District. Ordinance Definition - "Contributing Structure" A structure, located in a historic district, approximately fifty years old or older that helps to establish and maintain the character of that historic district. Although a contributing structure is not unique in itself, it adds to the historic associations or historic architectural design qualities that are significant for a district. The contributing structure may have had minor alterations, but its integrity remains. 122Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -l! HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location : 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 102 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 2 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Illustrations Figure 1: May 2, 1966 aerial photograph. Building present; pre-addition. Courtesy NMDOT. 123Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -qr HPD Office use only: ,cPI No. District No. 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Residence 2 Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 NRHP SRCP Criteria _A. B c 0 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe 10 #: 102 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Figure 2: February 27, 1969 aerial photograph Building present, pre-addition. Courtesy NMDOT. 124Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs For HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 HCPI No. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria _A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 102 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 2 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Survey Photographs (All images taken by John Murphey on January 18, 2018, except where indicated) Photo 1: Street elevation and south elevations, facing northeast. 125Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -1r HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe 10 #: Plaza del Monte 102 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 2 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 2: North and street elevations, facing southeast. 126Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs ~ ,r HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 ~o~PINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria _A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 102 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 2 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 3: East elevation, facing northwest. Non-historic addition on left. 127Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Base Form (FORM 1) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs - "'1( HPD Office use only: L:PI No. 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Residence 6 5. Property Type: j_ Buildings: Structures: _Site _Object 6. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 7. Previous Survey Date(s): Yes: _x_ No: 8. Name of Project: HDRB status review Plaza del Monte 9. Lat/Long: 35.693597, -105.935145 District No. NRHP 2. Location: 103 Camino Santiago Downtown and Eastside Historic District SRCP Criteria A B C _D 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: N/A Plaza del Monte lnvento 4. County: Santa Fe 10. Photo Information Negative: John Murphey View of: Front, south elevation, facing northwest. 11. Brief Description of the Property: Roughly 1,533 square-feet, the one-story residence is designed as an L-plan form. The plan puts the bedrooms in a cube- like mass, with the remainder of the functions of the house strung along a linear spine. Its fa~ade is defined by a long portal sheltering its entry and patio doors. The east end of the composition terminates as a one-bay carport. A line of vigas runs along the back (north) elevation supporting a short overhang. An exterior chimney breaks through the overhang, rising several feet above the roof. The house is fenestrated with an array of original and replacement aluminum windows . It is entered under the portal through a stylized wood panel door flanked by one set of sidelights. The dwelling's flat roof is outlined by a short parapet; the roof is covered with gravel. The frame structure is finished with cementitious brocade stucco in the buckskin tone. While contemporary in form, vigas used across the portal and the room block bedroom wing give the residence a Spanish-Pueblo Revival feel. The house was constructed in c.1965; its architect/designer is unknown but assumed to be architect Philippe Register. 13. Construction Date: c.1965 _x_Known _x_ Source: aerial photographs, city directory entries 14. Setting: _x_ Suburban _Rural _Village _ Urban If Urban: Commercial lndustrial_x_ Residentiai_Public i. Relationship to Surroundings: _x_ Similar Dissimilar Comments: N/A 128(Continued from other side) Source: Google Imagery, 2018 19. Is Property Endangered? Unknown _x_ No Yes How? 17. Surveyor: (your name, address, telephone number, and any group affiliation) John W. Murphey Architectural Historian Firstlight Consulting 505-577-7593 John@archhistorvservices.com For: Wayne S. Lloyd, A. I.A., Lloyd and Associates, Architects 18. Owner (if known) and other knowledgeable people: Plaza del Monte, LLC J. Significance to Current Community: _x_ Unknown _None _Low _ Moderate _High Describe: Unknown 21. Other Significance or Information of Interest: (such as historical, legendary, structural, former ownership, etc.) The house was constructed as part of the independent living section of Plaza del Monte, a Presbyterian residential community for retired clergy, missionaries and other professional staff. Developed between 1960 and 1977, Plaza del Monte operated as a retirement center until1988. The first resident identified with the house is Joseph McNeill, who is listed as a tenant in the 1966 Santa Fe city directory. 22. National or State Register: Is this property individually listed on a historic register? _Unknown _x_ No Yes If yes: _State National If 'no' or unknown, do you think this property is eligible for listing? No _x_Yes Wh ? See Anal sis of Historical Status. Is this property in a historic district? Unknown No _x_ Yes If yes: _Contributing _x_ Non-contributing_ No Status If 'yes', what is the name of the district? _State _National _x_ City of Santa: Downtown and Eastside Historic District 24. Supplemental Forms: None _x_ HCPI Detail Form (FORM 2) _Continuation Sheets, # pages: ______ Recommended Contributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District, March 28, 2018 129Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: 103 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte lnv~>nrnruPlaza del Monte Residence 6 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe Adobe Concrete: Cast Stone Metal: Corrugated Stone: Random Coursed Brick Concrete: Poured Metal: Structural Siding Stone: River Rock _x_Stucco: Tile: Clay Wood: Horizontal Wood: Siding Jacal _Wood: Tongue and Groove 10. Windows• Operation Material Sliding Aluminum Fixed Aluminum _ Composition Earth Plaster Metal: V-Crimp Stone:- Rusticated _Vinyl Siding Wood: Log Concrete: Block _Masonry: Simulated Stone: Random Ashlar Stone: Tabular Wood: Board and Batten _Wood: Shingle Other: Frame N/A Glazing 1-1 Single Number** 9 2 *Because of storm covers, the operation and material information is not definite. **Includes units 12. Chimneys 11. Doors Type Single-Leaf Single-Leaf 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 7. Number of Stories: Number: _x_1 _11/2 2 21/2 Other· 8. Foundation: N/A Not visible _x_ At Grade Materials: _x_ Concrete Other: _____ Notes: 9. Roof: N/A Shape: _x_Fiat None Raised Stone _ Hipped _ Pyramidal Shed Other: Pitch: None Low _ Medium _ Steep Features: Eave: _x_ Parapets Materials: _Asphalt Earth _x_ Gravel _Composition shingle _Metal: Pressed _Composition Roll _Metal: Corrugated _Metal: Standing Seam_ Metal: V- Crimp _Tile: Terra Cotta _Wood: Shingle Other: N/A Style Material Raised Square Panel Wood Raised Square Panel, Wood w/single sidelight 13. Porches N/A Number 1 1 One, stucco-clad, exposed on north elevation Type: _x_ Entry· portal Wrap Partial-Width Full-Width #1 Date: Unknown; replaced windows; visual and material evidence 130(Continued from other side) 16. Primary Architectural Style _ Not Applicable Art Deco/Streamline Mod erne Bungalow/Craftsman Colonial Revival Folk Victorian Notes: Gothic Revival International ltalianate Mediterranean 17. Documents Available and Their Locations New Mexico Historic Preservation Division 407 Galisteo Street, Suite 236 Santa Fe, NM 87501 (505) 827-6320 Are associated properties eligible for listing? No 19. Site Plan: Current plan is not available. Pueblo Queen Anne Ranch Mission Revival Neo-Classical Northern NM Prairie _Spanish-Colonial Other: Historic Preservation Division Land Use Department City of Santa Fe 200 Lincoln Avenue Santa Fe, NM 87504 (505) 955-6605 _x_ Spanish-Pueblo Revival Territorial Territorial Revival Tudor Revival 131Plaza del Monte Residence 6 Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: 103 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte ln\/eontnr" Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Evaluation of Historical Status Constructed before 1968, and representing the original Clark and Register design template for the Plaza del Monte retirement homes, the house is a good example of the "Santa Fe style." For this reason, the recommendation is to designate 103 Camino Santiago a Contributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District. Ordinance Definition - "Contributing Structure" A structure, located in a historic district, approximately fifty years old or older that helps to establish and maintain the character of that historic district. Although a contributing structure is not unique in itself, it adds to the historic associations or historic architectural design qualities that are significant for a district. The contributing structure may have had minor alterations, but its integrity remains. 132Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs ~ r HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe 10 #: Plaza del Monte 103 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 6 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Illustrations Figure 1: May 2, 1966 aerial photograph. Courtesy NMDOT. 133Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs --·} 1 HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 PI No. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 103 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 6 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Survey Photographs {All images taken by John Murphey on January 18, 2018, except where indicated) Photo 1: Street and east elevations, facing northwest. 134Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs qr HPD Office use only: CPINo. 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Residence 6 Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria .A. B c D 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: 103 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 2: Street and west elevations (top), facing northeast; west elevation, facing south (Sharon Joyce, February 23, 2018). 135Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -1r HPD Office use only: CPINo. District No. 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Residence 6 Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 NRHP SRCP Criteria _A B c D 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: 103 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 3: North elevation, facing southwest (Sharon Joyce, February 23, 2018). 136Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Base Form (FORM 1) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs use only: Plaza del Monte Residence 14 5. Property Type: j_ Buildings: Structures: _ Site _ Object 6. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 7. Previous Survey Date(s): Yes: _x_ No: 8. Name of Project: HDRB status review Plaza del Monte 9. Lat/Long: 35.693730, -105.935558 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: N/A 105 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte lnu,ontnru Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe ..... ~ .-1 Forming a long, linear composition, 105 Camino Santiago is one of three apartment bui ldings erected at Plaza del Monte. The carport- dominated structure works its way down the slope as two L-plan units joined together at the center by a laundry room. The structure is bookended by masses holding the apartments. The larger apartments containing two bedrooms are situated in the projecting roomblocks. The apartments share a party wall at the living room. Spanning between the apartments are the carports and the laundry room. The carports are detailed with a viga-roof structure which continues as a portal along the inner apartments. The rear (north) elevation is divided into small patios. The apartments are entered through wood panel doors; solid wood doors give access to the storage units and the laundry. The original multi-light steel casement windows have been replaced with aluminum units. A short parapet follows the outline of the apartments, and is penetrated on the south, east and west elevations with cut-through metal canales. The frame structure is finished with cementitious brocade stucco in a peach tone. While contemporary in form, the vigas used across the portales and carports and the cubed apartment masses give the residence a regional feel. The roughly 4,198-square- foot apartment building was constructed in 1971, after a design by architect Philippe Register. Rural Urban If Urban: Commercial Industrial Residential ic 15. Relationship to Surroundings: _x_ Similar Dissimilar Comments: N/A 137(Continued from other side) Unknown _x_ No Yes How? 17. Surveyor: (your name, address, telephone number, and any group affiliation) John W. Murphey Architectural Historian Firstlight Consulting 505-577-7593 John@archhistorvservices.com For: Wayne S. Lloyd, A. I.A., Lloyd and Associates, Architects 18. Owner (if known) and other knowledgeable people: Plaza del Monte, LLC 20. Significance to Current Community: _x_ Unknown _None _ Low _ Moderate _High Describe: Unknown 21. Other Significance or Information of Interest: (such as historical, legendary, structural, former ownership, etc.) The apartments were constructed as part of the independent living section of Plaza del Monte, a Presbyterian residential community for retired clergy, missionaries and other professional staff. Developed between 1960 and 1977, Plaza del Monte operated as a retirement center until1988. The first residents identified are Ruth Erwin and Ellen Foster. They are listed as tenants in the 1972 Santa Fe city directory. 22. National or State Register: Is this property individually listed on a historic register? _Unknown _x_ No Yes If yes: _State National If 'no' or unknown, do you think this property is eligible for listing? No _x_Yes Wh ? See Anal sis of Historical Status. 23. National or State Historic District: Is this property in a historic district? Unknown No _x_ Yes If yes: _ Contributing _ Non-contributing _x_ No Status If 'yes', what is the name of the district? _ State _ National _x_ City of Santa: Downtown and Eastside Historic District '.Supplemental Forms: None _x_ HCPI Detail Form _Continuation Sheets, # a es: Recommended Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District, March 28, 2018 138Historic Cultural Properties Inventory {HCPI) Detail Form {FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: 105 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte 1""'"ntnn•Plaza del Monte Residence 14 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe Adobe Brick Concrete: Concrete: Cast Stone Poured Metal: Metal: Corrugated Structural Siding Stone: Random Stone: Coursed River Rock _x_Stucco: Tile: Clay Wood: Horizontal Wood: Siding Jacal _Wood: Tongue and Groove 10. Windows* Operation Material Sliding Aluminum Sliding Aluminum Composition Concrete: Block Earth _Masonry: Plaster Simulated Metal: Stone: V-Crimp Random Ashlar Stone: Stone: Tabular- Rusticated _Vinyl Wood: Board Siding and Batten Wood: Wood: Shingle Log Other: Frame N/A Glazing 1-1 1-1 F-1 Number** 10 4 *Because of storm covers, the operation and material information is not definite. **Includes units 12. Chimneys 11. Doors Type Single-Leaf Single-Leaf Sliding 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 8. Foundation: Not visible _x_ At Grade Materials: _x_ Concrete Other: _____ Notes: 9. Roof: N/A Shape: _x_Fiat N/A None Raised Stone _Hipped_ Pyramidal Shed Other: Pitch: None Low _ Medium _Steep Features: Eave: _x_ Parapets Materials: _x_ Asphalt Earth Gravel _Composition shingle _Metal: Pressed _Composition Roll _Metal: Corrugated Metal: Standing Seam Metal: V- Crimp Tile: Terra Cotta _Wood: Shingle Other: N/A Style Raised Square Panel wl View Light Flush[?] Patio Material Wood Wood Aluminum 13. Porches N/A Number 4 12 8 4, stucco-clad, north exposure Type: _x_ Entry- portal Wrap Partial-Width Full-Width _x_ No known modifications 139HCPI Detail Form (FORM 2 (Continued from other side) 16. Primary Architectural Style _Not Applicable Art Deco/Streamline Moderne Bungalow/Craftsman Colonial Revival Folk Victorian Notes: Gothic Revival International ltalianate Mediterranean 17. Documents Available and Their Locations New Mexico Historic Preservation Division 407 Galisteo Street, Suite 236 Santa Fe, NM 87501 (505) 827-6320 Are associated properties eligible for listing? No 19. Site Plan: Current plan is not available. Mission Revival Neo-Classical Northern NM Prairie Pueblo Queen Anne Ranch _ Spanish-Colonial _ Spanish-Pueblo Revival Territorial Territorial Revival Tudor Revival Other: Contemporary with Spanish-Pueblo Revival ornamentation Historic Preservation Division Land Use Department City of Santa Fe 200 Lincoln Avenue Santa Fe, NM 87504 (505) 955-6605 140Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs Plaza del Monte Residence 14 105 Camino Santiago Downtown and Eastside Historic District Evaluation of Historical Status 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte lnve 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Representing a Contemporary design, the building does not harmonize or contribute to the historical character of the district. In addition, constructed in 1971, it does not meet the minimum age threshold for consideration. For this reason, the recommendation is to designate 105 Camino Santiago a Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District. Ordinance Definition - "Contributing Structure" A structure, located in a historic district, approximately fifty years old or older that helps to establish and maintain the character of that historic district. Although a contributing structure is not unique in itself, it adds to the historic associations or historic architectural design qualities that are significant for a district. The contributing structure may have had minor alterations, but its integrity remains. 141Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs ~"'~' HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 .;p1 No. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 105 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 14 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Illustrations Figure 1: May 2, 1966 aerial photograph. Building not present. Courtesy NMDOT. 142Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs ~ bHPD Office use only: PI No. District No. 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Residence 14 Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 NRHP SRCP Criteria ..A B c D 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe 10 #: 105 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Figure 2: February 27, 1969 aerial photograph Building not present. Courtesy NMDOT. 143Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs - . r HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 ,CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria _;.. B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 105 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 14 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Survey Photographs (All images taken by John Murphey on January 18, 2018, except where indicated) Photo 1: Street elevation and east elevations, facing northwest. 144Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs ~ ~~r HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPI No. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe 10 #: Plaza del Monte 105 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 14 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 2: Street and west elevations, facing northeast. 145Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -1r HPD Office use only: CPINo. District No. 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Residence 14 Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: 105 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 3: East Unit (top), facing northeast; West Unit (bottom), facing northwest. 146Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs - ,r HPD Office use only: ..,PI No. 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Residence 14 Please complete HCPI FORM 1 befote completing FORM 2 District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: 105 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 4: North elevation, facing west (top) and east (bottom) (Sharon Joyce, February 23, 2018}. 147Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Base Form (FORM 1) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs use only: Plaza del Monte Residence 3 5. Property Type: j_ Buildings: Structures: _Site _ Object 6. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 7. Previous Survey Date(s): Yes: _x_ No: 8. Name of Project: HDRB status review Plaza del Monte 9. Lat/Long: 35.693427, -105.935448 10. Photo Information District 11. Brief Description of the Property: 2. Location: 106 Camino Santiago Downtown and Eastside Historic District Likely the third unit to be constructed at Plaza del Monte, 106 Camino Santiago is a 2,301-square-foot dwelling with a portal across two elevations. In plan, it has an L-shaped foundation with an attached carport. The flat-roof dwelling holds three bedrooms confined to a wing at the west end. The rear (south) elevation is focused on a sma ll patio cut into the southwest corner of the house. The southeast corner is terminated by a one-space carport. The two-sided portal runs along the north and east elevations. The structure is made of vigas which sit on square girders held up by round posts with zappos-type corbels. The portal elevations are painted white and fenestrated with doors on each exposure. Small rectangular windows penetrate the bedroom wing. The remaining windows vary, including large picture and grouped casements and sliding units. The roof is finished with rolled asphalt which carries over the inner parapets. A squat stucco- faced chimney rises at the northeast corner. The house is finished with textured cementitious stucco in a light buckskin tone. It was erected in c.1965. Its designer is unknown but is suspected to be an early Clark and Register design . _x_Known 14. Setting: Suburban Rural Vii Urban If Urban: Commercial Industrial Residential ic 15. Relationship to Surroundings: _x_ Similar Dissimilar :omments: N/A 148(Continued from other side) North Source: Google Imagery, 2018 19. Is Property Endangered? Unknown _x_ No Yes How? 17. Surveyor: (your name, address, telephone number, and any group affiliation) John W. Murphey Architectural Historian Firstlight Consulting 505-577-7593 John@archhistorvservices.com For: Wayne S. Lloyd, A.I.A., Lloyd and Associates, Architects 18. Owner (if known) and other knowledgeable people: Plaza del Monte, LLC J. Significance to Current Community: _x_ Unknown _None _ Low _ Moderate _High Describe: Unknown 21. Other Significance or Information of Interest: (such as historical, legendary, structural, former ownership, etc.) The house was constructed as part of the independent living section of Plaza del Monte, a Presbyterian residential community for retired clergy, missionaries and other professional staff. Developed between 1960 and 1977, Plaza del Monte operated as a retirement center until1988. The first resident identified with the house is De Forest N. Shotwell, who is listed as a tenant in the 1966 Santa Fe city directory. 22. National or State Register: Is this property individually listed on a historic register? _Unknown _x_ No Yes If yes: _State National If 'no' or unknown, do you think this property is eligible for listing? No _x_ Yes Wh ? See Anal sis of Historical Status. 23. National or State Historic District: Is this property in a historic district? Unknown No _x_ Yes If yes: _Contributing _ Non-contributing _x_ No Status If 'yes', what is the name of the district? _State _National _x_ City of Santa: . Downtown and Eastside Historic District 24. Supplemental Forms: None _x_ HCPI Detail Form (FORM 2) _Continuation Sheets, # pages: ______ Recommended Contributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside 'Historic District, March 28, 2018 149Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: 106 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte lnventoPlaza del Monte Residence 3 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe Adobe Brick Concrete: Concrete: Cast Stone Poured Metal: Metal: Corrugated Structural Siding Stone: Random Stone: Coursed River Rock _x_Stucco: Tile: Clay Wood: Horizontal Wood: Siding Jacal _Wood: Tongue and Groove 10. Windows* Operation Sliding Fixed Material Aluminum Wood[?] _ Composition Concrete: Block Earth _Masonry: Plaster Simulated Metal: Stone: V-Crimp Random Ashlar Stone: Stone: Tabular- Rusticated _Vinyl Wood: Board Siding and Batten Wood: _Wood: Shingle Log Other: Frame N/A Glazing 1-1 Single Number** 6 1 *Because of storm covers, the operation and material is not definite. **Includes sin le and rouped units 12. Chimneys 11. Doors Type Single-Leaf Sliding 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 7. Number of Stories: N/A Number: _x_1 _11/2 2 21/2 Other: 8. Foundation: N/A Not visible _x_ At Grade Materials: _x_ Concrete Other: _____ Notes: 9. Roof: N/A Shape: _x_Fiat None Raised Stone Hipped Pyramidal Shed Other: Pitch: None Low _ Medium _Steep Features: Eave: _x_ Parapets Materials: _x_ Asphalt Earth Gravel _Composition shingle _Metal: Pressed _Composition Roll _Metal: Corrugated _Metal: Standing Seam_ Metal: V- Crimp _Tile: Terra Cotta _Wood: Shingle Other: N/A Style Raised Square Panel w/ View Light Patio Material Wood Aluminum 13. Porches N/A Number 4 One, stucco-clad, west exposure Type: _x_ Entry- portal- 2 Wrap Partial-Width Full-Width 14. Other Si nificant Features N/A 15. Modifications: _x_ No known modifications 15016. Primary Architectural Style Art Deco/Streamline Moderne Bungalow/Craftsman Colonial Revival Folk Victorian Notes: Gothic Revival International ltalianate Mediterranean 17. Documents Available and Their Locations New Mexico Historic Preservation Division 407 Galisteo Street, Suite 236 Santa Fe, NM 87501 (505) 827-6320 Are associated properties eligible for listing? No 19. Site Plan: Current plan is not available. (Continued from other side) Pueblo Queen Anne Ranch Mission Revival Neo-Classical Northern NM Prairie _Spanish-Colonial Other: Historic Preservation Division Land Use Department City of Santa Fe 200 Lincoln Avenue Santa Fe, NM 87504 (505) 955-6605 _x_ Spanish-Pueblo Revival Territorial Territorial Revival Tudor Revival 151Plaza del Monte Residence 3 Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: 106 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte lnvento Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Evaluation of Historical Status Constructed before 1968, and representing the original Clark and Register design template for the Plaza del Monte retirement homes, the house is a good example of the "Santa Fe style." For this reason, the recommendation is to designate 106 Camino Santiago a Contributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District. Ordinance Definition - "Contributing Structure" A structure, located in a historic district, approximately fifty years old or older that helps to establish and maintain the character of that historic district. Although a contributing structure is not unique in itself, it adds to the historic associations or historic architectural design qualities that are significant for a district. The contributing structure may have had minor alterations, but its integrity remains. 152Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs ~ 1! HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 ,CPI No. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A 8 c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 106 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 3 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Illustrations Figure 1: May 2, 1966 aerial photograph. Building present. Courtesy NMDOT. 153Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 1~/Jr HPO Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 HOPI No. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe 10 #: Plaza del Monte 106 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 3 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Survey Photographs (All images taken by John Murphey on January 18, 2018, except where indicated) Photo 1: South and east elevations, facing northwest. 154Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs ~ l HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 Criteria ..A .CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe 10 #: Plaza del Monte 106 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 3 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 2: South and east elevations, facing northwest. 155Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -qr HPD Office use onlv: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 106 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 3 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 3: Street and west elevations, facing southeast. 156Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Base Form (FORM 1) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs Office use only: Plaza del Monte Residence 15 5. Property Type: j_ Buildings: _ Structures: _ Site _ Object 6. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 7. Previous Survey Date(s): Yes: _x_ No: 8. Name of Project: HDRB status review Plaza del Monte 9. Lat/Long: 35.693826, -105.935966 10. Photo Information 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: N/A 109 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte lnv~>nrnrv Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe Negative: John Murphey View of: Front, south elevation, facing north. 11. Brief Description of the Property: Composed of a series of angled walls, the carport dominated residence was constructed in 1966, after a design by arch itect Philippe Register. The house presents to the street a tall and wide carport framed with a viga roof. The west end of the carport is she ltered by double splayed wall. The angled wall composition is echoed across the east elevation. In plan, the residence is roughly an "L" with its form obscured by the carport. The approximate ly 1,220-square-foot dwelling holds two bedrooms in a cube-like mass anchoring the east end . Between the bedroom mass and carport is a small enclosed patio and portal sheltering the main entry and a pair of oversized wood windows. The rear (north) elevation has a small viga canopy protecting a patio door. A tapered chimney breaks the wall plane on this elevation. Fenestration consists of mainly aluminum windows. The frame structure is finished with cementitious brocade stucco in the buckskin tone. The Contemporary-style house was constructed in c.1965. 14. Setting: _x_ Suburban Rural Urban If Urban: Commercial Industrial Residential lie 15. Relationship to _x_ Similar Dissimilar · omments: N/A 157(Continued from other side) North Unknown _x_ No Yes How? 17. Surveyor: (your name, address, telephone number, and any group affiliation) John W. Murphey Architectural Historian Firstlight Consulting 505-577-7593 John@archhistorvservices.com For: Wayne S. Lloyd, A.I.A. , Lloyd and Associates, Architects 18. Owner (if known) and other knowledgeable people: Plaza del Monte, LLC .J. Significance to Current Community: _x_ Unknown _ None _ Low _ Moderate _High Describe: Unknown 21. Other Significance or Information of Interest: (such as historical, legendary, structural, former ownership, etc.) The house was constructed as part of the independent living section of Plaza del Monte, a Presbyterian residential community for retired clergy, missionaries and other professional staff. Developed between 1960 and 1977, Plaza del Monte operated as a retirement center until1988. The first resident identified with the house is Jane Barber, who is listed as a tenant in the 1966 Santa Fe city directory. 22. National or State Register: Is this property individually listed on a historic register? _ Unknown _x_ No Yes If yes: _State National If 'no' or unknown, do you think this property is eligible for listing? No _x_ Yes Wh ? See Anal sis of Historical Status. Is this property in a historic district? Unknown No _x_ Yes If yes: _ Contributing _ Non-contributing _x_ No Status If 'yes', what is the name of the district? _State _ National _x_ City of Santa: Downtown and Eastside Historic District 24. Supplemental Forms: None _x_ HCPI Detail Form (FORM 2) _Continuation Sheets, #pages: _____ Recommended Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District, March 28, 2018 158Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: 109 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte lnuontnruPlaza del Monte Residence 15 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe Concrete: Cast Stone Metal: Corrugated Stone: Random Coursed Brick Concrete: Poured Metal: Structural Siding Stone: River Rock _x_Stucco: Tile: Clay Wood: Horizontal Wood: Siding Jacal Wood: Tongue and Groove 10. Windows* Operation Sliding Fixed Material Aluminum Wood _Composition Earth Plaster Metal: V-Crimp Stone:- Rusticated _Vinyl Siding Wood: Log Concrete: Block Masonry: Simulated Stone: Random Ashlar Stone: Tabular Wood: Board and Batten _Wood: Shingle Other: Frame N/A Glazing 1-1 2 Number** 6 1 *Because of storm covers, the operation and material information is not definite. **Includes units 12. Chimneys 11. Doors Type Single-Leaf Single-Leaf Sliding 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 8. Foundation: Not visible _x_ At Grade Materials: _x_ Concrete Other: _____ Notes: 9. Roof: N/A Shape: _x_Fiat None Raised Stone _ Hipped _ Pyramidal Shed Other: Pitch: None Low _ Medium _ Steep Features: Eave: _x_ Parapets Materials: _Asphalt Earth _x_ Gravel _Composition shingle _Metal: Pressed _Composition Roll _Metal: Corrugated Metal: Standing Seam_ Metal: V- Crimp Tile: Terra Cotta Wood: Shingle Other: N/A Style Material Raised Square Panel Wood Flush Wood Patio Aluminum 13. Porches N/A Number 4 1 1 One, stucco-clad, north exposure Type: _x_ Entry- portal Wrap Partial-Width Full-Width 159HCPI Detail Form (FORM 2 (Continued from other side) 16. Primary Architectural Style _Not Applicable Art Deco/Streamline Mod erne Bungalow/Craftsman Colonial Revival Folk Victorian Notes: Gothic Revival International ltalianate Mediterranean 17. Documents Available and Their Locations New Mexico Historic Preservation Division 407 Galisteo Street, Suite 236 Santa Fe, NM 87501 (505) 827-6320 Are associated properties eligible for listing? No 19. Site Plan: Current plan is not available. Mission Revival Neo-Classical Northern NM Prairie Pueblo Queen Anne Ranch _Spanish-Colonial _Spanish-Pueblo Revival Territorial Territorial Revival Tudor Revival Other: Contemporary with Spanish-Pueblo Revival ornamentation Historic Preservation Division Land Use Department City of Santa Fe 200 Lincoln Avenue Santa Fe, NM 87504 (505) 955-6605 160Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe 10 #: Plaza del Monte Residence 15 109 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte lnvento Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Evaluation of Historical Status Representing a Contemporary design, the house does not harmonize or contribute to the historical character of the district. For this reason, the recommendation is to designate 109 Camino Santiago a Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District. Ordinance Definition- "Contributing Structure" A structure, located in a historic district, approximately fifty years old or older that helps to establish and maintain the character of that historic district. Although a contributing structure is not unique in itself, it adds to the historic associations or historic architectural design qualities that are significant for a district. The contributing structure may have had minor alterations, but its integrity remains. 161Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs ~1rPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 PI No. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 109 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 15 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Illustrations Figure 1: May 2, 1966 aerial photograph. Building present. Courtesy NMDOT. 162Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs Jr HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 HCPI No. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe 10 #: Plaza del Monte 109 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 15 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Survey Photographs (All images taken by John Murphey on January 18, 2018, except where indicated) Photo 1: Street and east elevations, facing northwest. 163Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -,r HPD Office use only: CPINo. 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Residence 15 Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: 109 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 2: Street and west elevations (top), facing northeast. West elevation (bottom), facing southeast (Sharon Joyce, February 23, 2018}. 164Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -Qr HPD Office use only: CPINo. 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Residence 15 Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria ..A B c D 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: 109 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic 4. County: Santa Fe District 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 3: North elevation, facing southeast (top), west (bottom) (Sharon Joyce, February 23, 2018). 165Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Base Form (FORM 1) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Residence 5 5. Property Type: j_ Buildings: Structures: _ Site _Object 6. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 7. Previous Survey Date(s): Yes: _x_ No: 8. Name of Project: HDRB status review Plaza del Monte 9. Lat/Long: 35.693575,-105.936130 District 2. Location: 110 (112) Camino Santiago Downtown and Eastside Historic District 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: N/A Plaza del Monte lnvento 4. County: Santa Fe 10. Photo Information Negative: John Murphey View of: Front, north elevation, facing south. 11. Brief Description of the Property: Located at the west end of the common area are two residential units which were joined together at some point after 1970. The older unit, addressed 110 Camino Santiago, takes up the east end of the footprint. Constructed in c.1962, after a design by architect Kenneth S. Clark, it is roughly an L-shaped box with a rear portal and connected carport. The street- facing fac;:ade is defined by a small recessed entry. The entry holds a single door placed across the west wall. The remainder of the fac;:ade is divided into rectangular window openings holding sliding units. Smaller, rectangular sliding windows are applied across the east bedroom wing. A shallow portal runs across the rear (south) elevation historically leading to a single-space carport. The portal elevation is fenestrated with a patio door, sliding windows, and a louvered door leading to a utility room. The house is outlined with parapets and finished in buckskin cementitious stucco. It holds three bedrooms. Continued on Page 5 13. Construction Date: c.1962, with c.1968 addition and carport expansion _x_Known _x_ Source: aerial photographs, city directory entries 14. Setting: _x_ Suburban _ Rural _Village _ Urban If Urban: Commercial lndustrial_x_ Residential Public 15. Relationship to Surroundings: _x_ Similar Dissimilar Comments: N/A 166(Continued from other side) North Source: Google Imagery, 2018 19. Is Property Endangered? Unknown _x_ No Yes How? 17. Surveyor: (your name, address, telephone number, and any group affiliation) John W. Murphey Architectural Historian Firstlight Consulting 505-577-7593 John@archhistorvservices.com For: Wayne S. Lloyd, A. I.A., Lloyd and Associates, Architects 18. Owner (if known) and other knowledgeable people: Plaza del Monte, LLC J. Significance to Current Community: _x_ Unknown _None _ Low _ Moderate _High Describe: Unknown 21. Other Significance or Information of Interest: (such as historical, legendary, structural, former ownership, etc.) The house was constructed as part of the independent living section of Plaza del Monte, a Presbyterian residential community for retired clergy, missionaries and other professional staff. Developed between 1960 and 1977, Plaza del Monte operated as a retirement center until1988. The first resident identified with the original house (110) is Dorothy B. Fritz, who is listed as a tenant in the 1966 Santa Fe city directory. The first resident identified with the addition (112) is Thea R. Finley, listed in the 1970 Santa Fe city directory as a tenant. Currently the Santa Fe County Assessor treats the combined buildings as one residence addressed as 110 Camino Santiago. 22. National or State Register: Is this property individually listed on a historic register? _U nknown _x_ No Yes If yes: _State National If 'no' or unknown, do you think this property is eligible for listing? No _x_Yes Wh ? See Anal sis of Historical Status. Is this property in a historic district? Unknown No _x_ Yes If yes: _Contributing _ Non-contributing _x_ No Status If 'yes', what is the name of the district? _State _National _x_ City of Santa: Downtown and Eastside Historic District \ Supplemental Forms: None _x_ HCPI Detail Form _ Continuation Sheets, # pa es: Recommended Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District, March 28, 2018 167Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Residence 5 110 (112) Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte lnvento Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 6. Visible Construction Material: Adobe Brick _Composition Concrete: Block Concrete: Cast Stone Metal: Corrugated Stone: Random Coursed Concrete: Poured Metal: Structural Siding Stone: River Rock _x_Stucco: Tile: Clay Wood: Horizontal Wood: Siding Jacal _Wood: Tongue and Groove 10. Windows* Operation Material Sliding Aluminum Sliding Aluminum Casement Aluminum Earth Plaster Metal: V-Crimp Stone:- Rusticated _Vinyl Siding Wood: Log N/A Glazing 1-1 Single 1-1 F-1 _Masonry: Simulated Stone: Random Ashlar Stone: Tabular Wood: Board and Batten Wood: Shingle Other: Frame Number** 11 1 2 *Because of storm covers, the operation and material information is not definite. **Includes sin le and grouped units 12. Chimneys 11. Doors Type Single-Leaf Single-Leaf Double Double Sliding 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 7. Number of Stories: N/A Number: _x_1 _11/2 2 21/2 Other: 8. Foundation: N/A Not visible _x_ At Grade Materials: _x_ Concrete Other: _____ Notes: 9. Roof: N/A Shape: _x_Fiat None Raised Stone _ Hipped _ Pyramidal Shed Other: Pitch: None Low _ Medium _ Steep Features: Eave: _x_ Parapets Materials: _Asphalt Earth _x_ Gravel _Composition shingle _Metal: Pressed _ Composition Roll _ Metal: Corrugated _Metal: Standing Seam_ Metal: V· Crimp Tile: Terra Cotta Wood: Shingle Other: N/A Style Raised Square Panel wl View Light Flush Panel Louver Patio Material Wood Wood Wood Wood Aluminum 13. Porches N/A 1 Number 2 1 1 2 One, stucco-clad, north exposure Type: _x_ Entry- portal- 2 Wrap Partial-Width Full-Width 14. Other Si nificant Features N/A 15. Modifications: _! No known modifications #1 Date: c.1968; addition across west elevation and widening of carport; aerial photographs, drawings, material and visual evidence. 168HCPI Detail Form FORM 2) (Continued from other side) 16. Primary Architectural Style _Not Applicable Art Deco/Streamline Moderne Bungalow/Craftsman . Colonial Revival Folk Victorian Notes: Gothic Revival International ltalianate Mediterranean 17. Documents Available and Their Locations New Mexico Historic Preservation Division 407 Galisteo Street, Suite 236 Santa Fe, NM 87501 (505) 827-6320 Are associated properties eligible for listing? No 19. Site Plan: Current plan is not available. Mission Revival Neo-Classical Northern NM Prairie Pueblo Queen Anne Ranch Spanish-Colonial Other: Historic Preservation Division Land Use Department City of Santa Fe 200 Lincoln Avenue Santa Fe, NM 87504 (505) 955-6605 _x_ Spanish-Pueblo Revival Territorial Territorial Revival Tudor Revival 169Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte Residence 5 110 (112) Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte lnvento Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Continuation of Architectural Description: Attached to the west end of the original Clark design is a post-1966 addition. Arranged at a lower height, the approximately 864-square-foot appendage is a rectangular box with overhanging eaves and a porch. The addition, mostly likely designed by architect Philippe Register, introduces a contemporary vocabulary. A shallow overhang supported by squared rafters carries across the north and south elevations. Similar beams extend out from the west elevation to create the porch. A tall angular wall rising above the roofline defines its south edge. The addition is fenestrated with a few doors and square window openings holding single-light metal casements. The frame structure is finished with cementitious brocade stucco in the buckskin pigment. Most likely occurring with the addition, the carport was widened (or constructed anew) to hold two vehicles. Set back from the addition, the roughly 1,054-square-foot structure is supported by a viga- and-post system. Evaluation of Historical Status The original house received a contemporary addition across its secondary street fac;:ade and a demolition and widening of its carport in c. 1968. The combined alterations changed the overall massing and the appearance of the west elevation of the original structure. For this reason, the recommendation is to designate 110 (112) Camino Santiago a Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District. Ordinance Definition - "Contributing Structure" A structure, located in a historic district, approximately fifty years old or older that helps to establish and maintain the character of that historic district. Although a contributing structure is not unique in itself, it adds to the historic associations or historic architectural design qualities that are significant for a district. The contributing structure may have had minor alterations, but its integrity remains. 170Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -'r HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 113 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory ·Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Illustrations Figure 1: May 2, 1966 aerial photograph. Building not present. Courtesy NMDOT. 191Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -1r HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe 10 #: Plaza del Monte 113 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Survey Photographs (All images taken by John Murphey on January 18, 2018, except where indicated} Photo 1: Street and east elevations, facing northwest. 192Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -1r HPD Office use only: CPINo. 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: 113 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 2: North elevation, facing southeast and southwest (Sharon Joyce, February 23, 2018). 193Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Base Form (FORM 1) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs use only: Plaza del Monte Residence 26 5. Property Type: j_ Buildings: Structures: _ Site _ Object 6. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 7. Previous Survey Date(s): Yes: _x_ No: 8. Name of Project: HDRB status review Plaza del Monte 9. Lat/Long: ?.693668, -105.936489 District 2. Location: 114 Camino Santiago Downtown and Eastside Historic District Plaza del Monte lnvento 4. County: Santa Fe The house presents to Camino Santiago a traditional design of a cube-like mass projecting from a linear arm. In plan, it is roughly L-shaped with a large connecting carport attached to its southeast corner. The west end holds two bedrooms; the remainder of the footprint contains a large living room, kitchen and utility closet. The south exposure of the bedroom wing is penetrated by sliding glass doors. East of the bedroom wing, the front fac;:ade is divided into a recessed entry and a large casement-framed picture window. The entry holds a raised square panel wood door with a center view light. It is sheltered by a short overhang resting on vigas. A similar combined picture and casement window is found on the east elevation of the living room. The carport makes up most of the secondary street elevation. It is supported by a wood viga - and-post system . The structure shelters a patio door and single raised panel wood doors leading to the utility room and storage area. Wood, trough -like canales penetrate the parapets on the east and west elevations. The roof is covered with rolled asphalt, which carries over the bedroom wing's east exposure. A short stucco-clad chimney topped with a terra cotta cap rises from the center of the roof. Erected in c.1972, the residence was designed by Register, Ross & Burnet Architects . Rural Vi Urban If Urban: Commercial Industrial Residential lie ), Relationship to Surroundings: _x_ Similar Dissimilar Comments: N/A 194(Continued from other side) North Source: Google Imagery, 2018 19. Is Property Endangered? Unknown _x_ No Yes How? 17. Surveyor: (your name, address, telephone number, and any group affiliation) John W. Murphey Architectural Historian Firstlight Consulting 505-577-7593 John@archhistorvservices.com For: Wayne S. Lloyd, A. I.A., Lloyd and Associates, Architects 18. Owner (if known) and other knowledgeable people: Plaza del Monte, LLC J. Significance to Current Community: _x_ Unknown _ None _ Low _ Moderate _High Describe: Unknown 21. Other Significance or Information of Interest: (such as historical, legendary, structural, former ownership, etc.) The house was constructed as part of the independent living section of Plaza del Monte, a Presbyterian residential community for retired clergy, missionaries and other professional staff. Developed between 1960 and 1977, Plaza del Monte operated as a retirement center until1988. The 1972 Santa Fe directory indicates the house was under construction at that time. 22. National or State Register: Is this property individually listed on a historic register? _ Unknown _x_ No Yes If yes: _State National If 'no' or unknown, do you think this property is eligible for listing? No _x_Yes Wh ? See Anal sis of Historical Status. 23. National or State Historic District: Is this property in a historic district? Unknown No _x_ Yes If yes: _Contributing _ Non-contributing _x_ No Status If 'yes', what is the name of the district? _State _National _x_ City of Santa: Downtown and Eastside Historic District 24. Supplemental Forms: None _x_ HCPI Detail Form (FORM 2) _Continuation Sheets, # pages: ______ Recommended Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District, March 28, 2018 195Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: 114 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte lnventoPlaza del Monte Residence 26 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 6. Visible Construction Material: Adobe Brick _Composition Concrete: Block Concrete: Cast Stone Metal: Corrugated Stone: Random Coursed Concrete: Poured Metal: Structural Siding Stone: River Rock _x_Stucco: Tile: Clay Wood: Horizontal Wood: Siding Jacal Wood: Tongue and Groove 10. Windows* Operation Casement Casement Material Aluminum Aluminum Earth Plaster Metal: V-Crimp Stone:- Rusticated _Vinyl Siding Wood: Log N/A Glazing 1-1 1-1 F-1 _Masonry: Simulated Stone: Random Ashlar Stone: Tabular Wood: Board and Batten _Wood: Shingle Other: Frame Number** 3 4 *Because of storm covers, the operation and material information is not definite. **Includes sin le and rou ed units 12. Chimneys 11. Doors Type Single-Leaf Single-Leaf Sliding 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 7. Number of Stories: N/A Number: _x_1 _11/2 2 21/2 Other: 8. Foundation: N/A Not visible _x_ At Grade Materials: _x_ Concrete Other: _____ Notes: 9. Roof: N/A Shape: _x_Fiat None Raised Stone _ Hipped _ Pyramidal Shed Other: Pitch: None Low _ Medium _Steep Features: Eave: _x_ Parapets Materials: _Asphalt Earth _x_ Gravel _Composition shingle _Metal: Pressed _Composition Roll _Metal: Corrugated Metal: Standing Seam Metal: V· Crimp _Tile: Terra Cotta _Wood: Shingle Other: N/A Style Raised Square Panel w/ View Light Raised Square Panel Patio Material Wood Wood Aluminum 13. Porches N/A Number 2 2 2 One, stucco-clad, north exposure Type: _x_ Entry- portal _Partial-Width Full-Width Wrap 14. Other Si nificant Features N/A 15. Modifications: ..! No known modifications #1 Date: Unknown; replaced windows and doors; drawings and material and visual evidence. 196(Continued from other side) 16. Primary Architectural Style _ Not Applicable Art Deco/Streamline Moderne Bungalow/Craftsman Colonial Revival Folk Victorian Notes: Gothic Revival International ltalianate Mediterranean 17. Documents Available and Their Locations New Mexico Historic Preservation Division 407 Galisteo Street, Suite 236 Santa Fe, NM 87501 (505) 827-6320 Are associated properties eligible for listing? No 19. Site Plan: Current plan is not available. Pueblo _x_ Spanish-Pueblo Revival Queen Anne Territorial Ranch Territorial Revival Mission Revival Neo-Ciass ical Northern NM Prairie _Spanish-Colonial Tudor Revival Other: Historic Preservation Division Land Use Department City of Santa Fe 200 Lincoln Avenue Santa Fe, NM 87504 {505) 955-6605 197Plaza del Monte Residence 26 Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 114 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte lnvento Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Evaluation of Historical Status Constructed in c.1972, it does not meet the minimum age threshold for consideration. For this reason, the recommendation is to designate 114 Camino Santiago a Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District. Ordinance Definition- "Contributing Structure" A structure, located in a historic district, approximately fifty years old or older that helps to establish and maintain the character of that historic district. Although a contributing structure is not unique in itself, it adds to the historic associations or historic architectural design qualities that are significant for a district. The contributing structure may have had minor alterations, but its integrity remains. 198Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs ~ 1r HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 114 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 26 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Illustrations Figure 1: May 2, 1966 aerial photograph. Building not present. Courtesy NMDOT. 199Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs ~ ~r HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM'2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe 10 #: Plaza del Monte 114 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 26 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Survey Photographs Survey Photographs (All images taken by John Murphey on January 18, 2018, except where indicated) Photo 1: East and south elevations, facing northeast. 200Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -1r HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 ,CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe 10 #: Plaza del Monte 114 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 26 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 2: West elevation, facing southeast. 201Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Base Form (FORM 1) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs use only: Plaza del Monte 5. Property Type: j_ Buildings: Structures: _Site _ Object 6. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 7. Previous Survey Date(s): Yes: _x_ No: 8. Name of Project: HDRB status review Plaza del Monte 9. Lat/Long: 35.694030, -105.936677 10. Photo Information 11. Brief Description of the Property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: N/A 115 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte '""~'"•nru Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe Sharing a wall with the dwelling to the east (113 Camino Santiago), the small house contains two bedrooms. The dwelling portion of the building is composed of a rectangular bedroom wing. Attached to this are the living room, kitchen and a one-space carport. Connecting these elements is a beam portal. Together, both areas hold about 1,290 square feet. The front fac;:ade presents a simple canvas of a projecting mass balanced on one end with the void of the carport at the other. In between is the portal with its few window and door openings. The portal is supported by double round posts topped with zappos-type corbels. The rear (north) elevation contains a few windows and a sliding glass door sheltered by a shallow viga-supported overhang. The house is fenestrated with common doors and windows. The windows are tall, single-light aluminum casements. A raised-panel-and-view-light door gives entry to the dwelling under the portal. Short parapets outline the perimeter of the bedroom wing. The roof's asphalt material carries over the east exposure of the parapet. The house was erected in c.1970; its designer/architect is unknown. Source: aerial Rural Vi Urban If Urban: Commercial Industrial _x_ Residentiai_Public 15. Relationship to Surroundings: _x_ Similar Dissimilar Comments: N/A 202(Continued from other side) North Source: Google Imagery, 2018 19. Is Property Endangered? Unknown _x_ No Yes How? 17. Surveyor: (your name, address, telephone number, and any group affiliation) John W. Murphey Architectural Historian Firstlight Consulting 505-5 77-7593 John@archhistoryservices.com For: Wayne S. Lloyd, A. I.A., Lloyd and Associates, Architects 18. Owner (if known) and other knowledgeable people: Plaza del Monte, LLC ). Significance to Current Community: _x_ Unknown _None _ Low _ Moderate _ High Describe: Unknown 21. Other Significance or Information of Interest: (such as historical, legendary, structural, former ownership, etc.) The house was constructed as part of the independe nt living section of Plaza del Monte, a Presbyterian residential community for retired clergy, missionaries and other professional staff. Developed between 1960 and 1977, Plaza del Monte operated as a retirement center until1988. The first resident identified with the hou se is Westley L. Almy, who is listed as a tenant in the 1971 Santa Fe city directory. 22. National or State Register: Is this property individually listed on a historic register? _ Unknown _x_ No Yes If yes: _ State National If 'no' or unknown, do you think this property is eligible for listing? No _x_Yes Wh ? See Anal sis of Historical Status. 23. National or State Historic District: Is this property in a historic district? Unknown No _x_ Yes If yes: _ Contributing _ Non-contributing _x_ No Status If 'yes', what is the name of the district? _State _National _x_ City of Santa: Downtown and Eastside Historic District 24. Supplemental Forms: None _x_ HCPI Detail Form (FORM 2) _Continuation Sheets, # pages: ______ Recommended Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District, March 28, 2018 203Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs Plaza del Monte 115 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte lnvento Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe Adobe Brick _ Composition Concrete: Block Concrete: Concrete: Earth _Masonry: Cast Stone Poured Plaster Simulated Metal: Metal: Metal: Stone: Corrugated Structural V-Crimp Random Siding Ashlar Stone: Random Stone: Stone: Stone: Tabular- Coursed River Rock Rusticated _x_Stucco: Tile: _Vinyl Wood: Board Clay Siding and Batten Wood: Horizontal Wood: Wood: _Wood: Shingle Siding Jacal Log _Wood: Tongue and Groove Other: Frame 10. Windows* N/A Operation Material Glazing Number** Casement Aluminum 1 1 Casement Aluminum 1-1 1 Casement Aluminum 1-1 F-1 2 ]Casement Aluminum 1-2F-1 1 *Because of storm covers, the operation and material information is not definite. **Includes sin le and rouped units 12. Chimneys 11. Doors Type Single-Leaf Sliding Double 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 8. Foundation: Not visible _x_ At Grade Materials: _x_ Concrete Other: _____ Notes: 9. Roof: N/A Shape: _x_Fiat N/A None Raised Stone _ Hipped _ Pyramidal Shed Other: Pitch: None Low _ Medium_ Steep Features: Eave: _x_ Parapets Materials: _Asphalt Earth _x_ Gravel _Composition shingle _Metal: Pressed Composition Roll _ Metal: Corrugated _Metal: Standing Seam_ Metal: V- Crimp _Tile: Terra Cotta _Wood: Shingle Other: N/A Style Raised Square Panel wl View Light Patio Carport Material Wood Aluminum Wood 13. Porches N/A Number 2 2 1 One, stucco-clad, north exposure Type: _x_ Entry- portal _Partial-Width Full-Width Wrap 14. Other Si nificant Features N/A 15. Modifications: _x_ No known modifications 204HCPI Detail Form (FORM 2 (Continued from other side) 16. Primary Architectural Style _Not Applicable Art Deco/Streamline Moderne . Bungalow/Craftsman . Colonial Revival Folk Victorian Notes: Gothic Revival International ltalianate Mediterranean 17. Documents Available and Their Locations New Mexico Historic Preservation Division 407 Galisteo Street, Suite 236 Santa Fe, NM 87501 (505) 827-6320 Are associated properties eligible for listing? No 19. Site Plan: Current plan is not available. Pueblo Queen Anne Ranch Mission Revival Neo-Classical Northern NM Prairie _Spanish-Colonial Other: Historic Preservation Division Land Use Department City of Santa Fe 200 Lincoln Avenue Santa Fe, NM 87504 (505) 955-6605 _x_ Spanish-Pueblo Revival Territorial Territorial Revival Tudor Revival 205Plaza del Monte Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: 115 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte lnvento Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Evaluation of Historical Status Constructed in c.1970, it does not meet the minimum age threshold for consideration. For this reason, the recommendation is to designate 115 Camino Santiago a Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District. Ordinance Definition - "Contributing Structure" A structure, located in a historic district, approximately fifty years old or older that helps to establish and maintain the character of that historic district. Although a contributing structure is not unique in itself, it adds to the historic associations or historic architectural design qualities that are significant for a district. The contributing structure may have had minor alterations, but its integrity remains. 206Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -1r HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe 10 #: Plaza del Monte 115 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Illustrations Figure 1: May 2, 1966 aerial photograph. Building not present. Courtesy NMDOT. 207Historic Cultural Properties Inventory {HCPI) Detail Form {FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs "' 't~PD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 PI No. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c fi) 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 115 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Survey Photographs (All images taken by John Murphey on January 18, 2018, except where indicated) Photo 1: Street and east elevations, facing northwest. 208Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs ~ r HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria .A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 115 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 2: Street and west elevations, facing northeast. 209Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs "'?r HPD Office use only: jCPINo. District No. 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe 10 #: 115 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 3: North elevation, facing southwest (Sharon Joyce, February 23, 2018). 210Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Base Form (FORM 1) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs use only: Plaza del Monte 5. Property Type: j_ Buildings: Structures: _ Site _ Object 6. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 7. Previous Survey Date(s): Yes: _x_ No: 8. Name of Project: HDRB status review Plaza del Monte 9. Lat/Long: 35.694087, -105.936953 2. Location: 117 Camino Santiago Downtown and Eastside Historic District 10. Photo Information Negative: John Murphey View of: Front, east elevation, facing northwest. 11. Brief Description of the Property: Tucked into the northwest corner of the development, the house is a single-story, flat-roof dwelling characterized by its viga carport and continuous overhang. In form, its two box-like volumes are arranged in a modified L-plan. The house holds two bedrooms slung along the west wall. A large living room occupies the foot of the "L." With its carport included, the house contains approximately 1,422 square feet. The unarticulated flat front fa~;ade is penetrated by non-historic casement windows. A wood panel and view light door gives entry to the dwelling under the front portal. The rear (west) elevation is fenestrated with an asymmetrical pattern of tall aluminum casement windows. The frame building is finished with brocade-type stucco rendered in the buckskin color. It was constructed in 1966-67, after a design by architect Philippe Register. Window replacements appear to have removed the pedimented heads shown on Register's drawings. 13. Construction Date: 1966-67 _x_Known _x_ Source: drawings, aerial photographs, city directory entries 14. Setting: _x_ Suburban _ Rural _ Village _ Urban If Urban: Commercial lndustrial _x_ Residentiai _ Public • .,, Relationship to Surroundings: _x_ Similar Dissimilar Comments: N/A 211(Continued from other side) North Source: Google Imagery, 2018 19. Is Property Endangered? Unknown _x_ No Yes How? 17. Surveyor: (your name, address, telephone number, and any group affiliation) John W. Murphey Architectural Historian Firstlight Consulting 505-577-7593 John@archhistoryservices.com For: Wayne S. Lloyd, A. I.A., Lloyd and Associates, Architects 18. Owner (if known) and other knowledgeable people: Plaza del Monte, LLC J. Significance to Current Community: _x_ Unknown _ None _ Low _ Moderate _High Describe: Unknown 21. Other Significance or Information of Interest: (such as historical, legendary, structural, former ownership, etc.) The house was constructed as part of the independent living section of Plaza del Monte, a Presbyterian residential community for retired clergy, missionaries and other professional staff. Developed between 1960 and 1977, Plaza del Monte operated as a retirement center until1988. The first resident identified with the house is Reverend H. Thomas, who is listed as a tenant in the 1967 Santa Fe city directory. 22. National or State Register: Is this property individually listed on a historic register? _U nknown _x_ No Yes If yes: _State National If 'no' or unknown, do you think this property is eligible for listing? No _x_Yes Wh ? See Anal sis of Historical Status. Is this property in a historic district? Unknown No _x_ Yes If yes: _ Contributing _ Non-contributing _x_ No Status If 'yes', what is the name of the district? _State _National _x_ City of Santa: Downtown and Eastside Historic District 24. Supplemental Forms: None _x_ HCPI Detail Form (FORM 2) _ Continuation Sheets, # pages: ______ Recommended Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District, March 28, 2018 212Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs --~r~, .. •cF?J 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte 117 Camino Santiago 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte lnvento Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 6. Visible Construction Material: Adobe Brick _ Composition Concrete: Block Concrete: Cast Stone Metal: Corrugated Stone: Random Coursed Concrete: Poured Metal: Structural Siding Stone: River Rock _x_Stucco: Tile: Clay Wood: Horizontal Wood: Siding Jacal _Wood: Tongue and Groove 10. Windows* Operation Material Casement Aluminum Casement Aluminum Casement Aluminum ]Casement Aluminum Earth Plaster Metal: V-Crimp Stone:- Rusticated _Vinyl Siding Wood: Log N/A Glazing 1 1-1 1-1 F-1 1-2F-1 _Masonry: Simulated Stone: Random Ashlar Stone: Tabular Wood: Board and Batten Wood: Shingle Other: Frame Number** 2 3 1 3 *Because of storm covers, the operation and material information is not definite. **Includes sin le and rouped units 12. Chimneys 11. Doors Type Single-Leaf Single-Leaf Sliding Double 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 8. Foundation: Not visible _x_ At Grade Materials: _x_ Concrete Other: _____ Notes: 9. Roof: N/A Shape: _x_Fiat None Raised Stone _ Hipped _ Pyramidal Shed Other: Pitch: None Low _ Medium _Steep Features: Eave: _x_ Parapets Materials: Asphalt Earth _x_ Gravel _Composition shingle _Metal: Pressed _Composition Roll _Metal: Corrugated __ Metal: Standing Seam_ Metal: V- Crimp _Tile: Terra Cotta _Wood: Shingle Other: N/A Style Raised Square Panel wl View Light Raised Panel Patio Carport Material Wood Metal Aluminum Wood 13. Porches N/A Number 2 1 2 1 One, stucco-clad, north exposure Type: _x_ Entry- portal _Partial-Width Full-Width Wrap 14. Other Si nificant Features N/A 15. Modifications: ..! No known modifications #1 Date: Unknown; replaced windows and doors; drawings and material and visual evidence. 213(Continued from other side) 16. Primary Architectural Style _ Not Applicable Art Deco/Streamline Mod erne Bungalow/Craftsman Colonial Revival Folk Victorian Notes: Gothic Revival International ltalianate Mediterranean 17. Documents Available and Their Locations New Mexico Historic Preservation Division 407 Galisteo Street, Suite 236 Santa Fe, NM 87501 (505) 827-6320 Are associated properties eligible for listing? No 19. Site Plan: Current plan is not available. Mission Revival Neo-Classical Northern NM Prairie Pueblo Queen Anne Ranch Spanish-Colonial _ Spanish-Pueblo Revival Territorial Territorial Revival Tudor Revival Other: Contemporary with Spanish-Pueblo Revival ornamentation Historic Preservation Division Land Use Department City of Santa Fe 200 Lincoln Avenue Santa Fe, NM 87504 (505) 955-6605 214Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 117 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte lnvento Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Evaluation of Historical Status Representing a Contemporary design, the house does not harmonize or contribute to the historical character of the district. For this reason, the recommendation is to maintain 117 Camino Santiago as a Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District. Ordinance Definition - "Contributing Structure" A structure, located in a historic district, approximately fifty years old or older that helps to establish and maintain the character of that historic district. Although a contributing structure is not unique in itself, it adds to the historic associations or historic architectural design qualities that are significant for a district. The contributing structure may have had minor alterations, but its integrity remains. 215Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -'lr HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D _.. 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe 10 #: Plaza del Monte 117 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Illustrations Figure 1: May 2, 1966 aerial photograph. Building not present. Courtesy NMDOT. 216Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs - r HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 befol8 completing FORM 2 /CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 117 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Survey Photographs (All images taken by John Murphey on January 18, 2018, except where indicated) Photo 1: Street, west and south elevations, facing northeast. 217Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs ~ 1r HPD Office use only: ;CPI No. District No. 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 NRHP SRCP Criteria _A. B c D 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe 10 #: 117 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 2: West elevation, facing southwest (Sharon Joyce, February 23, 2018). 218Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -'>r HPD Office use only: ,CPINo. District No. 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: 117 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 3: North elevation, facing south (Sharon Joyce, February 23, 2018). 219Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Base Form (FORM 1) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs use only: 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte 5. Property Type: j_ Buildings: Structures: _ Site _Object 6. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 7. Previous Survey Date(s): Yes: _x_ No: 8. Name of Project: HDRB status review Plaza del Monte 9. Lat/Long: 35.693715, -105.936696 10. Photo Information 11. Brief Description of the Property: 2. Location: 118 Camino Santiago Downtown and Eastside Historic District 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: N/A Plaza del Monte '""~'"•nn• 4. County: Santa Fe Erected in c.1973, the stucco-over-frame, two-bedroom house sits on a rise at the southwest corner of Camino Santiago and Camino Matias. In plan, it is a modified L-shaped structure with a carport attached to its front fa~ade. The roughly 1,245-square-foot dwel ling has its bedrooms segregated to a wing across the west elevation. This volume is taller than the rest of the house and is outlined with parapets. The lower volume contains a living room, kitchen and dining area. The north (front) fa~ade is divided between the carport and the north face of the bedroom wing. The single space carport is erected over a wood structure supported by round posts. The outside beam continues across the fa~ade, sheltering the front entry. As with the door under the carport, the entry holds a raised square panel unit. The secondary elevations are fenestrated with single-light metal casement windows. The south (rear) elevation has an array of casement windows and an enclosure giving access to the carport. A shallow overhang resting on vigas outlines the elevation. The house is finished with cementitious brocade stucco in a peach pigment. The roof is covered with rolled asphalt, which carries over a portion of the bedroom wing's east exposure. Large, trough-like wood canales pierce the west parapet. It was designed by Register, Ross & Burnet Architects, and is one of the last houses to be completed in the development. entries Rural Vi Urban If Urban: Commercial Industrial Residential 15. Relationship to Surroundings: _x_ Similar Dissimilar Comments: N/A 220(Continued from other side) North Source: Google Imagery, 2018 19. Is Property Endangered? Unknown _x_ No Yes How? 17. Surveyor: (your name, address, telephone number, and any group affiliation) John W. Murphey Architectural Historian Firstlight Consulting 505-577-7593 John@archhistorvservices.com For: Wayne S. Lloyd, A.I.A., Lloyd and Associates, Architects 18. Owner (if known) and other knowledgeable people: Plaza del Monte, LLC J. Significance to Current Community: _x_ Unknown _None _ Low _ Moderate _ High Describe: Unknown 21. Other Significance or Information of Interest: (such as historical, legendary, structural, former ownership, etc.) The house was constructed as part of the independent living section of Plaza del Monte, a Presbyterian residential community for retired clergy, missionaries and other professional staff. Developed between 1960 and 1977, Plaza del Monte operated as a retirement center until1988. The first resident identified with the house is Duncan Spinning, who is listed as a tenant in the 1974 Santa Fe city directory. 22. National or State Register: Is this property individually listed on a historic register? _U nknown _x_ No Yes If yes: _State National If 'no' or unknown, do you think this property is eligible for listing? No _x_Yes Wh ? See Anal sis of Historical Status. Is this property in a historic district? Unknown No _x_ Yes If yes: _Contributing _ Non-contributing _x_ No Status If 'yes', what is the name of the district? _State _National _x_ City of Santa: Downtown and Eastside Historic District 24. Supplemental Forms: None _x_ HCPI Detail Form (FORM 2) _Continuation Sheets, # pages: ______ Recommended Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District, March 28, 2018 221Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs Local R~>t~>r~>n~~> Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 118 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte mv~>nrnrv Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Number: _x_1 Brick Composition Concrete: Block 8. Foundation: Concrete: Concrete: Earth _Masonry: Not visible None Cast Stone Poured Plaster Simulated _x_ At Grade Raised Materials: _x_ Concrete Stone Metal: Metal: Metal: Stone: Other: Corrugated Structural V·Crimp Random Notes: Siding Ashlar . Roof: N/A Stone: Random Stone: - Stone: Stone: Tabular Shape: _x_Fiat Coursed River Rock Rusticated _Hipped _ Pyramidal _x_Stucco: Tile: Vinyl Wood: Board Shed Other: Clay Siding and Batten Pitch: None Low Wood: Medium Steep Horizontal Wood: Wood: Wood: Shingle Features: Eave: Siding Jacal Log _x_ Parapets Materials: _Asphalt _Wood: Tongue and Groove Other: Frame Earth _x_ Gravel Composition shingle Metal: Pressed Composition Roll Metal: Corrugated _ Metal: Standing Seam Metal: V- Crimp _Tile: Terra Cotta _Wood: Shingle Other: 10. Windows* N/A 11. Doors Operation Material Glazing Number** Type Style Material Casement Steel 2-2F-2 1 Single-Leaf Raised Square Panel Wood Casement Steel 3-3 2 w/View Light Casement Steel 3-3F-3 2 Single-Leaf Raised Square Panel Wood Casement Steel 3-3F-3F-3 2 Double Carport Wood *Because of storm covers, the operation and material is not definite. **Includes si and units 12. Chimneys 13. Porches Number 1 One, stucco-clad, north exposure Type: _x_ Entry- portal _Partial-Width Full-Width Wrap _x_ No known modifications 222HCPI Detail Form (FORM 2) (Continued from other side) 16. Primary Architectural Style Not Applicable Art Deco/Streamline Moderne . Bungalow/Craftsman Colonial Revival Folk Victorian Notes: Gothic Revival International ltalianate Mediterranean 17. Documents Available and Their Locations New Mexico Historic Preservation Division 407 Galisteo Street, Suite 236 Santa Fe, NM 87501 (505) 827-6320 Are associated properties eligible for listing? No 19. Site Plan: Current plan is not available. Pueblo Queen Anne Ranch Mission Revival Neo-Classical Northern NM Prairie _Spanish-Colonial Other: Historic Preservation Division Land Use Department City of Santa Fe 200 Lincoln Avenue Santa Fe, NM 87504 (505) 955-6605 _x_ Spanish-Pueblo Revival Territorial Territorial Revival Tudor Revival 223Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 118 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte lnvento Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Evaluation of Historical Status Constructed in c.1973, it does not meet the minimum age threshold for consideration. For this reason, the recommendation is to designate 118 Camino Santiago a Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District. Ordinance Definition - 11Contributing Structure" A structure, located in a historic district, approximately fifty years old or older that helps to establish and maintain the character of that historic district. Although a contributing structure is not unique in itself, it adds to the historic associations or historic architectural design qualities that are significant for a district. The contributing structure may have had minor alterations, but its integrity remains. 224Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -9[. HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPI No. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 118 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Illustrations Figure 1: May 2, 1966 aerial photograph. Building not present. Courtesy NMDOT. 225Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -} ~PO Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 PI No. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 118 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Survey Photographs (All images taken by John Murphey on January 18, 2018, except where indicated} Photo 1: Street and east elevations, facing southwest. 226Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -1r HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 ;CPI No. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 118 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 2: West elevation, facing east. 227Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -'\" HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe 10 #: Plaza del Monte 118 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 3: West and south elevations, facing northeast. 228Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Base Form (FORM 1) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte 5. Property Type: j_ Buildings: Structures: _ Site _ Object 6. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 7. Previous Survey Date(s): Yes: _x_ No: 8. Name of Project: HDRB status review Plaza del Monte 9. Lat/Long: 35.693915, -105.937077 10. Photo Information District 2. Location: 119 Camino Santiago Downtown and Eastside Historic District Negative: John Murphey 11. Brief Description of the Property: Plaza del Monte lnve 4. County: Santa Fe Arranged slightly above grade, the box-like house is characterized by its continuous portal and horizontal emphasis. In plan it is a compact rectangle framed by angled walls on its north and south exposures. Large windows, a wood panel door and a three-panel sliding glass door appear on the front fac;ade. The rear (west) elevation has double sets of sliding windows and a patio door arranged under an overhang. The house's windows appear to be mostly replacement units. The south end of the dwelling is weighted with a large carport. A tall double splayed wall creates the south exposure. The portal is supported by vigas resting on a square beam . Round posts topped with double-ended corbels carry the weight to the floor. The roughly 1,485-square-foot structure contains two bedrooms placed along the west wall. The building was constructed in c.1965, after a design by architect Philippe Register. The main alteration is the removal of most of the angled wall along the northeast corner. Originally this feature enclosed a small patio. _x_Known 14. Setting: _x_ Suburban _ Rural _ Village _ Urban If Urban: Commercial lndustrial _x_ Residentiai _ Public 15. Relationship to Surroundings: _x_ Similar Dissimilar Comments: N/A 229(Continued from other side) North Source: Google Imagery, 2018 19. Is Property Endangered? Unknown _x_ No Yes How? 17. Surveyor: (your name, address, telephone number, and any group affiliation) John W. Murphey Architectural Historian Firstlight Consulting 505-577-7593 John@archhistoryservices.com For: Wayne S. Lloyd, A. I.A., Lloyd and Associates, Architects 18. Owner (if known) and other knowledgeable people: Plaza del Monte, LLC J. Significance to Current Community: _x_ Unknown _ None _Low _ Moderate _High Describe: Unknown 21. Other Significance or Information of Interest: (such as historical, legendary, structural, former ownership, etc.) The house was constructed as part of the independent living section of Plaza del Monte, a Presbyterian residential community for retired clergy, missionaries and other professional staff. Developed between 1960 and 1977, Plaza del Monte operated as a retirement center until1988. The first resident identified with the house is Muriel M. Boone, who is listed as a tenant in the 1966 Santa Fe city directory. 22. National or State Register: Is this property individually listed on a historic register? _ Unknown _x_ No Yes If yes: _ State National If 'no' or unknown, do you think this property is eligible for listing? No _x_Yes Wh ? See Anal sis of Historical Status. Is this property in a historic district? Unknown No _x_ Yes If yes: _Contributing _ Non-contributing _x_ No Status If 'yes', what is the name of the district? _State _National _x_ City of Santa: Downtown and Eastside Historic District 24. Supplemental Forms: None _x_ HCPI Detail Form (FORM 2) _Continuation Sheets, # pages: ______ Recommended Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District, March 28, 2018 230Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 119 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte ~nv.r:onrnrv Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe Adobe Brick Concrete: Concrete: Cast Stone Poured Metal: Metal: Corrugated Structural Siding Stone: Random Stone: Coursed River Rock _x_Stucco: Tile: Clay Wood: Horizontal Wood: Siding Jacal _Wood: Tongue and Groove 10. Windows* Operation Sliding Fixed Material Aluminum Wood _ Composition Concrete: Block Earth _Masonry: Plaster Simulated Metal: Stone: V-Crimp Random Ashlar Stone: Stone: Tabular- Rusticated _Vinyl Wood: Board Siding and Batten Wood: _Wood: Shingle Log Other: Frame N/A Glazing 1-1 Single Number** 6 2 *Because of storm covers, the operation and material information is not definite. **Includes si units 12. Chimneys 11. Doors Type Single-Leaf Sliding 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 7. Number of Stories: N/A Number: _x_1 _11/2 2 21/2 Other· 8. Foundation: N/A Not visible None _x_ At Grade Raised Materials: _x_ Concrete Stone Other: _____ N/A Shape: _x_Fiat _ Hipped _ Pyramidal Shed Other: Pitch: None Low _ Medium _Steep Features: Eave: _x_ Parapets Materials: _Asphalt Earth _x_ Gravel _Composition shingle _ Metal: Pressed _Composition Roll _Metal: Corrugated _Metal: Standing Seam_ Metal: V- Crimp _Tile: Terra Cotta _Wood: Shingle Other: N/A Style Material Raised Square Panel Wood Patio Aluminum 13. Porches N/A Number 4 2 One, stucco-clad, north exposure Type: _x_ Entry- portal- Wrap Partial-Width Full-Width #1 Date: Unknown; partial removal and alteration of northeast angled patio enclosure; drawings and material and visual evidence. 231(Continued from other side) 16. Primary Architectural Style _ Not Applicable Art Deco/Streamline Moderne Bungalow/Craftsman Colonial Revival Folk Victorian Notes: Gothic Revival International ltalianate Mediterranean 17. Documents Available and Their Locations New Mexico Historic Preservation Division 407 Galisteo Street, Suite 236 Santa Fe, NM 87501 (505) 827-6320 Are associated properties eligible for listing? No 19. Site Plan: Current plan is not available. Mission Revival Neo-Classical Northern NM Prairie Pueblo Queen Anne Ranch Spanish-Colonial _ Spanish-Pueblo Revival Territorial Territorial Revival Tudor Revival Other: Contemporary with Spanish-Pueblo Revival ornamentation Historic Preservation Division Land Use Department City of Santa Fe 200 Lincoln Avenue Santa Fe, NM 87504 (505) 955-6605 232Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 119 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte lnvento Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Evaluation of Historical Status Representing a Contemporary design, the house does not harmonize or contribute to the historical character of the district. For this reason, the recommendation is to maintain 119 Camino Santiago as a Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District. Ordinance Definition - "Contributing Structure" A structure, located in a historic district, approximately fifty years old or older that helps to establish and maintain the character of that historic district. Although a contributing structure is not unique in itself, it adds to the historic associations or historic architectural design qualities that are significant for a district. The contributing structure may have had minor alterations, but its integrity remains. 233Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -'lr HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 119 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Illustrations Figure 1: May 2, 1966 aerial photograph. Building present. Courtesy NMDOT. 234Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -11 HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 PI No. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria ..A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 119 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Survey Photographs {All images taken by John Murphey on January·lS, 2018, except where indicated) Photo 1: Street and south elevations, facing northwest. Box indicates removed portion of angled patio wall. 235Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -1r HPD Office use only: ,CPINo. District No. 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: 119 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 2: West elevation, facing south (Sharon Joyce, February 23, 2018}. 236Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs ~ 1r HPD Office use only: CPI No. District No. 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: 119 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 3: North elevation, facing southwest (Sharon Joyce, February 23, 2018). 237Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Base Form (FORM 1) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs use only: 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Residence 25 5. Property Type: j_ Buildings: Structures: _Site _ Object 6. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 7. Previous Survey Date(s): Yes: _x_ No: 8. Name of Project: HDRB status review Plaza del Monte 9. Lat/Long: 35.693597, -105.936785 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: N/A 120 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte lnv<•ntnrv Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe The small two bedroom house presents a contemporary carport-dominant design. Located along the south side of Camino Santiago, it sits back from the street. In plan, it is a modified liT" form with an attached carport projecting from the front fac;:ade. Its two bedrooms are confined to a wing making up the north elevation. Higher than the rest of the house, it is outlined with shaped parapets. The parapets are pierced with canales across the north and south exposures. The lower volume, historically containing a living room, kitchen and music room, is faced with a shallow overhang resting on vigas. The overhang shelters sliding glass doors, a window and a pedestrian entry. The secondary elevations are fenestrated with aluminum casement windows. Continued on Page 5 _x_Known 14. Setting: _x_ Suburban _ Rural _Village _ Urban If Urban: Commercial lndustrial_x_ Residential Public 15. Relationship to Surroundings: _x_ Similar Dissimilar Comments: N/A 238(Continued from other side) North Source: Google Imagery, 2018 19. Is Property Endangered? Unknown _x_ No Yes How? 17. Surveyor: (your name, address, telephone number, and any group affiliation) John W. Murphey Architectural Historian Firstlight Consulting 505-577-7593 John@archhistorvservices.com For: Wayne S. Lloyd, A. I.A., Lloyd and Associates, Architects 18. Owner (if known) and other knowledgeable people: Plaza del Monte, LLC J. Significance to Current Community: _x_ Unknown _ None _ Low _ Moderate _H igh Describe: Unknown 21. Other Significance or Information of Interest: (such as historical, legendary, structural, former ownership, etc.) The house was constructed as part of the independent living section of Plaza del Monte, a Presbyterian residential community for retired clergy, missionaries and other professional staff. Developed between 1960 and 1977, Plaza del Monte operated as a retirement center until1988. The first resident identified with the house is Ovid Sellers, who is listed as a tenant in the 1972 Santa Fe city directory. 22. National or State Register: Is this property individually listed on a historic register? _ Unknown _x_ No Yes If yes: _ State National If 'no' or unknown, do you think this property is eligible for listing? No _x_Yes Wh ? See Anal sis of Historical Status. 23. National or State Historic District: Is this property in a historic district? Unknown No _x_ Yes If yes: _Contributing _ Non-contributing _x_ No Status If 'yes', what is the name of the district? _State _ National _x_ City of Santa: Downtown and Eastside Historic District 24. Supplemental Forms: None _x_ HCPI Detail Form (FORM 2) _Continuation Sheets, # pages: ______ Recommended Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District, March 28, 2018 239Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: 120 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte lnventoPlaza del Monte Residence 25 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 6. Visible Construction Material: Adobe Brick _Composition Concrete: Block Concrete: Concrete: Earth _Masonry: Cast Stone Poured Plaster Simulated Metal: Metal: Metal: Stone: Corrugated Structural V-Crimp Random Siding Ashlar Stone: Random Stone: Stone: Stone: Tabular- Coursed River Rock Rusticated _x_Stucco: Tile: _Vinyl Wood: Board Clay Siding and Batten Wood: Horizontal Wood: Wood: Wood: Shingle Siding Jacal Log _Wood: Tongue and Groove Other: Frame 10. Windows* N/A Operation Material Glazing Number** Casement Aluminum 2-2F-2 1 Casement Aluminum 3-3F-3 4 Fixed Aluminum 21 1 *Because of storm covers, the operation and material is not definite. **Includes sin le and rou ed units 12. Chimneys 11. Doors Type Single-Leaf Single-Leaf Double Double 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 7. Number of Stories: Number: _x_1 _11/2 2 21/2 Other: 8. Foundation: N/A Not visible _x_ At Grade Materials: _x_ Concrete Other: _____ Notes: 9. Roof: N/A Shape: _x_Fiat None Raised Stone _ Hipped _ Pyramidal Shed Other: Pitch: None Low _ Medium _ Steep Features: Eave: _x_ Parapets Materials: _Asphalt Earth _x_ Gravel _Composition shingle _Metal: Pressed _Composition Roll _Metal: Corrugated _Metal: Standing Seam_ Metal: V- Crimp _Tile: Terra Cotta _Wood: Shingle Other: N/A Style Raised Square Panel w/ View Light Raised Panel French Carport Material Wood Metal Aluminum Wood 13. Porches N/A Number 1 1 1 3 One, stucco-clad, north exposure Type: _x_ Entry- portal _Partial-Width Full-Width Wrap 14. Other Si nificant Features N/A 15. Modifications: _! No known modifications #1 Date: Unknown; replaced windows and doors; drawings and material and visual evidence. 24016. Primary Architectural Style Art Deco/Streamline Mod erne Bungalow/Craftsman Colonial Revival Folk Victorian Notes: Gothic Revival International ltalianate Mediterranean 17. Documents Available and Their Locations New Mexico Historic Preservation Division 407 Galisteo Street, Suite 236 Santa Fe, NM 87501 (505) 827-6320 Are associated properties eligible for listing? No 19. Site Plan: Current plan is not available. (Continued from other side) Mission Revival Neo-Classical Northern NM Prairie Pueblo _Queen Anne Ranch _ Spanish-Colonial Other: Historic Preservation Division Land Use Department City of Santa Fe 200 Lincoln Avenue Santa Fe, NM 87504 (505) 955-6605 _x_ Spanish-Pueblo Revival Territorial Territorial Revival Tudor Revival 241Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs Plaza del Monte Residence 25 120 Camino Santiago Downtown and Eastside Historic District Continuation of Architectural Description: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte lnvento 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 The front (west) elevation is dominated by the carport. The structure is erected over a viga-and-post support system. The portal's outside beam continues across the fa~ade, sheltering the front entry. A wood raised square panel door with a center view light gives entry to the residence. The frame building is faced with cementitious stucco with brocade finish in a peach-like pigment. Including its carport and utility room, the building contains 1,804 square-feet. The house was erected in c.1971, after a design by Register, Ross & Burnet Architects. Evaluation of Historical Status Constructed in c.1971, it does not meet the minimum age threshold for consideration. For this reason, the recommendation is to designate 120 Camino Santiago a Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District. Definition- "Contributing Structure" A structure, located in a historic district, approximately fifty years old or older that helps to establish and maintain the character of that historic district. Although a contributing structure is not unique in itself, it adds to the historic associations or historic architectural design qualities that are significant for a district. The contributing structure may have had minor alterations, but its integrity remains. 242Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -l!' HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 ,CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe 10 #: Plaza del Monte 120 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 25 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Illustrations Figure 1: May 2, 1966 aerial photograph. Building not present. Courtesy NMDOT. 243Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -y HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A 8 c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 120 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 25 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Survey Photographs (All images taken by John Murphey on January 18, 2018, except where indicated) Photo 1: East elevation, facing north. 244Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs - r HPD Office use only: CPINo. District No. 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Residence 25 Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe 10 #: Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic 4. County: Santa Fe District 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 2: South elevation, facing northeast (Sharon Joyce, February 23, 2018}. 245Historic Cultural Properties Inventory {HCPI) Detail Form {FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs ..,r HPD Office use only: ~ PI No. District No. 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Residence 25 Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 NRHP SRCP Criteria _A B c D 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe 10 #: 120 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 3: North elevation, facing southwest (Sharon Joyce, February 23, 2018). 246Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Base Form (FORM 1) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -,r HPD Office use only: /CPINo. District No. _NRHP SRCP Criteria A B C D 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Residence 20 5. Property Type: 1._ Buildings: Structures: _ Site _ Object 6. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 7. Previous Survey Date(s): Yes: _x_ No: 8. Name of Project: HDRB status review Plaza del Monte 9. Lat/Long: 35.693719, -105.937155 2. Location: 121 Camino Santiago Downtown and Eastside Historic District 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: N/A Plaza del Monte lnvento 4. County: Santa Fe 10. Photo Information Negative: John Murphey View of: Front, east elevation, facing northwest. 11. Brief Description of the Property: Reflecting a carport-dominant design, the small, vernacular dwelling sits at grade on the west side of Camino Santiago. The roughly 1,309-square-foot structure holds one bedroom. In plan, it is a compact square enclosed by an angled wall across its south exposure. Unlike most units at Plaza del Monte, it has a low pitch roof. The front (ea st) fa~ade is dominated by the one-vehicle carport. The remainder of the fa~ade is divided into windows and doors. The windows are uniformly multi-light stee l casements in various standard sizes. The gabled north elevation has three identical windows. The rear (west) side of the house has more articulation, expressed through its beamed canopy over a pair of sliding doors. The frame house is finished with heavy brocade cementitious stucco in a peach -like color. A shallow square-beam supported overhang runs along the east and west elevations. It was constructed in c. 1971, after a design by Register, Ross and Brunet Architects . 13. Construction Date: c.1971 _x_Known _x_ Source: drawings, aerial photographs, city directory entries 14. Setting: _x_ Suburban _ Rural _ Village _ Urban If Urban: Commercial lndustrial_x_ Residentiai_Public 15. Relationship to Surroundings: _x_ Similar Dissimilar Comments: N/A 247(Continued from other side) North Source: Google Imagery, 2018 19. Is Property Endangered? Unknown _x_ No Yes How? 17. Surveyor: (your name, address, telephone number, and any group affiliation) John W. Murphey Architectural Historian Firstlight Consulting 505-577-7593 John @archh istorvservices. com For: Wayne S. Lloyd, A. I.A., Lloyd and Associates, Architects 18. Owner (if known) and other knowledgeable people: Plaza del Monte, LLC J. Significance to Current Community: _x_ Unknown _ None _ Low _ Moderate _High Describe: Unknown 21. Other Significance or Information of Interest: (such as historical, legendary, structural, former ownership, etc.) The house was constructed as part of the independent living section of Plaza del Monte, a Presbyterian residential community for retired clergy, missionaries and other professional staff. Developed between 1960 and 1977, Plaza del Monte operated as a retirement center until1988. The first resident identified with the house is Gilbert L. Boyd, who is listed as a tenant in the 1972 Santa Fe city directory. 22. National or State Register: Is this property individually listed on a historic register? _U nknown _x_ No Yes If yes: _ State National If 'no' or unknown, do you think this property is eligible for listing? No _x_Yes Wh ? See Anal sis of Historical Status. Is this property in a historic district? Unknown No _x_ Yes If yes: _Contributing _ Non-contributing _x_ No Status If 'yes', what is the name of the district? _State _ National _x_ City of Santa: Downtown and Eastside Historic District 24. Supplemental Forms: None _x_ HCPI Detail Form (FORM 2) _Continuation Sheets, # pages: ______ Recommended Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District, March 28, 2018 248Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: 121 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte lnv~>ntnrvPlaza del Monte Residence 20 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe Adobe Brick _ Composition Concrete: Block Concrete: Concrete: Earth _Masonry: Cast Stone Poured Plaster Simulated Metal: Metal: Metal: Stone: Corrugated Structural V-Crimp Random Siding Ashlar Stone: Random Stone: Stone: Stone: Tabular- Coursed River Rock Rusticated _x_Stucco: Tile: _Vinyl Wood: Board Clay Siding and Batten Wood: Horizontal Wood: Wood: _Wood: Shingle Siding Jacal Log Wood: Tongue and Groove Other: Frame 10. Windows* N/A Operation Material Glazing Number** Casement Steel 2-2 3 Casement Steel 3 [?] 1 Casement Steel 3-3 5 Casement Steel 3-3F-3F-3 1 *Because of storm covers, the operation and material is not definite. **Includes si and units 12. Chimneys 11. Doors Type Single-Leaf Single-Leaf Sliding Double 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 8. Foundation: Not visible _x_ At Grade Materials: _x_ Concrete Other: _____ Notes: 9. Roof: N/A Shape: _x_Fiat N/A None Raised Stone _ Hipped _ Pyramidal Shed Other: Pitch: None Low _ Medium _ Steep Features: Eave: _x_ Parapets Materials: _Asphalt Earth _x_ Gravel _Composition shingle _Metal: Pressed _Composition Roll _Metal: Corrugated _Metal: Standing Seam_ Metal: V· Crimp Tile: Terra Cotta Wood: Shingle Other: N/A Style Raised Square Panel w/ View Light Raised Square Panel Patio Carport Material Wood Wood Aluminum Wood 13. Porches N/A Number 1 1 2 3 One, stucco-clad, west exposure Type: _x_ Entry· portal _Partial-Width Full-Width Wrap _x_ No known modifications 24916. Primary Architectural Style Art Deco/Streamline Moderne Bungalow/Craftsman Colonial Revival Folk Victorian Notes: Gothic Revival International ltalianate Mediterranean 17. Documents Available and Their Locations New Mexico Historic Preservation Division 407 Galisteo Street, Suite 236 Santa Fe, NM 87501 (505) 827-6320 Are associated properties eligible for listing? No 19. Site Plan: Current plan is not available. (Continued from other side) Mission Revival Neo-Classical Northern NM Prairie Pueblo Queen Anne Ranch _Spanish-Colonial Spanish-Pueblo Revival Territorial Territorial Revival Tudor Revival Other: Contemporary with Spanish-Pueblo Revival ornamentation Historic Preservation Division Land Use Department City of Santa Fe 200 Lincoln Avenue Santa Fe, NM 87504 (505) 955-6605 250Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Residence 20 2. Location: 121 Camino Santiago Downtown and Eastside Historic District Evaluation of Historical Status 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte ~nv~•nTnrv 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Representing a Contemporary design, the house does not harmonize or contribute to the historical character of the district. Constructed in c.1971, it does not meet the minimum age threshold for consideration. For this reason, the recommendation is to designate 121 Camino Santiago a Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District. Ordinance Definition - "Contributing Structure" A structure, located in a historic district, approximately fifty years old or older that helps to establish and maintain the character of that historic district. Although a contributing structure is not unique in itself, it adds to the historic associations or historic architectural design qualities that are significant for a district. The contributing structure may have had minor alterations, but its integrity remains. 251Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs - r HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 ;CPINo. DlstrtctNo. NRHP SRCP Crtter'ia A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 121 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 20 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Illustrations Figure 1: May 2, 1966 aerial photograph. Building not present. Courtesy NMDOT. 252Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs - r HPD Office use only: _,CPI No. 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Residence 20 Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria .A. B c D 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: 121 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Survey Photographs (All images taken by John Murphey on January 18, 2018, except where indicated) Photo 1: South elevation, facing northeast and northwest (Sharon Joyce, February 23, 2018}. 253Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -.1[ HPD Office use only: CPINo. District No. 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Residence 20 Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe 10 #: 121 Camino Santiago Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 2: West elevation, southeast (Sharon Joyce, February 23, 2018}. 254Historic Cultural Properties Inventory {HCPI) Base Form {FORM 1) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs ; HPD Office use only: PI No. 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Residence 1 5. Property Type: ..1 Buildings: Structures: _Site _ Object 6. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 7. Previous Survey Date(s): Yes: _x_ No: 8. Name of Project: HDRB status review Plaza del Monte 9. Lat/Long: 35.693073, -105.935289 ,o. Photo Information District No. 11. Brief Description of the Property: _ NRHP _SRCP Criteria_A_B_C_D 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: N/A 104 Camino Matias Plaza del Monte lnvento ~-------~~--------~ Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe One of the first units to be constructed at Plaza del Monte, 104 Camino Matias is an L-shaped dwelling with a combined carport and portal. The approximately 1,143-square-foot, flat-roof structure holds two bedrooms. The bedrooms are placed in a wing forming the north end of the residence. Its front (west) fac;:ade presents a Spanish-Pueblo Revival plan with its cubic, battered mass and viga-roofed portal. Unlike many houses in the development, the carport plays a secondary role on the fac;:ade . The single-bay structure, arranged behind the portal, is less exuberant in its display of wood elements. The bedroom mass is fenestrated with small, rectangular windows; the remaining elevations have windows arranged in a more traditional pattern. The windows are mostly aluminum casement units. The portal elevation is painted white. A line of vigas runs along the top of the wall. It is supported by shiplap wood girders resting on round posts with zappos-type corbels. The house was constructed in c.1965. It represents the closest interpretation of the original1960 Kenneth S. Clark and Philippe Register template design for the development. 13. Construction Date: c.1965 _x_Known _x_ Source: aerial photographs, city directory entries 14. Setting: _x_ Suburban _ Rural _ Village _ Urban If Urban: Commercial lndustrial _x_ Residential Public 15. Relationship to Surroundings: _x_ Similar Dissimilar :omments: N/A 255(Continued from other side) North Source: Google Imagery, 2018 19. Is Property Endangered? Unknown _x_ No Yes How? 17. Surveyor: (your name, address, telephone number, and any group affiliation) John W. Murphey Architectural Historian Firstlight Consulting 505-577-7593 John@archhistorvservices.com For: Wayne S. Lloyd, A. I.A., Lloyd and Associates, Architects 18. Owner (if known) and other knowledgeable people: Plaza del Monte, LLC ). Significance to Current Community: _x_ Unknown _None _ Low _ Moderate _ High Describe: Unknown 21. Other Significance or Information of Interest: (such as historical, legendary, structural, former ownership, etc.) The house was constructed as part of the independent living section of Plaza del Monte, a Presbyterian residential community for retired clergy, missionaries and other professional staff. Developed between 1960 and 1977, Plaza del Monte operated as a retirement center until1988. The first resident identified with the house is Frederick H. Dawson, who is listed as a tenant in the 1966 Santa Fe city directory. 22. National or State Register: Is this property individually listed on a historic register? _Unknown _x_ No Yes If yes: _State National If 'no' or unknown, do you think this property is eligible for listing? No _x_Yes Wh ? See Anal sis of Historical Status. 23. National or State Historic District: Is this property in a historic district? Unknown No _x_ Yes If yes: _Contributing _x_ Non-contributing _ No Status If 'yes', what is the name of the district? _State _National _x_ City of Santa: Downtown and Eastside Historic District 24. Supplemental Forms: None _x_ HCPI Detail Form (FORM 2) _Continuation Sheets, # pages: ______ Recommended Contributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District, March 28, 2018 256Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: 104 Camino Matias Plaza del Monte lnv~>nrnruPlaza del Monte Residence 1 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe Adobe Brick _Composition Concrete: Block Concrete: Concrete: Earth _Masonry: Cast Stone Poured Plaster Simulated Metal: Metal: Metal: Stone: Corrugated Structural V·Crimp Random Siding Ashlar Stone: Random Stone: Stone: Stone: Tabular- Coursed River Rock Rusticated _x_Stucco: Tile: _Vinyl Wood: Board Clay Siding and Batten Wood: Horizontal Wood: Wood: _Wood: Shingle Siding Jacal Log _Wood: Tongue and Groove Other: Frame 10. Windows* N/A Operation Material Glazing Number** Casement Aluminum 1-1 6 Casement Aluminum 1-1F-1F-1 1 [?] [?] [?] 1 *Because of storm covers, the operation and material is not definite. **Includes e and units 12. Chimneys 11. Doors Type Single-Leaf Single-Leaf Sliding 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 7. Number of Stories: N/A Number: _x_1 _11/2 2 21/2 Other· 8. Foundation: N/A Not visible _x_ At Grade Materials: _x_ Concrete Other: _____ N/A Shape: _x_Fiat None Raised Stone _Hipped_ Pyramidal Shed Other: Pitch: None Low _ Medium _Steep Features: Eave: _x_ Parapets Materials: Asphalt Earth _x_ Gravel _Composition shingle _Metal: Pressed _Composition Roll _Metal: Corrugated _Metal: Standing Seam_ Metal: v. Crimp _Tile: Terra Cotta _Wood: Shingle Other: N/A Style Raised Square Panel wl View Light Flush Patio Material Wood Wood Aluminum 13. Porches N/A Number 2 2 1 One, stucco-clad, south exposure Type: _x_ Entry- portal Wrap Partial-Width Full-Width _x_ No known modifications 257(Continued from other side) 16. Primary Architectural Style _ Not Applicable Art Deco/Streamline Moderne . Bungalow/Craftsman Colonial Revival Folk Victorian Notes: Gothic Revival International ltalianate Mediterranean 17. Documents Available and Their Locations New Mexico Historic Preservation Division 407 Galisteo Street, Suite 236 Santa Fe, NM 87501 (505) 827-6320 Are associated properties eligible for listing? No 19. Site Plan: Current plan is not available. Pueblo Queen Anne Ranch Mission Revival Neo-Classical Northern NM Prairie _Spanish-Colonial Other: Historic Preservation Division Land Use Department City of Santa Fe 200 Lincoln Avenue Santa Fe, NM 87504 (505) 955-6605 _x_ Spanish-Pueblo Revival Territorial Territorial Revival Tudor Revival 258Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs Plaza del Monte Residence 1 104 Camino Matias Downtown and Eastside Historic District Evaluation of Historical Status 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte lnve 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Constructed before 1968, and representing the original Clark and Register design template for the Plaza del Monte retirement homes, the house is a good example of the "Santa Fe style." For this reason, the recommendation is to designate 104 Camino Matias a Contributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District. Ordinance Definition -"Contributing Structure" A structure, located in a historic district, approximately fifty years old or older that helps to establish and maintain the character of that historic district. Although a contributing structure is not unique in itself, it adds to the historic associations or historic architectural design qualities that are significant for a district. The contributing structure may have had minor alterations, but its integrity remains. 259Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -r HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 104 Camino Matias Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 1 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Illustrations Figure 1: May 2, 1966 aerial photograph. Building present. Courtesy NMDOT. 260Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs or HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 HCPI No. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 104 Camino Matias Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 1 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Survey Photographs (All images taken by John Murphey on January 18, 2018, except where indicated ) Photo 1: Street and south elevations, facing southeast. 261Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs "'1r HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 104 Camino Matias Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 1 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 2: Street and north elevations, facing southeast. 262Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -bHPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 PI No. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe 10 #: Plaza del Monte 104 Camino Matias Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 1 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 3: East elevation, facing northwest. 263Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Base Form (FORM 1) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs - r HPD Office use only: CPINo. 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Residence 10 5. Property Type: _!Buildings: Structures: _ Site _ Object 6. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 7. Previous Survey Date(s): Yes: _x_ No: 8. Name of Project: HDRB status review Plaza del Monte 9. Lat/Long: 35.693249, -105.935608 District No. _NRHP _SRCP Criteria A B C D 2. Location: 105 Camino Matias Downtown and Eastside Historic District 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: N/A Plaza del Monte lnvento 4. County: Santa Fe 10. Photo Information Negative: John Murphey View of: Front, south elevation, facing north. 11. Brief Description of the Property: This small house is one of three units constructed in 1950 for married staff employed by the Allison-James School. Arranged in a terrace-like fashion, each unit is a rectangular plan, side-gabled dwelling with an attached garage. The house has a telescoping roof form, evident along its north exposure. The roof extends over the walls on the north and south elevations to form small porches. The house is fenestrated with a mix of original and non-historic windows and doors. The windows are terminated with stuccoed concrete sills . Views from the house are oriented north toward the commons area. The north elevation contains a large picture window flanked by casements. Public entry is through an original ~-glass wood door on the south elevation. The garage door is a recent vinyl paneled unit. The roof is covered with three-tab asphalt shingles. Wood fascia has been applied to the north and south roof ends, obscuring (or removing) the original exposed rafters. A short stuccoed chimney rises from the north roof slope. The approximately 1,102-square-foot house holds three bedrooms. A non-historic, 220-square-foot carport has been erected over the driveway. 13. Construction Date: 1950 _x_Known _x_ Source: Allison-James School publication and aerial photographs 14. Setting: _x_ Suburban _ Rural _Village _ Urban If Urban: Commercial lndustrial _x_ Residential _Public 15. Relationship to Surroundings: Similar _x_ Dissimilar Comments: Vernacular, gabled building, dissimilar to the Contemporary and Spanish-Pueblo Revival housing of Plaza del Monte 264(Continued from other side) Source: Google Imagery, 2018 19. Is Property Endangered? Unknown _x_ No Yes How? 17. Surveyor: (your name, address, telephone number, and any group affiliation) John W. Murphey Architectural Historian Firstlight Consulting 505-577-7593 John@archhistorvservices.com For: Wayne S. Lloyd, A. I.A., Lloyd and Associates, Architects 18. Owner (if known) and other knowledgeable people: Plaza del Monte, LLC J. Significance to Current Community: _x_ Unknown _None _Low _Moderate _High Describe: Unk~own 21. Other Significance or Information of Interest: (such as historical, legendary, structural, former ownership, etc.) The first resident identified with the house during the Plaza del Monte period is Sidney S. Brown, who is listed as a tenant in the 1966 Santa Fe city directory. 22, National or State Register: Is this property individually listed on a historic register? _Unknown _x_ No Yes If yes: _State National If 'no' or unknown, do you think this property is eligible for listing? No _x_Yes Wh ? See Anal sis of Historical Status. 23. National or State Historic District: Is this property in a historic district? Unknown No _x_ Yes If yes: _x_ Contributing _ Non-contributing_ No Status If 'yes', what is the name of the district? _State _National _x_ City of Santa: Downtown and Eastside Historic District 24. Supplemental Forms: None _x_ HCPI Detail Form (FORM 2) _ Continuation Sheets, # pages: _____ Recommended Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District, March 28, 2018 265Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: 105 Camino Matias Plaza del Monte •nv,~>nrnrvPlaza del Monte Residence 10 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe Adobe Brick _ Composition Concrete: Block Concrete: Concrete: Earth Masonry: Cast Stone Poured Plaster Simulated Metal: Metal: Metal: Stone: Corrugated Structural V-Crimp Random Siding Ashlar Stone: Random Stone: Stone: Stone: Tabular- Coursed River Rock Rusticated _x_Stucco: Tile: _Vinyl Wood: Board Clay Siding and Batten Wood: Horizontal Wood: Wood: _Wood: Shingle Siding Jacal Log _Wood: Tongue and Groove Other: Frame 10. Windows* NIA Operation Material Glazing Number** Double-Hung Wood 111 4 Double-Hung Metal 212 3 Fixed Wood Single 1 Fixed Metaltwood Singled ftanked 1 by 212 DH Sliding Wood 1-1 *Because of storm covers, the operation and material is not definite. **Includes le and units 12. Chimneys 11. Doors Type Single-Leaf Single-Leaf Overhead 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 8. Foundation: Not visible None _x_ At Grade Raised Materials: _x_ Concrete Stone Other: _____ Notes: 9. Roof: N/A Shape: _x_Fiat Hipped_ Pyramidal Shed Other: Pitch: None Low _ Medium _ Steep Features: Eave: _x_ Parapets Materials: _Asphalt Earth _x_ Gravel _Composition shingle _Metal: Pressed _Composition Roll _Metal: Corrugated _Metal: Standing Seam_ Metal: V- Crimp _Tile: Terra Cotta _Wood: Shingle Other: NIA Style Material Raised Square Panel Wood Y:, -Glass Wood Sectional Vinyl 13. Porches NIA Number 2 1 1 One, stucco-clad, north exposure Type: _x_ Entry _Partial-Width _ Full-Width _Wrap 15. Modifications: _! No known modifications #1 Date: Unknown; replaced garage door; material and visual evidence. #2 Date: 1960s; assumed replacement of original windows in majority of openings. 266HCPI Detail Form (FORM 2 (Continued from other side) 16. Primary Architectural Style _Not Applicable Art Deco/Streamline Moderne Bungalow/Craftsman Colonial Revival Folk Victorian Notes: Gothic Revival International ltalianate Mediterranean 17. Documents Available and Their Locations New Mexico Historic Preservation Division 407 Galisteo Street, Suite 236 Santa Fe, NM 87501 (505) 827-6320 Are associated properties eligible for listing? No 19. Site Plan: Current plan is not available. Mission Revival Neo-Classical Northern NM Prairie Pueblo _Queen Anne Ranch _Spanish-Colonial Spanish-Pueblo Revival Territorial Territorial Revival Tudor Revival Other: No style- side-gable vernacular form Historic Preservation Division Land Use Department City of Santa Fe 200 Lincoln Avenue Santa Fe, NM 87504 (505) 955-6605 267Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Residence 10 2. Location: 105 Camino Matias Downtown and Eastside Historic District Evaluation of Historical Status 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte lnv~•ntnn.t 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Erected as a teacherage residence, the house does not harmonize or contribute to the aesthetic of Plaza del Monte or the historical character of the district. This includes non- conforming elements, such corner windows and cantilevered canopies over entries, which do not meet the ordinance standards. Additionally, its historical association lies with the Allison-James School, which was demolished in 1960. For these reasons, the recommendation is to designate 105 Camino Matias a Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District. Ordinance Definition - 11 Contributing Structure" A structure, located in a historic district, approximately fifty years old or older that helps to establish and maintain the character of that historic district. Although a contributing structure is not unique in itself, it adds to the historic associations or historic architectural design qualities that are significant for a district. The contributing structure may have had minor alterations, but its integrity remains. 268Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs - r HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 /CPI No. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 105 Camino Matias Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 10 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Illustrations Figure 1: May 2, 1966 aerial photograph. Building present. Courtesy NMDOT. 269Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -qr HPD Office use only: Please complete HOPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 ,CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 105 Camino Matias Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 10 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Figure 2: Rear (north) elevation of teacherage; Allison-James School in background. Source: Atkins, 1983. 270Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs ~ r HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe 10 #: Plaza del Monte 105 Camino Matias Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 10 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Survey Photographs (All images taken by John Murphey on January 18, 2018, except where indicated) Photo 1: west elevation, facing northeast. 271Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs ~ 1r HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 ,CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 105 Camino Matias Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 10 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 2: East elevation, facing northwest. 272Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -1 HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 105 Camino Matias Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 10 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 3: North elevation, facing southeast. 273Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Base Form (FORM 1) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -'>r HPD Office use only: ;OPI No. 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Residence 9 5. Property Type: j_ Buildings: Structures: _ Site _Object 6. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 7. Previous Survey Date(s): Yes: _x_ No: 8. Name of Project: HDRB status review Plaza del Monte 9. Lat/Long: 35.693289, -105.935797 District No. _NRHP _SRCP Criteria A_B C D 2. Location: 107 Camino Matias Downtown and Eastside Historic District 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: N/A Plaza del Monte lnvento 4. County: Santa Fe .o. Photo Information Negative: John Murphey 11. Brief Description of the Property: This small house is one of three units constructed in 1950 for married staff employed by the Allison -James School. Arranged in a terrace-like fashion, each unit is a rectangular plan, side-gabled dwelling with an attached garage. The house has a simple side-gable form terminating at the east end with a hipped roof over the garage. The gabled roof extends over the walls on the north and south elevations to form small porches. The dwelling is fenestrated with a mix of original and non-historic windows and doors. They are terminated with stuccoed concrete sills. Views from the house are oriented north toward the commons area. The north elevation contains a large picture window flanked by casements. Public entry is through an original ~-glass wood door on the south elevation. Two vertical [solar?] panels have been applied to the fac;:ade. The garage door is a recent vinyl paneled unit. The roof is covered with three-tab asphalt shingles. Wood fascia has been applied to the north and south roof ends, obscuring (or removing) the original exposed rafters. A short stuccoed chimney rises from the north roof slope. The house originally had an enclosed pedimented entry on the north elevation, which was reduced at some point in depth after 1969. The approximately 1,145-square-foot house holds two bedrooms. 12. Who uses the _x_Known 14. Setting: _x_ Suburban _ Rural _Village _ Urban If Urban: Commercial Industrial _x_ Residential _Public j . Relationship to Surroundings: Similar _x_ Dissimilar Comments: Vernacular, gabled building, dissimilar to the Contemporary and Spanish-Pueblo Revival housing of Plaza del Monte 274(Continued from other side) North Source: Google Imagery, 2018 19. Is Property Endangered? Unknown _x_ No Yes How? 17. Surveyor: (your name, address, telephone number, and any group affiliation) John W. Murphey Architectural Historian Firstlight Consulting 505-577-7593 John@archhistoryservices.com For: Wayne S. Lloyd, A.I.A., Lloyd and Associates, Architects 18. Owner (if known) and other knowledgeable people: Plaza del Monte, LLC ). Significance to Current Community: _x_ Unknown _ None _Low _ Moderate _ High Describe: Unknown 21. Other Significance or Information of Interest: (such as historical, legendary, structural, former ownership, etc.) The first resident identified with the house during the Plaza del Monte period is Adin B. Brooks, who is listed as a tenant in the 1966 Santa Fe city directory. 22. National or State Register: Is this property individually listed on a historic register? _Unknown _x_ No Yes If yes: _State National If 'no' or unknown, do you think this property is eligible for listing? No _x_Yes Wh ? See Anal sis of Historical Status. Is this property in a historic district? Unknown No _x_ Yes If yes: _ Contributing _x_ Non-contributing _ No Status If 'yes', what is the name of the district? _State _National _x_ City of Santa: Downtown and Eastside Historic District 24. Supplemental Forms: None _x_ HCPI Detail Form (FORM 2) _Continuation Sheets, # pages: ______ Recommended Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District, March 28, 2018 275Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Residence 9 Concrete: Cast Stone Metal: Corrugated Stone: Random Coursed Brick Concrete: Poured Metal: Structural Siding Stone: River Rock _x_Stucco: Tile: Clay Wood: Horizontal Wood: Siding Jacal _Wood: Tongue and Groove 2. Location: 107 Camino Matias Downtown and Eastside Historic District _Composition Concrete: Block Earth Plaster Metal: V-Crimp Stone:- Rusticated _Vinyl Siding Wood: Log _Masonry: Simulated Stone: Random Ashlar Stone: Tabular Wood: Board and Batten Wood: Shingle Other: Frame 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe 10 #: Plaza del Monte 1""'"ntnru 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 8. Foundation: Not visible _x_ At Grade Materials: _x_ Concrete Other: _____ Notes: 9. Roof: N/A Shape: _x_Fiat None Raised Stone _ Hipped _ Pyramidal Shed Other: Pitch: None Low Medium Steep Features: Eave: _x_ Parapets Materials: Asphalt Earth _x_ Gravel _Composition shingle _Metal: Pressed _Composition Roll _Metal: Corrugated 10. Windows* N/A Operation Material Glazing Number** Double-Hung Metal 2/2 6 Fixed Metal/Wood Singled flanked 1 by 2/2 DH Sliding Metal 1-1 *Because of storm covers, the operation and material is not definite. **Includes si and units 12. Chimneys 11. Doors Type Single-Leaf Overhead 13. Porches _Metal: Standing Seam_ Metal: V- Crimp _Tile: Terra Cotta _Wood: Shingle Other: N/A Style Material Y;. -Glass Wood Sectional Vinyl N/A 2 Number 1 One, stucco-clad, north exposure Type: __x_ Entry Partial-Width _ Full-Width _Wrap 1 Date: Post-1969; change of back door opening and enclosure; photograph, aerial imagery and material and visual evidence. 2 Date: Unknown; replaced garage door; material and visual evidence. 276HCPI Detail Form (FORM 2) (Continued from other side) 16. Primary Architectural Style Not Applicable Art Deco/Streamline Mod erne Bungalow/Craftsman Colonial Revival Folk Victorian Notes: Gothic Revival International ltalianate Mediterranean 17. Documents Available and Their Locations New Mexico Historic Preservation Division 407 Galisteo Street, Suite 236 Santa Fe, NM 87501 (505) 827-6320 Are associated properties eligible for listing? No 19. Site Plan: Current plan is not available. Mission Revival Neo-Classical Northern NM Prairie Pueblo Queen Anne Ranch _Spanish-Colonial _ Spanish-Pueblo Revival Territorial Territorial Revival Tudor Revival Other: No style- side-gable vernacular form Historic Preservation Division Land Use Department City of Santa Fe 200 Lincoln Avenue Santa Fe, NM 87504 (505) 955-6605 277Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Residence 9 2. Location: 107 Camino Matias Downtown and Eastside Historic District Evaluation of Historical Status 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte lnuonTnn• 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Erected as a teacherage residence, the house does not harmonize or contribute to the aesthetic of Plaza del Monte or the historical character of the district. It includes non- conforming elements, such corner windows and cantilevered canopies over entries, which do not meet the ordinance standards. Additionally, its historical association lies with the Allison-James School, which was demolished in 1960. For these reasons, the recommendation is to maintain the status of 107 Camino Matias as a Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District. Ordinance Definition- "Contributing Structure" A structure, located in a historic district, approximately fifty years old or older that helps to establish and maintain the character of that historic district. Although a contributing structure is not unique in itself, it adds to the historic associations or historic architectural design qualities that are significant for a district. The contributing structure may have had minor alterations, but its integrity remains. 278Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -1[ HPD Office use only: PINse complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A 8 c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 107 Camino Matias Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 9 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Illustrations Figure 1: May 2, 1966 aerial photograph. Building present. Courtesy NMDOT. 279Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs hHPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 PI No. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 107 Camino Matias Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 9 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Figure 2: Rear (north) elevation of teacherage; Allison-James School in background. Source: Atkins, 1983. 280Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -1! HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 107 Camino Matias Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 9 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Survey Photographs (All images taken by John Murphey on January 18, 2018, except where indicated) Photo 2: Street and east elevations, facing northeast. 281Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs - r HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 ,CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 107 Camino Matias Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 9 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 2: Street west elevations, facing northeast. 282Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -1r HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 107 Camino Matias Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 9 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 2: North elevation, facing south. 283Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Base Form (FORM 1) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -,r HPD Office use only: )CPI No. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria B C D 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Residence 8 5. Property Type: j_ Buildings: Structures: _ Site _ Object 6. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 7. Previous Survey Date(s): Yes: _x_ No: 8. Name of Project: HDRB status review Plaza del Monte 9. Lat/Long: 35.693343, -105.936001 10. Photo Information 2. Location: 109 Camino Matias Downtown and Eastside Historic District Negative: John Murphey 11. Brief Description of the Property: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: N/A Plaza del Monte lnvento 4. County: Santa Fe This small house is one of three units constructed in 1950 for married staff employed by the Allison -James School. Arranged in a terrace-like fashion, each unit is a rectangular plan, side-gabled dwelling with an attached garage. The house has a telescoping roof form. The roof extends over the walls on the north and south elevations to form small porches. The front (south) fac;:ade reveals an altered composition . At some point after 1960, a 131-square-foot addition was appended to the southwest corner creating a sunroom. The dwelling is fenestrated with a mix of original and non - historic windows and doors. Th e windows are mostly double-hung sash. They are terminated with stuccoed concrete sills. Vi ews from the house are oriented north toward the commons area . The north elevation contains a large picture window flanked by casements . Public entry is through an original ~ - glass wood door on the south elevation . The garage door is a recent vinyl paneled unit. The roof is covered with three -tab asphalt shingles. Wood fascia has been applied to the north and south roof ends, obscuring (or removing) the original exposed rafters. A short stuccoed chimney rises from the north roof slope. The approximately 1,141-square-foot house contains two bedrooms. 13. Construction Date: 1950 _x_Known _x_ Source: Allison-James School publication and aerial photographs 14. Setting: _x_ Suburban _ Rural _ Village _ Urban If Urban: Commercial Industrial _x_ Residential _Public ''i. Relationship to Surroundings: Similar _x_ Dissimilar Comments: Vernacular, gabled building, dissimilar to the Contemporary and Spanish-Pueblo Revival housing of Plaza del Monte 284(Continued from other side) North '2018 •9. Is Property Endangered? Unknown _x_ No Yes How? 17. Surveyor: (your name, address, telephone number, and any group affiliation) John W. Murphey Architectural Historian Firstlight Consulting 505-577-7593 John@archhistoryservices.com For: Wayne S. Lloyd, A. I.A., Lloyd and Associates, Architects 18. Owner (if known) and other knowledgeable people: Plaza del Monte, LLC 20. Significance to Current Community: _x_ Unknown _ None _ Low _Moderate _ High Describe: Unknown 21. Other Significance or Information of Interest: (such as historical, legendary, structural, former ownership, etc.) The first resident identified with the house during the Plaza del Monte period is Chester E. Witti er, who is listed as a tenant in the 1966 Santa Fe city directory. 22. National or State Register: Is this property individually listed on a historic register? _ Unknown _x_ No Yes If yes: _ State National If 'no' or unknown, do you think this property is eligible for listing? No _x_Yes Wh ? See Anal sis of Historical Status. Is this property in a historic district? Unknown No _x_ Yes If yes: _ Contributing _x_ Non-contributing _ No Status If 'yes', what is the name of the district? _State _National _x_ City of Santa: Downtown and Eastside Historic District 24. Supplemental Forms: None _x_ HCPI Detail Form (FORM 2) _ Continuation Sheets, # pages: ______ Recommended Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District, March 28, 2018 285Plaza del Monte Residence 8 Adobe Concrete: Cast Stone Metal: Corrugated Stone: Random Coursed _x_Stucco: Wood: Horizontal Siding Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 109 Camino Matias Downtown and Eastside Historic District Brick _ Composition Concrete: Block Concrete: Earth Masonry: Poured Plaster Simulated Metal: Metal: Stone: Structural V-Crimp Random Siding Ashlar Stone: - Stone: Stone: Tabular River Rock Rusticated Tile: _Vinyl Wood: Board Clay Siding and Batten Wood: Wood: _Wood: Shingle Jacal Log 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte mv,DnTnnt 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Number: _x_1 8. Foundation: Not visible _x_ At Grade Materials: _x_ Concrete Other: _____ Notes: 9. Roof: N/A Shape: _x_Fiat None Raised Stone _ Hipped _ Pyramidal Shed Other: Pitch: None Low _ Medium _Steep Features: Eave: _x_ Parapets Materials: _Asphalt Wood: Tongue and Groove Other: Frame Earth _x_ Gravel _Composition shingle _Metal: Pressed _Composition Roll _Metal: Corrugated 10. Windows* N/A Operation Material Glazing Number** Double-Hung Metal 212 8 Fixed Metal/Wood Singled flanked 1 by 2/2 DH Sliding Metal 1-1 *Because of storm covers, the operation and material is not definite. **Includes and units 12. Chimneys One, stucco-clad, north exposure 11. Doors Type Single-Leaf Overhead 13. Porches _Metal: Standing Seam_ Metal: V· Crimp _Tile: Terra Cotta _Wood: Shingle Other: Style Yz -Glass Sectional N/A N/A Material Wood Vinyl Type: _x_ Entry Partial-Width Full-Width #1 Date: Pre-1966; introduction of projection across front, south, facade; aerial photographs. #3 Date: Unknown; replaced garage door; and material and visual evidence. Number 2 1 Wrap 286(Continued from other side) 16. Primary Architectural Style _Not Applicable Art Deco/Streamline Moderne Bungalow/Craftsman Colonial Revival Folk Victorian Notes: Gothic Revival International ltalianate Mediterranean 17. Documents Available and Their Locations New Mexico Historic Preservation Division 407 Galisteo Street, Suite 236 Santa Fe, NM 87501 (505) 827-6320 Are associated properties eligible for listing? No 19. Site Plan: Current plan is not available. Mission Revival Neo-Classical Northern NM Prairie Pueblo Queen Anne Ranch _Spanish-Colonial _ Spanish-Pueblo Revival Territorial Territorial Revival Tudor Revival Other: No style- side-gable vernacular form Historic Preservation Division Land Use Department City of Santa Fe 200 Lincoln Avenue Santa Fe, NM 87504 (505) 955-6605 287Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs Plaza del Monte Residence 8 109 Camino Matias Downtown and Eastside Historic District Evaluation of Historical Status 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte lnv~•ntnru 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Erected as a teacherage residence, the house does not harmonize or contribute to the aesthetic of Plaza del Monte or the historical character of the district. This includes non- conforming elements, such corner windows and cantilevered canopies over entries, which do not meet the ordinance standards. Additionally, its historical association lies with the Allison-James School, which was demolished in 1960. For these reasons, the recommendation is to maintain the status of 109 Camino Matias as a Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District. Ordinance Definition- "Contributing Structure" A structure, located in a historic district, approximately fifty years old or older that helps to establish and maintain the character of that historic district. Although a contributing structure is not unique in itself, it adds to the historic associations or historic architectural design qualities that are significant for a district. The contributing structure may have had minor alterations, but its integrity remains. 288Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -1{ HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe 10 #: Plaza del Monte 109 Camino Matias Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 8 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Illustrations Figure 1: May 2, 1966 aerial photograph. Building present. Courtesy NMDOT. 289Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs ""<>r HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 befof8 completing FORM 2 ;CPI No. District No. NRI:IP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe 10 #: Plaza del Monte 109 Camino Matias Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 8 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Figure 2: Rear (north) elevation of teacherage; Allison-James School in background. Source: Atkins, 1983. 290Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs ~ .,r HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 109 Camino Matias Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 8 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Survey Photographs (All images taken by John Murphey on January 18, 2018, except where indicated) Photo 1: Street and east elevations, facing northwest. 291Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs ~ 1 HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 109 Camino Matias Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 8 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 2: Street and west elevations, facing northeast. 292Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs - r HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Cr.iteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 109 Camino Matias Plaza del Monte Inventory Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 3: North elevation, facing southwest. 293Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Base Form (FORM 1) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs ~ 1r HPD Office use only: _,CPI No. 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Residence 6 5. Property Type: j_ Buildings: Structures: _ Site _ Object 6. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 7. Previous Survey Date(s): Yes: _x_ No: 8. Name of Project: HDRB status review Plaza del Monte 9. Lat/Long: 35.693391, -105.936212 District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria _A _B C _D 2. Location: 111 Camino Matias Downtown and Eastside Historic District 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: N/A Plaza del Monte lnvento 4. County: Santa Fe 10. Photo Information Negative: John Murphey View of: Front, west elevation, facing northeast 11. Brief Description of the Property: Moved to the site prior to 1960, 111 Camino Matias is an altered three-bedroom house. The house is arranged on a north- south axis, and in plan consists of two telescoping gabled sections. To this basic form was added an L-shaped porch and connected carport in c.1966. The medium pitch roofs are covered with asphalt shingles and extend with overhangs. A short stuccoed chimney rises from the ridgeline. Small wood louvers are attached to the gable ends. The house is fenestrated with an array of original and non-historic windows. The windows - mostly double-hung sash - are arranged for interior functions. Windows are recessed from the wall and terminated with concrete sills. The combined porch and carport are supported by a framework of wood girders resting on grouped square posts. The single carport includes double storage units. A short breezeway leads from the carport to a back door. The 1,712-square-foot frame house is finished with textured cementitious stucco in a light buckskin color. 13. Construction Date: Pre-1960; moved to site c.1960; portal and carport added c.1966 _x_Known _x_ Source: aerial photographs 14. Setting: _x_ Suburban _ Rural _Village _ Urban If Urban: Commercial Industrial _x_ Residentiai_Public 15. Relationship to Surroundings: Similar _x_ Dissimilar Comments: Vernacular, gabled buildings, dissimilar to the Contemporary and Spanish-Pueblo Revival housing of Plaza del Monte 294(Continued from other side) North Source: Google Imagery, 2018 19. Is Property Endangered? Unknown _x_ No Yes How? 17. Surveyor: (your name, address, telephone number, and any group affiliation) John W. Murphey Architectural Historian Firstlight Consulting 505-577-7593 John@archhistorvservices.com For: Wayne S. Lloyd, A. I.A., Lloyd and Associates, Architects 18. Owner (if known) and other knowledgeable people: Plaza del Monte, LLC J. Significance to Current Community: _x_ Unknown _ None _ Low _ Moderate _ High Describe: Unknown 21 . Other Significance or Information of Interest: (such as historical, legendary, structural, former ownership, etc.) The first resident identified with the house during the Plaza del Monte period is Daniel 0. Shoop, who is listed as a tenant in the 1966 Santa Fe city directory. 22. National or State Register: Is this property individually listed on a historic register? _ Unknown _x_ No Yes If yes: _ State National If 'no' or unknown, do you think this property is eligible for listing? No _x_Yes Wh ? See Anal sis of Historical Status. 23. National or State Historic District: Is this property in a historic district? Unknown No _x_ Yes If yes: _ Contributing _x_ Non-contributing _ No Status If 'yes', what is the name of the district? _ State _ National _x_ City of Santa: Downtown and Eastside Historic District 24. Supplemental Forms: None _x_ HCPI Detail Form (FORM 2) _Continuation Sheets, # pages: ______ Recommended Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District, March 28, 2018 295Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: 111 Camino Matias Plaza del Monte lnu••ntnntPlaza del Monte Residence 6 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe Adobe Brick Concrete: Concrete: Cast Stone Poured Metal: Metal: Corrugated Structural Siding Stone: Random Stone: Coursed River Rock _x_Stucco: Tile: Clay Wood: Horizontal Wood: Siding Jacal _Wood: Tongue and Groove 10. Windows* Operation Double-Hung Fixed Material Metal Metal/Wood _ Composition Concrete: Block Earth _Masonry: Plaster Simulated Metal: Stone: V-Crimp Random Ashlar Stone: Stone: Tabular- Rusticated _Vinyl Wood: Board Siding and Batten Wood: _Wood: Shingle Log Other: Frame N/A Glazing 2/2 Singled flanked by 2/2 DH Number** 11 1 *Because of storm covers, the operation and material is not definite. **Includes si and units 12. Chimneys 11. Doors Type Single-Leaf Single-Leaf Double 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 8. Foundation: Not visible _x_ At Grade Materials: _x_ Concrete Other: _____ Notes: 9. Roof: N/A Shape: _x_Fiat None Raised Stone _ Hipped _ Pyramidal Shed Other: Pitch: None Low _ Medium _ Steep Features: Eave: _x_ Parapets Materials: _Asphalt Earth _x_ Gravel _Composition shingle _Metal: Pressed _Composition Roll _Metal: Corrugated _Metal: Standing Seam_ Metal: v. Crimp _Tile: Terra Cotta _Wood: Shingle Other: Style Raised Panel Flush N/A Carport Storage Material Wood Wood Wood 13. Porches N/A Number 1 1 2 One, stucco-clad, north exposure Type: _x_ Entry-portal Wrap Partial-Width Full-Width #1 Date: Pre-1960; house moved to site; primary source material and aerial photograph. #2 Date: Pre-1966; introduction of portal and carport; layout plan and aerial photograph. #3 Date: Pre-1966 (assumed); introduction of metal windows; visual and material evidence. 296HCPI Detail Form (FORM 2 (Continued from other side) 16. Primary Architectural Style _Not Applicable Art Deco/Streamline Moderne . Bungalow/Craftsman . Colonial Revival Folk Victorian Notes: Gothic Revival International ltalianate Mediterranean 17. Documents Available and Their Locations New Mexico Historic Preservation Division 407 Galisteo Street, Suite 236 Santa Fe, NM 87501 (505) 827-6320 Are associated properties eligible for listing? No 19. Site Plan: Current plan is not available. Mission Revival Neo-Classical Northern NM Prairie Pueblo Queen Anne Ranch Spanish-Colonial _Spanish-Pueblo Revival Territorial Territorial Revival Tudor Revival Other: No style -side-gable vernacular form Historic Preservation Division Land Use Department City of Santa Fe 200 Lincoln Avenue Santa Fe, NM 87504 (505) 955-6605 297Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs Plaza del Monte Residence 6 111 Camino Matias Downtown and Eastside Historic District Evaluation of Historical Status 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte lnvento 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Moved to this location before 1960, and modified in the mid-1960s with the addition of the portal and carport, the house does not harmonize or contribute to the aesthetic of Plaza del Monte or the historical character of the district. Additionally, its historical association lies with the Allison-James School, which was demolished in 1960. For these reasons, the recommendation is to maintain the status of 111 Camino Matias as a Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District. Ordinance Definition - "Contributing Structure" A structure, located in a historic district, approximately fifty years old or older that helps to establish and maintain the character of that historic district. Although a contributing structure is not unique in itself, it adds to the historic associations or historic architectural design qualities that are significant for a district. The contributing structure may have had minor alterations, but its integrity remains. 298Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs y HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 befo18 completing FORM 2 ,OPINo. Distrtct No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe 10 #: Plaza del Monte 111 Camino Matias Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 6 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Illustrations Figure 1: May 2, 1966 aerial photograph. Building present. Courtesy NMDOT. 299Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -"! HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 111 Camino Matias Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 6 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Survey Photographs (All images taken by John Murphey on January 18, 2018, except where indicated) Photo 1: East elevation, facing northwest. 300Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs -bHPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 PI No. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 111 Camino Matias Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 6 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 2: North and west elevations, facing southeast. 301Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Base Form (FORM 1) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs - r HPD Office use only: ,CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria _A _B _C D 1. Name of property: Plaza del Monte Residence 7 5. Property Type: _1 Buildings: Structures: _ Site _ Object 6. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 7. Previous Survey Date(s): Yes: _x_ No: 8. Name of Project: HDRB status review Plaza del Monte 9. Lat/Long: 35.693448, -105.936542 .o. Photo Information 11. Brief Description of the Property: 2. Location: 116/120 Camino Matias Downtown and Eastside Historic District 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: N/A Plaza del Monte lnvento 4. County: Santa Fe View of: Front, east elevation, facing northwest The vernacular, two-unit residence was erected before 1957, and modified nearly 30 years later with the addition of a cross gable entry. The combined residence is aligned along a north-south axis on the west side of Camino Matias. In plan, it is a side-gabled rectangle with a cross gable appended to its northeast corner. The north unit (120) holds about 1,256 square-feet, with three bedrooms . A window wall spanning the northeast corner signals its contemporary design. The north elevation under the gable is marred by a c.1984 shed -roof structure enclosing the furnace and water heater. The front fac;ade faces east and is dominated by the non-historic cross gable entry. A recessed entry at the south end leads to 116. The interior, encompassing approximately 939 square feet, is arranged like an apartment. A similar non-historic stuccoed enclosure around the furnace and water heater is attached to the south elevation. The rear (west) elevation of the combined units faces onto a common area. A continuous overhang characterizes this fac;ade. It is penetrated with three sliding glass doors and a mixture of fixed and sliding windows of different sizes. The roof is sheathed with rib metal panels. It unclear who designed the original house. The c.1984 addition of the cross gable and furnace and water heater enclosures wa s drawn in Philippe Registe r's shop. 13. Construction Date: pre-1958, with alterations and cross-gable entry added on front fa~ade in c.1984 _x_Known _x_ Source: aerial photograph 14. Setting: _x_ Suburban _ Rural _ Village _ Urban If Urban: Commercial lndustrial_x_ Residential Public .i. Relationship to Surroundings: Similar _x_ Dissimilar Comments: Vernacular, gabled buildings, dissimilar to the Contemporary and Spanish-Pueblo Revival housing of Plaza del Monte 302(Continued from other side) North Box Indicates Post-1968 Addition Unknown _x_ No Yes How? 17. Surveyor: (your name, address, telephone number, and any group affiliation) John W. Murphey Architectural Historian Firstlight Consulting 505-577-7593 John@archhistorvservices.com For: Wayne S. Lloyd, A. I.A., Lloyd and Associates, Architects 18. Owner (if known) and other knowledgeable people: Plaza del Monte, LLC 20. Significance to Current Community: _x_ Unknown _ None _ Low _ Moderate _H igh Describe: Unknown 21. Other Significance or Information of Interest: (such as historical, legendary, structural, former ownership, etc.) The first res idents identified with the house during the Plaza del Monte period are Margaret D. Becker (116) and Minnie C. Wither (120). Both are identified as tenants in the 1966 Santa Fe city directory. 22. National or State Register: Is this property individually listed on a historic register? _Unknown _x_ No Yes If yes: _State National If 'no' or unknown, do you think this property is eligible for listing? No _x_Yes Wh ? See Anal sis of Historical Status. Is this property in a historic district? Unknown No _x_ Yes If yes: _Contributing _x_ Non-contributing _No Status If 'yes', what is the name of the district? _State _National _x_ City of Santa: Downtown and Eastside Historic District 24. Supplemental Forms: None _x_ HCPI Detail Form (FORM 2) _Continuation Sheets, # pages: ______ Recommended Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District, March 28, 2018 303Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs "'~tH~P ,CRfN'o 1. Name of property: 116/120 Camino Matias 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte lnventoPlaza del Monte Residence 7 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 6. Visible Construction Material: Adobe Concrete: Cast Stone Metal: Corrugated Stone: Random Coursed Brick Concrete: Poured Metal: Structural Siding Stone: River Rock _x_Stucco: Tile: Clay Wood: Horizontal Wood: Siding Jacal _Wood: Tongue and Groove 10. Windows* Operation Material Casement Aluminum Sliding Aluminum Fixed Wood _Composition Concrete: Block Earth Plaster Metal: V-Crimp Stone:- Rusticated _Vinyl Siding Wood: Log N/A Glazing 8-8 1-1 Single _Masonry: Simulated Stone: Random Ashlar Stone: Tabular Wood: Board and Batten Wood: Shingle Other: Frame Number** 2 8 1 *Because of storm covers, the operation and material is not definite. **Includes single and grouped units 11. Doors Type Single-Leaf Single Sliding 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 7. Number of Stories: N/A Number: _x_1 _11/2 2 21/2 Other: 8. Foundation: N/A Not visible _x_ At Grade Materials: _x_ Concrete Other: _____ Notes: 9. Roof: N/A Shape: _x_Fiat None Raised Stone _Hipped_ Pyramidal Shed Other: Pitch: None Low _ Medium _Steep Features: Eave: _x_ Parapets Materials: _Asphalt Earth _x_ Gravel _Composition shingle _Metal: Pressed _Composition Roll _Metal: Corrugated _Metal: Standing Seam_ Metal: V- Crimp _Tile: Terra Cotta _Wood: Shingle Other: Style Flush Full-Glass Patio N/A Material Wood Wood Aluminum 13. Porches _x_ N/A Number 4 1 3 12. Chimneys N/A Type: Entry-portal Partial-Width Full-Width _Wrap 14. Other Si nificant Features N/A 15. Modifications: ..! No known modifications #1 Date: Pre-1966; introduction of modern fenestration; material and visual evidence. #2 Date: c.1984; introduction of cross-gable entry across front, east, facade; drawings, aerial photographs and material and visual evidence. 304HCPI Detail Form FORM 2) (Continued from other side) 16. Primary Architectural Style _Not Applicable Art Deco/Streamline Mod erne . Bungalow/Craftsman . Colonial Revival Folk Victorian Notes: Gothic Revival International ltalianate Mediterranean 17. Documents Available and Their Locations New Mexico Historic Preservation Division 407 Galisteo Street, Suite 236 Santa Fe, NM 87501 (505) 827-6320 Are associated properties eligible for listing? No 19. Site Plan: Current plan is not available. Mission Revival Neo-Classical Northern NM Prairie Pueblo Queen Anne Ranch _Spanish-Colonial _ Spanish-Pueblo Revival Territorial Territorial Revival Tudor Revival Other: No style- side-gable vernacular form with Ranch style elements Historic Preservation Division Land Use Department City of Santa Fe 200 Lincoln Avenue Santa Fe, NM 87504 (505) 955-6605 305Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs Plaza del Monte Residence 7 116/120 Camino Matias Downtown and Eastside Historic District Evaluation of Historical Status 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe 10 #: Plaza del Monte lnvento 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Erected before 1958, and modified in the mid-1980s with a cross-gable entry and small additions, the house does not harmonize or contribute to the aesthetic of Plaza del Monte or the historic character of the district. Additionally, its historical association lies with the Allison-James School, which was demolished in 1960. For these reasons, the recommendation is to maintain the status of 116/120 Camino Matias as a Noncontributing Structure to the Downtown and Eastside Historic District. Ordinance Definition - "Contributing Structure" A structure, located in a historic district, approximately fifty years old or older that helps to establish and maintain the character of that historic district. Although a contributing structure is not unique in itself, it adds to the historic associations or historic architectural design qualities that are significant for a district. The contributing structure may have had minor alterations, but its integrity remains. 306Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs - r HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 116/120 Camino Matias Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 7 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Illustrations Figure 1: May 2, 1966 aerial photograph. Building present; pre-alteration. Courtesy NMDOT. 307Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs ~~r HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 ,1CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A 8 c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe 10 #: Plaza del Monte 116/120 Camino Matias Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 7 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Figure 2: February 27, 1969 aerial photograph . Building present; pre-alteration. Courtesy NMDOT. 308Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs ~ r HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 116/120 Camino Matias Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 7 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Survey Photographs (All images taken by John Murphey on January 18, 2018, except where indicated ) Photo 1: Street and north elevations, facing southwest. 309Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs ""''lr HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria .A B c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe ID #: Plaza del Monte 116/120 Camino Matias Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 7 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 2: South elevation, facing northwest. 310Historic Cultural Properties Inventory (HCPI) Detail Form (FORM 2) Historic Preservation Division, New Mexico Department of Cultural Affairs ~ "' ~>r HPD Office use only: Please complete HCPI FORM 1 before completing FORM 2 CPINo. District No. NRHP SRCP Criteria A 8 c D 1. Name of property: 2. Location: 3. Local Reference Number: Santa Fe 10 #: Plaza del Monte 116/120 Camino Matias Plaza del Monte Inventory Residence 7 Downtown and Eastside Historic District 4. County: Santa Fe 5. Date of Survey: January 18, 2018 Photo 3: West elevation, facing northeast.